Bacteriophage lambda N protein alone can induce transcription antitermination in vitro

Early antitermination in the atypical coliphage mEp021 mediated by the Gp17 protein

The coliphage mEp021 belongs to a phage group with a unique immunity repressor, and its life cycle requires the host factor Nus. mEp021 has been classified as non-lambdoid based on its specific characteristics. The mEp021 genome carries a gene encoding an N_λ-like antiterminator protein, termed Gp17, and three nut sites (nutL, nutR1, and nutR2). Analysis of plasmid constructs containing these nut sites, a transcription terminator, and a GFP reporter gene showed high levels of fluorescence when Gp17 was expressed, but not in its absence. Like lambdoid N proteins, Gp17 has an arginine-rich motif (ARM), and mutations in its arginine codons inhibit its function. In infection assays using the mutant phage mEp021ΔGp17::Kan (where gp17 has been deleted), gene transcripts located downstream of transcription terminators were obtained only when Gp17 was expressed. In contrast to phage lambda, mEp021 virus particle production was partially restored (>1/3 relative to wild type) when nus mutants (nusA1, nusB5, nusC60, and nusE71) were infected with mEp021 and Gp17 was overexpressed. Our results suggest that RNA polymerase reads through the third nut site (nutR2), which is more than 7.9 kbp downstream of nutR1.

NusG, an Ancient Yet Rapidly Evolving Transcription Factor

Timely and accurate RNA synthesis depends on accessory proteins that instruct RNA polymerase (RNAP) where and when to start and stop transcription. Among thousands of transcription factors, NusG/Spt5 stand out as the only universally conserved family of regulators. These proteins interact with RNAP to promote uninterrupted RNA synthesis and with diverse cellular partners to couple transcription to RNA processing, modification or translation, or to trigger premature termination of aberrant transcription. NusG homologs are present in all cells that utilize bacterial-type RNAP, from endosymbionts to plants, underscoring their ancient and essential function. Yet, in stark contrast to other core RNAP components, NusG family is actively evolving: horizontal gene transfer and sub-functionalization drive emergence of NusG paralogs, such as bacterial LoaP, RfaH, and UpxY. These specialized regulators activate a few (or just one) operons required for expression of antibiotics, capsules, secretion systems, toxins, and other niche-specific macromolecules. Despite their common origin and binding site on the RNAP, NusG homologs differ in their target selection, interacting partners and effects on RNA synthesis. Even among housekeeping NusGs from diverse bacteria, some factors promote pause-free transcription while others slow the RNAP down. Here, we discuss structure, function, and evolution of NusG proteins, focusing on unique mechanisms that determine their effects on gene expression and enable bacterial adaptation to diverse ecological niches.

Ancient Transcription Factors in the News

In every cell from bacteria to mammals, NusG-like proteins bind transcribing RNA polymerase to modulate the rate of nascent RNA synthesis and to coordinate it with numerous cotranscriptional processes that ultimately determine the transcript fate. Housekeeping NusG factors regulate expression of the bulk of the genome, whereas their highly specialized paralogs control just a few targets.

In every cell from bacteria to mammals, NusG-like proteins bind transcribing RNA polymerase to modulate the rate of nascent RNA synthesis and to coordinate it with numerous cotranscriptional processes that ultimately determine the transcript fate. Housekeeping NusG factors regulate expression of the bulk of the genome, whereas their highly specialized paralogs control just a few targets. In Escherichia coli, NusG stimulates silencing of horizontally acquired genes, while its paralog RfaH counters NusG action by activating a subset of these genes. Acting alone or as part of regulatory complexes, NusG factors can promote uninterrupted RNA synthesis, bring about transcription pausing or premature termination, modulate RNA processing, and facilitate translation. Recent structural and mechanistic studies of NusG homologs from all domains of life reveal molecular details of multifaceted interactions that underpin their unexpectedly diverse regulatory roles. NusG proteins share conserved binding sites on RNA polymerase and many effects on the transcription elongation complex but differ in their mechanisms of recruitment, interactions with nucleic acids and secondary partners, and regulatory outcomes. Strikingly, some can alternate between autoinhibited and activated states that possess dramatically different secondary structures to achieve exquisite target specificity.

Non-programmed transcriptional frameshifting is common and highly RNA polymerase type-dependent

Background

The viral or host systems for a gene expression assume repeatability of the process and high quality of the protein product. Since level and fidelity of transcription primarily determines the overall efficiency, all factors contributing to their decrease should be identified and optimized. Among many observed processes, non-programmed insertion/deletion (indel) of nucleotide during transcription (slippage) occurring at homopolymeric A/T sequences within a gene can considerably impact its expression. To date, no comparative study of the most utilized Escherichia coli and T7 bacteriophage RNA polymerases (RNAP) propensity for this type of erroneous mRNA synthesis has been reported. To address this issue we evaluated the influence of shift-prone A/T sequences by assessing indel-dependent phenotypic changes. RNAP-specific expression profile was examined using two of the most potent promoters, P_araBAD of E. coli and φ10 of phage T7.

Results

Here we report on the first systematic study on requirements for efficient transcriptional slippage by T7 phage and cellular RNAPs considering three parameters: homopolymer length, template type, and frameshift directionality preferences. Using a series of out-of-frame gfp reporter genes fused to a variety of A/T homopolymeric sequences we show that T7 RNAP has an exceptional potential for generating frameshifts and is capable of slipping on as few as three adenine or four thymidine residues in a row, in a flanking sequence-dependent manner. In contrast, bacterial RNAP exhibits a relatively low ability to baypass indel mutations and requires a run of at least 7 tymidine and even more adenine residues. This difference comes from involvement of various intrinsic proofreading properties. Our studies demonstrate distinct preference towards a specific homopolymer in slippage induction. Whereas insertion slippage performed by T7 RNAP (but not deletion) occurs tendentiously on poly(A) rather than on poly(T) runs, strong bias towards poly(T) for the host RNAP is observed.

Conclusions

Intrinsic RNAP slippage properties involve trade-offs between accuracy, speed and processivity of transcription. Viral T7 RNAP manifests far greater inclinations to the transcriptional slippage than E. coli RNAP. This possibly plays an important role in driving bacteriophage adaptation and therefore could be considered as beneficial. However, from biotechnological and experimental viewpoint, this might create some problems, and strongly argues for employing bacterial expression systems, stocked with proofreading mechanisms.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12934-018-1034-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

SuhB Associates with Nus Factors To Facilitate 30S Ribosome Biogenesis in Escherichia coli

A complex of highly conserved proteins consisting of NusB, NusE, NusA, and NusG is required for robust expression of rRNA in Escherichia coli. This complex is proposed to prevent Rho-dependent transcription termination by a process known as "antitermination." The mechanism of this antitermination in rRNA is poorly understood but requires association of NusB and NusE with a specific RNA sequence in rRNA known as BoxA. Here, we identify a novel member of the rRNA antitermination machinery: the inositol monophosphatase SuhB. We show that SuhB associates with elongating RNA polymerase (RNAP) at rRNA in a NusB-dependent manner. Although we show that SuhB is required for BoxA-mediated antitermination in a reporter system, our data indicate that the major function of the NusB/E/A/G/SuhB complex is not to prevent Rho-dependent termination of rRNA but rather to promote correct rRNA maturation. This occurs through formation of a SuhB-mediated loop between NusB/E/BoxA and RNAP/NusA/G. Thus, we have reassigned the function of these proteins at rRNA and identified another key player in this complex.

IMPORTANCE

As RNA polymerase transcribes the rRNA operons in E. coli, it complexes with a set of proteins called Nus that confer enhanced rates of transcription elongation, correct folding of rRNA, and rRNA assembly with ribosomal proteins to generate a fully functional ribosome. Four Nus proteins were previously known, NusA, NusB, NusE, and NusG; here, we discover and describe a fifth, SuhB, that is an essential component of this complex. We demonstrate that the main function of this SuhB-containing complex is not to prevent premature transcription termination within the rRNA operon, as had been long claimed, but to enable rRNA maturation and a functional ribosome fully competent for translation.

Regulation of transcription elongation and termination

This article will review our current understanding of transcription elongation and termination in E. coli. We discuss why transcription elongation complexes pause at certain template sites and how auxiliary host and phage transcription factors affect elongation and termination. The connection between translation and transcription elongation is described. Finally we present an overview indicating where progress has been made and where it has not.

Ubiquitous transcription factors display structural plasticity and diverse functions: NusG proteins - Shifting shapes and paradigms

Numerous accessory factors modulate RNA polymerase response to regulatory signals and cellular cues and establish communications with co-transcriptional RNA processing. Transcription regulators are astonishingly diverse, with similar mechanisms arising via convergent evolution. NusG/Spt5 elongation factors comprise the only universally conserved and ancient family of regulators. They bind to the conserved clamp helices domain of RNA polymerase, which also interacts with non-homologous initiation factors in all domains of life, and reach across the DNA channel to form processivity clamps that enable uninterrupted RNA chain synthesis. In addition to this ubiquitous function, NusG homologs exert diverse, and sometimes opposite, effects on gene expression by competing with each other and other regulators for binding to the clamp helices and by recruiting auxiliary factors that facilitate termination, antitermination, splicing, translation, etc. This surprisingly diverse range of activities and the underlying unprecedented structural changes make studies of these "transformer" proteins both challenging and rewarding.

Minimal effects of macromolecular crowding on an intrinsically disordered protein: a small-angle neutron scattering study

Small-angle neutron scattering was used to study the effects of macromolecular crowding by two globular proteins, i.e., bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and equine metmyoglobin, on the conformational ensemble of an intrinsically disordered protein, the N protein of bacteriophage λ. The λ N protein was uniformly labeled with (2)H, and the concentrations of D2O in the samples were adjusted to match the neutron scattering contrast of the unlabeled crowding proteins, thereby masking their contribution to the scattering profiles. Scattering from the deuterated λ N was recorded for samples containing up to 0.12 g/mL bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor or 0.2 g/mL metmyoglobin. The radius of gyration of the uncrowded protein was estimated to be 30 Å and was found to be remarkably insensitive to the presence of crowders, varying by <2 Å for the highest crowder concentrations. The scattering profiles were also used to estimate the fractal dimension of λ N, which was found to be ∼1.8 in the absence or presence of crowders, indicative of a well-solvated and expanded random coil under all of the conditions examined. These results are contrary to the predictions of theoretical treatments and previous experimental studies demonstrating compaction of unfolded proteins by crowding with polymers such as dextran and Ficoll. A computational simulation suggests that some previous treatments may have overestimated the effective volumes of disordered proteins and the variation of these volumes within an ensemble. The apparent insensitivity of λ N to crowding may also be due in part to weak attractive interactions with the crowding proteins, which may compensate for the effects of steric exclusion.

Bacteriophage HK022 Nun protein arrests transcription by blocking lateral mobility of RNA polymerase during transcription elongation

Coliphage HK022 excludes phage λ by subverting the λ antitermination system and arresting transcription on the λ chromosome. The 12 kDa HK022 Nun protein binds to λ nascent transcript through its N-terminal Arginine Rich Motif (ARM), blocking access by λ N and arresting transcription via a C-terminal interaction with RNA polymerase. In a purified in vitro system, we recently demonstrated that Nun arrests transcription by restricting lateral movement of transcription elongation complex (TEC) along the DNA register, thereby freezing the translocation state. We will discuss some of the key experiments that led to this conclusion, as well as present additional results that further support it.

Bacteriophage λ N protein inhibits transcription slippage by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

Transcriptional slippage is a class of error in which ribonucleic acid (RNA) polymerase incorporates nucleotides out of register, with respect to the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) template. This phenomenon is involved in gene regulation mechanisms and in the development of diverse diseases. The bacteriophage λ N protein reduces transcriptional slippage within actively growing cells and in vitro. N appears to stabilize the RNA/DNA hybrid, particularly at the 5′ end, preventing loss of register between transcript and template. This report provides the first evidence of a protein that directly influences transcriptional slippage, and provides a clue about the molecular mechanism of transcription termination and N-mediated antitermination.

Chandipura Virus: an emerging tropical pathogen

Chandipura Virus (CHPV), a member of Rhabdoviridae, is responsible for an explosive outbreak in rural areas of India. It affects mostly children and is characterized by influenza-like illness and neurologic dysfunctions. It is transmitted by vectors such as mosquitoes, ticks and sand flies. An effective real-time one step reverse-transcriptase PCR assay method is adopted for diagnosis of this virus. CHPV has a negative sense RNA genome encoding five different proteins (N, P, M, G, and L). P protein plays a vital role in the virus's life cycle, while M protein is lethal in nature. There is no specific treatment available to date, symptomatic treatment involves use of mannitol to reduce brain edema. A Vero cell based vaccine candidate against CHPV was evaluated efficiently as a preventive agent against it. Prevention is the best method to suppress CHPV infection. Containment of disease transmitting vectors, maintaining good nutrition, health, hygiene and awareness in rural areas will help in curbing the menace of CHPV. Thus, to control virus transmission some immense preventive measures need to be attempted until a good anti-CHPV agent is developed.

Fractal dimension of an intrinsically disordered protein: small-angle X-ray scattering and computational study of the bacteriophage λ N protein

Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) was used to characterize the bacteriophage λ N protein, a 107 residue intrinsically disordered protein (IDP) that functions as a transcriptional antitermination factor. The SAXS data were used to estimate both the average radius of gyration and the fractal dimension, a measure of the protein's internal scaling properties, under a variety of solution conditions. In the absence of denaturants, the radius of gyration was 38 ± 3.5 Å and the fractal dimension was 1.76 ± 0.05, slightly larger than the value predicted for a well-solvated polymer with excluded volume (1.7). Neither the radius of gyration nor the fractal dimension changed significantly on the addition of urea, further indicating that the protein is extensively unfolded and well solvated in the absence of denaturant. The addition of NaCl or D(2) O was found to promote aggregation, but did not appear to affect the properties of the monomeric form. The experimental SAXS profiles were also compared with those predicted by a computational model for a random-coil polypeptide, with an adjustable solvation energy term. The experimental data were well fit to the model with the solvation energy close to zero. These results indicate that the λ N protein is among the more expanded members of the broad class of IDPs, most likely because of its high content of charged residues and a large net charge (+15 at neutral pH). The expanded nature of the conformational ensemble may play a role in facilitating the interactions of the protein with other components of the dynamic transcriptional complex.

Termination and antitermination: RNA polymerase runs a stop sign

Termination signals induce rapid and irreversible dissociation of the nascent transcript from RNA polymerase. Terminators at the end of genes prevent unintended transcription into the downstream genes, whereas terminators in the upstream regulatory leader regions adjust expression of the structural genes in response to metabolic and environmental signals. Premature termination within an operon leads to potentially deleterious defects in the expression of the downstream genes, but also provides an important surveillance mechanism. This Review discusses the actions of bacterial and phage antiterminators that allow RNA polymerase to override a terminator when the circumstances demand it.

Effects of macromolecular crowding on an intrinsically disordered protein characterized by small-angle neutron scattering with contrast matching

Small-angle neutron scattering was used to examine the effects of molecular crowding on an intrinsically disordered protein, the N protein of bacteriophage λ, in the presence of high concentrations of a small globular protein, bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI). The N protein was labeled with deuterium, and the D(2)O concentration of the solvent was adjusted to eliminate the scattering contrast between the solvent and unlabeled BPTI, leaving only the scattering signal from the unfolded protein. The scattering profile observed in the absence of BPTI closely matched that predicted for an ensemble of random conformations. With BPTI added to a concentration of 65 mg/mL, there was a clear change in the scattering profile representing an increase in the mass fractal dimension of the unfolded protein, from 1.7 to 1.9, as expected if crowding favors more compact conformations. The crowding protein also inhibited aggregation of the unfolded protein. At 130 mg/mL BPTI, however, the fractal dimension was not significantly different from that measured at the lower concentration, contrary to the predictions of models that treat the unfolded conformations as convex particles. These results are reminiscent of the behavior of polymers in concentrated melts, suggesting that these synthetic mixtures may provide useful insights into the properties of unfolded proteins under crowding conditions.

A processive riboantiterminator seeks a switch to make biofilms

Since the discovery of the first signal-sensing RNA structure by Grundy and Henkin in 1993, the list of cis-acting riboregulators has grown dramatically. Riboswitches fold into elaborate structures and respond to binding of small metabolites by altering the folding pattern of the surrounding transcript, thereby altering the gene expression programme. Riboswitches that use short-range mechanisms to control transcription attenuation and translation initiation and mediate mRNA cleavage have been characterized in many Gram-positive bacteria. Their action typically relies on alternative RNA structures that are differentially stabilized by the ligand binding. In this issue of Molecular Microbiology, Irnov and Winkler describe a novel Bacillus subtilis riboregulator called EAR that shares structural complexity with riboswitches but possesses a unique mechanism of action. EAR increases expression of exopolysaccharide genes and biofilm formation, and appears to act as a processive, long-range antiterminator, the first such example outside of Escherichia coli. While it is unclear whether EAR senses a biofilm-inducing signal, the results suggest that its action depends on yet unidentified auxiliary factors. Interestingly, efficient capsule biogenesis in E. coli and Bacteroides fragilis also depends on processive antiterminators but utilizes the protein-based mechanisms instead.

Functional specialization of transcription elongation factors

Elongation factors NusG and RfaH evolved from a common ancestor and utilize the same binding site on RNA polymerase (RNAP) to modulate transcription. However, although NusG associates with RNAP transcribing most Escherichia coli genes, RfaH regulates just a few operons containing ops, a DNA sequence that mediates RfaH recruitment. Here, we describe the mechanism by which this specificity is maintained. We observe that RfaH action is indeed restricted to those several operons that are devoid of NusG in vivo. We also show that RfaH and NusG compete for their effects on transcript elongation and termination in vitro. Our data argue that RfaH recognizes its DNA target even in the presence of NusG. Once recruited, RfaH remains stably associated with RNAP, thereby precluding NusG binding. We envision a pathway by which a specialized regulator has evolved in the background of its ubiquitous paralogue. We propose that RfaH and NusG may have opposite regulatory functions: although NusG appears to function in concert with Rho, RfaH inhibits Rho action and activates the expression of poorly translated, frequently foreign genes.

The antitermination activity of bacteriophage lambda N protein is controlled by the kinetics of an RNA-looping-facilitated interaction with the transcription complex

Protein N of bacteriophage lambda activates the lytic phase of phage development in infected Escherichia coli cells by suppressing the activity of transcriptional terminators that prevent the synthesis of essential phage proteins. N binds tightly to the boxB RNA hairpin located near the 5' end of the nascent pL and pR transcripts and induces an antitermination response in the RNA polymerase (RNAP) of elongation complexes located at terminators far downstream. Here we test an RNA looping model for this N-dependent "action at a distance" by cleaving the nascent transcript between boxB and RNAP during transcript elongation. Cleavage decreases antitermination, showing that an intact RNA transcript is required to stabilize the interaction of boxB-bound N with RNAP during transcription. In contrast, an antitermination complex that also contains Nus factors retains N-dependent activity after transcript cleavage, suggesting that these host factors further stabilize the N-RNAP interaction. Thus, the binding of N alone to RNAP is controlled by an RNA looping equilibrium, but after formation of the initial RNA loop and in the presence of Nus factors the system no longer equilibrates on the transcription time scale, meaning that the "range" of antitermination activity along the template in the full antitermination system is kinetically controlled by the dissociation rate of the stabilized N-RNAP complex. Theoretical calculations of nucleic acid end-to-end contact probabilities are used to estimate the local concentrations of boxB-bound N at elongation complexes poised at terminators, and are combined with N activity measurements at various boxB-to-terminator distances to obtain an intrinsic affinity (K(d)) of approximately 2 x 10(-5) M for the N-RNAP interaction. This RNA looping approach is extended to include the effects of N binding at nonspecific RNA sites on the transcript and the implications for transcription control in other regulatory systems are discussed.

RNA polymerase elongation factors

The elongation phase of transcription by RNA polymerase is highly regulated and modulated. Both general and operon-specific elongation factors determine the local rate and extent of transcription to coordinate the appearance of transcript with its use as a messenger or functional ribonucleoprotein or regulatory element, as well as to provide operon-specific gene regulation.

Reviewing Chandipura: a vesiculovirus in human epidemics

Chandipura virus, a member of the rhabdoviridae family and vesiculovirus genera, has recently emerged as human pathogen that is associated with a number of outbreaks in different parts of India. Although, the virus closely resembles with the prototype vesiculovirus, Vesicular Stomatitis Virus, it could be readily distinguished by its ability to infect humans. Studies on Chandipura virus while shed light into distinct stages of viral infection; it may also allow us to identify potential drug targets for antiviral therapy. In this review, we have summarized our current understanding of Chandipura virus life cycle at the molecular detail with particular interest in viral RNA metabolisms, namely transcription, replication and packaging of viral RNA into nucleocapsid structure. Contemporary research on otherwise extensively studied family member Vesicular Stomatitis Virus has also been addressed to present a more comprehensive picture of vesiculovirus life cycle. Finally, we reveal examples of protein economy in Chandipura virus life-cycle whereby each viral protein has evolved complexity to perform multiple tasks.

Allosteric control of the RNA polymerase by the elongation factor RfaH

Efficient transcription of long polycistronic operons in bacteria frequently relies on accessory proteins but their molecular mechanisms remain obscure. RfaH is a cellular elongation factor that acts as a polarity suppressor by increasing RNA polymerase (RNAP) processivity. In this work, we provide evidence that RfaH acts by reducing transcriptional pausing at certain positions rather than by accelerating RNAP at all sites. We show that ‘fast’ RNAP variants are characterized by pause-free RNA chain elongation and are resistant to RfaH action. Similarly, the wild-type RNAP is insensitive to RfaH in the absence of pauses. In contrast, those enzymes that may be prone to falling into a paused state are hypersensitive to RfaH. RfaH inhibits pyrophosphorolysis of the nascent RNA and reduces the apparent Michaelis–Menten constant for nucleotides, suggesting that it stabilizes the post-translocated, active RNAP state. Given that the RfaH-binding site is located 75 Å away from the RNAP catalytic center, these results strongly indicate that RfaH acts allosterically. We argue that despite the apparent differences in the nucleic acid targets, the time of recruitment and the binding sites on RNAP, unrelated antiterminators (such as RfaH and λQ) utilize common strategies during both recruitment and anti-pausing modification of the transcription complex.

Protection of antiterminator RNA by the transcript elongation complex

Nascent transcripts encoded by the putL and putR sites of phage HK022 bind the transcript elongation complex and suppress termination at downstream transcription terminators. We report here that the chemical stability of putL RNA is considerably greater than that of the typical Escherichia coli message because the elongation complex protects this RNA from degradation. When binding to the elongation complex was prevented by mutation of either putL or RNA polymerase, RNA stability decreased more than 50-fold. The functional modification conferred by putL RNA on the elongation complex is also long-lived: the efficiency of terminator suppression remained high for at least 10 kb from the putL site. We find that RNase III rapidly and efficiently cleaved the transcript just downstream of the putL sequences, but such cleavage changed neither the stability of putL RNA nor the efficiency of antitermination. These results argue that the continuity of the RNA that connects put sequences to the growing point is not required for persistence of the antiterminating modification in vivo.

Role of E.coli NusA in phage HK022 Nun-mediated transcription termination

The 109 amino acid residue Nun protein expressed from prophage HK022 excludes superinfecting phage lambda by arresting transcription on the lambda chromosome near the lambdanut sites. In vitro, the Nun N terminus binds to nascent lambdanutRNA, whereas the C terminus interacts with RNA polymerase and DNA template. Escherichia coli host factors, NusA, NusB, NusE (S10), and NusG, stimulate Nun-arrest. NusA binds the Nun C terminus and enhances formation of the Nun-nutRNA complex. Because of these in vitro activities of NusA, and since a nusA mutation (nusAE136K) blocked Nun in vivo, we assumed that NusA was required for Nun activity. However, using a nusAts strain, we find that NusA is required for termination at nutR but not at nutL. Furthermore, nusAE136K is dominant to nusA(+) for Nun-arrest, both in vitro and in vivo. NusAE136K shows increased affinity for Nun and, unlike NusA(+), can readily be recovered in a ternary complex with Nun and nutRNA. We propose NusAE136K suppresses Nun-arrest when it is a component of the transcription elongation complex, perhaps, in part, by blocking interactions between the Nun C terminus and RNA polymerase and DNA. We also find that in contrast to Nun-arrest, antitermination by lambda N requires NusA.

Switches in Bacteriophage Lambda Development

The lysis-lysogeny decision of bacteriophage lambda (lambda) is a paradigm for developmental genetic networks. There are three key features, which characterize the network. First, after infection of the host bacterium, a decision between lytic or lysogenic development is made that is dependent upon environmental signals and the number of infecting phages per cell. Second, the lysogenic prophage state is very stable. Third, the prophage enters lytic development in response to DNA-damaging agents. The CI and Cro regulators define the lysogenic and lytic states, respectively, as a bistable genetic switch. Whereas CI maintains a stable lysogenic state, recent studies indicate that Cro sets the lytic course not by directly blocking CI expression but indirectly by lowering levels of CII which activates cI transcription. We discuss how a relatively simple phage like lambda employs a complex genetic network in decision-making processes, providing a challenge for theoretical modeling.

A quantitative description of the binding states and in vitro function of antitermination protein N of bacteriophage lambda

The N protein of bacteriophage lambda activates transcription of genes that lie downstream of termination sequences by suppressing transcription termination. N binds to specific (boxB) and non-specific sites on the transcript RNA and contacts RNA polymerase via cis-RNA looping, resulting in "antitermination" of transcription. To find the effect of N-boxB binding on antitermination, we quantitatively relate binding measurements made in isolation to in vitro antitermination activity. We measure binding of N to boxB RNA, non-specific single-stranded RNA, and non-specific double-stranded DNA fluorimetrically, and use an equilibrium model to describe quantitatively the binding of N to nucleic acids of Escherichia coli transcription elongation complexes. We then test the model by comparison with in vitro N antitermination activity measured in reactions containing these same elongation complexes. We find that binding of N protein to the nucleic acid components of transcription elongation complexes can quantitatively predict antitermination activity, suggesting that antitermination in vitro is determined by a nucleic acid binding equilibrium with one molecule of N protein per RNA transcript being sufficient for antitermination. Elongation complexes contain numerous overlapping non-specific RNA and DNA-binding sites for N; the large number of sites compensates for the low N binding affinity, so multiple N proteins are expected to bind to elongation complexes. The occupancy/activity of these proteins is described by a binomial distribution of proteins on transcripts containing multiple non-specific sites. The contribution of specific (boxB) binding to activity also depends on this distribution. Specificity is not measured accurately by measurements made in the presence and in the absence of boxB. We find that antitermination is inhibited by non-productive binding of N to non-specific sites on template DNA, and that NusA protein covers RNA sites on the transcript, limiting N access and activity. The activity and specificity of regulatory proteins that loop from high-affinity binding sites are likely modulated by multiple non-specific binding events; in vivo activity may also be regulated by the modulation of non-specific binding.

Morphing molecular specificities between Arm-peptide and NUT-RNA in the antitermination complexes of bacteriophages lambda and P22

Bacteriophage lambda's N-protein includes a 17-amino-acid segment, Arm, rich in arginine and having specific affinity for a 15-nucleotide RNA stem-loop called BOX-B. Parallel but different Arm/BOX-B sequences in lambda's cousin, phage P22, account for some of the type specificity that distinguishes lambda from P22: the N of each works only with its cognate BOX-B in vivo. We find that the specificity of N(lambda) can be shifted gradually to that of N(22) by substituting sets of particular amino acids from Arm(22) into Arm of N(lambda). The determinative amino acids are generally those shown by nuclear magnetic resonance to contact BOX-B RNA; gain or loss of these contact amino acids is reasonably expected to contribute to the affinity of each amino acid sequence. Intermediate sequences may show no function with either BOX-B, or weak function with both BOX-B(lambda) and BOX-B(22), the latter suggesting possible evolutionary paths for specificity shifts.

Highly divergent RfaH orthologs from pathogenic proteobacteria can substitute for Escherichia coli RfaH both in vivo and in vitro

The transcriptional enhancer protein RfaH positively regulates production of virulence factors in Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium via a cis element, ops. Genes coding for RfaH orthologs were identified in conceptually translated genomes of bacterial pathogens, including Vibrio and Yersinia spp. We cloned the rfaH genes from Vibrio cholerae, Yersinia enterocolitica, S. enterica serovar Typhimurium, and Klebsiella pneumoniae into E. coli expression vectors. Purified RfaH orthologs, including the most divergent one from V. cholerae, were readily recruited to the E. coli transcription elongation complex. Postrecruitment stimulation of transcript elongation appeared to vary with the degree of similarity to E. coli RfaH. V. cholerae RfaH was particularly defective in reducing downstream pausing and termination; this defect was substantially alleviated by an increase in its concentration. When overexpressed episomally, all of the rfaH genes complemented the disruption of the chromosomal copy of the E. coli gene. Thus, despite the apparently accelerated divergent evolution of the RfaH proteins, the mechanism of their action is conserved well enough to make them transcriptionally active in the E. coli system.

Bacteriophage-induced modifications of host RNA polymerase

Bacteriophages have developed an impressive array of ingenious mechanisms to modify bacterial host RNA polymerase to make it serve viral needs. In this review we summarize the current knowledge about two types of host RNA polymerase modifications induced by double-stranded DNA phages: covalent modifications and modifications through RNA polymerase-binding proteins. We interpret the biochemical and genetic data within the framework of a structure-function model of bacterial RNA polymerase and viral biology.

Context and conformation dictate function of a transcription antitermination switch

In bacteriophage l, transcription elongation is regulated by the N protein, which binds a nascent mRNA hairpin (termed boxB) and enables RNA polymerase to read through distal terminators. We have examined the structure, energetics and in vivo function of a number of N-boxB complexes derived from in vitro protein selection. Trp18 fully stacks on the RNA loop in the wild-type structure, and can become partially or completely unstacked when the sequence context is changed three or four residues away, resulting in a recognition interface in which the best binding residues depend on the sequence context. Notably, in vivo antitermination activity correlates with the presence of a stacked aromatic residue at position 18, but not with N-boxB binding affinity. Our work demonstrates that RNA polymerase responds to subtle conformational changes in cis-acting regulatory complexes and that approximation of components is not sufficient to generate a fully functional transcription switch.

Selection of RRE RNA binding peptides using a kanamycin antitermination assay

The arginine-rich domains of several RNA-binding proteins have been shown to bind their cognate RNAs with high affinities and specificities as isolated peptides, adopting different conformations within different complexes. The sequence simplicity and structural diversity of the arginine-rich motif has made it a good framework for constructing combinatorial libraries and identifying novel RNA-binding peptides, including those targeted to the HIV Rev response element (RRE). Here we describe a modified transcription antitermination reporter assay engineered with kanamycin resistance that enables larger in vivo screens (approximately 10(9) sequences) than previously possible. We show that the assay detects only specific RNA-protein complexes, and that binders are enriched at least 300-fold per round of selection. We screened a large peptide library in which amino acids with charged, polar, and small side chains were randomly distributed within a polyarginine framework and identified a set of high affinity RRE-binding peptides. Most contain glutamine at one particular peptide position, and the best peptides display significantly higher antitermination activities than Rev or other previously described high-affinity RRE-binding peptides. The kanamycin antitermination (KAN) assay should be useful for screening relatively large libraries and thereby facilitate identification of novel RNA binders.

Transcription termination and anti-termination in E. coli

Transcription termination in Escherichia coli is controlled by many factors. The sequence of the DNA template, the structure of the transcript, and the actions of auxiliary proteins all play a role in determining the efficiency of the process. Termination is regulated and can be enhanced or suppressed by host and phage proteins. This complex reaction is rapidly yielding to biochemical and structural analysis of the interacting factors. Below we review and attempt to unify into basic principles the remarkable recent progress in understanding transcription termination and anti-termination.

Control of intrinsic transcription termination by N and NusA: the basic mechanisms

Intrinsic transcription termination plays a crucial role in regulating gene expression in prokaryotes. After a short pause, the termination signal appears in RNA as a hairpin that destabilizes the elongation complex (EC). We demonstrate that negative and positive termination factors control the efficiency of termination primarily through a direct modulation of hairpin folding and, to a much lesser extent, by changing pausing at the point of termination. The mechanism controlling hairpin formation at the termination point relies on weak protein interactions with single-stranded RNA, which corresponds to the upstream portion of the hairpin. Escherichia coli NusA protein destabilizes these interactions and thus promotes hairpin folding and termination. Stabilization of these contacts by phage lambda N protein leads to antitermination.

Interactions of an Arg-rich region of transcription elongation protein NusA with NUT RNA: implications for the order of assembly of the lambda N antitermination complex in vivo

The E. coli NusA transcription elongation protein (NusA(Ec)), identified because of its requirement for transcription antitermination by the N protein, has an Arg-rich S1 RNA-binding domain. A complex of N and NusA with other host factors binding at NUT sites in the RNA renders RNA polymerase termination-resistant. An E. coli haploid for nusA944, having nine different codons replacing four normally found in the Arg-rich region, is defective in support of N action. Another variant, haploid for the nusAR199A allele, with a change in a highly conserved Arg codon in the S1 domain, effectively supports N-mediated antitermination. However, nusAR199A is recessive to nusA944, while nusA(Ec) is dominant to nusA944 for support of N-mediated antitermination, suggesting a competition between NusA944 and NusAR199A during complex formation. Complex formation with the variant NusA proteins was assessed by mobility gel shifts. NusAR199A, unlike NusA(Ec) and NusA944, fails to form a complex with N and NUT RNA. However, while NusAR199A, like wild-type NusA, forms an enlarged complex with NUT RNA, N, RNA polymerase, and other host proteins required for efficient N-mediated antitermination, NusA944 does not form this enlarged complex. Consistent with the in vivo results, NusA944 prevents NusAR199A but not NusA(Ec) from forming the enlarged complex. The simplest conclusion from these dominance studies is that in the formation of the complete active antitermination complex in vivo, NusA and N binding to the newly synthesized NUT RNA precedes addition of the other factors. Alternative less effective routes to the active complex that allows bypass of this preferred pathway may also exist.

N-mediated transcription antitermination in lambdoid phage H-19B is characterized by alternative NUT RNA structures and a reduced requirement for host factors

Gene expression in lambdoid phages in part is controlled by transcription antitermination. For most lambdoid phages, maximal expression of delayed early genes requires an RNA polymerase modified by the phage N and host Nus proteins at RNA NUT sites. The NUT sites (NUTL and NUTR) are made up of three elements: BOXA, BOXB and an intervening spacer sequence. We report on N antitermination in H-19B, a lambdoid phage carrying shiga toxin 1 genes. H-19B N requires NusA, but not two other host factors required by lambda N, NusB and ribosomal protein S10. The H-19B NUT site BOXA is not required, whereas the BOXB is required for N action. H-19B nut sites have dyad symmetries in the spacer regions that are not in other nut sites. Changes in one arm of the dyad symmetry inactivate the NUT RNA. Compensating changes increasing the number of mutant nucleotides but restoring dyad symmetry restore activity. Deletion of the sequences encoding the dyad symmetry has little effect. Thus, the specific nucleotides composing the dyad symmetry seem relatively unimportant. We propose that the RNA stem-loop structure, called the 'reducer', by sequestering nucleotides from the linear RNA brings into proximity sites on either side of the dyad symmetry that contribute to forming an active NUT site.

Functional importance of regions in Escherichia coli elongation factor NusA that interact with RNA polymerase, the bacteriophage lambda N protein and RNA

The association of the essential Escherichia coli protein NusA with RNA polymerase increases pausing and the efficiency of termination at intrinsic terminators. NusA is also part of the phage lambda N protein-modified antitermination complex that functions to prevent transcriptional termination. We have investigated the structure of NusA using various deletion fragments of NusA in a variety of in vitro assays. Sequence and structural alignments have suggested that NusA has both S1 and KH homology regions that are thought to bind RNA. We show here that the portion of NusA containing the S1 and KH homology regions is important for NusA to enhance both termination and antitermination. There are two RNA polymerase-binding regions in NusA, one in the amino-terminal 137 amino acids and the other in the carboxy-terminal 264 amino acids; only the amino-terminal RNA polymerase-binding region provides a functional contact that enhances termination at an intrinsic terminator or antitermination by N. The carboxy-terminal region of NusA is also required for interaction with N and is important for the formation of an N-NusA-nut site or N-NusA-RNA polymerase-nut site complex; the instability of complexes lacking this carboxy-terminal region of NusA that binds N and RNA polymerase can be compensated for by the presence of the additional E. coli elongation factors, NusB, NusG and ribosomal protein S10.

RNA-mediated signaling in transcription

Structures of phage transcriptional antitermination complexes define novel motifs for recognition of RNA hairpins by arginine-rich peptides. A bent alpha-helix in each case follows the contour of an induced GNRA-like fold. A phage-specific pattern of base pairing, base stacking and base flipping underlies biological specificity and permits engagement with RNA polymerase. The structures suggest a mechanism of RNA-mediated signaling in transcriptional regulation.

Escherichia coli NusA is required for efficient RNA binding by phage HK022 nun protein

The Nun protein of phage HK022 is an RNA binding protein of the arginine-rich motif family. Nun binds the phage lambda boxB RNA sequence (BOXB) on nascent lambda transcripts and arrests transcription elongation. Binding to BOXB is inhibited by Zn2+ and stimulated by the Escherichia coli NusA protein. Deletion of the Nun C-terminal region enhances BOXB binding and makes it independent of Zn2+ and NusA. The C terminus of Nun thus appears to interfere with the N-terminal RNA binding motif. NusA relieves this interference by binding to the Nun C terminus and forming a complex with Nun and BOXB. However, NusA also inhibits transcription arrest in vitro, in the absence of the other Nus factors. Nun deleted for its C terminus fails to bind RNA polymerase (RNAP) (RNAP) or NusA in vitro or to arrest transcription in vivo or in vitro. Our findings are consistent with the idea that NusA inhibits transcription arrest by binding to the Nun C terminus, thus blocking the interaction between Nun and RNAP. NusG, NusB, and NusE factors restore transcription arrest, presumably by promoting transfer of Nun from NusA to RNAP.

Independent ligand-induced folding of the RNA-binding domain and two functionally distinct antitermination regions in the phage lambda N protein

The transcriptional antitermination protein N of bacteriophage lambda binds the boxB component of the RNA enhancer nut (boxA + boxB) and the E. coli elongation factor NusA. Efficient antitermination by N requires an RNA-binding domain (amino acids 1-22) and two activating regions for antitermination: a newly identified NusA-binding region (amino acids 34-47) that suppresses NusA's enhancement of termination, and a carboxy-terminal region (amino acids 73-107) that interacts directly with RNA polymerase. Heteronuclear magnetic resonance experiments demonstrate that N is a disordered protein. Interaction with boxB RNA induces only the RNA-binding domain of N to adopt a folded conformation, while the activating regions of the protein remain disordered in the absence of their target proteins.

Assembly of the N-dependent antitermination complex of phage lambda: NusA and RNA bind independently to different unfolded domains of the N protein

The N protein of bacteriophage lambda activates expression of the delayed early genes of this phage by modifying RNA polymerase (RNAP) into a form that is resistant to termination signals. N binds to the boxB hairpin that forms in the nascent RNA transcript upon transcription of the nut regulatory element, and then interacts with RNAP by RNA looping. The binding of the N-boxB subassembly to the transcription complex is further stabilized by interaction with the Escherichia coli NusA protein. N, free in solution, exists as an unfolded protein that becomes partially structured upon binding specifically to boxB RNA. Because NusA does not assist in antitermination unless N is specifically bound to boxB, we have asked whether the structural change induced by binding to boxB affects the interaction of N with NusA. Using fluorescence spectroscopy, we have measured the affinity of N for NusA in the presence and absence of boxB RNA. We find that NusA binds to the unfolded N protein with a dissociation constant (Kd) of approximately 70 nM, and although N undergoes a significant structural change upon binding to boxB, the binding affinity of NusA for a N protein complexed with boxB is not altered. We have also shown that the boxA element of nut does not affect NusA binding to N-boxB. These results demonstrate that the interaction of N with NusA is independent of RNA binding, arguing that NusA must interact with an unfolded region of the polypeptide that remains unstructured even when N binds to boxB RNA. To further establish this point we isolated a truncated peptide containing the amino-terminal 36 residues of the N protein. Binding of boxB RNA to this peptide showed that all of the structural change in N that occurs upon binding to boxB RNA is localized within the amino-terminal 36 residues of N, therefore the C terminus of N, including the regions necessary for NusA binding and RNAP activation, remains unfolded when the full length N binds to boxB RNA. Thus it appears that N can be described as an unfolded multi-domain protein that becomes ordered in a modular fashion as it encounters its various binding partners within the N-dependent antitermination complex.

Regulation of the elongation-termination decision at intrinsic terminators by antitermination protein N of phage lambda

The mechanisms that control N-protein-dependent antitermination in the phage lambda life cycle have counterparts in the regulatory systems of other organisms. Here we examine N-dependent antitermination at the intrinsic tR' terminator of lambda to elucidate the regulatory principles involved. The tR' terminator consists of a sequence of six base-pairs along the template at which the transcription complex is sufficiently destabilized to make RNA release possible. Within this "zone of opportunity" for termination the termination efficiency (TE) at each template position is determined by a kinetic competition between alternative reaction pathways that lead either to elongation or to termination. TE values at each position within tR' have been mapped as a function of NTP concentration, and it is shown that N protein (in the presence of NusA and a nut site; the minimal system for N-dependent antitermination) can offset increases in TE that are induced by limiting the concentrations of each of the next required NTPs. By limiting NTP concentrations or working at low temperature we show that a significant effect of N within the minimal system is to increase the rate of transcript elongation three- to fivefold at most positions along the template. Assuming that a comparable increase in elongation rate applies at template positions within the terminator, we show that an increase of this magnitude is not sufficient to account for the antitermination efficiency observed and that an approximately 100-fold stabilization of the transcription complex at intrinsic termination sites as a consequence of binding the N-containing antitermination sub-assembly must be invoked as well. A general method for partitioning TE effects in antitermination between changes in elongation rate and termination complex stability is demonstrated, based on competing free energy of activation barriers for the elongation and termination reactions. The analysis and utility of such mixed modes of transcriptional regulation are considered in general terms.