The effect of spatial frequency and contrast on visual persistence

Are the inverse-duration and inverse-proximity effects in temporal integration subserved by independent mechanisms?

Displays shorter than about 100 ms are normally seen as lasting longer than their physical duration. This visible persistence can bridge a temporal gap between two sequential stimuli causing them to be temporally integrated into a single percept. We investigated two findings in the temporal-integration literature: the inverse duration effect (temporal integration is progressively impaired as the duration of the first stimulus is increased) and the inverse proximity effect (temporal integration is progressively impaired as the spatial proximity between the stimuli is increased). In two experiments we asked whether the two effects are separable (i.e., whether they are subserved by independent mechanisms) or interact with one another. To estimate the duration of visible persistence we used the missing element paradigm in Experiment 1 and directional stroboscopic motion between two lines in Experiment 2. In both experiments we manipulated the duration of the leading stimulus and the spatial gap between the elements of the two sequential displays. Additive-factors logic was employed to examine the separability of the effects of duration and proximity. Independence (separability) of the two factors would be evidenced in a graph in which the functions of duration over proximity are parallel. The results pointed uniformly to separability. A plausible mechanism for the inverse duration effect is the burst of processing activity time-locked to stimulus onset. A plausible mechanism for the inverse proximity effect is lateral inhibition that acts to reduce the visible persistence of the leading stimulus.

Visual Discomfort From Flash Afterimages of Riloid Patterns

Op-art-based stimuli have been shown to be uncomfortable, possibly due to a combination of fixational eye movements (microsaccades) and excessive cortical responses. Efforts have been made to measure illusory phenomena arising from these stimuli in the absence of microsaccades, but there has been no attempt thus far to decouple the effects of the cortical response from the effect of fixational eye movements. This study uses flash afterimages to stabilise the image on the retina and thus reduce the systematic effect of eye movements, in order to investigate the role of the brain in discomfort from op-art-based stimuli. There was a relationship between spatial frequency and the magnitude of the P300 response, showing a similar pattern to that of discomfort judgements, which suggests that there might be a role of discomfort and excessive neural responses independently from the effects of microsaccades.

The impending demise of the icon: A critique of the concept of iconic storage in visual information processing

Without disputing the experimental evidence that subjects have available most of the content of brief displays for a fraction of a second, or that visual stimuli Persist after their physical termination for a similar time, I argue that this evidence is irrelevant to perception. Specifically, the notion of an icon as a brief storage of information persisting after stimulus termination cannot possibly be useful in any typical visual information-processing task except reading in a lightning storm. Since the visual world that provides the stimuli for perception is continuous and not chopped up by tachistoscopes, and since our eyes and heads are rarely motionless, no realistic circumstances exist in which having a frozen iconic storage of information could be helpful. Rather, the presence of such an icon interferes with perception. This paper examines instances of normal perception, and then reviews experimental evidence on temporal integration, saccadic suppression, masking, and the photoreceptor basis of visual persistence, to further demonstrate that a storage of excitation cannot be a useful device for storing information. Finally, I note that little would have to be changed in our theories of visual perception or information processing if we simply forgot all about the icon and iconic memory as an early stage of processing.

Attenuation of perceived motion smear during vergence and pursuit tracking

When the eyes move, the images of stationary objects sweep across the retina. Despite this motion of the retinal image and the substantial integration of visual signals across time, physically stationary objects typically do not appear to be smeared during eye movements. Previous studies indicated that the extent of perceived motion smear is smaller when a stationary target is presented during pursuit or saccadic eye movements than when comparable motion of the retinal image occurs during steady fixation. In this study, we compared the extent of perceived motion smear for a stationary target during smooth pursuit and vergence eye movements with that for a physically moving target during fixation. For a target duration of 100 ms or longer, perceived motion smear is substantially less when the motion of the retinal image results from vergence or pursuit eye movements than when it results from the motion of a target during fixation. The reduced extent of perceived motion smear during eye movements compared to fixation cannot be accounted for by different spatio-temporal interactions between visual targets or by unequal attention to the moving test spot under these two types of conditions. We attribute the highly similar attenuation of perceived smear during vergence and pursuit to a comparable action of the extra-retinal signals for disjunctive and conjugate eye movements.

Visible persistence and form correspondence in Ternus apparent motion

Visual stimuli remain visible for some time after their physical offset (visible persistence). Visible persistence has been hypothesized to play an important role in determining the pattern of correspondence matching in the Ternus apparent-motion display. In this display, one or more elements reappears in overlapping locations at different times, whereas another element appears alternately to the right or the left of these elements. Usually either the elements are perceived to move coherently as a group (group motion), or one element may be perceived to hop over one or more other elements (element motion). According to the visible-persistence account of the perceptual organization of the Ternus display, element motion is seen when the temporal gap between elements in overlapping locations is small enough to be bridged by visible persistence; if it is not, group motion is seen. We conducted four experiments to test this visible-persistence account. In Experiments 1 and 2, a form correspondence cue (line length) was introduced to bias the visual system toward the element-motion interpretation, while visible persistence was either reduced or eliminated. The element-motion percept dominated despite the elimination of visible persistence. In Experiments 3 and 4, we found that Ternus elements presented without interruption, and thus presumably persisting over time, can be perceived in group motion. Together, the results indicate that visible persistence is neither necessary nor sufficient to account for the pattern of correspondence matches in the Ternus display.

Perceptual grouping in space and time: evidence from the Ternus display

We report three experiments investigating the effect of perceptual grouping on the appearance of a bistable apparent-motion (Ternus) display. Subjects viewed a Ternus display embedded in an array of context elements that could potentially group with the Ternus elements. In contrast to several previous findings, we found that grouping influenced apparent motion perception. In Experiment 1, apparent motion perception was significantly affected via grouping by shape similarity, even when the visible persistence of the elements was controlled. In Experiment 2, elements perceived as moving without context were perceived as stationary without context were perceived as moving when grouped with moving elements perceived as stationary without context were perceived as moving when grouped with moving context elements. We argue that grouping in the spatial and temporal domains interact to yield perceptual experience of apparent-motion displays.

Temporal-discontinuity detection with contrast-modulated gratings

Three experiments on temporal-discontinuity detection were carried out. In experiment 1, temporal-discontinuity thresholds were measured for sinusoidal gratings by the use of the double-staircase method. A sinusoidal grating was presented twice successively. The subject judged whether or not an interval was present. The temporal-discontinuity threshold increased as the spatial frequency of the grating increased, but decreased as the contrast of the grating increased. In experiment 2, contrast-modulated gratings were used instead of the sinusoidal grating. The temporal-discontinuity threshold increased as the carrier frequency increased, and the threshold for each contrast-modulated grating was similar to that for the no-modulation (sinusoidal) grating whose contrast was the same as the maximum local contrast of the contrast-modulated grating. In experiment 3, temporal-discontinuity thresholds were measured for low-contrast (3%) sinusoidal gratings. The thresholds were very low, even for such low-contrast gratings. These results suggest that the low-spatial-frequency channels are not involved in detecting the modulation frequency of the contrast-modulated grating. Rather, the local contrast seems to be the determinant of the detection of the contrast-modulated grating itself.

Visible persistence decay rates for schizophrenics and substance abusers

Information-processing deficits are consistently reported for schizophrenics. The findings from the majority of psychophysical tasks indicate that the deficit is specific to schizophrenics and thus may represent a marker for schizophrenia. The present study evaluated for specificity of impairment by including controls using methadone. A two-pulsed forced choice information-processing task that required the detection of a line or a blank-field during an interstimulus interval (ISI) indexed efficiency of processing (i.e., visible persistence). There were 19 schizophrenic, 9 schizoaffective, 8 depressed, 12 on methadone, and 12 normal subjects. The visual stimuli were low and high spatial frequency gratings. Either a line of equivalent width to those of the gratings or a blank field was presented during the ISI. The gratings were presented for 150 msec prior to and following an ISI of 30, 60, 90, 120, 150, and 350 msec. The results support previous findings for impaired processing during a 90-150 msec interval for schizophrenics. Also, the methadone-using controls were not significantly different from schizophrenics. Normal and depressed controls' profiles did not differ from each other, however, they were significantly different from the other groups. The results support an early information-processing deficit in schizophrenic individuals and may implicate dysregulation of dopaminergic neuromodulation.

Effect of the ISI on the visible persistence of a stimulus in apparent motion

The persistence of briefly flashed stimuli undergoing a horizontal apparent motion is assessed as a function of the temporal interval (inter-stimulus interval or ISI) between successive locations. The main result is that the duration of persistence is increased when the ISI is reduced (within the range 1-15 msec). An increase of persistence also occurs when the spatial separation (delta chi) between successive presentations of the moving stimulus becomes larger, a well established result which is replicated here. In both cases, the elevation of persistence suggests that inhibitory processes, which are assumed to underlie the persistence-suppression, have become less efficient. According to the data, it seems that the spatio-temporal parameters of motion, and not the speed as such, are responsible for the strength of inhibition. Namely, optimal inhibition, and thus suppression, would need a minimum amount of time to take place, and would improve with proximity (i.e. with smaller delta chi). Finally, a persistence-suppression decrease is observed when the angular size of the flashed stimuli is reduced (i.e. when higher spatial frequencies become more predominant). A model of transient-on-sustained inhibition accounts well for these results.

An investigation of some sensory and refractive visual factors in dyslexia

The role of visual factors in dyslexia has been a long-standing source of controversy. Recent research has suggested that there may be a deficit of the transient visual subsystem in dyslexia. The evidence for this hypothesis comes principally from investigations of spatial and temporal contrast sensitivity and visual persistence. This evidence is reviewed and it is noted that previous work has never applied two of these purported "tests of transient function" to the same subject group. The hypothesised transient system deficit in dyslexia was investigated in a study comparing 43 control with 39 dyslexic children who were matched for age, sex, and intelligence. Comprehensive psychometric and optometric data were obtained, including visual acuities and refractive errors. The spatial contrast sensitivity function was determined in such a way as to investigate further the findings of Lovegrove, Martin, Bowling, Blackwood, Badcock and Paxton [(1982) Neuropsychology, 20, 309-315] and Martin and Lovegrove [(1984) Neuropsychologia, 22, 73-77]. It might be expected, from the work of Merigan and Maunsell [(1990) Neuroscience, 5, 347-352], that a better test of magno-cellular function would be to investigate the modulation threshold for a virtually uniform field that was flickering sinusoidally at 10 Hz. This temporal contrast sensitivity was studied in a similar way to Brannan and Williams [(1988) Clinical Vision Sciences, 3, 137-142]. A non-verbal simulated reading visual search task was used to investigate the effect of any visual deficits on a test that was, in its low-level visual requirements, similar to reading. The following factors were found to be significantly associated with dyslexia: reduced visual acuity, impaired flicker detection at 10 Hz, reduced low spatial frequency contrast sensitivity, and slightly slower performance at a simulated reading visual search task. The two alleged "tests of transient function" were only weakly correlated with one another (r = 0.183), suggesting that these variables do not measure the same function. Much of the dyslexic group's slightly slower performance at the simulated reading task could be accounted for by the psychometric variable of visual sequential memory. Like reading, the simulated reading task requires the accurate perception of sequential characters. Hence, it seems unlikely that the low-level visual deficits in the dyslexic group were major causes of their poor reading performance. Alternative explanations for the results are discussed.

Apparent duration and spatial structure

In three experiments, we investigated the relative perceived duration of a full bandwidth image and a set of high- and lowpass filtered images of a scene, briefly presented on a visual display unit. In Experiment 1, the various images were compared with each other, using a paired comparison method. All images were presented for 40 msec, and observers were asked to judge which of each pair of images had the longest duration. The results showed that images containing a wide spatial frequency bandwidth were judged to be of longer duration than were images of a narrower bandwidth, regardless of whether the latter were high- or lowpass filtered. In Experiment 2, a 40-msec presentation of each of the images was compared with a presentation of a probe that was 20, 40, 60, or 80 msec in duration. Observers again judged which of each pair of images had the longest duration. The results were very similar to those of Experiment 1, with wide bandwidth images being judged to be of longer duration than were narrow bandwidth images. In Experiment 3, instead of comparing the various filtered versions of the image with each other, we attempted to obtain a direct measure of perceived duration by comparing a flashing LED to a 40-msec flash of a subset of the images used in the previous experiments. The observers' task was to adjust the duration of the LED flash to match the perceived duration of each image.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Visual persistence of figures defined by relative motion

In order to measure visual persistence of figures that were solely defined by relative motion (motion-defined figures or motion figures), random-dot kinematograms were used to form stimulus figures in the two-frame, missing element task introduced by Di Lollo, V. (1977 Nature, 257, 241-243). Experiment 1 showed that motion-defined figures persisted for about 130 msec after the termination of the stimulus presentation (i.e. after the dots stopped moving). This was similar to but several tens of milliseconds longer than the visual persistence of figures which were defined by a luminance difference (luminance-defined figures or luminance figures) in the same random-dot pattern. Since motion detectors are not found in the retina or lateral geniculate in primates, our results strongly suggest that visual persistence is not only a retinal phenomenon but also a cortical one. Experiment 2 investigated the possible influence of motion aftereffects on the visual persistence of motion figures. The results showed that coherent movement of the dots over the whole display after the stimulus offset did not reduce the visual persistence of motion figures, suggesting that the source of this persistence is not a motion aftereffect. In Experiment 3, visual persistence for the motion-defined figures was shown to be longer than that for luminance-defined figures independently of the contrast of the stimulus figure as long as the stimuli could be seen clearly enough. This suggests that different mechanisms are involved in the visual persistence of motion-defined and luminance-defined figures.

The perceived duration of gratings

Since visible persistence of grating patterns increases with spatial frequency, it is often inferred that the perceived duration of a grating is also longer at higher spatial frequencies. However, other work has demonstrated that the perceived onset of a grating is also delayed at higher spatial frequencies. Thus it is impossible to infer the subjective duration from the results of visible persistence studies alone. In order to estimate perceived duration in the present study, reaction times (RTs) to grating onsets and offsets were measured for a range of spatial frequencies. The results indicate that although the perceived duration (ie the difference between offset and onset RTs) was consistently longer than the physical duration, the estimates of perceived duration did not vary with changes in spatial frequency. Differences between the present results and earlier findings are interpreted in the context of the different methods used to measure perceived offset.

Visual persistence of spatially filtered images

Periodic stimuli such as sine-wave gratings and checkerboard patterns have been used in many studies of visual perception. It is well known that with such stimuli, visual persistence increases as spatial frequency increases and as contrast decreases. It is not clear, however, that similar relationships obtain for aperiodic stimuli such as natural images. Digitized images of objects (a face and a vase) were submitted to two-dimensional Fourier analysis. Four pairs of spatial frequency band-limited images were created for each image. Each pair consisted of a normal (NP) and a scrambled (SP) phase version, with the magnitude spectrum and space-averaged luminance the same within each pair. Filter bandwidths were one octave wide. Threshold persistence was measured for each spatially filtered image. Visual persistence for SP images increased significantly as spatial frequency increased, whereas no significant differences were found for NP images. This suggests that the temporal processing of complex, aperiodic visual images is influenced by the spatial frequency and contrast of local features within the image and cannot be predicted by space-averaged estimates of contrast and spatial frequency.

Age differences in the temporal continuity of gratings as a function of their spatial frequency

This study compared young and elderly observers on the continuity of sinusoidal grating-pairs as a function of interstimulus interval (ISI) and spatial frequency (.5, 1.0, 2.0, 4.0, 8.0, and 12.0 c/deg). Consistent with prior research, the maximum ISI over which pattern continuity was maintained increased with spatial frequency. In addition, among older observers, grating continuity occurred at significantly longer ISI's at the two lowest spatial frequencies; no age difference was observed at the higher spatial frequencies. These results could not be attributed to an age difference in retinal illumination associated with pupillary miosis. However, they do indicate an age-related decline in detecting visual offset and are consistent with the hypothesis of a decline in the effectiveness of the transient visual channels.

Response persistence of cat retinal ganglion cells to the temporally discrete presentation of sinewave gratings

The neural basis of visible persistence is not well understood. In the present study the initial onset responses of cat retinal ganglion cells to the abrupt onset and offset of sinewave gratings were examined to determine if ganglion cells display a degree of response persistence that might account for the phenomenon of visible persistence. The responses of X and Y ganglion cell axons were tested using single-unit extracellular recording techniques. Both cell types displayed some degree of response persistence and over a limited range of short stimulus durations response persistence was inversely related to stimulus duration. These data suggest that neural persistence at the ganglion cell level may be the initial physiological basis for some types of visible persistence.

Spatial frequencies and the cerebral hemispheres: contrast sensitivity, visible persistence, and letter classification

The hypothesis that the two cerebral hemispheres are specialized for processing different visual spatial frequencies was investigated in three experiments. No differences between the left and right visual fields were found for: (1) contrast-sensitivity functions measured binocularly with vertical gratings ranging from 0.5 to 12 cycles per degree (cpd); (2) visible persistence durations for 1- and 10-cpd gratings measured with a stimulus alternation method; and (3) accuracy (d') and reaction times to correctly identify digitally filtered letters as targets (L or H) or nontargets (T or F). One significant difference, however, was found: In Experiment 3, a higher decision criterion (beta) was used when filtered letters were identified in the right visual field than when they were identified in the left. The letters were filtered with annular, 1-octave band-pass filters with center spatial frequencies of 1, 2, 4, 8, and 16 cpd. Combining four center frequencies with three letter sizes (0.5 degrees, 1 degree, and 2 degrees high) made some stimuli equivalent in distal spatial frequency (cycles per object) and some equivalent in proximal spatial frequency (cycles per degree). The effective stimulus in the third experiment seemed to be proximal spatial frequency (cycles per degree) not distal (cycles per object). We conclude that each cerebral hemisphere processes visual spatial frequency information with equal accuracy but that different decision rules are used.

Uniform-field flicker masking in control and specifically-disabled readers

Possible transient-system deficiencies in subjects with specific reading disabilities (SRDs) were investigated in groups of 13-year-old SRDs and control normal readers. In experiment 1, in which a 6 Hz uniform-field flicker (UFF) mask and a stationary test stimulus were used, it was found that the overall effect of UFF masking was to reduce differences in contrast sensitivity between SRDs and normal readers. In experiments 2a and 2b, with UFF masks of 6 and 20 Hz and a 6 Hz moving (experiment 2a) or flickering (experiment 2b) test stimulus, contrast sensitivity in both groups was decreased in the presence of the 6 Hz UFF mask. Only the control group, however, showed a further decrease in sensitivity with the 20 Hz UFF mask. This indicates that the groups differ in terms of a mechanism sensitive to high temporal frequencies. A 20 Hz counterphase flickering test stimulus was used in experiment 3 in the presence of 6 Hz UFF, and it was found that SRDs are less sensitive than controls to 20 Hz flicker across all spatial frequencies used. The 6 Hz mask, however, did not differentially affect the two groups. These findings provide further evidence for a transient-system deficit in the visual systems of SRDs, but also suggest a more complex situation by showing that the two groups differ in a high-temporal-frequency mechanism.

Visible persistence in paranoid schizophrenics

A visual temporal integration (i.e., visible persistence) task was performed by normal controls and paranoid schizophrenics. The task evaluated the critical duration (CD), which approximates the duration of peripheral persistence duration and post-CD persistence, which is possibly more associated with central processes. Subjects were required to report when temporally modulated spatial frequency patterns, which are known to have characteristic temporal processing rates, were pulsing "on-off" with a distinct "off" period. The dependent measure was the duration of visible persistence. An analysis of groups X spatial frequency duration (50, 75, 150, 300 msec) X spatial frequency (high, medium, low), with repeated measures on the last two variables, revealed that the second-order interaction was significant (p less than 0.05). Schizophrenics had shorter visible persistence only for the 300-msec presentation for the high spatial frequency pattern. Also, the CD of schizophrenics did not conform to the duration of normals on the high spatial frequency. The results are discussed in terms of the role high spatial frequencies plays in visual information processing and how shorter visible persistence by paranoid schizophrenics may reflect a premature termination of information necessary for synthesis into accurate percepts.