The structure of the coliphage HK022 Nun protein-lambda-phage boxB RNA complex. Implications for the mechanism of transcription termination

Structural basis of phage transcriptional regulation

Phages are the most prevalent and diverse entities in the biosphere and represent the simplest systems that are capable of self-replication. Many fundamental concepts of transcriptional regulation were revealed through phage studies. The replication of phages within bacteria entails the hijacking of the host transcription machinery. Typically, this is accomplished through proteins and RNAs encoded by the phage genome that bind to the host RNA polymerase and modify its characteristics. Understanding these processes offers valuable insights into the mechanisms of bacterial transcription itself. Historically, X-ray crystallography has been the major tool for elucidating the structural basis of phage transcriptional regulation. In recent years, the application of cryoelectron microscopy has not only allowed the exploration of protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions at near-atomic resolution but also captured transient intermediate states, further expanding our mechanistic understanding of phage transcriptional regulation.

Deep structural insights into RNA-binding disordered protein regions

Recent efforts to identify RNA binding proteins in various organisms and cellular contexts have yielded a large collection of proteins that are capable of RNA binding in the absence of conventional RNA recognition domains. Many of the recently identified RNA interaction motifs fall into intrinsically disordered protein regions (IDRs). While the recognition mode and specificity of globular RNA binding elements have been thoroughly investigated and described, much less is known about the way IDRs can recognize their RNA partners. Our aim was to summarize the current state of structural knowledge on the RNA binding modes of disordered protein regions and to propose a classification system based on their sequential and structural properties. Through a detailed structural analysis of the complexes that contain disordered protein regions binding to RNA, we found two major binding modes that represent different recognition strategies and, most likely, functions. We compared these examples with DNA binding disordered proteins and found key differences stemming from the nucleic acids as well as similar binding strategies, implying a broader substrate acceptance by these proteins. Due to the very limited number of known structures, we integrated molecular dynamics simulations in our study, whose results support the proposed structural preferences of specific RNA‐binding IDRs. To broaden the scope of our review, we included a brief analysis of RNA‐binding small molecules and compared their structural characteristics and RNA recognition strategies to the RNA‐binding IDRs.

This article is categorized under:

RNA Structure and Dynamics > RNA Structure, Dynamics, and Chemistry

RNA Interactions with Proteins and Other Molecules > Protein–RNA Recognition

RNA Interactions with Proteins and Other Molecules > Small Molecule–RNA Interactions

Structural basis of transcription arrest by coliphage HK022 Nun in an Escherichia coli RNA polymerase elongation complex

Coliphage HK022 Nun blocks superinfection by coliphage λ by stalling RNA polymerase (RNAP) translocation specifically on λ DNA. To provide a structural framework to understand how Nun blocks RNAP translocation, we determined structures of Escherichia coli RNAP ternary elongation complexes (TECs) with and without Nun by single-particle cryo-electron microscopy. Nun fits tightly into the TEC by taking advantage of gaps between the RNAP and the nucleic acids. The C-terminal segment of Nun interacts with the RNAP β and β’ subunits inside the RNAP active site cleft as well as with nearly every element of the nucleic acid scaffold, essentially crosslinking the RNAP and the nucleic acids to prevent translocation, a mechanism supported by the effects of Nun amino acid substitutions. The nature of Nun interactions inside the RNAP active site cleft suggests that RNAP clamp opening is required for Nun to establish its interactions, explaining why Nun acts on paused TECs.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.25478.001

HK022 Nun Requires Arginine-Rich Motif Residues Distinct from λ N

Bacteriophage λ N protein binds boxB RNA hairpins in the nut (N utilization) sites of immediate early λ transcripts and interacts with host factors to suppress transcriptional termination at downstream terminators. In opposition to λ N, the Nun protein of HK022 binds the boxBs of coinfecting λ transcripts, interacts with a similar or identical set of host factors, and terminates transcription to suppress λ replication. Comparison of N-boxB and Nun-boxB nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structural models suggests similar interactions, though limited mutagenesis of Nun is available. Here, libraries of Nun's arginine-rich motif (ARM) were screened for the ability to exclude λ coinfection, and mutants were assayed for Nun termination with a boxB plasmid reporter system. Several Nun ARM residues appear to be immutable: Asp26, Arg28, Arg29, Arg32, Trp33, and Arg36. Asp26 and Trp33 appear to be unable to contact boxB and are not found at equivalent positions in λ N ARM. To understand if the requirement of Asp26, Trp33, and Arg36 indicated differences between HK022 Nun termination and λ N antitermination complexes, the same Nun libraries were fused to the activation domain of λ N and screened for clones able to complement N-deficient λ. Mutants were assayed for N antitermination. Surprisingly, Asp26 and Trp33 were still essential when Nun ARM was fused to N. Docking suggests that Nun ARM contacts a hydrophobic surface of the NusG carboxy-terminal domain containing residues necessary for Nun function. These findings indicate that Nun ARM relies on distinct contacts in its ternary complex and illustrate how protein-RNA recognition can evolve new regulatory functions.

IMPORTANCE

λ N protein interacts with host factors to allow λ nut-containing transcripts to elongate past termination signals. A competing bacteriophage, HK022, expresses Nun protein, which causes termination of λ nut transcripts. λ N and HK022 Nun use similar arginine-rich motifs (ARMs) to bind the same boxB RNAs in nut transcripts. Screening libraries of Nun ARM mutants, both in HK022 Nun and in a λ N fusion, revealed amino acids essential to Nun that could bind one or more host factors. Docking suggests that NusG, which is present in both Nun termination and N antitermination, is a plausible partner. These findings could help understand how transcription elongation is regulated and illustrate how subtle differences allow ARMs to evolve new regulatory functions.

Ionic strength independence of charge distributions in solvation of biomolecules

Electrostatic forces enormously impact the structure, interactions, and function of biomolecules. We perform all-atom molecular dynamics simulations for 5 proteins and 5 RNAs to determine the dependence on ionic strength of the ion and water charge distributions surrounding the biomolecules, as well as the contributions of ions to the electrostatic free energy of interaction between the biomolecule and the surrounding salt solution (for a total of 40 different biomolecule/solvent combinations). Although water provides the dominant contribution to the charge density distribution and to the electrostatic potential even in 1M NaCl solutions, the contributions of water molecules and of ions to the total electrostatic interaction free energy with the solvated biomolecule are comparable. The electrostatic biomolecule/solvent interaction energies and the total charge distribution exhibit a remarkable insensitivity to salt concentrations over a huge range of salt concentrations (20 mM to 1M NaCl). The electrostatic potentials near the biomolecule's surface obtained from the MD simulations differ markedly, as expected, from the potentials predicted by continuum dielectric models, even though the total electrostatic interaction free energies are within 11% of each other.

Understanding the physical basis of the salt dependence of the electrostatic binding free energy of mutated charged ligand-nucleic acid complexes

The predictions of the derivative of the electrostatic binding free energy of a biomolecular complex, ΔG(el), with respect to the logarithm of the 1:1 salt concentration, d(ΔG(el))/d(ln[NaCl]), SK, by the Poisson-Boltzmann equation, PBE, are very similar to those of the simpler Debye-Hückel equation, DHE, because the terms in the PBE's predictions of SK that depend on the details of the dielectric interface are small compared to the contributions from long-range electrostatic interactions. These facts allow one to obtain predictions of SK using a simplified charge model along with the DHE that are highly correlated with both the PBE and experimental binding data. The DHE-based model developed here, which was derived from the generalized Born model, explains the lack of correlation between SK and ΔG(el) in the presence of a dielectric discontinuity, which conflicts with the popular use of this supposed correlation to parse experimental binding free energies into electrostatic and nonelectrostatic components. Moreover, the DHE model also provides a clear justification for the correlations between SK and various empirical quantities, like the number of ion pairs, the ligand charge on the interface, the Coulomb binding free energy, and the product of the charges on the complex's components, but these correlations are weak, questioning their usefulness.

Conformational distributions at the N-peptide/boxB RNA interface studied using site-directed spin labeling

In bacteriophage λ, interactions between a 22-amino acid peptide (called the N-peptide) and a stem-loop RNA element (called boxB) play a critical role in transcription anti-termination. The N-peptide/boxB complex has been extensively studied, and serves as a paradigm for understanding mechanisms of protein/RNA recognition. Particularly, ultrafast spectroscopy techniques have been applied to monitor picosecond fluorescence decay behaviors of 2-aminopurines embedded at various positions of the boxB RNA. The studies have led to a model in which the bound N-peptide exists in dynamic equilibrium between two states, with peptide C-terminal fragment either stacking on (i.e., the stacked state) or peeling away from (i.e., the unstacked state) the RNA loop. The function of the N-peptide/boxB complex seems to correlate with the fraction of the stacked state. Here, the N-peptide/boxB system is studied using the site-directed spin labeling technique, in which X-band electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy is applied to monitor nanosecond rotational behaviors of stable nitroxide radicals covalently attached to different positions of the N-peptide. The data reveal that in the nanosecond regime the C-terminal fragment of bound N-peptide adopts multiple discrete conformations within the complex. The characteristics of these conformations are consistent with the proposed stacked and unstacked states, and their distributions vary upon mutations within the N-peptide. These results suggest that the dynamic two-state model remains valid in the nanosecond regime, and represents a unique mode of function in the N-peptide/boxB RNA complex. It also demonstrates a connection between picosecond and nanosecond dynamics in a biological complex.

RNA polymerase elongation factors

The elongation phase of transcription by RNA polymerase is highly regulated and modulated. Both general and operon-specific elongation factors determine the local rate and extent of transcription to coordinate the appearance of transcript with its use as a messenger or functional ribonucleoprotein or regulatory element, as well as to provide operon-specific gene regulation.

The Y39A mutation of HK022 Nun disrupts a boxB interaction but preserves termination activity

Coliphage HK022 Nun protein targets phage lambda nut boxB RNA and acts as a transcriptional terminator, counteracting the phage lambda N protein, a suppressor of transcription termination. Both Nun and N protein interact directly with RNA polymerase, and Nun competes with N protein for boxB binding and prevents superinfection of Escherichia coli HK022 lysogens by lambda. Interaction of Trp18 of lambda N and A7 of boxB RNA in the N- boxB complex is essential for efficient antitermination. We found that the corresponding Nun mutation, Nun Y39A, disrupts the interaction between the aromatic ring of Y39 and A7, but the mutant retains in vivo termination activity. Stabilization of the complex by interaction of A7 with an aromatic amino acid is thus less important for Nun activity than it is for N activity. Structural investigations show similar binding of mutant and wild-type (wt) Nun protein to boxB RNA. The dissociation constants of the wt Nun(20-44)- boxB and mutant Nun(20-44)- boxB complex as well as the structures of the boxB RNA in both complexes are identical.

NELF-E RRM undergoes major structural changes in flexible protein regions on target RNA binding

The E subunit of the human heterotetrameric negative transcription elongation factor (NELF-E) contains a canonical betaalphabetabetaalphabeta RNA recognition motif (RRM) that binds to a wide variety of RNA sequences. These induce very similar conformational changes in the RRM as determined by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Although the RNA binding interface of a canonical RRM is mainly located at its beta-sheet surface, for NELF-E RRM large chemical shift perturbations are observed for residues in the flexible C-terminal region and the loop between beta 3 and alpha 2, and both regions are distant from the interface. We determined the solution structure of single-stranded transactivator responsive element (TAR) RNA-bound NELF-E RRM. This structure clearly shows that RNA binding to NELF-E RRM induces formation of a helix in the C-terminus. The RNA-bound form of NELF-E RRM is very similar to the RNA-bound form of U1A RRM, although the C-terminus of the NELF-E RRM is unstructured in the free protein, whereas it is helical in the U1A protein. Thus, RNA binding to NELF-E RRM induces a conformational change toward the U1A structure, resulting in highly similar RNA binding conformations for both proteins.

Ribonuclease P: the evolution of an ancient RNA enzyme

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is an ancient and essential endonuclease that catalyses the cleavage of the 5' leader sequence from precursor tRNAs (pre-tRNAs). The enzyme is one of only two ribozymes which can be found in all kingdoms of life (Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya). Most forms of RNase P are ribonucleoproteins; the bacterial enzyme possesses a single catalytic RNA and one small protein. However, in archaea and eukarya the enzyme has evolved an increasingly more complex protein composition, whilst retaining a structurally related RNA subunit. The reasons for this additional complexity are not currently understood. Furthermore, the eukaryotic RNase P has evolved into several different enzymes including a nuclear activity, organellar activities, and the evolution of a distinct but closely related enzyme, RNase MRP, which has different substrate specificities, primarily involved in ribosomal RNA biogenesis. Here we examine the relationship between the bacterial and archaeal RNase P with the eukaryotic enzyme, and summarize recent progress in characterizing the archaeal enzyme. We review current information regarding the nuclear RNase P and RNase MRP enzymes in the eukaryotes, focusing on the relationship between these enzymes by examining their composition, structure and functions.

A simple motif for protein recognition in DNA secondary structures

DNA in a single-stranded form (ssDNA) exists transiently within the cell and comprises the telomeres of linear chromosomes and the genomes of some DNA viruses. As with RNA, in the single-stranded state, some DNA sequences are able to fold into complex secondary and tertiary structures that may be recognized by proteins and participate in gene regulation. To better understand how such DNA elements might fold and interact with proteins, and to compare recognition features to those of a structured RNA, we used in vitro selection to identify ssDNAs that bind an RNA-binding peptide from the HIV Rev protein with high affinity and specificity. The large majority of selected binders contain a non-Watson-Crick G.T base-pair and an adjacent C:G base-pair and both are essential for binding. This GT motif can be presented in different DNA contexts, including a nearly perfect duplex and a branched three-helix structure, and appears to be recognized in large part by arginine residues separated by one turn of an alpha-helix. Interestingly, a very similar GT motif is necessary also for protein binding and function of a well-characterized model ssDNA regulatory element from the proenkephalin promoter.

RNA-protein recognition: single-residue ultrafast dynamical control of structural specificity and function

The transcription antiterminator N protein from bacteriophage lambda uses its arginine-rich motif to specifically bind a stem-loop RNA hairpin (boxB) as a bent alpha-helix. A single stacking interaction between a tryptophan (Trp-18) and an adenosine (A7) in the RNA loop is robust and necessary for antitermination activity in vivo. Previously, femtosecond fluorescence up-conversion experiments from this laboratory indicated that the N/boxB complex exists in a dynamical two-state equilibrium between stacked and unstacked conformations and that the extent of stacking depends on the identity of peptide residues 14 and 15. In the present work, we have combined transient absorption and fluorescence up-conversion to determine the nature of interactions responsible for this sequence-dependent behavior. Analysis of mutant complexes supports the idea that the beta-carbon of residue 14 enforces the stacked geometry by hydrophobic interaction with the ribose of A7, whereas a positive charge at this residue plays only a secondary role. A positive charge at position 15 substantially disfavors the stacked state but retains much of the binding energy. Remarkably, in vivo antitermination experiments show strong correlation with our femtosecond dynamics, demonstrating how conformational interplay can control the activity of a macromolecular machine.

Morphing molecular specificities between Arm-peptide and NUT-RNA in the antitermination complexes of bacteriophages lambda and P22

Bacteriophage lambda's N-protein includes a 17-amino-acid segment, Arm, rich in arginine and having specific affinity for a 15-nucleotide RNA stem-loop called BOX-B. Parallel but different Arm/BOX-B sequences in lambda's cousin, phage P22, account for some of the type specificity that distinguishes lambda from P22: the N of each works only with its cognate BOX-B in vivo. We find that the specificity of N(lambda) can be shifted gradually to that of N(22) by substituting sets of particular amino acids from Arm(22) into Arm of N(lambda). The determinative amino acids are generally those shown by nuclear magnetic resonance to contact BOX-B RNA; gain or loss of these contact amino acids is reasonably expected to contribute to the affinity of each amino acid sequence. Intermediate sequences may show no function with either BOX-B, or weak function with both BOX-B(lambda) and BOX-B(22), the latter suggesting possible evolutionary paths for specificity shifts.

The N-terminus is unstructured, but not dynamically disordered, in the complex between HK022 Nun protein and lambda-phage BoxB RNA hairpin

The Nun protein of lambdoid phage HK022 excludes lambda-phage superinfection by blocking expression of genes downstream from the lambda nut sequences. Heteronuclear NMR studies have been performed on a Nun peptide comprising residues 1-49 bound to the nutR BoxB RNA. The pattern of (13)C chemical shifts indicates that the arginine-rich motif of Nun forms an induced alpha-helix, consisting of residues 23-43, when bound to BoxB RNA, consistent with the structure of a shorter (residues 22-44) Nun peptide/BoxB RNA complex [Faber, C., Schärpf, M., Becker, T., Sticht, H. and Rösch (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 32064-32070]. The N-terminal extension, residues 1-22, does not show chemical shifts or nuclear Overhauser effects characteristic of stable secondary structure. Nonetheless, (15)N relaxation measurements indicate that this region is not completely disordered, as expected for a random coil peptide. Restriction of conformation flexibility in the N-terminal extension of Nun may be important for binding to other target molecules involved in transcription termination.

Sequence and structure space of RNA-binding peptides

Studies of RNA-binding peptides, and recent combinatorial library experiments in particular, have demonstrated that diverse peptide sequences and structures can be used to recognize specific RNA sites. The identification of large numbers of sequences capable of binding to a particular site has provided extensive phylogenetic information used to deduce basic principles of recognition. The high frequency at which RNA-binding peptides are found in large sequence libraries suggests plausible routes to evolve sequence-specific binders, facilitating the design of new binding molecules and perhaps reflecting characteristics of natural evolution.

Transcription termination and anti-termination in E. coli

Transcription termination in Escherichia coli is controlled by many factors. The sequence of the DNA template, the structure of the transcript, and the actions of auxiliary proteins all play a role in determining the efficiency of the process. Termination is regulated and can be enhanced or suppressed by host and phage proteins. This complex reaction is rapidly yielding to biochemical and structural analysis of the interacting factors. Below we review and attempt to unify into basic principles the remarkable recent progress in understanding transcription termination and anti-termination.