Fast coordination changes in cytochrome c do not necessarily imply folding

Hydrogen/Deuterium Exchange Measurements May Provide an Incomplete View of Protein Dynamics: a Case Study on Cytochrome c

Many aspects of protein function rely on conformational fluctuations. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) mass spectrometry (MS) provides a window into these dynamics. Despite the widespread use of HDX-MS, it remains unclear whether this technique provides a truly comprehensive view of protein dynamics. HDX is mediated by H-bond-opening/closing events, implying that HDX methods provide an H-bond-centric view. This raises the question if there could be fluctuations that leave the H-bond network unaffected, thereby rendering them undetectable by HDX-MS. We explore this issue in experiments on cytochrome c (cyt c). Compared to the Fe(II) protein, Fe(III) cyt c shows enhanced deuteration on both the distal and proximal sides of the heme. Previous studies have attributed the enhanced dynamics of Fe(III) cyt c to the facile and reversible rupture of the distal M80-Fe(III) bond. Using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we conducted a detailed analysis of various cyt c conformers. Our MD data confirm that rupture of the M80-Fe(III) contact triggers major reorientation of the distal Ω loop. Surprisingly, this event takes place with only miniscule H-bonding alterations. In other words, the distal loop dynamics are almost "HDX-silent". Moreover, distal loop movements cannot account for enhanced dynamics on the opposite (proximal) side of the heme. Instead, enhanced deuteration of Fe(III) cyt c is attributed to sparsely populated conformers where both the distal (M80) and proximal (H18) coordination bonds have been ruptured, along with opening of numerous H-bonds on both sides of the heme. We conclude that there can be major structural fluctuations that are only weakly coupled to changes in H-bonding, making them virtually impossible to track by HDX-MS. In such cases, HDX-MS may provide an incomplete view of protein dynamics.

Distal-proximal crosstalk in the heme binding pocket of the NO sensor DNR

In the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa the denitrification process is triggered by nitric oxide (NO) and plays a crucial role for the survival in chronic infection sites as a microaerobic-anaerobic biofilm. This respiratory pathway is transcriptionally induced by DNR, an heme-based gas sensor which positively responds to NO. Molecular details of the NO sensing mechanism employed by DNR are now emerging: we recently reported an in vitro study which dissected, for the first time, the heme-iron environment and identified one of the heme axial ligand (i.e. His187), found to be crucial to respond to NO. Nevertheless, the identification of the second heme axial ligand has been unsuccessful, given that a peculiar phenomenon of ligand switching around the heme-iron presumably occurs in DNR. The unusual heme binding properties of DNR could be due to the remarkable flexibility in solution of DNR itself, which, in turns, is crucial for the sensing activity; protein flexibility and dynamics indeed represent a common strategy employed by heme-based redox sensors, which present features deeply different from those of "canonical" hemeproteins. The capability of DNR to deeply rearrange around the heme-iron as been here demonstrated by means of spectroscopic characterization of the H167A/H187A DNR double mutant, which shows unusual kinetics of binding of NO and CO. Moreover, we show that the alteration (such as histidines mutations) of the distal side of the heme pocket is perceived by the proximal one, possibly via the DNR protein chain.

Picosecond binding of the His ligand to four-coordinate heme in cytochrome c': a one-way gate for releasing proximal NO

We provide a direct demonstration of a "kinetic trap" mechanism in the proximal 5-coordinate heme-nitrosyl complex (5c-NO) of cytochrome c' from Alcaligenes xylosoxidans (AXCP) in which picosecond rebinding of the endogenous His ligand following heme-NO dissociation acts as a one-way gate for the release of proximal NO into solution. This demonstration is based upon picosecond transient absorption changes following NO photodissociation of the proximal 5c-NO AXCP complex. We have determined the absolute transient absorption spectrum of 4-coordinate ferrous heme to which NO rebinds with a time constant τ(NO) = 7 ps (k(NO) = 1.4 × 10(11) s(-1)) and shown that rebinding of the proximal histidine to the 4-coordinate heme takes place with a time constant τ(His) = 100 ± 10 ps (k(His) = 10(10) s(-1)) after the release of NO from the proximal heme pocket. This rapid His reattachment acts as a one-way gate for releasing proximal NO by precluding direct proximal NO rebinding once it has left the proximal heme pocket and requiring NO rebinding from solution to proceed via the distal heme face.

Unusual heme binding properties of the dissimilative nitrate respiration regulator, a bacterial nitric oxide sensor

AIMS

In the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa, nitric oxide (NO) triggers the respiration of nitrate (denitrification), thus allowing survival in chronic infection sites as a microaerobic-anaerobic biofilm. The NO-dependent induction of denitrification is mediated by the dissimilative nitrate respiration regulator (DNR), a transcription factor forming a stable complex with heme, which is required to sense the physiological messenger (i.e., NO). The molecular details of NO sensing in DNR and, more in general, in this class of sensors are largely unknown, and a study aimed at integrating microbiology and biochemistry is needed.

RESULTS

Here we present a comprehensive study, including in vivo results and spectroscopy, kinetics, and protein engineering, that demonstrates the direct involvement of a histidine residue in heme iron coordination. Moreover, a peculiar phenomenon of ligand switching around heme iron, which hampers the identification of the second heme axial ligand, is also suggested. These results indicate that DNR is characterized by a remarkable flexibility in solution, as observed for other cAMP receptor protein/fumarate and nitrate reductase regulators (CRP-FNR) to which DNR belongs.

INNOVATION

The present work represents one of the few studies focused on the biochemistry of NO sensing by bacterial transcriptional regulators. The data presented demonstrate that structural plasticity of DNR is crucial for the sensing activity and confers to the protein unusual heme binding properties.

CONCLUSIONS

Protein flexibility and dynamics is a key structural feature essential to explain the evolutionary success and adaptability of CRP-FNR, and may represent a common strategy employed by heme-based redox sensors, which presents features deeply different from those of canonical hemeproteins.

Nitric oxide, substrate of Euphorbia characias peroxidase, switches off the CN(-) inhibitory effect

The oxidation of nitric oxide (NO) by Euphorbia characias latex peroxidase (ELP-Fe^III), in the presence or in the absence of added calcium, has been investigated. The addition of hydrogen peroxide to the native enzyme leads to the formation of Compound I and serves to catalyse the NO oxidation. The addition of NO to Compound I leads to the formation of Compound II and, afterwards, to the native enzyme spectrum. Under anaerobic conditions, the incubation of the native enzyme (ELP-Fe^III)with NO leads to the formation of the stable complex, showing a characteristic absorption spectrum (ELP-Fe^II–NO⁺). The rate of the formation of this complex is slower in the presence of calcium than in its absence, and the same applies to the rate of the formation of Compound II from Compound I, using NO as substrate. Finally, we demonstrate that NO protects ELP from the inactivation caused by CN⁻via a mechanism presumably requiring the formation of an enzyme-nitrosyl cyanide complex.

Observation of fast release of NO from ferrous d₁ haem allows formulation of a unified reaction mechanism for cytochrome cd₁ nitrite reductases

Cytochrome cd1 nitrite reductase is a haem-containing enzyme responsible for the reduction of nitrite into NO, a key step in the anaerobic respiratory process of denitrification. The active site of cytochrome cd1 contains the unique d1 haem cofactor, from which NO must be released. In general, reduced haems bind NO tightly relative to oxidized haems. In the present paper, we present experimental evidence that the reduced d1 haem of cytochrome cd1 from Paracoccus pantotrophus releases NO rapidly (k=65-200 s(-1)); this result suggests that NO release is the rate-limiting step of the catalytic cycle (turnover number=72 s(-1)). We also demonstrate, using a complex of the d1 haem and apomyoglobin, that the rapid dissociation of NO is largely controlled by the d1 haem cofactor itself. We present a reaction mechanism proposed to be applicable to all cytochromes cd1 and conclude that the d1 haem has evolved to have low affinity for NO, as compared with other ferrous haems.

Tracking the structural dynamics of proteins in solution using time-resolved wide-angle X-ray scattering

We demonstrate tracking of protein structural changes with time-resolved wide-angle X-ray scattering (TR-WAXS) with nanosecond time resolution. We investigated the tertiary and quaternary conformational changes of human hemoglobin under nearly physiological conditions triggered by laser-induced ligand photolysis. We also report data on optically induced tertiary relaxations of myoglobin and refolding of cytochrome c to illustrate the wide applicability of the technique. By providing insights into the structural dynamics of proteins functioning in their natural environment, TR-WAXS complements and extends results obtained with time-resolved optical spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography.

Non-native heme-histidine ligation promotes microsecond time scale secondary structure formation in reduced horse heart cytochrome c

Previous far-UV time-resolved optical rotatory dispersion (TRORD) studies of the sub-millisecond (burst) phase of secondary structure formation in horse and tuna cytochromes c after photoreduction in denaturant suggested that the non-native His18-Fe-His33 heme ligation dominant in the unfolded horse protein facilitated this fast folding better than did the His18-Fe-His26 coordination dominant in tuna [Chen, E., Goldbeck, R.A., and Kliger, D.S. (2003) J. Phys. Chem. A 107, 8149-8155; Chen, E., Goldbeck, R.A., and Kliger, D.S. (2004) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126, 11175-11181]. Whether His18-Fe-His33 coordination actually facilitates fast secondary structure formation or just slows folding less than His18-Fe-His26 coordination is probed by examining the double histidine mutant H26QH33N of horse heart cytochrome c. The fast folding phase is absent in H26QH33N, indicating that His18-Fe-His33 misligation does promote fast secondary structure formation, as does His18-Fe-His26 to a lesser extent. His33 may be better able to facilitate folding because it is not as constrained by hydrogen bonding interactions in the denatured state as is His26. A greater flexibility, not only because of weakened or disrupted Van der Waals interactions in the presence of guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) but also because of its position relative to His18, may allow His33 to ligate to the heme group more easily than His26. These results are discussed along with the results of far-UV CD and Soret and visible region MCD measurements, which were performed to probe heme ligation in H26QH33N and to understand how GuHCl affects its folding stability and cooperativity.

Fast Dissociation of Nitric Oxide from Ferrous Pseudomonas aeruginosa cd1 Nitrite Reductase

The heme-containing periplasmic nitrite reductase (cd(1) NIR) is responsible for the production of nitric oxide (NO) in denitrifying bacterial species, among which are several animal and plant pathogens. Heme NIRs are homodimers, each subunit containing one covalently bound c-heme and one d(1)-heme. The reduction of nitrite to NO involves binding of nitrite to the reduced protein at the level of d(1)-heme, followed by dehydration of nitrite to yield NO and release of the latter. The crucial rate-limiting step in the catalytic mechanism is thought to be the release of NO from the d(1)-heme, which has been proposed, but never demonstrated experimentally, to occur when the iron is in the ferric form, given that the reduced NO-bound derivative was presumed to be very stable, as in other hemeproteins. We have measured for the first time the kinetics of NO binding and release from fully reduced cd(1) NIR, using the enzyme from Pseudomonas aeruginosa and its site-directed mutant H369A. Quite unexpectedly, we found that NO dissociation from the reduced d(1)-heme is very rapid, several orders of magnitude faster than that measured for b-type heme containing reduced hemeproteins. Because the rate of NO dissociation from reduced cd(1) NIR, measured in the present report, is faster than or comparable with the turnover number, contrary to expectations this event may well be on the catalytic cycle and not necessarily rate-limiting. This finding also provides a rationale for the presence in cd(1) NIR of the peculiar d(1)-heme cofactor, which has probably evolved to ensure fast product dissociation.

Ligand Dynamics in an Electron Transfer Protein

Substitution of the heme coordination residue Met-80 of the electron transport protein yeast iso-1-cytochrome c allows external ligands like CO to bind and thus increase the effective redox potential. This mutation, in principle, turns the protein into a quasi-native photoactivable electron donor. We have studied the kinetic and spectral characteristics of geminate recombination of heme and CO in a series of single M80X (X = Ala, Ser, Asp, Arg) mutants, using femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy. In these proteins, all geminate recombination occurs on the picosecond and early nanosecond time scale, in a multiphasic manner, in which heme relaxation takes place on the same time scale. The extent of geminate recombination varies from >99% (Ala, Ser) to approximately 70% (Arg), the latter value being in principle low enough for electron injection studies. The rates and extent of the CO geminate recombination phases are much higher than in functional ligand-binding proteins like myoglobin, presumably reflecting the rigid and hydrophobic properties of the heme environment, which are optimized for electron transfer. Thus, the dynamics of CO recombination in cytochrome c are a tool for studying the heme pocket, in a similar way as NO in myoglobin. We discuss the differences in the CO kinetics between the mutants in terms of the properties of the heme environment and strategies to enhance the CO escape yield. Experiments on double mutants in which Phe-82 is replaced by Asp or Gly as well as the M80D substitution indicate that such steric changes substantially increase the motional freedom-dissociated CO.

Cardiolipin activates cytochrome c peroxidase activity since it facilitates H(2)O(2) access to heme

In this work, the effect of liposomes consisting of tetraoleyl cardiolipin and dioleyl phosphatidylcholine (1 : 1, mol/mol) on the rate of three more reactions of Cyt c heme with H2O2 was studied: (i) Cyt c (Fe2+) oxidation to Cyt c (Fe3+), (ii) Fe...S(Met80) bond breaking, and (iii) heme porphyrin ring decomposition. It was revealed that the rates of all those reactions increased greatly in the presence of liposomes containing cardiolipin and not of those consisting of only phosphatidylcholine, and approximately to the same extent as peroxidase activity. These data suggest that cardiolipin activates specifically Cyt c peroxidase activity not only because it promotes Fe...S(Met80) bond breaking but also facilitates H2O2 penetration to the reaction center.

Early events in the folding of four-helix-bundle heme proteins

Topologically homologous four-helix-bundle heme proteins exhibit striking diversity in their refolding kinetics. Cytochrome b562 has been reported to fold on a sub-millisecond time scale, whereas cytochrome c' refolding requires 10 s or more to complete. Heme dissociation in cytochrome b562 interferes with studies of folding kinetics, so a variant of cytochrome b562 (cytochrome c-b562) with a covalent c-type linkage to the heme has been expressed in Escherichia coli. Early events in the electron transfer-triggered folding of Fe(II)-cytochrome c-b562, along with those of Fe(II)-cytochrome c556, have been examined by using time-resolved absorption spectroscopy. Coordination of S(Met) to Fe(II) occurs within 10 mus after reduction of the denatured Fe(III)-cytochromes, and shortly thereafter (100 micros) the heme spectra are indistinguishable from those of the folded proteins. Under denaturing conditions, carbon monoxide binds to the Fe(II)-hemes in approximately 15 ms. By contrast, CO binding cannot compete with refolding in the Fe(II)-cytochromes, thereby confirming that the polypeptide encapsulates the heme in <10 ms. We suggest that Fe-S(Met) ligation facilitates refolding in these four-helix-bundle heme proteins by reducing the conformational freedom of the polypeptide chain.

Effects of Heme on the Structure of the Denatured State and Folding Kinetics of Cytochrome b562

Heme-linked proteins, such as cytochromes, are popular subjects for protein folding studies. There is the underlying question of whether the heme affects the structure of the denatured state by cross-linking it and forming other interactions, which would perturb the folding pathway. We have studied wild-type and mutant cytochrome b562 from Escherichia coli, a 106 residue four-alpha-helical bundle. The holo protein apparently refolds with a half-life of 4 micros in its ferrous state. We have analysed the folding of the apo protein using continuous-flow fluorescence as well as stopped-flow fluorescence and CD. The apo protein folded much more slowly with a half-life of 270 micros that was unaffected by the presence of exogenous heme. We examined the nature of the denatured states of both holo and apo proteins by NMR methods over a range of concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride. The starting point for folding of the holo protein in concentrations of denaturant around the denaturation transition was a highly ordered native-like species with heme bound. Fully denatured holo protein at higher concentrations of denaturant consisted of denatured apo protein and free heme. Our results suggest that the very fast folding species of denatured holo protein is in a compact state, whereas the normal folding pathway from fully denatured holo protein consists of the slower folding of the apo protein followed by the binding of heme. These data should be considered in the analysis of folding of heme proteins.

A heme tag for in vivo synthesis of artificial cytochromes

A genetic approach is described here that enables the specific covalent attachment of heme via a short C-terminal peptide tag to an otherwise non-heme-binding protein. Covalent attachment of heme to the apo-protein is catalysed by the cytochrome c maturation system of Escherichia coli. While its original enzymatic activity is retained, the resulting heme-tagged protein is red, has peroxidase activity and is redox active. The presence or absence of a C-terminal histidine tag results in low-spin heme iron with six- or high-spin heme iron with five coordinate ligands, respectively. The heme tag can be used as a tool for the rational design of artificial c-type cytochromes and metalloenzymes, thereby overcoming previous limitations set by chemical approaches. Moreover, the tag allows direct visualisation of the red fusion protein during purification.

Proton linkage for CO binding and redox properties of bovine lactoperoxidase

The pH-dependence of redox properties and of CO binding to bovine lactoperoxidase has been investigated over the range between 2 and 11. The pH-dependence of redox potentials shows a biphasic behavior, suggesting the existence of (at least) two redox-linked groups, which change their pKa values upon reduction. These values are in close agreement with those observed to play a relevant role in the modulation of CO binding to ferrous bovine lactoperoxidase. They have been tentatively attributed to Arg-372 and His-226, which are located on the distal side of the heme pocket of lactoperoxidase. A complete and unequivocal description of the proton-linked behavior of bovine lactoperoxidase requires, however, three residues, which are redox linked and relevant for the modulation of CO binding. The rate constant for CO binding to bovine lactoperoxidase is slower than what is reported for most hemoproteins, suggesting that these two residues, Arg-372 and His-226, are representing a severe barrier for the access of exogenous ligands to the heme. This aspect has been further investigated by fast kinetics following laser photolysis, trying to obtain information on the ligand binding pathway and on the energy barriers.

Cytochrome c(551) as a model system for protein folding

Considerable progress was made over the last few years in understanding the mechanism of folding of cytochrome c(551), a small acidic hemeprotein from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Comparison of our results with those obtained by others on horse heart cytochrome c allows to draw some general conclusions on the structural features that are common determinants in the folding of members of the cytochrome c family.

Early events in protein folding

Recent advances have significantly increased the time and spectroscopic resolution of protein folding experiments. We can now study the timescale and nature of polypeptide collapse, and how this correlates with secondary and tertiary structure formation. Studies on ultrafast folding proteins and peptides provide experimental benchmarks on a timescale that overlaps directly with that of molecular dynamics simulations. This makes possible direct tests of both simulations and current models of protein folding.

Rapid intrachain binding of histidine-26 and histidine-33 to heme in unfolded ferrocytochrome C

Time-resolved spectroscopic studies of unfolded horse iron(II) cytochrome c have suggested that the imidazole side chains of His26 and His33 bind transiently to the heme iron on microsecond time scales, after photodissociation of a carbon monoxide ligand from the heme. Our studies of four variants of cytochrome c (horse wild type, horse H33N, horse H33N/H26Q, and tuna wild type), unfolded in guanidine hydrochloride at pH 6.5, demonstrate that these side chains are responsible for the observed microsecond spectral changes. As His33 and then His26 are eliminated from the horse wild-type sequence, transient optical absorption spectra show systematic suppression of a rapid (approximately 10-100 micros) Soret absorbance change that follows photolysis of CO. Transient binding of these histidine side chains to the heme therefore generates one of the fast kinetic phases observed in previous photochemically triggered spectroscopic studies of dynamics in unfolded iron(II) cytochrome c. Furthermore, both His33 and His26 appear to contribute to a similar extent in these early kinetics. Thus, the stiffness of the polypeptide chain creates a deviation from Gaussian chain behavior by impeding, although not preventing, the formation of short (<10 peptide bonds) intrachain loops around the heme group.