Detection and characterization of mammalian DNA polymerase beta mutants by functional complementation in Escherichia coli

Incompatibility and Interchangeability in Molecular Evolution

There is remarkable variation in the rate at which genetic incompatibilities in molecular interactions accumulate. In some cases, minor changes-even single-nucleotide substitutions-create major incompatibilities when hybridization forces new variants to function in a novel genetic background from an isolated population. In other cases, genes or even entire functional pathways can be horizontally transferred between anciently divergent evolutionary lineages that span the tree of life with little evidence of incompatibilities. In this review, we explore whether there are general principles that can explain why certain genes are prone to incompatibilities while others maintain interchangeability. We summarize evidence pointing to four genetic features that may contribute to greater resistance to functional replacement: (1) function in multisubunit enzyme complexes and protein-protein interactions, (2) sensitivity to changes in gene dosage, (3) rapid rate of sequence evolution, and (4) overall importance to cell viability, which creates sensitivity to small perturbations in molecular function. We discuss the relative levels of support for these different hypotheses and lay out future directions that may help explain the striking contrasts in patterns of incompatibility and interchangeability throughout the history of molecular evolution.

Heterogeneity in expression of DNA polymerase beta and DNA repair activity in human tumor cell lines

The 39-kDa DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) is an essential enzyme in short-patch base excision repair pathway. A wild-type and a truncated forms of pol beta proteins are expressed in primary colorectal and breast adenocarcinomas and in a primary culture of renal cell carcinoma. To test whether pol beta has a contributory role in tumorigenicity of human tumor cell lines, we have undertaken a study to determine expression of pol beta in colon, breast, and prostate tumor cell lines. Unlike primary colon tumor cells, three types of pol beta mRNA have been identified in HCT116, LoVo, and DLD1, colon tumor cell lines. A 111-bp-deleted pol beta transcript was expressed in MCF7, a breast tumor cell line, but not in primary breast tumor cells. An expression of a smaller pol beta transcript has been revealed in DU145, a prostate tumor cell line, whereas, a single base (T) deletion in mRNA at codon 191 was found in prostate cancer tissue. Interestingly, a wild-type pol beta transcript was also expressed in all tumor cell lines similar to primary tumor cells. Furthermore, the cell extract of LoVo exhibited highest gap-filling synthesis function of pol beta when the extract of DU145 showed lowest activity. MNNG, a DNA alkylating agent, enhanced the gap-filling synthesis activity in extracts of LoVo cell line. Furthermore, the cellular viability of LoVo and HCT116 cells is sensitive to MNNG when DU145 cells are resistant. These results demonstrate heterogeneity in pol beta mRNA expression, which may be a risk factor related to tumorigenic activities of tumor cell lines.

Cellular roles of DNA polymerase beta

Since its discovery and purification in 1971, DNA polymerase ß (Pol ß) is one of the most well-studied DNA polymerases. Pol ß is a key enzyme in the base excision repair (BER) pathway that functions in gap filling DNA synthesis subsequent to the excision of damaged DNA bases. A major focus of our studies is on the cellular roles of Pol ß. We have shown that germline and tumor-associated variants of Pol ß catalyze aberrant BER that leads to genomic instability and cellular transformation. Our studies suggest that Pol ß is critical for the maintenance of genomic stability and that it is a tumor suppressor. We have also shown that Pol ß functions during Prophase I of meiosis. Pol ß localizes to the synaptonemal complex and is critical for removal of the Spo11 complex from the 5' ends of double-strand breaks. Studies with Pol ß mutant mice are currently being undertaken to more clearly understand the function of Pol ß during meiosis. In this review, we will highlight our contributions from our studies of Pol ß germline and cancer-associated variants.

Generation and characterization of new highly thermostable and processive M-MuLV reverse transcriptase variants

In vitro synthesis of cDNA is one of the most important techniques in present molecular biology. Faithful synthesis of long cDNA on highly structured RNA templates requires thermostable and processive reverse transcriptases. In a recent attempt to increase the thermostability of the wt Moloney Murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase (M-MuLV RT), we have employed the compartmentalized ribosome display (CRD) evolution in vitro technique and identified a large set of previously unknown mutations that enabled cDNA synthesis at elevated temperatures. In this study, we have characterized a group of the M-MuLV RT variants (28 novel amino acid positions, 84 point mutants) carrying the individual mutations. The performance of point mutants (thermal inactivation rate, substrate-binding affinity and processivity) correlated remarkably well with the mutation selection frequency in the CRD experiment. By combining the best-performing mutations D200N, L603W, T330P, L139P and E607K, we have generated highly processive and thermostable multiply-mutated M-MuLV RT variants. The processivity of the best-performing multiple mutant increased to 1500 nt (65-fold improvement in comparison to the wt enzyme), and the maximum temperature of the full-length 7.5-kb cDNA synthesis was raised to 62°C (17° higher in comparison with the wt enzyme).

Antimutator variants of DNA polymerases

Evolution balances DNA replication speed and accuracy to optimize replicative fitness and genetic stability. There is no selective pressure to improve DNA replication fidelity beyond the background mutation rate from other sources, such as DNA damage. However, DNA polymerases remain amenable to amino acid substitutions that lower intrinsic error rates. Here, we review these 'antimutagenic' changes in DNA polymerases and discuss what they reveal about mechanisms of replication fidelity. Pioneering studies with bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase (T4 Pol) established the paradigm that antimutator amino acid substitutions reduce replication errors by increasing proofreading efficiency at the expense of polymerase processivity. The discoveries of antimutator substitutions in proofreading-deficient 'mutator' derivatives of bacterial Pols I and III and yeast Pol δ suggest there must be additional antimutagenic mechanisms. Remarkably, many of the affected amino acid positions from Pol I, Pol III, and Pol δ are similar to the original T4 Pol substitutions. The locations of antimutator substitutions within DNA polymerase structures suggest that they may increase nucleotide selectivity and/or promote dissociation of primer termini from polymerases poised for misincorporation, leading to expulsion of incorrect nucleotides. If misincorporation occurs, enhanced primer dissociation from polymerase domains may improve proofreading in cis by an intrinsic exonuclease or in trans by alternate cellular proofreading activities. Together, these studies reveal that natural selection can readily restore replication error rates to sustainable levels following an adaptive mutator phenotype.

Toward safe genetically modified organisms through the chemical diversification of nucleic acids

It is argued that genetic proliferation should be rationally extended so as to enable the propagation in vivo of additional types of nucleic acids (XNA for 'xeno-nucleic acids'), whose chemical backbone motifs would differ from deoxyribose and ribose, and whose polymerization would not interfere with DNA and RNA biosynthesis. Because XNA building blocks do not occur in nature, they would have to be synthesized and supplied to cells which would be equipped with an appropriate enzymatic machinery for polymerizing them. The invasion of plants and animals with XNA replicons can be envisioned in the long run, but it is in microorganisms, and more specifically in bacteria, that the feasibility of such chemical systems and the establishment of genetic enclaves separated from DNA and RNA is more likely to take place. The introduction of expanded coding through additional or alternative pairing will be facilitated by the propagation of replicons based on alternative backbone motifs and leaving groups, as enabled by XNA polymerases purposefully evolved to this end.

Polymerase engineering: towards the encoded synthesis of unnatural biopolymers

DNA is not only a repository of genetic information for life, it is also a unique polymer with remarkable properties: it associates according to well-defined rules, it can be assembled into diverse nanostructures of defined geometry, it can be evolved to bind ligands and catalyse chemical reactions and it can serve as a supramolecular scaffold to arrange chemical groups in space. However, its chemical makeup is rather uniform and the physicochemical properties of the four canonical bases only span a narrow range. Much wider chemical diversity is accessible through solid-phase synthesis but oligomers are limited to <100 nucleotides and variations in chemistry can usually not be replicated and thus are not amenable to evolution. Recent advances in nucleic acid chemistry and polymerase engineering promise to bring the synthesis, replication and ultimately evolution of nucleic acid polymers with greatly expanded chemical diversity within our reach.

The evolution of DNA polymerases with novel activities

DNA and RNA polymerases have evolved in nature to function in specific environments with specific substrates. Thus, although the commercial availability of these enzymes has revolutionized the biotechnology industry, their applications are limited. The availability of polymerases that have unnatural properties would be of even greater utility. Towards this goal, several activity-based screening and selection approaches have been developed. Using these techniques, polymerases that synthesize a variety of different polymers, including those containing 2'-O-methyl-modified nucleotides or unnatural base pairs, have been evolved. These results suggest that polymerases tailored for any specific application could soon be available.

Mammary carcinogenesis in transgenic mice expressing a dominant-negative mutant of DNA polymerase beta in their mammary glands

DNA polymerase beta (polbeta) is a major contributor to mammalian DNA damage repair through its gap-filling DNA synthesis and 5'-deoxyribose phosphate lyase activities. In this way, polbeta plays pivotal roles in the repair of oxidative DNA damage, replication, embryonic survival, neuronal development, meiosis, apoptosis and telomere function. A 36 kDa truncated polbetaDelta protein is expressed in human colorectal, breast, lung and renal carcinomas, but not in normal matched tissues. Interestingly, a binary protein-protein complex of polbetaDelta and X-ray cross-complementing group 1 acts as dominant-negative mutant. In this study, the potential tumorigenic activity of polbetaDelta was examined in nude and transgenic mouse models. Mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) expressing polbetaDelta in the absence of endogenous polbeta exhibited increased susceptibility to N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU)-induced morphological transformation as compared with cells expressing wild-type (WT) polbeta. This was accompanied by reduced gap-filling DNA synthesis activity. Anchorage-independent transformed cells derived from polbetaDelta-expressing MEFs induced 100% tumor occurrence in nude mice. To support these data, we established transgenic mice expressing polbetaDelta specifically in the mammary glands from a whey acidic protein promoter-driven transgene. This is the first report of transgenic mice with tissue-specific expression of polbetaDelta. MNU-induced tumor formation was analyzed in transgenic mice expressing polbetaDelta together with endogenous WT polbeta in their mammary glands and in normal control mice expressing only WT polbeta. The latent period of tumor appearance was markedly shorter and tumor incidence was significantly higher in transgenic animals than in control animals treated under the same conditions. These results indicate that cells expressing the mutant polbetaDelta display an enhanced sensitivity to MNU that probably underlies an increased susceptibility to tumorigenesis.

Polymorphisms of the DNA polymerase beta gene in breast cancer

DNA polymerase beta (Polbeta) provides most of the gap-filling synthesis at apurinic/apyrimidine sites of damaged DNA in the base excision repair pathway. Mutations in the gene encoding DNA polbeta have been identified in various carcinomas. We performed a case-control study to test the association between two polymorphisms in the polbeta gene: a Pro --> Arg change at codon 242 (the Pro242Arg polymorphism) and a Lys --> Met change at codon 289 (the Lys289Met polymorphism) and breast cancer risk and cancer progression. Genotypes were determined in DNA from peripheral blood lymphocytes of 150 breast cancer patients and 150 cancer-free, age-matched women (controls) by PCR-RFLP. A strong association between breast cancer occurrence and the Met/Met phenotype of the Lys289Met polymorphism [odds ratio (OR) 3.67; 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.87-7.56] and the Pro/Arg phenotype of the Pro242Lys polymorphism (OR 1.96; 95% CI 1.15-3.34) was found. Polymorphism-polymorphism interaction between the Met/Met phenotype of the Lys289Met and the Pro/Arg phenotype of the Pro242Arg variants increased the risk of breast cancer (OR 3.05; 95% CI 1.31-7.09). We did not observe any correlation between studied polymorphisms and breast cancer progression evaluated by node-metastasis, tumor size and Bloom-Richardson grading. In conclusion, Polbeta may play a role in the breast carcinogenesis and the Lys289Met polymorphism of the polbeta gene may be considered as an independent, early, molecular diagnostic marker in breast cancer. The Pro242Arg polymorphism may contribute to the carcinogenesis through the interaction with the Lys289Met and therefore may be regarded as a dependent, auxiliary marker.

A Novel Nuclear Protein, MGC5306 Interacts with DNA Polymerase β and Has a Potential Role in Cellular Phenotype

A novel protein MGC5306 has been identified in yeast-two-hybrid analysis by screening a HeLa cDNA library with a truncated DNA polymerasebeta (polbetaDelta) as bait. The polbetaDelta is expressed in various types of cancers. Co-immunoprecipitation-Western blot analysis confirms not only its interaction with polbetaDelta but also with wild-type polbeta. Binding to polbeta indicates potential function of MGC5306 in repair pathway. Transfection of cells with MGC5306-GFP and Western blot analysis with anti-MGC5306 antibody reveal its nuclear localization. MGC5306 is expressed in human carcinomas and tumor cell lines but not in normal tissues, suggesting MGC5306 is most likely involved in carcinogenesis. An antigrowth activity and modulations of cell cycle events are identified in cells expressing siRNAMGC5306.

Analysis of the DNA joining repertoire of Chlorella virus DNA ligase and a new crystal structure of the ligase-adenylate intermediate

Chlorella virus DNA ligase is the smallest eukaryotic ATP-dependent DNA ligase known; it suffices for yeast cell growth in lieu of the essential yeast DNA ligase Cdc9. The Chlorella virus ligase-adenylate intermediate has an intrinsic nick sensing function and its DNA footprint extends 8-9 nt on the 3'-hydroxyl (3'-OH) side of the nick and 11-12 nt on the 5'-phosphate (5'-PO4) side. Here we establish the minimal length requirements for ligatable 3'-OH and 5'-PO4 strands at the nick (6 nt) and describe a new crystal structure of the ligase-adenylate in a state construed to reflect the configuration of the active site prior to nick recognition. Comparison with a previous structure of the ligase-adenylate bound to sulfate (a mimetic of the nick 5'-PO4) suggests how the positions and contacts of the active site components and the bound adenylate are remodeled by DNA binding. We find that the minimal Chlorella virus ligase is capable of catalyzing non-homologous end-joining reactions in vivo in yeast, a process normally executed by the structurally more complex cellular Lig4 enzyme. Our results suggest a model of ligase evolution in which: (i) a small 'pluripotent' ligase is the progenitor of the much larger ligases found presently in eukaryotic cells and (ii) gene duplications, variations within the core ligase structure and the fusion of new domains to the core structure (affording new protein-protein interactions) led to the compartmentalization of eukaryotic ligase function, i.e. by enhancing some components of the functional repertoire of the ancestral ligase while disabling others.

Threonine 79 is a hinge residue that governs the fidelity of DNA polymerase beta by helping to position the DNA within the active site

DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) is an ideal system for studying the role of its different amino acid residues in the fidelity of DNA synthesis. In this study, the T79S variant of pol beta was identified using an in vivo genetic screen. T79S is located in the N-terminal 8-kDa domain of pol beta and has no contact with either the DNA template or the incoming dNTP substrate. The T79S protein produced 8-fold more multiple mutations in the herpes simplex virus type 1-thymidine kinase assay than wild-type pol beta. Surprisingly, T79S is a misincorporation mutator only when using a 3'-recessed primer-template. In the presence of a single nucleotide-gapped DNA substrate, T79S displays an antimutator phenotype when catalyzing DNA synthesis opposite template C and has similar fidelity as wild type opposite templates A, G, or T. Threonine 79 is located directly between two helix-hairpin-helix motifs located within the 8-kDa and thumb domains of pol beta. As the pol beta enzyme closes into its active form, the helix-hairpin-helix motifs appear to assist in the production and stabilization of a 90 degrees bend of the DNA. The function of the bent DNA is to present the templating base to the incoming nucleotide substrate. We propose that Thr-79 is part of a hydrogen bonding network within the helix-hairpin-helix motifs that is important for positioning the DNA within the active site. We suggest that alteration of Thr-79 to Ser disrupts this hydrogen bonding network and results in an enzyme that is unable to bend the DNA into the proper geometry for accurate DNA synthesis.

Structure-based combinatorial protein engineering (SCOPE)

Presented here is the development a semi-rational protein engineering approach that uses information from protein structure coupled with established DNA manipulation techniques to design and create multiple crossover libraries from non-homologous genes. The utility of structure-based combinatorial protein engineering (SCOPE) was demonstrated by its application to two distantly related members of the X-family of DNA polymerases: rat DNA polymerase beta (Pol beta) and African swine fever virus DNA polymerase X (Pol X). These proteins share similar folds but have low sequence identity, and differ greatly in both size and activity. "Equivalent" subdomain elements of structure were designed on the basis of the tertiary structure of Pol beta and the corresponding regions of Pol X were inferred from homology modeling and sequence alignment analysis. Libraries of chimeric genes with up to five crossovers were synthesized in a series of PCR reactions by employing hybrid oligonucleotides that code for variable connections between structural elements. Genetic complementation in Escherichia coli enabled identification of several novel DNA polymerases with enhanced phenotypes. Both the composition of structural elements and the manner in which they were linked were shown to be essential for this property, indicating the importance of these aspects of design.

Enzymatic properties of rat DNA polymerase beta mutants obtained by randomized mutagenesis

We have used random sequence mutagenesis to generate mutants of DNA polymerase beta in an effort to identify amino acid residues important for function, catalytic efficiency and fidelity of replication. A library containing 100 000 mutants at residues 274-278 in the N-helix of the thumb subdomain of the polymerase was constructed and screened for polymerase activity by genetic complementation. The genetic screen identified 4000 active pol beta mutants, 146 of which were sequenced. Each of the five positions mutagenized tolerated substitutions, but residues G274 and F278 were only found substituted in combination with mutations at other positions. The least conserved residue, D276, was replaced by a variety of amino acids and, therefore, does not appear to be essential for function. Steady-state kinetic analysis, however, demonstrated that D276 may be important for catalytic efficiency. Mutant D276E exhibited a 25-fold increase in catalytic efficiency over the wild-type enzyme but also a 25-fold increase in G:T misincorporation efficiency. We present a structural model that can account for the observations and we discuss the implications of this study for the question of enzyme optimization by natural selection.

Base excision repair in yeast and mammals

Base excision repair (BER), as initiated by at least seven different DNA glycosylases or by enzymes that cleave DNA at abasic sites, executes the repair of a wide variety of DNA damages. Many of these damages arise spontaneously because DNA interacts with the cellular milieu, and so BER profoundly influences spontaneous mutation rates. In addition, BER provides significant protection against the toxic and mutagenic effects of DNA damaging agents present in the external environment, and as such is likely to prevent the adverse health effects of such agents. BER pathways have been studied in a wide variety of organisms (including yeasts) and here we review how these varied studies have shaped our current view of human BER.

DNA polymerase active site is highly mutable: evolutionary consequences

DNA polymerases contain active sites that are structurally superimposable and highly conserved in sequence. To assess the significance of this preservation and to determine the mutational burden that active sites can tolerate, we randomly mutated a stretch of 13 amino acids within the polymerase catalytic site (motif A) of Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I. After selection, by using genetic complementation, we obtained a library of approximately 8, 000 active mutant DNA polymerases, of which 350 were sequenced and analyzed. This is the largest collection of physiologically active polymerase mutants. We find that all residues of motif A, except one (Asp-610), are mutable while preserving wild-type activity. A wide variety of amino acid substitutions were obtained at sites that are evolutionarily maintained, and conservative substitutions predominate at regions that stabilize tertiary structures. Several mutants exhibit unique properties, including DNA polymerase activity higher than the wild-type enzyme or the ability to incorporate ribonucleotide analogs. Bacteria dependent on these mutated polymerases for survival are fit to replicate repetitively. The high mutability of the polymerase active site in vivo and the ability to evolve altered enzymes may be required for survival in environments that demand increased mutagenesis. The inherent substitutability of the polymerase active site must be addressed relative to the constancy of nucleotide sequence found in nature.

A set of temperature sensitive-replication/-segregation and temperature resistant plasmid vectors with different copy numbers and in an isogenic background (chloramphenicol, kanamycin, lacZ, repA, par, polA)

A set of plasmid vectors conferring chloramphenicol resistance (Cm(R)), 3064bp in size, or kanamycin resistance (Km(R)), 2972bp in size, were developed, having multiple cloning sites in lacZ' genes for alpha-complementation. pTH18cs1, pTH19cs1, pTH18ks1 and pTH19ks1 are temperature-sensitive (ts) in DNA replication (ts-Rep); pTH18cs5, pTH19cs5, pTH18ks5 and pTH19ks5 are ts in plasmid segregation (ts-Seg); and pTH18cr, pTH19cr, pTH18kr and pTH19kr are temperature resistant (tr) in both. They are based on the pSC101 replicon consisting merely of the replication origin and repA gene, compatible with ColE1/pMB1/p15-derived plasmids, and thus do not require polA function of host cells. The copy numbers of the ts-Rep, tr and ts-Seg plasmids were 14, 5 and 1 per chromosome at 30 degrees C, respectively. These plasmids are fairly stable when inherited at 30 degrees C, but not above 37 degrees C or 41.5 degrees C, depending on the repA mutations and host strains. They are isogenic apart from the ts mutations in the repA gene, and thus provide with useful tools for having appropriate controls in various experiments including bacterial gene-targeting, transposon mutagenesis, toxic gene expression, differential substitution on host functions, gene dosage analysis and so on.

Variant forms of DNA polymerase beta in primary lung carcinomas

DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) provides most of the gap-filling synthesis at apurinic/apyrimidine sites of damaged DNA in the base excision repair pathway. A truncated form of the pol beta protein is expressed in colon and breast cancers. However, the role of the pol beta gene in lung cancer is not known. Thus, we investigated a possible occurrence of pol beta variants in primary lung tumors. The entire cDNA of pol beta obtained by RT-PCR amplification was analyzed for nucleotide sequencing in lung tumor and matched normal lung tissue of the same patient. Three types of variants were detected in squamous, non-small, or large cell carcinomas. The most common variant was a deletion of 87 bp from pol beta cDNA at a site corresponding to exon 11. In addition, a variant exhibiting deletions of 87 and 140 bp together with an insertion of 105 bp was identified in three lung tumors. This is the first report of the occurrence of pol beta variants, possibly splicing variants, in lung cancer. A truncated pol beta protein resulting from variant forms of the gene may impact the function of the enzyme and increase susceptibility to carcinogenesis.

Yeast and human genes that affect the Escherichia coli SOS response

The sequencing of the human genome has led to the identification of many genes whose functions remain to be determined. Because of conservation of genetic function, microbial systems have often been used for identification and characterization of human genes. We have investigated the use of the Escherichia coli SOS induction assay as a screen for yeast and human genes that might play a role in DNA metabolism and/or in genome stability. The SOS system has previously been used to analyze bacterial and viral genes that directly modify DNA. An initial screen of meiotically expressed yeast genes revealed several genes associated with chromosome metabolism (e.g., RAD51 and HHT1 as well as others). The SOS induction assay was then extended to the isolation of human genes. Several known human genes involved in DNA metabolism, such as the Ku70 end-binding protein and DNA ligase IV, were identified, as well as a large number of previously unknown genes. Thus, the SOS assay can be used to identify and characterize human genes, many of which may participate in chromosome metabolism.

Improving enzymes for cancer gene therapy

New techniques now make it feasible to tailor enzymes for cancer gene therapy. Novel enzymes with desired properties can be created and selected from vast libraries of mutants containing random substitutions within catalytic domains. In this review, we first consider genes for the ablation of tumors, namely, genes that have been mutated (or potentially can be mutated) to afford enhanced activation of prodrugs and increased sensitization of tumors to specific chemotherapeutic agents. We then consider genes that have been mutated to provide better protection of normal host tissues, such as bone marrow, against the toxicity of specific chemotherapeutic agents. Expression of the mutant enzyme could render sensitive tissues, such as bone marrow, more resistant to specific cytotoxic agents.

A genetic system to identify DNA polymerase beta mutator mutants

DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) is a 39-kDa protein that functions in DNA repair processes in mammalian cells. As a first step toward understanding mechanisms of polymerase fidelity, we developed a genetic method to identify mammalian pol beta mutator mutants. This screen takes advantage of a microbial genetics assay and the ability of rat pol beta to substitute for Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I in DNA replication in vivo. Using this screen, we identified 13 candidate pol beta mutator mutants. Three of the candidate mutator mutants were further characterized in vivo and shown to confer an increased spontaneous mutation frequency over that of wild-type pol beta to our bacterial strain. Purification and subsequent analysis of one of our putative mutator proteins, the pol beta-14 protein, showed that it possesses intrinsic mutator activity in four different assays that measure the fidelity of DNA synthesis. Therefore, residue 265, which is altered in pol beta-14 and another of our mutant proteins, pol beta-166, is probably critical for accurate DNA synthesis by pol beta. Thus, our genetic method of screening for pol beta mutator mutants is useful in identifying active mammalian DNA polymerase mutants that encode enzymes that catalyze DNA synthesis with altered fidelity compared with the wild-type pol beta enzyme.

DNA repair functions in heterologous cells

Our genetic information is constantly challenged by exposure to endogenous and exogenous DNA-damaging agents, by DNA polymerase errors, and thereby inherent instability of the DNA molecule itself. The integrity of our genetic information is maintained by numerous DNA repair pathways, and the importance of these pathways is underscored by their remarkable structural and functional conservation across the evolutionary spectrum. Because of the highly conserved nature of DNA repair, the enzymes involved in this crucial function are often able to function in heterologous cells; as an example, the E. coli Ada DNA repair methyltransferase functions efficiently in yeast, in cultured rodent and human cells, in transgenic mice, and in ex vivo-modified mouse bone marrow cells. The heterologous expression of DNA repair functions has not only been used as a powerful cloning strategy, but also for the exploration of the biological and biochemical features of numerous enzymes involved in DNA repair pathways. In this review we highlight examples where the expression of DNA repair enzymes in heterologous cells was used to address fundamental questions about DNA repair processes in many different organisms.

Random mutagenesis of Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I: concordance of immutable sites in vivo with the crystal structure

Expression of Thermus aquaticus (Taq) DNA polymerase I (pol I) in Escherichia, coli complements the growth defect caused by a temperature-sensitive mutation in the host pol I. We replaced the nucleotide sequence encoding amino acids 659-671 of the O-helix of Taq DNA pol I, corresponding to the substrate binding site, with an oligonucleotide containing random nucleotides. Functional Taq pol I mutants were selected based on colony formation at the nonpermissive temperature. By using a library with 9% random substitutions at each of 39 positions, we identified 61 active Taq pol I mutants, each of which contained from one to four amino acid substitutions. Some amino acids, such as alanine-661 and threonine-664, were tolerant of several or even many diverse replacements. In contrast, no replacements or only conservative replacements were identified at arginine-659, lysine-663, and tyrosine-671. By using a library with totally random nucleotides at five different codons (arginine-659, arginine-660, lysine-663, phenylalanine-667, and glycine-668), we confirmed that arginine-659 and lysine-663 were immutable, and observed that only tyrosine substituted for phenylalanine-667. The two immutable residues and the two residues that tolerate only highly conservative replacements lie on the side of O-helix facing the incoming deoxynucleoside triphosphate, as determined by x-ray analysis. Thus, we offer a new approach to assess concordance of the active conformation of an enzyme, as interpreted from the crystal structure, with the active conformation inferred from in vivo function.

DNA end joining by the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I

DNA end joining is a type of illegitimate recombination characterized by the joining of two DNA ends that lack homology. Using oligonucleotides as substrate, we found that an exonuclease-free derivative of the Klenow fragment of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I can mediate DNA end joining in vitro. DNA sequence analysis of product DNA indicated that overlap products were formed between direct repeat sequences at the termini of the oligonucleotides. Formation of recombinant products was dependent on the strandedness of the substrate DNA, and the rate of product formation was dependent on the size of the potential overlap. With one to three complementary bases available for pairing at the 3' termini, there was an absolute requirement that one of the oligonucleotides be double-stranded, whereas with four complementary bases, products were also formed in reactions with single-stranded oligonucleotides. When noncomplementary nucleotides were added to the terminus of one of the oligonucleotides, product formation was delayed but not blocked. These data indicate that a DNA polymerase can mediate DNA double strand break rejoining in the absence of other proteins.

Identification of novel mRNA isoforms for human DNA polymerase beta

Recently, we reported the organization of the thirteen exons of the human DNA polymerase beta (beta-pol) gene and the sequences of the exon-intron junctions. Splice variants of human beta-pol mRNA have been postulated to be related to cancer development. Here, we report the characterization of isoforms of human beta-pol mRNA in different cells by reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). DNA sequence analysis of RT-PCR products revealed eight alternative splicing mRNA isoforms in the brain cancer cell line, SK-N-MC. These various isoforms were consistent with alternative splicing of four exons (II, IV, V, and VI) and with a 105-nucleotide insertion (exon alpha) between exons VI and VII. We also found an isoform with a 19-nucleotide sequence inserted into the exon IV and V junction, which resulted from usage of a different 3' splice site. Seven of the isoforms resulted in truncated open reading frame (ORF); five corresponded to deduced peptide of amino acids 1-20 of beta-pol and two corresponded to amino acids 1-60 of beta-pol. Only one of the right mRNA isoforms, that with the exon alpha insertion, was in-frame with the entire wild-type ORF resulting in a deduced protein of 370 residues, compared with the wild-type protein of 335 residues and 39 kD. This longer ORF was shown to be capable of encoding a beta-pol protein, larger than wild-type beta-pol, that cross-reacted with beta-pol antibody and exhibited beta-pol enzymatic activity. The mRNA isoform with the exon alpha insertion was not tumor specific because it as detected in low abundance in all cells tested, except the colon cell line CCD18 Co where the isoform was absent. The genomic location of exon alpha is in intron VI, 990 bp upstream of exon VII and flanked by consensus splice sites. Thus, this 105-bp genomic sequence is a beta-pol exon present in a low-abundance beta-pol mRNA isoform capable of encoding an approximately 42-kD beta-pol.

Dominant negative rat DNA polymerase beta mutants interfere with base excision repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA polymerase beta is one of the smallest known eukaryotic DNA polymerases. This polymerase has been very well characterized in vitro, but its functional role in vivo has yet to be determined. Using a novel competition assay in Escherichia coli, we isolated two DNA polymerase beta dominant negative mutants. When we overexpressed the dominant negative mutant proteins in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the cells became sensitive to methyl methanesulfonate. Interestingly, overexpression of the same polymerase beta mutant proteins did not confer sensitivity to UV damage, strongly suggesting that the mutant proteins interfere with the process of base excision repair but not nucleotide excision repair in S. cerevisiae. Our data implicate a role for polymerase IV, the S. cerevisiae polymerase beta homolog, in base excision repair in S. cerevisiae.

A screen in Escherichia coli for nucleoside analogs that target human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) reverse transcriptase: coexpression of HIV reverse transcriptase and herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) reverse transcriptase substitutes for temperature-sensitive DNA polymerase I (Pol Its) in Escherichia coli, providing a screen for anti-HIV reverse transcriptase nucleoside analogs in bacteria. Since phosphorylation of nucleosides in E. coli is limited to thymidine and its derivatives, we coexpressed herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase, an enzyme that phosphorylates a wide variety of nucleoside analogs, together with HIV reverse transcriptase. Coexpression of herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase and HIV reverse transcriptase rendered Pol Its cells sensitive to dideoxycytidine. Studies with different nucleoside analogs indicate that this bacterial screening system is able to select and identify nucleoside analogs that specifically target HIV reverse transcriptase.

Characterization of DNA polymerase beta mutants with amino acid substitutions located in the C-terminal portion of the enzyme

We used quantitative complementation assays to characterize individual DNA polymerase beta (Pol beta) mutants for their ability to function in DNA replication and DNA repair. We also describe a screen for detecting mutator activity of DNA polymerase beta mutants. By using these bioassays, together with DNA polymerase activity gels, we characterized 15 new DNA polymerase beta mutants that display a wide spectrum of phenotypes. Most of these mutants are generally defective in their ability to synthesize DNA. However, two of our Pol beta mutants show more complex phenotypes: they are able to function in DNA repair but unable to participate in DNA replication. One of our mutants displays mutator activity in vivo. Our work provides a model to study mutant mammalian enzymes in Escherichia coli with phenotypes that are otherwise difficult to assess.

DNA polymerase beta can substitute for DNA polymerase I in the initiation of plasmid DNA replication

We previously demonstrated that mammalian DNA polymerase beta can substitute for DNA polymerase I of Escherichia coli in DNA replication and in base excision repair. We have now obtained genetic evidence suggesting that DNA polymerase beta can substitute for E. coli DNA polymerase I in the initiation of replication of a plasmid containing a pMB1 origin of DNA replication. Specifically, we demonstrate that a plasmid with a pMB1 origin of replication can be maintained in an E. coli polA mutant in the presence of mammalian DNA polymerase beta. Our results suggest that mammalian DNA polymerase beta can substitute for E. coli DNA polymerase I by initiating DNA replication of this plasmid from the 3' OH terminus of the RNA-DNA hybrid at the origin of replication.

Human immunodeficiency virus reverse transcriptase substitutes for DNA polymerase I in Escherichia coli

We present evidence that human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) reverse transcriptase (RT) can substitute for DNA polymerase I in bacteria. Expression of HIV RT enables an Escherichia coli mutant, polA12 recA718, containing a temperature-sensitive mutation in DNA polymerase I, to grow at a nonpermissive temperature. The plasmid pBR322 contains a DNA polymerase I-dependent origin of replication. Expression of HIV RT enables the same E. coli mutant to maintain this plasmid at a nonpermissive temperature. Furthermore, expression of HIV RT in this mutant renders it sensitive to 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine, a commonly used anti-AIDS drug that targets HIV RT. These combined findings on the genetic complementation of DNA polymerase I by HIV RT provide a bacterial assay to screen for drugs directed against HIV RT. Genetic complementation provides a method for positive selection of large numbers of functional HIV RT mutants for studies on structure-function relationships.

DNA polymerase delta is required for base excision repair of DNA methylation damage in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We present evidence that DNA polymerase delta of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, an enzyme that is essential for viability and chromosomal replication, is also required for base excision repair of exogenous DNA methylation damage. The large catalytic subunit of DNA polymerase delta is encoded by the CDC2(POL3) gene. We find that the mutant allele cdc2-2 confers sensitivity to killing by methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) but allows wild-type levels of UV survival. MMS survival of haploid cdc2-2 strains is lower than wild type at the permissive growth temperature of 20 degrees C. Survival is further decreased relative to wild type by treatment with MMS at 36 degrees C, a nonpermissive temperature for growth of mutant cells. A second DNA polymerase delta allele, cdc2-1, also confers a temperature-sensitive defect in MMS survival while allowing nearly wild-type levels of UV survival. These observations provide an in vivo genetic demonstration that a specific eukaryotic DNA polymerase is required for survival of exogenous methylation damage. MMS sensitivity of a cdc2-2 mutant at 20 degrees C is complemented by expression of mammalian DNA polymerase beta, an enzyme that fills single-strand gaps in duplex DNA in vitro and whose only known catalytic activity is polymerization of deoxyribonucleotides. We conclude, therefore, that the MMS survival deficit in cdc2-2 cells is caused by failure of mutant DNA polymerase delta to fill single-strand gaps arising in base excision repair of methylation damage. We discuss our results in light of current concepts of the physiologic roles of DNA polymerases delta and epsilon in DNA replication and repair.

Multi-stage proofreading in DNA replication

The mechanisms by which DNA polymerases achieve their remarkable fidelity, including base selection and proofreading, are briefly reviewed. Nine proofreading models from the current literature are evaluated in the light of steady-state and transient kinetic studies of E. coli DNA polymerase I, the best-studied DNA polymerase. One model is demonstrated to predict quantitatively the response of DNA polymerase I to three mutagenic probes of proofreading: exogenous pyrophosphate, deoxynucleoside monophosphates, and the next correct deoxynucleoside triphosphate substrate, as well as the response to combinations of these probes. The theoretical analysis allows elimination of many possible proofreading mechanisms based on the kinetic data. A structural hypothesis links the kinetic analysis with crystallographic, NMR and genetic studies. It would appear that DNA polymerase I proofreads each potential error twice, at the same time undergoing two conformational changes within a catalytic cycle. Multi-stage proofreading is more efficient, and may be utilized in other biological systems as well. In fact, recent evidence suggests that fidelity of transfer RNA charging may be ensured by a similar mechanism.