"Infectious tolerance" develops after the spontaneous acceptance of Lewis-to-Dark Agouti rat liver transplants

Immunological Determinants of Liver Transplant Outcomes Uncovered by the Rat Model

For many individuals with end-stage liver disease, the only treatment option is liver transplantation. However, liver transplant rejection is observed in 24%-80% of transplant patients and lifelong drug regimens that follow the transplant procedure lead to serious side effects. Furthermore, the pool of donor livers available for transplantation is far less than the demand. Well-characterized and physiologically relevant models of liver transplantation are crucial to a deeper understanding of the cellular processes governing the outcomes of liver transplantation and serve as a platform for testing new therapeutic strategies to enhance graft acceptance. Such a model has been found in the rat transplant model, which has an advantageous size for surgical procedures, similar postoperative immunological progression, and high genome match to the human liver. From rat liver transplant studies published in the last 5 years, it is clear that the rat model serves as a strong platform to elucidate transplant immunological mechanisms. Using the model, we have begun to uncover potential players and possible therapeutic targets to restore liver tolerance and preserve host immunocompetence. Here, we present an overview of recent literature for rat liver transplant models, with an aim to highlight the value of the models and to provide future perspectives on how these models could be further characterized to enhance the overall value of rat models to the field of liver transplantation.

The CD8 T-cell response during tolerance induction in liver transplantation

Both experimental and clinical studies have shown that the liver possesses unique tolerogenic properties. Liver allografts can be spontaneously accepted across complete major histocompatibility mismatch in some animal models. In addition, some liver transplant patients can be successfully withdrawn from immunosuppressive medications, developing ‘operational tolerance'. Multiple mechanisms have been shown to be involved in inducing and maintaining alloimmune tolerance associated with liver transplantation. Here, we focus on CD8 T-cell tolerance in this setting. We first discuss how alloreactive cytotoxic T-cell responses are generated against allografts, before reviewing how the liver parenchyma, donor passenger leucocytes and the host immune system function together to attenuate alloreactive CD8 T-cell responses to promote the long-term survival of liver transplants.

SUFFICIENT TO RECOGNIZE SELF TO ATTACK NON-SELF: BLUEPRINT FOR A ONE-SIGNAL T CELL MODEL

Current consensus postulates that the class I-antigen processing system is evolved to present microbial antigens to specific T cells. Since such cells are rare and short-lived, they require three to five days to attain fighting strength. During this critical period he innate immune system holds back the briskly multiplying pathogens. Nevertheless, a T cell response is measurable in the lymph nodes draining the infection site within 12 to 18 h. In order to explain this paradox here we suggest a new T cell model. This is based on the observation that T cells require continuous contact of the T cell receptor (TCR) with selecting self-peptide–major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules in the periphery for their survival. We postulate that a dynamic steady state, a so-called coupled system is formed through low affinity complementary TCR–MHC interactions between T cells and host cells. Under such condition it is sufficient to recognize what is self in order to attack what is not self. A coupled system is regulated via soluble forms of peptide–MHC and TCR molecules by the law of mass action. In a coupled system one signal is sufficient for T cell activation. The new model implies that a significant fraction of the naive polyclonal T cells are recruited into the first line of defense from the very outset of an infection, so the number of activated T cells is increased by several orders of magnitude compared to conventional models. The one-signal model also predicts that therapeutic administration of soluble agonist or antagonist T cell receptor ligands may be able to fine tune the homeostatic physiological regulatory mechanism and thus improve the treatment of some chronic diseases such as metastatic cancer, HIV/AIDS, and transplantation.

Host-based Th2 cell therapy for prolongation of cardiac allograft viability

Donor T cell transfusion, which is a long-standing approach to prevent allograft rejection, operates indirectly by alteration of host T cell immunity. We therefore hypothesized that adoptive transfer of immune regulatory host Th2 cells would represent a novel intervention to enhance cardiac allograft survival. Using a well-described rat cardiac transplant model, we first developed a method for ex vivo manufacture of rat host-type Th2 cells in rapamycin, with subsequent injection of such Th2.R cells prior to class I and class II disparate cardiac allografting. Second, we determined whether Th2.R cell transfer polarized host immunity towards a Th2 phenotype. And third, we evaluated whether Th2.R cell therapy prolonged allograft viability when used alone or in combination with a short-course of cyclosporine (CSA) therapy. We found that host-type Th2.R cell therapy prior to cardiac allografting: (1) reduced the frequency of activated T cells in secondary lymphoid organs; (2) shifted post-transplant cytokines towards a Th2 phenotype; and (3) prolonged allograft viability when used in combination with short-course CSA therapy. These results provide further support for the rationale to use “direct” host T cell therapy for prolongation of allograft viability as an alternative to “indirect” therapy mediated by donor T cell infusion.

The protective effect of CD8+CD28- T suppressor cells on the acute rejection responses in rat liver transplantation

Regulatory T cells (Tr) or T-suppressor cells (Ts), which include CD4+CD25+ T cells and CD8+CD28- T cells respectively, have been shown to be essential for the induction and maintenance of immune tolerance. We have investigated the effect of CD8+CD28- Ts and CD4+CD25+ Tr on acute rejection responses in rat liver transplantation (OLT).

METHODS

CD8+CD28- Ts/CD4+CD25+ Tr were obtained from inbred and naïve rats that show spontaneous tolerance to OLT. Adoptive transfers were performed in acute rejection models of various strain combinations with survival times observed to evaluate suppressive effects. Donor-specific blood transfusion (DST) was used to induce CD8+CD28- Ts in naïve rats, which were assayed in vitro using carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl easter-labeled one-way mixed lymphocyte reactions. Secondary adoptive transfers of DST-induced CD8+CD28- Ts were also performed in an acute OLT rejection model.

RESULTS

CD8+CD28- Ts from tolerant OLT model rats possessed immunosuppressive activity in allogeneic recipients; adoptive transfers of these cells alleviated the acute rejection responses. However, CD4+CD25+ Tr derived from tolerant or naïve rats failed to do so. In vitro DST-induced CD8+CD28- Ts inhibited alloantigen T-cell responses in naïve syngeneic rats in an antigen-specific manner. Secondary adoptive transfer of DST-induced CD8+CD28-Ts further reduced acute rejection but not chronic rejection responses.

CONCLUSIONS

CD8+CD28- Ts cells protected allogeneic recipients from acute rejection in rat OLT. Furthermore, this activity was not present in CD4+CD25+Tr. DST was observed to be an effective method to generate functional CD8+CD28-Ts in naïve rats.

Lower Incidence of Bronchiolitis Obliterans in Pediatric Liver−Lung Transplant Recipients With Cystic Fibrosis

BACKGROUND

Simultaneous liver-lung transplantation is an infrequent but technically feasible procedure in patients with end-stage lung disease and advanced liver disease. We characterize the outcomes of pediatric patients who underwent this procedure at our institution.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective, case-control study and reviewed the medical records of all patients referred to our transplant program from its inception. Seven patients were listed for simultaneous liver-lung transplant. The five patients who survived to transplant were matched to 13 controls who underwent isolated bilateral sequential lung transplant for underlying diagnosis, age at time of transplant, gender, and era of transplant. Outcome measures included patient and graft survival, occurrence of bronchiolitis obliterans (BO), and episodes of rejection.

RESULTS

Of the five study patients who underwent liver-lung transplant, one died of multiorgan failure 11 days after transplant compared with 9 of 13 controls who died. The median survival for the study patients was 89 months (range, 0-112 months) compared with the controls, who had a median survival of 34 months (range, 0-118 months). The remaining four patients had bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome scores of 0 compared with 5 of 13 control patients (P=0.02). The rate of acute rejection per 100 patient days was 0.012 for the study patients compared with 0.11 for the controls (P=0.025).

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous liver-lung transplantation is a technically feasible procedure with excellent long-term outcomes. The surviving study subjects remain free from bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome. These results suggest that the transplanted liver may bestow immunologic privilege to the lung allograft.

Development of CD25– regulatory T cells following heart transplantation: Evidence for transfer of long-term survival

Donor-specific heart allograft acceptance can be induced in the MHC-mismatched LEW.1 W to LEW.1A rat by donor-specific transfusions. Whereas the induction phase of tolerance has been studied in detail, its maintenance remained poorly understood. Here, we performed a side-by-side comparison of CD25+ and CD25- splenic T cells of 100-day tolerant rats. Administration of CD25- T cells from tolerant rats to sublethally irradiated recipients transferred long-term graft survival. These CD25- T cells displayed a decreased donor-specific response in the mixed lymphocyte reaction and presented suppressive activity. These CD25- T cells accumulated IFN-gamma, IL-10 and Foxp3 transcripts. The in vitro suppressive activity of CD25- T cells required both cell contact and soluble factors (IL-10 and IFN-gamma). The CD25+ T cells from tolerant rats did not show any modification of their regulatory properties. We show that splenic CD25- T cells of tolerant rats contribute to the maintenance of tolerance following the transplantation. Our data show that regulatory T cells are not restricted to the CD4+ CD25+ T cell subset and provide new insights on the mechanisms of tolerance to allograft following donor cell priming.

The persistence of regulatory cells developing after rat spontaneous liver acceptance

BACKGROUND

We have previously reported that the spontaneous acceptance of Lewis (LEW, RT1(l)) to Dark Agouti (DA, RT1(a)) rat orthotopic liver transplant (OLT) is eliminated by donor gamma-irradiation. The acceptance of the irradiated LEW liver is also reestablished in a naïve rat after the adoptive transfer of T regulatory (T-reg) cells from a LEW to a DA liver-tolerant long-term (>60 days) survivor (LTS) into a naïve DA rat. However, little is known about the growth conditions required to maintain T-reg function. In this study, we examined the need for continued donor-specific alloantigen stimulation for the maintenance and function of T-reg cells.

METHODS

Splenocytes (SCs; 1.5 x 10(8) cells) from a LEW liver allograft-tolerant LTS DA recipient were adoptively transferred fresh or after in vitro stimulation into another naive DA rat on day 1, 4, or 7 before an irradiated (1000R) LEW liver transplant. For in vitro alloantigen stimulation, SCs from LEW to DA LTS were co-cultured with mitomycin-C (MMC)-treated naïve LEW (donor alloantigen-specific) or Brown Norway (BN) (RT1(n); third party) SCs for 72 hours. Graft rejection, as defined by death of the recipient, was confirmed histologically.

RESULTS

All LEW liver grafts were accepted spontaneously by DA recipients for more than 60 days (n=32), while all irradiated LEW livers were acutely rejected (n=9; mean survival time [MST]=12.8 +/- 4.0 days). When LTS DA SCs were adoptively transferred into a naive DA rat 1 day before OLT, all irradiated LEW grafts were accepted greater than 60 days (n=9). However, when fresh LTS DA SCs were transferred to a new naïve DA rat on 4 or 7 days before OLT, all irradiated LEW liver grafts were acutely rejected (MST=10.2 +/- 0.5 days [n=4] and MST=13.5 +/- 5.0 days [n=4], respectively). When LTS DA SCs were stimulated in vitro before adoptive transfer, irradiated LEW liver grafts after 4 days (n=5) were then accepted. In vitro culture of LTS DA SCs with MMC-treated BN SCs (third-party) for 72 hours before adoptive transfer resulted in 3 of 5 irradiated LEW livers at day 4 being accepted (n=5).

CONCLUSIONS

The maintenance of T-reg function requires continuous LEW donor-specific alloantigen stimulation.

Regulatory cells develop after the spontaneous acceptance of rat liver allografts

BACKGROUND

After donor-specific transfusion, tolerance to heart transplants is serially passed to naive rats by the adoptive transfer of long-term survivor (LTS)-tolerant splenocytes (SC). We examined whether regulatory cells similarly develop after the spontaneously accepted Lewis (LEW) to Dark Agouti (DA) liver transplants.

METHODS

SC from a LTS DA rat with a LEW liver were adoptively transferred to a naive DA 1 day before transplantation of an irradiated (1000 rad) LEW liver.

RESULTS

Untreated LEW to DA liver allografts were uniformly accepted; whereas all irradiated LEW liver grafts were rejected. In contrast, when 1.5 x 10 8 DA LTS SC were transferred to a naive DA recipient, all irradiated LEW liver grafts were accepted. When decreased to 1.0 x 10 8 LTS DA SC, only 1 of 4 irradiated LEW grafts was accepted. However, if 1.5 x 10 8 DA SC harvested only 30 days after liver transplantation were transferred, only 2 of 5 irradiated LEW liver grafts were accepted. The serial second and third adoptive transfers of 1.5 x 10 8 DA LTS SC also resulted in the uniform acceptance of irradiated LEW livers.

CONCLUSION

Regulatory cells that develop after the spontaneous acceptance of a LEW to DA liver transplant can serially transfer tolerance to new naive LEW liver allograft DA recipients. This "infectious tolerance" is dependent on the time of cell harvest after transplantation and on the cell dose given.

Rat liver transplantation without preservation of “phrenic ring” using double cuff method

AIM: To develop a double cuff method for rat liver transplantation without preservation of “phrenic ring” to shorten the portal vein clamping time.

METHODS: “Phrenic ring” was completely excluded from the donor liver, and end to end anastomosis of suprahepatic inferior vena cava was performed.

RESULTS: The portal vein clumping time was shortened to 10.6 min, the successful rate was 83.1%.

CONCLUSION: This method can simplify the operation and shorten the portal vein clumping time.

Lymph node removal enhances corneal graft survival in mice at high risk of rejection

Background

As shown previously, the submandibular (SM) lymph node (LN) is required for priming the immune response during corneal graft rejection. In this study, we wished to determine whether corneal grafts at "high-risk" of rejection were also protected after selective SM LN removal and if so to investigate whether this improved corneal graft survival was due to induction of specific regulatory/suppressor cells or was due to immunological "ignorance".

Methods

Two sets of experiments were performed. (1) Adoptive transfer of possible regulatory splenocytes from mice with long-term accepted corneal graft after SM LN removal. (2) SM LN removal and corneal grafts in "high-risk" hosts, which had been (A) subjected to corneal trauma with vascularization or (B) allosensitized by previous corneal graft or (C) allosensitized by previous skin graft.

Results

Adoptive transfer of splenocytes from tolerant mice after SM LN removal did not enhance corneal graft survival in naive recipients (p > 0.05).

SM LN removal in mice with corneal vascularization enhanced corneal allograft survival compared to grafted controls with/without vascularization (p < 0.0001). The removal of the SM LN in mice, who had already been allosensitized by a previous corneal graft, did not statistically prolong corneal graft survival (p > 0.05). SM LN removal procedure did not delay rejection of corneal grafts in mice allosensitized by a previous skin transplant with the same strain combination (p > 0.05).

Conclusion

The results suggest that removal of the SM LN in "high-risk" mice prevents rejection by mechanisms involving immune "ignorance", since prior allosensitization prevents graft acceptance after LN removal. In allosensitized recipients the stronger the allosensitization (skin- vs. corneal graft-presensitization) the greater the possibility of priming for rejection at alternative draining LN sites.