Mutations preventing transpositions of yeast mating type alleles

Practical Approaches for the Yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae Genome Modification

The yeast S. cerevisiae is a unique genetic object for which a wide range of relatively simple, inexpensive, and non-time-consuming methods have been developed that allow the performing of a wide variety of genome modifications. Among the latter, one can mention point mutations, disruptions and deletions of particular genes and regions of chromosomes, insertion of cassettes for the expression of heterologous genes, targeted chromosomal rearrangements such as translocations and inversions, directed changes in the karyotype (loss or duplication of particular chromosomes, changes in the level of ploidy), mating-type changes, etc. Classical yeast genome manipulations have been advanced with CRISPR/Cas9 technology in recent years that allow for the generation of multiple simultaneous changes in the yeast genome. In this review we discuss practical applications of both the classical yeast genome modification methods as well as CRISPR/Cas9 technology. In addition, we review methods for ploidy changes, including aneuploid generation, methods for mating type switching and directed DSB. Combined with a description of useful selective markers and transformation techniques, this work represents a nearly complete guide to yeast genome modification.

The genetic basis of differential autodiploidization in evolving yeast populations

Spontaneous whole-genome duplication, or autodiploidization, is a common route to adaptation in experimental evolution of haploid budding yeast populations. The rate at which autodiploids fix in these populations appears to vary across strain backgrounds, but the genetic basis of these differences remains poorly characterized. Here, we show that the frequency of autodiploidization differs dramatically between two closely related laboratory strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, BY4741 and W303. To investigate the genetic basis of this difference, we crossed these strains to generate hundreds of unique F1 segregants and tested the tendency of each segregant to autodiplodize across hundreds of generations of laboratory evolution. We find that variants in the SSD1 gene are the primary genetic determinant of differences in autodiploidization. We then used multiple laboratory and wild strains of S. cerevisiae to show that clonal populations of strains with a functional copy of SSD1 autodiploidize more frequently in evolution experiments, while knocking out this gene or replacing it with the W303 allele reduces autodiploidization propensity across all genetic backgrounds tested. These results suggest a potential strategy for modifying rates of spontaneous whole-genome duplications in laboratory evolution experiments in haploid budding yeast. They may also have relevance to other settings in which eukaryotic genome stability plays an important role, such as biomanufacturing and the treatment of pathogenic fungal diseases and cancers.

The budding yeast life cycle: More complex than anticipated?

The budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, has served as a model for nearly a century to understand the principles of the eukaryotic life cycle. The canonical life cycle of S. cerevisiae comprises a regular alternation between haploid and diploid phases. Haploid gametes generated by sporulation are expected to quickly restore the diploid phase mainly through inbreeding via intratetrad mating or haploselfing, thereby promoting genome homozygotization. However, recent large population genomics data unveiled that heterozygosity and polyploidy are unexpectedly common. This raises the interesting paradox of a haplo-diplobiontic species being well-adapted to inbreeding and able to maintain high levels of heterozygosity and polyploidy, thereby suggesting an unanticipated complexity of the yeast life cycle. Here, we propose that unprogrammed mating type switching, heterothallism, reduced spore formation and viability, cell-cell fusion and dioecy could play key and uncharted contributions to generate and maintain heterozygosity through polyploidization.

Functional analysis of HO gene in delayed homothallism in Saccharomyces cerevisiae wy2

Saccharomyces cerevisiae wy2 exhibits a novel life cycle, with delayed homothallism caused by a defective HO gene. In this strain, gradual diploidization occurs during successive subcultures. Three amino acids of wy2 HO were different from those of wild-type (wt) HO, which included a nonsense mutation (TAG) from Trp-292 and two amino acid changes of His-475 to Leu and Glu-530 to Lys. The ho gene of heterothallic strain CG379 was also sequenced in this study. Four amino acids of ho were different from those of HO. Among different amino acids in wy2 HO and ho, the alteration of His-475 to Leu was common between them. His-475 in HO was previously suggested to be involved in the DNA binding. We constructed a variety of chimeric HO genes by exchanging the corresponding restriction fragments generated from the wt HO, wy2 HO and ho genes. These results and the site-directed mutagenesis studies allowed us to draw the following conclusions: (a) Gly-223 is essential for HO activity; (b) mutation of His-475 to Leu significantly reduces the HO activity; (c) amber mutation (TAG) in wy2 HO car be suppressed inefficiently.

Identification of a protein that binds to the Ho endonuclease recognition sequence at the yeast mating type locus

Mating type switching in Saccharomyces cerevisiae initiates when Ho endonuclease makes a site-specific double-stranded break at MAT, the yeast mating type locus. To identify other proteins involved in this process, we examined whether extracts prepared from ho- mutants contain additional factors that bind near the recognition sequence for Ho. Using an electrophoretic mobility shift assay, we isolated a chromatographic fraction that contains an activity, named YZbp, which binds to two sequences flanking the recognition sequence at MATalpha and to one sequence overlapping it at MATa. MAT plasmids carrying mutations in the YZbp recognition sequence are cleaved by purified Ho at wild-type efficiencies in an in vitro assay. These same plasmids, however, are not cleaved by Ho inside cells, demonstrating that YZbp acts as a positive activator of in vivo cleavage. YZbp is present in all cell types, even those not undergoing mating type switching, suggesting that it has additional cellular functions.

Mutations affecting donor preference during mating type interconversion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Homothallic strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae can convert mating type from a to alpha or alpha to a as often as every generation, by replacing genetic information specifying one mating type at the expressor locus, MAT, with information specifying the opposite mating type. The cryptic mating type information that is copied and inserted at MAT is contained in either of two loci, HML or HMR. The particular locus selected as donor during mating type interconversion is regulated by the allele expressed at MAT. MATa cells usually select HML, and MAT alpha cells usually select HMR, a process referred to as donor preference. To identify factors required for donor preference, we isolated and characterized a number of mutants that frequently selected the nonpreferred donor locus during mating type interconversion. Many of these mutants were found to harbor chromosome rearrangements or mutations at MAT or HML that interfered with the switching process. However, one mutant carried a recessive allele of CHL1, a gene previously shown to be required for efficient chromosome segregation during mitosis. Homothallic strains of yeast containing a null allele of CHL1 exhibited almost random selection of the donor locus in a MATa background but were normal in their ability to select HMR in a MAT alpha background. Our results indicate that Chl1p participates in the process of donor selection and are consistent with a model in which Chl1p helps establish an intrinsic bias in donor preference.

Recombination initiated by double-strand breaks

The HO endonuclease was used to introduce a site-specific double-strand break (DSB) in an interval designed to monitor mitotic recombination. The interval included the trp1 and his3 genes inserted into chromosome III of S. cerevisiae between the CRY1 and MAT loci. Mitotic recombination was monitored in a diploid carrying heteroalleles of trp1 and his3. The normal recognition sites for the HO endonuclease were mutated at the MAT alleles and a synthetic recognition site for HO endonuclease was placed between trp1 and his3 on one of the chromosomes. HO-induced cleavage resulted in efficient recombination in this interval. Most of the data can be explained by double-strand gap repair in which the cut chromosome acts as the recipient. However, analysis of some of the recombinants indicates that regions of heteroduplex were generated flanking the site of the cut, and that some recombinants were the result of the cut chromosome acting as the genetic donor.

Heteroduplex formation and mismatch repair of the "stuck" mutation during mating-type switching in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We sequenced two alleles of the MATa locus of Saccharomyces cerevisiae that reduce homothallic switching and confer viability to HO rad52 strains. Both the MATa-stk (J. E. Haber, W. T. Savage, S. M. Raposa, B. Weiffenbach, and L. B. Rowe, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 77:2824-2828, 1980) and MATa-survivor (R. E. Malone and D. Hyman, Curr. Genet. 7:439-447, 1983) alleles result from a T----A base change at position Z11 of the MAT locus. These strains also contain identical base substitutions at HMRa, so that the mutation is reintroduced when MAT alpha switches to MATa. Mating-type switching in a MATa-stk strain relative to a MATa Z11T strain is reduced at least 50-fold but can be increased by expression of HO from a galactose-inducible promoter. We confirmed by Southern analysis that the Z11A mutation reduced the efficiency of double-strand break formation compared with the Z11T variant; the reduction was more severe in MAT alpha than in MATa. In MAT alpha, the Z11A mutation also creates a mat alpha 1 (sterile) mutation that distinguishes switches of MATa-stk to either MAT alpha or mat alpha 1-stk. Pedigree analysis of cells induced to switch in G1 showed that MATa-stk switched frequently (23% of the time) to produce one mat alpha 1-stk and one MAT alpha progeny. This postswitching segregation suggests that Z11 was often present in heteroduplex DNA that was not mismatch repaired. When mismatch repair was prevented by deletion of the PMS1 gene, there was an increase in the proportion of mat alpha 1-stk/MAT alpha sectors (59%) and in pairs of switched cells that both retained the stk mutation (27%). We conclude that at least one strand of DNA only 4 bp from the HO cut site is not degraded in most of the gene conversion events that accompany MAT switching.

Heteroduplex formation and mismatch repair of the "stuck" mutation during mating-type switching in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We sequenced two alleles of the MATa locus of Saccharomyces cerevisiae that reduce homothallic switching and confer viability to HO rad52 strains. Both the MATa-stk (J. E. Haber, W. T. Savage, S. M. Raposa, B. Weiffenbach, and L. B. Rowe, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 77:2824-2828, 1980) and MATa-survivor (R. E. Malone and D. Hyman, Curr. Genet. 7:439-447, 1983) alleles result from a T----A base change at position Z11 of the MAT locus. These strains also contain identical base substitutions at HMRa, so that the mutation is reintroduced when MAT alpha switches to MATa. Mating-type switching in a MATa-stk strain relative to a MATa Z11T strain is reduced at least 50-fold but can be increased by expression of HO from a galactose-inducible promoter. We confirmed by Southern analysis that the Z11A mutation reduced the efficiency of double-strand break formation compared with the Z11T variant; the reduction was more severe in MAT alpha than in MATa. In MAT alpha, the Z11A mutation also creates a mat alpha 1 (sterile) mutation that distinguishes switches of MATa-stk to either MAT alpha or mat alpha 1-stk. Pedigree analysis of cells induced to switch in G1 showed that MATa-stk switched frequently (23% of the time) to produce one mat alpha 1-stk and one MAT alpha progeny. This postswitching segregation suggests that Z11 was often present in heteroduplex DNA that was not mismatch repaired. When mismatch repair was prevented by deletion of the PMS1 gene, there was an increase in the proportion of mat alpha 1-stk/MAT alpha sectors (59%) and in pairs of switched cells that both retained the stk mutation (27%). We conclude that at least one strand of DNA only 4 bp from the HO cut site is not degraded in most of the gene conversion events that accompany MAT switching.

In vivo analysis of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae HO nuclease recognition site by site-directed mutagenesis

HO nuclease introduces a specific double-strand break in the mating-type locus (MAT) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, initiating mating-type interconversion. To define the sequence recognized by HO nuclease, random mutations were produced in a 30-base-pair region homologous to either MAT alpha or MATa by a chemical synthesis procedure. The mutant sites were introduced into S. cerevisiae on a shuttle vector and tested for the ability to stimulate recombination in an assay that mimics mating-type interconversion. The results suggest that a core of 8 noncontiguous bases near the Y-Z junction of MAT is essential for HO nuclease to bind and cleave its recognition site. Other contacts must be required because substrates that contain several mutations outside an intact core reduce or eliminate cleavage in vivo. The results show that HO site recognition is a complex phenomenon, similar to promoter-polymerase interactions.

In vivo analysis of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae HO nuclease recognition site by site-directed mutagenesis

HO nuclease introduces a specific double-strand break in the mating-type locus (MAT) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, initiating mating-type interconversion. To define the sequence recognized by HO nuclease, random mutations were produced in a 30-base-pair region homologous to either MAT alpha or MATa by a chemical synthesis procedure. The mutant sites were introduced into S. cerevisiae on a shuttle vector and tested for the ability to stimulate recombination in an assay that mimics mating-type interconversion. The results suggest that a core of 8 noncontiguous bases near the Y-Z junction of MAT is essential for HO nuclease to bind and cleave its recognition site. Other contacts must be required because substrates that contain several mutations outside an intact core reduce or eliminate cleavage in vivo. The results show that HO site recognition is a complex phenomenon, similar to promoter-polymerase interactions.

Homothallic mating type switching generates lethal chromosome breaks in rad52 strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

In homothallic cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a or alpha mating type information at the mating type locus (MAT) is replaced by the transposition of the opposite mating type allele from HML alpha or HMRa. The rad52-1 mutation, which reduces mitotic and abolishes meiotic recombination, also affects homothallic switching (Malone and Esposito, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 77:503-507, 1980). We have found that both HO rad52 MATa and HO rad52 MAT alpha cells die. This lethality is suppressed by mutations that substantially reduce but do not eliminate homothallic conversions. These mutations map at or near the MAT locus (MAT alpha inc, MATa-inc, MATa stk1) or are unlinked to MAT (HO-1 and swi1). These results suggest that the switching event itself is involved in the lethality. With the exception of swi1, HO rad52 strains carrying one of the above mutations cannot convert mating type at all. MAT alpha rad52 HO swi1 strains apparently can switch MAT alpha to MATa. However, when we analyzed these a maters, we found that few, if any, of them were bona fide MATa cells. These a-like cells were instead either deleted for part of chromosome III distal to and including MAT or had lost the entire third chromosome. Approximately 30% of the time, an a-like cell could be repaired to a normal MATa genotype if the cell was mated to a RAD52 MAT alpha-inc strain. The effects of rad52 were also studied in mata/MAT alpha-inc rad52/rad52 ho/HO diploids. When this diploid attempted to switch mata to MATa, an unstable broken chromosome was generated in nearly every cell. These studies suggest that homothallic switching involves the formation of a double-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid break or a structure which is labile in rad52 cells and results in a broken chromosome. We propose that the production of a double-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid break is the lethal event in rad52 HO cells.

Homothallic switching of Saccharomyces cerevisiae mating type genes by using a donor containing a large internal deletion

Homothallic switching of the mating type genes of Saccharomyces cerevisiae occurs by a gene conversion event, replacing sequences at the expressed MAT locus with a DNA segment copied from one of two unexpressed loci, HML or HMR. The transposed Ya or Y alpha sequences are flanked by homologous regions that are believed to be essential for switching. We examined the transposition of a mating type gene (hmr alpha 1-delta 6) which contains a 150-base-pair deletion spanning the site where the HO endonuclease generates a double-stranded break in MAT that initiates the gene conversion event. Despite the fact that the ends of the cut MAT region no longer share homology with the donor hmr alpha 1-delta 6, switching of MATa or MAT alpha to mat alpha 1-delta 6 was efficient. However, there was a marked increase in the number of aberrant events, especially the formation of haploid-inviable fusions between MAT and the hmr alpha 1-delta 6 donor locus.

Homothallic switching of Saccharomyces cerevisiae mating type genes by using a donor containing a large internal deletion

Homothallic switching of the mating type genes of Saccharomyces cerevisiae occurs by a gene conversion event, replacing sequences at the expressed MAT locus with a DNA segment copied from one of two unexpressed loci, HML or HMR. The transposed Ya or Y alpha sequences are flanked by homologous regions that are believed to be essential for switching. We examined the transposition of a mating type gene (hmr alpha 1-delta 6) which contains a 150-base-pair deletion spanning the site where the HO endonuclease generates a double-stranded break in MAT that initiates the gene conversion event. Despite the fact that the ends of the cut MAT region no longer share homology with the donor hmr alpha 1-delta 6, switching of MATa or MAT alpha to mat alpha 1-delta 6 was efficient. However, there was a marked increase in the number of aberrant events, especially the formation of haploid-inviable fusions between MAT and the hmr alpha 1-delta 6 donor locus.

Resolution of recombination intermediates generated during yeast mating type switching

Interchromosomal gene conversion between alleles has been shown in yeast frequently to be associated with the recombination of flanking genetic markers. Although this also holds true for gene conversion between two alleles of the yeast mating-type (MAT) locus, initiated by the homothallic switching system, we find no evidence that crossing-over ever accompanies gene conversion between the non-allelic HMR and MAT genes when initiated by this same homothallic switching system.

Deletions and single base pair changes in the yeast mating type locus that prevent homothallic mating type conversions

Several cis-acting mutations that prevent homothallic mating type conversions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae have been examined. Deletions within the mating type (MAT) locus were obtained by selecting for survivors among homothallic MAT alpha cells carrying the rad52 mutation. The survivors were unable to switch mating type, even in RAD+ derivatives. The deletions varied in size from fewer than 50 to more than 750 base pairs. All of the deletions removed a Hha I site at the border between the alpha-specific sequences (Y alpha) and the adjacent Z region. We also examined several spontaneous inc mutations that prevent MAT switching. Two of these mutations were cloned in recombinant DNA plasmids and their sequences were determined. The MAT alpha-inc 3-7 mutation proved to have an altered Hha I site at the Y alpha/Z border, by virtue of a single base pair substitution G . C leads to A . T in the second base pair of the Z region (Z2). Restriction fragment analysis showed that two other independently isolated strains with MAT alpha-inc mutations had altered the same Hha I site. The MAT a-inc 4-28 mutation contains a single base pair substitution C . G leads to T . A at position Z6. A base pair difference at position Z11 in two MATa strains does not affect MATa conversions. We conclude that the region near the Y/Z border is essential for the efficient switching of MAT alleles and constitutes an enzyme recognition site for a specific nucleolytic cleavage of MAT DNA.

Transposition of yeast mating type genes from two translocations of the left arm of chromosome III

In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the HIS4C gene lies on the left arm of chromosome III. We analyzed two chromosomal rearrangements that have HIS4C translocated either to chromosome XII or to a new translocation chromosome. Using the cmt mutation that allows expression of the normally silent copies of mating type genes, we found that both of these translocations also carried HML alpha, more than 30 map units distal to HIS4C which normally lies on chromosome III. In the case of the translocation chromosome (designated T3), we also found an exchange event between HML alpha on the translocation chromosome and HMLa on chromosome III. In diploids containing two T3 chromosomes (one carrying HML alpha and the carrying HMLa), we found that HML was 32 centimorgans from HIS4C, which was 10 centimorgans from an unknown centromere. In homothallic strains carrying HMLa MATa HMRa on chromosome III, switching from MATa to MAT alpha could occur by using the HML alpha on the translocation as the sole donor of alpha information. Transposition from HML alpha on chromosome T3 was about 20 to 40% as efficient as transposition from intact chromosome III. In contrast, transposition from the HML alpha inserted into chromosome XII was reduced about 100-fold. This reduced efficiency did not appear to be caused by an alteration in the sequences immediately surrounding HML alpha in the translocation. The translocated HML alpha sequence was located in the same size (29-kilobase) SalI fragment as was found in chromosome III, and the same EcoRI, HindIII, and BglII restriction sites were also found. Furthermore, HML alpha was still under the control of the CMT gene, which maintains HML as a silent copy of mating type information. These results suggested that the position of the HML alpha sequence plays an important role in the efficiency of mating type switching.

Relation between the efficiency of homothallic switching of yeast mating type genes and the distribution of cell types

Homothallic switching of yeast mating type genes occurs as often as each cell division, so that a colony derived from a single haploid spore soon contains an equal number of MATa and MAT alpha cells. Cells of opposite mating types conjugate, and eventually the colony contains only nonmating MATa/MAT alpha diploids. Mutations that reduce the efficiency of homothallic MAT conversions yield colonies that still contain many haploid cells of the original spore mating type plus a few recently generated cells of the opposite mating type. These (a greater than alpha)- or (alpha greater than a)-mating colonies also contain some nonmating diploid cells. As an alternative to microscopic pedigree analysis to determine the frequency of mating type conversions in a variety of mutant homothallic strains, we analyzed the proportions of MATa, MAT alpha, and MATa/MAT alpha cells in a colony by examining the mating phenotypes of subclones. We developed a mathematical model that described the proportion of cell types in a slow-switching colony. This model predicted that the proportion of nonmating cells would continually increase with the size (age) of a colony derived from a single cell. This prediction was confirmed by determining the proportion of cell types in colonies of an HO swi1 strain that was grown for different numbers of cell divisions. Data from subcloning (a greater than alpha) and (alpha greater than a) colonies from a variety of slow-switching mutations and chromosomal rearrangements were used to calculate the frequency of MAT conversions in these strains.

Transposition of yeast mating type genes from two translocations of the left arm of chromosome III

In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the HIS4C gene lies on the left arm of chromosome III. We analyzed two chromosomal rearrangements that have HIS4C translocated either to chromosome XII or to a new translocation chromosome. Using the cmt mutation that allows expression of the normally silent copies of mating type genes, we found that both of these translocations also carried HML alpha, more than 30 map units distal to HIS4C which normally lies on chromosome III. In the case of the translocation chromosome (designated T3), we also found an exchange event between HML alpha on the translocation chromosome and HMLa on chromosome III. In diploids containing two T3 chromosomes (one carrying HML alpha and the carrying HMLa), we found that HML was 32 centimorgans from HIS4C, which was 10 centimorgans from an unknown centromere. In homothallic strains carrying HMLa MATa HMRa on chromosome III, switching from MATa to MAT alpha could occur by using the HML alpha on the translocation as the sole donor of alpha information. Transposition from HML alpha on chromosome T3 was about 20 to 40% as efficient as transposition from intact chromosome III. In contrast, transposition from the HML alpha inserted into chromosome XII was reduced about 100-fold. This reduced efficiency did not appear to be caused by an alteration in the sequences immediately surrounding HML alpha in the translocation. The translocated HML alpha sequence was located in the same size (29-kilobase) SalI fragment as was found in chromosome III, and the same EcoRI, HindIII, and BglII restriction sites were also found. Furthermore, HML alpha was still under the control of the CMT gene, which maintains HML as a silent copy of mating type information. These results suggested that the position of the HML alpha sequence plays an important role in the efficiency of mating type switching.

Relation between the efficiency of homothallic switching of yeast mating type genes and the distribution of cell types

Homothallic switching of yeast mating type genes occurs as often as each cell division, so that a colony derived from a single haploid spore soon contains an equal number of MATa and MAT alpha cells. Cells of opposite mating types conjugate, and eventually the colony contains only nonmating MATa/MAT alpha diploids. Mutations that reduce the efficiency of homothallic MAT conversions yield colonies that still contain many haploid cells of the original spore mating type plus a few recently generated cells of the opposite mating type. These (a greater than alpha)- or (alpha greater than a)-mating colonies also contain some nonmating diploid cells. As an alternative to microscopic pedigree analysis to determine the frequency of mating type conversions in a variety of mutant homothallic strains, we analyzed the proportions of MATa, MAT alpha, and MATa/MAT alpha cells in a colony by examining the mating phenotypes of subclones. We developed a mathematical model that described the proportion of cell types in a slow-switching colony. This model predicted that the proportion of nonmating cells would continually increase with the size (age) of a colony derived from a single cell. This prediction was confirmed by determining the proportion of cell types in colonies of an HO swi1 strain that was grown for different numbers of cell divisions. Data from subcloning (a greater than alpha) and (alpha greater than a) colonies from a variety of slow-switching mutations and chromosomal rearrangements were used to calculate the frequency of MAT conversions in these strains.

Homothallic mating type switching generates lethal chromosome breaks in rad52 strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

In homothallic cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a or alpha mating type information at the mating type locus (MAT) is replaced by the transposition of the opposite mating type allele from HML alpha or HMRa. The rad52-1 mutation, which reduces mitotic and abolishes meiotic recombination, also affects homothallic switching (Malone and Esposito, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 77:503-507, 1980). We have found that both HO rad52 MATa and HO rad52 MAT alpha cells die. This lethality is suppressed by mutations that substantially reduce but do not eliminate homothallic conversions. These mutations map at or near the MAT locus (MAT alpha inc, MATa-inc, MATa stk1) or are unlinked to MAT (HO-1 and swi1). These results suggest that the switching event itself is involved in the lethality. With the exception of swi1, HO rad52 strains carrying one of the above mutations cannot convert mating type at all. MAT alpha rad52 HO swi1 strains apparently can switch MAT alpha to MATa. However, when we analyzed these a maters, we found that few, if any, of them were bona fide MATa cells. These a-like cells were instead either deleted for part of chromosome III distal to and including MAT or had lost the entire third chromosome. Approximately 30% of the time, an a-like cell could be repaired to a normal MATa genotype if the cell was mated to a RAD52 MAT alpha-inc strain. The effects of rad52 were also studied in mata/MAT alpha-inc rad52/rad52 ho/HO diploids. When this diploid attempted to switch mata to MATa, an unstable broken chromosome was generated in nearly every cell. These studies suggest that homothallic switching involves the formation of a double-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid break or a structure which is labile in rad52 cells and results in a broken chromosome. We propose that the production of a double-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid break is the lethal event in rad52 HO cells.