Statistical properties of fluctuating enzymes with dynamic cooperativity using a first passage time distribution formalism

Theoretical Tools to Quantify Stochastic Fluctuations in Single-Molecule Catalysis by Enzymes and Nanoparticles

Single-molecule microscopic techniques allow the counting of successive turnover events and the study of the time-dependent fluctuations of the catalytic activities of individual enzymes and different sites on a single heterogeneous nanocatalyst. It is important to establish theoretical methods to obtain the statistical measurements of such stochastic fluctuations that provide insight into the catalytic mechanism. In this review, we discuss a few theoretical frameworks for evaluating the first passage time distribution functions using a self-consistent pathway approach and chemical master equations, to establish a connection with experimental observables. The measurable probability distribution functions and their moments depend on the molecular details of the reaction and provide a way to quantify the molecular mechanisms of the reaction process. The statistical measurements of these fluctuations should provide insight into the enzymatic mechanism.

Reaction-path statistical mechanics of enzymatic kinetics

We introduce a reaction-path statistical mechanics formalism based on the principle of large deviations to quantify the kinetics of single-molecule enzymatic reaction processes under the Michaelis-Menten mechanism, which exemplifies an out-of-equilibrium process in the living system. Our theoretical approach begins with the principle of equal a priori probabilities and defines the reaction path entropy to construct a new nonequilibrium ensemble as a collection of possible chemical reaction paths. As a result, we evaluate a variety of path-based partition functions and free energies by using the formalism of statistical mechanics. They allow us to calculate the timescales of a given enzymatic reaction, even in the absence of an explicit boundary condition that is necessary for the equilibrium ensemble. We also consider the large deviation theory under a closed-boundary condition of the fixed observation time to quantify the enzyme-substrate unbinding rates. The result demonstrates the presence of a phase-separation-like, bimodal behavior in unbinding events at a finite timescale, and the behavior vanishes as its rate function converges to a single phase in the long-time limit.

Dissecting the Protein Dynamics Coupled Ligand Binding with Kinetic Models and Single-Molecule FRET

Protein-ligand interactions are crucial to many biological processes. Ligand binding and dissociation are the basic steps that allow proteins to function. Protein conformational dynamics have been shown to play important roles in ligand binding and dissociation. However, it is challenging to determine the ligand binding kinetics of dynamic proteins. Here, we undertook comprehensive single-molecule FRET (smFRET) measurements and kinetic model analysis to characterize the conformational dynamics coupled ligand binding of glutamine-binding protein (GlnBP). We showed that hinge and T118A mutations of GlnBP affect its conformational dynamics as well as the ligand binding affinity. Based on smFRET measurements, the kinetic model of ligand-GlnBP interactions was constructed. Using experimentally measured parameters, we solved the rate equations of the model and obtained the undetectable parameters of the model which allowed us to understand the ligand binding kinetics fully. Our results demonstrate that modulation of the conformational dynamics of GlnBP affects the ligand binding and dissociation rates. This study provides insights into the binding kinetics of ligands, which are related to the protein function itself.

A Revisit to Turnover Kinetics of Individual Escherichia coli β-Galactosidase Molecules

Single-molecule experiments on β-galactosidase from Escherichia coli that catalyzes the hydrolysis of resorufin-β-d-galactopyranoside revealed important observations like fluctuating catalytic rate, memory effects arising from temporal correlations between the enzymatic turnovers and nonexponential waiting time distributions. The root cause of the observed results is intrinsic fluctuations among the different conformers of the active species, during the course of the reaction, thereby imparting dynamic disorder in the system under investigation. Originally, a multistate stochastic kinetic theory was employed that, despite satisfying the measured waiting time distributions and the mean waiting times at different substrate concentrations, yields a constant estimate of the randomness parameter. Inevitably, this manifests a strong disagreement with the substrate-concentration-dependent time variations of the said distribution, which at the same time misinterprets the measured magnitudes of the randomness parameter at lower concentrations. Here, we suggest a dual approach to the single-enzyme reaction, independently, making important improvements over the parent study and the recently suggested two-state stochastic analyses followed by quantitative rationalization of the experimental data. In the first case, an off-pathway mechanism satisfied the Michaelis-Menten equation under the circumstance of prevailing disorder while tested against the single-molecule data. However, recovery of randomness data in the lower-concentration regime, albeit primarily marks a significant refinement, a qualitative agreement at the growing concentrations seems to be reasoned by an account of switching among the limited numbers of discrete conformers. Consequently, in the second case, we circumvented the conventional way of approaching the enzyme catalysis and mapped the dynamics of structural transitions of the biocatalyst with the temporal fluctuations of the spatial distance between the different locations along a coarse-grained polymer chain. Exploiting a general mechanism for dynamic disorder, a reaction-diffusion formalism yielded an analytical expression for the waiting time distribution of the enzymatic turnovers, from which the mean waiting time and the randomness parameter were readily determined. Application of our results to the findings of the experiment on single β-galactosidase shows a quantitative agreement in each case. This soundly validates the usefulness of accounting for a more rigorous microscopic description pertinent to the conformational multiplicity in rationalizing the real-time data over the routine state-based sketch of the reaction system.

Order Through Disorder: The Characteristic Variability of Systems

Randomness characterizes many processes in nature, and therefore its importance cannot be overstated. In the present study, we investigate examples of randomness found in various fields, to underlie its fundamental processes. The fields we address include physics, chemistry, biology (biological systems from genes to whole organs), medicine, and environmental science. Through the chosen examples, we explore the seemingly paradoxical nature of life and demonstrate that randomness is preferred under specific conditions. Furthermore, under certain conditions, promoting or making use of variability-associated parameters may be necessary for improving the function of processes and systems.

Dissecting the Conformational Dynamics-Modulated Enzyme Catalysis with Single-Molecule FRET

Conformational changes of enzyme proteins are often coupled with a catalytic reaction and modulate the enzyme activity. Single-molecule technology is a powerful tool to study the mechanism of enzyme catalysis in these complicated cases. However, the chemical reaction cycles and conformational changes could not be monitored simultaneously in a single-molecule detection experiment, resulting in some unresolved key kinetic parameters. Here, we describe a method to extract all of the kinetic parameters from comprehensive single-molecule FRET (smFRET) measurements and model analysis. On the basis of the smFRET, we calculated the undetectable parameters by solving the rate equations of the kinetic model with the input of the smFRET-measured conformational state populations and state-transition rate constants. A case study of MalK₂ ATPase demonstrates that this method could reveal the quantitative mechanism of the catalytic reaction of the enzyme as well as its coupled conformational dynamics. The strategy employed in this study could be widely applied to investigate the conformational fluctuation-coupled catalysis of other enzymes.

Effect of Substrate Number Fluctuations in Stochastic Enzyme Kinetics

Conventional studies on enzyme kinetics assume that the substrate concentration remains constant. However, for catalytic reactions taking place in intracellular compartments, the substrate molecules are fed in and out of the compartment and are catalyzed into product molecules within the compartment. In this work, we use a chemical master equation approach to study the stochastic kinetics of a single enzyme for different reaction pathways with one or more intermediate states. We obtain velocity expressions that deviate from the Michaelis-Menten expression. We study the coefficient of variation, which is a measure of the noise strength as a function of the mean substrate concentration for systems where there is influx or/and outflux of substrate molecules. Our results show that the noise strength decreases with the increase in the substrate concentration and finally remains the same when the substrate is present in abundance.

Generic Schemes for Single-Molecule Kinetics. 3: Self-Consistent Pathway Solutions for Nonrenewal Processes

We recently developed a pathway analysis framework (paper 1) for describing single-molecule kinetics for renewal (i.e., memoryless) processes based on the decomposition of a kinetic scheme into generic structures. In our approach, waiting time distribution functions corresponding to such structures are expressed in terms of self-consistent pathway solutions and concatenated to form measurable probability distribution functions (PDFs), affording a simple way to decompose and recombine a network. Here, we extend this framework to nonrenewal processes, which involve correlations between events, and employ it to formulate waiting time PDFs, including the first-passage time PDF, for a general kinetic network model. Our technique does not require the assumption of Poissonian kinetics, permitting a more general kinetic description than the usual rate approach, with minimal topological restrictiveness. To demonstrate the usefulness of this technique, we provide explicit calculations for our general model, which we adapt to two generic schemes for single-enzyme turnover with conformational interconversion. For each generic scheme, wherein the intermediate state(s) need not undergo Poissonian decay, the functional dependence of the mean first-passage time on the concentration of an external substrate is analyzed. When conformational detailed balance is satisfied, the enzyme turnover rate (related to the mean first-passage time) reduces to the celebrated Michaelis-Menten functional form, consistent with our previous work involving a similar scheme with all rate processes, thereby establishing further generality to this intriguing result. Our framework affords a general and intuitive approach for evaluating measurable waiting time PDFs and their moments, making it a potentially useful kinetic tool for a wide variety of single-molecule processes.