Oriented internal electrostatic fields: an emerging design element in coordination chemistry and catalysis

The power of oriented electrostatic fields (ESFs) to influence chemical bonding and reactivity is a phenomenon of rapidly growing interest. The presence of strong ESFs has recently been implicated as one of the most significant contributors to the activity of select enzymes, wherein alignment of a substrate's changing dipole moment with a strong, local electrostatic field has been shown to be responsible for the majority of the enzymatic rate enhancement. Outside of enzymology, researchers have studied the impacts of "internal" electrostatic fields via the addition of ionic salts to reactions and the incorporation of charged functional groups into organic molecules (both experimentally and computationally), and "externally" via the implementation of bulk fields between electrode plates. Incorporation of charged moieties into homogeneous inorganic complexes to generate internal ESFs represents an area of high potential for novel catalyst design. This field has only begun to materialize within the past 10 years but could be an area of significant impact moving forward, since it provides a means for tuning the properties of molecular complexes via a method that is orthogonal to traditional strategies, thereby providing possibilities for improved catalytic conditions and novel reactivity. In this perspective, we highlight recent developments in this area and offer insights, obtained from our own research, on the challenges and future directions of this emerging field of research.

Electrostatic vs. inductive effects in phosphine ligand donor properties and reactivity

Enhanced rates and selectivity in enzymes are enabled in part by precisely tuned electric fields within active sites. Analogously, the use of charged groups to leverage electrostatics in molecular systems is a promising strategy to tune reactivity. However, separation of the through space and through bond effects of charged functional groups is a long standing challenge that limits the rational application of electric fields in molecular systems. To address this challenge we developed a method using the phosphorus selenium coupling value (J _P-Se) of anionic phosphine selenides to quantify the electrostatic contribution of the borate moiety to donor strength. In this analysis we report the synthesis of a novel anionic phosphine, PPh₂CH₂BF₃K, the corresponding tetraphenyl phosphonium and tetraethyl ammonium selenides [PPh₄][SePPh₂CH₂BF₃] and [TEA][SePPh₂CH₂BF₃], and the Rh carbonyl complex [PPh₄][Rh(acac)(CO)(PPh₂(CH₂BF₃))]. Solvent-dependent changes in J _P-Se were fit using Coulomb's law and support up to an 80% electrostatic contribution to the increase in donor strength of [PPh₄][SePPh₂CH₂BF₃] relative to SePPh₂Et, while controls with [TEA][SePPh₂CH₂BF₃] exclude convoluting ion pairing effects. Calculations using explicit solvation or point charges effectively replicate the experimental data. This J _P-Se method was extended to [PPh₄][SePPh₂(2-BF₃Ph)] and likewise estimates up to a 70% electrostatic contribution to the increase in donor strength relative to SePPh₃. The use of PPh₂CH₂BF₃K also accelerates C-F oxidative addition reactivity with Ni(COD)₂ by an order of magnitude in comparison to the comparatively donating neutral phosphines PEt₃ and PCy₃. This enhanced reactivity prompted the investigation of catalytic fluoroarene C-F borylation, with improved yields observed for less fluorinated arenes. These results demonstrate that covalently bound charged functionalities can exert a significant electrostatic influence under common solution phase reaction conditions and experimentally validate theoretical predictions regarding electrostatic effects in reactivity.

Tuning Photoenolization-Driven Cycloadditions Using Theory and Spectroscopy

The first broad spectrum investigation into the photoenolization/Diels-Alder (PEDA) sequence was carried out using M06-2X/6-31+G(d,p) in conjunction with SMD solvation and supported by experimental UV-vis spectroscopy. A test set of 20 prodienes was chosen to examine the role of the H atom acceptor group (substituted and unsubstituted carbonyl, thiocarbonyl, and imine), the H atom donor group, and bystander ring substituents. As reaction partners for the photogenerated dienes, a diverse test set of 20 dienophiles was examined, comprising electron rich, electron poor, neutral, strain activated, hydrocarbon, and heteroatom-containing molecules including CO₂ and CO. A key finding of this work is the demonstration that the PEDA sequence of carbonyl based prodienes is tolerant of most substitution patterns. Another is that thiocarbonyl derivatives should behave analogously to the carbonyls but are likely to do so much more slowly, due to an inefficient intersystem crossing, an endothermic 1,5-hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) step, and a [1,5] sigmatropic H shift to regenerate the starting material that outcompetes the [4 + 2]cycloaddition. In contrast, the T₁ state of the ortho-alkyl imines displays the incorrect orbital symmetry for 1,5-HAT and is correspondingly accompanied by higher barriers, even in the excited state. However, provided these barriers can be overcome, the remaining steps in the PEDA sequence are predicted to be facile. The Diels-Alder reaction is predicted to be of much broader scope than reported synthetic literature: while electron poor dienophiles are expected to be the most reactive partners, ethylene and electron rich alkenes should react at a synthetically useful rate. CO is predicted to undergo a facile (4 + 1)cheletropic addition instead of the normal [4 + 2]cycloaddition pathway. This unique photoenolization/cheletropic addition (PECA) sequence could provide metal-free access to benzannelated cyclopentanones.

Solvent Effects on Ultrafast Photochemical Pathways

Photochemical reactions are increasingly being used for chemical and materials synthesis, for example, in photoredox catalysis, and generally involve photoexcitation of molecular chromophores dissolved in a liquid solvent. The choice of solvent influences the outcomes of the photochemistry because solute-solvent interactions modify the energies of and crossings between electronic states of the chromophores, and they affect the evolving structures of the photoexcited molecules. Ultrafast laser spectroscopy methods with femtosecond to picosecond time resolution can resolve the dynamics of these photoexcited molecules as they undergo structural and electronic changes, relax back to the ground state, dissipate their excess internal energy to the surrounding solvent, or undergo photochemical reactions. In this Account, we illustrate how experimental studies using ultrafast lasers can reveal the influences that different solvents or cosolutes exert on the photoinduced nonadiabatic dynamics of internal conversion and intersystem crossing in nonradiative relaxation pathways. Although the environment surrounding a solute molecule is rapidly changing, with fluctuations in the coordination to neighboring solvent molecules occurring on femtosecond or picosecond time scales, we show that it is possible to photoexcite selectively only those molecular chromophores transiently experiencing specific solute-solvent interactions such as intermolecular hydrogen bonding.The effects of different solvation environments on the photodynamics are illustrated using four selected examples of photochemical processes in which the solvent has a marked effect on the outcomes. We first consider two aromatic carbonyl compounds, benzophenone and acetophenone, which are known to undergo fast intersystem crossing to populate the first excited triplet state on time scales of a few picoseconds. We show that the nonadiabatic excited-state dynamics are modified by transient hydrogen bonding of the carbonyl group to a protic solvent or by coordination to a metal cation cosolute. We then examine how different solvents modify the competition between two alternative relaxation pathways in a photoexcited UVA-sunscreen molecule, diethylamino hydroxybenzoyl hexyl benzoate (DHHB). This relaxation back to the ground electronic state is an essential part of the effective operation of the sunscreen compound, but the dynamics are sensitive to the surrounding environment. Finally, we consider how solvents of different polarity affect the energies and lifetimes of excited states with locally excited or charge-transfer character in heterocyclic organic compounds used as excited-state electron donors for photoredox catalysis. With these and other examples, we seek to develop a molecular level understanding of how the choice of solution environment might be used to control the outcomes of photochemical reactions.

Tuning the Excited-State Dynamics of Acetophenone Using Metal Ions in Solution

The effects of dissolved metal salts on the excited-state dynamics of acetophenone in solution have been explored by using ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy at two UV excitation wavelengths. In the absence of metal ions, the S₁(nπ*) transition of acetophenone is excited at 320 nm, with intersystem crossing (ISC) occurring with a time constant τ_ISC = 5.95 ± 0.47 ps in acetonitrile solution. Excitation at 280 nm accesses the S₂(ππ*) state, which internally converts (<0.2 ps) to S₁ before undergoing ISC with τ_ISC = 4.36 ± 0.14 ps. Coordination to Mg²⁺ ions makes the S₂ state accessible to excitation at 320 nm, with the rate of S₂ → S₁ internal conversion reducing 3-fold but the ISC rate increasing. These changes to the excited-state energies and dynamics of this model photosensitizer indicate that dissolved metal salts could modify the photochemistry of synthetically useful homogeneous photocatalytic systems.

Electrostatically Tuning the Photodissociation of the Irgacure 2959 Photoinitiator in the Gas Phase by Cation Binding

The low-lying electronic states of Irgacure 2959, a Norrish-type I photoinitiator, complexed with a single metal cation are investigated in the gas phase by photodissociation action spectroscopy. Analysis of the band shifts using quantum chemical calculations (TD-DFT and SCS-CC2) reveals the underlying influence of the charge on the key electronic energy levels. Since the cations (H⁺, Li⁺, Na⁺, K⁺, Zn²⁺, Ca²⁺, and Mg²⁺) bind at varying distances, the magnitude of the electric field at the center of the chromophore due to the cation is altered, and this shifts the electronic states by different amounts. Photodissociation action spectra of cation-Irg complexes show that absorption transitions to the first ¹ππ* state are red-shifted with a magnitude proportional to the electric field strength (with red shifts >1 eV), and in most cases, the cation is essentially acting as a point charge. Calculations show that a neighboring ³nπ* state, a key state for the α-cleavage pathway, is destabilized (blue-shifted) by the orientated electric field. As such, if the ¹ππ*-³nπ* energy gap is reduced, increased intersystem crossing rates are expected, resulting in higher yields of the desired radical photoproducts, and this is controlled by the orientated electric field arising from the cation.

Using internal electrostatic fields to manipulate the valence manifolds of copper complexes

A series of tetradentate tris(phosphinimine) ligands (^R3P₃tren) was developed and bound to Cu^I to form the trigonal pyramidal, C_3v-symmetric cuprous complexes [^R3P₃tren-Cu][BAr^F₄] (1PR3) (PR₃ = PMe₃, PMe₂Ph, PMePh₂, PPh₃, PMe₂(NEt₂), BAr^F₄ = B(C₆F₅)₄). Electrochemical studies on the Cu^I complexes were undertaken, and the permethylated analog, 1PMe3, was found to display an unprecedentedly cathodic Cu^I/Cu^II redox potential (−780 mV vs. Fc/Fc⁺ in isobutyronitrile). Elucidation of the electronic structures of 1PR3via density functional theory (DFT) studies revealed atypical valence manifold configurations, resulting from strongly σ-donating phosphinimine moieties in the xy-plane that destabilize 2e (d_xy/d_x²−y²) orbital sets and uniquely stabilized a₁ (d_z²) orbitals. Support is provided that the a₁ stabilizations result from intramolecular electrostatic fields (ESFs) generated from cationic character on the phosphinimine moieties in ^R3P₃tren. This view is corroborated via 1-dimensional electrostatic potential maps along the z-axes of 1PR3 and their isostructural analogues. Experimental validation of this computational model is provided upon oxidation of 1PMe3 to the cupric complex [^Me3P₃tren-Cu][OTf]₂ (2PMe3), which displays a characteristic Jahn–Teller distortion in the form of a see-saw, pseudo-C_s-symmetric geometry. A systematic anodic shift in the potential of the Cu^I/Cu^II redox couple as the steric bulk in the secondary coordination sphere increases is explained through the complexes' diminishing ability to access the ideal C_s-symmetric geometry upon oxidation. The observations and calculations discussed in this work support the presence of internal electrostatic fields within the copper complexes, which subsequently influence the complexes' properties via a method orthogonal to classic ligand field tuning.

Secondary coordination sphere electrostatic effects tune the valence manifolds of copper centers, impacting molecular geometries, photophysical properties, and redox potentials.

Ordered Solvents and Ionic Liquids Can Be Harnessed for Electrostatic Catalysis

Herein, we employ classical molecular dynamics simulations using the Drude oscillator-based polarizable force field, quantum chemical calculations, and ONIOM multiscale calculations to study (a) how an external field orders the solvent environment in a chemical reaction and then (b) whether in the absence of this same applied field the ordered solvent environment alone can electrostatically catalyze a chemical reaction when compared with the corresponding disordered solvent. Our results show that a 0.2 V/Å external electric field, which is below the threshold for bond breaking of solvent molecules, leads to significant ordering of bulk methanol solvent and the ionic liquid [EMIM][BF₄]. Importantly, in the absence of this same field, the ordered solvent lowers the activation energy of the hydrogen-transfer reaction of o-alkylphenyl ketones in excess of 20 kcal/mol when the solvent is methanol and by over 30 kcal/mol for [EMIM][BF₄]. Even a 0.1 V/Å external field has effects of ca. 10 and 20 kcal/mol, respectively. This work suggests a possible strategy for scaling electrostatic catalysis by applying a pulsed external field to the reaction medium to maintain solvent ordering while allowing the reaction to proceed largely in the absence of an external field.

RACI Awards 2017–19

Collapse