Comparative trajectories of active and S195A inactive trypsin upon binding to serpins

Thermolysin damages animal life through degradation of plasma proteins enhanced by rapid cleavage of serpins and activation of proteases

Thermolysin, a metallopeptidase secreted by pathogenic microbes, is concluded as an important virulence factor due to cleaving purified host proteins in vitro. Using the silkworm Bombyx mori as a model system, we found that thermolysin injection into larvae induces the destruction of the coagulation response and the activation of hemolymph melanization, which results in larval death. Thermolysin triggers the rapid degradation of insect and mammalian plasma proteins at a level that is considerably greater than expected in vitro and/or in vivo. To more specifically explore the mechanism, thermolysin-induced changes to key proteins belonging to the insect melanization pathway were assessed as a window for observing plasma protein cleavage. The application of thermolysin induced the rapid cleavage of the melanization negative regulator serpin-3, but did not directly activate the melanization rate-limiting enzyme prophenoloxidase (PPO) or the terminal serine proteases responsible for PPO activation. Terminal serine proteases of melanization are activated indirectly after thermolysin exposure. We hypothesize that thermolysin induces the rapid degradation of serpins and the activation of proteases directly or indirectly, boosting uncontrolled plasma protein degradation in insects and mammalians.

Determining serpin conformational distributions with single molecule fluorescence

Conformational plasticity is key to inhibitory serpin function, and this plasticity gives serpins relatively easy access to alternative, dysfunctional conformations. Thus, a given serpin population may contain both functional and dysfunctional proteins. Single molecule fluorescence (SMF), with its ability to interrogate one fluorescently labeled protein at a time, is a powerful method for elucidating conformational distributions and monitoring how these distributions change over time. SMF and related methods have been particularly valuable for characterizing serpin polymerization. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy experiments have revealed a second lag phase during in vitro α(1)-antitrypsin polymerization associated with the formation of smaller oligomers that then condense to form longer polymers [Purkayastha, P., Klemke, J. W., Lavender, S., Oyola, R., Cooperman, B. S., and Gai, F. (2005). Alpha 1-antitrypsin polymerization: A fluorescence correlation spectroscopic study. Biochemistry44, 2642-2649.]. SMF studies of in vitro neuroserpin polymerization have confirmed that a monomeric intermediate is required for polymer formation while providing a test of proposed polymerization mechanisms [Chiou, A., Hägglöf, P., Orte, A., Chen, A. Y., Dunne, P. D., Belorgey, D., Karlsson-Li, S., Lomas, D., and Klenerman, D. (2009). Probing neuroserpin polymerization and interaction with amyloid-beta peptides using single molecule fluorescence. Biophys. J.97, 2306-2315.]. SMF has also been used to monitor protease-serpin interactions. Single pair Förster resonance energy transfer studies of covalent protease-serpin complexes suggest that the extent of protease structural disruption in the complex is protease dependent [Liu, L., Mushero, N., Hedstrom, L., and Gershenson, A. (2006). Conformational distributions of protease-serpin complexes: A partially translocated complex. Biochemistry45, 10865-10872.]. SMF techniques are still evolving and the combination of SMF with encapsulation methods has the potential to provide more detailed information on the conformational changes associated with serpin polymerization, protease-serpin complex formation, and serpin folding.

Short-lived protease serpin complexes: partial disruption of the rat trypsin active site

Serpins inhibit serine proteases by mechanically disrupting the protease active site. The protease first reacts with the serpin's reactive center loop (RCL) to form an acylenzyme. Then the RCL inserts into a beta-sheet in the body of the serpin, translocating the attached protease approximately 70 A and deforming the protease active site, thereby trapping the acylenzyme. Loop insertion (approximately 1 s(-1)) is an order of magnitude slower than hydrolysis of a typical substrate acylenzyme (approximately 50 s(-1)), indicating that the protease is inhibited during translocation. We have previously trapped a partially translocated covalent complex of rat trypsin and alpha1-proteinase inhibitor (EpartI*) resulting from attractive interactions between cationic dyes and anionic rat trypsin. Here, using single pair Förster resonance energy transfer, we demonstrate that EpartI* is a metastable complex that can dissociate to free protease and cleaved serpin (I*) as well as convert to the canonical fully translocated complex EfullI*. The partitioning between these two pathways is pH dependent, with conversion favored at low pH and dissociation favored at high pH. The short lifetime of EpartI* (approximately 3 h at pH 7.4) and the pH dependence of EpartI* dissociation suggest that, unlike in EfullI*, the catalytic triad is intact in EpartI*. These results also demonstrate that interactions between target proteases and the body of the serpin can hinder protease translocation leading to short-lived covalent complexes.

Reversible inactivation of serpins at acidic pH

The inhibitory activity of the serpins alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor, alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin, alpha(2)-antiplasmin, antithrombin and C(1)-esterase inactivator is rapidly lost at pH 3 but slowly recovers at pH 7.4 with variable first-order rates (t(1/2)=1.4-19.2 min). All except alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin undergo a variation in intrinsic fluorescence intensity upon acidification (midpoint ca. 4.5) with a slow bi-exponential return to the initial intensity at pH 7.4 (mean t(1/2)=2.3-23 min). No correlation was found between the time of fluorescence recovery and that of reactivation. The acid-treated serpins are proteolyzed at neutral pH by their target proteinases. alpha(1)-Proteinase inhibitor was studied in more detail. Its acidification at pH 3 has a mild effect on its secondary structure, strongly disorders its tertiary structure, changes the microenvironment of Cys(232) and causes a very fast change in ellipticity at 225 nm (t(1/2)=1.6s). Neutralization of the acid-treated alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor is an exothermic phenomenon. It leads to a much faster recovery of activity (t(1/2)=4+/-1 min) than of fluorescence intensity (t(1/2)=23+/-19 min), ellipticity (t(1/2)=32+/-4 min) and change in total energy, indicating that the inhibitory activity of alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor does not require a fully native structure.

Conformational distributions of protease-serpin complexes: a partially translocated complex

Serpins regulate serine proteases by forming metastable covalent complexes with their targets. The protease docks with the serpin and cleaves the serpin's reactive center loop (RCL) forming an acylenzyme intermediate. Cleavage triggers insertion of the RCL into beta sheet A, translocating the attached protease approximately 70 A and disrupting the protease active site, trapping the acylenzyme intermediate. Using single-pair Förster resonance energy transfer (spFRET), we have measured the conformational distributions of trypsin and alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor (alpha(1)PI) covalent complexes. Bovine trypsin (BTryp) complexes display a single set of conformations consistent with the full translocation of BTryp (E(full)I*). However, the range of spFRET efficiencies is large, suggesting that the region around the trypsin label is mobile. Most complexes between alpha(1)PI variants and the more stable rat trypsin (RTryp) also show a single set of conformations, but the conformational distribution is narrower, indicating less disruption of RTryp. Surprisingly, RTryp complexes containing alpha(1)PI labeled at Cys232 with a cationic fluorophore display two equally populated conformations, E(full)I* and a conformation in which RTryp is only partially translocated (E(part)I*). Destabilizing the RTryp active site, by substituting Ala for Ile16, increases the E(full)I* population. Thus, interactions between anionic RTryp and cationic dyes likely exert a restraining force on alpha(1)PI, increasing the energy needed to translocate trypsin, and this force can be counteracted by active site destabilization. These results highlight the role of protease stability in determining the conformational distributions of protease-serpin covalent complexes and show that full translocation is not required for the formation of metastable complexes.

The conversion of active to latent plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 is an energetically silent event

PAI-1 is a proteinase inhibitor, which plays a key role in the regulation of fibrinolysis. It belongs to the serpins, a family of proteins that behave either as proteinase inhibitors or proteinase substrates, both reactions involving limited proteolysis of the reactive center loop and insertion of part of this loop into beta-sheet A. Titration calorimetry shows that the inhibition of tissue-type plasminogen and pancreatic trypsin are exothermic reactions with DeltaH = -20.3, and -22.5 kcal.mol(-1), respectively. The Pseudomonas aeruginosa elastase-catalyzed reactive center loop cleavage and inactivation of the inhibitor is also exothermic (DeltaH = -38.9 kcal.mol(-1)). The bacterial elastase also hydrolyses peptide-bound PAI-1 in which acetyl-TVASSSTA, the octapeptide corresponding to the P(14)-P(7) sequence of the reactive center loop is inserted into beta-sheet A of the serpin with DeltaH = -4.0 kcal.mol(-1). In contrast, DeltaH = 0 for the spontaneous conversion of the metastable active PAI-1 molecule into its thermodynamically stable inactive (latent) conformer although this conversion also involves loop/sheet insertion. We conclude that the active to latent transition of PAI-1 is an entirely entropy-driven phenomenon.

Binding of nonphysiological protein and peptide substrates to proteases: differences between urokinase-type plasminogen activator and trypsin and contributions to the evolution of regulated proteolysis

Understanding the regulation of physiological processes requires detailed knowledge of the recognition of substrates by enzymes. One of the most productive model systems for the study of enzyme-substrate interactions is the serine protease family; however, most studies of protease action have used small substrates that contain an activated, non-natural scissile bond. Because few kinetic or structural studies have used protein substrates, the physiologically relevant target of most proteases, it seems likely that important mechanisms of substrate recognition and processing by proteases have not yet been fully elucidated. Consistent with this hypothesis, we have observed that K(m) values for protein substrates are reduced as much as 200-15000-fold relative to those of analogous peptide substrates. Here we examine the thermodynamic consequences of interactions between proteases and their substrates using staphylococcal nuclease (SNase) and SNase variants as model protein substrates. We have obtained values for enthalpy, entropy, and K(d) for binding of proteins and peptides by the nonspecific protease trypsin and the highly specific protease urokinase-type plasminogen activator (u-PA). To avoid cleavage of substrates during these measurements, we used inactive variants of trypsin and u-PA whose catalytic serine S195 had been replaced by alanine. Differences in the K(d) values for binding of protein and peptide substrates closely approximate the large differences observed in the corresponding K(m) values. Improved binding of protein substrates is due to decreased enthalpy, and this effect is pronounced for the selective protease u-PA. Fundamental differences in recognition of analogous protein and peptide substrates may have influenced the evolution of protease specificity.