Additivity of protein-guanine interactions in ribonuclease T1

Bacterial toxin RelE: a highly efficient ribonuclease with exquisite substrate specificity using atypical catalytic residues

The toxin RelE is a ribosome-dependent endoribonuclease implicated in diverse cellular processes, including persistence. During amino acid starvation, RelE inhibits translation by cleaving ribosomal A-site mRNA. Although RelE is structurally similar to other microbial endoribonucleases, the active-site amino acid composition differs substantially and lacks obvious candidates for general acid-base functionality. Highly conserved RelE residues (Lys52, Lys54, Arg61, Arg81, and Tyr87) surround the mRNA scissile phosphate, and specific 16S rRNA contacts further contribute to substrate positioning. We used a single-turnover kinetic assay to evaluate the catalytic importance of individual residues in the RelE active site. Within the context of the ribosome, RelE rapidly cleaves A-site mRNA at a rate similar to those of traditional ribonucleases. Single-turnover rate constants decreased between 10(2)- and 10(6)-fold for the RelE active-site mutants of Lys52, Lys54, Arg61, and Arg81. RelE may principally promote catalysis via transition-state charge stabilization and leaving-group protonation, in addition to achieving in-line substrate positioning in cooperation with the ribosome. This kinetic analysis complements structural information to provide a foundation for understanding the molecular mechanism of this atypical endoribonuclease.

Structure of RNase Sa2 complexes with mononucleotides--new aspects of catalytic reaction and substrate recognition

Although the mechanism of RNA cleavage by RNases has been studied for many years, there remain aspects that have not yet been fully clarified. We have solved the crystal structures of RNase Sa2 in the apo form and in complexes with mononucleotides. These structures provide more details about the mechanism of RNA cleavage by RNase Sa2. In addition to Glu56 and His86, which are the principal catalytic residues, an important role in the first reaction step of RNA cleavage also seems to be played by Arg67 and Arg71, which are located in the phosphate-binding site and form hydrogen bonds with the oxygens of the phosphate group of the mononucleotides. Their positive charge very likely causes polarization of the bonds between the oxygens and the phosphorus atom, leading to electron deficiency on the phosphorus atom and facilitating nucleophilic attack by O2' of the ribose on the phosphorus atom, leading to cyclophosphate formation. The negatively charged Glu56 is in position to attract the proton from O2' of the ribose. Extended molecular docking of mononucleotides, dinucleotides and trinucleotides into the active site of the enzyme allowed us to better understand the guanosine specificity of RNase Sa2 and to predict possible binding subsites for the downstream base and ribose of the second and third nucleotides.

Molecular basis of the recognition process: hydrogen-bonding patterns in the guanine primary recognition site of ribonuclease T1

Investigation of the intrinsic H-bonding pattern of the guanine complex with a sizable segment (from Asn43 to Glu46) of the primary recognition site (PRS) in RNase T1 at the B3LYP/6-311G(d,p) level of theory enables the electronic density characteristics of the H-bonding patterns of the guanine-PRS complexes to be identified. The perfect H-bonding pattern in the guanine recognition site is achieved through the guanine complex interactions with the large segment of the PRS. Two significant short H-bonds, O epsilon 1...HN1 and O epsilon 2...HN2, have been identified. The similar short H-bond distances found in the anionic GC- base pair and in this study suggest that the short hydrogen-bond distances may be characteristic of the multiple H-bonded anionic nucleobases. The H-bonding energy distribution, the geometric analysis of the H-bonding pattern, and the electron structure characteristics of the H-bonds in the guanine PRS of RNase T1 all suggest that the O epsilon 1...HN1 and O epsilon 2...HN2 side-chain H-bonds dominate the binding at the guanine recognition site of RNase T1. Also, the geometry evidence, the electron structure characteristics, and the properties of the bond critical points of the H-bonds reveal that the side-chain H-bonding and the main-chain H-bonding are mutually intensifying. Thus the positive cooperativity between Asn43 to Tyr45 and Glu46 is proposed.

RNase T1 variant RV cleaves single-stranded RNA after purines due to specific recognition by the Asn46 side chain amide

Attempts to alter the guanine specificity of ribonuclease T1 (RNase T1) by rational or random mutagenesis have failed so far. The RNase T1 variant RV (Lys41Glu, Tyr42Phe, Asn43Arg, Tyr45Trp, and Glu46Asn) designed by combination of a random and a rational mutagenesis approach, however, exhibits a stronger preference toward adenosine residues than wild-type RNase T1. Steady state kinetics of the cleavage reaction of the two dinucleoside phosphate substrates adenylyl-3',5'-cytidine and guanylyl-3',5'-cytidine revealed that the ApC/GpC ratio of the specificity coefficient (k(cat)/K(m)) was increased approximately 7250-fold compared to that of the wild-type. The crystal structure of the nucleotide-free RV variant has been refined in space group P6(1) to a crystallographic R-factor of 19.9% at 1.7 A resolution. The primary recognition site of the RV variant adopts a similar conformation as already known from crystal structures of RNase T1 not complexed to any nucleotide. Noteworthy is a high flexibility of Trp45 and Asn46 within the three individual molecules in the asymmetric unit. In addition to the kinetic studies, these data indicate the participation of Asn46 in the specific recognition of the base and therefore a specific binding of adenosine.

Guanine binding site of the Nicotiana glutinosa ribonuclease NW revealed by X-ray crystallography

Ribonuclease NW (RNase NW), the wound-inducible RNase in Nicotiana glutinosa leaves, preferentially cleaves guanylic acid. We expressed the cDNA encoding RNase NW in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris using the expression vector pPIC9K, and the resulting recombinant RNase NW (ryRNaseNW) secreted into medium was purified to apparent homogeneity using column chromatography. The crystal structure of ryRNase NW bound to 5'-GMP was determined at 1.5 A resolution by molecular replacement with tomato RNase LE as a search model. The RNase NW structurally belongs to the (alpha + beta) class of proteins, having eight helices (five alpha-helices and three 3(10) helices) and six beta-strands, and its structure is highly similar to those of other plant RNases, including a uridylic acid preferential RNase MC1 from bitter gourd seeds. The guanine ring of 5'-GMP lies in a hydrophobic pocket of the molecular surface composed of Tyr17, Tyr71, Ala80, Leu79, and Phe89: the guanine base is sandwiched between aromatic side chains of Tyr17 and Phe89. In addition, the guanine base is firmly stabilized by a network of hydrogen bonds of the side chains of Gln12 and Thr78, as well as of the main chain of Leu79. Therefore, Gln12, Tyr17, Thr78, Leu79, and Phe89 are responsible for recognition of the guanine base by RNase NW, findings which provide insight into the manner in which RNase NW preferentially cleaves guanylic acid.

Domain swapping in ribonuclease T1 allows the acquisition of double-stranded activity

A mutant of ribonuclease T1 (RNase T1), denoted RNase Talpha, that is designed to recognize double-stranded ribonucleic acid was created. RNase Talpha carries the structure of RNase T1 except for a part of its loop L3 domain, which has been swapped for a corresponding domain from alpha-sarcin. The RNase Talpha maintains the pleated beta-sheet structure and retains the guanyl-specific ribonuclease activity of the wild-type RNase T1. A steady-state kinetic study on the RNase Talpha-catalyzed transesterification of GpU dinucleoside phosphates reveals a slightly reduced K(m) value of 6.94 x 10(-7) M. When the stranded specificity is examined, RNase Talpha catalyzes the hydrolysis of guanine base not only of single-stranded but also, as by design, of double-stranded RNA. The change of stranded specificity suggests the feasibility of using domain swapping to make a substrate-specific ribonuclease. This study suggests that the loop L3 in RNase T1 can be used as a 'cassette player' for inserting a functional domain to make ribonuclease of various specificities.

Probing functional perfection in substructures of ribonuclease T1: double combinatorial random mutagenesis involving Asn43, Asn44, and Glu46 in the guanine binding loop

Combinatorial random mutageneses involving either Asn43 with Asn44 (set 1) or Glu46 with an adjacent insertion (set 2) were undertaken to explore the functional perfection of the guanine recognition loop of ribonuclease T(1) (RNase T(1)). Four hundred unique recombinants were screened in each set for their ability to enhance enzyme catalysis of RNA cleavage. After a thorough selection procedure, only six variants were found that were either as active or more active than wild type which included substitutions of Asn43 by Gly, His, Leu, or Thr, an unplanned Tyr45Ser substitution and Glu46Pro with an adjacent Glu47 insertion. Asn43His-RNase T(1) has the same loop sequence as that for RNases Pb(1) and Fl(2). None of the most active mutants were single substitutions at Asn44 or double substitutions at Asn43 and Asn44. A total of 13 variants were purified, and these were subjected to kinetic analysis using RNA, GpC, and ApC as substrates. Modestly enhanced activities with GpC and RNA involved both k(cat) and K(M) effects. Mutants having low activity with GpC had proportionately even lower relative activity with RNA. Asn43Gly-RNase T(1) and all five of the purified mutants in set 2 exhibited similar values of k(cat)/K(M) for ApC which were the highest observed and about 10-fold that for wild type. The specificity ratio [(k(cat)/K(M))(GpC)/(k(cat)/K(M))(ApC)] varied over 30 000-fold including a 10-fold increase [Asn43His variant; mainly due to a low (k(cat)/K(M))(ApC)] and a 3000-fold decrease (Glu46Ser/(insert)Gly47 variant; mainly due to a low (k(cat)/K(M))(GpC)) as compared with wild type. It is interesting that k(cat) (GpC) for the Tyr45Ser variant was almost 4-fold greater than for wild type and that Pro46/(insert)Glu47 RNase T(1) is 70-fold more active than the permuted variant (insert)Pro47-RNase T(1) which has a conserved Glu46. In any event, the observation that only 6 out of 800 variants surveyed had wild-type activity supports the view that functional perfection of the guanine recognition loop of RNase T(1) has been achieved.

Amino acid residues in ribonuclease MC1 from bitter gourd seeds which are essential for uridine specificity

The ribonuclease MC1 (RNase MC1), isolated from seeds of bitter gourd (Momordica charantia), consists of 190 amino acids and is characterized by specific cleavage at the 5'-side of uridine. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to evaluate the contribution of four amino acids, Asn71, Val72, Leu73, and Arg74, at the alpha4-alpha5 loop between alpha4 and alpha5 helices for recognition of uracil base by RNase MC1. Four mutants, N71T, V72L, L73A, and R74S, in which Asn71, Val72, Leu73, and Arg74 in RNase MC1 were substituted for the corresponding amino acids, Thr, Leu, Ala, and Ser, respectively, in a guanylic acid preferential RNase NW from Nicotiana glutinosa, were prepared and characterized with respect to enzymatic activity. Kinetic analysis with a dinucleoside monophosphate, CpU, showed that the mutant N71T exhibited 7.0-fold increased K(m) and 2.3-fold decreased k(cat), while the mutant L73A had 14.4-fold increased K(m), although it did retain the k(cat) value comparable to that of the wild-type. In contrast, replacements of Val72 and Arg74 by the corresponding amino acids Leu and Ser, respectively, had little effect on the enzymatic activity. This observation is consistent with findings in the crystal structure analysis that Asn71 and Leu73 are responsible for a uridine specificity for RNase MC1. The role of Asn71 in enzymatic reaction of RNase MC1 was further investigated by substituting amino acids Ala, Ser, Gln, and Asp. Our observations suggest that Asn71 has at least two roles: one is base recognition by hydrogen bonding, and the other is to stabilize the conformation of the alpha4-alpha5 loop by hydrogen bonding to the peptide backbone, events which possibly result in an appropriate orientation of the alpha-helix (alpha5) containing active site residues. Mutants N71T and N71S showed a remarkable shift from uracil to guanine specificity, as evaluated by cleavage of CpG, although they did exhibit uridine specificity against yeast RNA and homopolynucleotides.

Structural basis of mRNA cap recognition by proteins

Crystal structures have recently become available for two proteins (VP39 and eIF4E) complexed with their cognate ligand - the mRNA cap. Despite their total structural dissimilarity, both proteins bind N7-methylguanine between two parallel aromatic sidechains. The resulting stacked arrangement governs their high specificity for the alkylated form of the nucleobase.

Structural analysis of an RNase T1 variant with an altered guanine binding segment

The ribonuclease T1 variant 9/5 with a guanine recognition segment, altered from the wild-type amino acid sequence 41-KYNNYE-46 to 41-EFRNWQ-46, has been cocrystallised with the specific inhibitor 2'-GMP. The crystal structure has been refined to a crystallographic R factor of 0.198 at 2.3 A resolution. Despite a size reduction of the binding pocket, pushing the inhibitor outside by 1 A, 2'-GMP is fixed to the primary recognition site due to increased aromatic stacking interactions. The phosphate group of 2'-GMP is located about 4.2 A apart from its position in wild-type ribonuclease T1-2'-GMP complexes, allowing a Ca(2+), coordinating this phosphate group, to enter the binding pocket. The crystallographic data can be aligned with the kinetic characterisation of the variant, showing a reduction of both, guanine affinity and turnover rate. The presence of Ca(2+) was shown to inhibit variant 9/5 and wild-type enzyme to nearly the same extent.

Modification of ribonuclease T1 specificity by random mutagenesis of the substrate binding segment

Attempts to modify the guanine specificity of ribonuclease T1 (RNase T1) by rationally designed amino acid substitutions failed so far. Therefore, we applied a semirational approach by randomizing the guanine binding site. A combinatorial library of approximately 1.6 million RNase T1 variants containing permutations of 6 amino acid positions within the recognition loop was screened on RNase indicator plates. The specificity profiles of 180 individual clones showing RNase activity revealed that variant K41S/N43W/N44H/Y45A/E46D (RNaseT1-8/3) exhibits an altered preference toward purine nucleotides. The ApC/GpC preference in the cleavage reaction of this variant was increased 4000-fold compared to wild-type. Synthesis experiments of dinucleoside monophosphates from cytidine and the corresponding 2'3'-cyclic diesters using the reverse reaction of the transesterification step showed a 7-fold higher ApC synthesis rate of RNase 8/3 than wild-type, whereas the GpC synthesis rates for both enzymes were comparable. This study shows that site-directed random mutagenesis is a powerful additional tool in protein design in order to achieve new enzymatic specificities.

A core folding model for catalysis by the hammerhead ribozyme accounts for its extraordinary sensitivity to abasic mutations

Introducing abasic nucleotides at each of 13 positions in the conserved core of the hammerhead ribozyme causes a large decrease in the extent of catalysis [Peracchi, A., et al. (1996) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 93, 11522]. This extreme sensitivity to structural defects is in contrast to the behavior of protein enzymes and larger ribozymes. Several additional differences in the behavior of the hammerhead relative to that of protein enzymes and larger ribozymes are described herein. The deleterious effects of the abasic mutations are not relieved by lowering the temperature, by increasing the concentration of monovalent or divalent metal ions, or by adding polyamines, in contrast to effects observed with protein enzymes and large RNA enzymes. In addition, the abasic mutations do not significantly weaken substrate binding. These results and previous observations are all accounted for by a "core folding" model in which the stable ground state structure of the hammerhead ribozyme complexed with the substrate is a partially folded state that must undergo an additional folding event to achieve its catalytic conformation. We propose that the peculiar behavior of the hammerhead arises because the limited structural interconnections in a small RNA enzyme do not allow the ground state to stably adopt the catalytic conformation; within the globally folded catalytic conformation, limited structural interconnections may further impair catalysis by hampering the precise alignment of active site functional groups. This behavior represents a basic manifestation of the well-recognized interconnection between folding and catalysis.

A decade of protein engineering on ribonuclease T1--atomic dissection of the enzyme-substrate interactions

During the last decade, protein engineering has been used to identify the residues that contribute to the ribonuclease-T1-catalyzed transesterification. His40, Glu58 and His92 accelerate the associative nucleophilic displacement at the phosphate atom by the entering 2'-oxygen downstream guanosines in a highly cooperative manner. Glu58, assisted by the protonated His40 imidazole, abstracts a proton from the 2'-oxygen, while His92 protonates the leaving group. Tyr38, Arg77 and Phe100 further stabilize the transition state of the reaction. A functionally independent subsite, including Asn36 and Asn98, contributes to chemical turnover by aligning the substrate relative to the catalytic side chains upon binding of the leaving group. An invariant structural motive, involving residues 42-46, renders ribonuclease T1 guanine specific through a series of intermolar hydrogen bonds. Tyr42 contributes significantly to guanine binding through a parallel face-to-face stacking interaction. Tyr45, often referred to as the lid of the guanine-binding site, does not contribute to the binding of the base.