Improving low-accuracy protein structures using enhanced sampling techniques

Forging tools for refining predicted protein structures

Refining predicted protein structures with all-atom molecular dynamics simulations is one route to producing, entirely by computational means, structural models of proteins that rival in quality those that are determined by X-ray diffraction experiments. Slow rearrangements within the compact folded state, however, make routine refinement of predicted structures by unrestrained simulations infeasible. In this work, we draw inspiration from the fields of metallurgy and blacksmithing, where practitioners have worked out practical means of controlling equilibration by mechanically deforming their samples. We describe a two-step refinement procedure that involves identifying collective variables for mechanical deformations using a coarse-grained model and then sampling along these deformation modes in all-atom simulations. Identifying those low-frequency collective modes that change the contact map the most proves to be an effective strategy for choosing which deformations to use for sampling. The method is tested on 20 refinement targets from the CASP12 competition and is found to induce large structural rearrangements that drive the structures closer to the experimentally determined structures during relatively short all-atom simulations of 50 ns. By examining the accuracy of side-chain rotamer states in subensembles of structures that have varying degrees of similarity to the experimental structure, we identified the reorientation of aromatic side chains as a step that remains slow even when encouraging global mechanical deformations in the all-atom simulations. Reducing the side-chain rotamer isomerization barriers in the all-atom force field is found to further speed up refinement.

Refining protein structures using enhanced sampling techniques with restraints derived from an ensemble-based model

This paper reports a method for high-accuracy protein structural refinement, which is a direct extension of the method in our recent publication (Zang, J Chem Phys 2018; 149:072319). It combines a parallel continuous simulated tempering (PCST) method with a temperature-dependent restraint and a blind model selection scheme. In this work, a single-reference-based restraint in previous work was changed to an ensemble-based model (EBM), in which the non-bonded Lennard-Jones term for each contacting atomic pair in previous restraining potential was replaced by a multi-Gaussian function whose parameters are derived from an ensemble of structures such as the ones from various CASP participating groups. The purpose of EBM is to take advantage of partial "correctness" distributed among members of the structural ensemble. Totally 18 targets were refined from the refinement category of CASP10, CASP11 and CASP12. In Top-1 group, 11 out of 18 targets had better models (greater GDT_TS scores) than the CASPR participants. In Top-5 group, nine out of 18 were better. Our results show that PCST-EBM method can considerably improve the low-accuracy structures.