Evolution of DNA sequence organization in mitochondrial genomes of Zea

Advances in molecular marker techniques and their applications in plant sciences

Detection and analysis of genetic variation can help us to understand the molecular basis of various biological phenomena in plants. Since the entire plant kingdom cannot be covered under sequencing projects, molecular markers and their correlation to phenotypes provide us with requisite landmarks for elucidation of genetic variation. Genetic or DNA based marker techniques such as RFLP (restriction fragment length polymorphism), RAPD (random amplified polymorphic DNA), SSR (simple sequence repeats) and AFLP (amplified fragment length polymorphism) are routinely being used in ecological, evolutionary, taxonomical, phylogenic and genetic studies of plant sciences. These techniques are well established and their advantages as well as limitations have been realized. In recent years, a new class of advanced techniques has emerged, primarily derived from combination of earlier basic techniques. Advanced marker techniques tend to amalgamate advantageous features of several basic techniques. The newer methods also incorporate modifications in the methodology of basic techniques to increase the sensitivity and resolution to detect genetic discontinuity and distinctiveness. The advanced marker techniques also utilize newer class of DNA elements such as retrotransposons, mitochondrial and chloroplast based microsatellites, thereby revealing genetic variation through increased genome coverage. Techniques such as RAPD and AFLP are also being applied to cDNA-based templates to study patterns of gene expression and uncover the genetic basis of biological responses. The review details account of techniques used in identification of markers and their applicability in plant sciences.

Relationships among Cichorium species and related genera as determined by analysis of mitochondrial RFLPs

Mitochondrial DNA polymorphism was employed to assess cytoplasmic diversity among cytoypes of the genus Cichorium and related genera of the tribe Lactuceae (Asteraceae). Hybridization patterns of total DNA using six restriction enzymes and five heterologous mtDNA probes were examined. From estimates of mtDNA diversity, Cichorium spinosum appeared as an ecotype of C. intybus rather than a separate species. Interspecific mtDNA polymorphism in the genus Cichorium was higher than that observed in Cicerbita Crepis, Lactuca and Tragopogon. Molecular data seemed to indicate that Catananche is very distant from the other genera examined. Intergeneric comparisons allowed the clustering of Cicerbita, Lactuca and Cichorium, genera which belong to different subtribes. However, further molecular investigations on a larger number of genera are needed to clarify the relationships among genera within and between subtribes of the tribe Lactuceae.

Chimeric mitochondrial genes expressed in the C male-sterile cytoplasm of maize

Aberrant recombinations involving the mitochondrial atp9, atp6 and coxII genes have created unique chimeric sequences in the C male-sterile cytoplasm (cms-C) of maize. An apparent consequence of the rearrangements is the interchanging of transcriptional and/or translational regulatory signals for these genes, and alterations in the reading frames encoding the atp6 and coxII genes in the C cytoplasm. Particularly unusual is the organization of the atp6 gene in cms-C mitochondria, designated atp6-C. The atp6-C sequence is a triple gene fusion product comprised of DNAs derived from atp9, atp6 and an open reading frame of unknown origin. Although there is no direct evidence indicating that these chimeric genes are responsible for the cytoplasmic male sterility (cms) trait, their novel arrangements and the strong correlation between these genes and the C type of male sterility suggest such a role.

Variability and uniformity of mitochondrial DNA in populations of putative diploid ancestors of common wheat

By using restriction endonuclease digestion patterns, the degree of intraspecific polymorphism of mitochondrial DNA in four diploid species of wheat and Aegilops, Ae. speltoides, Ae. longissima, Ae. squarrosa, and Triticum monococcum, was assessed. The outbreeding Ae. speltoides was found to possess the highest degree of variability, the mean number of nucleotide substitutions among conspecific individuals being 0.027 substitutions per nucleotide site. A very low degree of mtDNA variation was detected among Ae. longissima accessions, with most of the enzyme-probe combinations exhibiting uniform hybridization patterns. The mean number of substitutions among Ae. longissima individuals was 0.001 substitutions per nucleotide site. The domesticated diploid wheat T. monococcum var. monococcum and its conspecific variant T. monococcum var. boeoticum seem to lack mitochondrial DNA variability altogether. Thus, the restriction fragment pattern can be used as a characteristic identifier of the T. monococcum cytoplasmic genome. Similarly, Ae. squarrosa accessions were found to be genetically uniform. A higher degree of variation among accessions is observed when noncoding sequences are used as probes then when adjacent coding regions are used. Thus, while noncoding regions may contain regulatory functions, they are subject to less stringent functional constraints than protein-coding regions. Intraspecific variation in mitochondrial DNA correlates perfectly with the nuclear variability detected by using protein electrophoretic characters. This correlation indicates that both types of variation are selectively neutral and are affected only by the effective population size.

The molecular basis of genetic diversity among cytoplasms of Triticum and Aegilops : 7. Restriction endonuclease analysis of mitochondrial DNAs from polyploid wheats and their ancestral species

Many related species and strains of common wheat were compared by matching differences among their mitochondrial genomes with their "parent" nuclear genomes. We examined three species of Aegilops, section Sitopsis (Ae. bicornis, Ae. sharonensis, and Ae. speltoides), emmer wheat (Triticum dicoccoides, T. dicoccum, and T. durum), common wheat (T. spelta, T. aestivum, and T. compaction), and timopheevi wheat (T. araraticum, T. timopheevi, and T. zhukovskyi). A single source of the cytoplasm was used in all the species, except Ae. speltoides (two sources), T. araraticum (two), and T. aestivum (three). Following restriction endonuclease analyses, the mitochondrial genomes were found to comprise seven types, and a dendrogram showing their genetic relatedness was constructed, based upon the percentage of common restriction fragments. MtDNAs from T. dicoccum, T. durum, T. aestivum, and T. compactum yielded identical restriction fragment patterns; these differed from T. dicoccoides and T. spelta mtDNAs in only 2.3% of their fragments. The fragment patterns of T. timopheevi and T. zhukovskyi were identical, and these differed from T. araraticum mtDNA by only one fragment. In both the emmer-dinkel and timopheevi groups, mitochondrial genome differentiation is evident, suggesting a diphyletic origin of each group. MtDNAs from four accessions of the Sitopsis species of Aegilops differ greatly from one another, but those of Ae. bicornis, Ae. sharonensis, and Ae. searsii, belonging to the same subsection Emarginata, are relatively similar. MtDNAs of timopheevi species are identical, or nearly so, to those of Ae. speltoides accession (09), suggesting that the latter was the cytoplasm donor to the former, polyploid group. The origin of this polyploid group seems to be rather recent in that the diploid and polyploid species possess nearly identical mitochondrial genomes. We cannot determine, with precision, the cytoplasm donor to the emmer-dinkel group. However, our results do suggest that mitochondrial DNAs show larger evolutionary divergence than do the ctDNAs from these same strains.

A nuclear sequence associated with self-incompatibility in Nicotiana alata has homology with mitochondrial DNA

A 1.0-kb nuclear fragment located 5' to a coding sequence associated with self-incompatibility in N. alata shows homology with mitochondrial chromosomal DNA on Southern blots. This sequence is also present in the mitochondrial DNA of two species of tomato, L. esculentum and L. pennellii, but shows no homology to mtDNA of Zea mays. The homologous mitochondrial fragment from N. alata was cloned and sequenced. A short region of 56 bp matches the nuclear sequence in 53/56 bp. Other matched but misaligned segments flank the 3' end. The nuclear sequence is marked at the 5' end by two 8 bp direct repeats. The function of the nuclear sequence is not known although, it is located 397 bp upstream from the site of transcription of the self-incompatibility gene. The mitochondrial sequence contains only limited open reading frames and the nuclear sequence has none. There is evidence that additional segments of the mitochondrial clone hybridize to other nuclear sequences. The exchange of sequences between the mitochondrial and nuclear genomes of plants is discussed.

Plant mitochondrial DNA evolves rapidly in structure, but slowly in sequence

We examined the tempo and mode of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) evolution in six species of crucifers from two genera, Brassica and Raphanus. The six mtDNAs have undergone numerous internal rearrangements and therefore differ dramatically with respect to the sizes of their subgenomic circular chromosomes. Between 3 and 14 inversions must be postulated to account for the structural differences found between any two species. In contrast, these mtDNAs are extremely similar in primary sequence, differing at only 1-8 out of every 1000 bp. The point mutation rate in these plant mtDNAs is roughly 4 times slower than in land plant chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) and 100 times slower than in animal mtDNA. Conversely, the rate of rearrangements is extraordinarily faster in plant mtDNA than in cpDNA and animal mtDNA.

Multiple sequence rearrangements accompanying the duplication of a tRNA(Pro) gene in wheat mitochondrial DNA

In the course of isolating tRNA genes from wheat mtDNA, we have found the same tRNA(Pro) gene in two different Hind III restriction fragments, H-P1 (0.7 kbp) and H-P2 (1.7 kbp). Sequences immediately flanking these duplicate genes are closely related, although not identical; sequence comparisons suggest that multiple rearrangements have occurred in the vicinity of the H-P2 tRNA(Pro) gene, relative to the H-P1 version. The chimeric nature of H-P2 is emphasized by the presence of sequences that are also found upstream of the wheat mitochondrial 26S rRNA gene, as well as sequences derived from chloroplast DNA. Comparison of H-P2 with H-P1 plus upstream sequences provides some insight into possible molecular events that might have generated H-P2. In particular, such comparisons suggest a model in which the homologous sequences in H-P2 are seen to be derived from H-P1 plus upstream sequences as a result of an intragenomic, site-specific rearrangement event, followed by amplification of the product, its fixation in the mitochondrial genome, and subsequent sequence divergence (single base changes as well as insertions/deletions of up to 50 nucleotides). The results reported here implicate particular primary sequence motifs in certain of the rearrangements that characterize H-P2.

Mitochondrial DNA variation in pearl millet and related species

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) restriction endonuclease fragment patterns and patterns of mtDNA hybridized by mitochondrial gene probes were used to study phylogenetic relationships of seven Pennisetum species, including five P. americanum (pearl millet) ecotypes and a reference species from the distantly related genus, Panicum. The restriction patterns of the pearl millet ecotypes were uniform with the exception of the ecotype collected in Ethiopia. The probe hybridization method revealed more variability, with both the Rhodesian and Ethiopian ecotypes differing from the others and from each other. Considerable restriction pattern polymorphism was noted among different species of Pennisetum, and Panicum. Significant relationships were noted of Pennisetum polystachyon to P. pedicellatum and of P. purpureum to P. squamulatum using the restriction pattern method. In addition to those relationships, the hybridization method showed relationships of pearl millet to P. purpureum and to P. squamulatum. The relationships noted between species by the hybridization method agreed more closely to the cytological data than those indicated by the restriction pattern method. Therefore, the hybridization method appeared to be the preferred method for studying species relationships. The mitochondrial genome size of pearl millet was calculated to be 407 kb and the mitochondrial genome sizes of other Pennisetum species ranged from 341 to 486 kb.

Intraspecific variation and multicircularity in Brassica mitochondrial DNAs

Intraspecific variation was examined among 25 mitochondrial DNAs (mtDNAs), representing between two and five lines of eight agriculturally important Brassica species. Each of the approximately 140 restriction sites surveyed was invariant within each species. Only two length polymorphisms, deletions of 700 bp and 100 bp in a Brassica nigra line, were detected. A single inversion polymorphism was found; this distinguished two different mtDNA populations within a single line of Brassica hirta. Approximately 60% of the mtDNA molecules in this line and in two other B. hirta lines were identical, whereas the other 40% of the molecules in the first line differed by a 62-kb inversion. Levels of within-species variability in mtDNA appear to be lower in Brassica than in other groups of plants. These mtDNA comparisons are in agreement with cpDNA studies regarding the maternal ancestry of three amphidiploid Brassica species. This agreement and others imply that the two cytoplasmic genomes must have shared a common, maternal mode of transmission throughout the history of the genus. Finally, analysis of a supercoiled fraction of mtDNA from cauliflower (Brassica oleracea) provides the strongest evidence yet in support of the multicircular model for plant mtDNAs.

Chimeric organization of two genes for the soybean mitochondrial ATPase subunit 6

There are two copies of the ATPase subunit 6 (atp6) gene in the soybean mitochondrial genome which differ in their gene organization but share extensive homology with the maize atp6 gene except at their 5' ends. The two soybean genes are chimeric, containing regions with homology to other known mitochondrial genes at their 5' ends. Sequences homologous to the cytochrome oxidase subunit II (coxII) are located in one copy and sequences homologous to the ATPase subunit 9 (atp9) gene are located in the other copy, both of which contain methionine (ATG) codons that are in-frame with the remainder of the atp6 open reading frame. At least the copy of atp6 that contains the coxII sequence at its 5' end is abundantly transcribed to give an RNA of approximately 1,200 nucleotides.

Sequence of the 18S-5S ribosomal gene region and the cytochrome oxidase II gene from mtDNA of Zea diploperennis

The coding and flanking sequences of the 18S-5S ribosomal RNA genes and the cytochrome oxidase subunit II gene of Zea diploperennis mitochondrial DNA have been determined and compared to the corresponding sequences of normal maize (Zea mays L.) Both length and substitution mutations are found in the coding region of the 18S rRNA gene, whereas only one substitution mutation is found in the coding region of cytochrome oxidase II. Sequence divergence between maize and Zea diploperennis is about one-tenth of that between wheat and maize. The rate of nucleotide divergence by base substitution is less for plant mitochrondrial genes than for comparable genes in animal mitochondria.

Mitochondrial DNA duplication/deletion events and polymorphism of the C group of male sterile maize cytoplasms

Five accessions of members of the C group of male sterile maize cytoplasms (BB, C, ES, PR, and RB) in two nuclear backgrounds (A619 and A632) were examined to elucidate the nature of mitochondrial genome diversity within a related group of cytoplasms. Cosmid and plasmid clones carrying single copy and recombinationally active sequences from N and S cytoplasms of maize were used as probes. Although restriction patterns are quite similar, each of the five could be discriminated by evidence of sequence duplication and recombination, deletion of recombinationally active sequences of N, normal cytoplasm, population of mini-circular DNAs, and by restriction patterns. Each member of the group carried a 1,913 bp minicircular mtDNA, while all entries but RB carried a 1,445 bp minicircular mtDNA. Members of the C group clearly are not molecularly identical; evolution of the group included principal genome reorganization involving sequence duplication/deletion events, apparently independent of the cms trait.

Unicircular structure of the Brassica hirta mitochondrial genome

Restriction mapping studies reveal that the mitochondrial genome of white mustard (Brassica hirta) exists in the form of a single circular 208 kb chromosome. The B. hirta genome has only one copy of the two sequences which, in several related Brassica species, are duplicated and undergo intramolecular recombination. This first report of a plant mitochondrial DNA that does not exist in a multipartite structure indicates that high frequency intramolecular recombination is not an obligatory feature of plant mitochondrial genomes. Heterologous filter hybridizations reveal that the mitochondrial genomes of B. hirta and B. campestris have diverged radically in sequence arrangement, as the result of approximately 10 large inversions. At the same time, however, the two genomes are similar in size, sequence content, and primary sequence.

Tricircular mitochondrial genomes of Brassica and Raphanus: reversal of repeat configurations by inversion

We constructed complete physical maps of the tripartite mitochondrial genomes of two Crucifers, Brassica nigra (black mustard) and Raphanus sativa (radish). Both genomes contain two copies of a direct repeat engaged in intragenomic recombination. The outcome of this recombination in black mustard is to interconvert a 231 kb master chromosome with two subgenomic circles of 135 kb and 96 kb. In radish, a 242 kb master chromosome interconverts with subgenomic circles of 139 kb and 103 kb. The recombination repeats are 7 kb in size in black mustard and 10 kb in radish, and are nearly identical except for two insertions in the radish repeat relative to the black mustard one. The two repeat configurations present on the master chromosome of black mustard are located on the subgenomes of radish and vice-versa. To explain this, we postulate the existence of an evolutionarily intermediate mitochondrial genome in which the recombination repeats were (are) present in an inverted orientation. The recombination repeats described for these two species are completely different from those previously found in the closely related species B. campestris, implying that such repeats are created and lost frequently in plant mitochondrial DNAs and making it less than likely that recombination occurs in a site-specific manner.

The wheat mitochondrial gene for apocytochrome b: absence of a prokaryotic ribosome binding site

The wheat mitochondrial gene for apocytochrome b (CYB) has been identified by its hybridization to a yeast CYB probe and its nucleotide sequence has been determined. The wheat CYB sequence predicts a cytochrome b apoprotein of 398 amino acids; it is almost identical to that of maize but has ten additional amino acids at the carboxy terminus. No introns are present in the wheat CYB gene, but an internal segment of the gene is repeated at another genomic location. Transcript analysis reveals a single wheat CYB mRNA of approximately 2.4 kb with a long untranslated leader. Sequences upstream of the CYB coding region are very similar in wheat and maize but the stretch proposed to be a ribosome binding site in maize is not conserved in wheat. The corresponding leader regions of the wheat mitochondrial mRNAs for cytochrome oxidase subunits I and II also lack complementarity to the 3'-end of the small subunit rRNA. We conclude that alternative signals are involved in the initiation of translation in plant mitochondria.

Comparison of the mitochondrial genome of Nicotiana tabacum with its progenitor species

Mitochondrial DNAs from Nicotiana tabacum, an amphiploid, and its putative progenitor species, N. sylvestris and N. tomentosiformis were compared in structure and organization. By using DNA transfer techniques and cloned fragments of known genes from maize and N. sylvestris as labeled probes, the positions of homologous sequences in restriction digests of the Nicotiana species were analyzed. Results indicate that the mitochondrial DNA of N. tabacum was inherited from N. sylvestris. Conservation in organization and sequence homology between mtDNAs of N. tabacum and the maternal progenitor, N. sylvestris, provide evidence that the mitochondrial genome in these species is evolutionarily stable. Approximately one-third of the probed restriction fragments of N. tomentosiformis mtDNA showed conservation of position with the other two species. Pattern variations indicate that extensive rearrangement of mtDNA has occurred in the evolution of these Nicotiana species.

Recombination sequences in plant mitochondrial genomes: diversity and homologies to known mitochondrial genes

Several plant mitochondrial genomes contain repeated sequences that are postulated to be sites of homologous intragenomic recombination (1-3). In this report, we have used filter hybridizations to investigate sequence relationships between the cloned mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) recombination repeats from turnip, spinach and maize and total mtDNA isolated from thirteen species of angiosperms. We find that strong sequence homologies exist between the spinach and turnip recombination repeats and essentially all other mitochondrial genomes tested, whereas a major maize recombination repeat does not hybridize to any other mtDNA. The sequences homologous to the turnip repeat do not appear to function in recombination in any other genome, whereas the spinach repeat hybridizes to reiterated sequences within the mitochondrial genomes of wheat and two species of pokeweed that do appear to be sites of recombination. Thus, although intragenomic recombination is a widespread phenomenon in plant mitochondria, it appears that different sequences either serve as substrates for this function in different species, or else surround a relatively short common recombination site which does not cross-hybridize under our experimental conditions. Identified gene sequences from maize mtDNA were used in heterologous hybridizations to show that the repeated sequences implicated in recombination in turnip and spinach/pokeweed/wheat mitochondria include, or are closely linked to genes for subunit II of cytochrome c oxidase and 26S rRNA, respectively. Together with previous studies indicating that the 18S rRNA gene in wheat mtDNA is contained within a recombination repeat (3), these results imply an unexpectedly frequent association between recombination repeats and plant mitochondrial genes.

A novel soybean mitochondrial transcript resulting from a DNA rearrangement involving the 5S rRNA gene

A tissue culture line of soybean cells (SB-1) is shown to have an unusual arrangement of mitochondrial genes. Fusion of the mitochondrial 5S gene to the distal end of an unidentified gene results in the abundant expression of an 800 nucleotide RNA with the 5S rRNA at its 5' end. Since only the fused 5S rRNA gene is found in this cell line, the functional 5S rRNA must arise by processing of the 800 nucleotide RNA or by intermittent termination of transcription. The 800 nucleotide transcript and its DNA arrangement are not detected at comparable levels in other soybean sources, including the parent plant of the SB-1 tissue culture line. The role of recombination in the origin of this gene fusion and in plant mitochondrial DNA in general is discussed.

A review of the structure and organization of the mitochondrial genome of higher plants

The structure, organisation and functions of the mitochondrial genome of most groups of eukaryotic organisms are known to varying degrees with the notable exception of higher plants. With the recent completion of physical mapping studies on the Brassica campestris (Chinese cabbage, turnip) and Zea mays (maize) mitochondrial genomes, many of the apparent problems of plant mitochondrial genome structure can now be answered. In this manuscript I review the literature relating to the physical observations on plant mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and assess the data in relation to our current understanding of mitochondrial genome structure.

Polymorphism of mitochondrial DNA 'S' regions among normal cytoplasms of maize

Genomic variation in S1 and S2 homologous sequences, defined as the S regions, were examined in mitochondrial DNAs of 12 normal cytoplasm maize lines collected in the United States. Three genomic variants were detected among the 12 cytoplasms, eight of which were identical to the Wf9 model structure. Hybridization data with S1 and S2 DNAs and with two cosmids spanning these regions were consistent with the concept that S1 and S2 sequences are found in each normal cytoplasm. Three variations of the S1 region were established; the Wf9 structure, a second group consisting of F6, A188, and W182BN, and a third, Black Mexican. Genome structure was conserved through the S2 region in all lines examined. None of the cytoplasms included complete copies of S1; the 1400 bp repeat characteristic of S1 and S2 was absent in the S1 region of all lines. A 2.1 kb linear DNA was observed instead of a 2.3 kb DNA in F6, A188, and W182BN. Integrated copies of S1 and S2 sequences may be a constituitive characteristic of normal, male-fertile maize cytoplasms.

Analysis of four tobacco mitochondrial DNA size classes

Supercoiled mtDNAs were isolated from tobacco suspension culture cells and three of the smallest size classes (10.1, 20.2 and 30.3 kb) were characterized through denaturation, heteroduplex and restriction mapping. The 20.2 molecule was found to be a head-to-tail dimer of the 10.1 or X size class, while the 30.3 kb size class was found to contain two kinds of molecules, a head-to-tail trimer of X (X3) and a second molecule, ABC. X and ABC had a 118 +/- 35 bp region of homology, and both size classes shared a degree of homology with at least one other size class. Restriction maps of both the X and ABC molecules are presented and the possible origin and role of the many plant mtDNA size classes are discussed.