Scanning mutagenesis reveals roles for helix n of the bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase thumb subdomain in transcription complex stability, pausing, and termination

Effective Synthesis of High-Integrity mRNA Using In Vitro Transcription

mRNA vaccines are entering a period of rapid development. However, their synthesis is still plagued by challenges related to mRNA impurities and fragments (incomplete mRNA). Most impurities of mRNA products transcribed in vitro are mRNA fragments. Only full-length mRNA transcripts containing both a 5'-cap and a 3'-poly(A) structure are viable for in vivo expression. Therefore, RNA fragments are the primary product-related impurities that significantly hinder mRNA efficacy and must be effectively controlled; these species are believed to originate from either mRNA hydrolysis or premature transcriptional termination. In the manufacturing of commercial mRNA vaccines, T7 RNA polymerase-catalyzed in vitro transcription (IVT) synthesis is a well-established method for synthesizing long RNA transcripts. This study identified a pivotal domain on the T7 RNA polymerase that is associated with erroneous mRNA release. By leveraging the advantageous properties of a T7 RNA polymerase mutant and precisely optimized IVT process parameters, we successfully achieved an mRNA integrity exceeding 91%, thereby further unlocking the immense potential of mRNA therapeutics.

C, Da LT, Yu J. A Viral T7 RNA Polymerase Ratcheting Along DNA With Fidelity Control

RNA polymerase (RNAP) from bacteriophage T7 is a representative single-subunit viral RNAP that can transcribe with high promoter activities without assistances from transcription factors. We accordingly studied this small transcription machine computationally as a model system to understand underlying mechanisms of mechano-chemical coupling and fidelity control in the RNAP transcription elongation. Here we summarize our computational work from several recent publications to demonstrate first how T7 RNAP translocates via Brownian alike motions along DNA right after the catalytic product release. Then we show how the backward translocation motions are prevented at post-translocation upon successful nucleotide incorporation, which is also subject to stepwise nucleotide selection and acts as a pawl for "selective ratcheting". The structural dynamics and energetics features revealed from our atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and related analyses on the single-subunit T7 RNAP thus provided detailed and quantitative characterizations on the Brownian-ratchet working scenario of a prototypical transcription machine with sophisticated nucleotide selectivity for fidelity control. The presented mechanisms can be more or less general for structurally similar viral or mitochondrial RNAPs and some of DNA polymerases, or even for the RNAP engine of the more complicated transcription machinery in higher organisms.

Identification of a unique insertion in plant organellar DNA polymerases responsible for 5'-dRP lyase and strand-displacement activities: Implications for Base Excision Repair

Plant mitochondrial and chloroplast genomes encode essential proteins for oxidative phosphorylation and photosynthesis. For proper cellular function, plant organelles must ensure genome integrity. Although plant organelles repair damaged DNA using the multi-enzyme Base Excision Repair (BER) pathway, the details of this pathway in plant organelles are largely unknown. The initial enzymatic steps in BER produce a 5'-deoxyribose phosphate (5'-dRP) moiety that must be removed to allow DNA ligation and in plant organelles, the enzymes responsible for the removal of a 5'-dRP group are unknown. In metazoans, DNA polymerases (DNAPs) remove the 5'-dRP moiety using their intrinsic lyase and/or strand-displacement activities during short or long-patch BER sub-pathways, respectively. The plant model Arabidopsis thaliana encodes two family-A DNAPs paralogs, AtPolIA and AtPolIB, which are the sole DNAPs in plant organelles identified to date. Herein we demonstrate that both AtPolIs present 5'-dRP lyase activities. AtPolIB performs efficient strand-displacement on a BER-associated 1-nt gap DNA substrate, whereas AtPolIA exhibits only moderate strand-displacement activity. Both lyase and strand-displacement activities are dependent on an amino acid insertion that is exclusively present in plant organellar DNAPs. Within this insertion, we identified that residue AtPollB-Lys593 acts as nucleophile for lyase activity. Our results demonstrate that AtPolIs are functionally equipped to play a role in short-patch BER and suggest a major role of AtPolIB in a predicted long-patch BER sub-pathway. We propose that the acquisition of insertion 1 in the polymerization domain of AtPolIs was a key component in their evolution as BER associated and replicative DNAPs.

The thumb subdomain of yeast mitochondrial RNA polymerase is involved in processivity, transcript fidelity and mitochondrial transcription factor binding

Single subunit RNA polymerases have evolved 2 mechanisms to synthesize long transcripts without falling off a DNA template: binding of nascent RNA and interactions with an RNA:DNA hybrid. Mitochondrial RNA polymerases share a common ancestor with T-odd bacteriophage single subunit RNA polymerases. Herein we characterized the role of the thumb subdomain of the yeast mtRNA polymerase gene (RPO41) in complex stability, processivity, and fidelity. We found that deletion and point mutants of the thumb subdomain of yeast mtRNA polymerase increase the synthesis of abortive transcripts and the probability that the polymerase will disengage from the template during the formation of the late initial transcription and elongation complexes. Mutations in the thumb subdomain increase the amount of slippage products from a homopolymeric template and, unexpectedly, thumb subdomain deletions decrease the binding affinity for mitochondrial transcription factor (Mtf1). The latter suggests that the thumb subdomain is part of an extended binding surface area involved in binding Mtf1.

Structure of human mitochondrial RNA polymerase elongation complex

The crystal structure of the human mitochondrial RNA polymerase (mtRNAP) transcription elongation complex was determined at 2.65 Å resolution. The structure reveals a 9–base pair hybrid formed between the DNA template and the RNA transcript and one turn of DNA both upstream and downstream of the hybrid. Comparisons with the distantly related RNAP from bacteriophage T7 indicates conserved mechanisms for substrate binding and nucleotide incorporation, but also strong mechanistic differences. Whereas T7 RNAP refolds during the transition from initiation to elongation, mtRNAP adopts an intermediary conformation that is capable of elongation without refolding. The intercalating hairpin that melts DNA during T7 RNAP initiation separates RNA from DNA during mtRNAP elongation. Newly synthesized RNA exits towards the PPR domain, a unique feature of mtRNAP with conserved RNA recognition motifs.

The structure of a transcribing T7 RNA polymerase in transition from initiation to elongation

Structural studies of the T7 bacteriophage DNA-dependent RNA polymerase (T7 RNAP) have shown that the conformation of the amino-terminal domain changes substantially between the initiation and elongation phases of transcription, but how this transition is achieved remains unclear. We report crystal structures of T7 RNAP bound to promoter DNA containing either a 7- or an 8-nucleotide (nt) RNA transcript that illuminate intermediate states along the transition pathway. The amino-terminal domain comprises the C-helix subdomain and the promoter binding domain (PBD), which consists of two segments separated by subdomain H. The structures of the intermediate complex reveal that the PBD and the bound promoter rotate by approximately 45 degrees upon synthesis of an 8-nt RNA transcript. This allows the promoter contacts to be maintained while the active site is expanded to accommodate a growing heteroduplex. The C-helix subdomain moves modestly toward its elongation conformation, whereas subdomain H remains in its initiation- rather than its elongation-phase location, more than 70 angstroms away.

T7 RNA polymerase studied by force measurements varying cofactor concentration

RNA polymerases carry out the synthesis of an RNA copy from a DNA template. They move along DNA, incorporate nucleotide triphosphate (NTP) at the end of the growing RNA chain, and consume chemical energy. In a single-molecule assay using the T7 RNA polymerase, we study how a mechanical force opposing the forward motion of the enzyme along DNA affects the translocation rate. We also study the influence of nucleotide and magnesium concentration on this process. The experiment shows that the opposing mechanical force is a competitive inhibitor of nucleotide binding. Also, the single-molecule data suggest that magnesium ions are involved in a step that does not depend on the external load force. These kinetic results associated with known biochemical and mutagenic data, along with the static information obtained from crystallographic structures, shape a very coherent view of the catalytic cycle of the enzyme: translocation does not take place upon NTP binding nor upon NTP cleavage, but rather occurs after PPi release and before the next nucleotide binding event. Furthermore, the energetic bias associated with the forward motion of the enzyme is close to kT and represents only a small fraction of the free energy of nucleotide incorporation and pyrophosphate hydrolysis.

The transition to an elongation complex by T7 RNA polymerase is a multistep process

During the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex (EC), T7 RNA polymerase undergoes major conformational changes that involve reorientation of a "core" subdomain as a rigid body and extensive refolding of other elements in the 266 residue N-terminal domain. The pathway and timing of these events is poorly understood. To examine this, we introduced proline residues into regions of the N-terminal domain that become alpha-helical during the reorganization and changed the charge of a key residue that interacts with the RNA:DNA hybrid 5 bp upstream of the active site in the EC but not in the initiation complex. These alterations resulted in a diminished ability to make products >5-7 nt and/or a slow transition through this point. The results indicate that the transition to an EC is a multistep process and that the movement of the core subdomain and reorganization of certain elements in the N-terminal domain commence prior to promoter release (at 8-9 nt).

Translocation by T7 RNA polymerase: a sensitively poised Brownian ratchet

Studies of halted T7 RNA polymerase (T7RNAP) elongation complexes (ECs) or of T7RNAP transcription against roadblocks due to DNA-bound proteins indicate that T7RNAP translocates via a passive Brownian ratchet mechanism. Crystal structures of T7RNAP ECs suggest that translocation involves an active power-stroke. However, neither solution studies of halted or slowed T7RNAP ECs, nor crystal structures of static complexes, are necessarily relevant to how T7RNAP translocates during rapid elongation. A recent single molecule study of actively elongating T7RNAPs provides support for the Brownian ratchet mechanism. Here, we obtain additional evidence for the existence of a Brownian ratchet during active T7RNAP elongation by showing that both rapidly elongating and halted complexes are equally sensitive to pyrophosphate. Using chemical nucleases tethered to the polymerase we achieve sub-ångström resolution in measuring the average position of halted T7RNAP ECs and find that the positional equilibrium of the EC is sensitively poised between pre-translocated and post-translocated states. This may be important in maximizing the sensitivity of the polymerase to sequences that cause pausing or termination. We also confirm that a crystallographically observed disorder to order transition in a loop formed by residues 589-612 also occurs in solution and is coupled to pyrophosphate or NTP release. This transition allows the loop to make interactions with the DNA that help stabilize the laterally mobile, ligand-free EC against dissociation.

Probing conformational changes in T7 RNA polymerase during initiation and termination by using engineered disulfide linkages

During the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex (EC), the single-subunit bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) undergoes dramatic conformational changes. To explore the significance of these changes, we constructed mutant RNAPs that are able to form disulfide bonds that limit the mobility of elements that are involved in the transition (or its reversal) and examined the effects of the crosslinks on initiation and termination. A crosslink that is specific to the initiation complex conformation blocks transcription at 5-6 nt, presumably by preventing isomerization to an EC. A crosslink that is specific to the EC conformation has relatively little effect on elongation or on termination at a class I terminator (T), which involves the formation of a stable stem-loop structure in the RNA. Crosslinked ECs also pause and resume transcription normally at a class II pause site (concatamer junction) but are deficient in termination at a class II terminator (PTH, which is found in human preparathyroid hormone gene), both of which involve a specific recognition sequence. The crosslinked amino acids in the EC lie close to the upstream end of the RNA-DNA hybrid and may prevent a movement of the polymerase that would assist in displacing or releasing RNA from a relatively unstable DNA-RNA hybrid in the paused PTH complex.

Major conformational changes during T7RNAP transcription initiation coincide with, and are required for, promoter release

During transcription initiation conformational changes in the transcriptional machinery are required to accommodate the growing RNA, to allow the polymerase to release the promoter, and to endow the elongation complex with high processivity. In T7 RNA polymerase these changes involve refolding and reorientation of elements of the N-terminal domain, as well as changes in how the DNA is bound within the complex. However, when and where these conformational changes occur is unknown, and the role of these changes in allowing the polymerase to disengage the promoter is poorly understood. To address this we have used chemical nucleases tethered to the polymerase to monitor conformational changes, and engineered disulfide bonds to block conformational changes at defined steps in transcription. We find that many of the major structural transitions occur cooperatively, at a point coincident with promoter release. Moreover, promoter release requires that two elements of the polymerase which form a continuous promoter recognition surface in the initial transcription complex move apart: if this movement is blocked the polymerase cannot disengage the promoter.

Weakening of the T7 promoter-polymerase interaction facilitates promoter release

During transcription initiation, RNA polymerases retain interactions with their promoters until the RNA is extended to 8-13 nucleotides, at which point the polymerase releases the promoter and moves downstream. It has been shown that release of the T7 promoter is inhibited when the T7 RNA polymerase-promoter interaction is strengthened. Here we asked whether release would be facilitated when the T7 promoter-polymerase interaction is weakened by the introduction of promoter mutations known to reduce promoter activity. Using chemical and enzymatic probes to monitor the position of the polymerase as a function of RNA length, we found that promoter mutations upstream of -4 facilitated release of the polymerase from the promoter, but more downstream mutations did not have such effects. We also found that released complexes turn over more slowly than promoter-bound complexes, indicating that retention of promoter interactions contributes to the dissociation of short RNAs during initial transcription.

RNA displacement and resolution of the transcription bubble during transcription by T7 RNA polymerase

Unlike DNA polymerases, RNA polymerases (RNAPs) must displace the nascent product from the template and restore the DNA to duplex form after passage of the transcription complex. To accomplish this, RNAPs establish a locally denatured "bubble" that encloses a short RNA:DNA hybrid. As the polymerase advances along the template, the RNA is displaced at the trailing edge of the bubble and the two DNA strands are reannealed. Structural analyses have revealed a number of elements that are likely to be involved in this process in T7 RNAP. In this work, we used genetic and biochemical methods to explore the roles of these elements during the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex. The results indicate that the transition is a multistep process and reveal a critical role for the nontemplate strand of the DNA.

Initial bubble collapse plays a key role in the transition to elongation in T7 RNA polymerase

RNA polymerases bind to specific sequences in DNA, melt open duplex DNA around the start site, and start transcription within the initially melted bubble. The initially transcribing complex is relatively unstable, releasing short abortive products. After synthesis of a minimal length of RNA (approximately 10-12 bases in the T7 system), RNA polymerases complete the transition to a processive (highly stable) elongation phase and lose the initial promoter contacts. The current study strongly supports a model for T7 RNA polymerase in which initial bubble collapse from position -4 to position +3 is responsible for initiating RNA displacement in the transition process. More specifically, collapse of the bubble from position -4 to position -1 indirectly and energetically facilitates the direct strand invasion offered by collapse at positions +1 to +3. Parallel work shows that promoter release, another key event occurring during this stage of transcription, begins after translocation to position +8 and is largely complete upon translocation to about position +12. The timing of promoter release agrees with the timing of initial bubble collapse determined by our previous fluorescence studies, suggesting that these two events are closely related.

Multiple Roles of T7 RNA Polymerase and T7 Lysozyme During Bacteriophage T7 Infection

T7 RNA polymerase selectively transcribes T7 genes during infection but is also involved in DNA replication, maturation and packaging. T7 lysozyme is an amidase that cuts a bond in the peptidoglycan layer of the cell wall, but it also binds T7 RNA polymerase and inhibits transcription, and it stimulates replication and packaging of T7 DNA. To better understand the roles of these two proteins during T7 infection, mutants of each were constructed or selected and their biochemical and physiological behavior analyzed. The amidase activity of lysozyme is needed for abrupt lysis and release of phage particles but appears to have no role in replication and packaging. The interaction between polymerase and lysozyme stimulates both replication and packaging. Polymerase mutants that gain the ability to grow normally in the absence of an interaction with lysozyme still fail to shut down late transcription and, remarkably, have become hypersensitive to inhibition when lysozyme is able to bind. These lysozyme-hypersensitive polymerases behave without lysozyme similarly to wild-type polymerase with lysozyme: both remain longer at the promoter before establishing a lysozyme-resistant elongation complex and both increase the length of pausing when elongation complexes encounter an eight-base recognition sequence involved in DNA packaging. Replication origins contain T7 promoters, but the role of T7 RNA polymerase in initiating replication is not understood well enough to more than speculate how the lysozyme-polymerase interaction stimulates replication. Maturation and packaging is apparently initiated through interaction between prohead-terminase complexes and transcription elongation complexes paused at the sequence TATCTGT(T/A), well conserved at the right-end of the concatemer junction of T7-like phages. A model that is consistent with the structure of an elongation complex and a large body of mutational and biochemical data is proposed to explain sequence-specific pausing and potential termination at the consensus recognition sequence (C/T)ATCTGT(T/A).

Discontinuous movement and conformational change during pausing and termination by T7 RNA polymerase

Time-resolved characterization of T7 RNA polymerase pausing and terminating at a class II termination site has been carried out using site-specifically tethered chemical nucleases. The data indicate that T7RNAP normally moves uniformly down the template as a rigid body. However, at the class II site this movement is interrupted, and the leading edge of the polymerase moves further along the DNA than the trailing edge. This discontinuous movement may persist until it can no longer be accommodated by conformational changes in the elongation complex, at which point the polymerase can either pause or terminate. Termination, but not pausing, is abrogated by introduction of a disulfide bond between the polymerase fingers and thumb subdomains. The introduced cysteines disrupt a thumb-fingers salt-bridge and, under reducing conditions, this mutant enzyme shows reduced processivity coincident with extension of the RNA to 5 nt. These observations suggest that termination requires that the thumb and fingers subdomains move apart, in a reversal of a conformational change important for initially forming a stable transcription complex.

Major conformational changes occur during the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex by T7 RNA polymerase

To examine changes that occur during the transition from an initiation complex (IC) to an elongation complex (EC) in T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP), we used nucleic acid-protein cross-linking methods to probe interactions of the RNAP with RNA and DNA in a halted EC. As the RNA is displaced from the RNA-DNA hybrid approximately 9 bp upstream from the active site (at -9) it interacts with a region within the specificity loop (residues 744-750) and is directed toward a positively charged surface that surrounds residues Lys-302 and Lys-303. Surprisingly, the template and non-template strands of the DNA at the upstream edge of the hybrid (near the site where the RNA is displaced) interact with a region in the N-terminal domain of the RNAP (residues 172-191) that is far away from the specificity loop before isomerization (in the IC). To bring these two regions of the RNAP into proximity, major conformational changes must occur during the transition from an IC to an EC. The observed nucleic acid-protein interactions help to explain the behavior of a number of mutant RNAPs that are affected at various stages in the initiation process and in termination.

Structure of a T7 RNA polymerase elongation complex at 2.9 A resolution

The single-subunit bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase carries out the transcription cycle in an identical manner to that of bacterial and eukaryotic multisubunit enzymes. Here we report the crystal structure of a T7 RNA polymerase elongation complex, which shows that incorporation of an 8-base-pair RNA-DNA hybrid into the active site of the enzyme induces a marked rearrangement of the amino-terminal domain. This rearrangement involves alternative folding of about 130 residues and a marked reorientation (about 130 degrees rotation) of a stable core subdomain, resulting in a structure that provides elements required for stable transcription elongation. A wide opening on the enzyme surface that is probably an RNA exit pathway is formed, and the RNA-DNA hybrid is completely buried in a newly formed, deep protein cavity. Binding of 10 base pairs of downstream DNA is stabilized mostly by long-distance electrostatic interactions. The structure implies plausible mechanisms for the various phases of the transcription cycle, and reveals important structural similarities with the multisubunit RNA polymerases.

Common structural features of nucleic acid polymerases

Structures of multisubunit RNA polymerases strongly differ from the many known structures of single subunit DNA and RNA polymerases. However, in functional complexes of these diverse enzymes, nucleic acids take a similar course through the active center. This finding allows superposition of diverse polymerases and reveals features that are functionally equivalent. The entering DNA duplex is bent by almost 90 degrees with respect to the exiting template-product duplex. At the point of bending, a dramatic twist between subsequent DNA template bases aligns the "coding" base with the binding site for the incoming nucleoside triphosphate (NTP). The NTP enters through an opening that is found in all polymerases, and, in most cases, binds between an alpha-helix and two catalytic metal ions. Subsequent phosphodiester bond formation adds a new base pair to the exiting template-product duplex, which is always bound from the minor groove side. All polymerases may undergo "induced fit" upon nucleic acid binding, but the underlying conformational changes differ.

Structural transitions mediating transcription initiation by T7 RNA polymerase

During transcription initiation, RNA polymerases appear to retain promoter interactions while transcribing short RNAs that are frequently released from the complex. Upon transition to elongation, the polymerase releases promoter and forms a stable elongation complex. Little is known about the changes in polymerase conformation or polymerase:DNA interactions that occur during this process. To characterize the transitions that occur in the T7 RNA polymerase transcription complex during initiation, we prepared enzymes with Fe-BABE conjugated at 11 different positions. Addition of H(2)O(2) to transcription complexes prepared with these enzymes led to nucleic acid strand scission near the conjugate. Changes in the cleavage sites revealed a series of conformational changes and rearrangements of protein:nucleic acid contacts that mediate progression through the initiation reaction.