Transcriptional precision in photoreceptor development and diseases - Lessons from 25 years of CRX research

The vertebrate retina is made up of six specialized neuronal cell types and one glia that are generated from a common retinal progenitor. The development of these distinct cell types is programmed by transcription factors that regulate the expression of specific genes essential for cell fate specification and differentiation. Because of the complex nature of transcriptional regulation, understanding transcription factor functions in development and disease is challenging. Research on the Cone-rod homeobox transcription factor CRX provides an excellent model to address these challenges. In this review, we reflect on 25 years of mammalian CRX research and discuss recent progress in elucidating the distinct pathogenic mechanisms of four CRX coding variant classes. We highlight how in vitro biochemical studies of CRX protein functions facilitate understanding CRX regulatory principles in animal models. We conclude with a brief discussion of the emerging systems biology approaches that could accelerate precision medicine for CRX-linked diseases and beyond.

A review of electroretinography waveforms and models and their application in the dog

Electroretinography (ERG) is a commonly used technique to study retinal function in both clinical and research ophthalmology. ERG responses can be divided into component waveforms, analysis of which can provide insight into the health and function of different types and populations of retinal cells. In dogs, ERG has been used in the characterization of normal retinal function, as well as the diagnosis of retinal diseases and measuring effects of treatment. While many components of the recorded waveform are similar across species, dogs have several notable features that should be differentiated from the responses in humans and other animals. Additionally, modifications of standard protocols, such as changing flash frequency and stimulus color, and mathematical models of ERG waveforms have been used in studies of human retinal function but have been infrequently applied to visual electrophysiology in dogs. This review provides an overview of the origins and applications of ERG in addition to potential avenues for further characterization of responses in the dog.

A recurrent arcuate retinopathy in familial cone-rod dystrophy secondary to heterozygous CRX deletion

Purpose: To describe an arcuate retinopathy appearance in a familial cone-rod dystrophy and the underlying genetic cause.Methods: Retrospective case series of an affected three-generation family (eight affected members, eight unaffected members)Results: The proband, a 47-year-old male, noted significant visual loss since his early thirties. In addition to central macular atrophic changes, retinal examination was notable for peripapillary atrophy and an arcuate of drusenoid deep yellow lesions in the temporal macula. Spectral-domain optical coherence tomography in the area of the lesions showed regional outer neurosensory retina loss with nasal extension (forming a ring around the central retina) but no drusen. Full-field electroretinography revealed cone-rod dysfunction with an electronegative waveform. Fifteen other available family members were examined, and seven (age range 13-71 years old) showed variable expressivity for similar phenotypic findings, most notably the arcuate lesions in all but the oldest individual who had end-stage atrophy. Exome sequencing of the proband's affected daughter uncovered a heterozygous CRX deletion [NM_000554.4: CRX: c.(100 + 1_101-1)_(c.900 + 1_?)del] that segregated with the disease.Conclusion: An unusual familial cone-rod dystrophy phenotype was associated with heterozygous CRX deletion, a pathogenic variant that had a presumed mechanism of haploinsufficiency. The consistent finding of arcuate temporal macular lesions among affected family members was striking, particularly given the variable expressivity previously associated with CRX-related retinopathy. Additional phenotypic studies are needed to assess how frequently this temporal arcuate retinopathy appearance occurs in individuals harboring a similar deletion who are not from the current family.

Mechanisms of blindness: animal models provide insight into distinct CRX-associated retinopathies

BACKGROUND

The homeodomain transcription factor CRX is a crucial regulator of mammalian photoreceptor gene expression. Mutations in the human CRX gene are associated with dominant inherited retinopathies Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP), Cone-Rod Dystrophy (CoRD), and Leber Congenital Amaurosis (LCA), of varying severity. In vitro and in vivo assessment of mutant CRX proteins have revealed pathogenic mechanisms for several mutations, but no comprehensive mutation-disease correlation has yet been reported.

RESULTS

Here we describe four different classes of disease-causing CRX mutations, characterized by mutation type, pathogenetic mechanism, and the molecular activity of the mutant protein: (1) hypomorphic missense mutations with reduced DNA binding, (2) antimorphic missense mutations with variable DNA binding, (3) antimorphic frameshift/nonsense mutations with intact DNA binding, and (4) antimorphic frameshift mutations with reduced DNA binding. Mammalian models representing three of these classes have been characterized.

CONCLUSIONS

Models carrying Class I mutations display a mild dominant retinal phenotype and recessive LCA, while models carrying Class III and IV mutations display characteristically distinct dominant LCA phenotypes. These animal models also reveal unexpected pathogenic mechanisms underlying CRX-associated retinopathies. The complexity of genotype-phenotype correlation for CRX-associated diseases highlights the value of developing comprehensive "true-to-disease" animal models for understanding pathologic mechanisms and testing novel therapeutic approaches.

Mechanistically distinct mouse models for CRX-associated retinopathy

Cone-rod homeobox (CRX) protein is a “paired-like” homeodomain transcription factor that is essential for regulating rod and cone photoreceptor transcription. Mutations in human CRX are associated with the dominant retinopathies Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP), Cone-Rod Dystrophy (CoRD) and Leber Congenital Amaurosis (LCA), with variable severity. Heterozygous Crx Knock-Out (KO) mice (“+/−”) have normal vision as adults and fail to model the dominant human disease. To investigate how different mutant CRX proteins produce distinct disease pathologies, we generated two Crx Knock-IN (K-IN) mouse models: Crx^E168d2 (“E168d2”) and Crx^R90W (“R90W”). E168d2 mice carry a frameshift mutation in the CRX activation domain, Glu168del2, which is associated with severe dominant CoRD or LCA in humans. R90W mice carry a substitution mutation in the CRX homeodomain, Arg90Trp, which is associated with dominant mild late-onset CoRD and recessive LCA. As seen in human patients, heterozygous E168d2 (“E168d2/+”) but not R90W (“R90W/+”) mice show severely impaired retinal function, while mice homozygous for either mutation are blind and undergo rapid photoreceptor degeneration. E168d2/+ mice also display abnormal rod/cone morphology, greater impairment of CRX target gene expression than R90W/+ or +/− mice, and undergo progressive photoreceptor degeneration. Surprisingly, E168d2/+ mice express more mutant CRX protein than wild-type CRX. E168d2neo/+, a subline of E168d2 with reduced mutant allele expression, displays a much milder retinal phenotype, demonstrating the impact of Crx expression level on disease severity. Both CRX^[E168d2] and CRX^[R90W] proteins fail to activate transcription in vitro, but CRX^[E168d2] interferes more strongly with the function of wild type (WT) CRX, supporting an antimorphic mechanism. E168d2 and R90W are mechanistically distinct mouse models for CRX-associated disease that will allow the elucidation of molecular mechanisms and testing of novel therapeutic approaches for different forms of CRX-associated disease.

The transcription factor Cone-Rod Homeobox (CRX) plays a central role in regulating gene expression of rod and cone photoreceptors, the primary light sensing cells of the retina. Mutations in the human CRX gene have been associated with the retinal degeneration diseases Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP), Cone-Rod Dystrophy (CoRD) and Leber Congential Amaurosis (LCA). These diseases cause progressive and permanent loss of vision, vary widely in age of onset and severity, and are currently untreatable. To understand how mutations in CRX cause distinct forms of retinal disease, we have genetically engineered mice to carry human disease-causing mutations in their Crx gene. These mouse lines accurately recapitulate distinct forms of CRX-associated disease, demonstrating that different classes of CRX mutations are responsible for phenotype variability in humans. We have characterized the pathology of these mice and identified critical mechanisms of disease. In addition, we have discovered that modifying the level of mutant protein had a dramatic effect on disease pathology in one mutant model, suggesting that targeted therapy against the mutant CRX could be an effective treatment strategy. These mouse models will allow for the testing of novel therapeutic strategies for retinal diseases caused by CRX mutations.

CRX variants in cone-rod dystrophy and mutation overview

Mutations in the cone-rod homeobox gene (CRX) are associated with cone-rod dystrophy (CORD), Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA), and, in rare cases, retinitis pigmentosa (RP). In this study, three variations were detected in 3 of 130 families with CORD, including two novel mutations, c.239A>G (p.Glu80Gly) and c.362C>T (p.Ala121Val). So far, 49 mutations in CRX were reported, affecting about 2.35% of LCA, 4.76% of CORD, and 0.80% of RP. These mutations can be classified as missense (38.78%), nonsense (4.08%), deletion (36.73%), insertion (16.33%), and indel (4.08%). They distributed in the three coding exons without mutation hot spots. No clear genotype-phenotype correlation could be established so far.

Genotype-phenotype correlation in a German family with a novel complex CRX mutation extending the open reading frame

PURPOSE

To describe the genotype-phenotype correlation in a German family with a novel CRX mutation and to perform a comparative analysis of published cases.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational case series, systematic review, and comparative analysis of the literature.

PARTICIPANTS

Four related patients with progressive retinal degeneration.

METHODS

Mutation screening by single-strand polymorphism analysis and direct sequencing. Clinical examination included kinetic visual fields (VFs), 2-color threshold perimetry (2CTP), full-field electroretinography, fundus photography, optical coherence tomography, and fundus autofluorescence (FA) recording.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Visual fields, subjective and objective cone- and rod-specific function, fundus aspect, retinal stratification, and FA.

RESULTS

A novel heterozygous complex mutation (c.816delCACinsAA) in CRX predicting the substitution of 27 C-terminal amino acids by 44 novel amino acids, thus abolishing the OTX tail, was identified in a 2-generation family finally diagnosed with cone-rod dystrophy (CRD), which was confirmed by 2CTP. Patients presented with variability in progression, nystagmus, and nyctalopia. Most of the patients were hyperopic. Electroretinography recordings showed residual rod and mixed cone-rod responses in 2 of the subjects. Age-dependent VF losses followed funduscopic changes of progressive atrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium and neuroretina in the macula and midperiphery marked by disturbed FA. Optical coherence tomography showed decreased central retinal thickness. Comparative analysis of the 131 published data sets revealed 2 groups: patients with early and late onset.

CONCLUSIONS

We described a 2-generation family with a novel mutation in CRX. The resulting phenotype is that of CRD with variable age at onset and progression. The phenotype description of previously published cases is conclusive only for CRD.

Conserved transcriptional activators of the Xenopus rhodopsin gene

Vertebrate rhodopsin promoters exhibit striking sequence identities proximal to the initiation site, suggesting that conserved transcription factors regulate rhodopsin expression in these animals. We identify and characterize two transcriptional activators of the Xenopus rhodopsin gene: homologs of the mammalian Crx and Nrl transcription factors, XOtx5 and XL-Nrl (originally named XL-maf), respectively. XOtx5 stimulated transcription approximately 10-fold in human 293 cells co-transfected with a plasmid containing the rhodopsin promoter (-508 to +41) upstream of luciferase, similar to the approximately 6-fold stimulation with human Crx. XL-Nrl stimulated transcription approximately 27-fold in mammalian 293 cells co-transfected with the rhodopsin luciferase reporter, slightly more than the approximately 17-fold stimulation with Nrl. Together, the Xenopus transcription factors synergistically activated the rhodopsin promoter (approximately 140-fold), as well as in combination with mammalian homologs. Deletion of the Nrl-response element, TGCTGA, eliminated the synergistic activation by both mammalian and Xenopus transcription factors. Deletion of the conserved ATTA sequences (Ret-1 or BAT-1), binding sites for Crx, did not significantly decrease activation by Crx/XOtx5. However, there was increased activation by Nrl/XL-Nrl and an increased synergy when the Ret-1 site was disrupted. These results illustrate conservation of mechanisms of retinal gene expression among vertebrates. In transgenic tadpoles, XOtx5 and XL-Nrl directed premature and ectopic expression from the Xenopus rhodopsin promoter-GFP transgene. Furthermore, activation of the endogenous rhodopsin gene was also observed in some animals, showing that XOtx5 and XL-Nrl can activate the promoter in native chromatin environment.

Dominant Leber congenital amaurosis, cone-rod degeneration, and retinitis pigmentosa caused by mutant versions of the transcription factor CRX

We summarize 18 mutations in the human CRX gene that have been associated with Leber congenital amaurosis (congenital retinal blindness), cone-rod degeneration, or retinitis pigmentosa. Except for one obviously null allele not definitely associated with a phenotype (a frameshift in codon 9), all CRX mutations appear to be completely penetrant and cause disease in heterozygotes. These dominant alleles fall into two categories. In one group are missense mutations and short, in-frame deletions; in the second group are frameshift mutations, all of which are in the last exon. All of these dominant mutations are likely to produce stable mRNA that is translated. Mutations in the missense group preferentially affect the conserved homeobox (codons 39-98), and all frameshift mutations leave the homeodomain intact but alter the OTX motif encoded by codons 284-295 at the carboxy terminus. We could not uncover any correlation between type of disease (congenital amaurosis vs. cone-rod degeneration or retinitis pigmentosa) and the type of mutation (missense vs. frameshift). Four of the 18 mutations (approximately 20%) were de novo mutations, and all of these were found in isolate cases of Leber congenital amaurosis. Dominant CRX mutations have not been associated with mental retardation or developmental delay that has sometimes been found in Leber congenital amaurosis caused by other genes. Implications regarding potential future therapies are discussed.

Screening for CRX gene mutations in Chinese patients with Leber congenital amaurosis and mutational phenotype

PURPOSE

To screen for possible disease-causing mutations in the CRX gene in Chinese patients with Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA) and to enrich the understanding of its mutational phenotype.

METHODS

Genomic DNA was collected from 27 patients with LCA. The coding sequences of the CRX gene were analyzed using the PCR-heteroduplex-SSCP method. Mutations were confirmed by DNA sequencing.

RESULTS

We identified two heterozygous variations in the CRX gene in two patients with LCA. One was a deletion (GCC-->-CC, A181D1bp) leading to a frameshift and protein truncation. This mutation was present in a patient with LCA, but not in his healthy parents. The ocular manifestations of this A181Delta1bp mutation are described. An intronic variation (IVS1-13G-->C) was found in a patient with LCA as well as in his healthy father.

CONCLUSION

A heterozygous A181D1bp mutation in the CRX gene caused an LCA phenotype in a Chinese patient.

Prevalence of mutations causing retinitis pigmentosa and other inherited retinopathies

Inherited retinopathies are a genetically and phenotypically heterogeneous group of diseases affecting approximately one in 2000 individuals worldwide. For the past 10 years, the Laboratory for Molecular Diagnosis of Inherited Eye Diseases (LMDIED) at the University of Texas-Houston Health Science Center has screened subjects ascertained in the United States and Canada for mutations in genes causing dominant and recessive autosomal retinopathies. A combination of single strand conformational analysis (SSCA) and direct sequencing of five genes (rhodopsin, peripherin/RDS, RP1, CRX, and AIPL1) identified the disease-causing mutation in approximately one-third of subjects with autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa (adRP) or with autosomal dominant cone-rod dystrophy (adCORD). In addition, the causative mutation was identified in 15% of subjects with Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA). Overall, we report identification of the causative mutation in 105 of 506 (21%) of unrelated subjects (probands) tested; we report five previously unreported mutations in rhodopsin, two in peripherin/RDS, and one previously unreported mutation in the cone-rod homeobox gene, CRX. Based on this large survey, the prevalence of disease-causing mutations in each of these genes within specific disease categories is estimated. These data are useful in estimating the frequency of specific mutations and in selecting individuals and families for mutation-specific studies.