Single-cell studies on hapten-specific B cells: response to T-cell-dependent antigens

A significant proportion of normal resting B cells are induced to secrete immunoglobulin through contact with anti-receptor antibody-activated helper T cells in clonal cultures

This report describes single-cell techniques to address the nature of a cellular interaction in which activated T lymphocytes stimulate small resting B cells to develop into antibody-forming cell clones in the absence of any surface immunoglobulin ligand or an antigen bridge. The cloned T helper cell line E9.D4 was stimulated with the anti-V beta 8 antibody F23.1 bound to the plastic of Terasaki 10-ul culture wells. When an excess of T helper lymphocytes was used (1,000 X-irradiated or 600 unirradiated, stimulated E9.D4 cells), 10-25% of B cells responded by antibody formation as judged by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay performed after 5 days of culture. When one of a very small number of B cells were present, the rate-limiting step to antibody-forming cell formation was the number of T cells present. Far fewer T cells sufficed for stimulation when culture trays were tilted to force T and B cells into proximity at the sulcus formed at the bottom edge of the culture wells. When T cell numbers were limiting, unirradiated T cells out-performed irradiated T cells. Some cell clones held for 7 days switched to IgG antibody production. E9.D4 supernatants were virtually ineffective in causing B cell stimulation, even when 3T3 filler cells were added to support cultures. The results suggest that cell contact, and perhaps conjugate formation, with a strongly activated T cell can cause changes in the adjacent resting B cells akin to those of Ig receptor cross-linking, following which a lymphokine flux (even one not involving IL 4 and 5) promotes antibody-forming cell development.

T-independent activation of single B cells: an orderly analysis of overlapping stages in the activation pathway

This review has three chief purposes. It describes a microculture system in which single, hapten-specific B lymphocytes can be microscopically observed, cultured and assayed for antibody production in isolation and thus are the unequivocal target of ligands present in the culture fluid. It defines the respective roles of antigens and cytokines acting singly or in combination in the four discernible phases of the immunoproliferative cascade, namely activation, clonal expansion, IgM antibody secretion and isotype switching. It then argues that this precise stepwise analysis can yield useful information concerning important immunological situations, such as experimentally induced immunological tolerance or the effects of constitutive expression of the c-myc oncogene. Evidence is presented that initial activation of the resting B cell in "T-independent" triggering can be achieved either by attachment of a molecule that has B-cell stimulatory properties, such as FLU-LPS or FLU-polymerized flagellin (FLU-POL) or by the lymphokine interleukin 4 (IL-4). IL-4 + FLU-POL is somewhat more effective than either agent alone. IL-4 alone or, better, FLU-POL + IL-4 can stimulate clonal proliferation of the B cell, but FLU-POL alone does not achieve this. Moreover, IL-4 or FLU-POL + IL-4 lead to very little antibody formation. None of IL-1, IL-2 or IL-5 acting alone causes either activation or proliferation. IgM antibody formation is stimulated most strongly by FLU-POL + IL-5, somewhat less strongly by FLU-POL + IL-1 + IL-2 and rather weakly with antigen plus only one of the latter cytokines. The cloning efficiency in the single cell system, and the median clone size can be markedly enhanced by the addition of small numbers of fibroblast or other filler cells to the cultures. While filler cell-free clones do not progress to the stage of isotype switching, filler cell-supported ones can do so in up to 30% of cases. The only cloned lymphokine which has so far been found to promote such switching is IL-4, and the fact that it is at least as powerful as a T-cell supernatant may mean that it is the only agent active in this particular system. However, the detailed pattern of secreted isotypes is different from that seen when MHC-restricted, carrier-specific T cells act on hapten-specific B cells. Hapten-specific B cells from animals rendered neonatally tolerant to FLU-HGG exhibit anergy in the single cell system.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Carrier-specific T cells sufficient for the expression of multiple isotypes in B cell cultures

A modified splenic fragment assay was used to assess the role of antigen-specific helper T cells in B cell isotype expression. Limiting numbers of carrier-specific helper T cells from lines or clones were injected along with a source of B cells into lethally irradiated unprimed recipients. The incidence of lodging of the T cell lines in recipient spleens at 18 h was determined by autoradiography to be 1.5 to 4.3% of the injected cells. These T cells were necessary and sufficient for the generation of T-dependent B cell responses within splenic fragments cultured in vitro with specific antigen. A comparison of isotypic responses from splenic and Peyer's patch B cells generated with the same T cell population revealed that a high proportion of the response from Peyer's patch B cells consisted of IgA antibody exclusively (46-57%) while the percentage of such responses from splenic B cells was much lower (7-10%). Thus, the isotype pattern of the response reflected the B cell source. Experiments in which cloned hemocyanin-specific T cells provided help to T-depleted spleen cells within splenic fragments from athymic recipients indicated that a single specificity of helper T cell is both necessary and sufficient to support the generation of antibody responses consisting of multiple isotypes. Isotype-specific T cells do not appear to be required in this system.

The Florey lecture, 1986. The regulatory biology of antibody formation

The regulatory biology of antibody formation entered a new phase of study with the development of selective theories of immunity. The discovery of the 'one cell - one antibody' dogma and the demonstration that only a small minority of B cells possessed receptors specific for a given antigen were consistent with Burnet's clonal selection hypothesis, which was later formally proven by preparing antigen-specific lymphocytes and inducing clonal activation in vitro. Clonal analysis has aided precise study of immunoregulation for both B and T lymphocytes. Clonal activation of B cells in the absence of T cells is now possible with high cloning efficiency. It requires the combined action of certain antigens and growth factors, collectively termed B-cell stimulatory factors (BSFS). Single cell analysis has shown that most BSFS so far tested, in contrast to most claims in the literature, possess the capacity (in synergy with antigen) to: stimulate B cells out of the G0 phase into active cell cycle; promote sequential mitotic divisions; and induce differentiation to active secretory status. This is clearly true for IL-1, IL-2, and BSF-p2. These multiple actions resemble those of the colony-stimulating factors in haemopoiesis. Regulation of antibody production by T lymphocytes can also be profitably analysed in clonal systems. The immunoregulatory problem of tolerance can also be analysed by means of clonal techniques. Studies are summarized which indicate that T-cell-mediated suppression and functional silencing of toleragen-specific lymphocytes are both cooperatively involved in many tolerance models. For the B lymphocyte, tolerance can be induced without an actual deletion of the cell involved; rather, the tolerant cell appears to have received and stored a negative signal, rendering it unresponsive to normally immunogenic stimuli. Thus, a state termed 'clonal anergy' has been induced within the cell. Functional clonal deletion has also been noted in several models to T-lymphocyte tolerance, but here it is not known whether clonal anergy or actual death of the relevant cell is at work. Self-tolerance sufficient to be consistent with good health need not mean a total absence of cells with any degree of self-reactivity. Indeed, it is clear that some B cells capable of forming antibody with some degree of affinity for self-constituents exist in the body, and can be activated, for example by lipopolysaccharide. The requirement is to limit the amount, affinity and duration of autoantibody production. A model suggesting how this may be achieved is presented.

Antigens apparently nonimmunogenic for xid/Y mice cause the development of specific splenic plasmablasts and of fusion partners for SP2 cells giving hybridomas that secrete antibodies

Although xid/Y mice fail to make a detectable primary antibody response to a variety of antigens such as Type III pneumococcal capsular polysaccharide (SIII), 2,4, 6-trinitrophenyl (TNP)-Ficoll, pneumococcal C carbohydrate, group A streptococcal vaccine and several kinds of related antigenic determinants such as phosphorylcholine (PC) and N-acetyl-glucosaminyl (GlcNAc), even when the latter are coupled to hemocyanin (Hy), they do show: (a) an antigen-dependent development of splenic B cells which can act as successful, productive fusion partners for SP2 cells giving hybridomas making monoclonal anti-SIII, anti-PC, anti-GlcNAc, anti-TNP, etc., and (b) an antigen-dependent appearance of antigen-binding plasmablasts in their spleens. The frequencies of specific B cells arising in xid/Y males with either of these properties are of the same order of magnitude as those found in immunocompetent xid/X female littermates. Further, both PC-Hy and GlcNAc-Hy prime xid/Y and xid/X mice for quantitatively and qualitatively similar secondary responses. All three of these expressions of a specific, primary response occur in xid/Y mice in the absence of any rise in circulating antibodies. The properties of successful, productive normal fusion partners leading to secretory hybridoma lines are unknown. Thus we cannot decide whether the antigen-binding plasmablasts that arise in xid/Y mice can also play the role of productive fusion partners. Neither do we know whether the development of specific IgM and IgG3 plasmablasts in xid/Y mice after antigen stimulation is an abnormality reflecting the xid mutation. It cannot be excluded that the development of productive fusion partners, of nonsecretory plasmablasts and of memory cells are all interrelated and reflect a process that also normally occurs in xid/X, X/X and X/Y mice following similar immunization regimens. It is tempting to speculate that such cells initially responding may lag in the development of normal secretory mechanisms and that the "transformed" fusion partner may complement this deficiency.