The modified Q-cycle explains the apparent mismatch between the kinetics of reduction of cytochromes c1 and bH in the bc1 complex

Respiratory Complex III: A Bioengine with a Ligand-Triggered Electron-Tunneling Gating Mechanism

Respiratory complex III (a.k.a., the bc1 complex) plays a key role in the electron transport chain in aerobic cells. The bc1 complex exhibits multiple unique electron tunneling (ET) processes, such as ET-bifurcation at the Qo site and movement of the Rieske domain. Moreover, we previously discovered that electron tunneling in the low potential arm of the bc1 complex is regulated by a key phenylalanine residue (Phe90). The main goal of the current work is to study the dynamics of the key Phe90 residue in the electron tunneling reaction between heme bL and heme bH as a function of the occupancy of the Qo and Qi binding sites in the bc1 complex. We simulated the molecular dynamics of four model systems of respiratory complex III with different ligands bound at the Qo and Qi binding sites. In addition, we calculated the electron tunneling rate constants between heme bL and heme bH along the simulated molecular dynamics trajectories. The binding of aromatic ligands at the Qo site induces a conformational cascade that properly positions the Phe90 residue, reducing the through-space ET distance from ∼7 to ∼5.5 Å and thus enhancing the electron transfer rate between the heme bL and the heme bH redox pair. Also, the binding of aromatic ligands at the Qi site induces conformational changes that stabilize the Phe90 conformational variation from ∼1.5 to ∼0.5 Å. Hence, our molecular dynamics simulation results show an on-demand two-step conformational connection between the occupancy of the Qo and Qi binding sites and the conformational dynamics of the Phe90 residue. Additionally, our dynamic electron tunneling results confirm our previously reported findings that the Phe90 residue acts as an electron-tunneling gate or switch, controlling the electron transfer rate between the heme bL and heme bH redox systems.

Modeling the Energy Landscape of Side Reactions in the Cytochrome bc1 Complex

Much of the metabolic molecular machinery responsible for energy transduction processes in living organisms revolves around a series of electron and proton transfer processes. The highly redox active enzymes can, however, also pose a risk of unwanted side reactions leading to reactive oxygen species, which are harmful to cells and are a factor in aging and age-related diseases. Using extensive quantum and classical computational modeling, we here show evidence of a particular superoxide production mechanism through stray reactions between molecular oxygen and a semiquinone reaction intermediate bound in the mitochondrial complex III of the electron transport chain, also known as the cytochrome b c 1 complex. Free energy calculations indicate a favorable electron transfer from semiquinone occurring at low rates under normal circumstances. Furthermore, simulations of the product state reveal that superoxide formed at the Q _o -site exclusively leaves the b c 1 complex at the positive side of the membrane and escapes into the intermembrane space of mitochondria, providing a critical clue in further studies of the harmful effects of mitochondrial superoxide production.

The modified Q-cycle: A look back at its development and forward to a functional model

On looking back at a lifetime of research, it is interesting to see, in the light of current progress, how things came to be, and to speculate on how things might be. I am delighted in the context of the Mitchell prize to have that excuse to present this necessarily personal view of developments in areas of my interests. I have focused on the Q-cycle and a few examples showing wider ramifications, since that had been the main interest of the lab in the 20 years since structures became available, - a watershed event in determining our molecular perspective. I have reviewed the evidence for our model for the mechanism of the first electron transfer of the bifurcated reaction at the Q_o-site, which I think is compelling. In reviewing progress in understanding the second electron transfer, I have revisited some controversies to justify important conclusions which appear, from the literature, not to have been taken seriously. I hope this does not come over as nitpicking. The conclusions are important to the final section in which I develop an internally consistent mechanism for turnovers of the complex leading to a state similar to that observed in recent rapid-mix/freeze-quench experiments, reported three years ago. The final model is necessarily speculative but is open to test.

Catalytic Reactions and Energy Conservation in the Cytochrome bc1 and b6f Complexes of Energy-Transducing Membranes

This review focuses on key components of respiratory and photosynthetic energy-transduction systems: the cytochrome bc1 and b6f (Cytbc1/b6f) membranous multisubunit homodimeric complexes. These remarkable molecular machines catalyze electron transfer from membranous quinones to water-soluble electron carriers (such as cytochromes c or plastocyanin), coupling electron flow to proton translocation across the energy-transducing membrane and contributing to the generation of a transmembrane electrochemical potential gradient, which powers cellular metabolism in the majority of living organisms. Cytsbc1/b6f share many similarities but also have significant differences. While decades of research have provided extensive knowledge on these enzymes, several important aspects of their molecular mechanisms remain to be elucidated. We summarize a broad range of structural, mechanistic, and physiological aspects required for function of Cytbc1/b6f, combining textbook fundamentals with new intriguing concepts that have emerged from more recent studies. The discussion covers but is not limited to (i) mechanisms of energy-conserving bifurcation of electron pathway and energy-wasting superoxide generation at the quinol oxidation site, (ii) the mechanism by which semiquinone is stabilized at the quinone reduction site, (iii) interactions with substrates and specific inhibitors, (iv) intermonomer electron transfer and the role of a dimeric complex, and (v) higher levels of organization and regulation that involve Cytsbc1/b6f. In addressing these topics, we point out existing uncertainties and controversies, which, as suggested, will drive further research in this field.

Terminal Respiratory Oxidases: A Targetables Vulnerability of Mycobacterial Bioenergetics?

Recently, ATP synthase inhibitor Bedaquiline was approved for the treatment of multi-drug resistant tuberculosis emphasizing the importance of oxidative phosphorylation for the survival of mycobacteria. ATP synthesis is primarily dependent on the generation of proton motive force through the electron transport chain in mycobacteria. The mycobacterial electron transport chain utilizes two terminal oxidases for the reduction of oxygen, namely the bc₁-aa₃ supercomplex and the cytochrome bd oxidase. The bc₁-aa₃ supercomplex is an energy-efficient terminal oxidase that pumps out four vectoral protons, besides consuming four scalar protons during the transfer of electrons from menaquinone to molecular oxygen. In the past few years, several inhibitors of bc₁-aa₃ supercomplex have been developed, out of which, Q203 belonging to the class of imidazopyridine, has moved to clinical trials. Recently, the crystal structure of the mycobacterial cytochrome bc₁-aa₃ supercomplex was solved, providing details of the route of transfer of electrons from menaquinone to molecular oxygen. Besides providing insights into the molecular functioning, crystal structure is aiding in the targeted drug development. On the other hand, the second respiratory terminal oxidase of the mycobacterial respiratory chain, cytochrome bd oxidase, does not pump out the vectoral protons and is energetically less efficient. However, it can detoxify the reactive oxygen species and facilitate mycobacterial survival during a multitude of stresses. Quinolone derivatives (CK-2-63) and quinone derivative (Aurachin D) inhibit cytochrome bd oxidase. Notably, ablation of both the two terminal oxidases simultaneously through genetic methods or pharmacological inhibition leads to the rapid death of the mycobacterial cells. Thus, terminal oxidases have emerged as important drug targets. In this review, we have described the current understanding of the functioning of these two oxidases, their physiological relevance to mycobacteria, and their inhibitors. Besides these, we also describe the alternative terminal complexes that are used by mycobacteria to maintain energized membrane during hypoxia and anaerobic conditions.

The cytochrome bc1 complex as an antipathogenic target

The cytochrome bc₁ complex is a key component of the mitochondrial respiratory chains of many eukaryotic microorganisms that are pathogenic for plants or humans, such as fungi responsible for crop diseases and Plasmodium falciparum, which causes human malaria. Cytochrome bc₁ is an enzyme that contains two (ubi)quinone/quinol-binding sites, which can be exploited for the development of fungicidal and chemotherapeutic agents. Here, we review recent progress in determination of the structure and mechanism of action of cytochrome bc₁ , and the associated development of antimicrobial agents (and associated resistance mechanisms) targeting its activity.

Charge polarization imposed by the binding site facilitates enzymatic redox reactions of quinone

Quinone reduction site (Q_i) of cytochrome bc₁ represents one of the canonical sites used to explore the enzymatic redox reactions involving semiquinone (SQ) states. However, the mechanism by which Q_i allows the completion of quinone reduction during the sequential transfers of two electrons from the adjacent heme b_H and two protons to C1- and C4-carbonyl remains unclear. Here we established that the SQ coupled to an oxidized heme b_H is a dominant intermediate of catalytic forward reaction and, contrary to the long-standing assumption, represents a significant population of SQ detected across pH 5-9. The pH dependence of its redox midpoint potential implicated proton exchange with histidine. Complementary quantum mechanical calculations revealed that the SQ anion formed after the first electron transfer undergoes charge and spin polarization imposed by the electrostatic field generated by histidine and the aspartate/lysine pair interacting with the C4- and C1-carbonyl, respectively. This favors a barrierless proton exchange between histidine and the C4-carbonyl, which continues until the second electron reaches the SQ_i. Inversion of charge polarization facilitates the uptake of the second proton by the C1-carbonyl. Based on these findings we developed a comprehensive scheme for electron and proton transfers at Q_i featuring the equilibration between the anionic and neutral states of SQ_i as means for a leak-proof stabilization of the radical intermediate. The key catalytic role of the initial charge/spin polarization of the SQ anion at the active site, inherent to the proposed mechanism, may also be applicable to the other quinone oxidoreductases.

Redox-Driven Proton Pumps of the Respiratory Chain

In aerobic cells, the proton gradient that drives ATP synthesis is created by three different proton pumps-membrane enzymes of the respiratory electron transport chain known as complex I, III, and IV. Despite the striking dissimilarity of structures and apparent differences in molecular mechanisms of proton pumping, all three enzymes have much in common and employ the same universal physical principles of converting redox energy to proton pumping. In this study, we describe a simple mathematical model that illustrates the general principles of redox-driven proton pumps and discuss their implementation in complex I, III, and IV of the respiratory chain.

Natively oxidized amino acid residues in the spinach cytochrome b 6 f complex

The cytochrome b ₆ f complex of oxygenic photosynthesis produces substantial levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS). It has been observed that the ROS production rate by b ₆ f is 10-20 fold higher than that observed for the analogous respiratory cytochrome bc₁ complex. The types of ROS produced (O₂^{•-, 1}O₂, and, possibly, H₂O₂) and the site(s) of ROS production within the b ₆ f complex have been the subject of some debate. Proposed sources of ROS have included the heme b _p , PQ _p^•- (possible sources for O₂^•-), the Rieske iron-sulfur cluster (possible source of O₂^•- and/or ¹O₂), Chl a (possible source of ¹O₂), and heme c _n (possible source of O₂^•- and/or H₂O₂). Our working hypothesis is that amino acid residues proximal to the ROS production sites will be more susceptible to oxidative modification than distant residues. In the current study, we have identified natively oxidized amino acid residues in the subunits of the spinach cytochrome b ₆ f complex. The oxidized residues were identified by tandem mass spectrometry using the MassMatrix Program. Our results indicate that numerous residues, principally localized near p-side cofactors and Chl a, were oxidatively modified. We hypothesize that these sites are sources for ROS generation in the spinach cytochrome b ₆ f complex.

Dissecting the pattern of proton release from partial process involved in ubihydroquinone oxidation in the Q-cycle

A key feature of the modified Q-cycle of the cytochrome bc₁ and related complexes is a bifurcation of QH₂ oxidation involving electron transfer to two different acceptor chains, each coupled to proton release. We have studied the kinetics of proton release in chromatophore vesicles from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, using the pH-sensitive dye neutral red to follow pH changes inside on activation of the photosynthetic chain, focusing on the bifurcated reaction, in which 4H⁺are released on complete turnover of the Q-cycle (2H⁺/ubiquinol (QH₂) oxidized). We identified different partial processes of the Q_o-site reaction, isolated through use of specific inhibitors, and correlated proton release with electron transfer processes by spectrophotometric measurement of cytochromes or electrochromic response. In the presence of myxothiazol or azoxystrobin, the proton release observed reflected oxidation of the Rieske iron‑sulfur protein. In the absence of Q_o-site inhibitors, the pH change measured represented the convolution of this proton release with release of protons on turnover of the Q_o-site, involving formation of the ES-complex and oxidation of the semiquinone intermediate. Turnover also regenerated the reduced iron-sulfur protein, available for further oxidation on a second turnover. Proton release was well-matched with the rate limiting step on oxidation of QH₂ on both turnovers. However, a minor lag in proton release found at pH 7 but not at pH 8 might suggest that a process linked to rapid proton release on oxidation of the intermediate semiquinone involves a group with a pK in that range.

Analysis of a Functional Dimer Model of Ubiquinol Cytochrome c Oxidoreductase

Ubiquinol cytochrome c oxidoreductase (bc₁ complex) serves as an important electron junction in many respiratory systems. It funnels electrons coming from NADH and ubiquinol to cytochrome c, but it is also capable of producing significant amounts of the free radical superoxide. In situ and in other experimental systems, the enzyme exists as a dimer. But until recently, it was believed to operate as a functional monomer. Here we show that a functional dimer model is capable of explaining both kinetic and superoxide production rate data. The model consists of six electronic states characterized by the number of electrons deposited on the complex. It is fully reversible and strictly adheres to the thermodynamics governing the reactions. A total of nine independent data sets were used to parameterize the model. To explain the data with a consistent set of parameters, it was necessary to incorporate intramonomer Coulombic effects between hemes b_L and b_H and intermonomer Coulombic effects between b_L hemes. The fitted repulsion energies fall within the theoretical range of electrostatic calculations. In addition, model analysis demonstrates that the Q pool is mostly oxidized under normal physiological operation but can switch to a more reduced state when reverse electron transport conditions are in place.

Mild phenotypes and proper supercomplex assembly in human cells carrying the homoplasmic m.15557G > A mutation in cytochrome b gene

Respiratory complex III (CIII) is the first enzymatic bottleneck of the mitochondrial respiratory chain both in its native dimeric form and in supercomplexes. The mammalian CIII comprises 11 subunits among which cytochrome b is central in the catalytic core, where oxidation of ubiquinol occurs at the Qo site. The Qo- or PEWY-motif of cytochrome b is the most conserved through species. Importantly, the highly conserved glutamate at position 271 (Glu271) has never been studied in higher eukaryotes so far and its role in the Q-cycle remains debated. Here, we showed that the homoplasmic m.15557G > A/MT-CYB, which causes the p.Glu271Lys amino acid substitution predicted to dramatically affect CIII, induces a mild mitochondrial dysfunction in human transmitochondrial cybrids. Indeed, we found that the severity of such mutation is mitigated by the proper assembly of CIII into supercomplexes, which may favor an optimal substrate channeling and buffer superoxide production in vitro.

pH and Potential Transients of the bc1 Complex Co-Reconstituted in Proteo-Lipobeads with the Reaction Center from Rb. sphaeroides

His-tag technology is employed to bind membrane proteins, such as the bc₁ complex and the reaction center (RC) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, to spherical as well as planar surfaces in a strict orientation. Subsequently, the spherical and planar surfaces are subjected to in situ dialysis to form proteo-lipobeads (PLBs) and protein-tethered bilayer membranes, respectively. PLBs based on Ni-nitrileotriacetic acid-functionalized agarose beads that have diameters ranging from 50 to 150 μm are used to assess proton release and membrane potential parameters by confocal laser-scanning microscopy. The pH and potential transients are thus obtained from bc₁ activated by the RC. To assess the turnover of bc₁ excited by the RC in a similar setting, we used the planar surface of an attenuated total reflection crystal modified with a thin gold layer to carry out time-resolved surface-enhanced IR absorption spectroscopy triggered by flash lamp excitation. The experiments suggest that both proteins interact in a cyclic manner in both environments. The activity of the proteins seems to be preserved in the same manner as that in chromatophores or reconstituted in liposomes.

Mutations at the Qo Site of the Cytochrome bc1 Complex Strongly Affect Oxygen Binding

The homodimeric bc₁ protein complex is embedded in membranes of mitochondria and photosynthetic bacteria, where it transports protons across the membrane to maintain an electrostatic potential used to drive ATP synthesis as part of the respiratory or photosynthetic pathways. The reaction cycle of the bc₁ complex is driven by series of redox processes involving substrate molecules from the membrane, but occasional side reactions between an intermediate semiquinone substrate and molecular oxygen are suspected to be a source of toxic superoxide, which is believed to be a factor in aging. The present investigation employs molecular dynamics simulations to study the effect of mutations in the Q_o binding sites of the bc₁ complex on the ability of oxygen molecules to migrate to and bind at various locations within the complex. It is found that the mutations strongly affect the ability of oxygen to bind at the Q_o sites, and moreover, different behavior of the two monomers of the bc₁ complex is observed. The conformational differences at the Q_o sites of the two monomers are studied in detail and discussed. The anionic form of semiquinone was identified as leading to the greatest opportunity for side reactions with oxygen.

Computational modeling analysis of mitochondrial superoxide production under varying substrate conditions and upon inhibition of different segments of the electron transport chain

A computational mechanistic model of superoxide (O2•-) formation in the mitochondrial electron transport chain (ETC) was developed to facilitate the quantitative analysis of factors controlling mitochondrial O2•- production and assist in the interpretation of experimental studies. The model takes into account all individual electron transfer reactions in Complexes I and III. The model accounts for multiple, often seemingly contradictory observations on the effects of ΔΨ and ΔpH, and for the effects of multiple substrate and inhibitor conditions, including differential effects of Complex III inhibitors antimycin A, myxothiazol and stigmatellin. Simulation results confirm that, in addition to O2•- formation in Complex III and at the flavin site of Complex I, the quinone binding site of Complex I is an additional superoxide generating site that accounts for experimental observations on O2•- production during reverse electron transfer. However, our simulation results predict that, when cytochrome c oxidase is inhibited during oxidation of succinate, ROS production at this site is eliminated and almost all superoxide in Complex I is generated by reduced FMN, even when the redox pressure for reverse electron transfer from succinate is strong. In addition, the model indicates that conflicting literature data on the kinetics of electron transfer in Complex III involving the iron-sulfur protein-cytochrome bL complex can be resolved in favor of a dissociation of the protein only after electron transfer to cytochrome bH. The model predictions can be helpful in understanding factors driving mitochondrial superoxide formation in intact cells and tissues.

The mechanism of ubihydroquinone oxidation at the Qo-site of the cytochrome bc1 complex

1. Recent results suggest that the major flux is carried by a monomeric function, not by an intermonomer electron flow. 2. The bifurcated reaction at the Qo-site involves sequential partial processes, - a rate limiting first electron transfer generating a semiquinone (SQ) intermediate, and a rapid second electron transfer in which the SQ is oxidized by the low potential chain. 3. The rate constant for the first step in a strongly endergonic, proton-first-then-electron mechanism, is given by a Marcus-Brønsted treatment in which a rapid electron transfer is convoluted with a weak occupancy of the proton configuration needed for electron transfer. 4. A rapid second electron transfer pulls the overall reaction over. Mutation of Glu-295 of cyt b shows it to be a key player. 5. In more crippled mutants, electron transfer is severely inhibited and the bell-shaped pH dependence of wildtype is replaced by a dependence on a single pK at ~8.5 favoring electron transfer. Loss of a pK ~6.5 is explained by a change in the rate limiting step from the first to the second electron transfer; the pK ~8.5 may reflect dissociation of QH. 6. A rate constant (<10(3)s(-1)) for oxidation of SQ in the distal domain by heme bL has been determined, which precludes mechanisms for normal flux in which SQ is constrained there. 7. Glu-295 catalyzes proton exit through H(+) transfer from QH, and rotational displacement to deliver the H(+) to exit channel(s). This opens a volume into which Q(-) can move closer to the heme to speed electron transfer. 8. A kinetic model accounts well for the observations, but leaves open the question of gating mechanisms. For the first step we suggest a molecular "escapement"; for the second a molecular ballet choreographed through coulombic interactions. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Respiratory complex III and related bc complexes.

A caged, destabilized, free radical intermediate in the q-cycle

The Rieske/cytochrome b complexes, also known as cytochrome bc complexes, catalyze a unique oxidant-induced reduction reaction at their quinol oxidase (Qo ) sites, in which substrate hydroquinone reduces two distinct electron transfer chains, one through a series of high-potential electron carriers, the second through low-potential cytochrome b. This reaction is a critical step in energy storage by the Q-cycle. The semiquinone intermediate in this reaction can reduce O2 to produce deleterious superoxide. It is yet unknown how the enzyme controls this reaction, though numerous models have been proposed. In previous work, we trapped a Q-cycle semiquinone anion intermediate, termed SQo , in bacterial cytochrome bc1 by rapid freeze-quenching. In this work, we apply pulsed-EPR techniques to determine the location and properties of SQo in the mitochondrial complex. In contrast to semiquinone intermediates in other enzymes, SQo is not thermodynamically stabilized, and can even be destabilized with respect to solution. It is trapped in Qo at a site that is distinct from previously described inhibitor-binding sites, yet sufficiently close to cytochrome bL to allow rapid electron transfer. The binding site and EPR analyses show that SQo is not stabilized by hydrogen bonds to proteins. The formation of SQo involves "stripping" of both substrate -OH protons during the initial oxidation step, as well as conformational changes of the semiquinone and Qo proteins. The resulting charged radical is kinetically trapped, rather than thermodynamically stabilized (as in most enzymatic semiquinone species), conserving redox energy to drive electron transfer to cytochrome bL while minimizing certain Q-cycle bypass reactions, including oxidation of prereduced cytochrome b and reduction of O2 .

Electron transfer mechanism of the Rieske protein from Thermus thermophilus from solution nuclear magnetic resonance investigations

We report nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) data indicating that the Rieske protein from the cytochrome bc complex of Thermus thermophilus (TtRp) undergoes modest redox-state-dependent and ligand-dependent conformational changes. To test models concerning the mechanism by which TtRp transfers between different sites on the complex, we monitored (1)H, (15)N, and (13)C NMR signals as a function of the redox state and molar ratio of added ligand. Our studies of full-length TtRp were conducted in the presence of dodecyl phosphocholine micelles to solvate the membrane anchor of the protein and the hydrophobic tail of the ligand (hydroubiquinone). NMR data indicated that hydroubiquinone binds to TtRp and stabilizes an altered protein conformation. We utilized a truncated form of the Rieske protein lacking the membrane anchor (trunc-TtRp) to investigate redox-state-dependent conformational changes. Local chemical shift perturbations suggested possible conformational changes at prolyl residues. Detailed investigations showed that all observable prolyl residues of oxidized trunc-TtRp have trans peptide bond configurations but that two of these peptide bonds (Cys151-Pro152 and Gly169-Pro170 located near the iron-sulfur cluster) become cis in the reduced protein. Changes in the chemical shifts of backbone signals provided evidence of redox-state- and ligand-dependent conformational changes localized near the iron-sulfur cluster. These structural changes may alter interactions between the Rieske protein and the cytochrome b and c sites and provide part of the driving force for movement of the Rieske protein between these two sites.

Role of the -PEWY-glutamate in catalysis at the Q(o)-site of the Cyt bc(1) complex

We re-examine the pH dependence of partial processes of ubihydroquinone (QH(2)) turnover in Glu-295 mutants in Rhodobacter sphaeroides to clarify the mechanistic role. In more crippled mutants, the bell-shaped pH profile of wildtype was replaced by dependence on a single pK at ~8.5 favoring electron transfer. Loss of the pK at 6.5 reflects a change in the rate-limiting step from the first to the second electron transfer. Over the range of pH 6-8, no major pH dependence of formation of the initial reaction complex was seen, and the rates of bypass reactions were similar to the wildtype. Occupancy of the Q(o)-site by semiquinone (SQ) was similar in the wildtype and the Glu→Trp mutant. Since heme b(L) is initially oxidized in the latter, the bifurcated reaction can still occur, allowing estimation of an empirical rate constant <10(3)s(-1) for reduction of heme b(L) by SQ from the domain distal from heme b(L), a value 1000-fold smaller than that expected from distance. If the pK ~8.5 in mutant strains is due to deprotonation of the neutral semiquinone, with Q(•-) as electron donor to heme b(L), then in wildtype this low value would preclude mechanisms for normal flux in which semiquinone is constrained to this domain. A kinetic model in which Glu-295 catalyzes H(+) transfer from QH•, and delivery of the H(+) to exit channel(s) by rotational displacement, and facilitates rapid electron transfer from SQ to heme b(L) by allowing Q(•-) to move closer to the heme, accounts well for the observations.

Oxygen dependent electron transfer in the cytochrome bc(1) complex

The effect of molecular oxygen on the electron transfer activity of the cytochrome bc(1) complex was investigated by determining the activity of the complex under the aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Molecular oxygen increases the activity of Rhodobacter sphaeroides bc(1) complex up to 82%, depending on the intactness of the complex. Since oxygen enhances the reduction rate of heme b(L), but shows no effect on the reduction rate of heme b(H), the effect of oxygen in the electron transfer sequence of the cytochrome bc(1) complex is at the step of heme b(L) reduction during bifurcated oxidation of ubiquinol.

Inter-monomer electron transfer is too slow to compete with monomeric turnover in bc(1) complex

The homodimeric bc(1) complexes are membrane proteins essential in respiration and photosynthesis. The ~11Å distance between the two b(L)-hemes of the dimer opens the possibility of electron transfer between them, but contradictory reports make such inter-monomer electron transfer controversial. We have constructed in Rhodobacter sphaeroides a heterodimeric expression system similar to those used before, in which the bc(1) complex can be mutated differentially in the two copies of cyt b to test for inter-monomer electron transfer, but found that genetic recombination by cross-over then occurs to produce wild-type homodimer. Selection pressure under photosynthetic growth always favored the homodimer over heterodimeric variants enforcing inter-monomer electron transfer, showing that the latter are not competitive. These results, together with kinetic analysis of myxothiazol titrations, demonstrate that inter-monomer electron transfer does not occur at rates competitive with monomeric turnover. We examine the results from other groups interpreted as demonstrating rapid inter-monomer electron transfer, conclude that similar mechanisms are likely to be in play, and suggest that such claims might need to be re-examined.

The mechanism of superoxide production by the antimycin-inhibited mitochondrial Q-cycle

Superoxide production from antimycin-inhibited complex III in isolated mitochondria first increased to a maximum then decreased as substrate supply was modulated in three different ways. In each case, superoxide production had a similar bell-shaped relationship to the reduction state of cytochrome b(566), suggesting that superoxide production peaks at intermediate Q-reduction state because it comes from a semiquinone in the outer quinone-binding site in complex III (Q(o)). Imposition of a membrane potential changed the relationships between superoxide production and b(566) reduction and between b(562) and b(566) redox states, suggesting that b(562) reduction also affects semiquinone concentration and superoxide production. To assess whether this behavior was consistent with the Q-cycle mechanism of complex III, we generated a kinetic model of the antimycin-inhibited Q(o) site. Using published rate constants (determined without antimycin), with unknown rate constants allowed to vary, the model failed to fit the data. However, when we allowed the rate constant for quinol oxidation to decrease 1000-fold and the rate constant for semiquinone oxidation by b(566) to depend on the b(562) redox state, the model fit the energized and de-energized data well. In such fits, quinol oxidation was much slower than literature values and slowed further when b(566) was reduced, and reduction of b(562) stabilized the semiquinone when b(566) was oxidized. Thus, superoxide production at Q(o) depends on the reduction states of b(566) and b(562) and fits the Q-cycle only if particular rate constants are altered when b oxidation is prevented by antimycin. These mechanisms limit superoxide production and short circuiting of the Q-cycle when electron transfer slows.

The electron transfer flavoprotein: ubiquinone oxidoreductases

Electron transfer flavoprotein: ubiqionone oxidoreductase (ETF-QO) is a component of the mitochondrial respiratory chain that together with electron transfer flavoprotein (ETF) forms a short pathway that transfers electrons from 11 different mitochondrial flavoprotein dehydrogenases to the ubiquinone pool. The X-ray structure of the pig liver enzyme has been solved in the presence and absence of a bound ubiquinone. This structure reveals ETF-QO to be a monotopic membrane protein with the cofactors, FAD and a [4Fe-4S](+1+2) cluster, organised to suggests that it is the flavin that serves as the immediate reductant of ubiquinone. ETF-QO is very highly conserved in evolution and the recombinant enzyme from the bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides has allowed the mutational analysis of a number of residues that the structure suggested are involved in modulating the reduction potential of the cofactors. These experiments, together with the spectroscopic measurement of the distances between the cofactors in solution have confirmed the intramolecular pathway of electron transfer from ETF to ubiquinone. This approach can be extended as the R. sphaeroides ETF-QO provides a template for investigating the mechanistic consequences of single amino acid substitutions of conserved residues that are associated with a mild and late onset variant of the metabolic disease multiple acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (MADD).

NMR investigations of the Rieske protein from Thermus thermophilus support a coupled proton and electron transfer mechanism

The Rieske protein component of the cytochrome bc complex contains a [2Fe−2S] cluster ligated by two cysteines and two histidines. We report here the pK_a values of each of the imidazole rings of the two ligating histidines (His134 and His154) in the oxidized and reduced states of the Rieske protein from Thermus thermophilus (TtRp) as determined by NMR spectroscopy. Knowledge of these pK_a values is of critical interest because of their pertinence to the mechanism of electron and proton transfer in the bifurcated Q-cycle. Although we earlier had observed the pH dependence of a ¹⁵N NMR signal from each of the two ligand histidines in oxidized TtRp (Lin, I. J.; Chen, Y.; Fee, J. A.; Song, J.; Westler, W. M.; Markley, J. L.J. Am. Chem. Soc.2006, 132, 10672−10673), the strong paramagnetism of the [2Fe−2S] cluster prevented the assignment of these signals by conventional methods. Our approach here was to take advantage of the unique histidine−leucine (His134−Leu135) sequence and to use residue-selective labeling to establish a key sequence-specific assignment, which was then extended. Analysis of the pH dependence of assigned ¹³C′, ¹³C^α, and ¹⁵N^ε2 signals from the two histidine cluster ligands led to unambiguous assignment of the pK_a values of oxidized and reduced TtRp. The results showed that the pK_a of His134 changes from 9.1 in oxidized to ∼12.3 in reduced TtRp, whereas the pK_a of His154 changes from 7.4 in oxidized to ∼12.6 in reduced TtRp. This establishes His154, which is close to the quinone when the Rieske protein is in the cytochrome b site, as the residue experiencing the remarkable redox-dependent pK_a shift. Secondary structural analysis of oxidized and reduced TtRp based upon our extensive chemical shift assignments rules out a large conformational change between the oxidized and reduced states. Therefore, TtRp likely translocates between the cytochrome b and cytochrome c sites by passive diffusion. Our results are most consistent with a mechanism involving the coupled transfer of an electron and transfer of the proton across the hydrogen bond between the hydroquinone and His154 at the cytochrome b site.

Reaction mechanism of superoxide generation during ubiquinol oxidation by the cytochrome bc1 complex

In addition to its main functions of electron transfer and proton translocation, the cytochrome bc(1) complex (bc(1)) also catalyzes superoxide anion (O(2)(*)) generation upon oxidation of ubiquinol in the presence of molecular oxygen. The reaction mechanism of superoxide generation by bc(1) remains elusive. The maximum O(2)(*) generation activity is observed when the complex is inhibited by antimycin A or inactivated by heat treatment or proteinase K digestion. The fact that the cytochrome bc(1) complex with less structural integrity has higher O(2)(*)-generating activity encouraged us to speculate that O(2)(*) is generated inside the complex, perhaps in the hydrophobic environment of the Q(P) pocket through bifurcated oxidation of ubiquinol by transferring its two electrons to a high potential electron acceptor, iron-sulfur cluster, and a low potential heme b(L) or molecular oxygen. If this speculation is correct, then one should see more O(2)(*) generation upon oxidation of ubiquinol by a high potential oxidant, such as cytochrome c or ferricyanide, in the presence of phospholipid vesicles or detergent micelles than in the hydrophilic conditions, and this is indeed the case. The protein subunits, at least those surrounding the Q(P) pocket, may play a role either in preventing the release of O(2)(*) from its production site to aqueous environments or in preventing O(2) from getting access to the hydrophobic Q(P) pocket and might not directly participate in superoxide production.

Modifications of protein environment of the [2Fe-2S] cluster of the bc1 complex: effects on the biophysical properties of the rieske iron-sulfur protein and on the kinetics of the complex

The rate-determining step in the overall turnover of the bc(1) complex is electron transfer from ubiquinol to the Rieske iron-sulfur protein (ISP) at the Q(o)-site. Structures of the ISP from Rhodobacter sphaeroides show that serine 154 and tyrosine 156 form H-bonds to S-1 of the [2Fe-2S] cluster and to the sulfur atom of the cysteine liganding Fe-1 of the cluster, respectively. These are responsible in part for the high potential (E(m)(,7) approximately 300 mV) and low pK(a) (7.6) of the ISP, which determine the overall reaction rate of the bc(1) complex. We have made site-directed mutations at these residues, measured thermodynamic properties using protein film voltammetry to evaluate the E(m) and pK(a) values of ISPs, explored the local proton environment through two-dimensional electron spin echo envelope modulation, and characterized function in strains S154T, S154C, S154A, Y156F, and Y156W. Alterations in reaction rate were investigated under conditions in which concentration of one substrate (ubiquinol or ISP(ox)) was saturating and the other was varied, allowing calculation of kinetic terms and relative affinities. These studies confirm that H-bonds to the cluster or its ligands are important determinants of the electrochemical characteristics of the ISP, likely through electron affinity of the interacting atom and the geometry of the H-bonding neighborhood. The calculated parameters were used in a detailed Marcus-Brønsted analysis of the dependence of rate on driving force and pH. The proton-first-then-electron model proposed accounts naturally for the effects of mutation on the overall reaction.

Substrate redox potential controls superoxide production kinetics in the cytochrome bc complex

The Q-cycle mechanism of the cytochrome bc(1) complex maximizes energy conversion during the transport of electrons from ubiquinol to cytochrome c (or alternate physiological acceptors), yet important steps in the Q-cycle are still hotly debated, including bifurcated electron transport, the high yield and specificity of the Q-cycle despite possible short-circuits and bypass reactions, and the rarity of observable intermediates in the oxidation of quinol. Mounting evidence shows that some bypass reactions producing superoxide during oxidation of quinol at the Q(o) site diverge from the Q-cycle rather late in the bifurcated reaction and provide an additional means of studying initial reactions of the Q-cycle. Bypass reactions offer more scope for controlling and manipulating reaction conditions, e.g., redox potential, because they effectively isolate or decouple the Q-cycle initial reactions from later steps, preventing many complications and interactions. We examine the dependence of oxidation rate on substrate redox potential in the yeast cytochrome bc(1) complex and find that the rate limitation occurs at the level of direct one-electron oxidation of quinol to semiquinone by the Rieske protein. Oxidation of semiquinone and reduction of cyt b or O(2) are subsequent, distinct steps. These experimental results are incompatible with models in which the transfer of electrons to the Rieske protein is not a distinct step preceding transfer of electrons to cytochrome b, and with conformational gating models that produce superoxide by different rate-limiting reactions from the normal Q-cycle.

Direct demonstration of half-of-the-sites reactivity in the dimeric cytochrome bc1 complex: enzyme with one inactive monomer is fully active but unable to activate the second ubiquinol oxidation site in response to ligand binding at the ubiquinone reduction site

We previously proposed that the dimeric cytochrome bc(1) complex exhibits half-of-the-sites reactivity for ubiquinol oxidation and rapid electron transfer between bc(1) monomers (Covian, R., Kleinschroth, T., Ludwig, B., and Trumpower, B. L. (2007) J. Biol. Chem. 282, 22289-22297). Here, we demonstrate the previously proposed half-of-the-sites reactivity and intermonomeric electron transfer by characterizing the kinetics of ubiquinol oxidation in the dimeric bc(1) complex from Paracoccus denitrificans that contains an inactivating Y147S mutation in one or both cytochrome b subunits. The enzyme with a Y147S mutation in one cytochrome b subunit was catalytically fully active, whereas the activity of the enzyme with a Y147S mutation in both cytochrome b subunits was only 10-16% of that of the enzyme with fully wild-type or heterodimeric cytochrome b subunits. Enzyme with one inactive cytochrome b subunit was also indistinguishable from the dimer with two wild-type cytochrome b subunits in rate and extent of reduction of cytochromes b and c(1) by ubiquinol under pre-steady-state conditions in the presence of antimycin. However, the enzyme with only one mutated cytochrome b subunit did not show the stimulation in the steady-state rate that was observed in the wild-type dimeric enzyme at low concentrations of antimycin, confirming that the half-of-the-sites reactivity for ubiquinol oxidation can be regulated in the wild-type dimer by binding of inhibitor to one ubiquinone reduction site.

Proton environment of reduced Rieske iron-sulfur cluster probed by two-dimensional ESEEM spectroscopy

The proton environment of the reduced [2Fe-2S] cluster in the water-soluble head domain of the Rieske iron-sulfur protein (ISF) from the cytochrome bc(1) complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides has been studied by orientation-selected X-band 2D ESEEM. The 2D spectra show multiple cross-peaks from protons, with considerable overlap. Samples in which (1)H(2)O water was replaced by (2)H(2)O were used to determine which of the observed peaks belong to exchangeable protons, likely involved in hydrogen bonds in the neighborhood of the cluster. By correlating the cross-peaks from 2D spectra recorded at different parts of the EPR spectrum, lines from nine distinct proton signals were identified. Assignment of the proton signals was based on a point-dipole model for interaction with electrons of Fe(III) and Fe(II) ions, using the high-resolution structure of ISF from Rb. sphaeroides. Analysis of experimental and calculated tensors has led us to conclude that even 2D spectra do not completely resolve all contributions from nearby protons. Particularly, the seven resolved signals from nonexchangeable protons could be produced by at least 13 protons. The contributions from exchangeable protons were resolved by difference spectra ((1)H(2)O minus (2)H(2)O), and assigned to two groups of protons with distinct anisotropic hyperfine values. The largest measured coupling exceeded any calculated value. This discrepancy could result from limitations of the point dipole approximation in dealing with the distribution of spin density over the sulfur atoms of the cluster and the cysteine ligands, or from differences between the structure in solution and the crystallographic structure. The approach demonstrated here provides a paradigm for a wide range of studies in which hydrogen-bonding interactions with metallic centers has a crucial role in understanding the function.

Regulatory interactions in the dimeric cytochrome bc(1) complex: the advantages of being a twin

The dimeric cytochrome bc(1) complex catalyzes the oxidation-reduction of quinol and quinone at sites located in opposite sides of the membrane in which it resides. We review the kinetics of electron transfer and inhibitor binding that reveal functional interactions between the quinol oxidation site at center P and quinone reduction site at center N in opposite monomers in conjunction with electron equilibration between the cytochrome b subunits of the dimer. A model for the mechanism of the bc(1) complex has emerged from these studies in which binding of ligands that mimic semiquinone at center N regulates half-of-the-sites reactivity at center P and binding of ligands that mimic catalytically competent binding of ubiquinol at center P regulates half-of-the-sites reactivity at center N. An additional feature of this model is that inhibition of quinol oxidation at the quinone reduction site is avoided by allowing catalysis in only one monomer at a time, which maximizes the number of redox acceptor centers available in cytochrome b for electrons coming from quinol oxidation reactions at center P and minimizes the leakage of electrons that would result in the generation of damaging oxygen radicals.

On the mechanism of quinol oxidation at the QP site in the cytochrome bc1 complex: studied using mutants lacking cytochrome bL or bH

To elucidate the mechanism of bifurcated oxidation of quinol in the cytochrome bc1 complex, Rhodobacter sphaeroides mutants, H198N and H111N, lacking heme bL and heme bH, respectively, were constructed and characterized. Purified mutant complexes have the same subunit composition as that of the wild-type complex, but have only 9-11% of the electron transfer activity, which is sensitive to stigmatellin or myxothiazol. The Em values for hemes bL and bH in the H111N and H198N complexes are -95 and -35 mV, respectively. The pseudo first-order reduction rate constants for hemes bL and bH in H111N and H198N, by ubiquiniol, are 16.3 and 12.4 s(-1), respectively. These indicate that the Qp site in the H111N mutant complex is similar to that in the wild-type complex. Pre-steady state reduction rates of heme c1 by these two mutant complexes decrease to a similar extent of their activity, suggesting that the decrease in electron transfer activity is due to impairment of movement of the head domain of reduced iron-sulfur protein, caused by disruption of electron transfer from heme bL to heme bH. Both mutant complexes produce as much superoxide as does antimycin A-treated wild-type complex. Ascorbate eliminates all superoxide generating activity in the intact or antimycin inhibited wild-type or mutant complexes.

The Q-cycle reviewed: How well does a monomeric mechanism of the bc(1) complex account for the function of a dimeric complex?

Recent progress in understanding the Q-cycle mechanism of the bc(1) complex is reviewed. The data strongly support a mechanism in which the Q(o)-site operates through a reaction in which the first electron transfer from ubiquinol to the oxidized iron-sulfur protein is the rate-determining step for the overall process. The reaction involves a proton-coupled electron transfer down a hydrogen bond between the ubiquinol and a histidine ligand of the [2Fe-2S] cluster, in which the unfavorable protonic configuration contributes a substantial part of the activation barrier. The reaction is endergonic, and the products are an unstable ubisemiquinone at the Q(o)-site, and the reduced iron-sulfur protein, the extrinsic mobile domain of which is now free to dissociate and move away from the site to deliver an electron to cyt c(1) and liberate the H(+). When oxidation of the semiquinone is prevented, it participates in bypass reactions, including superoxide generation if O(2) is available. When the b-heme chain is available as an acceptor, the semiquinone is oxidized in a process in which the proton is passed to the glutamate of the conserved -PEWY- sequence, and the semiquinone anion passes its electron to heme b(L) to form the product ubiquinone. The rate is rapid compared to the limiting reaction, and would require movement of the semiquinone closer to heme b(L) to enhance the rate constant. The acceptor reactions at the Q(i)-site are still controversial, but likely involve a "two-electron gate" in which a stable semiquinone stores an electron. Possible mechanisms to explain the cyt b(150) phenomenon are discussed, and the information from pulsed-EPR studies about the structure of the intermediate state is reviewed. The mechanism discussed is applicable to a monomeric bc(1) complex. We discuss evidence in the literature that has been interpreted as shown that the dimeric structure participates in a more complicated mechanism involving electron transfer across the dimer interface. We show from myxothiazol titrations and mutational analysis of Tyr-199, which is at the interface between monomers, that no such inter-monomer electron transfer is detected at the level of the b(L) hemes. We show from analysis of strains with mutations at Asn-221 that there are coulombic interactions between the b-hemes in a monomer. The data can also be interpreted as showing similar coulombic interaction across the dimer interface, and we discuss mechanistic implications.

The dimeric structure of the cytochrome bc(1) complex prevents center P inhibition by reverse reactions at center N

Energy transduction in the cytochrome bc(1) complex is achieved by catalyzing opposite oxido-reduction reactions at two different quinone binding sites. We have determined the pre-steady state kinetics of cytochrome b and c(1) reduction at varying quinol/quinone ratios in the isolated yeast bc(1) complex to investigate the mechanisms that minimize inhibition of quinol oxidation at center P by reduction of the b(H) heme through center N. The faster rate of initial cytochrome b reduction as well as its lower sensitivity to quinone concentrations with respect to cytochrome c(1) reduction indicated that the b(H) hemes equilibrated with the quinone pool through center N before significant catalysis at center P occurred. The extent of this initial cytochrome b reduction corresponded to a level of b(H) heme reduction of 33%-55% depending on the quinol/quinone ratio. The extent of initial cytochrome c(1) reduction remained constant as long as the fast electron equilibration through center N reduced no more than 50% of the b(H) hemes. Using kinetic modeling, the resilience of center P catalysis to inhibition caused by partial pre-reduction of the b(H) hemes was explained using kinetics in terms of the dimeric structure of the bc(1) complex which allows electrons to equilibrate between monomers.

A structural perspective on mechanism and function of the cytochrome bc (1) complex

The cytochrome bc (1) complex is a fundamental component of the energy conversion machinery of respiratory and photosynthetic electron transfer chains. The multi-subunit membrane protein complex couples electron transfer from hydroquinone to cytochrome c to the translocation of protons across the membrane, thereby substantially contributing to the proton motive force that is used for ATP synthesis. Considerable progress has been made with structural and functional studies towards complete elucidation of the Q cycle mechanism, which was originally proposed by Mitchell 30 years ago. Yet, open questions regarding key steps of the mechanism still remain. The role of the complex as a major source of reactive oxygen species and its implication in pathophysiological conditions has recently gained interest.

A semiquinone intermediate generated at the Qo site of the cytochrome bc1 complex: importance for the Q-cycle and superoxide production

The cytochrome bc1 and related complexes are essential energy-conserving components of mitochondrial and bacterial electron transport chains. They orchestrate a complex sequence of electron and proton transfer reactions resulting in the oxidation of quinol, the reduction of a mobile electron carrier, and the translocation of protons across the membrane to store energy in an electrochemical proton gradient. The enzyme can also catalyze substantial rates of superoxide production, with deleterious physiological consequences. Progress on understanding these processes has been hindered by the lack of observable enzymatic intermediates. We report the first direct detection of a semiquinone radical generated by the Q(o) site using continuous wave and pulsed EPR spectroscopy. The radical is a ubisemiquinone anion and is sensitive to both specific inhibitors and mutations within the Q(o) site as well as O2, suggesting that it is the elusive intermediate responsible for superoxide production. Paramagnetic interactions show that the new semiquinone species is buried in the protein, probably in or near the Q(o) site but not strongly interacting with the 2Fe2S cluster. The semiquinone is substoichiometric, even with conditions optimized for its accumulation, consistent with recently proposed models where the semiquinone is destabilized to limit superoxide production. The discovery of this intermediate provides a critical tool to directly probe the elusive chemistry that takes place within the Q(o) site.

Structural basis for the mechanism of electron bifurcation at the quinol oxidation site of the cytochrome bc1 complex

At the heart of the Q cycle hypothesis, the cytochrome bc1 complex (bc1) is required to separate the two electrons from a quinol molecule at the quinol oxidation site. Recent studies have brought to light an intricate mechanism for this bifurcated electron transfer. A survey of the protein data bank shows 30 entries for the structures of bc1 and the homologous b6 f complex. These structures provide considerable insights into the structural organization of mitochondrial, bacterial, and plant enzymes. Crystallographic binding studies of bc1 with either quinone reduction (QN) and/or quinol oxidation (QP) site inhibitors offer atomic details on how these compounds interact with residues at their respective sites. Most importantly, the different locations and apparent flexibility observed in crystals for the extrinsic domain of the iron-sulfur protein (ISP) subunit suggest a mechanism for electron bifurcation at the QP site. Analyses of various inhibitor-bound structures revealed two classes of QP site inhibitors: Pm inhibitors that promote ISP mobility and Pf inhibitors that favor the fixation of the ISP conformation. Those analyses also shed light on a possible process by which the ISP motion switch is controlled. The first phase reduction of ISP is shown to be comparable to the reduction of the bL heme by pre-steady state kinetic analysis, whereas the second phase reduction of ISP share similar kinetics with the reduction of the bH heme. The reduction of cyt c1 is measured much slower, indicating that the reduced ISP remains bound at the QP site until the reduced heme bL is oxidized by the heme bH and supporting the existence of a control mechanism for the ISP motion switch.

Atomic resolution structures of rieske iron-sulfur protein: role of hydrogen bonds in tuning the redox potential of iron-sulfur clusters

The Rieske [2Fe-2S] iron-sulfur protein of cytochrome bc(1) functions as the initial electron acceptor in the rate-limiting step of the catalytic reaction. Prior studies have established roles for a number of conserved residues that hydrogen bond to ligands of the [2Fe-2S] cluster. We have constructed site-specific variants at two of these residues, measured their thermodynamic and functional properties, and determined atomic resolution X-ray crystal structures for the native protein at 1.2 A resolution and for five variants (Ser-154-->Ala, Ser-154-->Thr, Ser-154-->Cys, Tyr-156-->Phe, and Tyr-156-->Trp) to resolutions between 1.5 A and 1.1 A. These structures and complementary biophysical data provide a molecular framework for understanding the role hydrogen bonds to the cluster play in tuning thermodynamic properties, and hence the rate of this bioenergetic reaction. These studies provide a detailed structure-function dissection of the role of hydrogen bonds in tuning the redox potentials of [2Fe-2S] clusters.

Molecular stochastic simulations of chromatophore vesicles from Rhodobacter sphaeroides

A kinetic model is presented for photosynthetic processes under varying illumination based on the recently introduced steady state model of the photosynthetic chromatophore vesicles of the purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. A stochastic simulation system is built up from independent copies of the different transmembrane proteins, each encapsulating its own set of binding sites and internal states. The proteins are then connected through pools for each of the metabolites. A number of steady state and time-dependent scenarios are presented showing that even under steady state conditions the stochastic model exhibits a different behavior than a continuous description. We find that the electronic coupling between the light harvesting complexes increases the efficiency of the core complexes which eventually allows the bacteria to bridge short illumination outages at already lower light intensities. Some new experiments are proposed by which the DeltapH dependent characteristic of the bc(1) complex or the proton buffering capacity of the vesicle could be determined.

Proton translocation by the cytochromebc1complexes of phototrophic bacteria: introducing the activated Q-cycle

The cytochrome bc1 complexes are proton-translocating, dimeric membrane ubiquinol:cytochrome c oxidoreductases that serve as "hubs" in the vast majority of electron transfer chains. After each ubiquinol molecule is oxidized in the catalytic center P at the positively charged membrane side, the two liberated electrons head out, according to the Mitchell's Q-cycle mechanism, to different acceptors. One is taken by the [2Fe-2S] iron-sulfur Rieske protein to be passed further to cytochrome c1. The other electron goes across the membrane, via the low- and high-potential hemes of cytochrome b, to another ubiquinone-binding site N at the opposite membrane side. It has been assumed that two ubiquinol molecules have to be oxidized by center P to yield first a semiquinone in center N and then to reduce this semiquinone to ubiquinol. This review is focused on the operation of cytochrome bc1 complexes in phototrophic purple bacteria. Their membranes provide a unique system where the generation of membrane voltage by light-driven, energy-converting enzymes can be traced via spectral shifts of native carotenoids and correlated with the electron and proton transfer reactions. An "activated Q-cycle" is proposed as a novel mechanism that is consistent with the available experimental data on the electron/proton coupling. Under physiological conditions, the dimeric cytochrome bc1 complex is suggested to be continually primed by prompt oxidation of membrane ubiquinol via center N yielding a bound semiquinone in this center and a reduced, high-potential heme b in the other monomer of the enzyme. Then the oxidation of each ubiquinol molecule in center P is followed by ubiquinol formation in center N, proton translocation and generation of membrane voltage.

In situ kinetics of cytochromes c1 and c2

In Rhodobacter sphaeroides chromatophores, cytochromes (cyt) c(1) and c(2) have closely overlapping spectra, and their spectral deconvolution provides a challenging task. As a result, analyses of the kinetics of different cytochrome components of the bc(1) complex in purple bacteria usually report only the sum cyt c(1) + cyt c(2) kinetics. Here we used newly determined difference spectra of individual components to resolve the kinetics of cyt c(1) and c(2) in situ via a least-squares (LS) deconvolution. We found that the kinetics of cyt c(1) and c(2) are significantly different from those measured using the traditional difference wavelength (DW) approach, based on the difference in the absorbance at two different wavelengths specific for each component. In particular, with the wavelength pairs previously recommended, differences in instrumental calibration led to kinetics of flash-induced cyt c(1) oxidation measured with the DW method which were faster than those determined by the LS method (half-time of approximately 120 micros vs half-time of approximately 235 micros, in the presence of antimycin). In addition, the LS approach revealed a delay of approximately 50 micros in the kinetics of cyt c(1) oxidation, which was masked when the DW approach was used. We attribute this delay to all processes leading to the oxidation of cyt c(1) after light activation of the photosynthetic reaction center, especially the dissociation of cyt c(2) from the reaction center. We also found that kinetics of both cyt c(1) and c(2) measured by the DW approach were significantly distorted at times longer than 1 ms, due to spectral contamination from changes in the b hemes. The successful spectral deconvolution of cyt c(1) and c(2), and inclusion of both cytochromes in the kinetic analysis, significantly increase the data available for mechanistic understanding of bc(1) turnover in situ.

Proton pumping in the bc1 complex: A new gating mechanism that prevents short circuits

The Q-cycle mechanism of the bc1 complex explains how the electron transfer from ubihydroquinone (quinol, QH2) to cytochrome (cyt) c (or c2 in bacteria) is coupled to the pumping of protons across the membrane. The efficiency of proton pumping depends on the effectiveness of the bifurcated reaction at the Q(o)-site of the complex. This directs the two electrons from QH2 down two different pathways, one to the high potential chain for delivery to an electron acceptor, and the other across the membrane through a chain containing heme bL and bH to the Qi-site, to provide the vectorial charge transfer contributing to the proton gradient. In this review, we discuss problems associated with the turnover of the bc1 complex that center around rates calculated for the normal forward and reverse reactions, and for bypass (or short-circuit) reactions. Based on rate constants given by distances between redox centers in known structures, these appeared to preclude conventional electron transfer mechanisms involving an intermediate semiquinone (SQ) in the Q(o)-site reaction. However, previous research has strongly suggested that SQ is the reductant for O2 in generation of superoxide at the Q(o)-site, introducing an apparent paradox. A simple gating mechanism, in which an intermediate SQ mobile in the volume of the Q(o)-site is a necessary component, can readily account for the observed data through a coulombic interaction that prevents SQ anion from close approach to heme bL when the latter is reduced. This allows rapid and reversible QH2 oxidation, but prevents rapid bypass reactions. The mechanism is quite natural, and is well supported by experiments in which the role of a key residue, Glu-295, which facilitates proton transfer from the site through a rotational displacement, has been tested by mutation.

Spectral and kinetic resolution of the bc1 complex components in situ: a simple and robust alternative to the traditional difference wavelength approach

The kinetics of the cytochrome (cyt) components of the bc(1) complex (ubiquinol: cytochrome c oxidoreductase, Complex III) are traditionally followed by using the difference of absorbance changes at two or more different wavelengths. However, this difference-wavelength (DW) approach is of limited accuracy in the separation of absorbance changes of components with overlapping spectral bands. To resolve the kinetics of individual components in Rhodobacter sphaeroides chromatophores, we have tested a simplified version of a least squares (LS) analysis, based on measurement at a minimal number of different wavelengths. The success of the simplified LS analysis depended significantly on the wavelengths used in the set. The "traditional" set of 6 wavelengths (542, 551, 561, 566, 569 and 575 nm), normally used in the DW approach to characterize kinetics of cyt c(tot) (cyt c(1)+cyt c(2)), cyt b(L), cyt b(H), and P870 in chromatophores, could also be used to determine these components via the simplified LS analysis, with improved resolution of the individual components. However, this set is not sufficient when information about cyts c(1) and c(2) is needed. We identified multiple alternative sets of 5 and 6 wavelengths that could be used to determine the kinetics of all 5 components (P870 and cyts c(1), c(2), b(L), and b(H)) simultaneously, with an accuracy comparable to that of the LS analysis based on a full set of wavelengths (1 nm intervals). We conclude that a simplified version of LS deconvolution based on a small number of carefully selected wavelengths provides a robust and significant improvement over the traditional DW approach, since it accounts for spectral interference of the different components, and uses fewer measurements when information about all five individual components is needed. Using the simplified and complete LS analyses, we measured the simultaneous kinetics of all cytochrome components of bc(1) complex in the absence and presence of specific inhibitors and found that they correspond well to those expected from the modified Q-cycle. This is the first study in which the kinetics of all cytochrome and reaction center components of the bc(1) complex functioning in situ have been measured simultaneously, with full deconvolution over an extended time range.