Molecular basis of DNA sequence recognition by the catabolite gene activator protein: detailed inferences from three mutations that alter DNA sequence specificity

ChIP-exo interrogation of Crp, DNA, and RNAP holoenzyme interactions

Numerous in vitro studies have yielded a refined picture of the structural and molecular associations between Cyclic-AMP receptor protein (Crp), the DNA motif, and RNA polymerase (RNAP) holoenzyme. In this study, high-resolution ChIP-exonuclease (ChIP-exo) was applied to study Crp binding in vivo and at genome-scale. Surprisingly, Crp was found to provide little to no protection of the DNA motif under activating conditions. Instead, Crp demonstrated binding patterns that closely resembled those generated by σ⁷⁰. The binding patterns of both Crp and σ⁷⁰ are indicative of RNAP holoenzyme DNA footprinting profiles associated with stages during transcription initiation that occur post-recruitment. This is marked by a pronounced advancement of the template strand footprint profile to the +20 position relative to the transcription start site and a multimodal distribution on the nontemplate strand. This trend was also observed in the familial transcription factor, Fnr, but full protection of the motif was seen in the repressor ArcA. Given the time-scale of ChIP studies and that the rate-limiting step in transcription initiation is typically post recruitment, we propose a hypothesis where Crp is absent from the DNA motif but remains associated with RNAP holoenzyme post-recruitment during transcription initiation. The release of Crp from the DNA motif may be a result of energetic changes that occur as RNAP holoenzyme traverses the various stable intermediates towards elongation complex formation.

Cyclic AMP receptor protein regulates cspD, a bacterial toxin gene, in Escherichia coli

cspD, a member of cspA family of cold shock genes in Escherichia coli, is not induced during cold shock. Its expression is induced during stationary phase. CspD inhibits DNA replication, and a high level of the protein is toxic to cells. Recently, CspD was proposed to be associated with persister cell formation in E. coli. Here, we show that cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) upregulates cspD transcription. Sequence analysis of the cspD upstream region revealed two tandem CRP target sites, CRP site-I (the proximal site centered at -83.5 with respect to the transcription start) and CRP site-II (the distal site centered at -112.5). The results from electrophoretic mobility shift assays showed that CRP indeed binds to these two target sites in PcspD. The promoter-proximal CRP target site was found to play a major role in PcspD activation by CRP, as studied by transcriptional fusions carrying mutations in the target sites. The results from in vitro transcription assays demonstrated that CRP activates PcspD transcription in the absence of additional factors other than RNA polymerase. The requirement for activating region 1 of CRP in PcspD activation, along with the involvement of the 287, 265, and 261 determinants of the α-CTD, suggest that CRP activates by a class I-type mechanism. However, only moderate activation in vitro was observed compared to high activation in vivo, suggesting there might be additional activators of PcspD. Overall, our findings show that CRP, a global metabolic regulator in E. coli, activates a gene potentially related to persistence.

Analysis of activator and repressor functions reveals the requirements for transcriptional control by LuxR, the master regulator of quorum sensing in Vibrio harveyi

LuxR-type transcription factors are the master regulators of quorum sensing in vibrios. LuxR proteins are unique members of the TetR superfamily of transcription factors because they activate and repress large regulons of genes. Here, we used chromatin immunoprecipitation and nucleotide sequencing (ChIP-seq) to identify LuxR binding sites in the Vibrio harveyi genome. Bioinformatics analyses showed that the LuxR consensus binding site at repressed promoters is a symmetric palindrome, whereas at activated promoters it is asymmetric and contains only half of the palindrome. Using a genetic screen, we isolated LuxR mutants that separated activation and repression functions at representative promoters. These LuxR mutants exhibit sequence-specific DNA binding defects that restrict activation or repression activity to subsets of target promoters. Altering the LuxR DNA binding site sequence to one more closely resembling the ideal LuxR consensus motif can restore in vivo function to a LuxR mutant. This study provides a mechanistic understanding of how a single protein can recognize a variety of binding sites to differentially regulate gene expression.

Bacteria use the cell-cell communication process called quorum sensing to regulate collective behaviors. In vibrios, LuxR-type transcription factors control the quorum-sensing gene expression cascade. LuxR-type proteins are structural homologs of TetR-type transcription factors. LuxR proteins were assumed to function analogously to TetR proteins, which typically bind to a single conserved binding site to repress transcription of one or two genes. We find here that unlike TetR proteins, LuxR acts a global regulator, directly binding upstream of and controlling more than 100 genes. Again unlike TetR, LuxR functions as both an activator and a repressor, and these two activities can be separated by mutagenesis. Finally, the consensus binding motifs driving LuxR-activated and -repressed genes are distinct. This work shows that LuxR, although structurally similar to TetR, has evolved unique features enabling it to differentially control a large regulon of genes in response to quorum-sensing cues.

Enhanced expression of membrane proteins in E. coli with a P(BAD) promoter mutant: synergies with chaperone pathway engineering strategies

Background

Membrane proteins (MPs) populate 20-30% of genomes sequenced to date and hold potential as therapeutic targets as well as for practical applications in bionanotechnology. However, MP toxicity and low yields in normally robust expression hosts such as E. coli has curtailed progress in our understanding of their structure and function.

Results

Using the seven transmembrane segments H. turkmenica deltarhodopsin (HtdR) as a reporter, we isolated a spontaneous mutant in the arabinose-inducible P_BAD promoter leading to improved cell growth and a twofold increase in the recovery of active HtdR at 37°C. A single transversion in a conserved region of the cyclic AMP receptor protein binding site caused the phenotype by reducing htdR transcript levels by 65%. When the mutant promoter was used in conjunction with a host lacking the molecular chaperone Trigger Factor (Δtig cells), toxicity was further suppressed and the amount of correctly folded HtdR was 4-fold that present in the membranes of control cells. More importantly, while improved growth barely compensated for the reduction in transcription rates when another polytopic membrane protein (N. pharonis sensory rhodopsin II) was expressed under control of the mutant promoter in wild type cells, a 4-fold increase in productivity could be achieved in a Δtig host.

Conclusions

Our system, which combines a downregulated version of the tightly repressed P_BAD promoter with a TF-deficient host may prove a valuable alternative to T7-based expression for the production of membrane proteins that have so far remained elusive targets.

Cyclic AMP receptor protein regulates cspE, an early cold-inducible gene, in Escherichia coli

cspE, a member of the cspA family of cold shock proteins in Escherichia coli, is an early cold-inducible protein. The nucleic acid melting ability and transcription antiterminator activity of CspE have been reported to be critical for growth at low temperature. Here, we show that the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP), a global regulator involved in sugar metabolism, upregulates cspE in E. coli. Sequence analysis of the cspE upstream region revealed a putative CRP target site centered at -61.5 relative to the transcription start. The binding of CRP to this target site was demonstrated using electrophoretic mobility shift assays. The presence of this site was shown to be essential for P(cspE) activation by CRP. Mutational analysis of the binding site indicated that the presence of an intact second core motif is more important than the first core motif for CRP-P(cspE) interaction. Based on the promoter architecture, we classified P(cspE) as a class I CRP-dependent promoter. This was further substantiated by our data demonstrating the involvement of the AR1 domain of CRP in P(cspE) transcription. Furthermore, the substitutions in the key residues of the RNA polymerase α-subunit C-terminal domain (α-CTD), which are important for class I CRP-dependent transcription, showed the involvement of 265 and 287 determinants in P(cspE) transcription. In addition, the deletion of crp led to a growth defect at low temperature, suggesting that CRP plays an important role in cold adaptation.

Point mutations within the streptococcal regulator of virulence (Srv) alter protein-DNA interactions and Srv function

Group A Streptococcus (GAS) possesses a complex regulatory system enabling the organism to colonize a range of physiologically distinct host sites. Within this network of regulators is the streptococcal regulator of virulence (Srv). Srv is a member of the CRP/FNR family of transcriptional regulators and is most similar to pleiotropic regulatory factor A (PrfA), a positive regulator of virulence in Listeria monocytogenes. Members of this family possess a characteristic C-terminal helix-turn-helix motif (HTH) that facilitates binding to DNA targets. Genome scanning identified four targets in GAS that were similar to the consensus DNA target recognized by PrfA. Furthermore, previous amino acid sequence alignments identified conserved residues within the Srv HTH which are necessary for function in PrfA and CRP. Here we investigated the ability of Srv to interact with DNA and evaluated the role of the HTH in this interaction. Purified recombinant Srv (rSrv) was found to co-purify with an untagged form of Srv. Glutaraldehyde cross-linking and gel-filtration chromatography indicated that this co-purification is likely due to the ability of Srv to oligomerize. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSAs) demonstrated that rSrv retarded the mobility of DNA targets and a supershift analysis confirmed the observation was rSrv-dependent. Competition EMSA indicated that rSrv had a higher relative affinity for the DNA targets studied than non-specific DNA. Site-directed mutagenesis of residues predicted to be in or near the HTH resulted in a decrease or abrogation of DNA binding. Complementation of MGAS5005Deltasrv with one of these site-directed mutants failed to restore wild-type SpeB activity. Taken together, these data suggest that the Srv HTH is necessary for DNA binding and Srv function.

Characterization of DNA-binding specificity and analysis of binding sites of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa global regulator, Vfr, a homologue of the Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein

Vfr, a global regulator of Pseudomonas aeruginosa virulence factors, is a homologue of the Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein, CRP. Vfr is 91% similar to CRP and maintains many residues important for CRP to bind cAMP, bind DNA, and interact with RNA polymerase at target promoters. While vfr can complement an E. coli crp mutant in beta-galactosidase production, tryptophanase production and catabolite repression, crp can only complement a subset of Vfr-dependent phenotypes in P. aeruginosa. Using specific CRP binding site mutations, it is shown that Vfr requires the same nucleotides as CRP for optimal transcriptional activity from the E. coli lac promoter. In contrast, CRP did not bind Vfr target sequences in the promoters of the toxA and regA genes. Footprinting analysis revealed Vfr protected sequences upstream of toxA, regA, and the quorum sensing regulator lasR, that are similar to but significantly divergent from the CRP consensus binding sequence, and Vfr causes similar DNA bending to CRP in bound target sequences. Using a preliminary Vfr consensus binding sequence deduced from the Vfr-protected sites, Vfr target sequences were identified upstream of the virulence-associated genes plcN, plcHR, pbpG, prpL and algD, and in the vfr/orfX, argH/fimS, pilM/ponA intergenic regions. From these sequences the Vfr consensus binding sequence, 5'-ANWWTGNGAWNY : AGWTCACAT-3', was formulated. This study suggests that Vfr shares many of the same functions as CRP, but has specialized functions, at least in terms of DNA target sequence binding, required for regulation of a subset of genes in its regulon.

Indirect readout of DNA sequence at the primary-kink site in the CAP-DNA complex: alteration of DNA binding specificity through alteration of DNA kinking

The catabolite activator protein (CAP) sharply bends DNA in the CAP-DNA complex, introducing a DNA kink, with a roll angle of approximately 40 degrees and a twist angle of approximately 20 degrees, between positions 6 and 7 of the DNA half-site, 5'-A(1)A(2)A(3)T(4)G(5)T(6)G(7)A(8)T(9)C(10)T(11)-3' ("primary kink"). CAP recognizes the base-pair immediately 5' to the primary-kink site, T:A(6), through an "indirect-readout" mechanism involving sequence effects on the energetics of primary-kink formation. CAP recognizes the base-pair immediately 3' to the primary-kink site, G:C(7), through a "direct-readout" mechanism involving formation of a hydrogen bond between Glu181 of CAP and G:C(7). Here, we report that substitution of the carboxylate side-chain of Glu181 of CAP by the one-methylene-group-shorter carboxylate side-chain of Asp changes DNA binding specificity at position 6 of the DNA half site, changing specificity for T:A(6) to specificity for C:G(6), and we report a crystallographic analysis defining the structural basis of the change in specificity. The Glu181-->Asp substitution eliminates the primary kink and thus eliminates indirect-readout-based specificity for T:A(6). The Glu181-->Asp substitution does not eliminate hydrogen-bond formation with G:C(7), and thus does not eliminate direct-readout-based specificity for G:C(7).

Mutational analysis of conserved residues in the putative DNA-binding domain of the response regulator Spo0A of Bacillus subtilis

The Spo0A protein of Bacillus subtilis is a DNA-binding protein that is required for the expression of genes involved in the initiation of sporulation. Spo0A binds directly to and both activates and represses transcription from the promoters of several genes required during the onset of endospore formation. The C-terminal 113 residues are known to contain the DNA-binding activity of Spo0A. Previous studies identified a region of the C-terminal half of Spo0A that is highly conserved among species of endospore-forming Bacillus and Clostridium and which encodes a putative helix-turn-helix DNA-binding domain. To test the functional significance of this region and determine if this motif is involved in DNA binding, we changed three conserved residues, S210, E213, and R214, to Gly and/or Ala by site-directed mutagenesis. We then isolated and analyzed the five substitution-containing Spo0A proteins for DNA binding and sporulation-specific gene activation. The S210A Spo0A mutant exhibited no change from wild-type binding, although it was defective in spoIIA and spoIIE promoter activation. In contrast, both the E213G and E213A Spo0A variants showed decreased binding and completely abolished transcriptional activation of spoIIA and spoIIE, while the R214G and R214A variants completely abolished both DNA binding and transcriptional activation. These data suggest that these conserved residues are important for transcriptional activation and that the E213 residue is involved in DNA binding.

Altering the DNA-binding specificity of Mu transposase in vitro

We describe the isolation of a variant of Mu transposase (MuA protein) which can recognize altered att sites at the ends of Mu DNA. No prior knowledge of the structure of the DNA binding domain or its mode of interaction with att DNA was necessary to obtain this variant. Protein secondary structure programs initially helped target mutations to predicted helical regions within a subdomain of MuA demonstrated to harbor att DNA binding activity. Of the 54 mutant positions examined, only two showed decreased affinity for att DNA, while eight others affected assembly of the Mu transpososome. A variant impaired in DNA binding [MuA(R146V)], and predicted to be in the recognition helix of an HTH motif, was challenged with altered att sites created from degenerate oligonucleotides to select for novel DNA binding specificity. DNA sequences bound to MuA(R146V) were detected by gel-retardation, and following several steps of PCR amplification/enrichment, were identified by cloning and sequencing. The strategy allowed recovery of an altered att site for which MuA(R146V) showed higher affinity than for the wild-type site, although this site was bound by wild-type MuA as well. The altered association between MuA(R146V) and an altered att site target was competent in transposition. We discuss the strengths and limitations of this methodology, which has applications in dissecting the functional role of specific protein-DNA associations.

A single substitution in the putative helix-turn-helix motif of the pleiotropic activator PrfA attenuates Listeria monocytogenes virulence

PrfA, the regulator of virulence-gene expression in the pathogenic bacterium Listeria monocytogenes, displays sequence similarity to members of the CAP-FNR family of transcriptional regulators. To test the functional significance of this similarity, we constructed and analysed substitutions of two amino acids of PrfA predicted to contact DNA, i.e. Ser-184 and Ser-183. Substitution of Ser-184 by Ala reduced DNA binding and virulence-gene activation, and attenuated the virulence in a mouse model of infection. In contrast, substitution of Ser-183 by Ala had the opposite effect in these functional assays. A 17bp DNA sequence, which includes a putative PrfA site, was shown to be sufficient for target-site recognition by PrfA and PrfA-S183A. Our results strongly support the hypothesis that PrfA is a structural and functional homologue of CAP. In addition, they establish a clear correlation between DNA binding by PrfA, virulence-gene activation, and virulence.

The vfr gene product, required for Pseudomonas aeruginosa exotoxin A and protease production, belongs to the cyclic AMP receptor protein family

The synthesis of exotoxin A (ETA) by Pseudomonas aeruginosa is a complex, regulated event. Several ETA putative regulatory mutants of P. aeruginosa PA103 have previously been characterized (S. E. H. West, S. A. Kaye, A. N. Hamood, and B. H. Iglewski, Infect. Immun. 62:897-903, 1994). In addition to ETA production, these mutants, PA103-15, PA103-16, and PA103-19, were also deficient in the production of protease and in regA P1 promoter activity. RegA is a positive regulator of ETA transcription. We cloned a gene, designated vfr for virulence factor regulator, that restored ETA and protease production to parental levels in these mutants. In addition, transcription from the regA P1 promoter was restored. In Escherichia coli, when vfr was overexpressed from a phage T7 promoter, a protein with an apparent molecular mass of 28.5 kDa was produced. Analysis of the deduced amino acid sequence of vfr revealed that the expected protein is 67% identical and 91% similar over a 202-amino-acid overlap to the E. coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP or Crp). The cloned vfr gene complemented the beta-galactosidase- and tryptophanase-deficient phenotypes of E. coli RZ1331, a crp deletion mutant. However, the E. coli crp gene under the control of the tac promoter did not complement the ETA-deficient or protease-deficient phenotype of PA103-15 or PA103-16. The ability of vfr to restore both ETA and protease production to these mutants suggests that vfr is a global regulator of virulence factor expression in P. aeruginosa.

Stereochemical basis of DNA recognition by Zn fingers

DNA-recognition rules for Zn fingers are discussed in terms of crystal structures. The rules can explain the DNA-binding characteristics of a number of Zn finger proteins for which there are no crystal structures. The rules have two parts: chemical rules, which list the possible pairings between the 4 DNA bases and the 20 amino acid residues, and stereochemical rules, which describe the specific base positions contacted by several amino acid positions in the Zn finger. It is discussed that to maintain the correct binding geometry, in which the N-terminus of the recognition helix is closer to the DNA than the C-terminus, the residues facing the DNA on the helix must be larger near the C-terminus, and that two different types of fingers (A and B) bind to DNA in distinctly different ways and cover different numbers of base pairs.

Identification of C/EBP basic region residues involved in DNA sequence recognition and half-site spacing preference

C/EBP and GCN4 are basic region-leucine zipper (bZIP) DNA-binding proteins that recognize the dyad-symmetric sequences ATTGCGCAAT and ATGAGTCAT, respectively. The sequence specificities of these and other bZIP proteins are determined by their alpha-helical basic regions, which are related at the primary sequence level. To identify amino acids that are responsible for the different DNA sequence specificities of C/EBP and GCN4, two kinds of hybrid proteins were constructed: GCN4-C/EBP chimeras fused at various positions in the basic region and substitution mutants in which GCN4 basic region amino acids were replaced by the corresponding residues from C/EBP. On the basis of the DNA-binding characteristics of these hybrid proteins, three residues that contribute significantly to the differences in C/EBP and GCN4 binding specificity were defined. These residues are clustered along one face of the basic region alpha helix. Two of these specificity residues were not identified as DNA-contacting amino acids in a recently reported crystal structure of a GCN4-DNA complex, suggesting that the residues used by C/EBP and GCN4 to make base contacts are not identical. A random binding site selection procedure also was used to define the optimal recognition sequences for three of the GCN4-C/EBP fusion proteins. These experiments identify an element spanning the hinge region between the basic region and leucine zipper domains that dictates optimal half-site spacing (either directly abutted for C/EBP or overlapping by one base pair for GCN4) in high-affinity binding sites for these two proteins.

Identification of C/EBP basic region residues involved in DNA sequence recognition and half-site spacing preference

C/EBP and GCN4 are basic region-leucine zipper (bZIP) DNA-binding proteins that recognize the dyad-symmetric sequences ATTGCGCAAT and ATGAGTCAT, respectively. The sequence specificities of these and other bZIP proteins are determined by their alpha-helical basic regions, which are related at the primary sequence level. To identify amino acids that are responsible for the different DNA sequence specificities of C/EBP and GCN4, two kinds of hybrid proteins were constructed: GCN4-C/EBP chimeras fused at various positions in the basic region and substitution mutants in which GCN4 basic region amino acids were replaced by the corresponding residues from C/EBP. On the basis of the DNA-binding characteristics of these hybrid proteins, three residues that contribute significantly to the differences in C/EBP and GCN4 binding specificity were defined. These residues are clustered along one face of the basic region alpha helix. Two of these specificity residues were not identified as DNA-contacting amino acids in a recently reported crystal structure of a GCN4-DNA complex, suggesting that the residues used by C/EBP and GCN4 to make base contacts are not identical. A random binding site selection procedure also was used to define the optimal recognition sequences for three of the GCN4-C/EBP fusion proteins. These experiments identify an element spanning the hinge region between the basic region and leucine zipper domains that dictates optimal half-site spacing (either directly abutted for C/EBP or overlapping by one base pair for GCN4) in high-affinity binding sites for these two proteins.

Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein mutants provide evidence for ligand contacts important in activation

The three-dimensional model of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP (cAMP) receptor protein (CRP) shows that several amino acids are involved as chemical contacts for binding cAMP. We have constructed and characterized mutants at four of these positions, E72, R82, S83, and R123. The mutations were made in wild-type crp as well as a cAMP-independent crp, crp*. The activities of the mutant proteins were characterized in vivo for their ability to activate the lac operon. These results provide genetic evidence to support that E72 and R82 are essential and S83 and R123 are important in the activation of CRP by cAMP.

Incorporation of an EDTA-metal complex at a rationally selected site within a protein: application to EDTA-iron DNA affinity cleaving with catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) and Cro

We have developed a simple procedure to incorporate an EDTA-metal complex at a rationally selected site within a full-length protein. Our procedure has two steps: In step 1, we use site-directed mutagenesis to introduce a unique solvent-accessible cysteine residue at the site of interest. In step 2, we derivatize the resulting protein with S-(2-pyridylthio)cysteaminyl-EDTA-metal, a novel aromatic disulfide derivative of EDTA-metal. We have used this procedure to incorporate an EDTA-iron complex at amino acid 2 of the helix-turn-helix motif of each of two helix-turn-helix motif sequence-specific DNA binding proteins, catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) and Cro, and we have analyzed EDTA-iron-mediated DNA affinity cleavage by the resulting protein derivatives. The CAP derivative cleaves DNA at base pair 2 of the DNA half-site in the protein-DNA complex, and the Cro derivative cleaves DNA at base pairs -3 to 5 of the DNA half-site in the protein-DNA complex. We infer that amino acid 2 of the helix-turn-helix motif of CAP is close to base pair 2 of the DNA half-site in the CAP-DNA complex in solution and that amino acid 2 of the helix-turn-helix motif of Cro is close to base pairs -3 to 5 of the DNA half-site in the Cro-DNA complex in solution.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Specific binding of cyclic-AMP receptor protein to DNA. Effect of the sequence and of the introduction of a nick in the binding site

The binding of Escherichia coli Cyclic AMP Receptor Protein (CRP) to several DNA fragments of about 45 base pairs, bearing the natural lactose or galactose sites, as well as several synthetic related sites, was investigated using fluorescence spectroscopy and gel retardation experiments. The salt dependence of the equilibrium binding constant indicates that CRP makes an identical number of ion pairs with the lac, lacL8 and gal sites although the binding constants are drastically different. However increasing the symmetry of the gal site leads to an increase of the number of ion pairs between the protein and the DNA. A single strand nick was introduced at the centre of a symmetrized gal site and this reduces the binding energy of CRP by about 0.6 Kcal. These results are discussed with respect to the bending constraints imposed on the DNA by the binding of CRP. The results are in agreement with the recently published crystal structure of the CRP complexed with DNA [Schutz, S.C., Shields, G.C. and Steitz, T.A., Science 253, 1001-1007 (1991)] showing that the 90 degrees bending of the DNA in the complex results from two kinks.

DNA binding specificity and sequence of Xanthomonas campestris catabolite gene activator protein-like protein

The Xanthomonas campestris catabolite gene activator protein-like protein (CLP) can substitute for the Escherichia coli catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) in transcription activation at the lac promoter (V. de Crecy-Lagard, P. Glaser, P. Lejeune, O. Sismeiro, C. Barber, M. Daniels, and A. Danchin, J. Bacteriol. 172:5877-5883, 1990). We show that CLP has the same DNA binding specificity as CAP at positions 5, 6, and 7 of the DNA half site. In addition, we show that the amino acids at positions 1 and 2 of the recognition helix of CLP are identical to the amino acids at positions 1 and 2 of the recognition helix of CAP:i.e., Arg at position 1 and Glu at position 2.

A model of the lac repressor-operator complex based on physical and genetic data

Computer graphics were used to build a molecular model of the complex of Lac repressor and lac operator. The model is based (a) on the NMR data of the Kaptein group [Boelens, R., Lamerichs, R. M. J. N., Rullmann, J. A. C., van Boom, J. H. & Kaptein, R. (1988) Protein Sequence Data Anal. 1, 487-498] and (b) on our genetic and biochemical data including specificity changes [Lehming, N., Sartorius, J., Kisters-Woike, B., von Wilcken-Bergmann, B. & Müller-Hill, B. (1990) EMBO J. 9, 615-621]. Effects of amino acid exchanges in the recognition helix could be predicted by the model and were subsequently tested and confirmed by genetic experiments. Comparison of the modelled lac complex with the known crystallographic structures of several helix-turn-helix DNA complexes reveals striking similarities and suggests rules which govern the recognition between particular amino acid side chains and particular base pairs in these systems.

DNA-sequence recognition by CAP: role of the adenine N6 atom of base pair 6 of the DNA site

Two similar, but not identical, models have been proposed for the amino acid-base pair contacts in the CAP-DNA complex ('Model I,' Weber, I. and Steitz, T., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 81, 3973-3977, 1984; 'Model II,' Ebright, et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 81, 7274-7278, 1984). One difference between the two models involves Glu181 of CAP. Model I predicts that Glu181 of CAP makes two specificity determining contacts: one H-bond with the cytosine N4 atom of G:C at base pair 7 of the DNA half site, and one H-bond with the adenine N6 atom of T:A at base pair 6 of the DNA half site. In contrast, Model II predicts that Glu181 makes only one specificity determining contact: one H-bond with the cytosine N4 atom of G:C at base pair 7 of the DNA half site. In the present work, we show that replacement of T:A at base pair 6 of the DNA half site by T:N6-methyl-adenine has no, or almost no, effect on the binding of CAP. We conclude, contrary to Model I, that Glu181 of CAP makes no contact with the adenine N6 atom of base pair 6 of the DNA half site.

Interconversion of the DNA-binding specificities of two related transcription regulators, CRP and FNR

In Escherichia coli, FNR and CRP are homologous transcriptional regulators which recognize similar nucleotide sequences via DNA-binding domains containing analogous helix-turn-helix motifs. The molecular basis for recognition and discrimination of their target sites has been investigated by directed amino acid substitutions in the corresponding DNA-recognition helices. In FNR, Glu-209 and Ser-212 are essential residues for the recognition of FNR sites. A V208R substitution confers CRP-site specificity without loss of FNR specificity, but this has adverse effects on anaerobic growth. In contrast, changes at two (V208R and E209D) or three (V208R, S212G and G216K) positions in FNR endow a single CRP-site binding specificity. In reciprocal experiments, two substitutions (R180V and G184S) were required to convert the binding specificity of CRP to that of FNR. Altering Asp-199 in FNR failed to produce a positive control phenotype, unlike substitutions at the comparable site in CRP. Implications for the mechanism of sequence discrimination by FNR and CRP are discussed.

Molecular genetic analysis of an FNR-dependent anaerobically inducible Escherichia coli promoter

From the effects of 13 deletions and three linker-scanner mutations at the Escherichia coli nirB promoter we have located sequences necessary for FNR-dependent induction of activity by anaerobiosis and further nitrite-dependent stimulation of expression. We describe a nirB promoter derivative that allows the cloning of 'cassettes' carrying different FNR-binding sequences and experiments in which a number of point mutations were introduced into these sequences. FNR-dependent stimulation of expression from the nirB promoter is critically dependent on the location of the FNR-binding site, and deletion or insertion of one base pair is sufficient to disrupt promoter function. We have transferred a number of cassette FNR-binding sequences from the nirB promoter to the unrelated melR promoter. The insertion of FNR-binding sequences at the melR promoter is sufficient to confer fnr-dependency on expression. However expression from these hybrid promoters is not as efficiently repressed during aerobic growth, suggesting that the function of bound FNR is dependent on the sequence context of the FNR-binding sequence.

Site-directed mutagenesis of a catabolite repression operator sequence in Bacillus subtilis

Catabolite repression of the Bacillus subtilis alpha-amylase gene (amyE) involves an operator sequence located just downstream of the promoter (amyR), overlapping the transcription start site. Oligonucleotide site-directed mutagenesis of this sequence identified bases required for catabolite repression. Two mutations increased both the 2-fold symmetry of the operator and the repression ratio. Although many mutations reduced the repression ratio 3- to 11-fold, some also caused a 2-fold or greater increase in amylase production. Others caused hyperproduction without affecting catabolite repression. Homologous sequences in other catabolite-repressed B. subtilis promoters suggest a common regulatory site may be involved in catabolite repression.

Identification of a contact between arginine-180 of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) and base pair 5 of the DNA site in the CAP-DNA complex

We have used site-directed mutagenesis to replace amino acid 1 of the recognition alpha-helix of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP), Arg-180, with glycine and with alanine. Substitution of Arg-180 of CAP eliminated specificity between G.C, A.T, C.G, and T.A at base pair 5 of the DNA half-site. The effect was position-specific: substitution of Arg-180 did not eliminate specificity between G.C, A.T, C.G, and T.A at base pair 7 of the DNA half-site. We conclude, in agreement with the model for the structure of the CAP-DNA complex [Weber, I. & Steitz, T. (1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 3973-3977; and Ebright, R., Cossart, P., Gicquel-Sanzey, B. & Beckwith, J. (1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 7274-7278], that Arg-180 of CAP makes a specificity-determining contact with base pair 5 of the DNA half-site in the CAP-DNA complex. The identification of the contact by Arg-180 in this report, in conjunction with the identification of the contact by Glu-181 in a previous report [Ebright, R., Cossart, P., Gicquel-Sanzey, B. & Beckwith, J. (1984) Nature (London) 311, 232-235], provides information sufficient to define the orientation of the helix-turn-helix motif of CAP with respect to DNA in the CAP-DNA complex.

Lysine 188 of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) plays no role in specificity at base pair 7 of the DNA half site

Two similar, but not identical, models have been proposed for the amino acid-base pair contacts in the CAP-DNA complex ('model I,' Weber, I. and Steitz, T., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 81, 3973-3977, 1984; 'model II,' Ebright, et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 81, 7274-7278, 1984). The most important difference between the two models involves Lys188 of CAP. Model I predicts that Lys188 of CAP makes a specificity determining contact with base pair 7 of the DNA half site. In contrast, model II predicts that Lys188 makes no contact with base pair 7 of the DNA half site. In the present work, we have used site-directed mutagenesis to replace Lys188 of CAP by Asn, an amino acid unable to make the putative contact. We have assessed the specificities of the following proteins, both in vitro and in vivo: wild-type CAP, [Asn188]CAP, [Val181]CAP, and [Val181;Asn188]CAP. The results indicate that Lys188 makes no contribution to specificity at base pair 7 of the DNA half site. We propose, contrary to model I, that Lys188 makes no contact with base pair 7 of the DNA half site.

Transcriptional regulation of the cytR repressor gene of Escherichia coli: autoregulation and positive control by the cAMP/CAP complex

The Escherichia coli cytR-encoded repressor protein (CytR) controls the expression of several genes involved in nucleoside and deoxynucleoside uptake and metabolism. The cytR promoter was identified by determining the transcriptional initiation site of the cytR gene. A chromosomal cytR-lacZ+ operon fusion was isolated and used to study the regulation of cytR. We show that cytR expression is negatively controlled by the CytR protein and positively affected by the cAMP/CAP complex. Footprinting studies with purified CAP protein revealed two CAP binding sites upstream of the cytR promoter. A previously described mutation (cytR*) in the cloned cytR gene, which results in the phenotypic suppression of a CytR operator mutation in the tsx P2 promoter, was analysed. DNA sequence analysis of the cytR* mutation revealed a G-C to an A-T base pair transition at position -34 bp relative to the translational initiation site of cytR. This point mutation activates a cryptic promoter that is stronger than the wild-type cytR promoter and leads to overproduction of the CytR repressor.

Consensus DNA site for the Escherichia coli catabolite gene activator protein (CAP): CAP exhibits a 450-fold higher affinity for the consensus DNA site than for the E. coli lac DNA site

We have synthesized two 40 base pair DNA fragments; one fragment contains the consensus DNA site for CAP (fragment 'ICAP'); the other fragment contains the E. coli lac promoter DNA site for CAP (fragment 'LCAP'). We have investigated the binding of CAP to the two DNA fragments using the nitrocellulose filter binding assay. Under standard conditions [( NaCl] = 200 mM, pH = 7.3), CAP exhibits a 450-fold higher affinity for ICAP than for LCAP. The salt dependence of the binding equilibrium indicates that CAP makes eight ion pairs with ICAP, but only six ion pairs with LCAP. Approximately half of the difference in binding free energy for interaction of CAP with ICAP vs. LCAP is attributable to this difference in ion-pair formation. The pH dependence of the binding equilibrium indicates that the eight CAP-ICAP ion pairs and the six CAP-LCAP ion pairs do not involve His residues of CAP.

Model-building of Fnr and FixK DNA-binding domains suggests a basis for specific DNA recognition

The DNA-binding C-terminal domains of the regulatory proteins Fnr from Escherichia coli and FixK from Rhizobium meliloti have been modelled on the basis of their homologies to the CAP protein from E. coli. Residues Glu181, Thr182 and Arg185 of CAP, which are exposed residues of the DNA-recognition helix alpha F, are conserved in Fnr and FixK. However, Arg180 and Gly184 are substituted by Val and Ser respectively in Fnr. We propose that this valine makes a Van der Waals' contact with the first thymine in the Fnr consensus TTGA-N6-TCAA, and that the serine contributes to the binding by displacing a thymine-bound water molecule. The corresponding residues in FixK, Ile and Ser allow the same interactions with a thymine. Therefore we predict that FixK may recognize the same sites as Fnr. This is supported experimentally by showing that Fnr can substitute for FixK in activating the fixN gene in E. coli.

Binding of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein to DNA fragments containing consensus nucleotide sequences

Binding of the Escherichia coli CRP protein to DNA fragments carrying nucleotide sequences closely corresponding to the consensus is very tight with a dissociation time of over 2 h in our conditions. The concentration of cyclic AMP required for this binding is below the physiological range of intracellular cyclic AMP concentrations. Changes in nucleotide sequence at positions that are not well-conserved between different naturally-occurring CRP sites allow a more rapid dissociation of CRP-DNA complexes. There is an inverse correlation between the stability of CRP binding to sites in vitro and the repression by glucose of expression dependent on these sites in vivo: expression that is dependent on the tighter binding sites cannot be repressed by the inclusion of glucose in the growth medium.

Mutational analysis of the lac regulatory region: second-site changes that activate mutant promoters

Second-site mutations that restored activity to severe lacP1 down-promoter mutants were isolated. This was accomplished by using a bacteriophage f1 vector containing a fusion of the mutant E. coli lac promoters with the structural gene for chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT), so that a system was provided for selecting phage revertants (or pseudorevertants) that conferred resistance of phage-infected cells to chloramphenicol. Among the second-site changes that relieved defects in mutant lac promoters, the only one that restored lacP1 activity was a T----G substitution at position -14, a weakly conserved site in E. coli promoters. Three other sequence changes, G----A at -2, A----T at +1, and C----A at +10, activated nascent promoters in the lac regulatory region. The nascent promoters conformed to the consensus rule, that activity is gained by sequence changes toward homology with consensus sequences at the -35 and -10 regions of the promoter. However, the relative activities of some promoters cannot be explained solely by consideration of their conserved sequence elements.

Cloning of binding sequences for the Escherichia coli transcription activators, FNR and CRP: location of bases involved in discrimination between FNR and CRP

Expression from the E.coli melR promoter (pmelR) is normally totally dependent on the transcription activator protein, CRP. We describe experiments with a genetically engineered DNA fragment carrying pmelR in which the wild type CRP binding site was replaced with synthetic oligonucleotides containing either FNR or CRP binding sequences. When the synthetic oligonucleotide contains the 22 bp consensus for FNR binding sites, expression from pmelR is dependent on FNR but not CRP. Single changes at either of two symmetrically-related positions create sites that are recognised by both FNR and CRP. Changes at both positions result in a site that is not recognised by FNR but which binds CRP tightly.

Recognition helices of lac and lambda repressor are oriented in opposite directions and recognize similar DNA sequences

Exchanges in positions 1 and 2 of the putative recognition helix allow lac repressor to bind to ideal lac operator variants in which base pair 4 has been replaced. We show here that an Arg-22----Asn exchange in position 6 of the putative recognition helix of lac repressor abolishes lac repressor binding to ideal lac operator. This lac repressor variant, however, binds to a variant of the ideal lac operator 5' TTTGAGCGCTCAAA 3' in which the original G.C of position 6 has been replaced by T.A. This result and our previous data confirm our suggestion that the N terminus of the recognition helix of lac repressor enters the major groove close to the center of symmetry of lac operator and that its C terminus leaves the major groove further away from the center of symmetry. The consequences of this model are discussed in regard to various phage and bacterial repressor operator systems.

Crystal structure of trp repressor/operator complex at atomic resolution

The crystal structure of the trp repressor/operator complex shows an extensive contact surface, including 24 direct and 6 solvent-mediated hydrogen bonds to the phosphate groups of the DNA. There are no direct hydrogen bonds or non-polar contacts to the bases that can explain the repressor's specificity for the operator sequence. Rather, the sequence seems to be recognized indirectly through its effects on the geometry of the phosphate backbone, which in turn permits the formation of a stable interface. Water-mediated polar contacts to the bases also appear to contribute part of the specificity.

Alterations in the binding site of the cyclic AMP receptor protein at the Escherichia coli galactose operon regulatory region

Gene manipulation techniques have been used to alter the binding site for the cyclic AMP-cyclic AMP receptor protein complex (cAMP-CRP) at the regulatory region of the Escherichia coli galactose (gal) operon. The effects of these changes on CRP-dependent stimulation of expression from the galP1 promoter in vivo have been measured, and gel binding assays have been used to measure the affinity of cAMP-CRP for the modified sites. Firstly we have deleted progressively longer sequences from upstream of the gal CRP site in order to locate the functional limit of the site. A deletion to -49, removing the first base that corresponds to the consensus sequence for a CRP binding site, is sufficient to reduce CRP binding and block CRP-dependent stimulation of P1. Secondly, we used synthetic oligonucleotides to invert the asymmetric nucleotide sequence at the gal CRP binding site or to make the sequence symmetric. Inversion of the site has little effect on CRP binding, the architecture of open complexes at P1 revealed by DNAase I footprinting, or the stimulation of transcription from P1. Making the site symmetric increases the affinity for CRP by over 50-fold and leads to increased transcription from P1, whilst hardly altering the DNAase I footprint of open complexes. Our results confirm that the strength of binding of CRP depends on the nature of the site and show that it is this that principally accounts for differences in CRP-dependent stimulation of transcription.

A mutant crp allele that differentially activates the operons of the fuc regulon in Escherichia coli

L-Fucose is used by Escherichia coli through an inducible pathway mediated by a fucP-encoded permease, a fucI-encoded isomerase, a fucK-encoded kinase, and a fucA-encoded aldolase. The adolase catalyzes the formation of dihydroxyacetone phosphate and L-lactaldehyde. Anaerobically, lactaldehyde is converted by a fucO-encoded oxidoreductase to L-1,2-propanediol, which is excreted. The fuc genes belong to a regulon comprising four linked operons: fucO, fucA, fucPIK, and fucR. The positive regulator encoded by fucR responds to fuculose 1-phosphate as the effector. Mutants serially selected for aerobic growth on propanediol became constitutive in fucO and fucA [fucO(Con) fucA(Con)], but noninducible in fucPIK [fucPIK(Non)]. An external suppressor mutation that restored growth on fucose caused constitutive expression of fucPIK. Results from this study indicate that this suppressor mutation occurred in crp, which encodes the cyclic AMP-binding (or receptor) protein. When the suppressor allele (crp-201) was transduced into wild-type strains, the recipient became fucose negative and fucose sensitive (with glycerol as the carbon and energy source) because of impaired expression of fucA. The fucPIK operon became hyperinducible. The growth rate on maltose was significantly reduced, but growth on L-rhamnose, D-galactose, L-arabinose, glycerol, or glycerol 3-phosphate was close to normal. Lysogenization of fuc+ crp-201 cells by a lambda bacteriophage bearing crp+ restored normal growth ability on fucose. In contrast, lysogenization of [fucO(Con)fucA(Con)fucPIK(Non)crp-201] cells by the same phage retarded their growth on fucose.

Mutants of the catabolite activator protein of Escherichia coli that are specifically deficient in the gene-activation function

In the presence of cyclic AMP, the catabolite activator protein (CAP) of Escherichia coli binds DNA and stimulates transcription at a number of promoters. We have examined a model of CAP bound at the gal promoter and, using directed mutagenesis, have isolated CAP mutants that are analogous to the lambda repressor positive control (pc) mutants. These CAP mutants bind DNA but are defective in stimulating transcription at the gal P1 promoter. These mutants are also altered in positive control at the lac and malT promoters, where CAP binds to sites further upstream from the transcription start site.

Efficient Tn10 transposition into a DNA insertion hot spot in vivo requires the 5-methyl groups of symmetrically disposed thymines within the hot-spot consensus sequence

Transposon Tn10 inserts preferentially at particular insertion "hot spots" that share a symmetrical 6-base-pair consensus sequence: 5' GCTNAGC 3'. The protein that recognizes this sequence is not known but is likely to be the Tn10-encoded transposase protein. We present evidence that the 5-methyl groups of the two thymines in this sequence are essential for efficient transposon insertion; in their absence the sequence is still recognized, but at lower efficiency. We have reached this conclusion by examination of a specific hot spot whose sequence is 5' GCCAGGC 3'. The innermost cytosines of this sequence happen to be substrates for methylation at their 5 positions by the bacterial dcm-encoded methylase. We find that Tn10 transposes into this site 15 times more frequently in a Dcm+ host than in a Dcm- host; in the Dcm- host, insertions still occur, but at a low frequency. Thus, at this site, the absence of pyrimidine 5-methyl groups at the third positions of the consensus sequence is sufficient to convert a strong insertion hot spot into a weaker but still recognizable hot spot. This observation supports the general proposition, suggested previously by comparisons among consensus sequences, that the presence or absence of these 5-methyl groups is one major feature that can make the difference between a strong and a weak Tn10 insertion hot spot.

Role of glutamic acid-181 in DNA-sequence recognition by the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) of Escherichia coli: altered DNA-sequence-recognition properties of [Val181]CAP and [Leu181]CAP

It has been proposed that Glu-181 of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) makes direct contact with certain base pairs of the specific DNA site. We have purified wild-type CAP and two substituted CAP variants, [Val181]CAP and [Leu181]CAP, and have assessed the DNA-sequence-recognition properties in vitro with respect to positions 5, 6, 7, 8, and 16 of the DNA site. The data indicate that [Val181]CAP and [Leu181]CAP fail to discriminate between the consensus DNA base pair and the three non-consensus-DNA base pairs at 2-fold-related positions 7 and 16 of the DNA site. In contrast, [Val181]CAP and [Leu181]CAP retain the ability to discriminate between different base pairs at positions 5 and 8 of the DNA site. We conclude that Glu-181 of CAP makes a direct contact with 2-fold-related positions 7 and 16 of the DNA site, as proposed previously based on in vivo results. We propose that upon replacement of Glu-181 by valine or leucine, this contact is eliminated and is replaced by no other functional contact. We estimate that the contact by Glu-181 with each position contributes -0.7 kcal/mol to the total CAP-DNA binding free energy.

The binding of the cyclic AMP receptor protein to synthetic DNA sites containing permutations in the consensus sequence TGTGA

The binding of the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) to symmetrical synthetic DNA-binding sites was investigated with a gel-retardation assay. A set of ten different sequences was employed, comprising all base permutations at positions 2, 4, and 5 of the consensus sequence 5'(TGTGA)3'. We show that: (i) CRP has a higher affinity for the completely symmetrical site than towards the lac wild-type site; (ii) base substitutions at position 2 lead to either a complete loss of specific CRP binding (G----C), a reduction in specific CRP binding (G----A) or only marginal effects on specific CRP binding (G----T); (iii) changes at position 4 abolish (G----C; G----A) or reduce (G----T) specific CRP binding; and (iv) base permutations at position 5 reduce specific CRP binding, but never completely abolish it. Thus position 4, and to a lesser extent position 2, in the DNA consensus sequence are the most crucial ones for specific binding by CRP.

Activation of the lac operon of Escherichia coli by a mutant FNR protein

The FNR protein of E. coli is a transcriptional activator required for the expression of genes involved in anaerobic respiratory pathways. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to alter three amino acids in the recognition helix of the putative DNA-binding domain of FNR, with the aim of changing its specificity to that of the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP). In the presence of the mutant protein (FNR-215) expression of the lac operon was activated during anaerobiosis and unaffected by glucose. FNR-215 did not have a uniform effect on the expression of other cAMP-CRP-dependent genes, but the results demonstrate the fundamental similarity between FNR- and CRP-mediated transcriptional activation.

Probing the sequence-specific interaction of the cyclic AMP receptor protein with DNA by site-directed mutagenesis

Mutants in the DNA-binding helix of the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP), as well as mutants in a synthetic DNA-binding site derived from the sequence in the lac regulatory region, have been constructed by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis, and used to study the effect of selected amino acid substitutions on CRP-mediated transcriptional activity and on sequence-specific DNA binding. It has been shown that mutation of Arg-180 to Lys or Leu abolishes both CRP-mediated expression of beta-galactosidase in vivo and CRP binding of DNA as measured by immunoprecipitation. In contrast, the mutation of Arg-185 to Leu or Lys and the mutation of Lys-188 to Leu does not appear to influence these two parameters significantly. On the DNA side, both substitutions studied, namely the exchange of the G . C base pair in position 2 of the consensus T1G2T3G4A5 motif into an A . T base pair and the exchange of the A . T base pair in position 5 for a G . C base pair, abolish specific binding. Implications of these findings with respect to the present models for specific CRP-DNA recognition are discussed.

crp genes of Shigella flexneri, Salmonella typhimurium, and Escherichia coli

The complete nucleotide sequences of the Salmonella typhimurium LT2 and Shigella flexneri 2B crp genes were determined and compared with those of the Escherichia coli K-12 crp gene. The Shigella flexneri gene was almost like the E. coli crp gene, with only four silent base pair changes. The S. typhimurium and E. coli crp genes presented a higher degree of divergence in their nucleotide sequence with 77 changes, but the corresponding amino acid sequences presented only one amino acid difference. The nucleotide sequences of the crp genes diverged to the same extent as in the other genes, trp, ompA, metJ, and araC, which are structural or regulatory genes. An analysis of the amino acid divergence, however, revealed that the catabolite gene activator protein, the crp gene product, is the most conserved protein observed so far. Comparison of codon usage in S. typhimurium and E. coli for all genes sequenced in both organisms showed that their patterns were similar. Comparison of the regulatory regions of the S. typhimurium and E. coli crp genes showed that the most conserved sequences were those known to be essential for the expression of E. coli crp.