Xenografting restores spermatogenesis to cryptorchid testicular tissue but does not rescue the phenotype of idiopathic testicular degeneration in the horse (Equus caballus)

Characterisation of the testicular transcriptome in stallions with age-related testicular degeneration

BACKGROUND

Age-related testicular degeneration can be defined as the progressive deterioration of the testis that typically occurs in middle-aged or older males and that leads to diminished testicular function and subfertility. In the equine breeding industry, genetically valuable males maintain their value as breeding animals well into old age. Because testicular degeneration is common in middle-aged and older stallions, the disease often has a significant negative impact on a stallion's breeding career and leads to economic losses in the horse breeding industry.

OBJECTIVE

Because testicular degeneration is a tissue autologous disease in the horse, the objective of this study was to use whole-transcriptome sequencing to compare the testicular transcriptomes of normal, fertile stallions to those of stallions affected by age-related testicular degeneration in order to better understand the pathophysiology of the disease.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross sectional.

METHODS

Testicular tissue samples from clinical castrations or euthanasia were collected from normal healthy (n = 3) or older subfertile (n = 4) stallions. Samples were processed and sequenced on an Illumina HiSeq™ 2000 Sequencing System. Bioinformatic analysis of the data was performed in R/RStudio, and the transcriptomes were compared between the two groups. Genes were considered to be differentially expressed between healthy and diseased tissue if they demonstrated at least a ±1.5× fold change difference and had a false discovery rate-adjusted P value <0.05. Gene ontology analysis was performed using Ingenuity® IPA.

RESULTS

Analyses of differential expression of individual genes, as well as computer-based gene ontology analysis, identified upregulation of cytokine-mediated inflammatory pathways in testes from stallions affected with testicular degeneration. This upregulation of inflammation was associated with upregulation of cell survival pathways, inhibition of apoptotic pathways and increases in collagen formation.

MAIN LIMITATIONS

There are unavoidable confounding factors (e.g. differences in breed, management, environment, age) that could create non disease-related genetic variation between our normal and affected samples. In addition, there are practical limitations to applying computer-based gene ontology analysis to equine samples. Gene ontology software relies on published information (mostly non-equine), and some biological processes (e.g. apoptosis and inflammation) are more commonly studied than others and so are over-represented in the literature and therefore more likely to be identified by computer algorithms. Caution should be taken when interpreting the data, as alterations in gene expression can be the cause of disease processes or can be the result of disease processes.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that chronic, low-grade inflammation may be involved in the pathophysiology of age-related testicular degeneration in stallions.

Declining testicular function in the aging stallion: Management options and future therapies

Declining fertility in association with declining testicular function is commonly seen as stallions age and can be the cause of significant economic losses in the equine breeding industry. This manuscript describes how to clinically recognize the signs of age-related declining testicular function (testicular degeneration) and also provides mare and stallion management strategies for improving reproductive outcomes. Finally, the current understanding of the pathophysiology of the disease is presented, including the results of recent studies that are beginning to uncover the underlying causes for age-related declines in testicular function in stallions. These new findings provide a basis for possible future treatments that could delay the effects of aging on the testis.

Dysregulation of angiogenesis-specific signalling in adult testis results in xenograft degeneration

Ectopic xenografting of testis is a feasible option for preservation of male fertility and angiogenesis plays a pivotal role in xenograft survival and functionality. When compared to immature testis, the adult testis is unable to establish functional xenografts due to potentially lower efficiency to induce angiogenesis. The precise molecular mechanism, however, remains elusive. In the present study, we compared adult and immature testis xenografts for survival, maturation and germ cell differentiation. Further, we evaluated differential expression of angiogenesis signalling-specific proteins in adult and immature testis and their xenografts. Results showed that adult testis xenografts degenerated whereas immature testis xenografts survived and established spermatogenesis with the production of haploid germ cells. Protein expression analysis demonstrated that immature testis xenografts were able to establish angiogenesis either through eNOS activation via VEGF and PI3K/AKT or through EGFR-mediated STAT3 pathway. The role of ERK/MAPK pathway in xenograft angiogenesis was ruled out. The absence or reduced expression of angiogenesis-specific proteins in adult testis and its xenografts possibly resulted in poor angiogenesis and in their subsequent degeneration. This study provides insight into angiogenesis mechanism that can be utilized to augment testis xenografting efficiency.

Xenografting of isolated equine (Equus caballus) testis cells results in de novo morphogenesis of seminiferous tubules but not spermatogenesis

The study of spermatogenesis in the horse is challenging because of the absence of an in vitro system that is capable of reproducing efficient spermatogenesis and because of the difficulties and costs associated with performing well-controlled studies in vivo. In an attempt to develop novel methods for the study of equine spermatogenesis, we tested whether cells from enzymatically digested pre-pubertal equine testicular tissue were capable of de novo tissue formation and spermatogenesis following xenografting under the back skin of immunocompromised mice. Testes were obtained from normal pre-pubertal colts and dissociated into cell suspensions using trypsin/collagenase digestion. Resulting cell pellets, consisting of both somatic and germ cells, were injected into fascial pockets under the back skin of immunocompromised, castrated mice and maintained for between 1 and 14 months. Mice were killed and grafts were recovered and analyzed. As has been reported for testis cell suspensions from pigs, mice, cattle, and sheep, de novo formation of equine testicular tissue was observed, as evidenced by the presence of seminiferous tubules and an interstitial compartment. There was an increased likelihood of de novo testicular formation as grafting period increased. Using indirect immunofluorescence, we confirmed the presence of spermatogonia in de novo formed seminiferous tubules. However, we found no evidence of meiotic or haploid cells. These results indicate that dissociated pre-pubertal equine testis cells are capable of reorganizing into the highly specialized endocrine and spermatogenic compartments of the testis following ectopic xenografting. However, in spite of the presence of spermatogonia within the seminiferous tubules, spermatogenesis does not occur. Although this technique does allow access to the cells within the seminiferous tubule and interstitial compartments of the equine testis prior to reaggregation, the absence of spermatogenesis will limit its use as a method for the study of testicular function in the horse.

Xenografting of testicular tissue pieces: 12 years of an in vivo spermatogenesis system

Spermatogenesis is a dynamic and complex process that involves endocrine and testicular factors. During xenotransplantation of testicular tissue fragments into immunodecifient mice, a functional communication between host brain and donor testis is established. This interaction allows for the progression of spermatogenesis and recovery of fertilisation-competent spermatozoa from a broad range of mammalian species. In the last few years, significant progress has been achieved in testis tissue xenografting that improves our knowledge about the factors determining the success of grafting. The goal of this review is to provide up to date information about the role of factors such as donor age, donor species, testis tissue preservation or type of recipient mouse on the efficiency of this technique. Applications are described and compared with other techniques with similar purposes. Recent work has demonstrated that testicular tissue xenografting is used as a model to study gonadotoxicity of drugs and to obtain sperm from valuable young males.

Clinical review: Present and future prospects of male fertility preservation for children and adolescents

CONTEXT

Rapid progress in fertility preservation strategies has led to the investigation of ways in which fertile gametes could be generated from cryopreserved immature testicular tissue. Childhood cancer patients remain the major group that can benefit from these techniques. Other potential candidates include patients undergoing gonadectomy and patients with Klinefelter's syndrome and cryptorchid testes. This review aims to present an overview of the current state of knowledge in experimental germ cell transplantation, testicular tissue transplantation, and germ cell culture as fertility preservation methods for males.

METHODOLOGY

We included English articles published in PubMed as well as personal files with the focus on studies including human or nonhuman material.

MAIN FINDINGS

Germ cell and testicular tissue transplantation demonstrate clinical options to mature germ cells from immature primate testicular tissue. The most promising approach involves autologous grafting of immature testicular tissue, whereas germ cell maturation in vitro provides the best strategies to overcome problems of cancer contamination in cryopreserved testicular tissue. Three-dimensional and organ culture systems offer the possibility to differentiate immature male germ cells up to the stage of elongated spermatids. Further characterization of early germ cell development in humans is needed to modify these systems for clinical use.

Suppression of spermatogenesis before grafting increases survival and supports resurgence of spermatogenesis in adult mouse testis

OBJECTIVE

To test whether absence of complete spermatogenesis in mature testicular tissue before grafting will increase graft survival.

DESIGN

Prospective experimental study.

SETTING

Laboratory.

ANIMAL(S)

Donor testes were obtained from adult untreated mice, adult mice rendered cryptorchid, and adult mice treated with a GnRH antagonist (acyline).

INTERVENTION(S)

Donor testes were ectopically grafted to nude mice and recovered at three time points.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Most advanced germ cell type and presence of spermatogonia were assessed. Donor testes and grafts were analyzed by histology and by immunocytochemistry for ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase-L1 to mark germ cells.

RESULT(S)

Suppression of spermatogenesis by inducing cryptorchidism or acyline treatment resulted in improved survival of grafted tissue compared with controls and recovery of complete spermatogenesis, whereas control testis grafts mostly degenerated and did not restore complete spermatogenesis.

CONCLUSION(S)

These results indicate that complete spermatogenesis at the time of grafting has a negative effect on graft survival. Grafting of adult testis tissue from donors with suppressed spermatogenesis leads to spermatogenic recovery and may provide a tool to study and preserve fertility and for conservation of genetic resources in individuals that lack complete germ cell differentiation.