Objective assessment of left ventricular wall motion from contrast-enhanced power modulation images

Quantification of left ventricular size and function using contrast-enhanced real-time 3D imaging with power modulation: comparison with cardiac MRI

In patients with optimal images, real-time 3-D echocardiography (RT3DE) allows accurate evaluation of left ventricular (LV) volumes and ejection fraction (EF). However, in patients with poor acoustic windows, lower correlations were reported despite the use of contrast. We hypothesized that power modulation (PM) RT3DE imaging that uses low mechanical indices and provides uniform LV opacification could overcome this problem. Accordingly, we sought to: (i) Test the feasibility of quantification of LV volumes and EF from contrast-enhanced (CE) PM RT3DE images, (ii) validate this technique against cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) reference and (iii) test its clinical value by quantifying the improvement in accuracy and reproducibility. We studied 20 patients who underwent CMR, harmonic nonenhanced RT3DE and CE PM RT3DE imaging on the same day. All images were analyzed to obtain end-systolic and end-diastolic LV volumes (EDV, ESV) and calculate EF. To determine the reproducibility of each RT3DE technique, imaging was repeated in the same setting by a second sonographer. In addition, patients were divided according to the quality of their RT3DE images into two groups, for which agreement with CMR and reproducibility were calculated separately. CE PM RT3DE imaging improved the accuracy of EDV, ESV and EF measurements in patients with poor acoustic windows without significantly affecting those in patients with optimal images. In addition, CE PM RT3DE imaging improved the reproducibility of the measurements, as reflected by a twofold decrease in intermeasurement variability. Importantly, the variability in CE PM RT3DE-derived volumes and EF was under 10%, irrespective of image quality. This methodology may become the new standard for LV size and function, which will be particularly important in patients with poor acoustic windows or contraindications to CMR.

Objective quantification of global and regional left ventricular systolic function by endocardial tracking of contrast echocardiographic sequences

BACKGROUND

Echocardiographic assessment of LV wall motion is still most frequently done visually. This study was designed to validate a new system for semi-automatic quantification of global and regional LV systolic function from contrast-enhanced cross-sectional echocardiograms.

METHODS

Measurements of LV volumes were validated in 50 patients using magnetic resonance (MR) as reference. The regional identification of the endocardial boundary was validated frame-by-frame against the visually identified border in another 27 patients. Finally, the applicability of the system for quantifying stress-echocardiographic exams was assessed in 52 patients undergoing dobutamine interventions. Echocardiographic sequences were digitally processed using custom-built algorithms, based on local phase feature descriptors, deformable contour fitting, and prospective training.

RESULTS

Compared to MR, the tracing system showed reasonable accuracy, with relative errors for end-diastolic volume, end-systolic volume, and EF of 21+/-20%, 27+/-33%, and--4+/-18%, respectively. Regional agreement of the instantaneous contours with visually traced borders was within the limits of visual reproducibility. The system was suitable for tracking stress-echo studies from all patients except two (96%). Quantification of regional radial shortening allowed to discriminate segments showing an abnormal regional wall motion with an overall area under the ROC curve of 0.87.

CONCLUSIONS

A reliable and accurate quantification of LV systolic function can be obtained by processing contrast echocardiograms. Values of LV volumes, ejection fraction, and regional endocardial shortening adequately correlate with currently available reference methods. Readily applicable to baseline and stress studies, endocardial tracking techniques increase the reliability of echocardiography for the assessment of global and regional systolic function.

Color encoding of endocardial motion improves the interpretation of contrast-enhanced echocardiographic stress tests by less-experienced readers

BACKGROUND

We hypothesized that color encoding of endocardial motion could aid less-experienced readers in detection of wall-motion abnormalities at rest and stress in patients with poor acoustic windows.

METHODS

Color-encoded images (color kinesis) were obtained at rest and peak dobutamine stress in 4 standard views during intravenous infusion of contrast agent in 117 patients with poorly visualized endocardium. In 101 of 117 patients (86%), in whom contrast enhancement allowed endocardial tracking, images were reviewed by two expert readers without color overlays. Each reader graded regional wall motion as normal, abnormal, or uninterpretable, and their consensus grades served as a gold standard. The same images were then reviewed and graded with and without color overlays by 3 cardiology fellows. The accuracy of the interpretation was calculated against the gold standard separately for the 3 vascular territories (left anterior descending, left circumflex, and right coronary arteries) and averaged for the 3 fellows.

RESULTS

With the addition of color encoding: (1) the number of uninterpretable segments decreased by 55% at rest and 61% at peak stress; and (2) all 3 fellows reached higher levels of accuracy in all 3 vascular territories both at rest (6%-82% average) and at stress (73%-80%).

CONCLUSION

The addition of color encoding of wall motion to contrast-enhanced images obtained in patients with poor acoustic windows during stress tests improves the interpretation of regional left ventricular function by less-experienced readers.

Assessment of left ventricular function with contrast echocardiography

Echocardiography continues to be the primary noninvasive imaging modality for the assessment of cardiac structure and function because of significant advances in ultrasound imaging technology over the last two decades, yet quantification of the LV function has remained an elusive goal. The introduction of contrast agents has represented a major advance in clinicians' ability to visualize the endocardium and to assess LV function accurately, particularly in patients who have poor acoustic windows. Ongoing and future refinements in imaging technology used with contrast enhancement have placed automated quantification of LV function on the brink of widespread clinical use.

Differential diagnosis of cardiac masses using contrast echocardiographic perfusion imaging

OBJECTIVES

We investigated the usefulness of echocardiographic contrast perfusion imaging in differentiating cardiac masses.

BACKGROUND

Two-dimensional echocardiography is the primary diagnostic modality for cardiac masses. However, differentiation between the different types of cardiac masses may be difficult at times. We hypothesized that echocardiographic contrast perfusion imaging would differentiate the neo-vascularization of malignancies from the avascularity of thrombi and the sparse vascularity of stromal tumors.

METHODS

Sixteen patients with cardiac masses underwent power-modulation imaging after echocardiographic intravenous contrast administration. Pixel intensities in the mass and an adjacent section of myocardium were analyzed visually and by dedicated software. All masses had a pathologic diagnosis or resolved after anticoagulation. In a subset of patients, video-intensity curves of contrast replenishment in the mass and myocardium over time were generated. The post-impulse steady-state pixel intensity (A) and initial rate of contrast replenishment after impulse (beta) were compared with an index of blood vessel area on pathology.

RESULTS

In seven of 16 patients, contrast enhancement resulted in greater pixel intensity in the mass than in the adjacent myocardium. All of these masses were classified pathologically as malignant (n = 6) or benign and vascular (n = 1). Nine masses demonstrated decreased pixel intensity, compared with the myocardium, and were diagnosed pathologically as myxomas (n = 2) or thrombi (n = 5), or they resolved with anticoagulation (n = 2). For the subset of patients, beta correlated with the vessel area index (r = 0.60).

CONCLUSIONS

Echocardiographic contrast perfusion imaging aids in the differentiation of cardiac masses. Compared with the adjacent myocardium, malignant and vascular tumors hyper-enhanced, whereas stromal tumors and thrombi hypo-enhanced.

Simultaneous real-time echocardiographic imaging of myocardial perfusion and regional function using color-encoded, contrast-enhanced power modulation

We hypothesized that color-encoded, contrast-enhanced, power modulation imaging could allow simultaneous quantification of myocardial perfusion and regional left ventricular function. We studied 12 anesthetized, closed-chest pigs at baseline, during acute ischemia, and during reperfusion, and 8 patients after acute myocardial infarction. Color kinesis was used to color encode endocardial motion during real-time contrast perfusion imaging with high-energy ultrasound pulses. Wall motion was assessed by calculating regional fractional area changes. Translation-free perfusion analysis was performed in automatically identified myocardial regions of interest. Steady-state intensity and postimpulse rate of contrast replenishment were calculated. In all animals, ischemia caused reversible changes in the images and the perfusion- and function-calculated indices. A significant decrease in pixel intensity (14%) and contrast replenishment rate (66%) in left anterior descending coronary artery segments, in agreement with fluorescent microspheres measurements, coincided with a decrease in fractional area change (34%). For patients, respective perfusion and function indices were 61%, 51%, and 58% lower in segments where perfusion defects, regional wall-motion abnormalities, or both were noted in gray scale images. Color-encoded, contrast-enhanced power modulation allows simultaneous real-time imaging and quantitative analysis of myocardial perfusion and regional left ventricular function.

Use of Contrast Enhancement for the Assessment of Left Ventricular Function

Endocardial visualization is essential for accurate interpretation of regional wall thickening abnormalities, which constitute the diagnostic hallmark of coronary artery disease, and for reproducible assessment of left ventricular (LV) ejection fraction. Unfortunately, in many cardiac patients, poor image quality does not allow consistent visualization, let alone automated detection, of the endocardial boundary in all segments throughout the cardiac cycle. Continuing efforts directed towards improving endocardial visualization made by both echocardiographic imaging equipment manufacturers and researchers have recently produced new objective, quantitative approaches for the assessment of global and regional LV function. Although these developments have not been integrated into routine clinical practice, they may have a positive impact on endocardial visualization and, thus, eventually improve the ability to accurately and objectively evaluate LV performance. In this review, we discuss some of the latest developments in the use of contrast for the evaluation of LV function.

Quantification of regional myocardial perfusion using semiautomated translation-free analysis of contrast-enhanced power modulation images

Quantitative analysis of myocardial perfusion is currently based on manual tracing and frame-by-frame realignment of regions of interest. We developed a technique for semiautomated identification of myocardial regions from power modulation images as a potential tool for quantification of myocardial contrast enhancement. This approach was tested in 13 anesthetized pigs during continuous intravenous infusion of contrast at baseline, left anterior descending coronary artery occlusion, and reperfusion. Regional pixel intensity was calculated for each consecutive end-systolic frame after a high-energy ultrasound impulse, and fitted with an exponential function. Perfusion defects caused by occlusion of left anterior descending coronary artery were confirmed by a significant decrease in both postimpulse steady-state intensity and the initial rate of contrast replenishment (P <.05), which were reversed with reperfusion. Automated measurements of myocardial intensity correlated highly with conventional manual tracing (r = 0.90 to 0.97), and resulted in improved signal-to-noise ratios. This technique allows translation-free quantification of regional myocardial perfusion, without the need for manual tracing.

Color kinesis during contrast-enhanced dobutamine stress echocardiography: feasibility and applicability

Accurate interpretation of dobutamine stress echocardiography (DSE) needs expertise. Color kinesis (CK) allows objective assessment of wall motion (WM), and its feasibility and accuracy are enhanced under harmonic imaging with contrast agents. To explore its utility, CK was performed in 41 unselected patients during contrast-enhanced DSE. After bolus injection of Levovist, the CK image was acquired in the apical 4- and 2-chamber views at baseline and peak stress using the ultraharmonic mode. Quad screen format with second harmonic imaging after another injection of Levovist was also obtained as a reference. Regional WM (12 segments in the apical view) was independently assessed by both methods. Heart rate increased from 67 beats/min at baseline to 135 beats/min (88% of age predicted maximal heart rate) at peak stress. The CK image was successfully obtained in all patients at baseline and in 38/41 patients at peak stress. CK tracked endocardial motion accurately in 93% (456/492) of left ventricular segments at baseline and 87% (427/492) at peak stress. The concordance rate of normal and abnormal WM between the 2 methods was 86% (392/456, Kappa 0.61) at baseline and 85% (362/427, kappa 0.53) at peak stress. Among the 38 patients in whom both methods were completed, the standard quad screen display showed abnormal DSE results in 17 patients and 28/114 vascular territories. The sensitivity, specificity and diagnostic accuracy of CK for detecting abnormal findings were, respectively, 71% (12/17), 90% (19/21) and 82% (31/38) in patients and 57% (16/28), 97% (83/86) and 87% (99/114) in vascular territories. The application of CK was highly feasible during contrast-enhanced DSE and gave an objective assessment of WM. This method can be a valuable adjunct to the conventional interpretation of DSE.

The role of contrast enhancement in echocardiographic assessment of left ventricular function

With or without contrast, echocardiographic evaluation of left ventricular (LV) function is qualitative, subjective, and experience dependent, because it is mostly based on visual interpretation of gray-scale 2-dimensional images or, at best, relies on tedious and time-consuming manual tracing of the endocardial boundaries. Adequate endocardial visualization is essential for accurate interpretation of regional wall thickening abnormalities, which constitute the diagnostic hallmark of coronary artery disease, and for reproducible assessment of LV ejection fraction. Studies performed in the last decade have estimated the number of patients with suboptimal endocardial delineation by fundamental imaging at 30%. These studies have highlighted the problem of variable image quality as a major limitation of transthoracic echocardiography because failure to adequately visualize a segment, either at rest or during stress, may compromise the ability of this technique to identify areas of dysfunctional myocardium. Several remedies based on different technologic and methodologic approaches have been tested over the years with variable success. In this review we discuss the most recent techniques that have had a positive impact on endocardial visualization, as well as the potential benefits of these approaches.