Role of the Asymmetry of the Homodimeric b2 Stator Stalk in the Interaction with the F1 Sector of Escherichia coli ATP Synthase

A Stutter in the Coiled-Coil Domain of Escherichia coli Co-chaperone GrpE Connects Structure with Function

In bacteria, the co-chaperone GrpE acts as a nucleotide exchange factor and plays an important role in controlling the chaperone cycle of DnaK. The functional form of GrpE is an asymmetric dimer, consisting of a non-ideal coiled coil. Partial unfolding of this region during heat stress results in reduced nucleotide exchange and disrupts protein folding by DnaK. In this study, we elucidate the role of non-ideality in the coiled-coil domain of Escherichia coli GrpE in controlling its co-chaperone activity. The presence of a four-residue stutter introduces nonheptad periodicity in the GrpE coiled coil, resulting in global structural changes in GrpE and regulating its interaction with DnaK. Introduction of hydrophobic residues at the stutter core increased the structural stability of the protein. Using an in vitro FRET assay, we show that the enhanced stability of GrpE resulted in an increased affinity for DnaK. However, these mutants were unable to support bacterial growth at 42°C in a grpE-deleted E. coli strain. This work provides valuable insights into the functional role of a stutter in GrpE in regulating the DnaK-chaperone cycle during heat stress. More generally, our findings illustrate how stutters in a coiled-coil domain regulate structure-function trade-off in proteins.

The Peripheral Stalk of Rotary ATPases

Rotary ATPases are a family of enzymes that are thought of as molecular nanomotors and are classified in three types: F, A, and V-type ATPases. Two members (F and A-type) can synthesize and hydrolyze ATP, depending on the energetic needs of the cell, while the V-type enzyme exhibits only a hydrolytic activity. The overall architecture of all these enzymes is conserved and three main sectors are distinguished: a catalytic core, a rotor and a stator or peripheral stalk. The peripheral stalks of the A and V-types are highly conserved in both structure and function, however, the F-type peripheral stalks have divergent structures. Furthermore, the peripheral stalk has other roles beyond its stator function, as evidenced by several biochemical and recent structural studies. This review describes the information regarding the organization of the peripheral stalk components of F, A, and V-ATPases, highlighting the key differences between the studied enzymes, as well as the different processes in which the structure is involved.

A mechano-chemiosmotic model for the coupling of electron and proton transfer to ATP synthesis in energy-transforming membranes: a personal perspective

ATP is synthesized using ATP synthase by utilizing energy either from the oxidation of organic compounds, or from light, via redox reactions (oxidative- or photo phosphorylation), in energy-transforming membranes of mitochondria, chloroplasts, and bacteria. ATP synthase undergoes several changes during its functioning. The generally accepted model for ATP synthesis is the well-known rotatory model (see e.g., Junge et al., Nature 459:364-370, 2009; Junge and Müller, Science 333:704-705, 2011). Here, we present an alternative modified model for the coupling of electron and proton transfer to ATP synthesis, which was initially developed by Albert Lester Lehninger (1917-1986). Details of the molecular mechanism of ATP synthesis are described here that involves cyclic low-amplitude shrinkage and swelling of mitochondria. A comparison of the well-known current model and the mechano-chemiosmotic model is also presented. Based on structural, and other data, we suggest that ATP synthase is a Ca(2+)/H(+)-K(+) Cl(-)-pump-pore-enzyme complex, in which γ-subunit rotates 360° in steps of 30°, and 90° due to the binding of phosphate ions to positively charged amino acid residues in the N-terminal γ-subunit, while in the electric field. The coiled coil b 2-subunits are suggested to act as ropes that are shortened by binding of phosphate ions to positively charged lysines or arginines; this process is suggested to pull the α 3 β 3-hexamer to the membrane during the energization process. ATP is then synthesized during the reverse rotation of the γ-subunit by destabilizing the phosphated N-terminal γ-subunit and b 2-subunits under the influence of Ca(2+) ions, which are pumped over from storage-intermembrane space into the matrix, during swelling of intermembrane space. In the process of ATP synthesis, energy is first, predominantly, used in the delivery of phosphate ions and protons to the α 3 β 3-hexamer against the energy barrier with the help of C-terminal alpha-helix of γ-subunit that acts as a lift; then, in the formation of phosphoryl group; and lastly, in the release of ATP molecules from the active center of the enzyme and the loading of ADP. We are aware that our model is not an accepted model for ATP synthesis, but it is presented here for further examination and test.

Individual interactions of the b subunits within the stator of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase

FOF1 ATP synthases are rotary nanomotors that couple proton translocation across biological membranes to the synthesis/hydrolysis of ATP. During catalysis, the peripheral stalk, composed of two b subunits and subunit δ in Escherichia coli, counteracts the torque generated by the rotation of the central stalk. Here we characterize individual interactions of the b subunits within the stator by use of monoclonal antibodies and nearest neighbor analyses via intersubunit disulfide bond formation. Antibody binding studies revealed that the C-terminal region of one of the two b subunits is principally involved in the binding of subunit δ, whereas the other one is accessible to antibody binding without impact on the function of FOF1. Individually substituted cysteine pairs suitable for disulfide cross-linking between the b subunits and the other stator subunits (b-α, b-β, b-δ, and b-a) were screened and combined with each other to discriminate between the two b subunits (i.e. bI and bII). The results show the b dimer to be located at a non-catalytic α/β cleft, with bI close to subunit α, whereas bII is proximal to subunit β. Furthermore, bI can be linked to subunit δ as well as to subunit a. Among the subcomplexes formed were a-bI-α, bII-β, α-bI-bII-β, and a-bI-δ. Taken together, the data obtained define the different positions of the two b subunits at a non-catalytic interface and imply that each b subunit has a different role in generating stability within the stator. We suggest that bI is functionally related to the single b subunit present in mitochondrial ATP synthase.

Manipulations in the peripheral stalk of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae F1F0-ATP synthase

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase peripheral stalk is composed of the OSCP, h, d, and b subunits. The b subunit has two membrane-spanning domains and a large hydrophilic domain that extends along one side of the enzyme to the top of F(1). In contrast, the Escherichia coli peripheral stalk has two identical b subunits, and subunits with substantially altered lengths can be incorporated into a functional F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase. The differences in subunit structure between the eukaryotic and prokaryotic peripheral stalks raised a question about whether the two stalks have similar physical and functional properties. In the present work, the length of the S. cerevisiae b subunit has been manipulated to determine whether the F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase exhibited the same tolerances as in the bacterial enzyme. Plasmid shuffling was used for ectopic expression of altered b subunits in a strain carrying a chromosomal disruption of the ATP4 gene. Wild type growth phenotypes were observed for insertions of up to 11 and a deletion of four amino acids on a nonfermentable carbon source. In mitochondria-enriched fractions, abundant ATP hydrolysis activity was seen for the insertion mutants. ATPase activity was largely oligomycin-insensitive in these mitochondrial fractions. In addition, very poor complementation was seen in a mutant with an insertion of 14 amino acids. Lengthier deletions yielded a defective enzyme. The results suggest that although the eukaryotic peripheral stalk is near its minimum length, the b subunit can be extended a considerable distance.

Accommodating discontinuities in dimeric left-handed coiled coils in ATP synthase external stalks

ATP synthases from coupling membranes are complex rotary motors that convert the energy of proton gradients across coupling membranes into the chemical potential of the beta-gamma anhydride bond of ATP. Proton movement within the ring of c subunits localized in the F(0)-sector drives gamma and epsilon rotation within the F(1)alpha(3)beta(3) catalytic core where substrates are bound and products are released. An external stalk composed of homodimeric subunits b(2) in Escherichia coli or heterodimeric bb' in photosynthetic synthases connects F(0) subunit a with F(1) subunits delta and most likely alpha. The external stalk resists rotation, and is of interest both functionally and structurally. Hypotheses that the external stalk contributes to the overall efficiency of the reaction through elastic coupling of rotational substeps, and that stalks form staggered, right-handed coiled coils, are investigated here. We report on different structures that accommodate heptad discontinuities with either local or global underwinding. Analyses of the knob-and-hole packing of the E. coli b(2) and Synechocystis bb' stalks strongly support the possibility that these proteins can adopt conventional left-handed coiled coils.

Domain architecture of the stator complex of the A1A0-ATP synthase from Thermoplasma acidophilum

A key structural element in the ion translocating F-, A-, and V-ATPases is the peripheral stalk, an assembly of two polypeptides that provides a structural link between the ATPase and ion channel domains. Previously, we have characterized the peripheral stalk forming subunits E and H of the A-ATPase from Thermoplasma acidophilum and demonstrated that the two polypeptides interact to form a stable heterodimer with 1:1 stoichiometry (Kish-Trier, E., Briere, L. K., Dunn, S. D., and Wilkens, S. (2008) J. Mol. Biol. 375, 673-685). To define the domain architecture of the A-ATPase peripheral stalk, we have now generated truncated versions of the E and H subunits and analyzed their ability to bind each other. The data show that the N termini of the subunits form an alpha-helical coiled-coil, approximately 80 residues in length, whereas the C-terminal residues interact to form a globular domain containingalpha- and beta-structure. We find that the isolated C-terminal domain of the E subunit exists as a dimer in solution, consistent with a recent crystal structure of the related Pyrococcus horikoshii A-ATPase E subunit (Lokanath, N. K., Matsuura, Y., Kuroishi, C., Takahashi, N., and Kunishima, N. (2007) J. Mol. Biol. 366, 933-944). However, upon the addition of a peptide comprising the C-terminal 21 residues of the H subunit (or full-length H subunit), dimeric E subunit C-terminal domain dissociates to form a 1:1 heterodimer. NMR spectroscopy was used to show that H subunit C-terminal peptide binds to E subunit C-terminal domain via the terminal alpha-helices, with little involvement of the beta-sheet region. Based on these data, we propose a structural model of the A-ATPase peripheral stalk.

The b subunits in the peripheral stalk of F1F0 ATP synthase preferentially adopt an offset relationship

The peripheral stalk of F1F0 ATP synthase is essential for the binding of F1 to FO and for proper transfer of energy between the two sectors of the enzyme. The peripheral stalk of Escherichia coli is composed of a dimer of identical b subunits. In contrast, photosynthetic organisms express two b-like genes that form a heterodimeric peripheral stalk. Previously we generated chimeric peripheral stalks in which a portion of the tether and dimerization domains of the E. coli b subunits were replaced with homologous sequences from the b and b' subunits of Thermosynechococcus elongatus (Claggett, S. B., Grabar, T. B., Dunn, S. D., and Cain, B. D. (2007) J. Bacteriol. 189, 5463-5471). The spatial arrangement of the chimeric b and b' subunits, abbreviated Tb and Tb', has been investigated by Cu2+-mediated disulfide cross-link formation. Disulfide formation was studied both in soluble model polypeptides and between full-length subunits within intact functional F1F0 ATP synthase complexes. In both cases, disulfides were preferentially formed between TbA83C and Tb'A90C, indicating the existence of a staggered relationship between helices of the two chimeric subunits. Even under stringent conditions rapid formation of disulfides between these positions occurred. Importantly, formation of this cross-link had no detectable effect on ATP-driven proton pumping, indicating that the staggered conformation is compatible with normal enzymatic activity. Under less stringent reaction conditions, it was also possible to detect b subunits cross-linked through identical positions, suggesting that an in-register, nonstaggered parallel conformation may also exist.

Conformational changes in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase b-dimer upon binding to F(1)-ATPase

Conformational changes within the subunit b-dimer of the E. coli ATP synthase occur upon binding to the F(1) sector. ESR spectra of spin-labeled b at room temperature indicated a pivotal point in the b-structure at residue 62. Spectra of frozen b +/- F(1) and calculated interspin distances suggested that where contact between b (2) and F(1) occurs (above about residue 80), the structure of the dimer changes minimally. Between b-residues 33 and 64 inter-subunit distances in the F(1)-bound b-dimer were found to be too large to accommodate tightly coiled coil packing and therefore suggest a dissociation and disengagement of the dimer upon F(1)-binding. Mechanistic implications of this "bubble" formation in the tether domain of ATP synthase b ( 2 ) are discussed.

Low resolution structure of subunit b (b (22-156)) of Escherichia coli F(1)F(O) ATP synthase in solution and the b-delta assembly

The first low resolution solution structure of the soluble domain of subunit b (b (22-156)) of the Escherichia coli F(1)F(O) ATPsynthase was determined from small-angle X-ray scattering data. The dimeric protein has a boomerang-like shape with a total length of 16.2 +/- 0.3 nm. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) shows that the protein binds effectively to the subunit delta, confirming their described neighborhood. Using the recombinant C-terminal domain (delta(91-177)) of subunit delta and the C-terminal peptides of subunit b, b (120-140) and b (140-156), FCS titration experiments were performed to assign the segments involved in delta-b assembly. These data identify the very C-terminal tail b (140-156) to interact with delta(91-177). The novel 3D structure of this peptide has been determined by NMR spectroscopy. The molecule adopts a stable helix formation in solution with a flexible tail between amino acid 140 to 145.