A single amino acid exchange, Arg-45 to Ala, generates an epidermal growth factor (EGF) mutant with high affinity for the chicken EGF receptor

Negative Constraints Underlie the ErbB Specificity of Epidermal Growth Factor-like Ligands

Epidermal growth factor (EGF)-like growth factors bind their ErbB receptors in a highly selective manner, but the molecular basis for this specificity is poorly understood. We have previously shown that certain residues in human EGF (Ser(2)-Asp(3)) and TGFalpha (Glu(26)) are not essential for their binding to ErbB1 but prevent binding to ErbB3 and ErbB4. In the present study, we have used a phage display approach to affinity-optimize the C-terminal linear region of EGF-like growth factors for binding to each ErbB receptor and thereby shown that Arg(45) in EGF impairs binding to both ErbB3 and ErbB4. By omitting all these so-called negative constraints from EGF, we designed a ligand designated panerbin that binds ErbB1, ErbB3, and ErbB4 with similarly high affinity as their wild-type ligands. Homology models, based on the known crystal structure of TGFalpha-bound ErbB1, showed that panerbin is able to bind ErbB1, ErbB3, and ErbB4 in a highly similar manner with respect to position and number of interaction sites. Upon in silico introduction of the experimentally known negative constraints into panerbin, we found that Arg(45) induced local charge repulsion and Glu(26) induced steric hindrance in a receptor-specific manner, whereas Ser(2)-Asp(3) impaired binding due to a disordered conformation. Furthermore, radiolabeled panerbin was used to quantify the level of all three receptors on human breast cancer cells in a single radioreceptor assay. It is concluded that the ErbB specificity of EGF-like growth factors primarily results from the presence of a limited number of residues that impair the unintended interaction with other ErbB receptors.

Epidermal Growth Factor Mutant with Wild-Type Affinity for Both ErbB1 and ErbB3

The family of epidermal growth factor (EGF)-like ligands binds to ErbB receptors in a highly selective manner. Previous studies indicated that both linear regions of the ligand play a major role in determining receptor selectivity, and phage display studies showed that each region could be optimized independently for enhanced affinity. In this study, we broadened the ErbB binding specificity of EGF by introducing the optimal sequence requirements for ErbB3 binding in both the N- and C-terminal linear regions. One such EGF mutant, designated WVR/EGF/IADIQ, gained high affinity for ErbB3 and showed concomitant ErbB3 activation through ErbB2.ErbB3 heterodimers similar to the natural ErbB3 ligand NRG1beta, while the capacity to bind and activate ErbB1 was fully maintained. Despite its high affinity for ErbB1 and ErbB3, this mutant was unable to activate ErbB1.ErbB3 heterodimers, as shown by the cell survival and receptor phosphorylation analysis. We concluded that despite the fact that no naturally occurring ligand exists with this dual-specificity, high-affinity binding to both ErbB1 and ErbB3 is not mutually exclusive. This mutant can be useful in a direct structural comparison of the ligand-binding characteristics of ErbB1 and ErbB3.

Ligand depletion negatively controls the mitogenic activity of epidermal growth factor

EGF activates the ErbB1 receptor, but there appears only a limited correlation between its receptor binding affinity and mitogenic activity. This is indicated by our present observation that in cells with high ErbB1 expression, including SUM102 breast tumor cells, low affinity EGF/Notch chimeras have similarly high mitogenic activity as EGF, in spite of the fact that EGF is superior in inducing receptor tyrosine phosphorylation and p42/p44 MAP-kinase activity. However, as a result of receptor-mediated internalisation high-affinity ligands such as EGF are depleted much more rapidly from the extracellular medium than low-affinity EGF/Notch chimeras. As a consequence, the mitogenic activity of EGF on ErbB1 overexpressing cells is limited by substantial degradation of internalised ligand in the period before cells enter S-phase, a phenomenon that is not observed for low affinity mutant ligands. The mitogenic activity of EGF on ErbB1 overexpressing cells does therefore not only depend on the applied concentration but also on the total amount of ligand added, and is strongly underestimated when tested in a limited assay volume. No such dependence on the incubation volume was observed for EGF activity on cells with low ErbB1 expression levels and on cells for which EGF is growth inhibitory.

Five carboxyl-terminal residues of neuregulin2 are critical for stimulation of signaling by the ErbB4 receptor tyrosine kinase

The neuregulins (NRGs) are members of the epidermal growth factor (EGF) family of peptide growth factors. These hormones are agonists for the ErbB family of receptor tyrosine kinases, a family that includes the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR/ErbB1), ErbB2/Neu/HER2, ErbB3/HER3, and ErbB4/HER4. We recently observed that the EGF family hormone NRG2beta is a potent agonist for ErbB4. In contrast, NRG2alpha, a splicing isoform of the same gene that encodes NRG2beta, is a poor ErbB4 agonist. We hypothesized that carboxyl-terminal residues of NRG2beta are critical for stimulation of ErbB4 tyrosine phosphorylation and coupling to downstream signaling events. Here, we demonstrate that the substitution of a lysine residue for Phe45 in NRG2beta results in reduced ligand potency. We also demonstrate that substitution of a phenylalanine for Lys45 in NRG2alpha results in increased ligand potency. Finally, analyses of the gain-of-function NRG2alpha Chg5 mutant demonstrate that Gln43, Met47, Asn49, and Phe50 regulate ligand efficacy. Thus, these data indicate that carboxyl-terminal residues of NRG2beta are critical for activation of ErbB4 signaling. Moreover, these NRG2alpha and NRG2beta mutants reveal new insights into models for ligand-induced ErbB family receptor tyrosine phosphorylation and coupling to downstream signaling events.

Structural analysis of an epidermal growth factor/transforming growth factor-alpha chimera with unique ErbB binding specificity

Various chimeras of the ErbB1-specific ligands epidermal growth factor (EGF) and transforming growth factor-alpha (TGFalpha) display an enlarged repertoire as activators of ErbB2.ErbB3 heterodimers. Mutational analysis indicated that particularly residues in the N terminus and B-loop region of these ligands are involved in the broadened receptor specificity. In order to understand the receptor specificity of T1E, a chimeric ligand constructed by the introduction of the linear N-terminal region of TGFalpha into EGF, we determined in this study the solution structure and dynamics of T1E by multidimensional NMR analysis. Subsequently, we studied the structural characteristics of T1E binding to both ErbB1 and ErbB3 by superposition modeling of its structure on the known crystal structures of ErbB3 and liganded ErbB1 complexes. The results show that the overall structure of T1E in solution is very similar to that of native EGF and TGFalpha but that its N terminus shows an extended structure that is appropriately positioned to form a triple beta-sheet with the large antiparallel beta-sheet in the B-loop region. This conformational effect of the N terminus together with the large overall flexibility of T1E, as determined by 15N NMR relaxation analysis, may be a facilitative property for its broad receptor specificity. The structural superposition models indicate that hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions of the N terminus and B-loop of T1E are particularly important for its binding to ErbB3.

pH-dependent receptor/ligand dissociation as a determining factor for intracellular sorting of ligands for epidermal growth factor receptors in rat hepatocytes

Both epidermal growth factor (EGF) and transforming growth factor-alpha (TGF alpha) bind to EGF receptors and TGF alpha has been reported to be more potent than EGF as far as many biological effects are concerned. One possible reason for this is thought to be the difference in their dissociation from the receptors in intracellular acidic compartments, which may affect the final pathway (lysosomal degradation or recycling to cell-surface) of endocytosed ligands. This study was aimed at clarifying the relationship between intracellular dissociation from the receptors and the fate of the endocytosed ligands. First, (125)I-human EGF (hEGF), mouse EGF (mEGF), or human TGF alpha (hTGF alpha) was prebound to cell-surface receptors or intracellularly preloaded, followed by further incubation at 37 degrees C in primary cultured rat hepatocytes. In these experiments, the magnitude of the dissociation rate constant (k(off)) of each ligand at pH 6.0, which is similar to that inside early endosomes, was found to be in the following order: hTGF alpha>mEGF>hEGF. The recycled portion of endocytosed ligands was also in the order: hTGF alpha>mEGF>hEGF. Digitonin treatment of preloaded cells revealed that the intracellular dissociation of hTGF alpha was more rapid than that of hEGF. Moreover, several histidine-inserted or -deleted hEGF mutants were prebound to rat liver sinusoidal membrane vesicle, followed by further incubation at 37 degrees C. The dissociation rate of histidine-deleted hEGF mutants was less rapid than that of hEGF itself. These results suggested that efficient dissociation in the earlier intracellular compartment leads the endocytosed ligands to be recycled to the cell surface whereas late dissociation results in intracellular degradation in hepatocytes. Thus, one possible strategy to improve their stability in the circulation may be a change in intracellular ligand/receptor dissociation with a minimal effect on the affinity for receptors on the cell-surface and histidine residues may partly contribute to the pH-sensitive dissociation.

Role of the N-terminus of epidermal growth factor in ErbB-2/ErbB-3 binding studied by phage display

Epidermal growth factor (EGF) binds with high affinity to the EGF receptor, also known as ErbB-1, but upon replacement of the N-terminal linear region by neuregulin (NRG) 1 or transforming growth factor (TGF) alpha sequences it gains in addition high affinity for ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers. However, these chimeras weakly bind to ErbB-3 alone. To further dissect the ligand binding selectivity of the ErbB network, we have applied the phage display technique to examine the role of the linear N-terminal region in EGF for interaction with ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers. A library of EGF variants was constructed in which residues 2, 3, and 4 were randomly mutated, followed by selection for binding to intact MDA-MB-453 cells that overexpress ErbB-2 and ErbB-3 but lack ErbB-1. Analysis of the selected phage EGF variants revealed clones with high binding affinity to ErbB-2/ErbB-3 while maintaining high affinity to ErbB-1. In these variants, Trp (or alternatively His) was almost exclusively present at position 2, while specific combinations of hydrophobic, basic, and small residues were found at positions 3 and 4. The mitogenic activity of the phage EGF variants corresponded with their relative binding affinity. Two of the selected EGF variants, EGF/WVS and EGF/WRS, were further characterized as recombinant proteins. In contrast to previously characterized chimeras of EGF with NRG-1 or TGF-alpha, these variants did not only show high binding affinity for ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers but also for ErbB-3 alone. These data show that the linear N-terminal region of EGF-like growth factors is directly involved in binding to ErbB-3.

Modeling the epidermal growth factor -- epidermal growth factor receptor l2 domain interaction: implications for the ligand binding process

Signaling from the epidermal growth factor (EGF) receptor is triggered by the binding of ligands such as EGF or transforming growth factor alpha (TGF-alpha) and subsequent receptor dimerization. An understanding of these processes has been hindered by the lack of structural information about the ligand-bound, dimerized EGF receptor. Using an NMR-derived structure of EGF and a homology model of the major ligand binding domain of the EGF receptor and experimental data, we modeled the binding of EGF to this EGF receptor fragment. In this low resolution model of the complex, EGF sits across the second face of the EGF receptor L2 domain and EGF residues 10-16, 36-37, 40-47 bind to this face. The structural model is largely consistent with previously published NMR data describing the residues of TGF-alpha which interact strongly with the EGF receptor. Other EGF residues implicated in receptor binding are accounted by our proposal that the ligand binding is a two-step process with the EGF binding to at least one other site of the receptor. This three-dimensional model is expected to be useful in the design of ligand-based antagonists of the receptor.

Epidermal growth factor contains both positive and negative determinants for interaction with ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers

Epidermal growth factor (EGF) and transforming growth factor (TGF)-alpha are potent activators of the ErbB-1 receptor, but, unlike TGF-alpha, EGF is also a weak activator of ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers. To understand the specificity of EGF-like growth factors for binding to distinct ErbB members, we used EGF/TGF-alpha chimeras to examine the requirements for ErbB-2/ErbB-3 activation. Here we show that in contrast to these two wild-type ligands, distinct EGF/TGF-alpha chimeras are potent activators of ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers. On the basis of differences in the potency of these various chimeras, specific residues in the linear N-terminal region and the so-called B-loop of these ligands were identified to be involved in interaction with ErbB-2/ErbB-3. A chimera consisting of human EGF sequences with the linear N-terminal region of human TGF-alpha was found to be almost as potent as the natural ligand neuregulin (NRG)-1beta in activating 32D cells expressing ErbB-2/ErbB-3 and human breast cancer cells. Binding studies revealed that this chimera, designated T1E, has high affinity for ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers, but not for ErbB-3 alone. Subsequent exchange studies revealed that introduction of both His2 and Phe3 into the linear N-terminal region was already sufficient to make EGF a potent activator of ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers, indicating that these two amino acids contribute positively to this receptor binding. Analysis of the B-loop revealed that Leu26 in EGF facilitates interaction with ErbB-2/ErbB-3 heterodimers, while the equivalent Glu residue in TGF-alpha impairs binding. Since all EGF/TGF-alpha chimeras tested have maintained high binding affinity for ErbB-1, it is concluded that the diversity of the ErbB signaling network is determined by specific amino acids that facilitate binding to one receptor member, in addition to residues that impede binding to other ErbB family members.

The Asn-420-linked sugar chain in human epidermal growth factor receptor suppresses ligand-independent spontaneous oligomerization. Possible role of a specific sugar chain in controllable receptor activation

To elucidate a role(s) of Asn-linked sugar chain(s) in the function of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), a series of the EGFR mutants were prepared in which potential glycosylation sites in the domain III were eliminated by site-directed mutagenesis. Although the wild-type and mutants of Asn-328, Asn-337, and Asn-389 underwent autophosphorylation in response to epidermal growth factor (EGF), the Asn-420 --> Gln mutant was found to be constitutively tyrosine-phosphorylated. This abnormal ligand-independent phosphorylation of the mutant appears to be due to a ligand-independent spontaneous oligomer formation, as shown by a cross-linking experiment using the purified soluble extracellular domain (sEGFR). As revealed by the dissociation of the Asn-420 --> Gln sEGFR oligomer by simple dilution, it seems likely that the equilibrium is shifted toward oligomer formation to an unusual degree. Furthermore, it was also found that the mutation caused a loss of the ability to bind EGF. These findings suggest that the sugar chain linked to Asn-420 plays a crucial role in EGF binding and prevents spontaneous oligomerization of the EGFR, which may otherwise lead to uncontrollable receptor activation, and support the view of a specific role of an Asn-linked sugar chain in the function of a glycoprotein.

Non-linear antigenic regions in epidermal growth factor (EGF) and transforming growth factor alpha (TGF alpha) studied by EGF-TGF alpha chimaeras

With the help of 16 chimaeras between human epidermal growth factor (hEGF) and human transforming growth factor alpha (hTGF alpha), a detailed analysis was performed on the epitope recognized by two polyclonal antibodies raised against hEGF, and one polyclonal antibody raised against hTGF alpha. All three antibodies recognized essentially the same antigenic site, a non-linear and conformation-dependent sequence that is located near the second and fourth disulphide-bonded cysteines and that includes the start of the B-loop beta-sheet. The epitope recognized by the anti-hEGF antibodies was further characterized using 8 chimaeras between hEGF and an EGF-repeat from Drosophila Notch and was found to include Met(21), Ala(30) and Asn(32). All three polyclonal antibodies were able to neutralize the biological activity of the respective growth factor when tested on 32D murine haematopoietic progenitor cells transfected with ErbB-1, indicating that the receptor binding domain is shielded upon binding of the antibody.

The EGF domain: requirements for binding to receptors of the ErbB family

Epidermal growth factor (EGF) has been the prototype growth-stimulating peptide for many years. It has a characteristic structure with three disulfide bridges, which is essential for its activity. However, many other proteins, including both growth factors and proteins with unrelated functions, have similar EGF-like domains. This indicates that besides a characteristic conformation provided by the EGF-like domain, specific amino acids are required to provide specificity in protein functioning. Currently, more than 10 different growth factors with an EGF-like domain have been characterized which all exert their action by binding to the four members of the erbB family of receptors. In this review, studies are described on the structure-function relationship of these EGF-like growth factor molecules in an attempt to analyze the individual amino acids that determine their binding specificity to the individual members of the erbB family.

Receptor recognition by histidine 16 of human epidermal growth factor via hydrogen-bond donor/acceptor interactions

Human epidermal growth factor (hEGF) and human transforming growth factor alpha (hTGFalpha) are prototypical of structurally related polypeptide mitogens which interact with the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). Several determinants of receptor recognition that specify function have been proposed on the basis of structural criteria. This study evaluates the role of one such candidate, H16 of hEGF, by site-specific mutagenesis. When assayed for receptor tyrosine kinase stimulation using (Glu4,Tyr1)n as the exogenous substrate in vitro, the relative agonist activities of position 16 mutants range from 14-263% of wild-type hEGF. The rank order of potency was found to correlate with the relative receptor binding affinities of the mutants, which range from 7-272% of wild-type, as determined by radioreceptor competition assays. The mitogenic activity of the H16 mutants is similar to that of wild-type hEGF as determined by clonogenic assays using rat tracheal epithelial cells. While the colony forming efficiencies do not reflect significant differences in growth rate or survival characteristics in the presence of the hEGF variants, it is reduced to 1.6% in control cultures which lack EGF in the medium. The results show that H16 of hEGF, although not essential for mitogenic activity, optimizes receptor recognition by hydrogen-bond donor/acceptor interactions and may share this feature with H18 of hTGFalpha.

The linear C-terminal regions of epidermal growth factor (EGF) and transforming growth factor-alpha bind to different epitopes on the human EGF receptor

Epidermal growth factor (EGF) and transforming growth factor-alpha (TGFalpha) bind with similar affinities in a competitive fashion to the human EGF receptor, and basically induce similar mitogenic responses. In spite of the fact that EGF and TGFalpha are structurally alike, it is still not clear if the two growth factors bind the receptor in an identical manner. The observation that the 13A9 antibody blocks binding of TGFalpha, but not that of EGF, to the human EGF receptor [Winkler, O'Connor, Winget and Fendly (1989) Biochemistry 28, 6373-6378] suggests that their binding characteristics are not identical. In the present study we have made use of a set of EGF/TGFalpha chimaeric molecules to show that the 13A9 antibody blocks receptor binding of ligands with TGFalpha sequences, but not of ligands with EGF sequences, in their C-terminal linear regions. Using HaCaT human keratinocyte cells in culture, it was determined that ligands that are able to bind the EGF receptor in the presence of 13A9 are also able to induce calcium release from intracellular stores in these cells, indicating that these ligands have the ability to activate the EGF receptor in the presence of the antibody. From these data it is concluded that the flexible C-terminal linear domains of EGF and TGFalpha bind to separate sequences on the EGF receptor, such that the binding domain of TGFalpha, but not that of EGF, overlaps with the binding epitope of the 13A9 antibody.

Identification of the minimal requirements for binding to the human epidermal growth factor (EGF) receptor using chimeras of human EGF and an EGF repeat of Drosophila Notch

Many proteins contain so-called epidermal growth factor (EGF)-like domains that share the characteristic spacing of cysteines and glycines with members of the EGF family. They are, however, functionally unrelated, despite the fact that the three-dimensional structure of these EGF-like domains, also, is often very similar to that of the EGF receptor agonists. In the present study, we linked an EGF-like repeat from the Drosophila Notch protein to the N- and C-terminal linear tail sequences of human EGF (hEGF), and we showed that this chimera (E1N6E) is unable to bind or activate the hEGF receptor. This recombinant protein was then used as a basic construct for identifying the minimal requirements for high affinity EGF receptor binding and activation. We selectively reintroduced a limited number of important hEGF-derived residues, and by using this unique approach, we were able to make hEGF/Notch chimeras that, compared with wild type hEGF, showed nearly 100% binding affinity and mitogenic activity on HER-14 cells expressing the hEGF receptor.

Differential endocytic routing of homo- and hetero-dimeric ErbB tyrosine kinases confers signaling superiority to receptor heterodimers

Both homo- and hetero-dimers of ErbB receptor tyrosine kinases mediate signaling by a large group of epidermal growth factor (EGF)-like ligands. However, some ligands are more potent than others, although they bind to the same direct receptor. In addition, signaling by receptor heterodimers is superior to homodimers. We addressed the mechanism underlying these two features of signal tuning by using three ligands: EGF; transforming growth factor alpha (TGFalpha); and their chimera, denoted E4T, which act on cells singly expressing ErbB-1 as a weak, a strong, and a very strong agonist, respectively. Co-expression of ErbB-2, a developmentally important co-receptor whose expression is frequently elevated in human cancers, specifically potentiated EGF signaling to the level achieved by TGFalpha, an effect that was partially mimicked by ErbB-3. Analysis of the mechanism underlying this trans-potentiation implied that EGF-driven homodimers of ErbB-1 are destined for intracellular degradation, whereas the corresponding heterodimers with ErbB-2 or with ErbB-3, dissociate in the early endosome. As a consequence, in the presence of either co-receptor, ErbB-1 is recycled to the cell surface and its signaling is enhanced. This latter route is followed by TGFalpha-driven homodimers of ErbB-1, and also by E4T-bound receptors, whose signaling is further enhanced by repeated cycles of binding and dissociation from the receptors. We conclude that alternative endocytic routes of homo- and hetero-dimeric receptor complexes may contribute to tuning and diversification of signal transduction. In addition, the ability of ErbB-2 to shunt ligand-activated receptors to recycling may explain, in part, its oncogenic potential.

Binding interaction of the heregulinbeta egf domain with ErbB3 and ErbB4 receptors assessed by alanine scanning mutagenesis

Individual residues of the heregulinbeta (HRG) egf domain were mutated to alanine and displayed monovalently on phagemid particles as gene III fusion proteins. Wild type HRGbeta egf domain displayed on phage was properly folded as evidenced by its ability to bind ErbB3 and ErbB4 receptor-IgG fusion proteins with affinities close to those measured for bacterially produced HRGbeta egf domain. Binding to ErbB3 and ErbB4 receptors was affected by mutation of residues throughout the egf domain; including the NH2 terminus (His2 and Leu3), the two beta-turns (Val15-Gly18 and Gly42-Gln46), and some discontinuous residues (including Leu3, Val4, Phe13, Val23, and Leu33) that form a patch on the major beta-sheet and the COOH-terminal region (Tyr48 and Met50-Phe53). Binding affinity was least changed by mutations throughout the Omega-loop and the second strand of the major beta-sheet. More mutants had greater affinity loss for ErbB3 compared with ErbB4 implying that it has more stringent binding requirements. Many residues important for HRG binding to its receptors correspond to critical residues for epidermal growth factor (EGF) and transforming growth factor alpha binding to the EGF receptor. Specificity may be determined in part by bulky groups that prevent binding to the unwanted receptor. All of the mutants tested were able to induce phosphorylation and mitogen-activated protein kinase activation through ErbB4 receptors and were able to modulate a transphosphorylation signal from ErbB3 to ErbB2 in MCF7 cells. An understanding of binding similarities and differences among the EGF family of ligands may facilitate the development of egf-like analogs with broad or narrow specificity.

In vivo analysis of Argos structure-function. Sequence requirements for inhibition of the Drosophila epidermal growth factor receptor

The Drosophila Argos protein is the only known extracellular inhibitor of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). It is structurally related to the activating ligands, in that it is a secreted protein with a single epidermal growth factor (EGF) domain. To understand the mechanism of Argos inhibition, we have investigated which regions of the protein are essential. A series of deletions were made and tested in vivo; furthermore, by analyzing chimeric proteins between Argos and the activating ligand, Spitz (a transforming growth factor-alpha-like factor), we have examined what makes one inhibitory and the other activating. Our results reveal that Argos has structural requirements that differ from all known EGFR activating ligands; domains flanking the EGF domain are essential for its function. We have also defined the important regions of the atypical Argos EGF domain. The extended B-loop is necessary, whereas the C-loop can be replaced with the equivalent Spitz region without substantially affecting Argos function. Comparison of the argos genes from Drosophila melanogaster and the housefly, Musca domestica, supports our structure-function analysis. These studies are a prerequisite for understanding how Argos inhibits the Drosophila EGFR and provide a basis for designing mammalian EGFR inhibitors.

Superagonistic behaviour of epidermal growth factor/transforming growth factor-alpha chimaeras: correlation with receptor routing after ligand-induced internalization

Human epidermal growth factor (EGF) and human transforming growth factor alpha (TGF-alpha) are structurally related polypeptide growth factors that exert their mitogenic activity through interaction with a common cell-surface receptor, the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). The biological effect induced by these two ligands is quantitatively similar in most cases; in some test systems, however, TGF-alpha functions as a more potent form of EGF. In this study, we have compared EGF, TGF-alpha and ten previously described chimaeras of these two ligands in terms of their ability to generate a mitogenic response in cells carrying the human EGFR, and observed that three of the mutant growth factors (E3T, E4T and T3E4T) are mitogenic at concentrations 10-fold lower than that of either wild-type EGF or TGF-alpha. No difference in tyrosine kinase activity of the receptor towards an external substrate was observed after binding of the various mutants. It has been established before [Ebner and Derynck (1991) Cell Regulation 2, 599-612] that EGF and TGF-alpha differ in the processing of the receptor-ligand complex after internalization, as a result of their different pH sensitivities of receptor binding. Similar measurements on our chimaeric mutants revealed that the above superagonists show an enhanced pH dependence of binding in comparison with EGF. Furthermore, induction of receptor recycling by these superagonists is largely comparable with that induced by TGF-alpha. No superagonistic behaviour was observed on a cell-line containing an EGFR/erbB-2 chimaera which does not show ligand-induced internalization. These data show that EGF/TGFalpha chimaeras can be more active than the naturally occurring ligands, and that receptor recycling after ligand-induced internalization seems to be a prerequisite for this phenomenon.

Chimeric proteins can exceed the sum of their parts: implications for evolution and protein design

Chimeric analogs derived from pairs of homologous proteins routinely exhibit activities found in one or both parents. We describe chimeras of two glycoprotein hormones, human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) and human follitropin (hFSH), that exhibit activity unique to a third family member, human thyrotropin (hTSH). The results show that biological activity can be separated from hormone-specific amino acid residues. This is consistent with a model for the evolution of homologous ligand-receptor pairs involving gene duplication and the creation of inhibitory determinants that restrict binding. Disruption of these determinants can unmask activities characteristic of other members of a protein family. Combining portions of two ligands to create analogs with properties of a third family member can facilitate identifying key determinants of protein-protein interaction and may be a useful strategy for creating novel therapeutics. In the case of the glycoprotein hormones, this showed that two different hormone regions (i.e., the seat-belt and the intersubunit groove) appear to limit inappropriate contacts with receptors for other members of this family. These observations also have important caveats for chimera-based protein design because an unexpected gain of function may limit the therapeutic usefulness of some chimeras.

Identification of residues of the epidermal growth factor receptor proximal to residue 45 of bound epidermal growth factor

A triple mutant of murine epidermal growth factor (mEGF), N1Q/H22Y/R45K-mEGF, was constructed by site-directed mutagenesis, expressed, purified, and characterized for use in an affinity cross-linking study to identify aminoacyl residues of the EGF receptor adjacent to a residue in the carboxyl-terminal domain of bound EGF thought to be important in distinguishing between EGF and transforming growth factor-alpha in their recognition by the receptor. Cyclization of Gln1 to form pyroglutamate (pE) limited the site of cross-linking in the mutant to Lys45, permitting identification of receptor residues that are proximal to this residue of bound EGF. The resulting N1pE/H22Y/R45K-mEGF was shown to be comparable to wild-type mEGF in receptor binding and stimulation of receptor autophosphorylation. 125I-Labeled N1pE/H22Y/R45K-mEGF was reacted with the heterobifunctional cross-linking reagent sulfo-N-succinimidyl-4-(fluorosulfonyl)benzoate, and the resulting modified EGF was incubated with A431 membrane vesicles bearing EGF receptors. Incubation resulted in specific cross-linking of the labeled N1pE/H22Y/R45K-mEGF to EGF receptors. The resulting cross-linked complex was then partially purified, denatured, reduced, and carboxyamidomethylated. Digestion with endoprotease LysC resulted in a unique radiolabeled peptide that could be immunoprecipitated using antibodies to mEGF. This immunoprecipitated fragment was purified by gel electrophoresis and subjected to microsequencing. The resulting sequence was matched to that of a LysC fragment of the receptor, which begins with Thr464 and is near the interface of receptor subdomains III and IV. Loss of signal at cycle 2 suggests that the point of attachment of cross-linked N1pE/H22Y/R45K is Lys465 of the receptor.