Limb girdle muscular disease caused by HMGCR mutation and statin myopathy treatable with mevalonolactone

Absence of Pathogenic Mutations and Strong Association With HLA-DRB1*11:01 in Statin-Naïve Early-Onset Anti-HMGCR Necrotizing Myopathy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Immune-mediated necrotizing myopathy (IMNM) caused by antibodies against 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A reductase (HMGCR) is an inflammatory myopathy that has been epidemiologically correlated with previous statin exposure. We characterized in detail a series of 11 young statin-naïve patients experiencing a chronic disease course mimicking a limb-girdle muscular dystrophy. With the hypothesis that HMGCR upregulation may increase immunogenicity and trigger the production of autoantibodies, our aim was to expand pathophysiologic knowledge of this distinct phenotype.

METHODS

Clinical and epidemiologic data, autoantibody titers, creatine kinase (CK) levels, response to treatment, muscle imaging, and muscle biopsies were assessed. HMGCR expression in patients' muscle was assessed by incubating sections of affected patients with purified anti-HMGCR+ serum. Whole-exome sequencing (WES) with a special focus on cholesterol biosynthesis-related genes and high-resolution human leukocyte antigen (HLA) typing were performed.

RESULTS

Patients, aged 3-25 years and mostly female (90.9%), presented with subacute proximal weakness progressing over many years and high CK levels (>1,000 U/L). Diagnostic delay ranged from 3 to 27 years. WES did not reveal any pathogenic variants. HLA-DRB1*11:01 carrier frequency was 60%, a significantly higher proportion than in the control population. No upregulation or mislocalization of the enzyme in statin-exposed or statin-naïve anti-HMGCR+ patients was observed, compared with controls.

DISCUSSION

WES of a cohort of patients with dystrophy-like anti-HMGCR IMNM did not reveal any common rare variants of any gene, including cholesterol biosynthesis-related genes. HLA analysis showed a strong association with HLA-DRB1*11:01, previously mostly described in statin-exposed adult patients; consequently, a common immunogenic predisposition should be suspected, irrespective of statin exposure. Moreover, we were unable to conclusively demonstrate muscle upregulation/mislocalization of HMGCR in IMNM, whether or not driven by statins.

Statins in hereditary myopathies: to give or not to give

Hyperlipidemia is not uncommon in patients with hereditary myopathies who get older and also in several conditions in which it is frequently observed. Thus, using the common cholesterol reducing medications of the stains group could be considered. However, the side effects of these drugs include myalgia, myopathy and rhabdomyolysis typically associated with high serum creatine kinase (CK). Because high CK levels are very frequently found in hereditary myopathies, physicians are reluctant to use statins in such patients. Reviewing the literature about statin side effects in hereditary myopathies does not provide a clear evidence about the true risk of these drugs. This review critically describes the reported cases of statin side effects in several genetic myopathies and suggests some guidelines for conditions that are contra indicated for statin usage (particularly in mitochondrial disorders, metabolic myopathies, myotonic dystrophy type 2). Possible solutions to the dilemma of whether to use statins in hereditary myopathies are discussed (prescribing other cholesterol lowering agents and a carefully monitored treatment initiation of statins).

Decoding the Intricacies of Statin-Associated Muscle Symptoms

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Hyperlipidemia is the major cardiovascular morbidity and mortality risk factor. Statins are the first-line treatment for hyperlipidemia. Statin-associated muscle symptoms (SAMS) are the main reason for the discontinuation of statins among patients. The purpose of this review is to guide clinicians to recognize the difference between self-limited and autoimmune statin myopathy in addition to the factors that potentiate them. Finally, treatment strategies will be discussed. This review mostly focuses on new data in the past 3 years.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent findings suggest that SAMS is a complex and multifactorial condition that involves mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress, and immune-mediated mechanisms. Effective management of SAMS requires a thorough evaluation of the patient's symptoms, risk factors, and medication history, as well as consideration of alternative treatment options. While statins are effective in reducing the risk of cardiovascular events, their use is associated with a range of adverse effects, including SAMS.

Pathological autoantibody internalisation in myositis

OBJECTIVES

Autoantibodies targeting intracellular proteins are common in various autoimmune diseases. In the context of myositis, the pathologic significance of these autoantibodies has been questioned due to the assumption that autoantibodies cannot enter living muscle cells. This study aims to investigate the validity of this assumption.

METHODS

Confocal immunofluorescence microscopy was employed to localise antibodies and other proteins of interest in myositis muscle biopsies. Bulk RNA sequencing was used to examine the transcriptomic profiles of 669 samples, including those from patients with myositis, disease controls and healthy controls. Additionally, antibodies from myositis patients were introduced into cultured myoblasts through electroporation, and their transcriptomic profiles were analysed using RNA sequencing.

RESULTS

In patients with myositis autoantibodies, antibodies accumulated inside myofibres in the same subcellular compartment as the autoantigen. Bulk RNA sequencing revealed that muscle biopsies from patients with autoantibodies targeting transcriptional regulators exhibited transcriptomic patterns consistent with dysfunction of the autoantigen. For instance, in muscle biopsies from patients with anti-PM/Scl autoantibodies recognising components of the nuclear RNA exosome complex, an accumulation of divergent transcripts and long non-coding RNAs was observed; these RNA forms are typically degraded by the nuclear RNA exosome complex. Introducing patient antibodies into cultured muscle cells recapitulated the transcriptomic effects observed in human disease. Further supporting evidence suggested that myositis autoantibodies recognising other autoantigens may also disrupt the function of their targets.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that, in myositis, autoantibodies are internalised into living cells, causing biological effects consistent with the disrupted function of their autoantigen.

Effects of HMGCR deficiency on skeletal muscle development

Pathogenic variants in HMGCR were recently linked to a limb-girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) phenotype. The protein product HMG CoA reductase (HMGCR) catalyzes a key component of the cholesterol synthesis pathway. The two other muscle diseases associated with HMGCR, statin-associated myopathy (SAM) and autoimmune anti-HMGCR myopathy, are not inherited in a Mendelian pattern. The mechanism linking pathogenic variants in HMGCR with skeletal muscle dysfunction is unclear. We knocked down Hmgcr in mouse skeletal myoblasts, knocked down hmgcr in Drosophila, and expressed three pathogenic HMGCR variants (c.1327C>T, p.Arg443Trp; c.1522_1524delTCT, p.Ser508del; and c.1621G>A, p.Ala541Thr) in Hmgcr knockdown mouse myoblasts. Hmgcr deficiency was associated with decreased proliferation, increased apoptosis, and impaired myotube fusion. Transcriptome sequencing of Hmgcr knockdown versus control myoblasts revealed differential expression involving mitochondrial function, with corresponding differences in cellular oxygen consumption rates. Both ubiquitous and muscle-specific knockdown of hmgcr in Drosophila led to lethality. Overexpression of reference HMGCR cDNA rescued myotube fusion in knockdown cells, whereas overexpression of the pathogenic variants of HMGCR cDNA did not. These results suggest that the three HMGCR-related muscle diseases share disease mechanisms related to skeletal muscle development.

Differential effects of OATP2B1 on statin accumulation and toxicity in a beta cell model

An increased risk of new-onset diabetes mellitus has been recently reported for statin therapy, and experimental studies have shown reduced glucose-stimulated insulin secretion (GSIS) and mitochondrial dysfunction in beta cells with effects differing among agents. Organic anion transporting polypeptide (OATP) 2B1 contributes to hepatic uptake of rosuvastatin, atorvastatin and pravastatin, three known substrates. Since OATP2B1 is present in beta cells of the human pancreas, we investigated if OATP2B1 facilitates the local accumulation of statins in a rat beta cell model INS-1 832/13 (INS-1) thereby amplifying statin-induced toxicity. OATP2B1 overexpression in INS-1 cells via adenoviral transduction showed 2.5-, 1.8- and 1.4-fold higher cellular retention of rosuvastatin, atorvastatin and pravastatin, respectively, relative to LacZ control, while absolute intracellular concentration was about twice as high for the lipophilic atorvastatin compared to the more hydrophilic rosuvastatin and pravastatin. After 24 h statin treatment at high concentrations, OATP2B1 enhanced statin toxicity involving activation of intrinsic apoptosis (caspase 3/7 activation) and mitochondrial dysfunction (NADH dehydrogenase activity) following rosuvastatin and atorvastatin, which was partly reversed by isoprenoids. OATP2B1 had no effect on statin-induced reduction in GSIS, mitochondrial electron transport chain complex expression or caspase 9 activation. We confirmed a dose-dependent reduction in insulin secretion by rosuvastatin and atorvastatin in native INS-1 with a modest change in cellular ATP. Collectively, our results indicate a role of OATP2B1, which is abundant in human beta cells, in statin accumulation and statin-induced toxicity but not insulin secretion of rosuvastatin and atorvastatin in INS-1 cells.

Pathogenic autoantibody internalization in myositis

Objectives

Myositis is a heterogeneous family of autoimmune muscle diseases. As myositis autoantibodies recognize intracellular proteins, their role in disease pathogenesis has been unclear. This study aimed to determine whether myositis autoantibodies reach their autoantigen targets within muscle cells and disrupt the normal function of these proteins.

Methods

Confocal immunofluorescence microscopy was used to localize antibodies and other proteins of interest in myositis muscle biopsies. Bulk RNA sequencing was used to study the transcriptomic profiles of 668 samples from patients with myositis, disease controls, and healthy controls. Antibodies from myositis patients were introduced into cultured myoblasts by electroporation and the transcriptomic profiles of the treated myoblasts were studied by bulk RNA sequencing.

Results

In patients with myositis autoantibodies, antibodies accumulated inside myofibers in the same subcellular compartment as the autoantigen. Each autoantibody was associated with effects consistent with dysfunction of its autoantigen, such as the derepression of genes normally repressed by Mi2/NuRD in patients with anti-Mi2 autoantibodies, the accumulation of RNAs degraded by the nuclear RNA exosome complex in patients with anti-PM/Scl autoantibodies targeting this complex, and the accumulation of lipids within myofibers of anti-HMGCR-positive patients. Internalization of patient immunoglobulin into cultured myoblasts recapitulated the transcriptomic phenotypes observed in human disease, including the derepression of Mi2/NuRD-regulated genes in anti-Mi2-positive dermatomyositis and the increased expression of genes normally degraded by the nuclear RNA exosome complex in anti-PM/Scl-positive myositis.

Conclusions

In myositis, autoantibodies are internalized into muscle fibers, disrupt the biological function of their autoantigen, and mediate the pathophysiology of the disease.

Anti-HMGCR immune-mediated necrotising myopathy: Addressing the remaining issues

The discovery of autoantibodies directed against the 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-CoA reductase (HMGCR) enzyme has defined a sub-set of immune-mediated necrotising myopathy (IMNM) which is strongly associated with exposure to statin medications. Although understanding of anti-HMGCR IMNM has grown considerably with the reporting of multiple cohorts in North America, Europe, Asia and Oceania, there remain many unanswered questions. The true incidence of anti-HMGCR IMNM is not known and heterogeneity of phenotype and treatment response within this autoantibody sub-group is being increasingly recognised. Statin-naïve adults and juvenile patients with anti-HMGCR potentially share characteristics distinct from statin-exposed patients, alluding to unique pathogenesis. Conflicting data exists on whether malignancies are associated with anti-HMGCR and further clarification is required to determine the degree of cancer screening required. Treatment approaches to anti-HMGCR IMNM are heterogeneous but generally highlight the efficacy of intravenous immunoglobulin. Even with multimodal immunosuppression, patients with anti-HMGCR remain prone to relapse, with younger patients generally manifesting more refractory disease. In this Review, we aim to summarise the current literature on anti-HMGCR and discuss the remaining issues.

Bi-allelic variants in HMGCR cause an autosomal-recessive progressive limb-girdle muscular dystrophy

Statins are a mainstay intervention for cardiovascular disease prevention, yet their use can cause rare severe myopathy. HMG-CoA reductase, an essential enzyme in the mevalonate pathway, is the target of statins. We identified nine individuals from five unrelated families with unexplained limb-girdle like muscular dystrophy and bi-allelic variants in HMGCR via clinical and research exome sequencing. The clinical features resembled other genetic causes of muscular dystrophy with incidental high CPK levels (>1,000 U/L), proximal muscle weakness, variable age of onset, and progression leading to impaired ambulation. Muscle biopsies in most affected individuals showed non-specific dystrophic changes with non-diagnostic immunohistochemistry. Molecular modeling analyses revealed variants to be destabilizing and affecting protein oligomerization. Protein activity studies using three variants (p.Asp623Asn, p.Tyr792Cys, and p.Arg443Gln) identified in affected individuals confirmed decreased enzymatic activity and reduced protein stability. In summary, we showed that individuals with bi-allelic amorphic (i.e., null and/or hypomorphic) variants in HMGCR display phenotypes that resemble non-genetic causes of myopathy involving this reductase. This study expands our knowledge regarding the mechanisms leading to muscular dystrophy through dysregulation of the mevalonate pathway, autoimmune myopathy, and statin-induced myopathy.