Associative desorption of hydrogen isotopologues from copper surfaces: Characterization of two reaction mechanisms

Thermal Rates and High-Temperature Tunneling from Surface Reaction Dynamics and First-Principles

Studying dynamics of the dissociative adsorption and recombinative desorption of hydrogen on copper surfaces has shaped our atomic-scale understanding of surface chemistry, yet experimentally determining the thermal rates for these processes, which dictate the outcome of catalytic reactions, has been impossible so far. In this work, we determine the thermal rate constants for dissociative adsorption and recombinative desorption of hydrogen on Cu(111) between 200 and 1000 K using data from reaction dynamics experiments. Contrary to current understanding, our findings demonstrate the predominant role of quantum tunneling, even at temperatures as high as 400 K. We also provide precise values for the reaction barrier (0.619 ± 0.020 eV) and adsorption energy (0.348 ± 0.026 eV) for H2 on Cu(111). Remarkably, the thermal rate constants are in excellent agreement with a first-principles quantum rate theory based on a new implementation of ring polymer molecular dynamics for reactions on surfaces, paving the way to discovering better catalysts using reliable and efficient computational methods.

On the quantum dynamical treatment of surface vibrational modes for reactive scattering of H2 from Cu(111) at 925 K

We construct the effective Hartree potential for H2 on Cu(111) as introduced in our earlier work [Dutta et al., J. Chem. Phys. 154, 104103 (2021), and Dutta et al., J. Chem. Phys. 157, 194112 (2022)] starting from the same gas-metal interaction potential obtained for 0 K. Unlike in that work, we now explicitly account for surface expansion at 925 K and investigate different models to describe the surface vibrational modes: (i) a cluster model yielding harmonic normal modes at 0 K and (ii) slab models resulting in phonons at 0 and 925 K according to the quasi-harmonic approximation-all consistently calculated at the density functional theory level with the same exchange-correlation potential. While performing dynamical calculations for the H2(v = 0, j = 0)-Cu(111) system employing Hartree potential constructed with 925 K phonons and surface temperature, (i) the calculated chemisorption probabilities are the highest compared to the other approaches over the energy domain and (ii) the threshold for the reaction probability is the lowest, in close agreement with the experiment. Although the survival probabilities (v' = 0) depict the expected trend (lower in magnitude), the excitation probabilities (v' = 1) display a higher magnitude since the 925 K phonons and surface temperature are more effective for the excitation process compared to the phonons/normal modes obtained from the other approaches investigated to describe the surface.

Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials for Reactive Hydrogen Dynamics at Metal Surfaces Based on Iterative Refinement of Reaction Probabilities

The reactive chemistry of molecular hydrogen at surfaces, notably dissociative sticking and hydrogen evolution, plays a crucial role in energy storage and fuel cells. Theoretical studies can help to decipher underlying mechanisms and reaction design, but studying dynamics at surfaces is computationally challenging due to the complex electronic structure at interfaces and the high sensitivity of dynamics to reaction barriers. In addition, ab initio molecular dynamics, based on density functional theory, is too computationally demanding to accurately predict reactive sticking or desorption probabilities, as it requires averaging over tens of thousands of initial conditions. High-dimensional machine learning-based interatomic potentials are starting to be more commonly used in gas-surface dynamics, yet robust approaches to generate reliable training data and assess how model uncertainty affects the prediction of dynamic observables are not well established. Here, we employ ensemble learning to adaptively generate training data while assessing model performance with full uncertainty quantification (UQ) for reaction probabilities of hydrogen scattering on different copper facets. We use this approach to investigate the performance of two message-passing neural networks, SchNet and PaiNN. Ensemble-based UQ and iterative refinement allow us to expose the shortcomings of the invariant pairwise-distance-based feature representation in the SchNet model for gas-surface dynamics.

Hyperthermal velocity distributions of recombinatively-desorbing oxygen from Ag(111)

This study presents velocity-resolved desorption experiments of recombinatively-desorbing oxygen from Ag (111). We combine molecular beam techniques, ion imaging, and temperature-programmed desorption to obtain translational energy distributions of desorbing O2. Molecular beams of NO2 are used to prepare a p (4 × 4)-O adlayer on the silver crystal. The translational energy distributions of O2 are shifted towards hyperthermal energies indicating desorption from an intermediate activated molecular chemisorption state.

The quantum dynamics of H2 on Cu(111) at a surface temperature of 925 K: Comparing state-of-the-art theory to state-of-the-art experiments 2

State-of-the-art 6D quantum dynamics simulations for the dissociative chemisorption of H₂ on a thermally distorted Cu(111) surface, using the static corrugation model, were analyzed to produce several (experimentally available) observables. The expected error, especially important for lower reaction probabilities, was quantified using wavepackets on several different grids as well as two different analysis approaches to obtain more accurate results in the region where a slow reaction channel was experimentally shown to be dominant. The lowest reaction barrier sites for different thermally distorted surface slabs are shown to not just be energetically, but also geometrically, different between surface configurations, which can be used to explain several dynamical effects found when including surface temperature effects. Direct comparison of simulated time-of-flight spectra to those obtained from state-of-the-art desorption experiments showed much improved agreement compared to the perfect lattice BOSS approach. Agreement with experimental rotational and vibrational efficacies also somewhat improved when thermally excited surfaces were included in the theoretical model. Finally, we present clear quantum effects in the rotational quadrupole alignment parameters found for the lower rotationally excited states, which underlines the importance of careful quantum dynamical analyses of this system.

SBH17: Benchmark Database of Barrier Heights for Dissociative Chemisorption on Transition Metal Surfaces

Accurate barriers for rate controlling elementary reactions on metal surfaces are key to understanding, controlling, and predicting the rate of heterogeneously catalyzed processes. While barrier heights for gas phase reactions have been extensively benchmarked, dissociative chemisorption barriers for the reactions of molecules on metal surfaces have received much less attention. The first database called SBH10 and containing 10 entries was recently constructed based on the specific reaction parameter approach to density functional theory (SRP-DFT) and experimental results. We have now constructed a new and improved database (SBH17) containing 17 entries based on SRP-DFT and experiments. For this new SBH17 benchmark study, we have tested three algorithms (high, medium, and light) for calculating barrier heights for dissociative chemisorption on metals, which we have named for the amount of computational effort involved in their use. We test the performance of 14 density functionals at the GGA, GGA+vdW-DF, and meta-GGA rungs. Our results show that, in contrast with the previous SBH10 study where the BEEF-vdW-DF2 functional seemed to be most accurate, the workhorse functional PBE and the MS2 density functional are the most accurate of the GGA and meta-GGA functionals tested. Of the GGA+vdW functionals tested, the SRP32-vdW-DF1 functional is the most accurate. Additionally, we found that the medium algorithm is accurate enough for assessing the performance of the density functionals tested, while it avoids geometry optimizations of minimum barrier geometries for each density functional tested. The medium algorithm does require metal lattice constants and interlayer distances that are optimized separately for each functional. While these are avoided in the light algorithm, this algorithm is found not to give a reliable description of functional performance. The combination of relative ease of use and demonstrated reliability of the medium algorithm will likely pave the way for incorporation of the SBH17 database in larger databases used for testing new density functionals and electronic structure methods.

Velocity map images of desorbing oxygen from sub-surface states of Rh(111)

We combine velocity map imaging (VMI) with temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) experiments to record the angular-resolved velocity distributions of recombinatively-desorbing oxygen from Rh(111). We assign the velocity distributions to desorption from specific surface and sub-surface states by matching the recorded distributions to the desorption temperature. These results provide insight into the recombinative desorption mechanisms and the availability of oxygen for surface-catalyzed reactions.

Accurate Description of the Quantum Dynamical Surface Temperature Effects on the Dissociative Chemisorption of H2 from Cu(111)

Accurately describing surface temperature effects for the dissociative scattering of H2 on a metal surface on a quantum dynamical level is currently one of the open challenges for theoretical surface scientists. We present the first quantum dynamical (QD) simulations of hydrogen dissociating on a Cu(111) surface which accurately describe all relevant surface temperature effects, using the static corrugation model (SCM). The reaction probabilities we obtain show very good agreement with those found using quasi-classical dynamics (QCD), both for individual surface slabs and for an averaged, thus Monte-Carlo sampled, set of thermally distorted surface configurations. Rovibrationally elastic scattering probabilities show a much clearer difference between the QCD and QD results, which appears to be traceable back towards thermally distorted surface configurations with very low dissociation probabilities and underlines the importance of investigating more observables than just dissociation. By reducing the number of distorted surface atoms included in the dynamical model, we also show that only including one, or even three, surface atoms is generally not enough to accurately describe the effects of surface temperature on dissociation and elastic scattering. These results are a major step forward in accurately describing hydrogen scattering from a thermally excited Cu(111) surface, and open up a pathway to better describe reaction and scattering from other relevant crystal facets, such as stepped surfaces, at moderately elevated surface temperatures where quantum effects are expected to play a more important role in the dissociation of H2 on Cu.

Highly Efficient Activation of HCl Dissociation on Au(111) via Rotational Preexcitation

The probability for dissociation of molecules on metal surfaces, which often controls the rate of industrially important catalytic processes, can depend strongly on how energy is partitioned in the incident molecule. There are many example systems where the addition of vibrational energy promotes reaction more effectively than the addition of translational energy, but for rotational pre-excitation similar examples have not yet been discovered. Here, we make an experimentally testable theoretical prediction that adding energy to the rotation of HCl can promote its dissociation on Au(111) 20 times more effectively than increasing its translational energy. In the underlying mechanism, the molecule's initial rotational motion allows it to pass through a critical region of the reaction path, where this path shows a strong and nonmonotonic dependence on the molecular orientation.

Performance of Made Simple Meta-GGA Functionals with rVV10 Nonlocal Correlation for H2 + Cu(111), D2 + Ag(111), H2 + Au(111), and D2 + Pt(111)

Accurately modeling heterogeneous catalysis requires accurate descriptions of rate-controlling elementary reactions of molecules on metal surfaces, but standard density functionals (DFs) are not accurate enough for this. The problem can be solved with the specific reaction parameter approach to density functional theory (SRP-DFT), but the transferability of SRP DFs among chemically related systems is limited. We combine the MS-PBEl, MS-B86bl, and MS-RPBEl semilocal made simple (MS) meta-generalized gradient approximation (GGA) (mGGA) DFs with rVV10 nonlocal correlation, and we evaluate their performance for the hydrogen (H2) + Cu(111), deuterium (D2) + Ag(111), H2 + Au(111), and D2 + Pt(111) gas-surface systems. The three MS mGGA DFs that have been combined with rVV10 nonlocal correlation were not fitted to reproduce particular experiments, nor has the b parameter present in rVV10 been reoptimized. Of the three DFs obtained the MS-PBEl-rVV10 DF yields an excellent description of van der Waals well geometries. The three original MS mGGA DFs gave a highly accurate description of the metals, which was comparable in quality to that obtained with the PBEsol DF. Here, we find that combining the three original MS mGGA DFs with rVV10 nonlocal correlation comes at the cost of a slightly less accurate description of the metal. However, the description of the metal obtained in this way is still better than the descriptions obtained with SRP DFs specifically optimized for individual systems. Using the Born-Oppenheimer static surface (BOSS) model, simulations of molecular beam dissociative chemisorption experiments yield chemical accuracy for the D2 + Ag(111) and D2 + Pt(111) systems. A comparison between calculated and measured E 1/2(ν, J) parameters describing associative desorption suggests chemical accuracy for the associative desorption of H2 from Au(111) as well. Our results suggest that ascending Jacob's ladder to the mGGA rung yields increasingly more accurate results for gas-surface reactions of H2 (D2) interacting with late transition metals.

Computational approaches to dissociative chemisorption on metals: towards chemical accuracy

We review the state-of-the-art in the theory of dissociative chemisorption (DC) of small gas phase molecules on metal surfaces, which is important to modeling heterogeneous catalysis for practical reasons, and for achieving an understanding of the wealth of experimental information that exists for this topic, for fundamental reasons. We first give a quick overview of the experimental state of the field. Turning to the theory, we address the challenge that barrier heights (E_b, which are not observables) for DC on metals cannot yet be calculated with chemical accuracy, although embedded correlated wave function theory and diffusion Monte-Carlo are moving in this direction. For benchmarking, at present chemically accurate E_b can only be derived from dynamics calculations based on a semi-empirically derived density functional (DF), by computing a sticking curve and demonstrating that it is shifted from the curve measured in a supersonic beam experiment by no more than 1 kcal mol^-1. The approach capable of delivering this accuracy is called the specific reaction parameter (SRP) approach to density functional theory (DFT). SRP-DFT relies on DFT and on dynamics calculations, which are most efficiently performed if a potential energy surface (PES) is available. We therefore present a brief review of the DFs that now exist, also considering their performance on databases for E_b for gas phase reactions and DC on metals, and for adsorption to metals. We also consider expressions for SRP-DFs and briefly discuss other electronic structure methods that have addressed the interaction of molecules with metal surfaces. An overview is presented of dynamical models, which make a distinction as to whether or not, and which dissipative channels are modeled, the dissipative channels being surface phonons and electronically non-adiabatic channels such as electron-hole pair excitation. We also discuss the dynamical methods that have been used, such as the quasi-classical trajectory method and quantum dynamical methods like the time-dependent wave packet method and the reaction path Hamiltonian method. Limits on the accuracy of these methods are discussed for DC of diatomic and polyatomic molecules on metal surfaces, paying particular attention to reduced dimensionality approximations that still have to be invoked in wave packet calculations on polyatomic molecules like CH₄. We also address the accuracy of fitting methods, such as recent machine learning methods (like neural network methods) and the corrugation reducing procedure. In discussing the calculation of observables we emphasize the importance of modeling the properties of the supersonic beams in simulating the sticking probability curves measured in the associated experiments. We show that chemically accurate barrier heights have now been extracted for DC in 11 molecule-metal surface systems, some of which form the most accurate core of the only existing database of E_b for DC reactions on metal surfaces (SBH10). The SRP-DFs (or candidate SRP-DFs) that have been derived show transferability in many cases, i.e., they have been shown also to yield chemically accurate E_b for chemically related systems. This can in principle be exploited in simulating rates of catalyzed reactions on nano-particles containing facets and edges, as SRP-DFs may be transferable among systems in which a molecule dissociates on low index and stepped surfaces of the same metal. In many instances SRP-DFs have allowed important conclusions regarding the mechanisms underlying observed experimental trends. An important recent observation is that SRP-DFT based on semi-local exchange DFs has so far only been successful for systems for which the difference of the metal work function and the molecule's electron affinity exceeds 7 eV. A main challenge to SRP-DFT is to extend its applicability to the other systems, which involve a range of important DC reactions of e.g. O₂, H₂O, NH₃, CO₂, and CH₃OH. Recent calculations employing a PES based on a screened hybrid exchange functional suggest that the road to success may be based on using exchange functionals of this category.

Effect of surface temperature on quantum dynamics of H2 on Cu(111) using a chemically accurate potential energy surface

The effect of surface atom vibrations on H₂ scattering from a Cu(111) surface at different temperatures is being investigated for hydrogen molecules in their rovibrational ground state (v = 0, j = 0). We assume weakly correlated interactions between molecular degrees of freedom and surface modes through a Hartree product type wavefunction. While constructing the six-dimensional effective Hamiltonian, we employ (a) a chemically accurate potential energy surface according to the static corrugation model [M. Wijzenbroek and M. F. Somers, J. Chem. Phys. 137, 054703 (2012)]; (b) normal mode frequencies and displacement vectors calculated with different surface atom interaction potentials within a cluster approximation; and (c) initial state distributions for the vibrational modes according to Bose-Einstein probability factors. We carry out 6D quantum dynamics with the so-constructed effective Hamiltonian and analyze sticking and state-to-state scattering probabilities. The surface atom vibrations affect the chemisorption dynamics. The results show physically meaningful trends for both reaction and scattering probabilities compared to experimental and other theoretical results.

Designing new SRP density functionals including non-local vdW-DF2 correlation for H2 + Cu(111) and their transferability to H2 + Ag(111), Au(111) and Pt(111)

Specific reaction parameter density functionals (SRP-DFs) that can describe dissociative chemisorption molecular beam experiments of hydrogen (H₂) on cold transition metal surfaces with chemical accuracy have so far been shown to be only transferable among different facets of the same metal, but not among different metals. We design new SRP-DFs that include non-local vdW-DF2 correlation for the H₂ + Cu(111) system, and evaluate their transferability to the highly activated H₂ + Ag(111) and H₂ + Au(111) systems and the non-activated H₂ + Pt(111) system. We design our functionals for the H₂ + Cu(111) system since it is the best studied system both theoretically and experimentally. Here we demonstrate that a SRP-DF fitted to reproduce molecular beam sticking experiments for H₂ + Cu(111) with chemical accuracy can also describe such experiments for H₂ + Pt(111) with chemical accuracy, and vice versa. Chemically accurate functionals have been obtained that perform very well with respect to reported van der Waals well geometries, and which improve the description of the metal over current generalized gradient approximation (GGA) based SRP-DFs. From a systematic comparison of our new SRP-DFs that include non-local correlation to previously developed SRP-DFs, for both activated and non-activated systems, we identify non-local correlation as a key ingredient in the construction of transferable SRP-DFs for H₂ interacting with transition metals. Our results are in excellent agreement with experiment when accurately measured observables are available. It is however clear from our analysis that, except for the H₂ + Cu(111) system, there is a need for more, more varied, and more accurately described experiments in order to further improve the design of SRP-DFs. Additionally, we confirm that, when including non-local correlation, the sticking of H₂ on Cu(111) is still well described quasi-classically.

Following the microscopic pathway to adsorption through chemisorption and physisorption wells

Adsorption involves molecules colliding at the surface of a solid and losing their incidence energy by traversing a dynamical pathway to equilibrium. The interactions responsible for energy loss generally include both chemical bond formation (chemisorption) and nonbonding interactions (physisorption). In this work, we present experiments that revealed a quantitative energy landscape and the microscopic pathways underlying a molecule’s equilibration with a surface in a prototypical system: CO adsorption on Au(111). Although the minimum energy state was physisorbed, initial capture of the gas-phase molecule, dosed with an energetic molecular beam, was into a metastable chemisorption state. Subsequent thermal decay of the chemisorbed state led molecules to the physisorption minimum. We found, through detailed balance, that thermal adsorption into both binding states was important at all temperatures.

First principles rates for surface chemistry employing exact transition state theory: application to recombinative desorption of hydrogen from Cu(111)

We present first principles calculations of the reactive flux for thermal recombinative desorption of hydrogen from Cu(111).

Unified and transferable description of dynamics of H2 dissociative adsorption on multiple copper surfaces via machine learning

Schematic of the developed neural network potential energy surface enabling a unified and transferable description of dynamics of H₂ dissociative adsorption on multiple copper surfaces.

Ring Polymer Molecular Dynamics in Gas-Surface Reactions: Inclusion of Quantum Effects Made Simple

Accurately modeling gas-surface collision dynamics presents a great challenge for theory, especially in the low-energy (or temperature) regime where quantum effects are important. Here, a path integral-based nonequilibrium ring polymer molecular dynamics (NE-RPMD) approach is adapted to calculate dissociative initial sticking probabilities (S₀) of H₂ on Cu(111) and D₂O on Ni(111), revealing the distinct quantum nature in the two benchmark surface reactions. NE-RPMD successfully captures quantum tunneling in H₂ dissociation at very low energies, where the quasi-classical trajectory (QCT) method suddenly fails. Additionally, QCT substantially overestimates S₀ of D₂O because of severe zero point energy (ZPE) leakage, even at collision energies greater than the ZPE-corrected barrier. Instead, NE-RPMD predicts S₀ values of D₂O in much improved agreement with reference results obtained by the quantum wavepacket method with reasonable corrections of the thermal contribution. Our results suggest NE-RPMD as a promising approach to model quantum effects in gas-surface reactions.

Quantum Dynamics of Dissociative Chemisorption of H2 on the Stepped Cu(211) Surface

Reactions on stepped surfaces are relevant to heterogeneous catalysis, in which a reaction often takes place at the edges of nanoparticles where the edges resemble steps on single-crystal stepped surfaces. Previous results on H₂ + Cu(211) showed that, in this system, steps do not enhance the reactivity and raised the question of whether this effect could be, in any way, related to the neglect of quantum dynamical effects in the theory. To investigate this, we present full quantum dynamical molecular beam simulations of sticking of H₂ on Cu(211), in which all important rovibrational states populated in a molecular beam experiment are taken into account. We find that the reaction of H₂ with Cu(211) is very well described with quasi-classical dynamics when simulating molecular beam sticking experiments, in which averaging takes place over a large number of rovibrational states and over translational energy distributions. Our results show that the stepped Cu(211) surface is distinct from its component Cu(111) terraces and Cu(100) steps and cannot be described as a combination of its component parts with respect to the reaction dynamics when considering the orientational dependence. Specifically, we present evidence that, at translational energies close to the reaction threshold, vibrationally excited molecules show a negative rotational quadrupole alignment parameter on Cu(211), which is not found on Cu(111) and Cu(100). The effect arises because these molecules react with a site-specific reaction mechanism at the step, that is, inelastic rotational enhancement, which is only effective for molecules with a small absolute value of the magnetic rotation quantum number. From a comparison to recent associative desorption experiments as well as Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics calculations, it follows that the effects of surface atom motion and electron-hole pair excitation on the reactivity fall within chemical accuracy, that is, modeling these effect shifts extracted reaction probability curves by less than 1 kcal/mol translational energy. We found no evidence in our fully state-resolved calculations for the "slow" reaction channel that was recently reported for associative desorption of H₂ from Cu(111) and Cu(211), but our results for the fast channel are in good agreement with the experiments on H₂ + Cu(211).

Hydrogen adsorption and desorption from Cu(111) and Cu(211)

We present a combined experimental-theoretical study on structural and coverage dependences of the adsorption and desorption of molecular hydrogen on atomically flat Cu(111) and highly stepped Cu(211) surfaces. For molecules with identical incident energy from supersonic molecular beams, we find a reduced dissociative sticking probability for the stepped surface compared to Cu(111). DFT calculations of activation barriers to dissociation for the clean and partially precovered surfaces, as well as quantitative analysis of TPD spectra, support that the A-type step of the (211) surface causes an upward shift in activation barriers to dissociation and lowering of the desorption barrier. The new data allow us to determine low sticking probabilities at conditions where King and Wells measurements fail to determine the reactivity. They are also fully consistent with the unexpected observation that monoatomic steps on a surface lower the reactivity toward the dissociation of a diatomic molecule.