Structure and Functional Properties of the Active Form of the Proteolytic Complex, ClpP1P2, from Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Targeted protein degradation in mycobacteria uncovers antibacterial effects and potentiates antibiotic efficacy

Proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs) represent a new therapeutic modality involving selectively directing disease-causing proteins for degradation through proteolytic systems. Our ability to exploit targeted protein degradation (TPD) for antibiotic development remains nascent due to our limited understanding of which bacterial proteins are amenable to a TPD strategy. Here, we use a genetic system to model chemically-induced proximity and degradation to screen essential proteins in Mycobacterium smegmatis (Msm), a model for the human pathogen M. tuberculosis (Mtb). By integrating experimental screening of 72 protein candidates and machine learning, we find that drug-induced proximity to the bacterial ClpC1P1P2 proteolytic complex leads to the degradation of many endogenous proteins, especially those with disordered termini. Additionally, TPD of essential Msm proteins inhibits bacterial growth and potentiates the effects of existing antimicrobial compounds. Together, our results provide biological principles to select and evaluate attractive targets for future Mtb PROTAC development, as both standalone antibiotics and potentiators of existing antibiotic efficacy.

Nucleotide-induced ClpC oligomerization and its non-preferential association with ClpP isoforms of pathogenic Leptospira

Bacterial caseinolytic protease-chaperone complexes participate in the elimination of misfolded and aggregated protein substrates. The spirochete Leptospira interrogans possess a set of Clp-chaperones (ClpX, ClpA, and ClpC), which may associate functionally with two different isoforms of LinClpP (ClpP1 and ClpP2). The L. interrogans ClpC (LinClpC) belongs to class-I chaperone with two active ATPase domains separated by a middle domain. Using the size exclusion chromatography, ANS dye binding, and dynamic light scattering analysis, the LinClpC is suggested to undergo nucleotide-induced oligomerization. LinClpC associates with either pure LinClpP1 or LinClpP2 isoforms non-preferentially and with equal affinity. Regardless, pure LinClpP isoforms cannot constitute an active protease complex with LinClpC. Interestingly, the heterocomplex LinClpP1P2 in association with LinClpC forms a functional proteolytic machinery and degrade β-casein or FITC-casein in an energy-independent manner. Adding either ATP or ATPγS further fosters the LinClpCP1P2 complex protease activity by nurturing the functional oligomerization of LinClpC. The antibiotic, acyldepsipeptides (ADEP1) display a higher activatory role on LinClpP1P2 protease activity than LinClpC. Altogether, this work illustrates an in-depth study of hetero-tetradecamer LinClpP1P2 association with its cognate ATPase and unveils a new insight into the structural reorganization of LinClpP1P2 in the presence of chaperone, LinClpC to gain protease activity.

ClpP Peptidase as a Plausible Target for the Discovery of Novel Antibiotics

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) to currently available antibiotics/drugs is a global threat. It is desirable to develop new drugs that work through a novel target(s) to avoid drug resistance. This review discusses the potential of the caseinolytic protease P (ClpP) peptidase complex as a novel target for finding novel antibiotics, emphasising the ClpP's structure and function. ClpP contributes to the survival of bacteria via its ability to destroy misfolded or aggregated proteins. In consequence, its inhibition may lead to microbial death. Drugs inhibiting ClpP activity are currently being tested, but no drug against this target has been approved yet. It was demonstrated that Nblocked dipeptides are essential for activating ClpP's proteolytic activity. Hence, compounds mimicking these dipeptides could act as inhibitors of the formation of an active ClpP complex. Drugs, including Bortezomib, Cisplatin, Cefmetazole, and Ixazomib, inhibit ClpP activation. However, they were not approved as drugs against the target because of their high toxicity, likely due to the presence of strong electrophiles in their warheads. The modifications of these warheads could be a good strategy to reduce the toxicity of these molecules. For instance, a boronate warhead was replaced by a chloromethyl ketone, and this new molecule was shown to exhibit selectivity for prokaryotic ClpP. A better understanding of the structure and function of the ClpP complex would benefit the search for compounds mimicking N-blocked dipeptides that would inhibit ClpP complex activity and cause bacterial death.

Discovery and Mechanistic Study of Novel Mycobacterium tuberculosis ClpP1P2 Inhibitors

Caseinolytic protease P (ClpP) responsible for the proteolysis of damaged or misfolded proteins plays a critical role in proteome homeostasis. MtbClpP1P2, a ClpP enzyme complex, is required for survival in Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and it is therefore considered as a promising target for the development of antituberculosis drugs. Here, we discovered that cediranib and some of its derivatives are potent MtbClpP1P2 inhibitors and suppress M. tuberculosis growth. Protein pull-down and loss-of-function assays validated the in situ targeting of MtbClpP1P2 by cediranib and its active derivatives. Structural and mutational studies revealed that cediranib binds to MtbClpP1P2 by binding to an allosteric pocket at the equatorial handle domain of the MtbClpP1 subunit, which represents a unique binding mode compared to other known ClpP modulators. These findings provide us insights for rational drug design of antituberculosis therapies and implications for our understanding of the biological activity of MtbClpP1P2.

Electrostatic interactions guide substrate recognition of the prokaryotic ubiquitin-like protein ligase PafA

Pupylation, a post-translational modification found in Mycobacterium tuberculosis and other Actinobacteria, involves the covalent attachment of prokaryotic ubiquitin-like protein (Pup) to lysines on target proteins by the ligase PafA (proteasome accessory factor A). Pupylated proteins, like ubiquitinated proteins in eukaryotes, are recruited for proteasomal degradation. Proteomic studies suggest that hundreds of potential pupylation targets are modified by the sole existing ligase PafA. This raises intriguing questions regarding the selectivity of this enzyme towards a diverse range of substrates. Here, we show that the availability of surface lysines alone is not sufficient for interaction between PafA and target proteins. By identifying the interacting residues at the pupylation site, we demonstrate that PafA recognizes authentic substrates via a structural recognition motif centered around exposed lysines. Through a combination of computational analysis, examination of available structures and pupylated proteomes, and biochemical experiments, we elucidate the mechanism by which PafA achieves recognition of a wide array of substrates while retaining selective protein turnover.

Interactome Analysis Identifies MSMEI_3879 as a Substrate of Mycolicibacterium smegmatis ClpC1

The prevalence of drug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis infections has prompted extensive efforts to exploit new drug targets in this globally important pathogen. ClpC1, the unfoldase component of the essential ClpC1P1P2 protease, has emerged as one particularly promising antibacterial target. However, efforts to identify and characterize compounds that impinge on ClpC1 activity are constrained by our limited knowledge of Clp protease function and regulation. To expand our understanding of ClpC1 physiology, we employed a coimmunoprecipitation and mass spectrometry workflow to identify proteins that interact with ClpC1 in Mycolicibacterium smegmatis, a surrogate for M. tuberculosis. We identify a diverse panel of interaction partners, many of which coimmunoprecipitate with both the regulatory N-terminal domain and the ATPase core of ClpC1. Notably, our interactome analysis establishes MSMEI_3879, a truncated gene product unique to M. smegmatis, as a novel proteolytic substrate. Degradation of MSMEI_3879 by ClpC1P1P2 in vitro requires exposure of its N-terminal sequence, reinforcing the idea that ClpC1 selectively recognizes disordered motifs on substrates. Fluorescent substrates incorporating MSMEI_3879 may be useful in screening for novel ClpC1-targeting antibiotics to help address the challenge of M. tuberculosis drug resistance. IMPORTANCE Drug-resistant tuberculosis infections are a major challenge to global public health. Much effort has been invested in identifying new drug targets in the causative pathogen, Mycobacterium tuberculosis. One such target is the ClpC1 unfoldase. Compounds have been identified that kill M. tuberculosis by disrupting ClpC1 activity, yet the physiological function of ClpC1 in cells has remained poorly defined. Here, we identify interaction partners of ClpC1 in a model mycobacterium. By building a broader understanding of the role of this prospective drug target, we can more effectively develop compounds that inhibit its essential cellular activities.

Acyldepsipeptide Antibiotics and a Bioactive Fragment Thereof Differentially Perturb Mycobacterium tuberculosis ClpXP1P2 Activity in Vitro

Proteolytic complexes in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the deadliest bacterial pathogen, are major foci in tuberculosis drug development programs. The Clp proteases, which are essential for Mtb viability, are high-priority targets. These proteases function through the collaboration of ClpP1P2, a barrel-shaped heteromeric peptidase, with associated ATP-dependent chaperones like ClpX and ClpC1 that recognize and unfold specific substrates in an ATP-dependent fashion. The critical interaction of the peptidase and its unfoldase partners is blocked by the competitive binding of acyldepsipeptide antibiotics (ADEPs) to the interfaces of the ClpP2 subunits. The resulting inhibition of Clp protease activity is lethal to Mtb. Here, we report the surprising discovery that a fragment of the ADEPs retains anti-Mtb activity yet stimulates rather than inhibits the ClpXP1P2-catalyzed degradation of proteins. Our data further suggest that the fragment stabilizes the ClpXP1P2 complex and binds ClpP1P2 in a fashion distinct from that of the intact ADEPs. A structure-activity relationship study of the bioactive fragment defines the pharmacophore and points the way toward the development of new drug leads for the treatment of tuberculosis.

Targeting caseinolytic protease P and its AAA1 chaperone for tuberculosis treatment

Caseinolytic protease P with its AAA1 chaperone, known as Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb)ClpP1P2 proteolytic machinery, maintains protein homeostasis in Mtb cells and is essential for bacterial survival. It is regarded as an important biological target with the potential to address the increasingly serious issue of multidrug-resistant (MDR) TB. Over the past 10 years, many MtbClpP1P2-targeted modulators have been identified and characterized, some of which have shown potent anti-TB activity. In this review, we describe current understanding of the substrates, structure and function of MtbClpP1P2, classify the modulators of this important protein machine into several categories based on their binding subunits or pockets, and discuss their binding details; Such information provides insights for use in candidate drug research and development of TB treatments by targeting MtbClpP1P2 proteolytic machinery.

Identification of the inhibitory mechanism of ecumicin and rufomycin 4-7 on the proteolytic activity of Mycobacterium tuberculosis ClpC1/ClpP1/ClpP2 complex

Ecumicin and rufomycin 4-7 disrupt protein homeostasis in Mycobacterium tuberculosis by inhibiting the proteolytic activity of the ClpC1/ClpP1/ClpP2 complex. Although these compounds target ClpC1, their effects on the ATPase activity of ClpC1 and proteolytic activity of ClpC1/ClpP1/ClpP2 vary. Herein, we explored the ClpC1 molecular dynamics with these compounds through fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. The effect of these compounds on the ATPase activity of ClpC1-cys, the recombinant protein for fluorescence labeling, and proteolytic activity of ClpC1-cys/ClpP1/ClpP2 were identical to those of native ClpC1, whereas the intermolecular dynamics of fluorescence-labelled ClpC1 were different. Treatment with up to 1 nM ecumicin increased the population of slower diffused ClpC1 components compared with ClpC1 without ecumicin. However, this population was considerably reduced when treated with 10 nM ecumicin. Rufomycin 4-7 treatment resulted in a slower diffused component of ClpC1, and the portion of this component increased in a concentration-dependent manner. Ecumicin can generate an abnormal ClpC1 component, which cannot form normal ClpC1/ClpP1/ClpP2, via two different modes. Rufomycin 4-7 only generates slower diffused ClpC1 component that is inadequate to form normal ClpC1/ClpP1/ClpP2. Overall, we demonstrate that ecumicin and rufomycin 4-7 use different action mechanisms to generate abnormal ClpC1 components that cannot couple with ClpP1/ClpP2.

The structure of caseinolytic protease subunit ClpP2 reveals a functional model of the caseinolytic protease system from Chlamydia trachomatis

Chlamydia trachomatis (ct) is the most reported bacterial sexually transmitted infection worldwide and the leading cause of preventable blindness. Caseinolytic proteases (ClpP) from pathogenic bacteria are attractive antibiotic targets, particularly for bacterial species that form persister colonies with phenotypic resistance against common antibiotics. ClpP functions as a multisubunit proteolytic complex, and bacteria are eradicated when ClpP is disrupted. Although crucial for chlamydial development and the design of agents to treat chlamydia, the structures of ctClpP1 and ctClpP2 have yet to be solved. Here, we report the first crystal structure of full-length ClpP2 as an inactive homotetradecamer in a complex with a candidate antibiotic at 2.66 Å resolution. The structure details the functional domains of the ClpP2 protein subunit and includes the handle domain, which is integral to proteolytic activation. In addition, hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectroscopy probed the dynamics of ClpP2, and molecular modeling of ClpP1 predicted an assembly with ClpP2. By leveraging previous enzymatic experiments, we constructed a model of ClpP2 activation and its interaction with the protease subunits ClpP1 and ClpX. The structural information presented will be relevant for future rational drug design against these targets and will lead to a better understanding of ClpP complex formation and activation within this important human pathogen.

Structure of the drug target ClpC1 unfoldase in action provides insights on antibiotic mechanism of action

The unfoldase ClpC1 is one of the most exciting drug targets against tuberculosis. This AAA+ unfoldase works in cooperation with the ClpP1P2 protease and is the target of at least four natural product antibiotics: cyclomarin, ecumicin, lassomycin, and rufomycin. Although these molecules are promising starting points for drug development, their mechanisms of action remain largely unknown. Taking advantage of a middle domain mutant, we determined the first structure of Mycobacterium tuberculosis ClpC1 in its apo, cyclomarin-, and ecumicin-bound states via cryo-EM. The obtained structure displays features observed in other members of the AAA+ family and provides a map for further drug development. While the apo and cyclomarin-bound structures are indistinguishable and have N-terminal domains that are invisible in their respective EM maps, around half of the ecumicin-bound ClpC1 particles display three of their six N-terminal domains in an extended conformation. Our structural observations suggest a mechanism where ecumicin functions by mimicking substrate binding, leading to ATPase activation and changes in protein degradation profile.

Identification of Arginine Phosphorylation in Mycolicibacterium smegmatis

Tuberculosis is a leading cause of worldwide infectious mortality. The prevalence of multidrug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis infections drives an urgent need to exploit new drug targets. One such target is the ATP-dependent protease ClpC1P1P2, which is strictly essential for viability. However, few proteolytic substrates of mycobacterial ClpC1P1P2 have been identified to date. Recent studies in Bacillus subtilis have shown that the orthologous ClpCP protease recognizes proteolytic substrates bearing posttranslational arginine phosphorylation. While several lines of evidence suggest that ClpC1P1P2 is similarly capable of recognizing phosphoarginine-bearing proteins, the existence of phosphoarginine modifications in mycobacteria has remained in question. Here, we confirm the presence of posttranslational phosphoarginine modifications in Mycolicibacterium smegmatis, a nonpathogenic surrogate of M. tuberculosis. Using a phosphopeptide enrichment workflow coupled with shotgun phosphoproteomics, we identified arginine phosphosites on several functionally diverse targets within the M. smegmatis proteome. Interestingly, phosphoarginine modifications are not upregulated by heat stress, suggesting divergent roles in mycobacteria and Bacillus. Our findings provide new evidence supporting the existence of phosphoarginine-mediated proteolysis by ClpC1P1P2 in mycobacteria and other actinobacterial species. IMPORTANCE Mycobacteria that cause tuberculosis infections employ proteolytic pathways that modulate cellular behavior by destroying specific proteins in a highly regulated manner. Some proteolytic enzymes have emerged as novel antibacterial targets against drug-resistant tuberculosis infections. However, we have only a limited understanding of how these enzymes function in the cell and how they select proteins for destruction. Some proteolytic enzymes are capable of recognizing proteins that carry an unusual chemical modification, arginine phosphorylation. Here, we confirm the existence of arginine phosphorylation in mycobacterial proteins. Our work expands our understanding of a promising drug target in an important global pathogen.

Acyldepsipeptide Analogues: A Future Generation Antibiotics for Tuberculosis Treatment

Acyldepsipeptides (ADEPs) are a new class of emerging antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), which are currently explored for treatment of pathogenic infections, including tuberculosis (TB). These cyclic hydrophobic peptides have a unique bacterial target to the conventional anti-TB drugs, and present a therapeutic window to overcome Mycobacterium Tuberculosis (M. tb) drug resistance. ADEPs exerts their antibacterial activity on M. tb strains through activation of the protein homeostatic regulatory protease, the caseinolytic protease (ClpP1P2). ClpP1P2 is normally regulated and activated by the ClpP-ATPases to degrade misfolded and toxic peptides and/or short proteins. ADEPs bind and dysregulate all the homeostatic capabilities of ClpP1P2 while inducing non-selective proteolysis. The uncontrolled proteolysis leads to M. tb cell death within the host. ADEPs analogues that have been tested possess cytotoxicity and poor pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties. However, these can be improved by drug design techniques. Moreover, the use of nanomaterial in conjunction with ADEPs would yield effective synergistic effect. This new mode of action has potential to combat and eradicate the extensive multi-drug resistance (MDR) problem that is currently faced by the public health pertaining bacterial infections, especially TB.

Structural insights into ClpP protease side exit pore-opening by a pH drop coupled with substrate hydrolysis

The ClpP serine peptidase is a tetradecameric degradation molecular machine involved in many physiological processes. It becomes a competent ATP-dependent protease when coupled with Clp-ATPases. Small chemical compounds, acyldepsipeptides (ADEPs), are known to cause the dysregulation and activation of ClpP without ATPases and have potential as novel antibiotics. Previously, structural studies of ClpP from various species revealed its structural details, conformational changes, and activation mechanism. Although product release through side exit pores has been proposed, the detailed driving force for product release remains elusive. Herein, we report crystal structures of ClpP from Bacillus subtilis (BsClpP) in unforeseen ADEP-bound states. Cryo-electron microscopy structures of BsClpP revealed various conformational states under different pH conditions. To understand the conformational change required for product release, we investigated the relationship between substrate hydrolysis and the pH-lowering process. The production of hydrolyzed peptides from acidic and basic substrates by proteinase K and BsClpP lowered the pH values. Our data, together with those of previous findings, provide insight into the molecular mechanism of product release by the ClpP self-compartmentalizing protease.

Structure and function of ClpXP, a AAA+ proteolytic machine powered by probabilistic ATP hydrolysis

ClpXP is an archetypical AAA+ protease, consisting of ClpX and ClpP. ClpX is an ATP-dependent protein unfoldase and polypeptide translocase, whereas ClpP is a self-compartmentalized peptidase. ClpXP is currently the only AAA+ protease for which high-resolution structures exist, the molecular basis of recognition for a protein substrate is understood, extensive biochemical and genetic analysis have been performed, and single-molecule optical trapping has allowed direct visualization of the kinetics of substrate unfolding and translocation. In this review, we discuss our current understanding of ClpXP structure and function, evaluate competing sequential and probabilistic mechanisms of ATP hydrolysis, and highlight open questions for future exploration.

Recent structural insights into the mechanism of ClpP protease regulation by AAA+ chaperones and small molecules

ClpP is a highly conserved serine protease that is a critical enzyme in maintaining protein homeostasis and is an important drug target in pathogenic bacteria and various cancers. In its functional form, ClpP is a self-compartmentalizing protease composed of two stacked heptameric rings that allow protein degradation to occur within the catalytic chamber. ATPase chaperones such as ClpX and ClpA are hexameric ATPases that form larger complexes with ClpP and are responsible for the selection and unfolding of protein substrates prior to their degradation by ClpP. Although individual structures of ClpP and ATPase chaperones have offered mechanistic insights into their function and regulation, their structures together as a complex have only been recently determined to high resolution. Here, we discuss the cryoelectron microscopy structures of ClpP-ATPase complexes and describe findings previously inaccessible from individual Clp structures, including how a hexameric ATPase and a tetradecameric ClpP protease work together in a functional complex. We then discuss the consensus mechanism for substrate unfolding and translocation derived from these structures, consider alternative mechanisms, and present their strengths and limitations. Finally, new insights into the allosteric control of ClpP gained from studies using small molecules and gain or loss-of-function mutations are explored. Overall, this review aims to underscore the multilayered regulation of ClpP that may present novel ideas for structure-based drug design.

Clp protease and antisense RNA jointly regulate the global regulator CarD to mediate mycobacterial starvation response

Under starvation conditions, bacteria tend to slow down their translation rate by reducing rRNA synthesis, but the way they accomplish that may vary in different bacteria. In Mycobacterium species, transcription of rRNA is activated by the RNA polymerase (RNAP) accessory transcription factor CarD, which interacts directly with RNAP to stabilize the RNAP-promoter open complex formed on rRNA genes. The functions of CarD have been extensively studied, but the mechanisms that control its expression remain obscure. Here, we report that the level of CarD was tightly regulated when mycobacterial cells switched from nutrient-rich to nutrient-deprived conditions. At the translational level, an antisense RNA of carD (AscarD) was induced in a SigF-dependent manner to bind with carD mRNA and inhibit CarD translation, while at the post-translational level, the residual intracellular CarD was quickly degraded by the Clp protease. AscarD thus worked synergistically with Clp protease to decrease the CarD level to help mycobacterial cells cope with the nutritional stress. Altogether, our work elucidates the regulation mode of CarD and delineates a new mechanism for the mycobacterial starvation response, which is important for the adaptation and persistence of mycobacterial pathogens in the host environment.

Listeria monocytogenes utilizes the ClpP1/2 proteolytic machinery for fine-tuned substrate degradation at elevated temperatures

Listeria monocytogenes exhibits two ClpP isoforms (ClpP1/ClpP2) which assemble into a heterooligomeric complex with enhanced proteolytic activity. Herein, we demonstrate that the formation of this complex depends on temperature and reaches a maximum ratio of about 1 : 1 at 30 °C, while almost no complex formation occurred below 4 °C. In order to decipher the role of the two isoforms at elevated temperatures, we constructed L. monocytogenes ClpP1, ClpP2 and ClpP1/2 knockout strains and analyzed their protein regulation in comparison to the wild type (WT) strain via whole proteome mass-spectrometry (MS) at 37 °C and 42 °C. While the ΔclpP1 strain only altered the expression of very few proteins, the ΔclpP2 and ΔclpP1/2 strains revealed the dysregulation of many proteins at both temperatures. These effects were corroborated by crosslinking co-immunoprecipitation MS analysis. Thus, while ClpP1 serves as a mere enhancer of protein degradation in the heterocomplex, ClpP2 is essential for ClpX binding and functions as a gatekeeper for substrate entry. Applying an integrated proteomic approach combining whole proteome and co-immunoprecipitation datasets, several putative ClpP2 substrates were identified in the context of different temperatures and discussed with regards to their function in cellular pathways such as the SOS response.

Unlike most bacteria, L. monocytogenes encodes 2 isoforms of Caseinolytic Protease P. Balogh et al. show that both proteins form a heterocomplex temperature-dependently and find protein substrate candidates with an integrated proteomic approach.

Probing allosteric interactions in homo-oligomeric molecular machines using solution NMR spectroscopy

Developments in solution NMR spectroscopy have significantly impacted the biological questions that can now be addressed by this methodology. By means of illustration, we present here a perspective focusing on studies of a number of molecular machines that are critical for cellular homeostasis. The role of NMR in elucidating the structural dynamics of these important molecules is emphasized, focusing specifically on intersubunit allosteric communication in homo-oligomers. In many biophysical studies of oligomers, allostery is inferred by showing that models specifically including intersubunit communication best fit the data of interest. Ideally, however, experimental studies focusing on one subunit of a multisubunit system would be performed as an important complement to the more traditional bulk measurements in which signals from all components are measured simultaneously. Using an approach whereby asymmetric molecules are prepared in concert with NMR experiments focusing on the structural dynamics of individual protomers, we present examples of how intersubunit allostery can be directly observed in high-molecular-weight protein systems. These examples highlight some of the unique roles of solution NMR spectroscopy in studies of complex biomolecules and emphasize the important synergy between NMR and other atomic resolution biophysical methods.

Effect of Clp protease from Corynebacterium glutamicum on heterologous protein expression

The protease present in a host may reduce the yield and biological activity of heterologous proteins. In this study, we used protease overexpression and deletion strategies to examine the effect of the Clp protease system in Corynebacterium glutamicum on the recombinant protein and to produce a highly efficient heterologous protein expression host. In this study, we identified seven genes in the Clp protease family in Corynebacterium glutamicum ATCC 13032 through bioinformatics analysis, and studied their effects on the enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) reporter protein. The fluorescence intensity of the knockout strain was significantly higher, and the effect of the clpS deletion strain was the most obvious. To verify the universal effect of the lack of clpS, the excellent industrial strain C. glutamicum 1.15647 was transformed to form recombinant 15647-ΔclpS. Based on the results, 15647-ΔclpS had a more significant effect on improving protein expression. Furthermore, recombinant human teriparatide (rhPTH) and variable domain of heavy chain of heavy-chain antibody (VHH) were selected to verify the universal applicability of the knockout strain for expressing heterologous proteins. Accordingly, we found that protease deficiency could increase the production of heterologous proteins. Finally, through a large-scale fermentation, the 15647-ΔclpS strain was used to produce VHH. Its yield was approximately 530 mg/L, which was 65% higher than that of WT-15647. In this study, a host that could effectively increase heterologous protein expression was successfully obtained.

Acyldepsipeptide activated ClpP1P2 macromolecule of Leptospira, an ideal Achilles' heel to hamper the cell survival and deregulate ClpP proteolytic activity

Antibiotic acyldepsipeptide (ADEP) targets the bacterial ClpP serine protease and can inhibit the growth of numerous bacterial species by activating/dysregulating the protease activity within the cell. The spirochete Leptospira interrogans harbors two ClpP isoforms (LepClpP1 and LepClpP2). Supplementation of ADEP in the Leptospira growth medium resulted in the inhibition of bacterial growth. The ADEP mediated activation of the LepClpP mixture was dependent on the time allowed for the self-assembly of LepClpP1 and LepClpP2. The dynamic light scattering of the LepClpP mixture in the presence of the ADEP indicated a conformational transformation of the LepClpP machinery. Serine 98, a catalytic triad residue of the LepClpP1 in the LepClpP1P2 heterocomplex, was critical for the ADEP mediated activation. The computational prototype of the LepClpP1P2 structure suggested that the hydrophobic pockets wherein the ADEPs or the physiological chaperone ClpX predominantly dock are exclusively present in the LepClpP2 heptamer. Using the ADEP as a tool, this investigation provides an insight into the molecular function of the LepClpP1P2 in a coalition with its ATPase chaperone LepClpX. The shreds of the evidence illustrated in this investigation verify that ADEP1 possesses the ability to control the LepClpP system in an unconventional approach than the other organisms.

A pH-Dependent Conformational Switch Controls N. meningitidis ClpP Protease Function

ClpPs are a conserved family of serine proteases that collaborate with ATP-dependent translocases to degrade protein substrates. Drugs targeting these enzymes have attracted interest for the treatment of cancer and bacterial infections due to their critical role in mitochondrial and bacterial proteostasis, respectively. As such, there is significant interest in understanding structure-function relationships in this protein family. ClpPs are known to crystallize in extended, compact, and compressed forms; however, it is unclear what conditions favor the formation of each form and whether they are populated by wild-type enzymes in solution. Here, we use cryo-EM and solution NMR spectroscopy to demonstrate that a pH-dependent conformational switch controls an equilibrium between the active extended and inactive compressed forms of ClpP from the Gram-negative pathogen Neisseria meningitidis. Our findings provide insight into how ClpPs exploit their rugged energy landscapes to enable key conformational changes that regulate their function.

Structure of the N-terminal domain of ClpC1 in complex with the antituberculosis natural product ecumicin reveals unique binding interactions

The biological processes related to protein homeostasis in Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the etiologic agent of tuberculosis, have recently been established as critical pathways for therapeutic intervention. Proteins of particular interest are ClpC1 and the ClpC1-ClpP1-ClpP2 proteasome complex. The structure of the potent antituberculosis macrocyclic depsipeptide ecumicin complexed with the N-terminal domain of ClpC1 (ClpC1-NTD) is presented here. Crystals of the ClpC1-NTD-ecumicin complex were monoclinic (unit-cell parameters a = 80.0, b = 130.0, c = 112.0 Å, β = 90.07°; space group P2₁; 12 complexes per asymmetric unit) and diffracted to 2.5 Å resolution. The structure was solved by molecular replacement using the self-rotation function to resolve space-group ambiguities. The new structure of the ecumicin complex showed a unique 1:2 (target:ligand) stoichiometry exploiting the intramolecular dyad in the α-helical fold of the target N-terminal domain. The structure of the ecumicin complex unveiled extensive interactions in the uniquely extended N-terminus, a critical binding site for the known cyclopeptide complexes. This structure, in comparison with the previously reported rufomycin I complex, revealed unique features that could be relevant for understanding the mechanism of action of these potential antituberculosis drug leads. Comparison of the ecumicin complex and the ClpC1-NTD-L92S/L96P double-mutant structure with the available structures of rufomycin I and cyclomarin A complexes revealed a range of conformational changes available to this small N-terminal helical domain and the minor helical alterations involved in the antibiotic-resistance mechanism. The different modes of binding and structural alterations could be related to distinct modes of action.

The Bewildering Antitubercular Action of Pyrazinamide

Pyrazinamide (PZA) is a cornerstone antimicrobial drug used exclusively for the treatment of tuberculosis (TB). Due to its ability to shorten drug therapy by 3 months and reduce disease relapse rates, PZA is considered an irreplaceable component of standard first-line short-course therapy for drug-susceptible TB and second-line treatment regimens for multidrug-resistant TB. Despite over 60 years of research on PZA and its crucial role in current and future TB treatment regimens, the mode of action of this unique drug remains unclear. Defining the mode of action for PZA will open new avenues for rational design of novel therapeutic approaches for the treatment of TB. In this review, we discuss the four prevailing models for PZA action, recent developments in modulation of PZA susceptibility and resistance, and outlooks for future research and drug development.

An allosteric switch regulates Mycobacterium tuberculosis ClpP1P2 protease function as established by cryo-EM and methyl-TROSY NMR

The 300-kDa ClpP1P2 protease from Mycobacterium tuberculosis collaborates with the AAA+ (ATPases associated with a variety of cellular activities) unfoldases, ClpC1 and ClpX, to degrade substrate proteins. Unlike in other bacteria, all of the components of the Clp system are essential for growth and virulence of mycobacteria, and their inhibitors show promise as antibiotics. MtClpP1P2 is unique in that it contains a pair of distinct ClpP1 and ClpP2 rings and also requires the presence of activator peptides, such as benzoyl-leucyl-leucine (Bz-LL), for function. Understanding the structural basis for this requirement has been elusive but is critical for the rational design and improvement of antituberculosis (anti-TB) therapeutics that target the Clp system. Here, we present a combined biophysical and biochemical study to explore the structure-dynamics-function relationship in MtClpP1P2. Electron cryomicroscopy (cryo-EM) structures of apo and acyldepsipeptide-bound MtClpP1P2 explain their lack of activity by showing loss of a key β-sheet in a sequence known as the handle region that is critical for the proper formation of the catalytic triad. Methyl transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (TROSY)-based NMR, cryo-EM, and biochemical assays show that, on binding Bz-LL or covalent inhibitors, MtClpP1P2 undergoes a conformational change from an inactive compact state to an active extended structure that can be explained by a modified Monod-Wyman-Changeux model. Our study establishes a critical role for the handle region as an on/off switch for function and shows extensive allosteric interactions involving both intra- and interring communication that regulate MtClpP1P2 activity and that can potentially be exploited by small molecules to target M. tuberculosis.

A processive rotary mechanism couples substrate unfolding and proteolysis in the ClpXP degradation machinery

The ClpXP degradation machine consists of a hexameric AAA+ unfoldase (ClpX) and a pair of heptameric serine protease rings (ClpP) that unfold, translocate, and subsequently degrade client proteins. ClpXP is an important target for drug development against infectious diseases. Although structures are available for isolated ClpX and ClpP rings, it remains unknown how symmetry mismatched ClpX and ClpP work in tandem for processive substrate translocation into the ClpP proteolytic chamber. Here, we present cryo-EM structures of the substrate-bound ClpXP complex from Neisseria meningitidis at 2.3 to 3.3 Å resolution. The structures allow development of a model in which the sequential hydrolysis of ATP is coupled to motions of ClpX loops that lead to directional substrate translocation and ClpX rotation relative to ClpP. Our data add to the growing body of evidence that AAA+ molecular machines generate translocating forces by a common mechanism.

Mechanism of the allosteric activation of the ClpP protease machinery by substrates and active-site inhibitors

Coordinated conformational transitions in oligomeric enzymatic complexes modulate function in response to substrates and play a crucial role in enzyme inhibition and activation. Caseinolytic protease (ClpP) is a tetradecameric complex, which has emerged as a drug target against multiple pathogenic bacteria. Activation of different ClpPs by inhibitors has been independently reported from drug development efforts, but no rationale for inhibitor-induced activation has been hitherto proposed. Using an integrated approach that includes x-ray crystallography, solid- and solution-state nuclear magnetic resonance, molecular dynamics simulations, and isothermal titration calorimetry, we show that the proteasome inhibitor bortezomib binds to the ClpP active-site serine, mimicking a peptide substrate, and induces a concerted allosteric activation of the complex. The bortezomib-activated conformation also exhibits a higher affinity for its cognate unfoldase ClpX. We propose a universal allosteric mechanism, where substrate binding to a single subunit locks ClpP into an active conformation optimized for chaperone association and protein processive degradation.

Insights to the Assembly of a Functionally Active Leptospiral ClpP1P2 Protease Complex along with Its ATPase Chaperone ClpX

Leptospira interrogans genome is predicted to encode multiple isoforms of caseinolytic proteases (ClpP1 and ClpP2). The ClpP proteins with the aid of its ATPase chaperone are known to be involved in establishing cellular proteostasis and have emerged as a target for developing new antibiotics. We report the molecular characterization of recombinant ClpP1 (rClpP1) and rClpP2 of Leptospira along with its ATPase chaperone rClpX. The two isoforms of rClpPs when coupled together in an equivalent concentration exhibit optimum activity on small fluorogenic peptide substrates, whereas the pure rClpP isoforms are enzymatically inactive. Isothermal titration calorimetry analysis suggests that the two rClpP isoforms bind each other moderately in a 1:1 stoichiometry with a dissociation constant of 2.02 ± 0.1 μM at 37 °C and is thermodynamically favored. Size exclusion chromatography fractionates the majority of pure rClpP1 at ≥308 kDa (14-21-mer) and the pure rClpP2 at 308 kDa (tetradecamer), whereas the functionally active rClpP isoform mixture fractionates as a tetradecamer. The distinct and unprecedented oligomeric form of rClpP1 was also evident through native-gel and dynamic light scattering. Moreover, the rClpP isoform mixture formed after the site-directed mutation of either or both the isoforms at one of the catalytic triad residues (Ser 98/97 to Ala 98/97) resulted in the complete loss of protease activity. The rClpP isoform mixture gets stimulated to degrade the casein substrate in the presence of rClpX and in an energy-dependent manner. On the contrary, pure rClpP1 or the rClpP2 isoform in association with rClpX are incapable of forming operative protease. The reported finding suggests that in Leptospira, the enzymatic activity of the rClpP protease complex in the presence or absence of cochaperone is performed solely by the tetradecamer structure which is hypothesized to be composed of 2-stacked ClpP heptameric rings, wherein each ring is a homo-oligomer of ClpP1 and ClpP2 subunits. Understanding the activities and regulation principle of multi-isoforms of ClpP in pathogenic bacteria may aid in intervening disease outcomes particularly to the co-evolving antibiotic resistance strains.

Rufomycin Targets ClpC1 Proteolysis in Mycobacterium tuberculosis and M. abscessus

ClpC1 is an emerging new target for the treatment of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infections, and several cyclic peptides (ecumicin, cyclomarin A, and lassomycin) are known to act on this target. This study identified another group of peptides, the rufomycins (RUFs), as bactericidal to M. tuberculosis through the inhibition of ClpC1 and subsequent modulation of protein degradation of intracellular proteins.

ClpC1 is an emerging new target for the treatment of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infections, and several cyclic peptides (ecumicin, cyclomarin A, and lassomycin) are known to act on this target. This study identified another group of peptides, the rufomycins (RUFs), as bactericidal to M. tuberculosis through the inhibition of ClpC1 and subsequent modulation of protein degradation of intracellular proteins. Rufomycin I (RUFI) was found to be a potent and selective lead compound for both M. tuberculosis (MIC, 0.02 μM) and Mycobacterium abscessus (MIC, 0.4 μM). Spontaneously generated mutants resistant to RUFI involved seven unique single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) mutations at three distinct codons within the N-terminal domain of clpC1 (V13, H77, and F80). RUFI also significantly decreased the proteolytic capabilities of the ClpC1/P1/P2 complex to degrade casein, while having no significant effect on the ATPase activity of ClpC1. This represents a marked difference from ecumicin, which inhibits ClpC1 proteolysis but stimulates the ATPase activity, thereby providing evidence that although these peptides share ClpC1 as a macromolecular target, their downstream effects are distinct, likely due to differences in binding.

Clostridium difficile ClpP Homologues are Capable of Uncoupled Activity and Exhibit Different Levels of Susceptibility to Acyldepsipeptide Modulation

Caseinolytic protease P (ClpP) has emerged as a promising new target for antibacterial development. While ClpPs from single isoform expressing bacteria have been studied in detail, the function and regulation of systems with more than one ClpP homologue are still poorly understood. Herein, we present fundamental studies toward understanding the ClpP system in C. difficile, an anaerobic spore-forming pathogen that contains two chromosomally distant isoforms of ClpP. Examination of proteomic and genomic data suggest that ClpP1 is the primary isoform responsible for normal growth and virulence, but little is known about the function of ClpP2 or the context required for the formation of functional proteases. For the first time in a pathogenic bacterium, we demonstrate that both isoforms are capable of forming operative proteases. Interestingly, ClpP1 is the only homologue that possesses characteristic response to small molecule acyldepsipeptide activation. On the contrary, both ClpP1 and ClpP2 respond to cochaperone activation to degrade an ssrA-tagged substrate. These observations indicate that ClpP2 is less susceptible to acyldepsipeptide activation but retains the ability to interact with a known cochaperone. Homology models reveal no obvious characteristics that would allow one to predict less efficient acyldepsipeptide binding. The reported findings establish the uniqueness of the ClpP system in C. difficile, open new avenues of inquiry, and highlight the importance of more detailed structural, genetic, and biological characterization of the ClpP system in C. difficile.

Development of high throughput screening methods for inhibitors of ClpC1P1P2 from Mycobacteria tuberculosis

Tuberculosis affects about 100 million people worldwide and causes nearly 2 million deaths annually. It has been estimated that one third of all humans is infected with latent Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb). Moreover, Mtb has become increasingly resistant to available antibiotics. Consequently, it is important to identify and characterize new therapeutic targets in Mtb and to synthesize selective inhibitors. ClpP1, ClpP2 and their associated regulatory ATPases, ClpX and ClpC1 are required for the growth of Mtb and for its virulence during murine infection and are highly attractive drug targets, especially since they are not present in the cytosol of mammalian cells, and they differ markedly from the mitochondrial ClpP complex. The importance of these proteins in Mtb is emphasized by the existence of several natural antibiotics targeting this system. In order to find new inhibitors of ClpC1P1P2 system, we developed an assay based on the ATP-dependent degradation of a fluorescent protein substrate. The hits obtained were further characterized with a set of secondary assays to identify precise targets within a complex. A large library of compounds was screened and led to the identification of a ClpC1 ATPase inhibitor demonstrating that this approach can be used in future searches for anti-TB agents.

Reversible inhibition of the ClpP protease via an N-terminal conformational switch

Protein homeostasis is critically important for cell viability. Key to this process is the refolding of misfolded or aggregated proteins by molecular chaperones or, alternatively, their degradation by proteases. In most prokaryotes and in chloroplasts and mitochondria, protein degradation is performed by the caseinolytic protease ClpP, a tetradecamer barrel-like proteolytic complex. Dysregulating ClpP function has shown promise in fighting antibiotic resistance and as a potential therapy for acute myeloid leukemia. Here we use methyl-transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (TROSY)-based NMR, cryo-EM, biochemical assays, and molecular dynamics simulations to characterize the structural dynamics of ClpP from Staphylococcus aureus (SaClpP) in wild-type and mutant forms in an effort to discover conformational hotspots that regulate its function. Wild-type SaClpP was found exclusively in the active extended form, with the N-terminal domains of its component protomers in predominantly β-hairpin conformations that are less well-defined than other regions of the protein. A hydrophobic site was identified that, upon mutation, leads to unfolding of the N-terminal domains, loss of SaClpP activity, and formation of a previously unobserved split-ring conformation with a pair of 20-Å-wide pores in the side of the complex. The extended form of the structure and partial activity can be restored via binding of ADEP small-molecule activators. The observed structural plasticity of the N-terminal gates is shown to be a conserved feature through studies of Escherichia coli and Neisseria meningitidis ClpP, suggesting a potential avenue for the development of molecules to allosterically modulate the function of ClpP.

AAA+ Machines of Protein Destruction in Mycobacteria

The bacterial cytosol is a complex mixture of macromolecules (proteins, DNA, and RNA), which collectively are responsible for an enormous array of cellular tasks. Proteins are central to most, if not all, of these tasks and as such their maintenance (commonly referred to as protein homeostasis or proteostasis) is vital for cell survival during normal and stressful conditions. The two key aspects of protein homeostasis are, (i) the correct folding and assembly of proteins (coupled with their delivery to the correct cellular location) and (ii) the timely removal of unwanted or damaged proteins from the cell, which are performed by molecular chaperones and proteases, respectively. A major class of proteins that contribute to both of these tasks are the AAA+ (ATPases associated with a variety of cellular activities) protein superfamily. Although much is known about the structure of these machines and how they function in the model Gram-negative bacterium Escherichia coli, we are only just beginning to discover the molecular details of these machines and how they function in mycobacteria. Here we review the different AAA+ machines, that contribute to proteostasis in mycobacteria. Primarily we will focus on the recent advances in the structure and function of AAA+ proteases, the substrates they recognize and the cellular pathways they control. Finally, we will discuss the recent developments related to these machines as novel drug targets.

Towards Selective Mycobacterial ClpP1P2 Inhibitors with Reduced Activity against the Human Proteasome

Mycobacterium tuberculosis is responsible for the greatest number of deaths worldwide due to a bacterial agent. We recently identified bortezomib (Velcade; compound 1) as a promising antituberculosis (anti-TB) compound. We showed that compound 1 inhibits the mycobacterial caseinolytic proteases P1 and P2 (ClpP1P2) and exhibits bactericidal activity, and we established compound 1 and ClpP1P2 as an attractive lead/target couple. However, compound 1 is a human-proteasome inhibitor currently approved for cancer therapy and, as such, exhibits significant toxicity. Selective inhibition of the bacterial protease over the human proteasome is desirable in order to maintain antibacterial activity while reducing toxicity. We made use of structural data in order to design a series of dipeptidyl-boronate derivatives of compound 1. We tested these derivatives for whole-cell ClpP1P2 and human-proteasome inhibition as well as bacterial-growth inhibition and identified compounds that were up to 100-fold-less active against the human proteasome but that retained ClpP1P2 and mycobacterial-growth inhibition as well as bactericidal potency. The lead compound, compound 58, had low micromolar ClpP1P2 and anti-M. tuberculosis activity, good aqueous solubility, no cytochrome P450 liabilities, moderate plasma protein binding, and low toxicity in two human liver cell lines, and despite high clearance in microsomes, this compound was only moderately cleared when administered intravenously or orally to mice. Higher-dose oral pharmacokinetics indicated good dose linearity. Furthermore, compound 58 was inhibitory to only 11% of a panel of 62 proteases. Our work suggests that selectivity over the human proteasome can be achieved with a drug-like template while retaining potency against ClpP1P2 and, crucially, anti-M. tuberculosis activity.

Insights into ClpXP proteolysis: heterooligomerization and partial deactivation enhance chaperone affinity and substrate turnover in Listeria monocytogenes

Caseinolytic proteases (ClpP) are important for recognition and controlled degradation of damaged proteins. While the majority of bacterial organisms utilize only a single ClpP, Listeria monocytogenes expresses two isoforms (LmClpP1 and LmClpP2). LmClpPs assemble into either a LmClpP2 homocomplex or a LmClpP1/2 heterooligomeric complex. The heterocomplex in association with the chaperone ClpX, exhibits a boost in proteolytic activity for unknown reasons. Here, we use a combined chemical and biochemical strategy to unravel two activation principles of LmClpPs. First, determination of apparent affinity constants revealed a 7-fold elevated binding affinity between the LmClpP1/2 heterocomplex and ClpX, compared to homooligomeric LmClpP2. This tighter interaction favors the formation of the proteolytically active complex between LmClpX and LmClpP1/2 and thereby accelerating the overall turnover. Second, screening a diverse library of fluorescent labeled peptides and proteins with various ClpP mutants allowed the individual analysis of substrate preferences for both isoforms within the heterocomplex. In addition to Leu and Met, LmClpP2 preferred a long aliphatic chain (2-Aoc) in the P1 position for cleavage. Strikingly, design and synthesis of a corresponding 2-Aoc chloromethyl ketone inhibitor resulted in stimulation of proteolysis by 160% when LmClpP2 was partially alkylated on 20% of the active sites. Determination of apparent affinity constants also revealed an elevated complex stability between partially modified LmClpP2 and the cognate chaperone LmClpX. Thus, the stimulation of proteolysis through enhanced binding to the chaperone seems to be a characteristic feature of LmClpPs.

Two ways to skin a cat: acyldepsipeptides antibiotics can kill bacteria through activation or inhibition of ClpP activity

Infection by Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) has had a devastating effect on the world population. Acyldepsipeptide antibiotics (ADEPs) are known to kill some bacteria by over activating the bacterial ClpP peptidase. ADEP antibiotics also target Mtb, with the assumption that uncontrolled ADEP-activated proteolysis by ClpP is the common mode of killing. In this issue of Molecular Microbiology, Famulla, et al. now show that ADEP's effectiveness in mycobacteria is likely due to inhibition of ClpP-dependent protease activity rather than activation. This finding of how the same antibiotic can kill bacteria by either inhibiting or activating proteases illustrates the utility of targeting these enzymes for sorely needed new antibiotics.

Acyldepsipeptide antibiotics kill mycobacteria by preventing the physiological functions of the ClpP1P2 protease

The Clp protease complex in Mycobacterium tuberculosis is unusual in its composition, functional importance and activation mechanism. Whilst most bacterial species contain a single ClpP protein that is dispensable for normal growth, mycobacteria have two ClpPs, ClpP1 and ClpP2, which are essential for viability and together form the ClpP1P2 tetradecamer. Acyldepsipeptide antibiotics of the ADEP class inhibit the growth of Gram-positive firmicutes by activating ClpP and causing unregulated protein degradation. Here we show that, in contrast, mycobacteria are killed by ADEP through inhibition of ClpP function. Although ADEPs can stimulate purified M. tuberculosis ClpP1P2 to degrade larger peptides and unstructured proteins, this effect is weaker than for ClpP from other bacteria and depends on the presence of an additional activating factor (e.g. the dipeptide benzyloxycarbonyl-leucyl-leucine in vitro) to form the active ClpP1P2 tetradecamer. The cell division protein FtsZ, which is a particularly sensitive target for ADEP-activated ClpP in firmicutes, is not degraded in mycobacteria. Depletion of the ClpP1P2 level in a conditional Mycobacterium bovis BCG mutant enhanced killing by ADEP unlike in other bacteria. In summary, ADEPs kill mycobacteria by preventing interaction of ClpP1P2 with the regulatory ATPases, ClpX or ClpC1, thus inhibiting essential ATP-dependent protein degradation.