Analyses based on statistical thermodynamics for large difference between thermophilic rhodopsin and xanthorhodopsin in terms of thermostability

Concerted primary proton transfer reactions in a thermophilic rhodopsin studied by time-resolved infrared spectroscopy at high temperature

The primary proton transfer reactions of thermophilic rhodopsin, which was first discovered in an extreme thermophile, Thermus thermophilus JL-18, were investigated using time-resolved Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy at various temperatures ranging from 298 to 343 K (25 to 70 °C) and proton transport activity analysis. The analyses were performed using counterion (D95E, D95N, D229E, and D229N) and proton donor mutants (E106D and E106Q) as well. First, the initial proton transfer from the protonated retinal Schiff base (PRSB) to D95 was identified. The temperature dependency showed that the proton transfer reaction in the intermediate states dramatically changed above 318 K (45 °C). In addition, the proton transfer reaction correlated well with the structural change from turn to β-strand in the protein moiety, suggesting that this step may be regulated by the rigidity of the loop region. We also elucidated that the proton transfer reaction from proton donor E106 to the retinal Schiff base occurred synchronously with the primary proton transfer from the PRSB to D95. Surprisingly, we discovered that the direction of proton transfer was regulated by the secondary counterion, D229. Comparative analysis of Gloeobacter rhodopsin from the mesophile, Gloeobacter violaceus, highlighted that the primary proton transfer reactions in thermophilic rhodopsin were optimized at high temperatures partly due to the specific turn to β-strand structural change. This was not observed in Gloeobacter rhodopsin and other related proteins such as bacteriorhodopsin.

A methodology for creating mutants of G-protein coupled receptors stabilized in active state by combining statistical thermodynamics and evolutionary molecular engineering

We challenged the stabilization of a G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) in the active state solely by multiple amino-acid mutations without the agonist binding. For many GPCRs, the free energy of the active state is higher than that of the inactive state. When the inactive state is stabilized through the lowering of its free energy, the apparent midpoint temperature of thermal denaturation Tm exhibits a significant increase. However, this is not always the case for the stabilization of the active state. We constructed a modified version of our methodology combining statistical thermodynamics and evolutionary molecular engineering, which was recently developed for the inactive state. First, several residues to be mutated are determined using our statistical-thermodynamics theory. Second, a gene (mutant) library is constructed using Escherichia coli cells to efficiently explore most of the mutational space. Third, for the mutant screening, the mutants prepared in accordance with the library are expressed in engineered Saccharomyces cerevisiae YB14 cells which can grow only when a GPCR mutant stabilized in the active state has signaling function. For the adenosine A2A receptor tested, the methodology enabled us to sort out two triple mutants and a double mutant. It was experimentally corroborated that all the mutants exhibit much higher binding affinity for G protein than the wild type. Analyses indicated that the mutations make the structural characteristics shift toward those of the active state. However, only slight increases in Tm resulted from the mutations, suggesting the unsuitability of Tm to the stability measure for the active state.

Development of an Outward Proton Pumping Rhodopsin with a New Record in Thermostability by Means of Amino Acid Mutations

We have developed a methodology for identifying further thermostabilizing mutations for an intrinsically thermostable membrane protein. The methodology comprises the following steps: (1) identifying thermostabilizing single mutations (TSSMs) for residues in the transmembrane region using our physics-based method; (2) identifying TSSMs for residues in the extracellular and intracellular regions, which are in aqueous environment, using an empirical force field FoldX; and (3) combining the TSSMs identified in steps (1) and (2) to construct multiple mutations. The methodology is illustrated for thermophilic rhodopsin whose apparent midpoint temperature of thermal denaturation T_m is ∼91.8 °C. The TSSMs previously identified in step (1) were F90K, F90R, and Y91I with ΔT_m ∼5.6, ∼5.5, and ∼2.9 °C, respectively, and those in step (2) were V79K, T114D, A115P, and A116E with ΔT_m ∼2.7, ∼4.2, ∼2.6, and ∼2.3 °C, respectively (ΔT_m denotes the increase in T_m). In this study, we construct triple and quadruple mutants, F90K+Y91I+T114D and F90K+Y91I+V79K+T114D. The values of ΔT_m for these multiple mutants are ∼11.4 and ∼13.5 °C, respectively. T_m of the quadruple mutant (∼105.3 °C) establishes a new record in a class of outward proton pumping rhodopsins. It is higher than T_m of Rubrobacter xylanophilus rhodopsin (∼100.8 °C) that was the most thermostable in the class before this study.

Theoretical identification of thermostabilizing amino acid mutations for G-protein-coupled receptors

Thermostabilization of a membrane proteins, especially G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), is often necessary for biochemical applications and pharmaceutical studies involving structure-based drug design. Here we review our theoretical, physics-based method for identifying thermostabilizing amino acid mutations. Its novel aspects are the following: The entropic effect originating from the translational displacement of hydrocarbon groups within the lipid bilayer is treated as a pivotal factor; a reliable measure of thermostability is introduced and a mutation which enlarges the measure to a significant extent is chosen; and all the possible mutations can be examined with moderate computational effort. It was shown that mutating the residue at a position of N_BW = 3.39 (N_BW is the Ballesteros-Weinstein number) to Arg or Lys leads to the stabilization of significantly many different GPCRs of class A in the inactive state. Up to now, we have been successful in stabilizing several GPCRs and newly solving three-dimensional structures for the muscarinic acetylcholine receptor 2 (M2R), prostaglandin E receptor 4 (EP4), and serotonin 2A receptor (5-HT_2AR) using X-ray crystallography. The subjects to be pursued in future studies are also discussed.

Methodology for Further Thermostabilization of an Intrinsically Thermostable Membrane Protein Using Amino Acid Mutations with Its Original Function Being Retained

We develop a new methodology best suited to the identification of thermostabilizing mutations for an intrinsically stable membrane protein. The recently discovered thermophilic rhodopsin, whose apparent midpoint temperature of thermal denaturation T_m is measured to be ∼91.8 °C, is chosen as a paradigmatic target. In the methodology, we first regard the residues whose side chains are missing in the crystal structure of the wild type (WT) as the "residues with disordered side chains," which make no significant contributions to the stability, unlike the other essential residues. We then undertake mutating each of the residues with disordered side chains to another residue except Ala and Pro, and the resultant mutant structure is constructed by modifying only the local structure around the mutated residue. This construction is based on the postulation that the structure formed by the other essential residues, which is nearly optimized in such a highly stable protein, should not be modified. The stability changes arising from the mutations are then evaluated using our physics-based free-energy function (FEF). We choose the mutations for which the FEF is much lower than for the WT and test them by experiments. We successfully find three mutants that are significantly more stable than the WT. A double mutant whose T_m reaches ∼100 °C is also discovered.