Refinement of the structure of the ligand-occupied cholecystokinin receptor using a photolabile amino-terminal probe

Cholecystokinin-induced satiety, a key gut servomechanism that is affected by the membrane microenvironment of this receptor

The gastrointestinal (GI) tract has a central role in nutritional homeostasis, as location for food ingestion, digestion and absorption, with the gut endocrine system responding to and regulating these events, as well as influencing appetite. One key GI hormone with the full spectrum of these activities is cholecystokinin (CCK), a peptide released from neuroendocrine I cells scattered through the proximal intestine in response to fat and protein, with effects to stimulate gall bladder contraction and pancreatic exocrine secretion, to regulate gastric emptying and intestinal transit, and to induce satiety. There has been interest in targeting the type 1 CCK receptor (CCK1R) for drug development to provide non-caloric satiation as an aid to dieting and weight loss; however, there have been concerns about CCK1R agonists related to side effects and potential trophic impact on the pancreas. A positive allosteric modulator (PAM) of CCK action at this receptor without intrinsic agonist activity could provide a safer and more effective approach to long-term administration. In addition, CCK1R stimulus-activity coupling has been shown to be negatively affected by excess membrane cholesterol, a condition described in the metabolic syndrome, thereby potentially interfering with an important servomechanism regulating appetite. A PAM targeting this receptor could also potentially correct the negative impact of cholesterol on CCK1R function. We will review the molecular basis for binding natural peptide agonist, binding and action of small molecules within the allosteric pocket, and the impact of cholesterol. Novel strategies for taking advantage of this receptor for the prevention and management of obesity will be reviewed.

Molecular Mechanism of Action of Triazolobenzodiazepinone Agonists of the Type 1 Cholecystokinin Receptor. Possible Cooperativity across the Receptor Homodimeric Complex

The type 1 cholecystokinin receptor (CCK1R) has multiple physiologic roles relating to nutrient homeostasis, including mediation of postcibal satiety. This effect has been central in efforts to develop agonists of this receptor as part of a program to manage and/or prevent obesity. While a number of small molecule CCK1R agonists have been developed, none have yet been approved for clinical use, based on inadequate efficacy, side effects, or the potential for toxicity. Understanding the molecular details of docking and mechanism of action of these ligands can be helpful in the rational refinement and enhancement of small molecule drug candidates. In the current work, we have defined the mechanism of binding and activity of two triazolobenzodiazepinones, CE-326597 and PF-04756956, which are reported to be full agonist ligands. To achieve this, we utilized receptor binding with a series of allosteric and orthosteric radioligands at structurally related CCK1R and CCK2R, as well as chimeric CCK1R/CCK2R constructs exchanging residues in the allosteric pocket, and assessment of biological activity. These triazolobenzodiazepinones docked within the intramembranous small molecule allosteric ligand pocket, with higher affinity binding to CCK2R than CCK1R, yet with biological activity exclusive to or greatly enhanced at CCK1R. These ligands exhibited cooperativity with benzodiazepine binding across the CCK1R homodimeric complex, resulting in their ability to inhibit only a fraction of the saturable binding of a benzodiazepine radioligand, unlike other small molecule antagonists and agonists of this receptor. This may contribute to the understanding of the unique short duration and reversible gallbladder contraction observed in vivo upon administration of these drugs.

Direct demonstration of unique mode of natural peptide binding to the type 2 cholecystokinin receptor using photoaffinity labeling

Direct analysis of mode of peptide docking using intrinsic photoaffinity labeling has provided detailed insights for the molecular basis of cholecystokinin (CCK) interaction with the type 1 CCK receptor. In the current work, this technique has been applied to the closely related type 2 CCK receptor that also binds the natural full agonist peptide, CCK, with high affinity. A series of photolabile CCK analog probes with sites of covalent attachment extending from position 26 through 32 were characterized, with the highest affinity analogs that possessed full biological activity utilized in photoaffinity labeling. The position 29 probe, incorporating a photolabile benzoyl-phenylalanine in that position, was shown to bind with high affinity and to be a full agonist, with potency not different from that of natural CCK, and to covalently label the type 2 CCK receptor in a saturable, specific and efficient manner. Using proteolytic peptide mapping, mutagenesis, and radiochemical Edman degradation sequencing, this probe was shown to establish a covalent bond with type 2 CCK receptor residue Phe¹²⁰ in the first extracellular loop. This was in contrast to its covalent attachment to Glu³⁴⁵ in the third extracellular loop of the type 1 CCK receptor, directly documenting differences in mode of docking this peptide to these receptors.

Sensitivity of cholecystokinin receptors to membrane cholesterol content

Cholesterol represents a structurally and functionally important component of the eukaryotic cell membrane, where it increases lipid order, affects permeability, and influences the lateral mobility and conformation of membrane proteins. Several G protein-coupled receptors have been shown to be affected by the cholesterol content of the membrane, with functional impact on their ligand binding and signal transduction characteristics. The effects of cholesterol can be mediated directly by specific molecular interactions with the receptor and/or indirectly by altering the physical properties of the membrane. This review focuses on the importance and differential effects of membrane cholesterol on the activity of cholecystokinin (CCK) receptors. The type 1 CCK receptor is quite sensitive to its cholesterol environment, while the type 2 CCK receptor is not. The possible structural basis for this differential impact is explored and the implications of pathological states, such as metabolic syndrome, in which membrane cholesterol may be increased and CCK1R function may be abnormal are discussed. This is believed to have substantial potential importance for the development of drugs targeting the CCK receptor.

The CCK(-like) receptor in the animal kingdom: functions, evolution and structures

In this review, the cholecystokinin (CCK)(-like) receptors throughout the animal kingdom are compared on the level of physiological functions, evolutionary basis and molecular structure. In vertebrates, the CCK receptor is an important member of the G-protein coupled receptors as it is involved in the regulation of many physiological functions like satiety, gastrointestinal motility, gastric acid secretion, gall bladder contraction, pancreatic secretion, panic, anxiety and memory and learning processes. A homolog for this receptor is also found in nematodes and arthropods, called CK receptor and sulfakinin (SK) receptor, respectively. These receptors seem to have evolved from a common ancestor which is probably still closely related to the nematode CK receptor. The SK receptor is more closely related to the CCK receptor and seems to have similar functions. A molecular 3D-model for the CCK receptor type 1 has been built together with the docking of the natural ligands for the CCK and SK receptors in the CCK receptor type 1. These molecular models can help to study ligand-receptor interactions, that can in turn be useful in the development of new CCK(-like) receptor agonists and antagonists with beneficial health effects in humans or potential for pest control.

Elucidation of the molecular basis of cholecystokinin Peptide docking to its receptor using site-specific intrinsic photoaffinity labeling and molecular modeling

G protein-coupled receptors represent the largest family of receptors and the major target of current drug development efforts. Understanding of the mechanisms of ligand binding and activation of these receptors remains limited, despite recent advances in structural determination of family members. This work focuses on the use of photoaffinity labeling and molecular modeling to elucidate the structural basis of binding a natural peptide ligand to a family A G protein-coupled receptor, the type 1 cholecystokinin receptor. Two photolabile cholecystokinin analogues were developed and characterized as representing high-affinity, fully biologically active probes with sites of covalent attachment at positions 28 and 31. The sites of receptor labeling were identified by purification, proteolytic peptide mapping, and radiochemical sequencing of labeled wild-type and mutant cholecystokinin receptors. The position 28 probe labeled second extracellular loop residue Leu(199), while the position 31 probe labeled first extracellular loop residue Phe(107). Along with five additional spatial approximation constraints coming from previous photoaffinity labeling studies and 12 distance restraints from fluorescence resonance energy transfer studies, these were built into two homology models of the cholecystokinin receptor, based on the recent crystal structures of the beta2-adrenergic receptor and A2a-adenosine receptor. The resultant agonist ligand-occupied receptor models fully accommodate all existing experimental data and represent the best refined models of a peptide hormone receptor in this important family.

Application of fluorescence resonance energy transfer techniques to establish ligand-receptor orientation

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) has been utilized to determine distances between a fluorescence donor and a fluorescence acceptor having appropriately overlapping spectra. In this chapter, we utilize this approach to establish distances between a fluorescence donor situated in a distinct position within a docked ligand and a fluorescence acceptor situated in a distinct position within its receptor. This technique is applicable to receptor expressed in the environment of an intact cell containing the full complement of signaling and regulatory proteins. A number of controls are necessary, including those establishing the normal function of the modified ligand and receptor, the absence of energy transfer to non-receptor proteins, and the specificity of transfer between the donor of interest and the acceptor of interest. We have utilized the example of FRET between a secretin peptide incorporating Alexa(488) and a secretin receptor construct derivatized with Alexa(568). The latter was prepared by the derivatization of a mono-cysteine-reactive receptor construct with a fluorescent methanethiosulfonate reagent. This approach can provide important spatial information that can be useful in the meaningful docking of a ligand at its receptor.

Use of multidimensional fluorescence resonance energy transfer to establish the orientation of cholecystokinin docked at the type A cholecystokinin receptor

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) represents a powerful tool to establish relative distances between donor and acceptor fluorophores. By utilizing several donors situated in distinct positions within a docked full agonist ligand and several acceptors distributed at distinct sites within its receptor, multiple interdependent dimensions can be determined. These can provide a unique method to establish or confirm three-dimensional structure of the molecular complex. In this work, we have utilized full agonist analogues of cholecystokinin (CCK) with Aladan distributed throughout the pharmacophore in positions 24, 29, and 33, along with receptor constructs derivatized with Alexa (546) at positions 94, 102, 204, and 341 in the helical bundle and first, second, and third extracellular loops, respectively. These provided 12 FRET distances to overlay on working models of the CCK-occupied receptor. These established that the carboxyl terminus of CCK resides at the external surface of the lipid bilayer, adjacent to the receptor amino-terminal tail, rather than being inserted into the helical bundle. They also provide important experimentally derived constraints for understanding spatial relationships between the docked ligand and the flexible extracellular loop regions. Multidimensional FRET provides a new independent method to establish and refine structural insights into ligand-receptor complexes.

Benzodiazepine ligands can act as allosteric modulators of the Type 1 cholecystokinin receptor

The cholecystokinin (CCK(1)) receptor is a G protein-coupled receptor important for nutrient homeostasis. The molecular basis of CCK-receptor binding has been debated, with one prominent model suggesting occupation of the same region of the intramembranous helical bundle as benzodiazepines. Here, we used a specific assay of allosteric ligand interaction to probe the mode of binding of devazepide, a prototypic benzodiazepine ligand. Devazepide elicited marked slowing of dissociation of pre-bound CCK, only possible through binding to a topographically distinct allosteric site. This effect was disrupted by chemical modification of a cysteine in the benzodiazepine-binding pocket. Application of an allosteric model to the equilibrium interaction between a series of benzodiazepine ligands and CCK yielded quantitative estimates of each modulator's affinity for the allosteric site, as well as the degree of negative cooperativity for the interaction between occupied orthosteric and allosteric sites. The allosteric nature of benzodiazepine binding to the CCK(1) receptor provides new opportunities for small molecule drug development.

Structural basis of cholecystokinin receptor binding and regulation

Two structurally-related guanine nucleotide-binding protein-coupled receptors for two related peptides, cholecystokinin (CCK) and gastrin, have evolved to exhibit substantial diversity in specificity of ligand recognition, in their molecular basis of binding these ligands, and in their mechanisms of biochemical and cellular regulation. Consistent with this, the CCK1 and CCK2 receptors also play unique and distinct roles in physiology and pathophysiology. The paradigms for ligand recognition and receptor regulation and function are reviewed in this article, and should be broadly applicable to many members of this remarkable receptor superfamily. This degree of specialization is instructive and provides an encouraging basis for the diversity of potential drugs targeting these receptors and their actions that can be developed.

Role of lysine187 within the second extracellular loop of the type A cholecystokinin receptor in agonist-induced activation. Use of complementary charge-reversal mutagenesis to define a functionally important interdomain interaction

Activation of guanine nucleotide-binding protein (G protein)-coupled receptors is believed to involve conformational change that exposes a domain for G protein coupling at the cytosolic surface of the helical confluence, although the mechanisms for achieving this are not well understood. This conformational change can be achieved by docking a diverse variety of agonist ligands, known to occur by interacting with different regions of these receptors. In this study, we focus on the importance of a specific basic residue (Lys187) within the second extracellular loop of the receptor for the peptide hormone, cholecystokinin. Alanine-replacement and charge-reversal mutagenesis of this residue showed that it had no effect on the binding of natural peptide and nonpeptidyl ligands of this receptor but markedly interfered with agonist-stimulated signaling. It was demonstrated that this negative effect on biological activity could be eliminated with the truncation of the first 30 residues of the amino-terminal tail of this receptor. Complementary charge-reversal mutagenesis of each of the five conserved acidic residues within this region of the receptor in the presence of the charge-reversed Lys187 revealed that only the Asp5 mutant fully reversed the negative functional impact of the Lys187 charge reversal. Thus, we have demonstrated that a basic residue within the second extracellular loop of the cholecystokinin receptor interacts with a specific acidic residue within the amino terminus of this receptor. This residue-residue interaction is nicely accommodated within a new molecular model of the agonist-occupied cholecystokinin receptor.

Fluorescent Indicators Distributed throughout the Pharmacophore of Cholecystokinin Provide Insights into Distinct Modes of Binding and Activation of Type A and B Cholecystokinin Receptors

Ligand probes with fluorescent indicators positioned throughout the pharmacophoric domain can provide important insights into the molecular basis of receptor binding and activation as reflected in the microenvironment of each indicator while docked at a receptor. We developed three cholecystokinin-like probes with Aladan situated at the N terminus, in the mid-region, and at the C terminus (positions 24, 29, and 33, respectively). These were studied in solution and docked at type A and B cholecystokinin receptors. This study demonstrated clear differences in mechanisms of cholecystokinin binding and activation of these structurally related receptors with distinct agonist structure-activity relationships. The fluorescence characteristics of Aladan are highly sensitive to the polarity of its microenvironment. The mid-region probe was least accessible to the aqueous milieu as determined by fluorescence emission spectra and iodide quenching, which was not altered by changes in conformation from active to inactive. Accessibility of the N- and C-terminal probes was affected by receptor conformation. The position 24 probe was more easily quenched in the active than in the G protein-uncoupled conformation for both receptors. However, the position 33 probe docked at the type A cholecystokinin receptor was more easily quenched in the active conformation, whereas the same probe docked at the type B cholecystokinin receptor was more easily quenched in the inactive conformation. Fluorescence anisotropy and red edge excitation shift determinations confirmed these observations and supported the proposed movements. Although both type A and B cholecystokinin receptors bind cholecystokinin with high affinity, resulting in fully efficacious biological responses, these receptors utilize distinct molecular modes of binding.

Fluorescence Characteristics of Hydrophobic Partial Agonist Probes of the Cholecystokinin Receptor

Fluorescence spectroscopic studies are powerful tools for the evaluation of receptor structure and the dynamic changes associated with receptor activation. Here, we have developed two chemically distinct fluorescent probes of the cholecystokinin (CCK) receptor by attaching acrylodan or a nitrobenzoxadiazole moiety to the amino terminus of a partial agonist CCK analogue. These two probes were able to bind to the CCK receptor specifically and with high affinity, and were able to elicit only submaximal intracellular calcium responses typical of partial agonists. The fluorescence characteristics of these probes were compared with those previously reported for structurally-related full agonist and antagonist probes. Like the previous probes, the partial agonist probes exhibited longer fluorescence lifetimes and increased anisotropy when bound to the receptor than when free in solution. The receptor-bound probes were not easily quenched by potassium iodide, suggesting that the fluorophores were protected from the extracellular aqueous milieu. The fluorescence characteristics of the partial agonist probes were quite similar to those of the analogous full agonist probes and quite distinct from the analogous antagonist probes. These data suggest that the partially activated conformational state of this receptor is more closely related to its fully active state than to its inactive state.

Differential spatial approximation between cholecystokinin residue 30 and receptor residues in active and inactive conformations

Understanding the structures of active and inactive agonist- and antagonist-bound receptor complexes is of great interest. In this work, we focus on position 30 of cholecystokinin (CCK) and its spatial approximation with the type A CCK receptor. For this, we developed two photoaffinity labeling probes, replacing the naturally occurring tryptophan with p-benzoyl-l-phenylalanine (Bpa) or p-nitro-phenylalanine (NO(2)-Phe). The Bpa probe was shown to represent an antagonist, whereas the NO(2)-Phe probe stimulated intracellular calcium as a fully efficacious agonist (EC(50) = 81 +/- 15 nM). Both ligands bound to the receptor specifically, although with lower affinity than CCK (K(i) values: Bpa probe, 270 +/- 72 nM; NO(2)-Phe probe, 180 +/- 40 nM). Both probes covalently labeled the receptor in an efficient manner. The Bpa antagonist labeled the receptor in two distinct regions as identified by cyanogen bromide cleavage, with labeled bands migrating at M(r) = 25,000 and 4500. The former represented the glycosylated amino-terminal fragment, with the site of attachment further localized by endoproteinase Lys-C cleavage to the region between Asn(10) and Lys(37). The latter was shown to represent the first extracellular loop using further cleavage and sequencing of the wild-type and a mutant receptor. Following the same approach, the NO(2)-Phe agonist probe was shown to also label the first extracellular loop region. Radiochemical sequencing identified that the Bpa antagonist probe labeled receptor residue Lys(105), whereas the NO(2)-Phe agonist probe labeled residue Leu(99). These data extend our understanding of the molecular basis of binding and the conformational states of this important receptor.

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer analysis of the antagonist- and partial agonist-occupied states of the cholecystokinin receptor

Changes in receptor conformation are believed to be key for ligand-induced regulation of cellular signaling cascades. However, little information exists about specific conformations of a receptor. We recently applied fluorescence resonance energy transfer to determine distances from distinct points distributed over the surface and within the helical bundle of the cholecystokinin receptor to the amino terminus of a full agonist CCK analogue (Harikumar, K. G., Pinon, D. I., Wessels, W. S., Dawson, E. S., Lybrand, T. P., Prendergast, F. G., and Miller, L. J. (2004) Mol. Pharmacol. 65, 28-35). Here, we apply the same experimental strategy to determine distances from the same receptor positions to an analogous point at the amino terminus of structurally related partial agonist (Alexa488-Gly-[(Nle(28,31))CCK-26-32]phenethyl ester) and antagonist (Alexa488-Gly-[(D-Trp31, Nle(28,31))CCK-26-32]phenethyl ester) ligands. A high degree of spectral overlap and fluorescence transfer was observed for ligand-occupied fluorescent-tagged receptors with no transfer observed for the ligand-occupied pseudo-wild type null cysteine-reactive mutant receptor (C94S). For the partial agonist, calculated distances to receptor positions 94, 102, 204, and 341, representing sites within the helical confluence, and the first, second, and third loops, were 21 +/- 0.4, 18 +/- 0.4, 25 +/- 1, and 17 +/- 1 angstroms, not different from those measured previously for the analogous full agonist. For the antagonist, the analogous distances were 21 +/- 2, 28 +/- 2, 15 +/- 1 and 21 +/- 1 angstroms. Distances to the first and third loops were longer and the distance to the second loop was shorter for the antagonist relative to both the full and partial agonist probes, whereas all three probes demonstrated similar distances to the intrahelical reference point. This supports the possibilities of changes in the conformation of the probe and/or the receptor induced by structurally similar ligands having distinct intrinsic biological activities.

Key Differences in Molecular Complexes of the Cholecystokinin Receptor with Structurally Related Peptide Agonist, Partial Agonist, and Antagonist

The molecular basis of docking of receptor ligands having differences in biological activity and their subsequent effects on receptor conformation represent areas of great interest. In this work, we focus on the sulfated tyrosyl residue in position 27 of cholecystokinin (CCK) and its spatial approximation with the type A CCK receptor residue Arg(197) that has been predicted from mutagenesis experiments. We have examined the requirement for sulfation of this residue in a series of structurally related peptide agonists, partial agonists, and antagonists using assays of receptor binding and biological activity. Whereas sulfation of CCK position 27 was critical for affinity and potency of a full agonist, it had progressively less effect as the biological activity of the ligand was reduced. It had an intermediate effect on the partial agonist and no effect on the antagonist. In addition, photoaffinity labeling was used to determine the spatial approximations between the receptor and residue 27 of the agonist and antagonist in this series. Direct photoaffinity labeling with a full agonist probe confirmed the spatial approximation of ligand residue 27 and receptor residue Arg(197) in the active complex. Of note, the analogous antagonist probe labeled a distinct region within the receptor amino terminus, confirming a key structural difference in active and inactive complexes.

Measurement of Intermolecular Distances for the Natural Agonist Peptide Docked at the Cholecystokinin Receptor Expressed in Situ Using Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer is a powerful biophysical technique used to analyze the structure of membrane proteins. Here, we used this tool to determine the distances between a distinct position within a docked agonist and a series of distinct sites within the intramembranous confluence of helices and extracellular loops of the cholecystokinin (CCK) receptor. Pseudo-wild-type CCK receptor constructs having single reactive cysteine residues inserted into each of these sites were developed. The experimental strategy included the use of the full agonist, Alexa488-CCK, bound to these receptors as donor, with Alexa568 covalently bound to the specific sites within the CCK receptor as acceptor. Site-labeling was achieved by derivatization of intact cells with a novel fluorescent methanethiosulfonate reagent. A high degree of spectral overlap was observed between receptor-bound donor and receptor-derivatized acceptors, with no transfer observed for a series of controls representing saturation of the receptor binding site with nonfluorescent ligand and use of a null-reactive CCK receptor construct. The measured distances between the fluorophore within the docked agonist and the sites within the first (residue 102) and third (residue 341) extracellular loops of the receptor were shorter than those directed to the second loop (residue 204) or to intramembranous helix two (residue 94). These distances were accommodated well within a refined molecular model of the CCK-occupied receptor that is fully consistent with all existing structure-activity and photoaffinity-labeling studies. This approach provides the initial insights into the conformation of extracellular loop regions of this receptor and establishes clear differences from analogous loops in the rhodopsin crystal structure.

Heterodimerization of Type A and B Cholecystokinin Receptors Enhance Signaling and Promote Cell Growth

Dimerization of several G protein-coupled receptors has recently been described, but little is known about its clinical and functional relevance. Cholecystokinin (CCK) and gastrin are structurally related gastrointestinal and neuronal peptides whose functions are mediated by two structurally related receptors in this superfamily, the type A and B CCK receptors. We previously demonstrated spontaneous homodimerization of type A CCK receptors and the dissociation of those complexes by agonist occupation (Cheng, Z. J., and Miller, L. J. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 48040-48047). Here, for the first time, we also demonstrate spontaneous homodimerization of type B CCK receptors, as well as heterodimerization of that receptor with the type A CCK receptor. Unlike type A CCK receptor dimers, the homodimerization of type B CCK receptors was not affected by ligand occupation. However, although heterodimers of type A and B CCK receptors bound natural agonists normally, they exhibited unusual functional and regulatory characteristics. Such complexes demonstrated enhanced agonist-stimulated cellular signaling and delayed agonist-induced receptor internalization. As a likely consequence, agonist-stimulated cell growth was markedly enhanced in cells simultaneously expressing both of these receptors. Our results provide the first evidence that heterodimerization of G protein-coupled receptors can form a more "powerful" signaling unit, which has potential clinical significance in promoting cell growth.

Importance of the amino terminus in secretin family G protein-coupled receptors. Intrinsic photoaffinity labeling establishes initial docking constraints for the calcitonin receptor

The calcitonin receptor is a member of the class B family of G protein-coupled receptors, closely related to secretin and parathyroid hormone receptors. Although mechanisms of ligand binding have been directly explored for those receptors, current knowledge of the molecular basis of calcitonin binding to its receptor is based only on receptor mutagenesis. In this work we have utilized the more direct approach of photoaffinity labeling to explore spatial approximations between distinct residues within calcitonin and its receptor. For this we have developed two human calcitonin analogues incorporating a photolabile p-benzoyl-l-phenylalanine residue in the mid-region and carboxyl-terminal half of the peptide in positions 16 and 26, respectively. Both probes specifically bound to the human calcitonin receptor with high affinity and were potent stimulants of cAMP accumulation in calcitonin receptor-bearing human embryonic kidney 293 cells. They covalently labeled the calcitonin receptor in a saturable and specific manner. Further purification, deglycosylation, specific chemical and enzymatic cleavage, and sequencing of labeled wild type and mutant calcitonin receptors identified the sites of labeling for the position 16 and 26 probes as receptor residues Phe137 and Thr30, respectively. Both were within the extracellular amino terminus of the calcitonin receptor, with the former adjacent to the first transmembrane segment and the latter within the distal amino-terminal tail of the receptor. These data are consistent with affinity labeling of other members of the class B G protein-coupled receptors using analogous probes and may suggest a common ligand binding mechanism for this family.

Determination of ligand-receptor interactions of cholecystokinin by nuclear magnetic resonance

To date high resolution structural studies of G protein coupled receptors, with the exception of rhodopsin, have not been feasible using conventional spectroscopic techniques. To overcome these difficulties, the structural features of partial or intact domains of GPCRs have been studied by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography. Here, we describe the structural characterization of receptor domains from the cholecystokinin 1 and 2 receptors and the elucidation of intermolecular interactions between the extracellular receptor domains and CCK-8 by solution state nmr.

The role of segment 32-47 of cholecystokinin receptor type A in CCK8 binding: synthesis, nuclear magnetic resonance, circular dichroism and fluorescence studies

The segment 32-47 of the N-terminal extracellular domain of the type A cholecystokinn receptor, CCK(A)-R(32-47), was synthesized and structurally characterized in a membrane mimicking environment by CD, NMR and molecular dynamics calculations. The region of CCK(A)-R(32-47) encompassing residues 39-46 adopted a well-defined secondary structure in the presence of DPC micelles, whereas the conformation of the N-terminal region (segment 32-37) could not be uniquely defined by the NOE derived distance constraints because of local flexibility. The conformation of the binding domain of CCK(A)-R(32-47) was different from that found for the Intact N-terminal receptor tail, CCK(A)-R(1-47). To assess whether CCK(A)-R(32-47) was still able to bind the nonsulfated cholecystokinin C-terminal octapeptide, CCK8, a series of titrations was carried out in SDS and DPC micelles, and the binding interaction was followed by fluorescence spectroscopy. These titrations gave no evidence for complex formation, whereas a high binding affinity was found between CCK(A)-R(1-47) and CCK8. The different affinities for the ligand shown by CCK(A)-R(32-47) and CCK(A)-R(1-47) were paralleled by different interaction modes between the receptor segments and the micelles.The interaction of CCK(A)-R(32-47) with DPC micelles was much weaker than that of CCK(A)-R(1-47), because the former receptor segment lacks proper stabilizing contacts with the micelle surface. In the case of SDS micelles CCK(A)-R(32-47] was found to form non-micellar adducts with the detergent that prevented the onset of a functionally significant Interaction between the receptor segment and the micelle. It is concluded that tertiary structure interactions brought about by the 1-31 segment play a key role in the stabilization of the membrane bound, biologically active conformation of the N-terminal extracellular tail of the CCKA receptor.

Cgamma H2 of Met174 side chain is the site of covalent attachment of a substance P analog photoactivable in position 5

Analogs of substance P (H-RPKPQQFFGLM-NH(2)) incorporating a photoreactive para-benzoyl-l-phenylalanine (p-Bzl)Phe at position 4, 5, 6, 9, or 10 of the sequence have been synthesized and pharmacologically characterized previously as full NK-1 receptor agonists. In this study we show that all analogs, [BAPA(0), (p-Bzl)Phe(x), Met(O(2))(11)]SP also display high yields (40-70%) of NK-1 receptor photolabeling. To identify the site of photoinsertion in the receptor, covalent ligand/receptor complexes were digested with enzymes or chemically cleaved with cyanogen bromide and purified with streptavidin-coated magnetic beads before matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry analysis. Only the analog photoreactive at position 5 gave irreversible, reproducible, and unequivocal covalent linkage. Sequential digestions of the covalent complex, substance P analog photoreactive at position 5/NK-1 receptor, with trypsin, endo-GluC and carboxypeptidase Y, led to the identification of the tripeptide (173)TMP(175) in the second extracellular loop of the hNK-1 receptor as the site of photoinsertion. Reaction of cyanogen bromide on the pentapeptide TMPSR did not yield the expected cleavage on the carboxylic side of methionine. The high precision of mass spectrometry analysis on the mass measured led us to determine that C(gamma)H(2) of Met(174) was the site of covalent linkage of the photoreactive substance P analog. Such an insertion (photolinked ligand) on its C(gamma)H(2) renders methionine refractory to CNBr cleavage.

Moleular models for cholecystokinin-A receptor

Numerous techniques have been used to elucidate the structural basis for interaction of cholecystokinin (CCK)-related peptides with their hormone-binding receptor, the CCK-A receptor (CCK-AR), including structure-activity relationship studies, site-directed mutagenesis, photoaffinity-labeling, and solution NMR analysis of both CCK peptide ligands and peptide fragments derived from the CCK-A receptor. Different structural models have been developed for the peptide-receptor complexes using various subsets of the available experimental data (Giragossian & Mierke 2001; Ding et al. 2002; Escrieut et al. 2002). Here, we review details of the various models and evaluate the impact of selected experimental data sets on model development.

Applications of fluorescence in the characterization of the ligand-binding domain and activation of the cholecystokinin receptor

Fluorescence techniques can be applied to guanine nucleotide-binding protein-coupled receptors to gain insights into the environment and molecular motion of a fluorophore that is either incorporated into a ligand or more directly into a specific site within the receptor. Fluorescence studies can provide insight into the environment of that indicator. By situating the same indicator into an analogous position in both agonist and antagonist ligands, comparisons can provide insights into differences between active and inactive states of the receptor. These types of studies have been performed for the cholecystokinin receptor and show that receptor activation by agonist occupation is associated with a movement of the CCK-like ligand out of a protected environment and into a more accessible hydrophilic milieu.

Molecular basis of agonist binding to the type A cholecystokinin receptor

The receptors for cholecystokinin (CCK) peptides are guanine nucleotide-binding protein-coupled receptors in the rhodopsin/beta-adrenergic receptor family. The molecular basis of natural ligand binding to the type A CCK receptor has been studied using ligand structure-activity series, receptor mutagenesis, and photoaffinity labeling studies. These have focused attention on the extracellular loop and tail domains, with the most direct insights coming from intrinsic photoaffinity labeling studies. A model of the binding of CCK to this receptor is consistent with all these studies. This model places the carboxyl terminus of CCK adjacent to the amino-terminal tail outside of transmembrane segment 1, the mid-region of the peptide adjacent to the third extracellular loop outside of transmembrane segment 7, and includes a charge-charge interaction between peptide residue tyrosine-sulfate 27 and the arginine residue in the second extracellular loop of the receptor in position 197.

Development of a biologically active secretin analogue incorporating a radioiodinatable photolabile p-(4-hydroxybenzoyl)phenylalanine in position 10

Photoaffinity labeling is a powerful approach for direct elucidation of residue-residue approximations as a ligand is bound to its receptor, providing important constraints for molecular modeling. Probes utilized for this need to incorporate photolabile sites of covalent attachment and an indicator, such as a radiolabel. Radioiodine provides a particularly useful high specific radioactivity label, but due to its size, can only be accommodated in limited positions within a peptide ligand. In this work, we attempted to develop a probe for the secretin receptor that would directly provide spatial approximation data for position 10 of secretin, its site of radiolabeling. This was achieved by incorporation into a secretin analogue of the radioiodinatable and photolabile benzophenone moiety, p-(4-hydroxybenzoyl)phenylalanine (OH-Bpa). An unintended additional modification of secretin in synthesizing this probe was the elimination of Gly(4). This probe was shown to bind to the secretin receptor specifically and saturably (K(i)=25.3+/-6.0 nM). It represented a full agonist, stimulating intracellular cAMP in a concentration-dependent manner (EC(50)=4.2+/-0.7 nM). It was also able to affinity label the secretin receptor in a specific and efficient manner. This probe should provide the opportunity to identify the region of the secretin receptor in spatial approximation with position 10, within the pharmacophore of secretin, leading to refinement of molecular conformational models of this agonist-bound receptor.

Insights into the molecular basis of ligand binding by the cholecystokinin receptor

The receptor for the peptide hormone, cholecystokinin, is a G-protein-coupled receptor in the rhodopsin/beta-adrenergic receptor family. A number of methodological approaches have been utilized to gain insights into the molecular basis for natural peptide ligand binding and activation of this physiologically important receptor. Insights into this have come from sequence analysis, ligand and receptor structure-activity data, receptor mutagenesis, conformational analysis of ligand and receptor fragments, and photoaffinity labeling. In this work, we review the contributions of each of these complementary approaches and provide a current integrated view of the active complex of cholecystokinin bound to its receptor.

Environment and mobility of a series of fluorescent reporters at the amino terminus of structurally related peptide agonists and antagonists bound to the cholecystokinin receptor

Fluorescence is a powerful biophysical tool for the analysis of the structure and dynamics of proteins. Here, we have developed two series of new fluorescent probes of the cholecystokinin (CCK) receptor, representing structurally related peptide agonists and antagonists. Each ligand had one of three distinct fluorophores (Alexa(488), nitrobenzoxadiazolyl, or acrylodan) incorporated in analogous positions at the amino terminus just outside the hormone's pharmacophore. All of the probes bound to the CCK receptor specifically and with high affinity, and intracellular calcium signaling studies showed the chemically modified peptides to be fully biologically active. Quenching by iodide and measurement of fluorescence spectra, anisotropy, and lifetimes were used to characterize the response of the fluorescence of the probe in the peptide-receptor complex for agonists and antagonists. All three fluorescence indicators provided the same insights into differences in the environment of the same indicator in the analogous position for agonist and antagonist peptides bound to the CCK receptor. Each agonist had its fluorescence quenched more easily and showed lower anisotropy (higher mobility of the probe) and shorter lifetime than the analogous antagonist. Treatment of agonist-occupied receptors with a non-hydrolyzable GTP analogue shifted the receptor into its inactive low affinity state and increased probe fluorescence lifetimes toward values observed with antagonist probes. These data are consistent with a molecular conformational change associated with receptor activation that causes the amino terminus of the ligand (situated above transmembrane segment six) to move away from its somewhat protected environment and toward the aqueous milieu.

Conformational and molecular modeling studies of sulfated cholecystokinin-15

Conformational features of the C-terminal carboxyamidated pentadecapeptide of CCK (S(19)HRISDRD[SO(4)]-YMGWMDF(33)-NH(2)) were determined by NMR spectroscopy in a zwitterionic membrane-mimetic solvent system, composed of DPC micelles. The C-terminal octapeptide consisted of a well-defined pseudohelix that was nearly identical to the structure previously reported for nonsulfated CCK-8 in the same solvent system. N-terminal amino acids of CCK-15 were highly disordered, with no clear conformational preference. Extensive NOE-restrained molecular dynamics simulations of the CCK-15/CCK(1)-R complex suggested that almost all the experimentally determined intermolecular contact points provided by NMR, site-directed mutagenesis, and photoaffinity labeling could be simultaneously satisfied, when the N-terminus of the ligand is placed in close spatial proximity to the N-terminus of the receptor.

NMR studies of CCK-8/CCK1 complex support membrane-associated pathway for ligand-receptor interaction

The interaction of peptide ligands with their associated G-protein-coupled receptors has been examined by a number of different experimental approaches over the years. We have been developing an approach utilizing high-resolution NMR to determine the structural features of the peptide ligand, well-designed fragments of the receptor, and the ligand-receptor complexes formed upon titration of the peptide hormone. The results from these investigations provide evidence for a membrane-associated pathway for the initial interaction of peptide ligands with the receptor. Here, our results from the investigation of the interaction of CCK-8 with the CCK1 receptor are described. Our spectroscopic results clearly show that both CCK-8 and the regions of CCK1 with which it interacts are closely associated with the zwitterionic interface of the lipids utilized in our solution spectroscopic studies.

Refinement of the conformation of a critical region of charge-charge interaction between cholecystokinin and its receptor

Insight into the molecular basis of cholecystokinin (CCK) binding to its receptor has come from receptor mutagenesis and photoaffinity labeling studies, with both contributing to the current hypothesis that the acidic Tyr-sulfate-27 residue within the peptide is situated adjacent to basic Arg(197) in the second loop of the receptor. Here, we refine our understanding of this region of interaction by examining a structure-activity series of these positions within both ligand and receptor and by performing three-dimensional molecular modeling of key pairs of modified ligand and receptor constructs. The important roles of Arg(197) and Tyr-sulfate-27 were supported by the marked negative impact on binding and biological response with their natural partner molecule when the receptor residue was replaced by acidic Asp or Glu and when the peptide residue was replaced by basic Arg, Lys, p-amino-Phe, p-guanidino-Phe, or p-methylamino-Phe. Complementary ligand-receptor charge-exchange experiments were unable to regain the lost function. This was supported by the molecular modeling, which demonstrated that the charge-reversed double mutants could not form a good interaction without extensive rearrangement of receptor conformation. The models further predicted that R197D and R197E mutations would lead to conformational changes in the extracellular domain, and this was experimentally supported by data showing that these mutations decreased peptide agonist and antagonist binding and increased nonpeptidyl antagonist binding. These receptor constructs also had increased susceptibility to trypsin degradation relative to the wild-type receptor. In contrast, the relatively conservative R197K mutation had modest negative impact on peptide agonist binding, again consistent with the modeling demonstration of loss of a series of stabilizing inter- and intramolecular bonds. The strong correlation between predicted and experimental results support the reported refinement in the three-dimensional structure of the CCK-occupied receptor.

Agonist-dependent dissociation of oligomeric complexes of G protein-coupled cholecystokinin receptors demonstrated in living cells using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer

Dimerization of some G protein-coupled receptors has recently been demonstrated, but how widespread this phenomenon might be and its functional implications are not yet clear. We have utilized biophysical and biochemical techniques to evaluate whether the type A cholecystokinin (CCK) receptor can form oligomeric complexes in the plasma membrane and the impact of ligand binding and signaling on such complexes. We investigated the possibility of bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) between receptor constructs that included carboxyl-terminal tags of Renilla luciferase or yellow fluorescent protein. Indeed, co-expression of these constructs in COS cells resulted in the constitutive presence of a significant BRET signal above that in a series of controls, with this signal reduced by co-expression of competing non-tagged CCK receptors. The presence of an oligomeric complex of CCK receptor molecules was confirmed in co-immunoprecipitation experiments. Occupation of CCK receptors with agonist ligands (CCK or gastrin-4) resulted in the rapid reduction in BRET signal in contrast to the enhancement of such a signal reported after agonist occupation of the beta(2)-adrenergic receptor. These effects on CCK receptor oligomerization were concentration-dependent, correlating with the potencies of the agonists. A smaller effect was observed for a partial agonist, and no effect was observed for antagonist occupation of this receptor. Agonist-induced reduction in BRET signal was also observed for pairs of CCK receptors with a donor-acceptor pair situated in other positions within the receptor. Manipulation of the phosphorylation state of CCK receptor using protein kinase C activation with phorbol ester or inhibition with staurosporine had no effect on the basal level or agonist effect on CCK receptor oligomerization. This provides the first evidence for CCK receptor oligomerization in living cells, with insights that the active conformation of this receptor dissociates these complexes in a phosphorylation-independent manner.

Receptor biology and signal transduction

This year has witnessed substantial advances in receptor biology and signal transduction that are relevant to the function and regulation of the healthy pancreas and to the pathogenesis and potential therapy of pancreatitis and pancreatic carcinoma. There has been an expansion in the cast of pancreatic regulatory molecules, now including protease-activated receptors, chemokines, and chemokine receptors. There have been new insights into the cellular distribution and signaling initiated at the classic pancreatic receptors. There have also been dramatic advances in insights into the structure of G protein-coupled receptors, with the first solution of a crystal structure of a member of this superfamily, and into the molecular basis of ligand binding and activation of these important molecules. This will clearly improve the opportunities for the rational design and refinement of receptor-active drugs. In addition to these fundamental advances, there has been renewed attention to the expression, function, and regulation of receptors and signaling pathways in pancreatic cells present in the setting of pancreatitis and pancreatic carcinoma. It is hoped that this will contribute toward earlier diagnosis, more successful therapy, and new chemopreventive strategies for these illnesses.

Peptide hormone binding to G-protein-coupled receptors: structural characterization via NMR techniques

G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) allow cells to respond to calcium, hormones, and neurotransmitters. Not surprisingly, they currently make up the largest family of validated drug targets. Rational drug design for molecular regulators targeting GPCRs has been limited to theoretical-based computational approaches. X-ray crystallography of intact GPCRs has provided the topological orientation of the seven transmembrane helices, but limited structural information of the extracellular and intracellular loops and protein termini. In this review we detail an NMR-based approach which provides the high-resolution structural features on the extracellular domains of GPCRs and the ligand/receptor complexes formed upon titration of the peptide hormone. The results provide important contact points and a high-resolution description of the ligand/receptor interactions, which may be useful for the rational design of therapeutic agents targeting GPCRs. Recent results from our investigation of the cholecystokinin peptide hormone system are used to highlight this approach.

Characterization of the type A cholecystokinin receptor hormone-binding domain: use of contrasting and complementary methodologies

Insights into the molecular basis of binding of the peptide hormone, cholecystokinin, to its G protein-coupled receptor is of substantial interest and may contribute to the successful production and refinement of receptor-active drugs. A number of methodological approaches provide complementary data to contribute to these insights. These include receptor mutagenesis, ligand structure-activity data, conformational analysis of ligand and receptor fragments, and photoaffinity labeling. In this work, we compare and contrast each of these methods and provide our current view of the cumulative impact of the current data on molecular conformational models of the agonist-occupied type A cholecystokinin receptor. These support the key roles played by extracellular loop and tail regions of this receptor for binding its natural peptide ligand.