Antibody-mediated activation of genetically defective Escherichia coli beta-galactosidases by monoclonal antibodies produced by somatic cell hybrids

Antibody-mediated enzyme formation: Its legacy at age fifty-four

Antibody-mediated enzyme formation is a phenomenon first described in 1968 and further studied by molecular Immunologists and Biochemists over the following five decades. The present review is made mainly by analyzing the 27 articles concerned with AMEF that appeared over the course of 47 years, commenting 16 original figures selected to be re-printed in AMEF's Legacy. We, the reviewers, started by revisiting our own "insider's" experience of discovery, and followed by considering all results, our own and of members of other AMEF Labs. We had planned to conclude the review by correlating the various AMEF mutants to a detailed knowledge of the consensus betaGal structure. However, we became aware of several "robust" papers, published between 1989 and 2014, by authors outside of AMEF Labs. We familiarly called this surge: "The Second Wave" and adorned it with a doodle in Hokusai style. We were thrilled and happy to take them on board and properly examined their data. A team of this second wave had imagined unique uses for AMEF, and new doors to modern biotechnology. Another one had used AMEF as Tool and Marker to attain high levels of crystallography, solving puzzles of conformation, and ultimate structure. Together, they doubled our motivation to review AMEF. Serendipity gives us back the pleasure of finding, a treat at any age.

Exploring peptide space for enzyme modulators

A method is presented for screening high-density arrays to discover peptides that bind and modulate enzyme activity. A polyvinyl alcohol solution was applied to array surfaces to limit the diffusion of product molecules released from enzymatic reactions, allowing the simultaneous measurement of enzyme activity and binding at each peptide spot. For proof of concept, it was possible to identify peptides that bound to horseradish peroxidase, alkaline phosphatase, and beta-galactosidase and substantially altered enzyme activity by comparing the binding level of peptide to enzyme and bound enzyme activity. This basic technique may be generally applicable to find peptides or other small molecules that modify enzyme activity.

Monoclonal Antibodies Inducing Conformational Changes on the Antigen Molecule

Monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) are extensively used as biological tools because of their invariable specificity. However, the interpretation of results can be misled by the behaviour of MoAb displaying allosteric effects, i.e. long-range conformational changes on the antigen (Ag). It has been shown that some MoAbs are able to modify the spatial structure of the corresponding protein Ag, affecting in this way its biological activity as well as its binding to a second MoAb. Thus, a researcher using a MoAb as a tool to investigate some features of an antigenic molecule must be aware of the possible positive or negative allosteric properties of the antibody.

Analysis of H2-O influence on antigen presentation by B cells

HLA-DM (DM; in mouse H2-DM) promotes the exchange of MHC class II-associated peptides, resulting in the accumulation of stable MHC class II-peptide complexes. In naive (but not germinal center) B cells, a large part of DM is tightly associated with HLA-DO (DO; in mouse H2-O), but the functional consequence of this association for Ag presentation is debated. Here, we have extended previous studies by examining the presentation of multiple epitopes after Ag internalization by fluid phase endocytosis or receptor-mediated uptake by membrane Ig (mIg) receptors. We find that the effects of H2-O are more complex than previously appreciated; thus, while only minor influences on Ag presentation could be detected after fluid phase uptake, many epitopes were substantially affected after mIg-mediated uptake. Unexpectedly, the presentation of different epitopes was found to be enhanced, diminished, or unaffected in the absence of H2-O, depending on the specificity of the mIg used for Ag internalization. Interestingly, epitopes from the same Ag did not necessarily show the same H2-O dependency. This finding suggests that H2-O may control the repertoire of peptides presented by B cells depending on the mIg-Ag interaction. The absence of DO/H2-O from germinal center B cells suggests that this control may be released during B cell maturation.

Expression and folding of an antibody fragment selected in vivo for high expression levels in Escherichia coli cytoplasm

In this review, we summarize some of our results on folding and directed evolution of an antibody fragment in Escherichia coli cytoplasm. We will also discuss some attempts to construct other antibodies active in this cellular compartment.

Nonclassical MHC class II molecules

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules are cell surface proteins that present peptides to CD4(+) T cells. In addition to these wellcharacterized molecules, two other class II-like proteins are produced from the class II region of the MHC, HLA-DM (DM) and HLA-DO (DO) (called H2-M, or H2-DM and H2-O in the mouse). The function of DM is well established; it promotes peptide loading of class II molecules in the endosomal/lysosomal system by catalyzing the release of CLIP peptides (derived from the class II-associated invariant chain) in exchange for more stably binding peptides. While DM is present in all class II- expressing antigen presenting cells, DO is expressed mainly in B cells. In this cell type the majority of DM molecules are not present as free heterodimers but are instead associated with DO in tight heterotetrameric complexes. The association with DM is essential for the intracellular transport of DO, and the two molecules remain associated in the endosomal system. DO can clearly modify the peptide exchange activity of DM both in vitro and in vivo, but the physiological relevance of this interaction is still only partly understood.

Successful mimicry of a complex viral antigen by multiple peptide insertions in a carrier protein

The antigenic properties of a viral peptide from the surface of foot-and-mouth disease virus particles have been successfully mimicked by multiple insertion in solvent-exposed regions of Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase. By increasing the number of viral peptides per enzyme monomer, the average IC(50) of hybrid proteins in a competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) have decreased to values close to that presented by natural virions. Moreover, the antigenic diversity of these new recombinant enzymes when measured with different anti-virus antibodies has also been largely reduced, indicating a better presentation of the epitopes located in the viral peptide. Although bivalent antibody binding could have been favoured by multiple presentation, conformational modifications of the viral peptide, due to the presence of other insertions or a cooperative antibody binding cannot be excluded. In addition, a multidimensional antigenic analysis have grouped together the multiple-inserted proteins with the native virus, suggesting that increasing the number of insertions could be a good strategy to reproduce the antigenic properties of an immunoreactive peptide in a natural multimeric disposition.

The role of H2-O and HLA-DO in major histocompatibility complex class II-restricted antigen processing and presentation

The function of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules is to sample exogenous antigens for presentation to CD4+ T helper cells. After synthesis in the endoplasmic reticulum, class II molecules are directed into the endosomal system by association with the invariant chain (Ii), which is sequentially cleaved, generating class II dimers loaded with Ii-derived peptides (CLIP). These class II-peptide complexes are physiological substrates for H2-M/HLA-DM, a resident of the endosomal/lysosomal system which facilitates the removal of CLIP from newly synthesised class II alpha beta dimers. Exchange of CLIP for antigenic class II-binding peptides is also promoted by the action of H2-M/HLA-DM, resulting in stable peptide-class II complexes that are transported to the cell surface for presentation to CD4+ T cells. Recent evidence suggests that this H2-M/HLA-DM-mediated 'peptide editing' is influenced by another MHC class II-encoded molecule, H2-O/HLA-DO. This non-polymorphic alpha beta heterodimer is associated with H2-M/HLA-DM during intracellular transport and within the endosomal system of B cells. H2-O/HLA-DO alters the peptide exchange function of H2-M/HLA-DM in a pH-dependent manner, so that H2-M/HLA-DM activity is limited to more acidic conditions, corresponding to lysosomal compartments. Indeed, H2-O/HLA-DO may serve to limit the presentation of antigens after fluid phase uptake by B cells, while augmenting presentation of antigens internalised via membrane Ig receptors. Such a mechanism may maintain the fidelity of the B-cell-CD4+ T-cell interaction, counteracting self reactivity arising from less stringent lymphocyte activation. Here, data evaluating the role of H2-O/HLA-DO shall be reviewed and its putative function discussed.

Expression of an antibody fragment at high levels in the bacterial cytoplasm

Recombinant antibody fragments expressed in the cytoplasm of cells have considerable practical potential. However in the reducing environment of the cytoplasm, the intradomain disulphide bonds are not formed and the fragments are unstable and expressed in low yields. Here we attempted to overcome these limitations. We first isolated an antibody single chain Fv fragment that binds and activates an inactive mutant beta-galactosidase. We then subjected the gene encoding the scFv fragment to random mutation in vitro by error-prone polymerase chain reaction, and co-expressed the mutant beta-galactosidase and mutant antibody fragments in lac- bacteria. By plating on limiting lactose, we selected for antibody mutants with improved expression, and after four successive rounds of mutation and selection, isolated an antibody fragment that is expressed in the bacterial cytoplasm with yields of 0.5 g/l in a shaker flask (A600 nm of 5.5) and 3.1 g/l (A600 nm=33) in a fermentor. Analysis of the mutant antibody fragments revealed that the disulphide bonds are reduced in the cytoplasm, and that the fragments could be denatured and renatured efficiently under reducing conditions in vitro. This shows that with a suitable method of screening or selection, it is possible to make folded and functional antibody fragments in excellent yield in the cytoplasm.

Rapid and sensitive detection of Staphylococcus species in milk by ELISA based on monodisperse magnetic particles

Staphylococcus spp. are the single most important cause of mastitis in dairy cows. Aiming for a rapid and sensitive method for detection of staphylococci, a magnetic bead-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) employing MAb for the detection of staphylococci in milk was developed. Pretreatment of the sample with lysostaphin increased the sensitivity of the assay. The method is specific for most of staphylococci which cause mastitis in bovines, detects between 10(4)-10(5) organisms per ml and takes three hours. Thus, the principle for staphylococci ELISA based on monodisperse magnetic beads is a way for rapid detection of staphylococci in milk and possibly also for detecting staphylococci by direct testing of other clinical specimens. The system may be automated.

Altered antigen presentation in mice lacking H2-O

HLA-DM catalyzes the release of MHC class II-associated invariant chain-derived peptides (CLIP) from class II molecules. Recent evidence has suggested that HLA-DO is a negative regulator of HLA-DM in B cells, but the physiological function of HLA-DO remains unclear. Analysis of antigen presentation by B cells from mice lacking H2-O (the mouse equivalent of HLA-DO), together with biochemical analysis using purified HLA-DO and HLA-DM molecules, suggests that HLA-DO/H2-O influences the peptide loading of class II molecules by limiting the pH range in which HLA-DM is active. This effect may serve to decrease the presentation of antigens internalized by fluid-phase endocytosis, thus concentrating the B cell-mediated antigen presentation to antigens internalized by membrane immunoglobulin.

Novel immunoenzymatic assay for identification of coagulase- and protein A-negative Staphylococcus aureus strains

A purified monoclonal antibody (MAb) which specifically reacts with Staphylococcus aureus glucosaminidase was obtained. This MAb was utilized to develop an immunoenzymatic assay for the identification of S. aureus strains. The sensitivity of this assay, based on the simultaneous detection of S. aureus glucosaminidase and protein A, was evaluated by analyzing a total of 196 strains, 26 of which did not exhibit one or more of the following properties: protein A, clumping factor, and staphylocoagulase. All strains yielded positive results by the MAb-based immunoenzymatic test. The assay's ability to differentiate between S. aureus and other staphylococci was then analyzed by testing a total of 277 non-S. aureus strains that yielded negative results. Our data demonstrate that this immunoenzymatic assay can be used as a single S. aureus identification criterion, particularly useful for those strains negative for clumping factor, staphylocoagulase, or protein A.

Inhibitory activity of HIV envelope gp120 dominates over its antigenicity for human T cells

HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein (gp120), as a CD4-binding reactant, has been shown to inhibit in its native form human T cell responses to several antigens. Here we show that gp120 in soluble form also inhibits activation of a specific human T cell line that responds to gp120-pulsed autologous antigen-presenting cells. In addition the inhibitory property of gp120 for antigen-driven T cell proliferation depends upon its ability to bind CD4 and is lost when CD4-binding capacity is abolished by denaturation, or blocked by complexing with soluble CD4 or with polyclonal antibodies. In contrast, antigenicity of denatured or complexed gp120 for specific human T cells is preserved. Similar effects are also observed with another CD4-binding reactant (i.e. anti-Leu 3a MoAb), which stimulates and/or inhibits human T cells specific for mouse immunoglobulins depending on native or denatured conformation.

Effect of antigen/antibody ratio on macrophage uptake, processing, and presentation to T cells of antigen complexed with polyclonal antibodies

Activation of a galactosidase-specific murine T hybridoma clone and of a human tetanus toxoid-specific T clone by antigen-presenting cells (APC) was used to evaluate the regulatory function of antibodies complexed with the relevant antigen. Complexed antigen, in fact, is taken up with high efficiency thanks to Fc receptors borne by APC. Antibody/antigen ratio in the complexes proved to be a critical parameter in enhancing antigen presentation. Complexes in moderate antibody excess provided optimal T cell activation independently of the physical state of the complexes (precipitated by a second antibody or solubilized by complement). Complexes in extreme antibody excess, on the contrary, did not yield T cell activation although taken up by APC efficiently. The effect of antibodies at extreme excess was observed with substimulatory dose of antigen (loss of potentiation) and with optimal dose of antigen (loss of stimulation). An excess of specific polyclonal antibodies hampers proteolytic degradation of antigen in vitro, supporting the view that a similar mechanism may operate within the APC that have internalized immune complexes in extreme antibody excess. The possibility that immune complex forming in extreme antibody excess may turn off the T cell response is proposed as a regulatory mechanism.

Reaction of phosphofructokinase 2/fructose 2,6-bisphosphatase with monoclonal antibodies. A proof of the bifunctionality of the enzyme

Monoclonal antibodies were derived from mice immunized against homogeneous chicken liver phosphofructokinase 2/fructose 2,6-bisphosphatase. Of 112 clones, 30 were found to secrete antibodies that specifically reacted with the antigen in enzyme-linked immunoabsorbant assay (ELISA) while 17, which were ELISA-negative, produced antibodies that affected the enzymic activity of the antigen. Four clones were subcloned and used for an extensive investigation of the reaction of the corresponding antibodies with the supposedly bifunctional enzyme. A definite proof of the bifunctionality of the enzyme was obtained from the two following observations. First, the two activities were similarly retained by the four antibodies that had been coupled to Sepharose. Second, one of the antibodies inhibited both activities with the same efficiency. Furthermore, the antigen-antibody reaction led to the formation of aggregates with an apparent molecular mass of several megadaltons, showing that the two subunits of the antigen reacted with the same antibody and were therefore identical. The four monoclonal antibodies affected the activity of phosphofructokinase 2. This effect was seen as an up to 17-fold activation as well as an up to 85% inhibition. Only one of the four antibodies (antibody 10) had inhibitory effects on fructose 2,6-bisphosphatase, an effect which was in part explained by a decrease in the rate of formation of the intermediary phosphoenzyme. All the effects described above were obtained on both the chicken liver and the pigeon muscle enzymes but with lower doses of antibody in the case of the former enzyme. Antibody 10 was also shown to react with mouse liver phosphofructokinase 2/fructose 2,6-bisphosphatase, and with phosphofructokinase 2 from chicken brain, heart and testis and from frog skeletal muscle and liver. None of the four antibodies cross-reacted with phosphofructokinase 2 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae or from spinach leaves.

Activation and stabilization of asparaginase by anti-asparaginase IgG and its Fab

Modified asparaginase, in which 4 tryptophan residues were modified with 2-hydroxy-5-nitrobenzyl bromide, had little enzymic activity and retained immunoreactivity [(1976) FEBS Lett. 65, 11-15]. Addition of IgG or its Fab towards asparaginase to the modified asparaginase gave rise to marked enhancement of the enzymic activity. Native asparaginase (4 subunits) lost the enzymic activity due to dissociation into subunits by dilution of the enzyme solution. However, in the presence of Fab, asparaginase did not lose enzymic activity on dilution, probably due to no dissociation into subunits occurring.

Constraints in T-B cooperation related to epitope topology on E. coli beta-galactosidase. I. The fine specificity of T cells dictates the fine specificity of antibodies directed to conformation-dependent determinants

Experiments to test the relationship between the epitopes on a protein antigen recognized by T and B cells in their collaboration to produce antibody cannot rely solely on hapten-carrier models. In the present work we used E. coli beta-galactosidase, a molecule whose tertiary and quaternary epitopes have been well characterized, as the model antigen. T helper cells were raised by stimulating mice with the intact or the denatured molecule or with any of several beta-galactosidase cyanogen bromide peptides. In a series of in vitro helper T cell assays we confronted the various T populations with B cells preimmunized with the native antigen, and we tested their capacity to help production of (a) binding antibodies and (b) antibodies directed to single conformational epitopes, characterized by their capacity to protect the enzyme from heat denaturation or to activate defective beta-galactosidase. According to our results, (a) equivalent T cell help can be provided by T helper cells primed with native or denatured antigen, even for the production of "conformational" antibodies; (b) one of the peptides (CB-18) is most efficient in raising help for binding antibodies; and (c) two peptides (CB-20 and CB-21) rank highest in priming T helper cells for the eventual production of protecting and activating antibodies, respectively. Thus, not every beta-galactosidase-specific T helper cell is useful in providing help to B cells specific for any particular epitope on the molecule, but rather preferential pairings exist, possibly governed by a proximity rule.

Structural and functional influence of enzyme-antibody interactions: effects of eight different monoclonal antibodies on the enzymatic activity of Escherichia coli tryptophan synthase

Twelve monoclonal antibodies directed against the beta 2 subunit of Escherichia coli tryptophan synthase (EC 4.2.1.20) were produced from hybridoma clones. These monoclonal antibodies are found to recognize at least eight different epitopes on beta 2, and eight classes of monoclonal antibodies are thus defined. The effects of these monoclonal antibodies on the enzymatic activities of beta 2 are studied. The monoclonal antibodies from three classes rapidly inhibit the serine deaminase activity catalyzed by the beta 2 subunit alone; two of them lead to an inhibition plateau under stoichiometric conditions, and their inhibitory effects are cumulative. With the antibodies from two of these three classes, the tryptophan synthase activity of the alpha 2 beta 2 complex is recovered, through a competition between the alpha subunit and the monoclonal antibody. On the contrary, the antibody from the third class is inhibitory even in the presence of an excess of alpha subunit. The antibodies from the five other classes, though binding easily to the coated antigen in the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, react only very slowly with beta 2 in solution and, only after a long time of incubation, inhibit the enzymatic activity at different levels.

A single domain of human prostatic acid phosphatase shows antibody-mediated restoration of catalytic activity

By limited proteolysis with mouse submaxillaris protease, human prostatic acid phosphatase (EC 3.1.3.2) was cleaved into three fragments, Sp1, Sp2, and Sp3, which individually had no enzymatic activity. One of the fragments, Sp3, regained enzymatic activity after interaction with rabbit antibody to prostatic acid phosphatase. The Sp3 fragment was purified and characterized as to its molecular weight, amino acid composition, and carbohydrate content. The Sp3 fragment behaved like the parent molecule in L(+)-tartrate affinity and in trapping of a phosphoryl intermediate. The same Sp3 fragment also bears the most prominent antigenic determinants. This evidence suggest that Sp3 is the enzymatically active domain of prostatic acid phosphatase.