Exploring the effects of active site constraints on HIV-1 reverse transcriptase DNA polymerase fidelity

HIV-1 reverse transcriptase inhibitors: beyond classic nucleosides and non-nucleosides

Reverse transcriptase (RT) of HIV-1 remains an important target in current treatments of HIV-1 infection. Clinically available inhibitors of HIV-1 RT include nucleoside analog RT inhibitors and non-nucleoside RT inhibitors. Nucleoside analog RT inhibitors compete with the natural dNTP substrate and act as chain terminators, while non-nucleoside RT inhibitors bind to an allosteric pocket, inhibiting polymerization noncompetitively. In addition to these two classes of approved drugs, there are a number of RT inhibitors that target the enzyme in different ways. These include nonobligate chain terminators, nucleotide-competing RT inhibitors, pyrophosphate analogs and compounds that inhibit the RT-associated RNase H activity. Here, we review the mechanisms of action associated with these compounds and discuss opportunities and challenges in drug discovery and development efforts.

Steric constraints dependent on nucleobase pair orientation vary in different DNA polymerase active sites

Finding the right fit: Herein, we report on the development of novel steric probes and present initial insights into their interplay with DNA polymerases. Our findings provide experimental evidence for varied enzyme-substrate interactions that might account for the varied selectivity previously observed.

HIV-1 nucleocapsid traps reverse transcriptase on nucleic acid substrates

Conversion of the genomic RNA of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) into full-length viral DNA is a complex multistep reaction catalyzed by the reverse transcriptase (RT). Numerous studies have shown that the viral nucleocapsid (NC) protein has a vital impact on various steps during reverse transcription, which is crucial for virus infection. However, the exact molecular details are poorly defined. Here, we analyzed the effect of NC on RT-catalyzed single-turnover, single-nucleotide incorporation using different nucleic acid substrates. In the presence of NC, we observed an increase in the amplitude of primer extension of up to 3-fold, whereas the transient rate of nucleotide incorporation ( k pol) dropped by up to 50-fold. To unravel the underlying molecular mechanism, we carefully analyzed the effect of NC on RT-nucleic acid substrate dissociation. The studies revealed that NC considerably enhances the stability of RT-substrate complexes by reducing the observed dissociation rate constants, which more than compensates for the observed drop in k pol. In conclusion, our data strongly support the concept that NC not only indirectly assists the reverse transcription process by its nucleic acid chaperoning activity but also positively affects the RT-catalyzed nucleotide incorporation reaction by increasing polymerase processivity presumably via a physical interaction of the two viral proteins.

Varied active-site constraints in the klenow fragment of E. coli DNA polymerase I and the lesion-bypass Dbh DNA polymerase

We report on comparative pre-steady-state kinetic analyses of exonuclease-deficient Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment, KF-) and the archaeal Y-family DinB homologue (Dbh) of Sulfolobus solfataricus. We used size-augmented sugar-modified thymidine-5'-triphosphate (T(R)TP) analogues to test the effects of steric constraints in the active sites of the polymerases. These nucleotides serve as models for study of DNA polymerases exhibiting both relatively high and low intrinsic selectivity. Substitution of a hydrogen atom at the 4'-position in the nucleotide analogue by a methyl group reduces the maximum rate of nucleotide incorporation by about 40-fold for KF- and about twelve fold for Dbh. Increasing the size to an ethyl group leads to a further twofold reduction in the rates of incorporation for both enzymes. Interestingly, the affinity of KF- for the modified nucleotides is only marginally affected, which would indicate no discrimination during the binding step. Dbh even has a higher affinity for the modified analogues than it does for the natural substrate. Misincorporation of either TTP or T(Me)TP opposite a G template causes a drastic decline in incorporation rates for both enzymes. At the same time, the binding affinities of KF- for these nucleotides drop by about 16- and fourfold, respectively, whereas Dbh shows only a twofold reduction. Available structural data for ternary complexes of relevant DNA polymerases indicate that both enzymes make close contacts with the sugar moiety of the dNTP. Thus, the varied proficiencies of the two enzymes in processing the size-augmented probes indicate varied flexibility of the enzymes' active sites and support the notion of active site tightness being a criterion for DNA polymerase selectivity.

Opposed steric constraints in human DNA polymerase beta and E. coli DNA polymerase I

DNA polymerase selectivity is crucial for the survival of any living species, yet varies significantly among different DNA polymerases. Errors within DNA polymerase-catalyzed DNA synthesis result from the insertion of noncanonical nucleotides and extension of misaligned DNA substrates. The substrate binding characteristics among DNA polymerases are believed to vary in properties such as shape and tightness of the binding pocket, which might account for the observed differences in fidelity. Here, we employed 4'-alkylated nucleotides and primer strands bearing 4'-alkylated nucleotides at the 3'-terminal position as steric probes to investigate differential active site properties of human DNA polymerase beta (Pol beta) and the 3'-->5'-exonuclease-deficient Klenow fragment of E. coli DNA polymerase I (KF(exo-)). Transient kinetic measurements indicate that both enzymes vary significantly in active site tightness at both positions. While small 4'-methyl and -ethyl modifications of the nucleoside triphosphate perturb Pol beta catalysis, extension of modified primer strands is only marginally affected. Just the opposite was observed for KF(exo-). Here, incorporation of the modified nucleotides is only slightly reduced, whereas size augmentation of the 3'-terminal nucleotide in the primer reduces the catalytic efficiency by more than 7000- and 260,000-fold, respectively. NMR studies support the notion that the observed effects derive from enzyme substrate interactions rather than inherent properties of the modified substrates. These findings are consistent with the observed differential capability of the investigated DNA polymerases in fidelity such as processing misaligned DNA substrates. The results presented provide direct evidence for the involvement of varied steric effects among different DNA polymerases on their fidelity.

Gln151 of HIV-1 Reverse Transcriptase Acts as a Steric Gate Towards Clinically Relevant Acyclic Phosphonate Nucleotide Analogues

Background

In the treatment of HIV, the loose active site of the HIV-1 reverse transcriptase (RT) allows numerous nucleotide analogues to act as proviral DNA ‘chain-terminators’. Acyclic nucleotide phosphonate analogues (ANPs) represent a particular class of nucleotide analogue that does not possess a ribose moiety. The structural basis for their substrate efficiency regarding viral DNA polymerases is poorly understood.

Methods

Pre-steady-state kinetics on HIV-1 RT together with molecular modelling, were used to evaluate the relative characteristics of both the initial binding and incorporation into DNA of three different ANP diphosphates with progressively increasing steric demands on the acyclic linker: adefovir-diphosphate (DP), tenofovir-DP, and cidofovir-DP.

Results

The increase of steric demand in ANPs induced a proportional loss of the binding affinity to wild-type HIV-1 RT ( K d cidofovir-D P>> K d tenofovir-D P> K d adefovir-DP∼ K d dNTPs), consistent with the lack of HIV-1 inhibitory activity for cidofovir. We show that, starting from adefovir-DP, the steric constraints mainly map to Gln151, as its mutation to alanine provides cidofovir-DP sensitivity. Interactions between the Gln151 residue and the methyl group of tenofovir-DP further increase with the mutation Gln151Met, resulting in a specific discrimination and low-level resistance to tenofovir-DP. This alteration is the result of a dual decrease in the binding affinity ( K d) and the catalytic rate ( k pol) of incorporation of tenofovir-DP. By contrast, the tenofovir resistance mutation K65R induces a broad ‘ k pol-dependent’ nonspecific discrimination towards the three ANPs.

Conclusions

Overall, our results show that the efficiency of ANPs to compete against natural nucleotides as substrates for RT is determined by their close interaction with specific amino acids such as Gln151 within the RT active site. These results should help us to map and predict ANP sensitivity determinants in cellular and viral DNA polymerase active sites for which the understanding of different ANP sensitivity patterns are of medical importance.

In vitro fidelity of the prototype primate foamy virus (PFV) RT compared to HIV-1 RT

We compared the in vitro fidelity of wild-type human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase (RT) and the prototype foamy virus (PFV) RT. Both enzymes had similar error rates for single nucleotide substitutions; however, PFV RT did not appear to make errors at specific hotspots, like HIV-1 RT. In addition, PFV RT made more deletions and insertions than HIV-1 RT. Although the majority of the missense errors made by HIV-1 RT and PFV RT are different, relatively few of the mutations caused by either enzyme can be explained by a misalignment/slippage mechanism. We suggest that the higher polymerase activity of PFV RT could contribute to the ability of the enzyme to jump to the same or a different template.

Stepping statistics of single HIV-1 reverse transcriptase molecules during DNA polymerization

DNA polymerases are protein machines that processively incorporate complimentary nucleotides into a growing double-stranded DNA (ds-DNA). Single-base nucleotide incorporation rates have been determined by stalling and restarting various polymerases, but intrinsic processive rates have been difficult to obtain, particularly for polymerases with low processivity, such as the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase (HIV RT) polymerase. Here we find, using a new fluorescence-based single-molecule polymerization assay, that the intrinsic processive DNA-dependent polymerization of HIV RT is approximately Poissionian (i.e. each nucleotide is added sequentially) with a rate of about 100 bases per second at 21 degrees C. From the same experiments, based on the stepping statistics of polymerization, we also estimate the rates for HIV RT early termination and final release of completely replicated primer-template DNA. In addition, by measuring the rate of polymerization as a function of temperature, we have estimated the activation energy for processive nucleotide incorporation.

Pre-steady-state kinetic characterization of the DinB homologue DNA polymerase of Sulfolobus solfataricus

Equilibrium as well as pre-steady-state measurements were performed to characterize the molecular basis of DNA binding and nucleotide incorporation by the thermostable archaeal DinB homologue (Dbh) DNA polymerase of Sulfolobus solfataricus. Equilibrium titrations show a DNA binding affinity of about 60 nm, which is approximately 10-fold lower compared with other DNA polymerases. Investigations of the binding kinetics applying stopped-flow and pressure jump techniques confirm this weak binding affinity. Furthermore, these measurements suggest that the DNA binding occurs in a single step, diffusion-controlled manner. Single-turnover, single dNTP incorporation studies reveal maximal pre-steady-state burst rates of 0.64, 2.5, 3.7, and 5.6 s(-1) for dTTP, dATP, dGTP, and dCTP (at 25 degrees C), which is 10-100-fold slower than the corresponding rates of classical DNA polymerases. Another unique feature of the Dbh is the very low nucleotide binding affinity (K(d) approximately 600 mum), which again is 10-20-fold lower compared with classical DNA polymerases as well as other Y-family polymerases. Surprisingly, the rate-limiting step of nucleotide incorporation (correct and incorrect) is the chemical step (phosphoryl transfer) and not a conformational change of the enzyme. Thus, unlike replicative polymerases, an "induced fit" mechanism to select and incorporate nucleotides during DNA polymerization could not be detected for Dbh.

Incorporation of non-nucleoside triphosphate analogues opposite to an abasic site by human DNA polymerases beta and lambda

A novel class of non-nucleoside triphosphate analogues, bearing hydrophobic groups sterically similar to nucleosides linked to the alpha-phosphate but lacking the chemical functional groups of nucleic acids, were tested against six different DNA polymerases (polymerases). Human polymerases alpha, beta and lambda, and Saccharomyces cerevisiae polymerase IV, were inhibited with different potencies by these analogues. On the contrary, Escherichia coli polymerase I and HIV-1 reverse transcriptase were not. Polymerase beta incorporated these derivatives in a strictly Mn++-dependent manner. On the other hand, polymerase lambda could incorporate some alkyltriphosphate derivatives with both Mg++ and Mn++, but only opposite to an abasic site on the template strand. The active site mutant polymerase lambda Y505A showed an increased ability to incorporate the analogues. These results show for the first time that neither the base nor the sugar moieties of nucleotides are required for incorporation by family X DNA polymerases.

4'C-ethynyl-thymidine acts as a chain terminator during DNA-synthesis catalyzed by HIV-1 reverse transcriptase

Recently, 4'C-ethynyl nucleoside analogues have been identified as highly potent agents against HIV-1, including several multidrug-resistant strains. In contrast to most known nucleoside inhibitors 4'C-ethynyl nucleoside analogues possess a 3'-hydroxyl function. Here we show that the 5'O-triphosphate of 4'C-ethynyl thymidine gets readily incorporated into a nascent DNA strand by HIV-1 reverse transcriptase and significantly inhibits further post-incorporation chain extension by the enzyme.

Expanded-size bases in naturally sized DNA: evaluation of steric effects in Watson-Crick pairing

We describe physicochemical properties in DNA of altered-size nucleobases that retain Watson-Crick analogous hydrogen-bonding ability. Size-expanded analogues of adenine and thymine (xA and xT, respectively, which are expanded by benzo-fusion) were incorporated into natural DNA oligonucleotides, and their effects on helix stability were measured. Base stacking studies revealed that the two stretched analogues stack much more strongly than do their naturally sized counterparts. In contrast to this, pairing studies showed that single substitutions of the new bases are destabilizing to the natural helix as compared to A or T in standard A-T pairs in the same context, unless multiple adjacent substitutions are used. Interestingly, the size-expanded bases displayed selective recognition of the hydrogen-bonding complementary partners, suggesting that Watson-Crick analogous pairs were still formed despite local backbone strain. In an attempt to compensate for the added size of the expanded adenine, we tested a formamide deoxynucleoside, which Leonard proposed as a shortened thymine analogue (F(o)). Data showed, however, that this compound adopts a conformation unfavorable for pairing. On the basis of the combined thermodynamic data, we estimate the energetic cost of the 2.4 A stretching of an isolated base pair in DNA at ca. +1 to 2 kcal/mol. Notably, during the pairing studies, the two size-expanded nucleobases were found to display significant changes in fluorescence on formation of stacked versus unstacked structures, suggesting possible applications in probing nucleic acid structures and biochemical mechanisms.

Convenient synthesis of nucleoside borane diphosphate analogues: deoxy- and ribonucleoside 5'-P(alpha)-boranodiphosphates

The nucleoside boranophosphates, having one of the nonbridging phosphate oxygens substituted with a borane (BH(3)) group, have shown potential therapeutical applications as aptamers, antisense agents, and antiviral prodrugs. An oxathiaphospholane approach, which does not require exocyclic amine protection of the nucleobase, has been successfully developed to efficiently synthesize 5'-P(alpha)-boranodiphosphates of 2'-deoxythymidine, adenosine, guanosine, and uridine. The approach involves a key intermediate, the borane complex of nucleoside 5'-O-1,3,2-oxathiaphospholane 16, that undergoes a ring-opening reaction catalyzed by 1,4-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]-undec-7-ene to form the protected nucleoside 5'-P(alpha)-boranodiphosphate 18. Treatment of 18 with ammonium hydroxide yielded diastereoisomeric mixtures of nucleoside 5'-P(alpha)-boranodiphosphates 5. This oxathiaphospholane approach ensures the availability of nucleoside 5'-P(alpha)-boranodiphosphate analogues needed for antiviral drug research.

Increased single-nucleotide discrimination of PCR by primer probes bearing hydrophobic 4'C modifications

We report on significantly increased selectivity of real-time PCR through employment of primer probes that bear hydrophobic 4'C modifications at the 3'-terminal nucleotide. The primer probes were designed to bind the target sequences in such a way that the 3'-terminal nucleotide defines whether a matched or a single mismatched basepair is present depending on the respective target sequence. Several commercially available thermostable DNA polymerases belonging to different DNA polymerase families were tested for their efficacy in discriminating between PCR amplification of matched substrates and duplexes that contain a single mismatch. It turned out that, depending on the 4'C modification and the employed DNA polymerase, significantly increased differentiation between single matches and mismatches could be observed with real-time PCR. The degrees of the observed effects varied with the employed 4'C modification and the sequence context studied. The system is robust enough to work faithfully under several buffer conditions. Our approach should be useful for the direct diagnosis of single nucleotide variations within genes, like single nucleotide polymorphisms or mutations, by PCR without the need for further time- and cost-intensive post-PCR analysis.