Can the Ca2+ hypothesis and the Ca2+-voltage hypothesis for neurotransmitter release be reconciled?

Effects of glial release and somatic receptors on bursting in synchronized neuronal networks

A model is constructed to study the phenomenon of bursting in cultured neuronal networks by considering the effects of glial release and the extrasynaptic receptors on neurons. In the frequently observed situations of synchronized bursting, the whole neuronal network can be described by a mean-field model. In this model, the dynamics of the synchronized network in the presence of glia is represented by an effective two-compartment neuron with stimulations on both the dendrite and soma. Numerical simulations of this model show that most of the experimental observations in bursting, in particular the high plateau and the slow repolarization, can be reproduced. Our findings suggest that the effects of glia release and extrasynaptic receptors, which are usually neglected in neuronal models, can become important in intense network activities. Furthermore, simulations of the model are also performed for the case of glia-suppressed cultures to compare with recent experimental results.

A novel fast mechanism for GPCR-mediated signal transduction--control of neurotransmitter release

In addition to calcium influx, charge movement in the G protein–coupled M₂-muscarinic receptor is required for the control of acetylcholine release.

Reliable neuronal communication depends on accurate temporal correlation between the action potential and neurotransmitter release. Although a requirement for Ca²⁺ in neurotransmitter release is amply documented, recent studies have shown that voltage-sensitive G protein–coupled receptors (GPCRs) are also involved in this process. However, how slow-acting GPCRs control fast neurotransmitter release is an unsolved question. Here we examine whether the recently discovered fast depolarization-induced charge movement in the M₂-muscarinic receptor (M₂R) is responsible for M₂R-mediated control of acetylcholine release. We show that inhibition of the M₂R charge movement in Xenopus oocytes correlated well with inhibition of acetylcholine release at the mouse neuromuscular junction. Our results suggest that, in addition to Ca²⁺ influx, charge movement in GPCRs is also necessary for release control.

Control of neurotransmitter release: From Ca2+ to voltage dependent G-protein coupled receptors

This review discusses two theories that try to explain mechanisms of control of neurotransmitter release in fast synapses: the Ca(2+) hypothesis and the Ca(2+) voltage hypothesis. The review summarizes experimental results that are incompatible with predictions from the Ca(2+) hypothesis and concludes that Ca(2+) is involved in the control of the amount of release but not in the control of the time course of evoked release, i.e., initiation and termination of evoked release. Results summarizing direct effects of changes in membrane potential on the release machinery are then presented. These changes in membrane potential affect the affinity (for the transmitter) of presynaptic autoinhibitory G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs). The voltage dependence of these GPCRs and their pivotal role in determining the time course of evoked release is discussed.

Depolarization amplitude and Ca2+ -inflow control the time course of quantal releases at murine motor nerve terminals

In order to test whether the time courses of quantal releases after a depolarization pulse are affected by the depolarization amplitude, time courses were measured for small depolarization pulses that elicited close to threshold releases and for large depolarizations that elicited releases approaching saturation level. Diaphragms of young mice were excised and superfused with Bretag's solution at 18 degrees C. Synaptic currents were elicited and recorded through a perfused macropatch pipette. Releases elicited by threshold depolarizations rose earlier than releases elicited by saturation depolarizations. The short delays in the rising phases of release after large depolarizations may be due to the shift of Ca(2+) currents flowing during the pulse to tail currents. After its peak, release decayed with a time constant tau. For saturation depolarizations tau was about 0.3 ms, and for threshold depolarizations tau increased up to 0.8 ms. In order to differentiate between the effects of variations in Ca(2+) inflow and in depolarization, the amplitudes of large depolarization pulses were held constant while the amount of release was depressed by halving the Ca(2+) concentration at the terminal. The time course of the lowered releases was slightly delayed while tau remained at 0.3 ms as typical for saturation depolarizations. Double pulse facilitation unexpectedly revealed a short phase of depression of release after the pulse. This depression may contribute to the rapid decay (tau) of release after large depolarizations. The dependence of tau on depolarization amplitude indicates that the final phase of the time course of release is largely controlled by the amplitude of the preceding depolarization.

Action potential modulates Ca2+-dependent and Ca2+-independent secretion in a sensory neuron

Neurotransmitter release normally requires calcium triggering. However, the somata of dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons possess a calcium-independent but voltage-dependent secretion (CIVDS) in addition to the classic calcium-dependent secretion (CDS). Here, we investigated the physiological role of CIVDS and the contributions of CIVDS and CDS induced by action potentials (APs) in DRG soma. Using membrane capacitance measurements, caged calcium photolysis, and membrane capacitance kinetics analysis, we demonstrated that AP-induced secretion had both CIVDS and CDS components. Following physiological stimuli, the dominant component of AP-induced secretion was either CIVDS for spontaneous firing or CDS for high-intensity stimuli. AP frequency modulates CDS-coupled exocytosis and CIVDS-coupled endocytosis but not CIVDS-coupled exocytosis and CDS-coupled endocytosis. Finally, CIVDS did not contribute to excitatory postsynaptic currents induced by APs in DRG presynaptic terminals in the spinal cord. Thus, CIVDS is probably an essential physiological component of AP-induced secretion in the soma. These findings bring novel insights into primary sensory processes in DRG neurons.

Astrocytes optimize the synaptic transmission of information

Chemical synapses transmit information via the release of neurotransmitter-filled vesicles from the presynaptic terminal. Using computational modeling, we predict that the limited availability of neurotransmitter resources in combination with the spontaneous release of vesicles limits the maximum degree of enhancement of synaptic transmission. This gives rise to an optimal tuning that depends on the number of active zones. There is strong experimental evidence that astrocytes that enwrap synapses can modulate the probabilities of vesicle release through bidirectional signaling and hence regulate synaptic transmission. For low-fidelity hippocampal synapses, which typically have only one or two active zones, the predicted optimal values lie close to those determined by experimentally measured astrocytic feedback, suggesting that astrocytes optimize synaptic transmission of information.

Release of chemical (neurotransmitter)-filled vesicles at neuronal junctions called synapses leads to transmission of information between neurons. In a successful synaptic transmission, a voltage spike (action potential) generated by a presynaptic neuron initiates neurotransmitter vesicle release and leads to a small current in the postsynaptic neuron. For many synapses in the central nervous system, the probability that a neurotransmitter vesicle is released in response to an action potential is conspicuously small, raising the question whether transmission failures can in any way prove advantageous. Apart from “induced vesicle release” (in response to an action potential), vesicles are also released asynchronously (in absence of an action potential). An induced release probability that is too small samples the information poorly, as many of the incoming action potentials do not result in a postsynaptic current response. Maximizing induced release in order to maximize information transmission at a synapse is accompanied by the exceptionable outcome of increased asynchronous release; in addition, both these releases draw from the same neurotransmitter resource pool. A large release rate thus comprising both induced as well as asynchronous release of vesicles can suppress synaptic transmission via either depletion of neurotransmitter resources or desensitization of postsynaptic receptors. In this paper, we propose that the competing dynamics of induced and asynchronous vesicle release gives rise to an optimal release probability. Further, by comparing experimental data of astrocyte-enhanced synaptic transmission with simulations, we argue that synapses enwrapped by astrocytes operate close to our predicted optimum. This optimality is achieved through a closed-loop control circuitry that involves the presynaptic neuron and the synaptic astrocyte.

On the Feedback Between Theory and Experiment in Elucidating the Molecular Mechanisms Underlying Neurotransmitter Release

This review describes the development of the molecular level Ca(2+)-voltage hypothesis. Theoretical considerations and feedback between theory and experiments played a key role in its development. The theory, backed by experiments, states that at fast synapses, membrane potential by means of presynaptic inhibitory autoreceptors controls initiation and termination of neurotransmitter release. A molecular kinetic scheme which depicts initiation and termination of evoked release is discussed. This scheme is able to account for both spontaneous release and evoked release. The physiological implications of this scheme are enumerated.

Presynaptic calcium and control of vesicle fusion

Vesicle fusion and transmitter release at synapses is driven by a highly localized Ca2+ signal that rapidly builds up around open Ca2+-channels at and near presynaptic active zones. It has been difficult to estimate the amplitude and the kinetics of this 'microdomain' signal by direct Ca2+-imaging approaches. Recently, Ca2+ uncaging at large CNS synapses, among them the calyx of Held, has shown that the intrinsic cooperativity of Ca2+ in inducing vesicle fusion is high, with 4-5 Ca2+ ions needed to trigger vesicle fusion. Given the Ca2+-sensitivity of vesicle fusion as determined by Ca2+-uncaging, it was found that a surprisingly small (10-25 microM) and brief (<1 ms) local Ca2+ signal is sufficient to achieve the amount, and the kinetics of the physiological transmitter release. The high cooperativity of Ca2+ in inducing vesicle fusion and the non-saturation of the Ca2+-sensor for vesicle fusion renders small changes of the local Ca2+-signal highly effective in changing the release probability; an insight that is important for our understanding of short-term modulation of synaptic strength.

Release of Neurotransmitter Induced by Ca2+-Uncaging: Reexamination of the Ca-Voltage Hypothesis for Release

The primacy of Ca2+ in controlling the amount of released neurotransmitter is well established. However, it is not yet clear what controls the time-course (initiation and termination) of release. Various experiments indicated that the time-course is controlled by membrane potential per se. Consequently the phenomenological Ca-Voltage-Hypothesis (CVH) was formulated. The CVH was later embodied in a molecular level mathematical model, whose key predictions were affirmed experimentally. Nonetheless, the single most important basis for the CVH, namely that depolarization per se is needed to induce physiological phasic release, was challenged by two major experimental findings. (i) Release was induced by Ca2+ alone by means of Ca2+-uncaging. (ii) There was at most a small additional effect when depolarization was applied after release was induced by Ca2+-uncaging. Point (i) was dealt with previously, but additional conclusions are drawn here. Here we concentrate on (ii) and show that the experimental results can be fully accounted for by the molecular level CVH model, with essentially the same parameters.

A simulation study on the Ca2+-independent but voltage-dependent exocytosis and endocytosis in dorsal root ganglion neurons

In patch-clamped somata of dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons, two types of secretion have been proposed: Ca(2+)-dependent secretion and Ca(2+)-independent but voltage-dependent secretion (CIVDS). The Ca(2+)-induced and the depolarization-induced membrane capacitance (C(m)) increases contribute 80 and 20% to the total C(m) increase, respectively (Zhang and Zhou in Nat Neurosci 5:425, 2002). In order to explore the mechanism of the voltage-dependent C(m) change (DeltaC(m)), we constructed a model with sequential states. The simulation with this model closely approximates all the experimental data. The model predicts that the majority of fusion events (approximately 80%) are so-called "kiss-and-run" events, which account for the fast recovery or the rapid retrieval feature of the signals. The remaining 20% are attributed to full fusion events, which account for a slow retrieval feature. On the basis of the model, one mechanism of the activity-dependent endocytosis has revealed a differential distribution of vesicles between the kiss-and-run and full fusion states at different stimulation frequencies. The quantitative model presented in this study may help us to understand the mechanism of the CIVDS and the tightly coupled endocytosis found in mammalian DRG neurons.

Depolarization initiates phasic acetylcholine release by relief of a tonic block imposed by presynaptic M2 muscarinic receptors

The role of presynaptic muscarinic autoreceptors in the initiation of phasic acetylcholine (ACh) release at frog and mouse neuromuscular junctions was studied by measuring the dependency of the amount (m) of ACh release on the level of presynaptic depolarization. Addition of methoctramine (a blocker of M2 muscarinic receptors), or of acetylcholinesterase (AChE), increased release in a voltage-dependent manner; enhancement of release declined as the depolarizing pulse amplitude increased. In frogs and wild-type mice the slope of log m/log pulse amplitude (PA) was reduced from about 7 in the control to about 4 in the presence of methoctramine or AChE. In M2 muscarinic receptor knockout mice, the slope of log m/log PA was much smaller (about 4) and was not further reduced by addition of either methoctramine or AChE. The effect of a brief (0.1 ms), but strong (-1.2 microA) depolarizing prepulse on the dependency of m on PA was also studied. The depolarizing prepulse had effects similar to those of methoctramine and AChE. In particular, it enhanced release of test pulses in a voltage-dependent manner and reduced the slope of log m/log PA from about 7 to about 4. Methoctramine + AChE occluded the prepulse effects. In knockout mice, the depolarizing prepulse had no effects. The cumulative results suggest that initiation of phasic ACh release is achieved by depolarization-mediated relief of a tonic block imposed by presynaptic M2 muscarinic receptors.

Two-photon imaging of spontaneous vesicular release in acute brain slices and its modulation by presynaptic GABAA receptors

Action potential-independent spontaneous vesicular release of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) in the CNS mediates miniature inhibitory postsynaptic currents (mIPSCs) and exerts an important control on central excitability. Using dual-photon laser scan microscopy and hyperosmotic loading of the readily releasable vesicle pool with the fluorescent styryl dye FM1-43 in hippocampal slice, we demonstrate action potential-independent release of vesicles (fluorescence destaining) from proximal perisomatic, presumed GABAergic terminals and significant inhibition of this release by the specific GABA(A) receptor agonist muscimol in the presence of tetrodotoxin and glutamate receptor antagonists CNQX and AP5. These data agree with reduction of mIPSCs by muscimol in whole-cell recordings from CA3 pyramidal neurons. In contrast, rate of vesicle release from distal, presumably glutamatergic terminals, was significantly lower and not changed by muscimol. The effect of muscimol on mIPSCs was not blocked but rather enhanced in the absence of external calcium. Our data directly demonstrate a potent disinhibitory reduction of GABA release by GABA(A) receptor activation. Those novel methods should be well suited to study pathophysiological changes in inhibition in resections obtained from neurosurgical treatment of epilepsy patients.

The timing of phasic transmitter release is Ca2+-dependent and lacks a direct influence of presynaptic membrane potential

Ca2+ influx through voltage-gated Ca2+ channels and the resulting elevation of intracellular Ca2+ concentration, [Ca2+]i, triggers transmitter release in nerve terminals. However, it is controversial whether in addition to the opening of Ca2+ channels, membrane potential directly affects transmitter release. Here, we assayed the influence of membrane potential on transmitter release at the calyx of Held nerve terminals. Transmitter release was evoked by presynaptic Ca2+ uncaging, or by presynaptic Ca2+ uncaging paired with presynaptic voltage-clamp depolarizations to +80 mV, under pharmacological block of voltage-gated Ca2+ channels. Such a change in membrane potential did not alter the Ca2+ dependence of transmitter release rates or synaptic delays. We also found, by varying the amount of Ca2+ influx during Ca2+ tail-currents, that the time course of phasic transmitter release is not invariant to changes in release probability. Rather, the time difference between peak Ca2+ current and peak transmitter release became progressively shorter with increasing Ca2+ current amplitude. When this time difference was plotted as a function of the estimated local [Ca2+]i at the sites of vesicle fusion, a slope of approximately 100 micros per 10 microM [Ca2+]i was found, in reasonable agreement with a model of cooperative Ca2+ binding and vesicle fusion. Thus, the amplitude and time course of the [Ca2+]i signal at the sites of vesicle fusion controls the timing and the amount of transmitter release, both under conditions of brief periods of Ca2+ influx, as well as during step-like elevations of [Ca2+]i produced by Ca2+ uncaging.

Use of knockout mice reveals involvement of M2-muscarinic receptors in control of the kinetics of acetylcholine release

We have previously suggested that presynaptic M(2)-muscarinic receptors (M(2)R) are involved in the control of the time course of evoked acetylcholine release in the frog neuromuscular junction. The availability of knockout mice lacking functional M(2)R (M(2)-KO) enabled us to address this issue in a more direct way. Using the phrenic diaphragm preparation, we show that in wild-type (WT) mice experimental manipulations known to affect Ca(2+) entry and removal, greatly affected the amount of acetylcholine released (quantal content). However, the time course of release remained unaltered under all these experimental treatments. On the other hand, in the M(2)-KO mice, similar experimental treatments affected both the quantal content and the time course of release. In general, a larger quantal content was accompanied by a longer duration of release. Similarly, the rise time of the postsynaptic current produced by axon stimulation was sensitive to changes in [Ca(2+)](o) or [Mg(2+)](o) in M(2)-KO mice but not in WT mice. Measurements of Ca(2+) currents revealed that the shorter rise time of the postsynaptic current seen in high [Mg(2+)](o) in M(2)-KO mice was not produced by a shorter wave of the presynaptic Ca(2+) current. These results support our earlier findings and provide direct evidence for the major role that presynaptic M(2)-muscarinic receptors play in the control of the time course of evoked acetylcholine release under physiological conditions.