A continuous hyperchromicity assay to characterize the kinetics and thermodynamics of DNA lesion recognition and base excision

Forces Driving a Magic Bullet to Its Target: Revisiting the Role of Thermodynamics in Drug Design, Development, and Optimization

Drug discovery strategies have advanced significantly towards prioritizing target selectivity to achieve the longstanding goal of identifying “magic bullets” amongst thousands of chemical molecules screened for therapeutic efficacy. A myriad of emerging and existing health threats, including the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, alarming increase in bacterial resistance, and potentially fatal chronic ailments, such as cancer, cardiovascular disease, and neurodegeneration, have incentivized the discovery of novel therapeutics in treatment regimens. The design, development, and optimization of lead compounds represent an arduous and time-consuming process that necessitates the assessment of specific criteria and metrics derived via multidisciplinary approaches incorporating functional, structural, and energetic properties. The present review focuses on specific methodologies and technologies aimed at advancing drug development with particular emphasis on the role of thermodynamics in elucidating the underlying forces governing ligand–target interaction selectivity and specificity. In the pursuit of novel therapeutics, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) has been utilized extensively over the past two decades to bolster drug discovery efforts, yielding information-rich thermodynamic binding signatures. A wealth of studies recognizes the need for mining thermodynamic databases to critically examine and evaluate prospective drug candidates on the basis of available metrics. The ultimate power and utility of thermodynamics within drug discovery strategies reside in the characterization and comparison of intrinsic binding signatures that facilitate the elucidation of structural–energetic correlations which assist in lead compound identification and optimization to improve overall therapeutic efficacy.

Characterization of Aurintricarboxylic Acid (ATA) Interactions with Plasma Transporter Protein and SARS-CoV-2 Viral Targets: Correlation of Functional Activity and Binding Energetics

In an effort to identify functional-energetic correlations leading to the development of efficient anti-SARS-CoV-2 therapeutic agents, we have designed synthetic analogs of aurintricarboxylic acid (ATA), a heterogeneous polymeric mixture of structurally related linear homologs known to exhibit a host of biological properties, including antiviral activity. These derivatives are evaluated for their ability to interact with a plasma transporter protein (human serum albumin), eukaryotic (yeast) ribosomes, and a SARS-CoV-2 target, the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). The resultant data are critical for characterizing drug distribution, bioavailability, and effective inhibition of host and viral targets. Promising lead compounds are selected on the basis of their binding energetics which have been characterized and correlated with functional activities as assessed by inhibition of RNA replication and protein synthesis. Our results reveal that the activity of heterogeneous ATA is mimicked by linear compounds of defined molecular weight, with a dichlorohexamer salicylic-acid derivative exhibiting the highest potency. These findings are instrumental for optimizing the design of structurally defined ATA analogs that fulfill the requirements of an antiviral drug with respect to bioavailability, homogeneity, and potency, thereby expanding the arsenal of therapeutic regimens that are currently available to address the urgent need for effective SARS-CoV-2 treatment strategies.

Biochemical characterization and mutational studies of the 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase from the hyperthermophilic and radioresistant archaeon Thermococcus gammatolerans

8-oxoguanine (GO) is a major lesion found in DNA that arises from guanine oxidation. The hyperthermophilic and radioresistant euryarchaeon Thermococcus gammatolerans encodes an archaeal GO DNA glycosylase (Tg-AGOG). Here, we characterized biochemically Tg-AGOG and probed its GO removal mechanism by mutational studies. Tg-AGOG can remove GO from DNA at high temperature through a β-elimination reaction. The enzyme displays an optimal temperature, ca.85-95 °C, and an optimal pH, ca.7.0-8.5. In addition, Tg-AGOG activity is independent on a divalent metal ion. However, both Co²⁺ and Cu²⁺ inhibit its activity. The enzyme activity is also inhibited by NaCl. Furthermore, Tg-AGOG specifically cleaves GO-containing dsDNA in the order: GO:C, GO:T, GO:A, and GO:G. Moreover, the temperature dependence of cleavage rates of the enzyme was determined, and from this, the activation energy for GO removal from DNA was first estimated to be 16.9 ± 0.9 kcal/mol. In comparison with the wild-type Tg-AGOG, the R197A mutant has a reduced cleavage activity for GO-containing DNA, whereas both the P193A and F167A mutants exhibit similar cleavage activities for GO-containing DNA. While the mutations of P193 and F167 to Ala lead to increased binding, the mutation of R197 to Ala had no significant effect on binding. These observations suggest that residue R197 is involved in catalysis, and residues P193 and F167 are flexible for conformational change.

Multiple mutations in the aglycone binding pocket to convert the substrate specificity of dalcochinase to linamarase

Dalcochinase from Dalbergia cochinchinensis Pierre and linamarase from Manihot esculenta Crantz are β-glucosidases which share 47% sequence identity, but show distinct substrate specificities in hydrolysis and transglucosylation. Previously, three amino acid residues of dalcochinase, namely I185, N189 and V255, were identified as being important for determining substrate specificity. In this study, kinetic analysis of the ensuing double and triple mutants of dalcochinase showed that only those containing the 185A mutation could appreciably hydrolyze linamarin as well as transfer glucose to 2-methyl-2-propanol. So, the space provided by the I185A mutation appeared to be a prerequisite for accommodation of the aglycone moiety containing three substituents at the carbinol carbon. However, quantitative analysis of the energy parameters revealed mostly antagonistic interactions between these mutations. In addition, the N189F mutant showed a potential for use in enzymatic synthesis of alkyl glucosides via transglucosylation and reverse hydrolysis reactions. Thus, substitution of only 2-3 key residues in the aglycone binding pocket of dalcochinase could convert its specificities to that of linamarase, as well as to be suitable for any chosen hydrolytic or synthetic applications.

Base-Independent DNA Base-Excision Repair of 8-Oxoguanine

Living organisms protect their genome from gene mutation by excising damaged DNA bases. Here, 8-oxoguanine (8OG) is one of the most abundant DNA lesions. In bacteria the base excision is catalyzed by the enzyme formamidopyrimidine-DNA- glycosylase (Fpg), for which two different orientations of 8OG binding into the active site of Fpg have been proposed: syn- and anti-conformation. Here, we present a new ribose-protonated repair mechanism for 8OG that is base-independent and can excise 8OG in both conformations. Using high-level QM/MM calculations with up to 588/573 atoms in the QM sphere, the activation barrier is computed in excellent agreement with the experimentally measured value. Since the excised base itself is not directly involved in the mechanism, this implies that lesion discrimination does not occur within the active site of the enzyme.

Impact of bistrand abasic sites and proximate orientation on DNA global structure and duplex energetics

Bistrand lesions embedded within a single helical turn of tridecameric deoxyoligonucleotide duplexes represent a model system for exploring the impact of clustered lesions that occur in vivo and pose a significant challenge to cellular repair machineries. Such investigations are essential for understanding the forces that dictate lesion‐induced mutagenesis, carcinogenesis, and cytotoxicity within a context that mimics local helical perturbations caused by an ionizing radiation event. This study characterizes the structural and energy profiles of DNA duplexes harboring synthetic abasic sites (tetrahydrofuran, F) as models of clustered bistrand abasic (AP) lesions. The standard tridecameric dGCGTACCCATGCG·dCGCATGGGTACGC duplex is employed to investigate the energetic impact of single and bistrand AP sites by strategically replacing one or two bases within the central CCC/GGG triplet. Our combined analysis of temperature‐dependent UV and circular dichroism (CD) profiles reveals that the proximity and relative orientation of AP sites within bistrand‐damaged duplexes imparts a significant thermodynamic impact. Specifically, 3′‐staggered lesions (CCF/GFG) exert a greater destabilizing effect when compared with their 5′‐counterpart (FCC/GFG). Moreover, a duplex harboring the central bistrand AP lesion (CFC/GFG) is moderately destabilized yet exhibits distinct properties relative to both the 3′ and 5′‐orientations. Collectively, our energetic data are consistent with structural studies on bistrand AP‐duplexes of similar sequence in which a 3′‐staggered lesion exerts the greatest perturbation, a finding that provides significant insight regarding the impact of orientation on lesion repair processing efficiency.

Pressure and Temperature Effects on the Activity and Structure of the Catalytic Domain of Human MT1-MMP

Membrane type 1-matrix metalloproteinase (MT1-MMP or MMP-14) is a zinc-transmembrane metalloprotease involved in the degradation of extracellular matrix and tumor invasion. While changes in solvation of MT1-MMP have been recently studied, little is known about the structural and energetic changes associated with MT1-MMP while interacting with substrates. Steady-state kinetic and thermodynamic data (including activation energies and activation volumes) were measured over a wide range of temperatures and pressures by means of a stopped-flow fluorescence technique. Complementary temperature- and pressure-dependent Fourier-transform infrared measurements provided corresponding structural information of the protein. MT1-MMP is stable and active over a wide range of temperatures (10-55 °C). A small conformational change was detected at 37 °C, which is responsible for the change in activity observed at the same temperature. Pressure decreases the enzymatic activity until complete inactivation occurs at 2 kbar. The inactivation is associated with changes in the rate-limiting step of the reaction caused by additional hydration of the active site upon compression and/or minor conformational changes in the active site region. Based on these data, an energy and volume diagram could be established for the various steps of the enzymatic reaction.

Impact of thymine glycol damage on DNA duplex energetics: Correlations with lesion-induced biochemical and structural consequences

The magnitude and nature of lesion-induced energetic perturbations empirically correlate with mutagenicity/cytotoxicity profiles and can be predictive of lesion outcomes during polymerase-mediated replication in vitro. In this study, we assess the sequence and counterbase-dependent energetic impact of the Thymine glycol (Tg) lesion on a family of deoxyoligonucleotide duplexes. Tg damage arises from thymine and methyl-cytosine exposure to oxidizing agents or radiation-generated free-radicals. The Tg lesion blocks polymerase-mediated DNA replication in vitro and the unrepaired site elicits cytotoxic lethal consequences in vivo. Our combined calorimetric and spectroscopic characterization correlates Tg -induced energetic perturbations with biological and structural properties. Specifically, we incorporate a 5R-Tg isomer centered within the tridecanucleotide sequence 5'-GCGTACXCATGCG-3' (X = Tg or T) which is hybridized with the corresponding complementary sequence 5'-CGCATGNGTACGC-3' (N = A, G, T, C) to generate families of Tg -damaged (Tg ·N) and lesion-free (T·N) duplexes. We demonstrate that the magnitude and nature of the Tg destabilizing impact is dependent on counterbase identity (i.e., A ∼ G < T < C). The observation that a Tg lesion is less destabilizing when positioned opposite purines suggests that favorable counterbase stacking interactions may partially compensate lesion-induced perturbations. Moreover, the destabilizing energies of Tg ·N duplexes parallel their respective lesion-free T·N mismatch counterparts (i.e., G < T < C). Elucidation of Tg-induced destabilization relative to the corresponding undamaged mismatch energetics allows resolution of lesion-specific and sequence-dependent impacts. The Tg-induced energetic perturbations are consistent with its replication blocking properties and may serve as differential recognition elements for discrimination by the cellular repair machinery.

Biofunctionalized nanoparticles with pH-responsive and cell penetrating blocks for gene delivery

Bridging the gap between nanoparticulate delivery systems and translational gene therapy is a long sought after requirement in nanomedicine-based applications. However, recent developments regarding nanoparticle functionalization have brought forward the ability to synthesize materials with biofunctional moieties that mimic the evolved features of viral particles. Herein we report the versatile conjugation of both cell penetrating arginine and pH-responsive histidine moieties into the chitosan polymeric backbone, to improve the physicochemical characteristics of the native material. Amino acid coupling was confirmed by 2D TOCSY NMR and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The synthesized chitosan-histidine-arginine (CH-H-R) polymer complexed plasmid DNA biopharmaceuticals, and spontaneously assembled into stable 105 nm nanoparticles with spherical morphology and positive surface charge. The functionalized delivery systems were efficiently internalized into the intracellular compartment, and exhibited remarkably higher transfection efficiency than unmodified chitosan without causing any cytotoxic effect. Additional findings regarding intracellular trafficking events reveal their preferential escape from degradative lysosomal pathways and nuclear localization. Overall, this assembly of nanocarriers with bioinspired moieties provides the foundations for the design of efficient and customizable materials for cancer gene therapy.

Cooperative self-assembly of a macrocyclic Schiff base complex

A metal template approach affords in high yield a tetra-Zn(salphen) macrocycle (3) which shows strong and cooperative self-assembly mediated by the formation of Zn(salphen) dimer units held together via μ(2)-phenoxo interactions. A cooperative binding mode for the tetranuclear Zn(4) macrocycle 3 is supported by comparison of UV-vis and fluorescence titration data recorded for 3 when compared with respective mononuclear and dinuclear Zn(salphen) model compounds. UV-vis dilution experiments carried out for Zn(4) macrocycle 3 and its Pd(4) analogue 4, as well as comparative TEM studies involving the same tetranuclear macrocycles further support the strong assembly behavior of 3. This self-assembly seems to be primarily dictated by its ability to form multiple, self-assembled dimeric [Zn(salphen)](2) units.

Novel post-synthetic generation, isomeric resolution, and characterization of Fapy-dG within oligodeoxynucleotides: differential anomeric impacts on DNA duplex properties

Accumulation of damaged guanine nucleobases within genomic DNA, including the imidazole ring opened N⁶-(2-Deoxy-α,β-D-erythro-pentafuranosyl)-2,6-diamino-4-hydroxy-5-formylamidopyrimidine (Fapy-dG), is associated with progression of age-related diseases and cancer. To evaluate the impact of this mutagenic lesion on DNA structure and energetics, we have developed a novel synthetic strategy to incorporate cognate Fapy-dG site-specifically within any oligodeoxynucleotide sequence. The scheme involves the synthesis of an oligonucleotide precursor containing a 5-nitropyrimidine moiety at the desired lesion site via standard solid-phase procedures. Following deprotection and isolation, the Fapy-dG lesion is generated by catalytic hydrogenation and subsequent formylation. NMR assignment of the Fapy-dG lesion (X) embedded within a TXT trimer reveals the presence of rotameric and anomeric species. The latter have been characterized by synthesizing the tridecamer oligodeoxynucleotide d(GCGTACXCATGCG) harboring Fapy-dG as the central residue and developing a protocol to resolve the isomeric components. Hybridization of the chromatographically isolated fractions with their complementary d(CGCATGCGTACGC) counterpart yields two Fapy-dG·C duplexes that are differentially destabilized relative to the canonical G·C parent. The resultant duplexes exhibit distinct thermal and thermodynamic profiles that are characteristic of α- and β-anomers, the former more destabilizing than the latter. These anomer-specific impacts are discussed in terms of differential repair enzyme recognition, processing and translesion synthesis.

Interference with spectrophotometric analysis of nucleic acids and proteins by leaching of chemicals from plastic tubes

Absorbance spectroscopy is routinely used to monitor the concentrations of nucleic acids and proteins within solutions and to assess changes in their structure caused by interaction with chemicals or other biomolecules. Biological samples used for such analyses are manipulated and stored in small microcentrifuge tubes (microtubes) composed of polypropylene plus several plastic additives. Here we demonstrate that normal handling of laboratory microtubes causes leaching of light-absorbing chemicals into biological samples that interfere with spectrophotometric measurements. The leached chromophores absorbed UV light strongly at 220 and 260 nm, which are the wavelengths normally used to detect and quantitate proteins and DNA. Some common laboratory techniques, including sonication and PCR, were particularly effective inducers of leaching. The magnitude of the increase in absorbance was dependent upon both exposure time and heat history, with greatest induction after tubes were warmed to temperatures at or above 37 degrees C. Mass spectrometry revealed that aqueous solutions stored in plastic microtubes accumulate a complex mixture of leached chemicals with molecular masses of 200-1400 Da. Leaching was ubiquitous among commercially available brands of microtubes, indicating a persistent source of error in biomolecule detection and concentration measurements.

Fluorescent probes for the analysis of DNA strand scission in base excision repair

We have developed fluorescent probes for the detection of strand scission in the excision repair of oxidatively damaged bases. They were hairpin-shaped oligonucleotides, each containing an isomer of thymine glycol or 5,6-dihydrothymine as a damaged base in the center, with a fluorophore and a quencher at the 5'- and 3'-ends, respectively. Fluorescence was detected when the phosphodiester linkage at the damage site was cleaved by the enzyme, because the short fragment bearing the fluorophore could not remain in a duplex form hybridized to the rest of the molecule at the incubation temperature. The substrate specificities of Escherichia coli endonuclease III and its human homolog, NTH1, determined by using these probes agreed with those determined previously by gel electrophoresis using (32)P-labeled substrates. Kinetic parameters have also been determined by this method. Since different fluorophores were attached to the oligonucleotides containing each lesion, reactions with two types of substrates were analyzed separately in a single tube, by changing the excitation and detection wavelengths. These probes were degraded during an incubation with a cell extract. Therefore, phosphorothioate linkages were incorporated to protect the probes from nonspecific nucleases, and the base excision repair activity was successfully detected in HeLa cells.

Energetic signatures of single base bulges: thermodynamic consequences and biological implications

DNA bulges are biologically consequential defects that can arise from template-primer misalignments during replication and pose challenges to the cellular DNA repair machinery. Calorimetric and spectroscopic characterizations of defect-containing duplexes reveal systematic patterns of sequence-context dependent bulge-induced destabilizations. These distinguishing energetic signatures are manifest in three coupled characteristics, namely: the magnitude of the bulge-induced duplex destabilization (DeltaDeltaG(Bulge)); the thermodynamic origins of DeltaDeltaG(Bulge) (i.e. enthalpic versus entropic); and, the cooperativity of the duplex melting transition (i.e. two-state versus non-two state). We find moderately destabilized duplexes undergo two-state dissociation and exhibit DeltaDeltaG(Bulge) values consistent with localized, nearest neighbor perturbations arising from unfavorable entropic contributions. Conversely, strongly destabilized duplexes melt in a non-two-state manner and exhibit DeltaDeltaG(Bulge) values consistent with perturbations exceeding nearest-neighbor expectations that are enthalpic in origin. Significantly, our data reveal an intriguing correlation in which the energetic impact of a single bulge base centered in one strand portends the impact of the corresponding complementary bulge base embedded in the opposite strand. We discuss potential correlations between these bulge-specific differential energetic profiles and their overall biological implications in terms of DNA recognition, repair and replication.

Analysis of an anomalous mutant of MutM DNA glycosylase leads to new insights into the catalytic mechanism

To determine the factors involved in the specific recognition function of a bacterial 8-oxoguanine (oxoG) DNA glycosylase MutM, a series of potentials of mean force and thermodynamic integration simulations were performed with the wild type and a single-point E3Q mutant of MutM bound to oxoG and G-containing DNA, respectively. Interestingly, the mutation of the catalytically important Glu3 (E3) residue to Gln (Q) significantly changes the free-energy surface so that oxoG can bind stably in the active site of the enzyme. Free-energy simulations with the protonated and deprotonated E3 residue further showed that the protonation of the catalytically important E3 residue plays a key role in distinguishing oxoG versus G in the active site by lowering the free energy of oxoG preferentially in the active site. The results suggest that MutM utilizes the thermodynamic recognition mechanism for stable binding of the lesion base in the active site of the enzyme in addition to kinetic discrimination at the early stage of the base extrusion for facilitated extrusion of oxoG.

DNA repair and DNA triplet repeat expansion: the impact of abasic lesions on triplet repeat DNA energetics

Enhanced levels of DNA triplet expansion are observed when base excision repair (BER) of oxidative DNA base damage (e.g., 8-oxo-dG) occurs at or near CAG repeat sequences. This observation suggests an interplay between processing mechanisms required for DNA repair and expansion pathways that yield genotypes associated with many neurological/developmental disorders. It has been proposed that DNA expansion involves the transient formation within the triplet repeat domains of non-native slipped DNA structures that are incorrectly processed by the BER machinery of repair during DNA synthesis. We show here that replacement within a triplet repeat bulge loop domain of a guanosine residue by an abasic site, the universal BER intermediate, increases the population of slipped/looped DNA structures relative to the corresponding lesion-free construct. Such abasic lesion-induced energetic enhancement of slipped/looped structures provides a linkage between BER and DNA expansion. We discuss how the BER machinery of repair may be influenced by abasic-induced energetic alterations in the properties of regions proximal to and/or within triplet repeat domains, thereby potentially modulating levels of DNA expansion.