Is protein kinase substrate efficacy a reliable barometer for successful inhibitor design?

Kinetic characterization of the soluble butane monooxygenase from Thauera butanivorans, formerly 'Pseudomonas butanovora'

Soluble butane monooxygenase (sBMO), a three-component di-iron monooxygenase complex expressed by the C(2)-C(9) alkane-utilizing bacterium Thauera butanivorans, was kinetically characterized by measuring substrate specificities for C(1)-C(5) alkanes and product inhibition profiles. sBMO has high sequence homology with soluble methane monooxygenase (sMMO) and shares a similar substrate range, including gaseous and liquid alkanes, aromatics, alkenes and halogenated xenobiotics. Results indicated that butane was the preferred substrate (defined by k(cat) : K(m) ratios). Relative rates of oxidation for C(1)-C(5) alkanes differed minimally, implying that substrate specificity is heavily influenced by differences in substrate K(m) values. The low micromolar K(m) for linear C(2)-C(5) alkanes and the millimolar K(m) for methane demonstrate that sBMO is two to three orders of magnitude more specific for physiologically relevant substrates of T. butanivorans. Methanol, the product of methane oxidation and also a substrate itself, was found to have similar K(m) and k(cat) values to those of methane. This inability to kinetically discriminate between the C(1) alkane and C(1) alcohol is observed as a steady-state concentration of methanol during the two-step oxidation of methane to formaldehyde by sBMO. Unlike methanol, alcohols with chain length C(2)-C(5) do not compete effectively with their respective alkane substrates. Results from product inhibition experiments suggest that the geometry of the active site is optimized for linear molecules four to five carbons in length and is influenced by the regulatory protein component B (butane monooxygenase regulatory component; BMOB). The data suggest that alkane oxidation by sBMO is highly specialized for the turnover of C(3)-C(5) alkanes and the release of their respective alcohol products. Additionally, sBMO is particularly efficient at preventing methane oxidation during growth on linear alkanes > or =C(2,) despite its high sequence homology with sMMO. These results represent, to the best of our knowledge, the first kinetic in vitro characterization of the closest known homologue of sMMO.

Effects of cryostabilizers, low temperature, and freezing on the kinetics of the pectin methylesterase-catalyzed de-esterification of pectin

The kinetics of the pectin methylesterase (PME)-catalyzed de-esterification of pectin was studied at 25 degrees C in the presence of sucrose, fructose, maltodextrin (DE = 16.5-19.5), and carboxymethylcellulose at different concentrations and in the presence of maltodextrin and sucrose at different concentrations in a temperature range between +25 and -4 degrees C in subcooled and frozen states. The objective was to determine whether the reaction is diffusion-controlled, to gain insight about the factors determining the diffusion of the reactants, and to determine the effect of the carbohydrates, low temperature, and freezing on the structural conformation of the enzyme. The results indicate that the PME-catalyzed de-esterification of pectin is diffusion-controlled. Nevertheless, the diffusion is not controlled by the macroviscosity of the reaction medium, but rather by the microviscosity experienced by the diffusants. Low temperature in the temperature range studied does not affect the structural conformation of the enzyme, while freezing seems to have some effect.

Systematic development of an enzymatic phosphorylation assay compatible with mass spectrometric detection

The enzymatic peptide phosphorylation by cAMP-dependent protein kinase A (PKA) was optimized and monitored by means of electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The direct detection of phosphorylated peptides by MS renders labeling unnecessary, reduces time and labor, due to less initial sample pretreatment. In this study the phosphorylation of the peptide malantide by PKA was performed in batch and reaction compounds were detected by ESI-MS after the incubation time. The subsequent product quantitation was accomplished by using one-point normalization. Applying this set-up, optimum solvent conditions (such as salt and modifier content), concentrations of essential reaction compounds (such as cAMP, Mg2+ and ATP), and the influence of reaction properties (such as pH and reaction time) were determined. The reaction milieu has to be suitable for both, the enzymatic reaction and the mass spectrometric detection. We found that the modifier content and the pH value had to be changed after the enzymatic reaction occurred. Through the addition of methanol and acetic acid, the reaction stopped immediately and a more sensitive mass spectrometric detection could be obtained simultaneously. Furthermore, an inhibitor study was performed, testing the inhibition potency of three protein kinase A inhibitors (PKIs). IC50 values were determined and used to calculate the Ki values, that were 7.4, 19.0 and 340.0 nmol/L for PKI(6-22)amide, PKI(5-24)amide, and PKI(14-24)amide, respectively. These data vary between factor 4.4 (for PKI(6-22)amide) and 8.3 (for PKI(5-24)amide) compared to the Ki values described in literature. However, the Ki values are in good agreement with the data mainly obtained by fluorescence- or radioactivity-based methods. Nevertheless, our results indicate that ESI-MS is a realistic alternative to radioactivity and fluorescence detection in determining enzymatic activity. Furthermore we were able to illustrate its high potential as a quantitative detection method.

Phosphoryl transfer step in the C-terminal Src kinase controls Src recognition

All members of the Src family of nonreceptor protein tyrosine kinases are phosphorylated and subsequently down-regulated by the C-terminal Src kinase, Csk. Although the recognition of Src protein substrates is essential for a diverse set of signaling events linked to cellular growth and differentiation, the factors controlling this critical protein-protein interaction are not well known. To understand how Csk recognizes Src, the chemical/physical events that modulate apparent substrate affinity and turnover were investigated. Src is phosphorylated in a biphasic manner in rapid quench flow experiments, suggesting that the phosphoryl transfer step is fast and highly favorable and does not limit overall turnover. As opposed to other kinase-substrate pairs, turnover is not limited by the physical release of ADP based on stopped-flow fluorescence and catalytic trapping experiments, suggesting that other steps control net phosphorylation. The K(d) for Src is considerably larger than the K(m) based on single turnover kinetic and equilibrium sedimentation experiments. Taken together, the data are consistent with a mechanism whereby Csk achieves a low K(m) for the substrate Src, not by stabilizing protein-protein interactions but rather by facilitating a fast phosphoryl transfer step. In this manner, the phosphoryl transfer step functions as a chemical clamp facilitating substrate recognition.

Activation loop phosphorylation and catalysis in protein kinases: is there functional evidence for the autoinhibitor model?

Many protein kinases are activated strongly by the phosphorylation of a polypeptide region (activation loop) that lies outside the active-site cleft. Analysis of the X-ray crystallographic structures of the insulin receptor with the activation loop in the phosphorylated and dephosphorylated forms offers a testable model for the mechanism of activity regulation by the loop. In this model, the dephosphorylated activation loop can act as an autoinhibitor by blocking substrate access to the active site. Phosphorylation of the loop could then release the autoinhibitor from the active site, allowing substrate binding and catalysis. While this model has been widely invoked, it was not clear if solution studies would support an autoinhibitory model for kinase regulation, in general. We review the results of solution studies on six protein kinases that test the role of the activation loop in controlling active-site access. While loop phosphorylation enhances substrate binding in two cases, four protein kinases display little or no effect on substrate dissociation constants. By comparison, phosphorylation increases catalysis by 2-4 orders of magnitude in all cases. These findings can be used to place the phosphorylatable activation loops into two broad, functional subcategories. (i) Gated activation loops exhibit bifunctional properties restricting substrate access and controlling catalysis. (ii) Nongated activation loops allow free movement of the substrate in and out of the active site irrespective of phosphorylation state but potently modulate the phosphoryl transfer step. Thus, while activation loop phosphorylation greatly modulates catalytic potential, it does not necessarily affect substrate binding, as once widely believed.

Delineation of selective cyclic GMP-dependent protein kinase Ialpha substrate and inhibitor peptides based on combinatorial peptide libraries on paper

Peptide libraries on cellulose paper have proven to be valuable tools for the a priori determination of substrate specificities of cyclic AMP- and cyclic GMP-dependent protein kinases (cAMP-kinase and cGMP-kinase) on the basis of octa-peptide sequences. Here, we report the extension of our peptide library screens to 12-mer and 14-mer peptide sequences, resulting in highly cGMP-kinase Ialpha selective peptides. The sequences TQAKRKKSLAMA-amide and TQAKRKKSLAMFLR-amide, with Km values for cGMP-kinase Ialpha of 0.7 and 0.26 microM and Vmax values of 11.5 and 10.9 micromol/min/mg, respectively, display a high specificity for this enzyme. Furthermore, replacing the phosphate acceptor residue serine with alanine in TQAKRKKSLAMA-amide resulted in the highly cGMP-kinase Ialpha selective inhibitor peptide TQAKRKKALAMA-amide, with inhibitor constants for cGMP-kinase Ialpha and cAMP-kinase of 7.5 microM and 750 microM, respectively. Selective cGMP-kinase inhibitors have the potential to play an important role in the elucidation of the distinct cellular functions of cGMP-kinase separate from those activated by cAMP-kinases, and, therefore, may play an important role as pharmaceutical targets. Molecular docking experiments of the most cGMP-kinase selective sequences on a molecular model of the catalytic domain of cGMP-kinase Ialpha suggest that they adopt unique conformations, which differ significantly from those observed for the cAMP-kinase-specific inhibitor PKI(5-24). Our results suggest that despite their structural similarities, cAMP-kinase and cGMP-kinase use distinct peptide substrate and inhibitor conformations, which could account for their unique substrate specificities. These findings are further supported by cAMP- and cGMP-kinase-selective inhibitor analogs with (D)-Ala residues at the inhibitory positions.

Cyclic peptides as probes of the substrate binding site of the cytosolic tyrosine kinase, pp60c-src

A series of 48 cyclic peptides based on the amino acid sequence surrounding the autophosphorylation site of pp60(c-src) was synthesized and each was tested as both a substrate and an inhibitor of this protein tyrosine kinase. Starting with cyclo(Asp1-Asn2-Gln3-Tyr4-Ala5-Ala6-Arg7-Gln8-d- Phe9-Pro10) a six-amino-acid survey was performed at positions 1 through 8 to determine which positions were critical for affinity and phosphorylation and which amino acids produced the greatest activity. Our survey found that Arg7 was detrimental for binding and phosphorylation and that aromatic residues were preferred at this position. Further increases in affinity were obtained with hydrophobic residues at position 6 with the optimum for both affinity and phosphorylation being Phe. Changes on the "amino-terminal" side of Tyr4 resulted in reduced Vmax values, illustrating the requirement for acidic residues in peptidic tyrosine kinase substrates. The result of the survey was cyclo(Asp1-Asn2-Gln3-Tyr4-Ala5-Phe6-Phe7-Gln8-d-Phe 9-Pro10). The change of residues 6 and 7 resulted in a 42-fold increase in affinity and no increase in Vmax. As a substrate, this peptide displayed Michaelis-Menten kinetics at saturating ATP conditions. As an inhibitor, mixed inhibition was observed. A linear version of this peptide was 13-fold less potent an inhibitor than the cyclic peptide.