Recognition helices of lac and lambda repressor are oriented in opposite directions and recognize similar DNA sequences

Introduction to a special issue of Magnetic Resonance in honour of Robert Kaptein at the occasion of his 80th birthday

This publication, in honour of Robert Kaptein's 80th birthday, contains contributions from colleagues, many of whom have worked with him, and others who admire his work and have been stimulated by his research. The contributions show current research in biomolecular NMR, spin hyperpolarisation and spin chemistry, including CIDNP (chemically induced dynamic nuclear polarisation), topics to which he has contributed enormously. His proposal of the radical pair mechanism was the birth of the field of spin chemistry, and the laser CIDNP NMR experiment on a protein was a major breakthrough in hyperpolarisation research. He set milestones for biomolecular NMR by developing computational methods for protein structure determination, including restrained molecular dynamics and 3D NMR methodology. With a lac repressor headpiece, he determined one of the first protein structures determined by NMR. His studies of the lac repressor provided the first examples of detailed studies of protein nucleic acid complexes by NMR. This deepened our understanding of protein DNA recognition and led to a molecular model for protein sliding along the DNA. Furthermore, he played a leading role in establishing the cluster of NMR large-scale facilities in Europe. This editorial gives an introduction to the publication and is followed by a biography describing his contributions to magnetic resonance.

Screening for protein-DNA interactions by automatable DNA-protein interaction ELISA

DNA-binding proteins (DBPs), such as transcription factors, constitute about 10% of the protein-coding genes in eukaryotic genomes and play pivotal roles in the regulation of chromatin structure and gene expression by binding to short stretches of DNA. Despite their number and importance, only for a minor portion of DBPs the binding sequence had been disclosed. Methods that allow the de novo identification of DNA-binding motifs of known DBPs, such as protein binding microarray technology or SELEX, are not yet suited for high-throughput and automation. To close this gap, we report an automatable DNA-protein-interaction (DPI)-ELISA screen of an optimized double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) probe library that allows the high-throughput identification of hexanucleotide DNA-binding motifs. In contrast to other methods, this DPI-ELISA screen can be performed manually or with standard laboratory automation. Furthermore, output evaluation does not require extensive computational analysis to derive a binding consensus. We could show that the DPI-ELISA screen disclosed the full spectrum of binding preferences for a given DBP. As an example, AtWRKY11 was used to demonstrate that the automated DPI-ELISA screen revealed the entire range of in vitro binding preferences. In addition, protein extracts of AtbZIP63 and the DNA-binding domain of AtWRKY33 were analyzed, which led to a refinement of their known DNA-binding consensi. Finally, we performed a DPI-ELISA screen to disclose the DNA-binding consensus of a yet uncharacterized putative DBP, AtTIFY1. A palindromic TGATCA-consensus was uncovered and we could show that the GATC-core is compulsory for AtTIFY1 binding. This specific interaction between AtTIFY1 and its DNA-binding motif was confirmed by in vivo plant one-hybrid assays in protoplasts. Thus, the value and applicability of the DPI-ELISA screen for de novo binding site identification of DBPs, also under automatized conditions, is a promising approach for a deeper understanding of gene regulation in any organism of choice.

Towards evolving a better repressor

Transcriptional regulation is an essential component of all metabolic pathways. At the most basic level, a protein binds to a particular DNA sequence (operator) on the genome and either positively or negatively alters the level of transcription. Together, the protein and its operator form an epigenetic switch that regulates gene expression. In an effort to produce a 'better' switch, we have discovered novel facets of the lac operon that are responsible for optimal functionality. We have uncovered a relationship between operator binding affinity and inducibility and demonstrated that the operator DNA is not a passive component of a genetic switch; it is responsible for establishing binding affinity, specificity as well as translational efficiency. In addition, an operator's directionality can indirectly affect gene expression. Unraveling the basic properties of this classical epigenetic switch demonstrates that multiple factors must be optimized in designing a better switch.

A novel molecular switch

Transcriptional regulation is a fundamental process for regulating the flux of all metabolic pathways. For the last several decades, the lac operon has served as a valuable model for studying transcription. More recently, the switch that controls the operon has also been successfully adapted to function in mammalian cells. Here we describe how, using directed evolution, we have created a novel switch that recognizes an asymmetric operator sequence. The new switch has a repressor with altered headpiece domains for operator recognition and a redesigned dimer interface to create a heterodimeric repressor. Quite unexpectedly, the heterodimeric switch functions better than the natural system. It can repress more tightly than the naturally occurring switch of the lac operon; it is less leaky and can be induced more efficiently. Ultimately, these novel repressors could be evolved to recognize eukaryotic promoters and used to regulate gene expression in mammalian systems.

“Cold-Sensitive” Mutants of the Lac Repressor

Thirteen of more than 4,000 single-amino-acid-replacement mutants of the Lac repressor, generated by suppression of amber nonsense mutants, were characterized as having a cold-sensitive phenotype. However, when expressed as missense mutations, none of the replacements cause cold sensitivity, implicating the suppression mechanism as being responsible for this phenotype.

Altered specificity in DNA binding by the lac repressor: a mutant lac headpiece that mimics the gal repressor

Recognition of the lac operator by the lac repressor involves specific interactions between residues in the repressor's recognition helix and bases in the DNA major groove. Tyr17 and Gln18, at positions 1 and 2 in the lac repressor recognition helix, can be exchanged for other amino acids to generate mutant repressors that display altered specificity. We have solved the solution structure of a protein-DNA complex of an altered-specificity mutant lac headpiece in which Tyr17 and Gln18 were exchanged for valine and alanine, respectively, as found in the recognition helix of the gal repressor. As previously described by Lehming et al. (EMBO J. 1987, 6, 3145-3153), this altered-specificity mutant of the lac repressor recognizes a variant lac operator that is similar to the gal operator Oe. The mutant lac headpiece showed the predicted specificity and is also able to mimic the gal repressor by recognizing and bending the natural gal operator Oe. These structural data show that, while most of the anchoring points that help the lac headpiece to assemble on the lac operator were preserved, a different network of protein-DNA interactions connecting Ala17 and Val18 to bases in the DNA major groove drives the specificity towards the altered operator.

Induction of the lac promoter in the absence of DNA loops and the stoichiometry of induction

In vivo induction of the Escherichia coli lactose operon as a function of inducer concentration generates a sigmoidal curve, indicating a non-linear response. Suggested explanations for this dependence include a 2:1 inducer–repressor stoichiometry of induction, which is the currently accepted view. It is, however, known for decades that, in vitro, operator binding as a function of inducer concentration is not sigmoidal. This discrepancy between in vivo and in vitro data has so far not been resolved. We demonstrate that the in vivo non-linearity of induction is due to cooperative repression of the wild-type lac operon through DNA loop formation. In the absence of DNA loops, in vivo induction curves are hyperbolic. In the light of this result, we re-address the question of functional molecular inducer–repressor stoichiometry in induction of the lac operon.

Design and expression of oligomeric fibronectin fusion protein: a strategy for enhancing cell adhesion activity

Cell adhesion to extracellular matrices, including fibronectin, results in clustering of integrins in focal adhesions. To promote the clustering of fibronectin and thus enhance its activity at the sites of focal adhesion formation, we have engineered a fusion protein containing recombinant fibronectin fragment (hFN) connected to the tetramerization helix domain of lac repressor for oligomeric assembly. Purified Lac-hFN fusion protein exhibited significant increase of cell adhesion and proliferation of GF cells compared with hFN alone (p < 0.05).

A study of the CopF repressor of plasmid pAMbeta1 by phage display

We studied DNA binding of a transcriptional repressor, CopF, displayed on a filamentous phage. Mutagenesis of a putative helix-turn-helix motif of CopF and of certain bases of the operator abolished the protein-DNA interaction, establishing the elements involved in CopF function and showing that phage display can be used to study repressor proteins.

Dimerisation mutants of Lac repressor. II. A single amino acid substitution, D278L, changes the specificity of dimerisation

Assembly of the lactose repressor tetramer involves two subunit interfaces, the C-terminal heptad repeats, and the monomer-monomer interface. Dimerisation between two monomers of Lac repressor of Escherichia coli lacking the two C-terminal heptad repeats occurs through the interactions between three alpha-helices of each monomer, which form a highly hydrophobic interface. Residues possibly involved in specific dimer formation are known from X-ray studies and from the phenotypes of more than 4000 single amino acid substitutions. During the examination of numerous mutants within the dimerisation interface of Lac repressor, we found that substitution of one amino acid, D278 to leucine, is sufficient to change the specificity of dimerisation. Analysis of this single substitution indicates that D278L mutant Lac repressor represses like wild-type. However, it no longer forms heterodimers with wild-type Lac repressor.

Dimerisation mutants of Lac repressor. I. A monomeric mutant, L251A, that binds Lac operator DNA as a dimer

Dimer formation between monomers of the Escherichia coli Lac repressor is substantially specificed by the interactions between three alpha-helices in each monomer which form a hydrophobic interface. As a first step in analysing the specificity of this interaction, we examined the mutant L251A. LacR bearing this mutation in a background lacking the C-terminal heptad repeats is completely incapable of forming dimers in solution, with a dimer-monomer equilibrium dissociation constant, or Kd, higher than 10(-5)M. This correlates with a 200-fold decrease in its ability to repress the lac operon in vivo compared to dimeric LacR. Surprisingly, the mutant is still capable of forming dimers upon binding to short operator DNA in vitro. Analysis of the kinetic parameters of binding of the mutant to operator DNA reveals a 2000 to 3000-fold increase in the equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) of the mutant-DNA complex in comparison to dimeric LacR-operator complexes, with the change almost entirely due to a greater than 1000-fold decrease in association rate. The dissociation rate varies only by a factor of about two, in comparison to dimeric LacR. This change reflects a kinetic pathway in which dimer formation, in solution or on DNA, is the rate-limiting step. These findings have implications for the specificity and stability of the protein-protein interface in question.

Specific contacts between residues in the DNA-binding domain of the TyrR protein and bases in the operator of the tyrP gene of Escherichia coli

In the presence of tyrosine, the TyrR protein of Escherichia coli represses the expression of the tyrP gene by binding to the double TyrR boxes which overlap the promoter. Previously, we have carried out methylation, uracil, and ethylation interference experiments and have identified both guanine and thymine bases and phosphates within the TyrR box sequences that are contacted by the TyrR protein (J. S. Hwang, J. Yang, and A. J. Pittard, J. Bacteriol. 179:1051-1058, 1997). In this study, we have used missing contact probing to test the involvement of all of the bases within the tyrP operator in the binding of TyrR. Our results indicate that nearly all the bases within the palindromic arms of the strong and weak boxes are important for the binding of the TyrR protein. Two alanine-substituted mutant TyrR proteins, HA494 and TA495, were purified, and their binding affinities for the tyrP operator were measured by a gel shift assay. HA494 was shown to be completely defective in binding to the tyrP operator in vitro, while, in comparison with wild-Type TyrR, TA495 had only a small reduction in DNA binding. Missing contact probing was performed by using the purified TA495 protein, and the results suggest that T495 makes specific contacts with adenine and thymine bases at the +/-5 positions in the TyrR boxes.

Is nitrocellulose filter binding really a universal assay for protein-DNA interactions?

The ability to bind to nitrocellulose is commonly accepted as being a universal property of proteins and has been widely used in many different fields of study. This property was first exploited in the study of DNA-binding proteins 30 years ago, in studies involving DNA binding by the lactose repressor (LacR) of Escherichia coli. Termed the filter-binding assay, it remains the quickest and easiest assay available for the study of protein-DNA interactions. However, the exact mechanism by which proteins bind to nitrocellulose remains uncertain. Given the supposedly universal nature of the interaction, we were surprised to notice that certain LacR variants were completely unable to bind simultaneously to DNA containing a single lac operator and nitrocellulose. Investigation of this loss of binding suggests that LacR requires a protein region that is both hydrophobic in nature and more or less unstructured, in order to bind to both nitrocellulose and DNA. In the case of wild-type, tetrameric LacR, the DNA-recognition domain that is not bound to DNA suffices. Dimeric LacR variants will only bind if they have certain C-terminal extensions. These experiments sound a cautionary note for the use of filter binding as an assay of choice, particularly in applications involving screening for the DNA-binding site of putative DNA-binding proteins.

Dimeric lac repressors exhibit phase-dependent co-operativity

Transcription of the lac operon in Escherichia coli is repressed by the binding of Lac repressor (LacR) to lac operator O1, a pseudo-palindromic sequence centred 11 bp downstream of the transcription start. Full repression of the wild-type promoter by wild-type, tetrameric LacR requires the presence of at least two operator sequences that must not only be in close proximity to O1, 401 bp and 92 bp for the auxiliary operators O2 and O3, respectively, but must also be present on the same side of the DNA helix. LacR mutants lacking the C-terminal heptad repeat and thus only capable of dimer formation still repress, but at a much reduced level. Their repression of the lac promoter is comparable to repression by tetrameric LacR when both auxiliary operators are destroyed. We have examined the residual repression, by dimeric LacR, of a series of constructs containing a CAP-independent promoter and two lac operators, O1 and Oid, separated by a series of spacers increasing in size by single base-pair increments. Surprisingly, repression of these constructs still exhibits phase dependence. The periodicity of maxima is similar to the helical repeat of DNA in vivo, as measured by phase-dependent repression with tetrameric LacR, although the magnitude of repression is much smaller than that obtained in previous experiments with tetrameric LacR. Two additional variants of dimeric LacR with altered C termini that were tested also show phase dependence. Control experiments show that the presence of O1 is required for repression in this system. In the absence of O1, occupancy of the auxiliary operator does not lead to repression. The magnitudes of repression maxima correlate best with the overall basic nature of the C terminus. Weak, unspecific contacts by this region with DNA seem sufficient to explain the observed periodicity. It remains to be seen whether additional factors are also involved in this residual repression.

Operator search by mutant Lac repressors

The Escherichia coli Lac and Gal repressors are two members of a large family of bacterial repressor proteins that share significant sequence and structural homology. Efficient repression by all family members requires specific binding to a site or sites close to the transcriptional start of the genes regulated. Both LacR and GalR have to bind to at least two sites for efficient repression, yet they differ in one important respect: LacR is a homotetramer whereas GalR is a homodimer. In an attempt to understand this difference, we studied the operator binding activity of a LacR variant that has the DNA-binding specificity of GalR (LacR-V17A18). A tetrameric version of this protein shows a 30-fold decrease in association rate to operator located on a long (lambda) DNA molecule, in comparison to wild-type LacR, while a dimeric version of this protein shows an unaltered association rate in comparison to dimeric LacR. This reduction in association rate correlates with a broadened DNA-binding specificity for base-pairs 4 and 5 of the operator: examination of an additional LacR variant with an even broader DNA-binding specificity indicates that a tetrameric version also shows a 30-fold decrease in association rate in comparison to wild-type LacR, while a dimeric version again shows an unaltered association rate in comparison to dimeric LacR. This difference in association rate in vitro correlates with whether a tetrameric or dimeric variant of LacR of a given DNA-binding specificity will repress lacZ under control of a single operator more efficiently in vivo. We therefore propose that the formation of stable homotetramers becomes a distinct disadvantage unless a high degree of DNA-binding specificity is also present, and demonstrate that this in indeed the case for GalR-mediated repression of the gal operon. This functional constraint seems to have influenced the evolution of the LacI-GalR family of repressors, most of which have a relatively broad specificity of DNA-binding and most of which form only stable homodimers.

Lactose repressor protein: functional properties and structure

The lactose repressor protein (LacI), the prototype for genetic regulatory proteins, controls expression of lactose metabolic genes by binding to its cognate operator sequences in E. coli DNA. Inducer binding elicits a conformational change that diminishes affinity for operator sequences with no effect on nonspecific binding. The release of operator is followed by synthesis of mRNA encoding the enzymes for lactose utilization. Genetic, chemical and physical studies provided detailed insight into the function of this protein prior to the recent completion of X-ray crystallographic structures. The structural information can now be correlated with the phenotypic data for numerous mutants. These structures also provide the opportunity for physical and chemical studies on mutants designed to examine various aspects of lac repressor structure and function. In addition to providing insight into protein structure-function correlations, LacI has been utilized in a wide variety of applications both in prokaryotic gene expression and in eukaryotic gene regulation and studies of mutagenesis.

Combinatorial mutations of lac repressor. Stability of monomer-monomer interface is increased by apolar substitution at position 84

To examine the monomer-monomer subunit interface in the lac repressor, a mutation that generates dimeric protein (deletion of C-terminal amino acids to disrupt the dimer-dimer interface) has been combined with amino acid substitutions that alter the monomer-monomer interface (substitution at Lys84 or Tyr282). Dimeric proteins with significantly increased stability to urea denaturation were formed by the introduction of the apolar amino acids Ala or Leu in lieu of Lys84 in concert with the deletion of 11 C-terminal amino acids. K84A/-11 deletion protein retained wild-type affinity for operator DNA, while K84L/-11 deletion protein displayed operator affinity similar to its parent tetramer. To assess further the influence of monomer-monomer interface stability on assembly and DNA binding, triple mutants were generated with Y282D, an alteration that disrupts assembly completely in the wild-type background. The triple mutants were dimeric, but they exhibited diminished dimer stability to urea denaturation and decreased operator affinity compared with the double mutations. These results demonstrate directly the stabilizing influence of apolar substitution at position 84 on the monomer-monomer interface.

Recognition of DNA by single-chain derivatives of the phage 434 repressor: high affinity binding depends on both the contacted and non-contacted base pairs

Single-chain derivatives of the phage 434 repressor, termed single-chain repressors, contain covalently dimerized DNA-binding domains (DBD) which are connected with a peptide linker in a head-to-tail arrangement. The prototype RR69 contains two wild-type DBDs, while RR*69 contains a wild-type and an engineered DBD. In this latter domain, the DNA- contacting amino acids of thealpha3 helix of the 434 repressor are replaced by the corresponding residues of the related P22 repressor. We have used binding site selection, targeted mutagenesis and binding affinity studies to define the optimum DNA recognition sequence for these single-chain proteins. It is shown that RR69 recognizes DNA sequences containing the consensus boxes of the 434 operators in a palindromic arrangement, and that RR*69 optimally binds to non-palindromic sequences containing a 434 operator box and a TTAA box of which the latter is present in most P22 operators. The spacing of these boxes, as in the 434 operators, is 6 bp. The DNA-binding of both single-chain repressors, similar to that of the 434 repressor, is influenced indirectly by the sequence of the non-contacted, spacer region. Thus, high affinity binding is dependent on both direct and indirect recognition. Nonetheless, the single-chain framework can accommodate certain substitutions to obtain altered DNA-binding specificity and RR*69 represents an example for the combination of altered direct and unchanged indirect readout mechanisms.

Inducible gene expression and environmentally regulated genes in lactic acid bacteria

Relatively recently, a number of genes and operons have been identified in lactic acid bacteria that are inducible and respond to environmental factors. Some of these genes/operons had been isolated and analysed because of their importance in the fermentation industry and, consequently, their transcription was studied and found to be regulatable. Examples are the lactose operon, the operon for nisin production, and genes in the proteolytic pathway of Lactococcus lactis, as well as xylose metabolism in Lactobacillus pentosus. Some other operons were specifically targetted with the aim to compare their mode of regulation with known regulatory mechanisms in other well-studied bacteria. These studies, dealing with the biosynthesis of histidine, tryptophan, and of the branched chain amino acids in L. lactis, have given new insights in gene regulation and in the occurrence of auxotrophy in these bacteria. Also, nucleotide sequence analyses of a number of lactococcal bacteriophages was recently initiated to, among other things, specifically learn more about regulation of the phage life cycle. Yet another approach in the analysis of regulated genes is the 'random' selection of genetic elements that respond to environmental stimuli and the first of such sequences from lactic acid bacteria have been identified and characterized. The potential of these regulatory elements in fundamental research and practical (industrial) applications will be discussed.

Transcription regulation by inflexibility of promoter DNA in a looped complex

The gal operon of Escherichia coli is negatively regulated by repressor binding to bipartite operators separated by 11 helical turns of DNA. Synergistic binding of repressor to separate sites on DNA results in looping, with the intervening DNA as a topologically closed domain containing the two promoters. A closed DNA loop of 11 helical turns, which is in-flexible to torsional changes, disables the promoters either by resisting DNA unwinding needed for open complex formation or by impeding the processive DNA contacts by an RNA polymerase in flux during transcription initiation. Interaction between two proteins bound to different sites on DNA modulating the activity of the intervening segment toward other proteins by allostery may be a common mechanism of regulation in DNA-multiprotein complexes.

Characterization of mutants affecting the KRK sequence in the carboxyl-terminal domain of lac repressor

The lac repressor carboxyl-terminal region is required for tetramer assembly and protein stability. To further investigate this region, especially the unusual sequence KRK, four deletion mutants eliminating the carboxyl-terminal 34, 35, 36, and 39 amino acids and five substitution mutants at the position of Arg-326, R326K, R326A, R326E, R326L, and R326W, were constructed using site-specific mutagenesis. The -34-amino-acid (aa) mutant, missing the most carboxyl-proximal lysine from the KRK sequence, exhibited lower affinity for both operator and inducer and lower protein stability than dimeric proteins studied previously. The -35-aa mutant with RK missing, as well as -36 aa and -39 aa, for which the entire KRK sequence was deleted, yielded inactive polypeptides that could be detected only by monoclonal antibody for lac repressor. In the Arg-326 mutant proteins, operator binding affinity was decreased by approximately 6-fold, the shift in inducer binding at elevated pH was diminished, and protein stability was decreased. Dramatic decreases in protein expression and stability occurred with substitution at position 326 by glutamate, leucine, or tryptophan. These results suggest that Arg-326 plays an important role in the formation of the proper tertiary structure necessary for inducer and operator affinity and for protein stability.

Crystal structure of LacI member, PurR, bound to DNA: minor groove binding by alpha helices

The three-dimensional structure of a ternary complex of the purine repressor, PurR, bound to both its corepressor, hypoxanthine, and the 16-base pair purF operator site has been solved at 2.7 A resolution by x-ray crystallography. The bipartite structure of PurR consists of an amino-terminal DNA-binding domain and a larger carboxyl-terminal corepressor binding and dimerization domain that is similar to that of the bacterial periplasmic binding proteins. The DNA-binding domain contains a helix-turn-helix motif that makes base-specific contacts in the major groove of the DNA. Base contacts are also made by residues of symmetry-related alpha helices, the "hinge" helices, which bind deeply in the minor groove. Critical to hinge helix-minor groove binding is the intercalation of the side chains of Leu54 and its symmetry-related mate, Leu54', into the central CpG-base pair step. These residues thereby act as "leucine levers" to pry open the minor groove and kink the purF operator by 45 degrees.

Structure of the Tet repressor-tetracycline complex and regulation of antibiotic resistance

The most frequently occurring resistance of Gram-negative bacteria against tetracyclines is triggered by drug recognition of the Tet repressor. This causes dissociation of the repressor-operator DNA complex and enables expression of the resistance protein TetA, which is responsible for active efflux of tetracycline. The 2.5 angstrom resolution crystal structure of the homodimeric Tet repressor complexed with tetracycline-magnesium reveals detailed drug recognition. The orientation of the operator-binding helix-turn-helix motifs of the repressor is inverted in comparison with other DNA binding proteins. The repressor-drug complex is unable to interact with DNA because the separation of the DNA binding motifs is 5 angstroms wider than usually observed.

Control of gal transcription through DNA looping: inhibition of the initial transcribing complex

Involvement of DNA looping between two spatially separated gal operators, OE and OI, in repression of the gal operon has been demonstrated in vivo. An in vitro transcription assay using a minicircle DNA containing the gal promoter region with lac operators was employed to elucidate the molecular mechanism of repression. Wild-type lac repressors (LacI+ protein molecules), which are capable of associating into a tetramer and forming a DNA loop, repressed transcription from promoter sites P1 and P2, whereas a non-looping lac repressor mutant (LacI(adi)) failed to show normal repression of both of the gal promoters. Thus a DNA loop is also required for repression of transcription in vitro. Repression mediated by DNA looping resulted in the inhibition of the synthesis of complete as well as aborted transcripts, demonstrating that the repressive action was on the formation or activity of the initial transcribing complex. Under similar conditions, the gal repressor (GalR protein) did not repress the gal promoters effectively, apparently because it failed to loop DNA containing gal operators in the purified system. The component(s) or conditions that aid GalR in DNA looping remain to be identified.

Specificities of three tight-binding Lac repressors

Tight binding mutants of Lac repressor exhibit complex repression phenomena. In this work, in vivo Lac operator binding of three such mutants of E. coli Lac repressor (X86: ser 61-leu, l12: pro 3-tyr and the double mutant l12X86: pro 3-tyr, ser 61-leu) was analyzed. Repression of beta-galactosidase synthesis controlled by ideal lac operator and its 27 symmetric operator variants containing each possible base-pair at each single half-operator position in the presence of the tight-binding Lac repressor mutants was determined. The average increase of repression with all operator variants was about 3 fold with the X86 mutant. It was about 4 fold with the l12 mutant and about 2 fold with the double mutant l12X86 as compared to wildtype Lac repressor. The X86 mutant showed the same increase of affinity to all operator variants, whereas the l12 and l12X86 mutants exhibited lower repression with some variants than with most others. These results suggest that the X86 mutant has gained no additional specificity. In contrast the l12 mutant and the l12X86 mutant exhibit a relaxed specificity for certain base pairs in positions 1 and 3 of lac operator. This suggests that the extreme N-terminus of Lac repressor may interact with the inner base-pairs in the minor groove.

Sliding and intermolecular transfer of the lac repressor: kinetic perturbation of a reaction intermediate by a distant DNA sequence

The lac repressor associates with its operator at a rate faster than conventional diffusion allows, either because of one-dimensional diffusion of a captured repressor along the DNA (sliding) or because the tetrameric repressor can be rapidly transferred between DNA sites distant from each other in the primary sequence (direct transfer). We report measurements of relative repressor-operator association rates at physiological operator concentrations. We assay for the ability of DNA targets of equal length (approximately 200 base pairs) containing one or six operator segments to compete for repressor; as the sliding range decreases, the hexameric operator fragment should react up to six times faster than the monomeric operator fragment. We find that the advantage enjoyed by the hexameric fragment varies from little to none at low operator concentration (depending on ionic strength) to more than 3-fold at high concentration. We ascribe this behavior to sliding at low operator concentration and to an increasing contribution of bimolecular direct transfer events as concentration increases. The observations require a "semibound" intermediate state of the protein at operator sites. This species can either undergo a relatively slow (tau greater than 1 sec) unimolecular isomerization to the final complex, or the isomerization can occur in a bridged complex with another operator site, accompanied by transfer to the second operator with probability of 0.5. Bridging alters one or more rate constants in the complex.

Two-dimensional 1H, 15N NMR investigation of uniformly 15N-labeled lac repressor headpiece

15N uniformly labeled lac repressor and lac repressor headpiece were prepared. 15N NMR spectra of lac repressor were shown resolution inadequate for detailed study while the data showed that the 15N labeled N-terminal part of the protein is quite suitable for this type of study allowing future investigation of the specific interaction of the lac repressor headpiece with the lac operator. We report here the total assignment of proton 1H and nitrogen 15NH backbone resonances of this headpiece in the free state. Assignments of the 15N resonances of the protein were obtained in a sequential manner using heteronuclear multiple quantum coherence (HMQC), relayed HMQC nuclear Overhauser and relayed HMQC-HOHAHA spectroscopy. More than 80 per cent of residues were assigned by their 15NH(i)-N1H(i + 1) and 15NH(i)-N1H(i - 1) connectivities. Values of the 3JNH alpha splitting for 39 of the 51 residues of the headpiece were extracted from HMQC and HMQC-J. The observed 15NH(i)-C beta H cross peaks and the 3JNH alpha coupling constants values are in agreement with the three alpha-helices previously described [Zuiderweg, E.R.P., Scheek, R.M., Boelens, R., van Gunsteren, W.F. and Kaptein, R., Biochimie 67, 707 (1985)]. The 3JNH alpha coupling constants can be now used for a more confident determination of the lac repressor headpiece. From these values it is shown that the geometry of the ends of the second and third alpha-helices exhibit deviation from the canonical alpha-helix structure. On the basis of NOEs and 3JNH alpha values, the geometry of the turn of the helix-turn-helix motif is discussed.

Effect of lac repressor oligomerization on regulatory outcome

Regulatory outcome in a bacterial operon depends on the interactions of all the components which influence mRNA production. Levels of mRNA can be altered profoundly by both negative and positive regulatory elements which modulate initiation of transcription. The occupancy of regulatory sites on the DNA by repressors and activators is determined not only by the affinity of these proteins for their cognate site(s) but also by the oligomeric state of the regulatory protein. The lac operon in Escherichia coli provides an excellent prototypic example of the influence of protein assembly on the transcriptional status of the associated structural genes. DNA loop formation is essential for maximal repression of the lac operon and is contingent upon the presence of multiple operator sites in the DNA and the ability of the repressor to self-associate to form a bidentate tetramer. The stability of this looped complex is enhanced significantly by DNA supercoiling. Tetramer assembly from dimers apparently occurs via interactions of a 'leucine zipper' motif in the C-terminal domain of the protein, and the tetramer is essential to formation of looped complexes. Furthermore, analysis of the DNA-binding characteristics of dimeric mutants has established that the monomer-dimer association and dimer-DNA binding (monomer does not bind to DNA) are coupled equilibria. Thus, dimer assembly is essential for generating a DNA-binding unit, and tetramer assembly is required for formation of the stable looped DNA structure that maximally represses mRNA synthesis. Protein-protein interactions therefore play a pivotal role in the regulatory activities of the lac repressor and must be considered when analysing the activities of any oligomeric DNA-binding protein.

31P NMR spectra of oligodeoxyribonucleotide duplex lac operator-repressor headpiece complexes: importance of phosphate ester backbone flexibility in protein-DNA recognition

The 31P NMR spectra of various 14-base-pair lac operators bound to both wild-type and mutant lac repressor headpiece proteins were analyzed to provide information on the backbone conformation in the complexes. The 31P NMR spectrum of a wild-type symmetrical operator, d(TGTGAGCGCTCACA)2, bound to the N-terminal 56-residue headpiece fragment of a Y7I mutant repressor was nearly identical to the spectrum of the same operator bound to the wild-type repressor headpiece. In contrast, the 31P NMR spectrum of the mutant operator, d(TATAGAGCGCTCATA)2, wild-type headpiece complex was significantly perturbed relative to the wild-type repressor-operator complex. The 31P chemical shifts of the phosphates of a second mutant operator, d(TGTGTGCGCACACA)2, showed small but specific changes upon complexation with either the wild-type or mutant headpiece. The 31P chemical shifts of the phosphates of a third mutant operator, d(TCTGAGCGCTCAGA)2, showed no perturbations upon addition of the wild-type headpiece. The 31P NMR results provide further evidence for predominant recognition of the 5'-strand of the 5'-TGTGA/3'-ACACT binding site in a 2:1 protein to headpiece complex. It is proposed that specific, strong-binding operator-protein complexes retain the inherent phosphate ester conformational flexibility of the operator itself, whereas the phosphate esters are conformationally restricted in the weak-binding operator-protein complexes. This retention of backbone torsional freedom in strong complexes is entropically favorable and provides a new (and speculative) mechanism for protein discrimination of different operator binding sites. It demonstrates the potential importance of phosphate geometry and flexibility on protein recognition and binding.

Orientation of the Lac repressor DNA binding domain in complex with the left lac operator half site characterized by affinity cleaving

Lac repressor (LacR) is a helix-turn-helix motif sequence-specific DNA binding protein. Based on proton NMR spectroscopic investigations, Kaptein and co-workers have proposed that the helix-turn-helix motif of LacR binds to DNA in an orientation opposite to that of the helix-turn-helix motifs of lambda repressor, lambda cro, 434 repressor, 434 cro, and CAP [Boelens, R., Scheek, R., van Boom, J. and Kaptein, R., J. Mol. Biol. 193, 1987, 213-216]. In the present work, we have determined the orientation of the helix-turn-helix motif of LacR in the LacR-DNA complex by the affinity cleaving method. The DNA cleaving moiety EDTA.Fe was attached to the N-terminus of a 56-residue synthetic protein corresponding to the DNA binding domain of LacR. We have formed the complex between the modified protein and the left DNA half site for LacR. The locations of the resulting DNA cleavage positions relative to the left DNA half site provide strong support for the proposal of Kaptein and co-workers.

A model of the lac repressor-operator complex based on physical and genetic data

Computer graphics were used to build a molecular model of the complex of Lac repressor and lac operator. The model is based (a) on the NMR data of the Kaptein group [Boelens, R., Lamerichs, R. M. J. N., Rullmann, J. A. C., van Boom, J. H. & Kaptein, R. (1988) Protein Sequence Data Anal. 1, 487-498] and (b) on our genetic and biochemical data including specificity changes [Lehming, N., Sartorius, J., Kisters-Woike, B., von Wilcken-Bergmann, B. & Müller-Hill, B. (1990) EMBO J. 9, 615-621]. Effects of amino acid exchanges in the recognition helix could be predicted by the model and were subsequently tested and confirmed by genetic experiments. Comparison of the modelled lac complex with the known crystallographic structures of several helix-turn-helix DNA complexes reveals striking similarities and suggests rules which govern the recognition between particular amino acid side chains and particular base pairs in these systems.

Linker mutagenesis in the lacZ gene of Escherichia coli yields variants of active beta-galactosidase

Synthetic octameric oligonucleotides that code for a unique restriction site were cloned into a randomly linearized plasmid that carries the lacZ gene. The insertions were mapped by digestion with appropriate restriction endonucleases. 12 mutants were identified which carry an insertion within the lacZ gene and still express active beta-galactosidase. Small deletions or duplications of the wild-type sequence occurred at these positions which restore the correct reading frame. The insertions occurred in the first and the last third of the internal duplication of the lacZ gene and within the domain homologous to dihydrofolate reductase.

Assignment of the 1H-NMR spectrum of a lac repressor headpiece-operator complex in H2O and identification of NOEs. Consequences for protein-DNA interaction

A complex between the headpiece amino-terminal residues 1-56 of lac repressor (HP56) and an 11-bp lac operator fragment was studied by 1H NMR. The sequence specific assignment of the exchangeable and non-exchangeable protons has been accomplished. Several protons have favourable chemical shifts in the complex, therefore new intraprotein NOEs could be found that had not been unambigously identified in the free protein. By comparison, most of these intraprotein NOEs are also present in the spectra of the free headpiece but some are different. Furthermore, several new proteins DNA NOEs could be identified. The NOE between the side-chain amide protons of Gln18 and C5H of C7 confirms the specific contact between these residues which was proposed from genetic experiments [Ebright, R. M. (1985) J. Biomol. Struct. & Dyn. 3, 281-297]. The implications of the new data for the interaction between the lac repressor headpiece and its operator are discussed.

Identification of a contact between arginine-180 of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) and base pair 5 of the DNA site in the CAP-DNA complex

We have used site-directed mutagenesis to replace amino acid 1 of the recognition alpha-helix of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP), Arg-180, with glycine and with alanine. Substitution of Arg-180 of CAP eliminated specificity between G.C, A.T, C.G, and T.A at base pair 5 of the DNA half-site. The effect was position-specific: substitution of Arg-180 did not eliminate specificity between G.C, A.T, C.G, and T.A at base pair 7 of the DNA half-site. We conclude, in agreement with the model for the structure of the CAP-DNA complex [Weber, I. & Steitz, T. (1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 3973-3977; and Ebright, R., Cossart, P., Gicquel-Sanzey, B. & Beckwith, J. (1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 7274-7278], that Arg-180 of CAP makes a specificity-determining contact with base pair 5 of the DNA half-site in the CAP-DNA complex. The identification of the contact by Arg-180 in this report, in conjunction with the identification of the contact by Glu-181 in a previous report [Ebright, R., Cossart, P., Gicquel-Sanzey, B. & Beckwith, J. (1984) Nature (London) 311, 232-235], provides information sufficient to define the orientation of the helix-turn-helix motif of CAP with respect to DNA in the CAP-DNA complex.

DNA looping in cellular repression of transcription of the galactose operon

Communication between distant DNA sites is a central feature of many DNA transactions. Negative regulation of the galactose (gal) operon of Escherichia coli requires repressor binding to two operator sites located on opposite sides of the promoter. The proposed mechanism for regulation involves binding of the repressor to both operator sites, followed by a protein-protein association that loops the intervening promoter DNA (double occupancy plus association). To assess these requirements in vivo, we have previously converted gal operator sites to lac and shown that both operator sites must be occupied by the homologous repressor protein (Lac or Gal) for negative regulation of the gal operon. We have now addressed more directly the need for protein-protein association by the use of the converted operator sites and a mutant Lac repressor defective in association of the DNA-binding dimers. We have compared the biological and biochemical activity of two Lac repressors: the wild-type (tetramer) I+ form, in which the DNA-binding dimer units are tightly associated; and the mutant Iadi repressor, in which the dimer units do not associate effectively. The I+ repressor is an efficient negative regulator of the gal operon in vivo, but the Iadi mutant is an ineffective repressor. Purified I+ repressor efficiently forms DNA loops between operator sites that we have visualized by electron microscopy; the Iadi repressor fails to form DNA loops, although the protein binds effectively to both operator sites. From the clear correlation between looping in vitro and repression in vivo, we conclude that regulation of the gal operon depends on the association of repressor proteins bound to the two operator sites.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

MalI, a novel protein involved in regulation of the maltose system of Escherichia coli, is highly homologous to the repressor proteins GalR, CytR, and LacI

The maltose regulon of Escherichia coli comprises several operons that are under common regulatory control of the MalT activator protein. Five mal genes, organized in two divergent operons, code for a binding-protein-dependent transport system specific for maltose and maltodextrins. MalK, one of the subunits of this transport system, not only is essential for transport but also plays a role in regulation. Mutations abolishing MalK function not only result in inability to transport maltose but also cause constitutive expression of the maltose regulon. For this constitutivity to be exerted, the function of an additional gene product, MalI, is necessary. Using the constitutive expression of a malK-lacZ fusion as a signal, we cloned the malI gene, expressed it in minicells, and determined its DNA sequence. The sequence predicted a protein of 34,729 molecular weight, in agreement with the apparent molecular weight of the protein (35,000) when expressed in minicells and analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and autoradiography. MalI exhibited high homology to the repressor proteins GalR, CytR, and LacI. When the amino acid sequences were appropriately aligned, MalI showed 28% identity to GalR, 21% to CytR, and 24% to LacI. Including conservative amino acid exchanges, these numbers increased to 69, 56, and 58%, respectively. The regions of high homology were clustered in particular at the N-terminal portion of the protein that includes the helix-turn-helix motif thought to be involved in DNA binding. The protein contained a short stretch of 30 amino acids that was surprisingly homologous to a sequence in MalT. The amino-terminal half of the protein exhibited significant homology with MalK. The transcriptional start of malI was determined by reverse transcriptase and by S1 nuclease mapping. We found a possible binding site for cyclic AMP receptor protein in the promoter region of malI as well as two perfect direct repeats of 14 base pairs with twofold symmetry indicating their possible role as operator sites. Upstream to malI we observed a divergent open reading frame that extended to the end of the sequenced DNA.

Binding of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein to DNA fragments containing consensus nucleotide sequences

Binding of the Escherichia coli CRP protein to DNA fragments carrying nucleotide sequences closely corresponding to the consensus is very tight with a dissociation time of over 2 h in our conditions. The concentration of cyclic AMP required for this binding is below the physiological range of intracellular cyclic AMP concentrations. Changes in nucleotide sequence at positions that are not well-conserved between different naturally-occurring CRP sites allow a more rapid dissociation of CRP-DNA complexes. There is an inverse correlation between the stability of CRP binding to sites in vitro and the repression by glucose of expression dependent on these sites in vivo: expression that is dependent on the tighter binding sites cannot be repressed by the inclusion of glucose in the growth medium.

Purification and characterization of RepA, a protein involved in the copy number control of plasmid pLS1

The promiscuous streptococcal plasmid pLS1 encodes for the 5.1 kDa RepA protein, involved in the regulation of the plasmid copy number. Synthesis of RepA was observed both in Bacillus subtilis minicells and in an Escherichia coli expression system. From this system, the protein has been purified and it appears to be a dimer of identical subunits. The amino acid sequence of RepA has been determined. RepA shows the alpha helix-turn-alpha helix motif typical of many DNA-binding proteins and it shares homology with a number of repressors, specially with the TrfB repressor encoded by the broad-host-range plasmid RK2. DNase I footprinting revealed that the RepA target is located in the region of the promoter for the repA and repB genes. Trans-complementation analysis showed that in vivo, RepA behaves as a repressor by regulating the plasmid copy number. We propose that the regulatory role of RepA is by limitation of the synthesis of the initiator protein RepB.