Analysis of higher order intermediates and synapsis in the bent-L pathway of bacteriophage lambda site-specific recombination

Bacteriophage lambda site-specific recombination

The site-specific recombination pathway of bacteriophage λ encompasses isoenergetic but highly directional and tightly regulated integrative and excisive reactions that integrate and excise the vial chromosome into and out of the bacterial chromosome. The reactions require 240 bp of phage DNA and 21 bp of bacterial DNA comprising 16 protein binding sites that are differentially used in each pathway by the phage-encoded Int and Xis proteins and the host-encoded integration host factor and factor for inversion stimulation proteins. Structures of higher-order protein-DNA complexes of the four-way Holliday junction recombination intermediates provided clarifying insights into the mechanisms, directionality, and regulation of these two pathways, which are tightly linked to the physiology of the bacterial host cell. Here we review our current understanding of the mechanisms responsible for regulating and executing λ site-specific recombination, with an emphasis on key studies completed over the last decade.

The λ Integrase Site-specific Recombination Pathway

The site-specific recombinase encoded by bacteriophage λ (Int) is responsible for integrating and excising the viral chromosome into and out of the chromosome of its Escherichia coli host. Int carries out a reaction that is highly directional, tightly regulated, and depends upon an ensemble of accessory DNA bending proteins acting on 240 bp of DNA encoding 16 protein binding sites. This additional complexity enables two pathways, integrative and excisive recombination, whose opposite, and effectively irreversible, directions are dictated by different physiological and environmental signals. Int recombinase is a heterobivalent DNA binding protein and each of the four Int protomers, within a multiprotein 400 kDa recombinogenic complex, is thought to bind and, with the aid of DNA bending proteins, bridge one arm- and one core-type DNA site. In the 12 years since the publication of the last review focused solely on the λ site-specific recombination pathway in Mobile DNA II, there has been a great deal of progress in elucidating the molecular details of this pathway. The most dramatic advances in our understanding of the reaction have been in the area of X-ray crystallography where protein-DNA structures have now been determined for of all of the DNA-protein interfaces driving the Int pathway. Building on this foundation of structures, it has been possible to derive models for the assembly of components that determine the regulatory apparatus in the P-arm, and for the overall architectures that define excisive and integrative recombinogenic complexes. The most fundamental additional mechanistic insights derive from the application of hexapeptide inhibitors and single molecule kinetics.

A new in vitro strand transfer assay for monitoring bacterial class 1 integron recombinase IntI1 activity

IntI1 integrase is a tyrosine recombinase involved in the mobility of antibiotic resistance gene cassettes within bacterial class 1 integrons. Recent data have shown that its recombination specifically involves the bottom strand of the attC site, but the exact mechanism of the reaction is still unclear. An efficient in vitro assay is still required to better characterize the biochemical properties of the enzyme. In this report we describe for the first time an in vitro system partially reproducing the activity of a recombinant pure IntI1. This new assay, which constitutes the only available in vitro model of recombination by IntI1, was used to determine whether this enzyme might be the sole bacterial protein required for the recombination process. Results show that IntI1 possesses all the features needed for performing recombination between attI and attC sites. However, differences in the in vitro intermolecular recombination efficiencies were found according to the target sites and were correlated with DNA affinities of the enzyme but not with in vivo data. The differential affinity of the enzyme for each site, its capacity to bind to a single-stranded structure at the attC site and the recombination observed with single-stranded substrates unambiguously confirm that it constitutes an important intermediary in the reaction. Our data strongly suggest that the enzyme possesses all the functions for generating and/or recognizing this structure even in the absence of other cellular factors. Furthermore, the in vitro assay reported here constitutes a powerful tool for the analysis of the recombination steps catalyzed by IntI1, its structure-function studies and the search for specific inhibitors.

Spermidine biases the resolution of Holliday junctions by phage lambda integrase

Holliday junctions are a central intermediate in diverse pathways of DNA repair and recombination. The isomerization of a junction determines the directionality of the recombination event. Previous studies have shown that the identity of the central sequence of the junction may favor one of the two isomers, in turn controlling the direction of the pathway. Here we demonstrate that, in the absence of DNA sequence-mediated isomer preference, polycations are the major contributor to biasing strand cleavage during junction resolution. In the case of wild-type phage λ excision junctions, spermidine plays the dominant role in controlling the isomerization state of the junction and increases the rate of junction resolution. Spermidine also counteracts the sequence-imposed bias on resolution. The spermidine-induced bias is seen equally on supercoiled and linear excisive recombination junction intermediates, and thus is not just an artefact of in vitro recombination conditions. The contribution of spermidine requires the presence of accessory factors, and results in the repositioning of Int's core-binding domains on junctions, perhaps due to DNA-spermidine–protein interactions, or by influencing DNA conformation in the core region. Our results lead us to propose that spermidine together with accessory factors promotes the formation of the second junction isomer. We propose that this rearrangement triggers the activation of the second pair of Int active sites necessary to resolve Holliday junctions during phage λ Int-mediated recombination.

Unequal access of chromosomal regions to each other in Salmonella: probing chromosome structure with phage lambda integrase-mediated long-range rearrangements

We have investigated the fluidity of the Salmonella chromosome architecture using the phage lambda site-specific recombination system as a probe. We determined how chromosome position affects the extent of integrase-mediated recombination between pairs of inversely oriented att sites at various loci. We also investigated the accessibility of each chromosomal att site to an extrachromosomal partner carried on a low-copy plasmid. Recombination events were assayed by semi-quantitative polymerase chain reaction of the attP product. The extent of recombination between the chromosome and the plasmid was generally higher than intrachromosomal recombination except for two loci, araA::attL and galT::attL, which gave no detectable recombination with any other locus. Based on 20 intervals, we found that chromosomal locations are not equally accessible to each other. Although multiple factors probably affect accessibility, the most important is the specific combination of the end-points used. Neither the size of the intervals nor the accessibility of individual end-points to extrachromosomal sequences is as important. These results suggest that the chromosome is not completely fluid but rather organized in some way, with barriers that limit the movement of DNA within the cell. The nature of the barriers involved in chromosomal organization remains to be determined.

Reversible Inhibitors of λ Integrase-mediated Recombination Efficiently Trap Holliday Junction Intermediates and Form the Basis of a Novel Assay for Junction Resolution

The bacteriophage lambda integrase catalyzes four site-specific recombination pathways with distinct protein and DNA requirements and nucleoprotein intermediates. Some of these intermediates are very transient and difficult to obtain in significant amounts, due to the high efficiency and processivity of integrase, the lack of requirements for external energy factors or metal ions, and the highly reversible nature of each of the intermediates. We have previously used mixture-based combinatorial libraries to identify hexapeptides that trap 40-60% of recombination substrates at the Holliday junction stage of the reaction. These inhibitors discriminate between the four pathways, blocking one of them (bent-L recombination) more severely than the others and blocking the excision pathway least. We presume that these differences reflect specific conformational differences of the nucleoprotein intermediates in each pathway. We have now identified new inhibitors of the excision pathway. One of these, WRWYCR, is over 50-fold more potent at inhibiting excision than the previously identified peptides. This peptide stably traps Holliday junction complexes in all recombination pathways mediated by integrase as well as Cre. This finding and other data presented indicate that the peptide's target is a common feature shared by the Holliday junction complexes assembled by tyrosine recombinases. We have taken advantage of reversible inhibition by the active peptides to develop a new assay for Holliday junction resolution. This assay is particularly useful for determining junction resolution rates in cases where complexes directly assembled on junction substrates undergo little or no catalysis.

Mutations at residues 282, 286, and 293 of phage lambda integrase exert pathway-specific effects on synapsis and catalysis in recombination

Bacteriophage lambda integrase (Int) catalyzes site-specific recombination between pairs of attachment (att) sites. The att sites contain weak Int-binding sites called core-type sites that are separated by a 7-bp overlap region, where cleavage and strand exchange occur. We have characterized a number of mutant Int proteins with substitutions at positions S282 (S282A, S282F, and S282T), S286 (S286A, S286L, and S286T), and R293 (R293E, R293K, and R293Q). We investigated the core- and arm-binding properties and cooperativity of the mutant proteins, their ability to catalyze cleavage, and their ability to form and resolve Holliday junctions. Our kinetic analyses have identified synapsis as the rate-limiting step in excisive recombination. The IntS282 and IntS286 mutants show defects in synapsis in the bent-L and excisive pathways, respectively, while the IntR293 mutants exhibit synapsis defects in both the excision and bent-L pathways. The results of our study support earlier findings that the catalytic domain also serves a role in binding to core-type sites, that the core contacts made by this domain are important for both synapsis and catalysis, and that Int contacts core-type sites differently among the four recombination pathways. We speculate that these residues are important for the proper positioning of the catalytic residues involved in the recombination reaction and that their positions differ in the distinct nucleoprotein architectures formed during each pathway. Finally, we found that not all catalytic events in excision follow synapsis: the attL site probably undergoes several rounds of cleavage and ligation before it synapses and exchanges DNA with attR.

Mechanism of inhibition of site-specific recombination by the Holliday junction-trapping peptide WKHYNY: insights into phage lambda integrase-mediated strand exchange

Holliday junctions are central intermediates in site-specific recombination reactions mediated by tyrosine recombinases. Because these intermediates are extremely transient, only artificially assembled Holliday junctions have been available for study. We have recently identified hexapeptides that cause the accumulation of natural Holliday junctions of bacteriophage lambda Integrase (Int)-mediated reactions. We now show that one of these peptides acts after the first DNA cleavage event to stabilize protein-bound junctions and to prevent their resolution. The peptide acts before the step affected by site affinity (saf) mutations in the core region, in agreement with a model that the peptide stabilizes the products of strand exchange (i.e. Holliday junctions) while saf mutations reduce ligation of exchanged strands.Strand exchange events leading to Holliday junctions in phage lambda integration and excision are asymmetric, presumably because interactions between Int and some of its core-binding sites determine the order of strand cleavage. We have compared the structure of Holliday junctions in one unidirectional and in two bidirectional Int-mediated pathways and show that the strand cleavage steps are much more symmetric in the bidirectional pathways. Thus Int-DNA interactions which determine the order of top and bottom strand cleavage and exchange are unique in each recombination pathway.

Conservation of structure and function among tyrosine recombinases: homology-based modeling of the lambda integrase core-binding domain

Tyrosine recombinases participate in diverse biological processes by catalyzing recombination between specific DNA sites. Although a conserved protein fold has been described for the catalytic (CAT) domains of five recombinases, structural relationships between their core-binding (CB) domains remain unclear. Despite differences in the specificity and affinity of core-type DNA recognition, a conserved binding mechanism is suggested by the shared two-domain motif in crystal structure models of the recombinases Cre, XerD and Flp. We have found additional evidence for conservation of the CB domain fold. Comparison of XerD and Cre crystal structures showed that their CB domains are closely related; the three central alpha-helices of these domains are superposable to within 1.44 A. A structure-based multiple sequence alignment containing 25 diverse CB domain sequences provided evidence for widespread conservation of both structural and functional elements in this fold. Based upon the Cre and XerD crystal structures, we employed homology modeling to construct a three-dimensional structure for the lambda integrase CB domain. The model provides a conceptual framework within which many previously identified, functionally important amino acid residues were investigated. In addition, the model predicts new residues that may participate in core-type DNA binding or dimerization, thereby providing hypotheses for future genetic and biochemical experiments.

The future of bacteriophage biology

After an illustrious history as one of the primary tools that established the foundations of molecular biology, bacteriophage research is now undergoing a renaissance in which the primary focus is on the phages themselves rather than the molecular mechanisms that they explain. Studies of the evolution of phages and their role in natural ecosystems are flourishing. Practical questions, such as how to use phages to combat human diseases that are caused by bacteria, how to eradicate phage pests in the food industry and what role they have in the causation of human diseases, are receiving increased attention. Phages are also useful in the deeper exploration of basic molecular and biophysical questions.

Characterization of a mutation of bacteriophage lambda integrase. Putative role in core binding and strand exchange for a conserved residue

Site-specific recombination is involved in processes ranging from resolution of bacterial chromosome dimers to adeno-associated viral integration and is a versatile tool for mammalian genetics. The bacteriophage lambda-encoded site-specific recombinase integrase (Int) is one of the best studied site-specific recombinases and mediates recombination via four distinct pathways. We have characterized a mutant version of lambda Int, IntT236I; this mutant can perform the bent-L pathway only, whereas the corresponding IntT236A mutant can perform bent-L, excision and integration pathways. Experiments with both IntT236I and IntT236A show that the hydroxyl group of threonine is necessary for wild-type recombination. Substitution of the threonine by serine leads to nearly complete rescue of the mutant phenotypes. In addition, our data show that the IntT236I mutant is defective partially due to obstructive steric interactions. Comparisons of crystal structures reveal that the threonine at residue 236 may play an important role in stabilizing recombination intermediates through solvent-mediated protein-DNA interactions at the core-binding sites and that the hydroxyl group is important for effective cleavage and Holliday junction formation. Our data also indicate that Int contacts the core sites differently in intermediates assembled in excisive versus bent-L recombination.

The nicking step in V(D)J recombination is independent of synapsis: implications for the immune repertoire

In all of the transposition reactions that have been characterized thus far, synapsis of two transposon ends is required before any catalytic steps (strand nicking or strand transfer) occur. In V(D)J recombination, there have been inconclusive data concerning the role of synapsis in nicking. Synapsis between two 12-substrates or between two 23-substrates has not been ruled out in any studies thus far. Here we provide the first direct tests of this issue. We find that immobilization of signals does not affect their nicking, even though hairpinning is affected in a manner reflecting its known synaptic requirement. We also find that nicking is kinetically a unireactant enzyme-catalyzed reaction. Time courses are no different between nicking seen for a 12-substrate alone and a reaction involving both a 12- and a 23-substrate. Hence, synapsis is neither a requirement nor an effector of the rate of nicking. These results establish V(D)J recombination as the first example of a DNA transposition-type reaction in which catalytic steps begin prior to synapsis, and the results have direct implications for the order of the steps in V(D)J recombination, for the contribution of V(D)J recombination nicks to genomic instability, and for the diversification of the immune repertoire.

Dissection of bacteriophage lambda site-specific recombination using synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries

A wide variety of tools have been used to dissect biochemical pathways, inhibitors being chief among them. Combinatorial approaches have made the search for inhibitors much more efficient. We have applied such an approach to identify hexapeptides which inhibit different steps in a site-specific recombination reaction mediated by the bacteriophage lambda integrase protein. Integrase's mechanism is still incompletely understood, in large part because several pathway intermediates remain hard to isolate. Integrase-catalyzed recombination is very efficient, but if blocked, it is highly reversible to substrates; this combination makes some intermediates exceedingly transient. We have used synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries to screen for hexapeptides that affect the recombination pathway at different stages, and have identified two families of peptides: one probably blocks DNA cleavage, the other may stabilize the Holliday junction intermediates. These peptides do not resemble parts of integrase or any of the other helper functions in the pathway. The deconvolution of hexapeptide libraries based both on inhibition of an enzymatic reaction as well as on accumulation of reaction intermediates is a novel approach to finding useful tools for dissecting a biochemical pathway.

Peptide inhibitors of DNA cleavage by tyrosine recombinases and topoisomerases

The study of biochemical pathways requires the isolation and characterization of each and every intermediate in the pathway. For the site-specific recombination reactions catalyzed by the bacteriophage lambda tyrosine recombinase integrase (Int), this has been difficult because of the high level of efficiency of the reaction, the highly reversible nature of certain reaction steps, and the lack of requirements for high-energy cofactors or metals. By screening synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries, we have identified two related hexapeptides, KWWCRW and KWWWRW, that block the strand-cleavage activity of Int but not the assembly of higher-order intermediates. Although the peptides bind DNA, their inhibitory activity appears to be more specifically targeted to the Int-substrate complex, insofar as inhibition is resistant to high levels of non-specific competitor DNA and the peptides have higher levels of affinity for the Int-DNA substrate complex than for DNA alone. The peptides inhibit the four pathways of Int-mediated recombination with different potencies, suggesting that the interactions of the Int enzyme with its DNA substrates differs among pathways. The KWWCRW and KWWWRW peptides also inhibit vaccinia virus topoisomerase, a type IB enzyme, which is mechanistically and structurally related to Int. The peptides differentially affect the forward and reverse DNA transesterification steps of the vaccinia topoisomerase. They block formation of the covalent vaccinia topoisomerase-DNA intermediate, but have no apparent effect on DNA religation by preformed covalent complexes. The peptides also inhibit Escherichia coli topoisomerase I, a type IA enzyme. Finally, the peptides inhibit the bacteriophage T4 type II topoisomerase and several restriction enzymes with 2000-fold lower potency than they inhibit integrase in the bent-L pathway.

Tn10 transpososome assembly involves a folded intermediate that must be unfolded for target capture and strand transfer

Tn10 transposition, like all transposition reactions examined thus far, involves assembly of a stable protein-DNA transpososome, containing a pair of transposon ends, within which all chemical events occur. We report here that stable Tn10 pre-cleavage transpososomes occur in two conformations: a folded form which contains the DNA-bending factor IHF and an unfolded form which lacks IHF. Functional analysis shows that both forms undergo double strand cleavage at the transposon ends but that only the unfolded form is competent for target capture (and thus for strand transfer to target DNA). Additional studies reveal that formation of any type of stable transpososome, folded or unfolded, requires not only IHF but also non-specific transposase-DNA contacts immediately internal to the IHF-binding site, implying the occurrence of a topo- logically closed loop at the transposon end. Overall, transpososome assembly must proceed via a folded intermediate which, however, must be unfolded in order for intermolecular transposition to occur. These and other results support key features of a recently proposed model for transpososome assembly and morphogenesis.

The amino terminus of bacteriophage lambda integrase is involved in protein-protein interactions during recombination

Bacteriophage lambda integrase (Int) catalyzes at least four site-specific recombination pathways between pairs of attachment (att) sites. Protein-protein contacts between monomers of Int are presumed to be important for these site-specific recombination events for several reasons: Int binds to the att sites cooperatively, catalytic Int mutants can complement each other for strand cleavage, and crystal structures for two other recombinases in the Int family (Cre from phage P1 and Int from Haemophilus influenzae phage HP1) show extensive protein-protein contacts between monomers. We have begun to investigate interactions between Int monomers by three approaches. First, using a genetic assay, we show that regions of protein-protein interactions occur throughout Int, including in the amino-terminal domain. This domain was previously thought to be important only for high-affinity protein-DNA interactions. Second, we have found that an amino-terminal His tag reduces cooperative binding to DNA. This disruption in cooperativity decreases the stable interaction of Int with core sites, where catalysis occurs. Third, using protein-protein cross-linking to investigate the multimerization of Int during recombination, we show that Int predominantly forms dimers, trimers, and tetramers. Moreover, we show that the cysteine at position 25 is present at or near the interface between monomers that is involved in the formation of dimers and tetramers. Our evidence indicates that the amino-terminal domain of Int is involved in protein-protein interactions that are likely to be important for recombination.