Mutagenesis of avian carcinoma virus MH2: only one of two potential transforming genes (delta gag-myc) transforms fibroblasts

Host range restrictions of oncogenes: myc genes transform avian but not mammalian cells and mht/raf genes transform mammalian but not avian cells

The host range of retroviral oncogenes is naturally limited by the host range of the retroviral vector. The question of whether the transforming host range of retroviral oncogenes is also restricted by the host species has not been directly addressed. Here we have tested in avian and murine host species the transforming host range of two retroviral onc genes, myc of avian carcinoma viruses MH2 and MC29 and mht/raf of avian carcinoma virus MH2 and murine sarcoma virus MSV 3611. Virus vector-mediated host restriction was bypassed by recombining viral oncogenes with retroviral vectors that can readily infect the host to be tested. It was found that, despite high expression, transforming function of retroviral myc genes is restricted to avian cells, and that of retroviral mht/raf genes is restricted to murine cells. Since retroviral oncogenes encode the same proteins as certain cellular genes, termed protooncogenes, our data must also be relevant to the oncogene hypothesis of cancer. According to this hypothesis, cancer is caused by mutation of protooncogenes. Because protooncogenes are conserved in evolution and are presumed to have conserved functions, the oncogene hypothesis assumes no host range restriction of transforming function. For example, mutated human proto-myc is postulated to cause Burkitt lymphoma, because avian retroviruses with myc genes cause cancer in birds. But there is no evidence that known mutated protooncogenes can transform human cells. The findings reported here indicate that host range restriction appears to be one of the reasons (in addition to insufficient transcriptional activation) why known, mutated protooncogenes lack transforming function in human cells.

Avian erythroblastosis virus E26: only one (myb) of two cell-derived coding regions is necessary for oncogenicity

The oncogene hypothesis postulates that mutated cellular genes, termed proto-onc genes, function as cancer genes because they are related to retroviral onc genes. However, in contrast to retroviral onc genes, mutated proto-onc genes from cancers are not sufficient for carcinogenesis. Therefore, it has been proposed that mutated proto-onc genes depend on other proto-onc genes for carcinogenesis. Since the oncogene of the avian leukemia virus E26 includes coding regions derived from two cellular proto-onc genes, proto-myb and proto-ets, this hybrid gene has been proposed to be a model for two-gene-carcinogenesis. Here we set out to test this proposal. For this purpose myb and ets deletion mutants of cloned E26 provirus were prepared, and the corresponding viruses, produced by transfected primary chicken embryo cells, were tested for leukemogenicity in newborn chickens. It was found that an ets deletion mutant was just as leukemogenic as the wild-type virus and that a myb deletion mutant lacked leukemogenicity completely. To eliminate the possibility that our E26 myb deletion mutant failed to be leukemogenic because it failed to replicate, the virus was titered by a quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) method. By this method, E26 from the plasma of infected chickens was first allowed to reverse-transcribe viral RNA to cDNA in vitro, and then the cDNA concentration was determined from the lowest dilution that gave a positive signal after amplification of E26 cDNA by the PCR method. Virus titers of about 10(5) per ml were found for wild type and for myb and ets deletion mutants of E26. It is concluded that the ets region is not essential for carcinogenesis, and E26 derives transforming function from overexpression of its proto-myb coding region via the retroviral promoter. Thus, E26 is a single-hit carcinogen and, like all other oncogenic retroviruses, is not a model for two-gene-carcinogenesis. Viral ets probably reflects a genetic accident that transduced sequences of proto-ets together with proto-myb in generating E26.

Evidence that retroviral transduction is mediated by DNA not by RNA

Retroviral transduction of cellular nucleic acid sequences requires illegitimate RNA or DNA recombination. To test a model that postulates transduction via efficient illegitimate recombination during reverse transcription of viral and cellular RNAs, we have measured the ability of Harvey sarcoma viruses (HaSVs) with artificial 3' termini to recover a retroviral 3' terminus from helper Moloney virus (MoV) by illegitimate and homologous recombination. For this purpose, mouse NIH 3T3 cells were transformed with Harvey proviruses and then superinfected with MoV. The proviruses lacked the 3' long terminal repeat and an untranscribed region of the 5' long terminal repeat to prevent virus regeneration from input provirus. Only 0-11 focus-forming units of HaSV were generated upon MoV superinfection of 3 x 10(6) cells transformed by Harvey proviruses with MoV-unrelated termini. This low frequency is consistent with illegitimate DNA recombination via random Moloney provirus integration 3' of the transforming viral ras gene in the 10(6)-kilobase mouse genome. When portions of murine viral envelope (env) genes were attached 3' of ras, 10(2)-10(5) focus-forming units of HaSV were generated, depending on the extent of homology with env of MoV. These recombinants all contained HaSV-specific sequences 5' and MoV-specific sequences 3' of the common env homology. They were probably generated by recombination during reverse transcription rather than by recombination among either input or secondary proviruses, since (i) the yield of recombinants was reduced by a factor of 10 when the env sequence was flanked by splice signals and (ii) HaSV RNAs without retroviral 3' termini would be inadequate templates for provirus synthesis. We conclude that there is no efficient illegitimate recombination in retroviruses. In view of known precedents of illegitimate DNA recombination, the structure of known viral onc genes, and our evidence for illegitimate DNA recombination via provirus integration, we favor the DNA model of transduction over the RNA model.

Cancer genes by illegitimate recombination

Retroviral onc genes are as yet the only proven cancer genes. They are generated by rare illegitimate recombinations between retroviruses and cellular genes, termed proto-onc genes. The claims that these proto-onc genes cause virus-free cancers upon "activation" by mechanisms that do not alter their germline structure are challenged. Instead, it is proposed that retroviral onc genes and cellular cancer genes are generated de novo by illegitimate recombinations that alter the germline structure of normal genes.

The ets sequence is required for induction of erythroblastosis in chickens by avian retrovirus E26

E26 is a replication-defective avian retrovirus that causes an erythroblastic leukemia in vivo and transforms hematopoietic precursor cells of both the erythroid and the myeloid lineages in vitro. The E26 genome contains two sets of cell-derived sequences, ets and myb. myb sequences are also present in avian myeloblastosis virus, which transforms myeloblasts exclusively. To determine whether the ets sequence is responsible for the erythroid specificity of E26, we analyzed the transforming activities of several viruses carrying mutations in the ets sequence constructed in vitro. The mutant viruses retained the ability to transform myeloid cells in vitro, indicating that the myb oncogene is sufficient for this viral function. However, the ets-deficient viruses did not cause an overt leukemia in chickens. The results indicate that the ets sequence is required for the induction of erythroblastosis by E26.

Two autonomous myc oncogenes in avian carcinoma virus OK10

The oncogenic avian retrovirus OK10 has the genetic structure gag-delta pol-myc-delta-env. The myc sequence is transduced from a cellular gene, proto-myc, while gag, pol, and env are essential retrovirus genes. By analogy with other directly oncogenic retroviruses, the specific myc sequence of OK10 is thought to be essential for transforming function. However, unlike the specific sequences of all other transforming retroviruses that encode unique transforming proteins, the myc sequence of OK10 encodes two potential transforming proteins, p58 and p200. p200 is translated from the gag-delta pol-myc region of genomic RNA, while p58 is thought to be translated from the gag leader and the open reading frame of myc via a subgenomic mRNA. In this paper, we ask whether both myc genes of OK10 are autonomous transforming genes. By differentially inactivating the p200 myc gene of OK10 provirus in vitro and analyzing transforming function in quail embryo cells, it was found that mutants expressing only p58 transformed like wild-type OK10. Further, it was shown that p58 with and without the gag leader had transforming function and that p58 of wild-type OK10 is initiated from the gag leader. Mutants expressing only p200 were also transforming but less efficiently than mutants that express only p58. A mutant OK10 virus in which the native frameshift of retroviruses between gag and pol was deleted expressed a shortened p200 (delta p200). Although this virus expressed more delta p200 than wild-type OK10 did, it transformed cells less efficiently. It follows that OK10 expresses two autonomous transforming genes, which is unique among retroviruses with onc genes.

Retroviral transduction of oncogenic sequences involves viral DNA instead of RNA

We have studied whether the origin of retroviral onc genes, by transduction of sequences from cellular proto-onc genes, involves DNA or RNA recombination. By using altered Harvey sarcoma proviruses as models for transduction intermediates, we have investigated the mechanism of regeneration of transforming virus from truncated proviruses with only a single 5' long terminal repeat (LTR) but with a complete 5'-LTR-ras transforming gene. The Harvey proviruses were specifically altered to discriminate between virus regeneration by RNA template switching during reverse transcription, as has been postulated, and virus regeneration by DNA recombination with either helper virus or among elements of the defective provirus alone. For this purpose U3 elements of the Harvey proviral LTR, which are essential for replication but not for transcription, were deleted in vitro. Only proviral constructions with an intact or a nearly intact single LTR regenerated infectious Harvey sarcoma virus. Since all constructions transformed cells and produced identical RNAs, our results exclude a model of virus regeneration by switching of RNA templates during reverse transcription. We conclude that regeneration of infectious Harvey viruses from truncated provirus involved illegitimate recombination of cellular or cotransfected DNAs flanking the 5'-LTR-ras gene of Harvey sarcoma virus. Based on this and evidence from the literature, we propose that retroviral transduction proceeds by way of rare illegitimate recombinations between proviral and cellular DNAs.

myc protooncogene linked to retroviral promoter, but not to enhancer, transforms embryo cells

To define conditions under which the chicken protooncogene p-myc is converted to a viral and possibly to a cellular transforming gene, we assayed transforming function of hybrid genes put together from cloned retroviral and p-myc elements and of p-myc genes isolated from spontaneous viral lymphomas. Transforming function was measured in quail embryo cells transfected with cloned myc genes. We found that only myc genes with a promoter of a retroviral long terminal repeat (LTR) located between the native p-myc promoter and the second p-myc exon have transforming function. Transforming efficiencies decreased with increasing lengths of unspliced sequences between the LTR and p-myc exon 2. p-myc DNAs with LTRs downstream of the coding region or upstream but in the opposite transcriptional orientation failed to transform embryo cells. Likewise, only those retroviral-p-myc combinations from chicken B-cell lymphomas with a LTR positioned as promoter upstream of p-myc exon 2 had transforming function. We conclude that substitution of a retroviral LTR for the promoter and for as yet poorly defined, untranscribed regulatory elements of p-myc is sufficient to convert chicken p-myc to a transforming gene. However, retroviral LTRs can only convert p-myc genes to embryo-cell-transforming genes from a limited number of positions, and not as position-independent enhancers. Further, we deduce that there are two classes of viral chicken B-cell lymphomas, those with and those without embryo-cell-transforming p-myc genes.

Transformed and tumorigenic phenotypes induced by avian retroviruses containing the v-mil oncogene

Avian retrovirus MH2 contains two oncogenes, v-mil and v-myc. We have previously shown that a spontaneous mutant of MH2 (PA200-MH2), expressing only the v-mil oncogene, is able to induce proliferation of quiescent neuroretina cells. In this study, we investigated the transforming and tumorigenic properties of v-mil. PA200 induced fibrosarcomas in about 60% of the injected chickens, whereas inoculation of MH2 resulted mainly in the appearance of kidney carcinomas. Analysis of several parameters of transformation showed that PA200, in contrast to MH2, induced only limited in vitro transformation of fibroblasts and neuroretina cells. These results suggest that v-myc is the major transforming and tumorigenic gene in MH2-infected cells. This low in vitro transforming capacity differentiates v-mil not only from other avian oncogenes, but also from the homologous murine v-raf gene.

Cancer genes generated by rare chromosomal rearrangements rather than activation of oncogenes

The 20 known transforming onc genes of retroviruses are defined by sequences that are transduced from cellular genes, termed proto-oncogenes or cellular oncogenes. Based on these sequences, viral onc genes have been postulated to be transduced cellular cancer genes and proto-onc genes have been postulated to be latent cancer genes that can be activated from within the cell to cause virus-negative tumors. The hypothesis is popular because it promises direct access to cellular cancer genes. However, the existence of latent cancer genes presents a paradox since such genes are clearly undesirable. The hypothesis predicts (i) that viral onc genes and proto-onc genes are isogenic, (ii) that expression of proto-onc genes induces tumors, (iii) that activated proto-onc genes transform diploid cells upon transfection, like viral onc genes, and (iv) that diploid tumors exist that differ from normal cells only in transcriptionally or mutationally activated proto-onc genes. As yet, none of these predictions is confirmed. Moreover, the probability of spontaneous transformation in vivo is at least 10(9) times lower than predicted from the mechanisms thought to activate proto-onc genes. Therefore the hypothesis, that proto-onc genes are latent cellular oncogenes, appears to be an overinterpretation of sequence homology to structural and functional homology with viral onc genes. Here it is proposed that only rare truncations and illegitimate recombinations that alter the germline configuration of cellular genes, generate viral and possibly cellular cancer genes. The clonal chromosome abnormalities that are consistently found in tumor cells are microscopic evidence for rearrangements that may generate cancer genes. The clonality indicates that the tumors are initiated with, and possibly by, these abnormalities as predicted by Boveri in 1914 (Zur Frage der Entstehung maligner Tumoren, Jena, Fischer).

Retention or loss of v-mil sequences after propagation of MH2 virus in vivo or in vitro

During propagation of the defective avian retrovirus MH2 in the presence of replication-competent helper virus, deletion of portions of the viral genome occurred frequently. After transformation of quail cells in vitro, v-mil sequences were lost, leading to populations of MH2 viruses which were highly deficient for mil gene expression but which could transform macrophage and fibroblast cells in vitro with high efficiency. In contrast, after induction of tumors in quail with mil-deficient MH2 viral stocks, a majority of the tumor DNAs contained mil+ proviruses, suggesting that there is selection for retention of the v-mil gene in vivo and that the mil protein may play a role in the oncogenicity of MH2 virus. We also isolated MH2-transformed cell lines which contained deleted proviruses arising from packaging and subsequent integration of the subgenomic v-myc-encoding mRNA. Some of these cell lines produced viruses which encoded abnormal v-myc proteins and had altered in vitro transforming properties. These altered phenotypes may be caused by mutations within the v-myc gene.

Fibroblast transformation parameters induced by the avian v-mil oncogene

An avian retrovirus containing only the v-mil oncogene (PA200-MH2) was analyzed for its ability to induce a transformed phenotype in chicken embryo fibroblasts. Infected cultures exhibited an altered morphology, disarranged actin cable filaments, and a decrease in the amount of cell surface fibronectin. In addition, these cells showed a high level of plasminogen activator protease activity and were also capable of growth in low serum concentrations. In contrast, PA200-MH2 was very inefficient at inducing foci under agar and colonies in semisolid medium relative to the Mill Hill 2 and Rous sarcoma viruses. This inefficiency was further reflected in vivo by the total inability of PA200-MH2 to induce wing tumors in young birds. However, 40% of the birds inoculated in the wing web with PA200-MH2-infected cells did develop slow-growing tumors at the site of injection, with no evidence of hematopoietic involvement. Our results indicate that the v-mil oncogene is transforming both in vitro and in vivo and that each of the oncogenes in the Mill Hill 2 virus, v-mil and v-myc, can independently transform fibroblasts. These data suggest that v-mil is functionally related to its homologous murine counterpart, v-raf, which also transforms fibroblasts.

Cancer genes: rare recombinants instead of activated oncogenes (a review)

The 20 known transforming (onc) genes of retroviruses are defined by sequences that are transduced from cellular genes termed protooncogenes or cellular oncogenes. Based on these sequences, viral onc genes have been postulated to be transduced cellular cancer genes, and proto-onc genes have been postulated to be latent cancer genes that can be activated from within the cell to cause virus-negative tumors. The hypothesis is popular because it promises direct access to cellular cancer genes. However, the existence of latent cancer genes presents a paradox, since such genes are clearly undesirable. The hypothesis predicts that viral onc genes and proto-onc genes are isogenic; that expression of proto-onc genes induces tumors; that activated proto-onc genes transform diploid cells upon transfection, like viral onc genes; and that diploid tumors exist. As yet, none of these predictions is confirmed. Instead: Structural comparisons between viral onc genes, essential retroviral genes, and proto-onc genes show that all viral onc genes are indeed new genes, rather than transduced cellular cancer genes. They are recombinants put together from truncated viral and truncated proto-onc genes. Proto-onc genes are frequently expressed in normal cells. To date, not one activated proto-onc gene has been isolated that transforms diploid cells. Above all, no diploid tumors with activated proto-onc genes have been found. Moreover, the probability of spontaneous transformation in vivo is at least 10(9) times lower than predicted from the mechanisms thought to activate proto-onc genes. Therefore, the hypothesis that proto-onc genes are latent cellular oncogenes appears to be an overinterpretation of sequence homology to structural and functional homology with viral onc genes. Here it is proposed that only rare truncations and illegitimate recombinations that alter the germ-line configuration of cellular genes generate viral and possibly cellular cancer genes. The clonal chromosome abnormalities that are consistently found in tumor cells are microscopic evidence for rearrangements that may generate cancer genes. The clonality indicates that the tumors are initiated with, and possibly by, these abnormalities, as predicted by Boveri in 1914.

The v-myc oncogene is sufficient to induce growth transformation of chick neuroretina cells

A number of studies have shown that full transformation of non-established rodent fibroblasts can be efficiently achieved in vitro by the concerted action of two oncogenes belonging to different complementation groups. Extension of the two-genes carcinogenesis model to other differentiated cell types, presumably endowed with different controls of growth, is desirable for a better understanding of questions such as the host cell selectivity of oncogene action. A recent report claimed that cooperation between two oncogenes, v-myc and v-mil, is required to achieve transformation of chicken embryo neuroretina cells, which are characterized by a limited growth capacity in monolayer culture. Here we present evidence that the v-myc oncogene alone is sufficient to induce growth transformation of glial and neuronal precursor cell types from chick neuroretina. We also report that induction of transformation by v-myc is accompanied by faithful preservation of some of the differentiated functions of the chick cells.

Characterization of murine A-raf, a new oncogene related to the v-raf oncogene

A 1.6-kilobase cDNA (A-raf) has been isolated from a murine spleen cDNA library which encodes part of a protein related to the raf oncogene. Its amino acid sequence has 85% homology to raf in a central portion of 100 amino acids. In contrast to raf, A-raf shows a highly restricted tissue distribution of expression, with highest levels observed in epididymis, followed by intestine. When incorporated into a retrovirus, the resulting gag-A-raf fusion gene causes transformation in vitro and induces tumors in newborn mice. Thus, A-raf represents a new proto-oncogene. Transformation by A-raf is independent of ras gene function, as is the case for raf and mos but not other oncogenes.

Structure and transforming function of transduced mutant alleles of the chicken c-myc gene

A small retroviral vector carrying an oncogenic myc allele was isolated as a spontaneous variant (MH2E21) of avian oncovirus MH2. The MH2E21 genome, measuring only 2.3 kilobases, can be replicated like larger retroviral genomes and hence contains all cis-acting sequence elements essential for encapsidation and reverse transcription of retroviral RNA or for integration and transcription of proviral DNA. The MH2E21 genome contains 5' and 3' noncoding retroviral vector elements and a coding region comprising the first six codons of the viral gag gene and 417 v-myc codons. The gag-myc junction corresponds precisely to the presumed splice junction on subgenomic MH2 v-myc mRNA, the possible origin of MH2E21. Among the v-myc codons, the first 5 are derived from the noncoding 5' terminus of the second c-myc exon, and 412 codons correspond to the c-myc coding region. The predicted sequence of the MH2E21 protein product differs from that of the chicken c-myc protein by 11 additional amino-terminal residues and by 25 amino acid substitutions and a deletion of 4 residues within the shared domains. To investigate the functional significance of these structural changes, the MH2E21 genome was modified in vitro. The gag translational initiation codon was inactivated by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. Furthermore, all but two of the missense mutations were reverted, and the deleted sequences were restored by replacing most of the MH2E21 v-myc allele by the corresponding segment of the CMII v-myc allele which is isogenic to c-myc in that region. The remaining two mutations have not been found in the v-myc alleles of avian oncoviruses MC29, CMII, and OK10. Like MH2 and MH2E21, modified MH2E21 (MH2E21m1c1) transforms avian embryo cells. Like c-myc, it encodes a 416-amino-acid protein initiated at the myc translational initiation codon. We conclude that neither major structural changes, such as in-frame fusion with virion genes or internal deletions, nor specific, if any, missense mutations of the c-myc coding region are necessary for activation of the basic oncogenic function of transduced myc alleles.

Characterization of murine A-raf, a new oncogene related to the v-raf oncogene

A 1.6-kilobase cDNA (A-raf) has been isolated from a murine spleen cDNA library which encodes part of a protein related to the raf oncogene. Its amino acid sequence has 85% homology to raf in a central portion of 100 amino acids. In contrast to raf, A-raf shows a highly restricted tissue distribution of expression, with highest levels observed in epididymis, followed by intestine. When incorporated into a retrovirus, the resulting gag-A-raf fusion gene causes transformation in vitro and induces tumors in newborn mice. Thus, A-raf represents a new proto-oncogene. Transformation by A-raf is independent of ras gene function, as is the case for raf and mos but not other oncogenes.

Dispersed chromosomal localization of the proto-oncogenes transduced into the genome of Mill Hill 2 or E26 leukemia virus

Both Mill Hill 2 and E26 retroviruses have transduced two cellular genes--c-myc and c-mil/mht (Mill Hill 2) and c-myb and c-ets (E26). We localized the genes transduced by these viruses to different chromosomes: c-myc and c-myb to relatively large chromosomes and c-mil/mht and c-ets to microchromosomes. Thus, like avian erythroblastosis virus, each of these retroviruses has transduced two cellular genes unlinked in the chicken genome.

Harvey ras genes transform without mutant codons, apparently activated by truncation of a 5' exon (exon -1)

The hypothesis is tested that the ras gene of Harvey sarcoma virus (Ha-SV) and the proto-ras DNAs from certain tumor cells derive transforming function from specific codons in which they differ from normal proto-ras genes. Molecularly cloned Harvey proviral vectors carrying viral ras, normal rat proto-ras, and recombinant ras genes in which the virus-specific ras codons 12 and 59 were replaced by proto-ras equivalents each transformed aneuploid mouse 3T3 cells after latent periods that ranged from 4 to 10 days. Viruses with or without virus-specific ras codons all transformed diploid rat cells in 3-5 days equally well. However, in the absence of virus replication, mutant codons were beneficial for transforming function. Deletion of non-ras regions of Ha-SV did not affect transforming function. We conclude that specific ras codons are not necessary for transforming function. Comparisons of the ras sequences of Ha-SV, BALB SV, and Rasheed SV with sequences of proto-ras genes from rat and man revealed an upstream proto-ras exon, termed exon -1. The 3' end of this exon is present in all three viruses and in a ras pseudogene of the rat. Since ras genes transform without mutation and since exon -1 is truncated in viral ras genes and all transforming proto-ras DNAs of the Harvey and the Kirsten ras family, we propose that ras genes are activated by truncation of exon -1 either via viral transduction or artificially via cloning and transfection. The proposal implies that untruncated proto-ras genes with point mutations may not be cellular cancer genes.