Elongation factor Tu.guanosine 3'-diphosphate 5'-diphosphate complex increases the fidelity of proofreading in protein biosynthesis: mechanism for reducing translational errors introduced by amino acid starvation

At the Crossroad of Nucleotide Dynamics and Protein Synthesis in Bacteria

Nucleotides are at the heart of the most essential biological processes in the cell, be it as key protagonists in the dogma of molecular biology or by regulating multiple metabolic pathways. The dynamic nature of nucleotides, the cross talk between them, and their constant feedback to and from the cell's metabolic state position them as a hallmark of adaption toward environmental and growth challenges. It has become increasingly clear how the activity of RNA polymerase, the synthesis and maintenance of tRNAs, mRNA translation at all stages, and the biogenesis and assembly of ribosomes are fine-tuned by the pools of intracellular nucleotides. With all aspects composing protein synthesis involved, the ribosome emerges as the molecular hub in which many of these nucleotides encounter each other and regulate the state of the cell. In this review, we aim to highlight intracellular nucleotides in bacteria as dynamic characters permanently cross talking with each other and ultimately regulating protein synthesis at various stages in which the ribosome is mainly the principal character.

Direct binding targets of the stringent response alarmone (p)ppGpp

The Escherichia coli stringent response, mediated by the alarmone ppGpp, is responsible for the reorganization of cellular transcription upon nutritional starvation and other stresses. These transcriptional changes occur mainly as a result of the direct effects of ppGpp and its partner transcription factor DksA on RNA polymerase. An often overlooked feature of the stringent response is the direct targeting of other proteins by ppGpp. Here we review the literature on proteins that are known to bind ppGpp and, based on sequence homology, X-ray crystal structures and in silico docking, we propose new potential protein binding targets for ppGpp. These proteins were found to fall into five main categories: (i) cellular GTPases, (ii) proteins involved in nucleotide metabolism, (iii) proteins involved in lipid metabolism, (iv) general metabolic proteins and (v) PLP-dependent basic aliphatic amino acid decarboxylases. Bioinformatic rationale is provided for expanding the role of ppGpp in regulating the activities of the cellular GTPases. Proteins involved in nucleotide and lipid metabolism and general metabolic proteins provide an interesting set of structurally varied stringent response targets. While the inhibition of some PLP-dependent decarboxylases by ppGpp suggests the existence of cross-talk between the acid stress and stringent response systems.

The magic spot ppGpp influences in vitro the molecular and functional properties of the elongation factor 1α from the archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus

Guanosine tetra-phosphate (ppGpp), also known as "magic spot I", is a key molecule in the stringent control of most eubacteria and some eukarya. Here, we show that ppGpp affects the functional and molecular properties of the archaeal elongation factor 1α from Sulfolobus solfataricus (SsEF-1α). Indeed, ppGpp inhibited archaeal protein synthesis in vitro, even though the concentration required to get inhibition was higher than that required for the eubacterial and eukaryal systems. Regarding the partial reactions catalysed by SsEF-1α the effect produced by ppGpp on the affinity for aa-tRNA was lower than that measured in the presence of GTP but higher than that for GDP. Magic spot I was also able to bind SsEF-1α with an intermediate affinity in comparison to that displayed by GDP and GTP. Furthermore, ppGpp inhibited the intrinsic GTPase of SsEF-1α with a competitive behaviour. Finally, the binding of ppGpp to SsEF-1α rendered the elongation factor more resistant to heat treatment and the analysis of the molecular model of the complex between SsEF-1α and ppGpp suggests that this stabilisation arises from the charge optimisation on the surface of the protein.

The ObgE/CgtA GTPase influences the stringent response to amino acid starvation in Escherichia coli

The stringent response is important for bacterial survival under stressful conditions, such as amino acid starvation, and is characterized by the accumulation of ppGpp and pppGpp. ObgE (CgtA, YhbZ) is an essential conserved GTPase in Escherichia coli and several observations have implicated the protein in the control of the stringent response. However, consequences of the protein on specific responses to amino acid starvation have not been noted. We show that ObgE binds to ppGpp with biologically relevant affinity in vitro, implicating ppGpp as an in vivo ligand of ObgE. ObgE mutants increase the ratio of pppGpp to ppGpp within the cell during the stringent response. These changes are correlated with a delayed inhibition of DNA replication by the stringent response, delayed resumption of DNA replication after release, as well as a decreased survival after amino acid deprivation. With these data, we place ObgE as an active effector of the response to amino acid starvation in vivo. Our data correlate the pppGpp/ppGpp ratio with DNA replication control under bacterial starvation conditions, suggesting a possible role for the relative balance of these two nucleotides.

Genetic analysis of the invariant residue G791 in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA implicates RelA in ribosome function

Previous studies identified G791 in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA as an invariant residue for ribosome function. In order to establish the functional role of this residue in protein synthesis, we searched for multicopy suppressors of the mutant ribosomes that bear a G-to-U substitution at position 791. We identified relA, a gene whose product has been known to interact with ribosomes and trigger a stringent response. Overexpression of RelA resulted in the synthesis of approximately 1.5 times more chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) protein than could be synthesized by the mutant ribosomes in the absence of RelA overexpression. The ratio of mutant rRNA to the total ribosome pool was not changed, and the steady-state level of CAT mRNA was decreased by RelA overexpression. These data confirmed that the phenotype of RelA as a multicopy suppressor of the mutant ribosome did not result from the enhanced synthesis of mutant rRNA or CAT mRNA from the plasmid. To test whether the phenotype of RelA was related to the stringent response induced by the increased cellular level of (p)ppGpp, we screened for mutant RelA proteins whose overexpression enhances CAT protein synthesis by the mutant ribosomes as effectively as wild-type RelA overexpression and then screened for those whose overexpression does not produce sufficiently high levels of (p)ppGpp to trigger the stringent response under the condition of amino acid starvation. Overexpression of the isolated mutant RelA proteins resulted in the accumulation of (p)ppGpp in cells, which was amounted to approximately 18.2 to 38.9% of the level of (p)ppGpp found in cells that overexpress the wild-type RelA. These findings suggest that the function of RelA as a multicopy suppressor of the mutant ribosome does not result from its (p)ppGpp synthetic activity. We conclude that RelA has a previously unrecognized role in ribosome function.

Charging levels of four tRNA species in Escherichia coli Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains during amino acid starvation: a simple model for the effect of ppGpp on translational accuracy

Escherichia coli strains mutated in the relA gene lack the ability to produce ppGpp during amino acid starvation. One consequence of this deficiency is a tenfold increase in misincorporation at starved codons compared to the wild-type. Previous work had shown that the charging levels of tRNAs were the same in Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains and reduced, at most, two- to fivefold in both strains during starvation. The present reinvestigation of the charging levels of tRNA(2)(Arg), tRNA(1)(Thr), tRNA(1)(Leu) and tRNA(His) during starvation of isogenic Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains showed that starvation reduced charging levels tenfold to 40-fold. This reduction corresponds much better with the decreased rate of protein synthesis during starvation than that reported earlier. The determination of the charging levels of tRNA(2)(Arg) and tRNA(1)(Thr) during starvation were accurate enough to demonstrate that charging levels were at least fivefold lower in the Rel(-) strain compared to the Rel(+) strain. Together with other data from the literature, these new data suggest a simple model in which mis-incorporation increases as the substrate availability decreases and that ppGpp has no direct effect on enhancing translational accuracy at the ribosome.

The rates of macromolecular chain elongation modulate the initiation frequencies for transcription and translation in Escherichia coli

Here we show that most macromolecular biosynthesis reactions in growing bacteria are sub-saturated with substrate. The experiments should in part test predictions from a previously proposed model (Jensen & Pedersen 1990) which proposed a central role for the rates of the RNA and peptide chain elongation reactions in determining the concentration of initiation competent RNA polymerases and ribosomes and thereby the initiation frequencies for these reactions. We have shown that synthesis of ribosomal RNA and the concentration of ppGpp did not exhibit the normal inverse correlation under balanced growth conditions in batch cultures when the RNA chain elongation rate was limited by substrate supply. The RNA chain elongation rate for the polymerase transcribing lacZ mRNA was directly measured and found to be reduced by two-fold under conditions of high ppGpp levels. In the case of translation, we have shown that the peptide elongation rate varied at different types of codons and even among codons read by the same tRNA species. The faster translated codons probably have the highest cognate tRNA concentration and the highest affinity to the tRNA. Thus, the ribosome may operate close to saturation at some codons and be unsaturated at synonymous codons. Therefore, not only translation of the codons for the seven amino acids, whose biosynthesis is regulated by attenuation, but also a substantial fraction of the other translation reactions may be unsaturated. Recently, we have obtained results which indicate that also many ribosome binding sites are unsaturated with their substrate, i.e. with ribosomes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Relationship between guanosine tetraphosphate and accuracy of translation in Salmonella typhimurium

In bacteria a high level of mistranslation is observed in amino acid starved rel-, but not rel+, strains, and mistranslation can be studied qualitatively by means of "stuttering" experiments in two-dimensional protein gels. It has been suggested that the low level of mistranslation that occurs in rel+ strains is assured by guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp), a nucleotide whose intracellular concentration greatly increases in rel+ cells under amino acid starvation. In the present study the relationship between level of ppGpp and mistranslation was analyzed by performing stuttering experiments in amino acid starved bacteria that contained either high or low levels of ppGpp. Three strains of Salmonella typhimurium were used in these experiments: a relA+ hisT+ strain (TA997), a relA+ hisT strain (TA1001), and a relA hisT strain (PD2). These strains were first characterized with respect to macromolecular syntheses and ppGpp levels under exponential growth and under amino acid starvation. Both rel+ strains exhibited stringent control over RNA synthesis. ppGpp accumulated to high levels when TA997 was starved for either of three amino acids. Starvation of TA1001 for histidine did not cause accumulation of ppGpp, whereas starvation for lysine and arginine produced high levels of ppGpp. Extracts from the three strains, obtained either under exponential growth or under amino acid starvation, were then subjected to two-dimensional electrophoretic anaylsis: mistranslation was observed whenever ppGpp was absent. In particular, starvation of TA1001 for histidine resulted in high mistranslation frequencies, while under lysine and arginine starvation mistranslation was undetectable, regardless of whether the cells were rel+ or rel-.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Translation of the sequence AGG-AGG yields 50% ribosomal frameshift

We have inserted the sequence 5'-AAG-GAGGU-3', which is complementary to the 3' terminus of Escherichia coli 16S rRNA, in a reading frame and analyzed its effect on the accuracy and overall rate of translation in vivo. Translation over the sequence yields a 50% ribosomal frameshift if the reading phase is A-AGG-AGG-U. The other two possible frames do not give shifts. The introduction of a UAA stop codon before (UAA-AGG-AGG-U) but not after (A-AGG-AGG-UAA) the AGG codons abolishes the frameshift. The change in the reading phase occurs exclusively to the +1 direction. Efficient frameshifting is also induced by the sequence A-AGA-AGA-U. The arginine codons AGG and AGA are read by minor tRNA. Suppression of frameshifting takes place when a gene for minor tRNA(Arg) is introduced on a multicopy plasmid. We suggest that frameshifting during translation of the A-AGG-AGG-U sequence is due to the erroneous decoding of the tandem AGG codons and arises by depletion of tRNA(Arg). The complementarity of tandem AGG codons to the 3' terminus of 16S rRNA is a coincidence and apparently not related to the shift. Replacing the AGG-AGG sequence by the optimal arginine codons CGU-CGU does not increase the overall rate of translation.

Maintenance of accuracy during amino acid starvation

The kinetics of the tRNA cycle is in itself capable of keeping the translational error level almost unaffected by amino acid starvation. There is no need to assume any yet unknown mechanism or property. Kinetic analysis shows that the concentration of aminoacyl-tRNA can stay high even for large reductions in aminoacylation, since the pool of uncharged tRNA normally is very small. An enhanced binding of uncharged tRNA to the ribosome could increase the effect and produce an extremely efficient error damping. A similar result is obtained when EF-Tu is partially inhibited by ppGpp.

Expression of arg genes of Escherichia coli during arginine limitation dependent upon stringent control of translation

The transcription and translation of operons for arginine biosynthetic enzymes after arginine removal (arginine down shift) were studied in relA and relA+ strains of Escherichia coli. After arginine down shift, derepression of synthesis of the arginine biosynthetic enzymes ornithine carbamoyltransferase (argF) and argininosuccinate lyase (argH) began at about 15 min in relA+ cells but was delayed in relA cells for more than 2 h. However, both relA+ and relA cells accumulated high levels of argCBH mRNA, as shown by dot blot hybridization, after arginine down shift. After 15 min of arginine limitation, the proportion of ribosome-bound argCBH mRNA was equivalent in both relA+ and relA cells. During the 15 min after the arginine down shift, relA+ cells produced a significant burst of argF and argH enzyme synthesis when arginine was added back to the culture, whereas relA cells did not produce this burst of enzyme synthesis. The relA cells regained the ability to produce a burst of argF and argH enzyme synthesis when alpha-methylglucose-induced glucose starvation was combined with arginine limitation. Significant guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate accumulated in relA cells under this condition. Our results support the view that during periods of severe amino acid limitation guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate acts in some way to ensure the translation of argCBH mRNA.