Myoseptal architecture of sarcopterygian fishes and salamanders with special reference to Ambystoma mexicanum

Homology and architecture of the caudal basket of Pachycephalosauria (Dinosauria: Ornithischia): the first occurrence of myorhabdoi in Tetrapoda

Background

Associated postcranial skeletons of pachycephalosaurids, most notably those of Stegoceras and Homalocephale, reveal enigmatic osseous structures not present in other tetrapod clades. The homology and functional significance of these structures have remained elusive as they were originally interpreted to be abdominal ribs or gastralia, and more recently have been interpreted as de novo structures in the tail.

Principal Findings

Analysis of these structures in nearly all pachycephalosaurid skeletons has facilitated a complete description of their architecture, and the establishment of patterns consistent with those of myorhabdoid ossifications — ossifications of the myoseptal tendons associated with myomeres. The presence and structure of myorhabdoid ossifications are well established for teleost fish, but this marks their first recognition within Tetrapoda. These elements are both structurally and histologically distinct from the deep, paraxial ossified tendon bundles of other ornithischian clades, although they may have performed a similar function in the stiffening of the tail.

Conclusions/Significance

These myorhabdoi are not de novo structures, but are instead ossifications (and therefore more amenable to fossilization) of the normally unossified plesiomorphic caudal myosepta of vertebrates. The ubiquitous ossification of these structures in pachycephalosaurids (all specimens preserving the tail also exhibit myorhabdoid ossifications) suggests it is a likely synapomorphic condition for Pachycephalosauria.

Limb-bone histology of temnospondyls: implications for understanding the diversification of palaeoecologies and patterns of locomotion of Permo-Triassic tetrapods

The locomotion of early tetrapods has long been a subject of great interest in the evolutionary history of vertebrates. However, we still do not have a precise understanding of the evolutionary radiation of their locomotory strategies. We present here the first palaeohistological study based on theoretical biomechanical considerations among a highly diversified group of early tetrapods, the temnospondyls. Based on the quantification of microanatomical and histological parameters in the humerus and femur of nine genera, this multivariate analysis provides new insights concerning the adaptations of temnospondyls to their palaeoenvironments during the Early Permian, and clearly after the Permo-Triassic crisis. This study therefore presents a methodology that, if based on a bigger sample, could contribute towards a characterization of the behaviour of species during great evolutionary events.

Fiber-type distribution of the perivertebral musculature in Ambystoma

Many salamanders locomote in aquatic and terrestrial environments. During swimming, body propulsion is solely produced by the axial musculature generating lateral undulations of the trunk and tail. During terrestrial locomotion, the trunk is oscillated laterally in a standing wave, and body propulsion is achieved by concerted trunk and limb muscle action. The goal of this study was to increase our knowledge of the functional morphology of the tetrapod trunk. We investigated the muscle-fiber-type distribution and the anatomical cross-sectional area of all perivertebral muscles in Ambystoma tigrinum and A. maculatum. Muscle-fiber-type composition was determined in serial cross-sections based on m-ATPase activity. Five different body segments were investigated to test for cranio-caudal changes along the trunk. The overall fiber-type distribution was very similar between the species, but A. tigrinum had relatively larger muscles than A. maculatum, which may be related to its digging behavior. None of the perivertebral muscles possessed a homogeneous fiber-type composition. The M. interspinalis showed a distinct layered organization and may function to ensure the integrity of the spine (local stabilization). The M. dorsalis trunci exhibited the plesiomorphic pattern for notochordates in having a distinct superficial layer of red and intermediate fibers, which covered the central white fibers; therefore, it is suggested to function as a mobilizer and a stabilizer of the trunk, but, may also be involved in modulating body stiffness. Similarly, the M. subvertebralis showed clear regionalizations, implying functional subunits that can stabilize and mobilize the trunk as well as modulate of body stiffness. Cranio-caudally, neither the fiber-type composition nor the a-csa changed dramatically, possibly reflecting the need to perform well in both aquatic and terrestrial habitats.

Evolution of high-performance swimming in sharks: Transformations of the musculotendinous system from subcarangiform to thunniform swimmers

In contrast to all other sharks, lamnid sharks perform a specialized fast and continuous "thunniform" type of locomotion, more similar to that of tunas than to any other known shark or bony fish. Within sharks, it has evolved from a subcarangiform mode. Experimental data show that the two swimming modes in sharks differ remarkably in kinematic patterns as well as in muscle activation patterns, but the morphology of the underlying musculotendinous system (red muscles and myosepta) that drives continuous locomotion remains largely unknown. The goal of this study was to identify differences in the musculotendinous system of the two swimming types and to evaluate these differences in an evolutionary context. Three subcarangiform sharks (the velvet belly lantern shark, Etmopterus spinax, the smallspotted catshark, Scyliorhinus canicula, and the blackmouth catshark, Galeus melanostomus) from the two major clades (two galeans, one squalean) and one lamnid shark, the shortfin mako, Isurus oxyrhinchus, were compared with respect to 1) the 3D shape of myomeres and myosepta of different body positions; 2) the tendinous architecture (collagenous fiber pathways) of myosepta from different body positions; and 3) the association of red muscles with myoseptal tendons. Results show that the three subcarangiform sharks are morphologically similar but differ remarkably from the lamnid condition. Moreover, the "subcarangiform" morphology is similar to the condition known from teleostomes. Thus, major features of the "subcarangiform" condition in sharks have evolved early in gnathostome history: Myosepta have one main anterior-pointing cone and two posterior-pointing cones that project into the musculature. Within a single myoseptum cones are connected by longitudinally oriented tendons (the hypaxial and epaxial lateral and myorhabdoid tendons). Mediolaterally oriented tendons (epineural and epipleural tendons; mediolateral fibers) connect vertebral axis and skin. An individual lateral tendon spans only a short distance along the body (a fraction between 0.05 and 0.075 of total length, L, of the shark). This span is similar in all tendons along the body. Red muscles insert into the midregion of the lateral tendons. The shortfin mako differs substantially from this condition in several respects: Red muscles are internalized and separated from white muscles by a sheath of lubricative connective tissue. They insert into the anterior part of the hypaxial lateral tendon. Rostrocaudally, this tendon becomes very distinct and its span increases threefold (0.06L anteriorly to 0.19L posteriorly). Mediolateral fibers do not form distinct epineural/epipleural tendons in the mako. Since our morphological findings are in good accordance with experimental data it seems likely that the thunniform swimming mode has evolved along with the described morphological specializations.

The myoseptal system in Chimaera monstrosa: collagenous fiber architecture and its evolution in the gnathostome stem lineage

Recent studies have revealed the 3D morphology and collagen fiber architecture of myosepta in teleostome fishes. Here we present the first data set on the myoseptal structure of a representative of the chondrichthyan clade. We investigate the series of myosepta in the ratfish Chimaera monstrosa (Holocephali) from the anterior to the posterior body using microdissections of cleared and stained specimens, polarized light microscopy of excised myosepta, and histology. The features of the myoseptal system of Chimaera are compared to data from closely related vertebrate groups and are mapped onto a phylogenetic tree to further clarify the characteristics of the myoseptal series in the gnathostome ancestor. The 3D morphology and collagen fiber architecture of the myoseptal series in C. monstrosa resembles that of Teleostomi (Actinopterygii+Sarcopterygii) with regard to several features. Our comparative analysis reveals that some of them have evolved in the gnathostome stem lineage. (1) A series of epineural and epaxial lateral tendons (LTs) along the whole body, and a series of epipleural and hypaxial LTs in the postanal region evolved in the gnathostome stem lineage. (2) The LTs increase in length towards the posterior body (three-fold in Chimaera). Data on Chimaera and some comparative data on actinopterygian fishes indicate that LTs also increase in thickness towards the posterior body, but further data are necessary to test whether this holds true generally. (3) Another conspicuous apomorphic gnathostome feature is represented by multi-layer structures of myosepta. These are formed along the vertebral column by converging medial regions of successive sloping parts of myosepta. (4) The dorsalmost and ventralmost flanking parts of myosepta bear a set of mediolaterally oriented collagen fibers that are present in all gnathostomes but are lacking in outgroups. Preanal hypaxial myosepta are clearly different from epaxial myosepta and postanal hypaxial myosepta in terms of their collagen fiber architecture. In Chimaera, preanal hypaxial myosepta consist of an array of mediolaterally oriented collagen fibers closely resembling the condition in other gnathostome groups and in petromyzontids. Only one series of tendons, the myorhabdoid tendons of the flanking parts of myosepta, have evolved in the stem lineage of Myopterygii (Gnathostomata+Petromyzontida). Similar to LTs, the tendons of this series also increase in length towards the posterior body. In combination with other studies, the present study provides a framework for the design of morphologically based experiments and modeling to further address the function of myosepta and myoseptal tendons in gnathostomes.

From head to tail: The myoseptal system in basal actinopterygians

Experimental studies indicated that myomeres play several functional roles during swimming. Some of the functions in question are thought to change rostrocaudally, e.g., anterior myomeres are thought to generate forces, whereas posterior myomeres are thought to transmit forces. In order to determine whether these putative functions are reflected in myoseptal morphology we carried out an analysis of the myoseptal system that includes epaxial and hypaxial myosepta of all body regions for the first time. We combined clearing and staining, microdissections, polarized light microscopy, SEM technique, and length measurements of myoseptal parts to reveal the spatial arrangement, collagen fiber architecture, and rostrocaudal gradients of myosepta. We included representatives of the four basal actinopterygian clades to evaluate our findings in an evolutionary and in a functional context. Our comparison revealed a set of actinopterygian groundplan features. This includes a set of specifically arranged myoseptal tendons (epineural, epipleural, lateral, and myorhabdoid tendons) in all epaxial and postanal hypaxial myosepta. Only preanal hypaxial myosepta lack tendons and exclusively consist of mediolateral fibers. Laterally, myosepta generally align with the helically wound fibers of the dermis in order not to limit the body's maximum curvature. Medially, the relationship of myosepta to vertebrae clearly differs from a 1:1 relationship: a myoseptum attaches to the anterior margin of a vertebra, turns caudally, and traverses at least three vertebrae in an almost horizontal orientation in all body regions. By this arrangement, horizontal multiple layers of myosepta are formed along the trunk dorsal and ventral to the horizontal septum. Due to their reinforcement by epineural or epipleural tendons, these multiple layers are hypothesized to resist the radial expansion of underlying muscle fibers and thus contribute to modulation of body stiffness. Rostrocaudally, a dorsoventral symmetry of epaxial and hypaxial myosepta in terms of spatial arrangement and collagen fiber architecture is gradually developed towards the postanal region. Furthermore, the rostrocaudal extension of myosepta measured between anterior and posterior cones gradually increases. This myoseptal region is reinforced by longitudinal fibers of lateral tendons. Furthermore, the percentage of connective tissue in a cross section increases. These morphological data indicate that posterior myosepta are equipped for multisegmental force transmission towards the caudal fin. Anteriormost myosepta have reinforced and elongated dorsal posterior cones. They are adequately designed to transmit epaxial muscular forces to the neurocranium in order to cause its elevation during suction feeding.

Structure and evolution of the horizontal septum in vertebrates

Although the horizontal septum (HS) has been identified as playing a role in fish biomechanics and in path finding of cells during zebrafish development, its morphology is poorly known. However, it is generally regarded as an evolutionarily conserved structure. To test this idea, we applied a novel combination of techniques to analyse the HS of 35 species from all major gnathostome clades in which is visualized its collagen fibre architecture. Results show that the HS is a conserved trait only with respect to the presence of caudolateral [= epicentral] and craniolateral [= posterior oblique] collagen fibre tracts, but differs remarkably with respect to the specifications of these tracts. Our data revealed several evolutionary changes within vertebrates. In the gnathostome ancestor, the two tracts are represented by evenly distributed epicentral fibres (ECFs) and posterior oblique fibres (POFs). ECFs are condensed to distinct epicentral tendons (ECTs) in the actinopteran ancestor. POFs independently evolved to distinct posterior oblique tendons (POTs) at least two times within teleosts. Within basal teleostomes, POFs as well as ECFs or ECTs were lost two times independently. POTs were lost at least three times independently within teleosts. This view of a homoplastic HS remains stable regardless of the competing phylogenies used for analysis. Our data make problematic any generalization of biomechanical models on fish swimming that include the HS. They indicate that the pathfinding role of the HS in zebrafish may be extended to gnathostome fishes, but not to agnathans, sarcopterygian fishes and tetrapods.

The ear region of Latimeria chalumnae: functional and evolutionary implications

The anatomy of Latimeria chalumnae has figured prominently in discussions about tetrapod origins. While the gross anatomy of Latimeria is well documented, relatively little is known about its otic anatomy and ontogeny. To examine the inner ear and the otoccipital part of the cranium, a serial-sectioned juvenile coelacanth was studied in detail and a three-dimensional reconstruction was made. The ear of Latimeria shows a derived condition compared to other basal sarcopterygians in having a connection between left and right labyrinths. This canalis communicans is perilymphatic in nature and originates at the transition point of the saccule and the lagena deep in the inner ear, where a peculiar sense end organ can be found. In most gnathostomes the inner ears are clearly separated from each other. A connection occurs in some fishes, e.g. within the Ostariophysi. In the sarcopterygian lineage no connections between the inner ears are known except in the Actinistia. Some fossil actinistians show a posteriorly directed duct lying between the foramen magnum and the notochordal canal, similar to the condition in the ear of Latimeria, so this derived character complex probably developed early in actinistian history. Because some features of the inner ear of Latimeria have been described as having tetrapod affinities, the problem of hearing and the anatomy of the otical complex in the living coelacanth has been closely connected to the question of early tetrapod evolution. It was assumed in the past that the structure found in Latimeria could exemplify a transitional stage in otic evolution between the fishlike sarcopterygians and the first tetrapods in a functional or even phylogenetic way. Here the possibility is considered that the canalis communicans does not possess any auditory function but rather is involved in sensing pressure changes during movements involving the intracranial joint. Earlier hypotheses of a putative tympanic ear are refuted.

Spatial arrangement of white muscle fibers and myoseptal tendons in fishes

We describe the arrangement of white muscle fibers and tendinous myoseptal structures and the relation of these structures to each other in order to provide an anatomical framework for discussions and experimental research on fish swimming mechanics. For the three major craniate groups, the petromyzontids, myxinids and gnathostomes, we identify three conditions that differ remarkably. Myxinids are characterized by asymmetrical myosepta with long cones. Within a single myoseptum these are connected by collagenous fibers that are almost oriented longitudinally. Distinct tendons are absent in myxinid myosepta. Petromyzontid myosepta lack cones and distinct myoseptal tendons, whereas gnathostomes bear cones and distinct tendinous structures: the lateral band, epineural (epipleural) tendon and myhabdoid tendon. Myoseptal fibers of petromyzontids and myoseptal tendons of gnathostome myosepta are firmly anchored in the skin. Myxinids lack firm myoseptal-skin-connections. Their muscular arrangement is neither comparable to that of petromyzontids nor to that of gnathostomes. The latter two bear archlike arrangements of muscle fibers spanning several segments that are hypothesized to play a role during bending. In gnathostomes, archlike helical muscle fiber arrangements (HMFAs) are present that span the length of several body segments and are multiply intersected by myosepta. Hence, a series of tendinous lateral bands of myosepta is embedded in HMFAs. The posterodorsally oriented HMFAs are underlain by posteroventrally oriented crossing muscle fibers (CMFs). Bending may be generated by contraction of the muscle fibers belonging to an HMFA and the simultaneous counteraction of CMFs. Moving caudally, this anterior muscle fiber arrangement gradually changes, eventually becoming the posterior muscle fiber arrangement. This pattern suggests that the function of the myomeres will also change. Three additional putative roles of myoseptal tendons can be deduced from their relations to white muscle fibers in gnathostomes (and in part in petromyzontids): (1) Posterior transmission of anteriorly generated muscular forces via lateral bands and/or myorhabdoid tendons. These tendons are more robust posteriorly. Anterior and posterior cones appear to play an important role in force transmission. (2) Pulling on collagen fibers of the skin via lateral bands and myorhabdoid tendons, suggesting a transmission of muscular forces that puts the skin into tension. (3) Resisting radial expansion of contracting muscle fibers by epineural (epipleural) tendons. By the latter two mechanisms modulation of body stiffness is likely to be achieved.