Viroids and virusoids are related to group I introns

Molecular interactions of plant viral satellites

Plant viral satellites fall under the category of subviral agents. Their genomes are composed of small RNA or DNA molecules a few hundred nucleotides in length and contain an assortment of highly complex and overlapping functions. Each lacks the ability to either replicate or undergo encapsidation or both in the absence of a helper virus (HV). As the number of known satellites increases steadily, our knowledge regarding their sequence conservation strategies, means of replication and specific interactions with host and helper viruses is improving. This review demonstrates that the molecular interactions of these satellites are unique and highly complex, largely influenced by the highly specific host plants and helper viruses that they associate with. Circularized forms of single-stranded RNA are of particular interest, as they have recently been found to play a variety of novel cellular functions. Linear forms of satRNA are also of great significance as they may complement the helper virus genome in exacerbating symptoms, or in certain instances, actively compete against it, thus reducing symptom severity. This review serves to describe the current literature with respect to these molecular mechanisms in detail as well as to discuss recent insights into this emerging field in terms of evolution, classification and symptom development. The review concludes with a discussion of future steps in plant viral satellite research and development.

Circular RNAs with hammerhead ribozymes encoded in eukaryotic genomes: The enemy at home

A new family of non-autonomous retrotransposons with self-cleaving hammerhead ribozymes, the so called retrozymes, has recently been found encoded in diverse plant genomes. These retroelements can be actively transcribed, and their RNAs accumulate in the cells as abundant non-coding circular RNAs (circRNAs) of small size (600–1000 nt). Related circRNAs with self-cleaving ribozymes had already been described in plants, and belong to a group of infectious RNA agents with an uncertain origin: the viroids and viroid-like satellites of plant RNA viruses. These pathogenic circRNAs show many structural similarities with retrozyme circRNAs, and both have been found to occur in flowering plants as heterogeneous RNA molecules of positive and negative polarities. Taking all these data together, we hypothesize that circRNAs encoded by genomic retrozymes could have given origin to infectious circRNAs with self-cleaving ribozymes. Moreover, we propose that retrozymes in time could have evolved from the ancient family of Penelope-like retroelements, which also harbour hammerhead ribozymes. Putative retrozyme sequences with hammerhead ribozymes have been detected as well in metazoan genomes, opening the door to a common occurrence of circRNAs with self-cleaving motifs among eukaryotes.

Non coding RNAs and viruses in the framework of the phylogeny of the genes, epigenesis and heredity

The origin of genes is one of the most enigmatic events in the origin of life. It has been suggested that noncoding (nc) RNA was probably a precursor in the formation of the first polypeptide, and also at the origin of the first manifestation of life and genes. ncRNAs are also becoming central for understanding gene expression and silencing. Indeed, before the discovery of ncRNAs, proteins were viewed as the major molecules in the regulation of gene expression and gene silencing; however, recent findings suggest that ncRNA also plays an important role in gene expression. Reverse transcription of RNA viruses and their integration into the genome of eukaryotes and also their relationship with the ncRNA suggest that their origin is basal in genome evolution, and also probably constitute the first mechanism of gene regulation. I am to review the different roles of ncRNAs in the framework of gene evolution, as well as the importance of ncRNAs and viruses in the epigenesis and in the non-Mendelian model of heredity and evolution.

Circular RNA interference effector molecules (WO10084371)

Just over a decade after the discovery of RNA interference (RNAi), the RNAi field has begun travelling the bumpy road towards the clinic. Notwithstanding this extraordinarily rapid progress, and despite holding great promise for substantial future clinical impact, RNAi-inducing agents unfortunately exhibit certain physico-chemical and pharmacokinetic drawbacks. The patent application WO10084371 utilizes the exquisite biological mechanism of auto-catalytic intron splicing to generate circularized interfering RNAs (ciRNAs) in order to remedy the issue of rapid nuclease-mediated degradation of RNAi-inducers. The present patent evaluation assesses the utility of the ciRNAs in light of commonly used nucleotide modification strategies for modulating the properties of siRNAs, as well as scrutinizes the experimental data substantiating the patent application in question. The ciRNAs disclosed in WO10084371 exhibit potency on par with exogenously introduced short hairpin RNAs, albeit displaying increased exonuclease resistance. However, experimental validation as to the exact silencing mechanism is sparse, although the potential Dicer-substrate function of the ciRNAs is indeed a promising aspect. Despite the novel, elegant approach of WO10084371, the current gold standard nucleotide modifications appear to deliver sufficient stability for therapeutic applications, meaning that solving the issue of siRNA delivery still remains the major hurdle for clinical success.

Viroids and the nature of viroid diseases

In its methodology, the unexpected discovery of the viroid in 1971 resembles that of the virus by Beijerinck some 70 years earlier. In either case, a novel type of plant pathogen was recognized by its ability to penetrate through a medium with pores small enough to exclude even the smallest previously known pathogen: bacteria as compared with the tobacco mosaic agent; viruses as compared with the potato spindle tuber agent. Interestingly, one of the two methods used by Beijerinck, diffusion of the tobacco mosaic agent into agar gels, is conceptually similar to one method used to establish the size of the potato spindle tuber agent, namely polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Further work demonstrated that neither agent is an unusually small conventional pathogen (a microbe in the case of the tobacco mosaic agent; a virus in the case of the potato spindle tuber agent), but that either agent represents the prototype of a fundamentally distinct class of pathogen, the viruses and the viroids, respectively. With the viroids, this distinction became evident once their unique molecular structure, lack of mRNA activity, and autonomous replication had become elucidated. Functionally, viroids rely to a far greater extent than viruses on their host's biosynthetic systems: Whereas translation of viral genetic information is essential for virus replication, viroids are totally dependent on their hosts' transcriptional system and, in contrast to viruses, no viroid-coded proteins are involved. Because of the viroids' simplicity and extremely small size they approach more closely even than viruses Beijerinck's concept of a contagium vivum fluidum.

Origin and evolution of viroids and viroid-like satellite RNAs

Viroids, the smallest and simplest agents of infectious disease, cause a number of economically important diseases of crop plants. Present evidence indicates that most of these diseases originated recently (in the 20th century) by chance transfer of viroids from endemically infected wild plants or by use of viroid-infected germplasm during plant breeding. Modern agricultural practices, such as widespread monoculture of genetically identical plants, and worldwide distribution of planting material, has made it possible for the pathogens to maintain themselves in the crop plants and to conquer new territories. Phylogenetic analysis of their nucleotide sequences indicates that viroids and satellite RNAs represent a monophyletic group, with all but the two self-cleaving viroids forming one cluster and the satellite RNAs another. The two self-cleaving viroids are phylogenetically distant from either cluster; they may represent ancestral forms. Results from site-directed mutagenesis experiments indicate that, upon exposure to selective pressures, viroids can evolve extremely rapidly, with another, fitter, component of the quasi-species often becoming dominant within days or weeks. This extreme plasticity of their nucleotide sequences establishes viroids as the most rapidly evolving biological system known.

RNA-mediated ligation of self-cleavage products of a Neurospora mitochondrial plasmid transcript

Neurospora VS RNA is a mitochondrial single-stranded RNA that combines certain features of catalytic RNAs and group I introns. We report here that monomeric VS RNA synthesized in vitro by self-cleavage of a multimeric transcript can perform an RNA-mediated self-ligation reaction producing circular RNAs indistinguishable from those isolated from mitochondria. We conclude that the active site for the ligation reaction is present in the RNA itself. Also, the mechanism for aligning the termini to be ligated may be different from mechanisms previously described. The lack of sequence similarity between VS RNA and previously characterized catalytic RNAs suggests that VS RNA is an independently evolved ribozyme capable of both cleavage and ligation.

Phylogeny of viroids, viroidlike satellite RNAs, and the viroidlike domain of hepatitis delta virus RNA

We report a phylogenetic study of viroids, some plant satellite RNAs, and the viroidlike domain of human hepatitis delta virus RNA. Our results support a monophyletic origin of these RNAs and are consistent with the hypothesis that they may be "living fossils" of a precellular RNA world. Moreover, the viroidlike domain of human hepatitis delta virus RNA appears closely related to the viroidlike satellite RNAs of plants, with which it shares some structural and functional properties. On the basis of our phylogenetic analysis, we propose a taxonomic classification of these RNAs.

A transposon-related palindromic repetitive sequence from C. elegans

A family of transposon-like sequences in the C. elegans genome is described. This family, termed the Tc6 family, consists mostly of conserved, 1.6 kb elements. Four Tc6 elements or partial elements have been cloned and the DNA sequences of three were determined. One appears to be a complete element of 1603 nucleotides, consisting of a palindrome of 765 nucleotides, with a central, non-palindromic region of 73 nucleotides. Another has an identical structure except for an internal deletion. A third is a partial element terminating at a probable internal restriction site used for cloning. A fourth clone contained portions of the Tc6 sequence juxtaposed to non-Tc6 sequences. All C. elegans strains examined contain 20-30 Tc6 elements. The ends of Tc6 elements are conserved and have sequence similarity to the ends of C. elegans transposons Tc1 and Tc3. The ends of Tc6 elements also have sequence similarity to the heptamer portion of the immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor recombination signal sequence, raising the possibility of wide phylogenetic conservation of the recombination mechanism. Tc6 elements also share sequence motifs with plant-pathogenic viroid RNA's, possibly indicative of a Tc6 RNA replicative phase.

Australian grapevine viroid--evidence for extensive recombination between viroids

Australian grapevine viroid (AGV, 369 residues) is a novel viroid with less than 50% sequence similarity with any known viroid. Nevertheless its entire sequence can be divided into regions, each with a high sequence similarity with segments from one of citrus exocortis, potato spindle tuber, apple scar skin, and grapevine yellow speckle viroids. AGV contains the entire central conserved region of the apple scar skin viroid group and is proposed as a member of this group. AGV appears to have originated from extensive RNA recombination involving other viroids. The vegetatively propagated grapevines which have been exposed to multiple viroid infections during their long history of cultivation may have allowed such recombination.

Circular RNAs: relics of precellular evolution?

The demonstration of enzymatic capabilities of certain RNAs, in addition to their well-known template properties, has led to the recognition that RNAs are the only biological macromolecules that can function both as genotype and phenotype, hence raising the possibility of Darwinian selection and precellular evolution at the RNA level in the absence of DNA or protein. Recent models of such precellular RNA systems are patterned after the properties of intron-derived ribozymes. On the basis of a phylogenetic analysis and known properties of certain small plant pathogenic RNAs (viroids and viroid-like satellite RNAs), I suggest that these plant RNAs are more plausible candidates than introns as "living fossils" of a precellular RNA world. Their small size and circularity would have enhanced probability of their survival in error-prone, primitive self-replicating RNA systems and assured complete replication without the need for initiation or termination signals. All of these RNAs possess efficient mechanisms for the precise cleavage of monomers from oligomeric replication intermediates. Some (most viroids) require a host factor, but others (viroid-like satellite RNAs and one viroid) function as self-cleaving RNA enzymes far smaller and simpler than those derived from introns. The question is raised whether introns could have evolved from viroids or viroid-like satellite RNAs rather than vice versa, as has been widely speculated.

Subviral pathogens of plants: the viroids

Research during the last 15 years has conclusively shown that viroids are not only fundamentally different from viruses at the molecular level, but that they are most likely not directly related to viruses in an evolutionary sense. Today, viroids are among the most thoroughly studied biological macromolecules. Their molecular structures have been elucidated to a large extent, but much needs to be learned regarding the correlation between molecular structure and biological function. The availability of the tools of recombinant DNA technology in viroid research promises rapid progress in these areas of inquiry.

Antigenomic RNA of human hepatitis delta virus can undergo self-cleavage

The structure and replication of the single-stranded circular RNA genome of hepatitis delta virus (HDV) are unique relative to those of known animal viruses, and yet there are real similarities between HDV and certain infectious RNAs of plants. Therefore, since some of the latter RNAs have been shown to undergo in vitro site-specific cleavage and even ligation, we tested the hypothesis that similar events might also occur for HDV RNA. In partial confirmation of this hypothesis, we found that in vitro the RNA complementary to the HDV genome, the antigenomic RNA, could undergo a self-cleavage that was not only more than 90% efficient but also occurred only at a single location. This cleavage was found to produce junction fragments consistent with a 5'-hydroxyl and a cyclic 2',3'-monophosphate. Since the observed cleavage was both site-specific and occurred only once per genome length, we propose that the site may be relevant to the normal intracellular replication of the HDV genome. Because the site is located almost adjacent to the 3' end of the delta antigen-coding region, the only known functional open reading frame of HDV, we suggest that the cleavage may have a role not only in genome replication but also in RNA processing, helping to produce a functional mRNA for the translation of delta antigen.

The molecular structure of hop latent viroid (HLV), a new viroid occurring worldwide in hops

A new viroid which does not seem to produce any symptoms of disease, and is therefore tentatively named hop latent viroid (HLV) was found to occur worldwide in hops. HLV proved to be infectious when mechanically inoculated onto viroid- and virus-free hops. The viroid nature of HLV was also substantiated by sequence analysis which revealed that HLV is a circular RNA consisting of 256 nucleotides, that can be arranged into the viroid-specific, rod-like secondary structure. HLV also contains the central conserved region typical for most of the presently known viroids. However HLV does not contain the viroid-specific oligo(A) stretch in the upper left part of its rod-like molecule. Because of this feature and a sequence similarity with the prototypes of the other viroid groups below 55%, HLV can be regarded as the first member of a new viroid group.

Three nuclear genes suppress a yeast mitochondrial splice defect when present in high copy number

A gene bank of a yeast wild type DNA in the high copy number vector YEp13 was screened for recombinant plasmids which suppress the mitochondrial RNA splice defect exerted by mutant M1301, a -1 bp deletion in the first intron of the mitochondrial COB gene (bI1). A total of 17 recombinant plasmids with similar suppressor activity were found. Restriction mapping and cross-hybridization of the inserts revealed that these 17 plasmids contain three different inserts, all lacking any extended sequence homology. Each of the inserts, when present in high copy number, has a similar suppressor activity: high in the presence of mutation M1301 in bI1, a group II intron, and low but significant with the presence of few mutants in bI2 and bI3 of the COB gene, both of which are group I introns.

tRNA-like structures tag the 3' ends of genomic RNA molecules for replication: implications for the origin of protein synthesis

Single-stranded RNA viruses often have 3'-terminal tRNA-like structures that serve as substrates for the enzymes of tRNA metabolism, including the tRNA synthases and the CCA-adding enzyme. We propose that such 3'-terminal tRNA-like structures are in fact molecular fossils of the original RNA world, where they tagged genomic RNA molecules for replication and also functioned as primitive telomeres to ensure that 3'-terminal nucleotides were not lost during replication. This picture suggests that the CCA-adding activity was originally an RNA enzyme, that modern DNA telomeres with the repetitive structure CmAn are the direct descendants of the CCA terminus of tRNA, and that the precursor of the modern enzyme RNase P evolved to convert genomic into functional RNA molecules by removing this 3'-terminal tRNA-like tag. Because early RNA replicases would have been catalytic RNA molecules that used the 3'-terminal tRNA-like tag as a template for the initiation of RNA synthesis, these tRNA-like structures could have been specifically aminoacylated with an amino acid by an aberrant activity of the replicase. We show that it is mechanistically reasonable to suppose that this aminoacylation occurred by the same sequence of reactions found in protein synthesis today. The advent of such tRNA synthases would thus have provided a pathway for the evolution of modern protein synthesis.

Cloning and characterisation of a delta virus cDNA sequence derived from a human source

We report the extraction of delta virus RNA from the serum of a delta-virus-infected patient and the subsequent cloning and analysis of a 380-nucleotide-long cDNA (D380). The nucleotide sequence of D380 shows overall differences of approximately 20% when compared with previously published sequences and does not include the viroid consensus sequence previously reported (Wang et al: Nature 323:508-514, 1986). A potentially coding open reading frame extending over the whole length of the D380 has been identified. Our results demonstrate the existence of genetic heterogeneity amongst different delta virus isolates.

Site-specific mutagenesis of potato spindle tuber viroid cDNA: : Alterations within premelting region 2 that abolish infectivity

The infectivity of cloned viroid cDNAs permits investigation of structure/function relationships in these unusual pathogenic RNAs by systematic site-specific mutagenesis of the cDNAs and subsequent bioassay. We have used three different strategies to create nucleotide substitutions within premelting region 2, a region of potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTV) believed to be important in viroid replication: sodium bisulfitecatalyzed deamination of deoxycytosine residues, oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis, and construction of chimeric viroid cDNAs from fragments of infectious PSTV and tomato apical stunt viroid cDNAs. Although their effects upon the rod-like native structure of PSTV should be minimal, C → U transitions at positions 92 or 284 appeared to be lethal. When inoculation with PSTV cDNA containing a single nucleotide substitution was mediated by the Ti plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens, PSTV progeny with an unaltered 'wild type' sequence was obtained. Two factors, the high error frequency characteristic of RNA synthesis and the use of a systemic bioassay for PSTV replication, may explain such sequence reversion and emphasize the importance of an appropriate bioassay system for screening mutant viroid cDNAs.

Relationship of viroids and certain other plant pathogenic nucleic acids to group I and II introns

The nucleotide sequences of viroids contain features believed to be essential for the splicing of group I introns. Common sequence elements include a 16-nucleotide consensus sequence and three pairs of short sequences arranged in the same sequential order in both types of RNAs. The calculated probability of finding sequences resembling the 16-nucleotide consensus sequence in random nucleotide chains showed that at low fidelity (up to 5 mismatched nucleotides), the number of such sequences in viroids, plant viral satellite RNAs, plant viral RNAs and one plant viral DNA, group I introns and flanking exons does not significantly differ from the number expected at random. As the degree of fidelity is increased, the number in both introns and viroids, but not in exons or the other plant pathogens examined, greatly exceeds that expected in random chains. These findings suggest that viroids may have evolved from group I introns and/or that processing of viroid oligomers to monomers may have structural requirements similar to those of group I introns. The nucleotide sequences of viroids do not show close homology with two conserved regions of group II introns, the 14-base pair consensus region and the 5' terminal segment. However, close homology does exist between the conserved sequence of the 3' terminal segment of group II introns and viroids thus suggesting a possible evolutionary or functional relationship.