Effect of sleep deprivation on self-selected workload

Degradation of Performance Due to Sleep Deprivation: A Field Test

During a 72 h field test, two groups of elite, “ranger type” soldiers were evaluted five times (during the first 8 h, after 30 h of continuous field duty, after a rest period, after 30 more h of continuous field duty, and after a second rest). One group (7 soldiers) received two rests of 3 h each. The second group (6 soldiers) received two rests of 6 h each. Five military tasks (map reading, decoding messages, vehicle/aircraft recognition, assembly and disassembly of the M-16 rifle, and preparation of an AN/PRC radio for operation) were used. These tasks were considered by the commander to be representative of duties that the soldiers would do and were considered to be completely familiar to the soldiers. In addition, a peg into pegboard task and a subjective evaluation of fatigue questionnaire were given.

There was no significant effect of time or difference between the two groups. The soldiers completed these tasks of short duration (less than 3 min) without decreasing performance—even after extended periods of sleep loss. These performance results occurred even though subjectively the soldiers reported they were tired.

The effect of one night's sleep deprivation on temperature, mood, and physical performance in subjects with different amounts of habitual physical activity

Eleven healthy males were studied twice. On one occasion (control, C), they slept (night 1) and then underwent a battery of tests at 4 h intervals from 06:00 day 1 to 02:00 day 2; then, after a normal sleep (night 2), they were tested from 10:00 to 22:00 on day 2. On the second occasion (sleep deprivation, SD), the subjects remained awake during night 1. Each battery of tests consisted of measurements of tympanic membrane temperature, profile of mood states (POMS), muscle strength, self-chosen work rate (SCWR), perceived exertion, and heart rate (HR) while exercising on a stationary cycle ergometer. Subjects also kept a diary of their activities during the two days and answered a questionnaire about their habitual physical activity. Results showed a significant negative effect of sleep deprivation on most mood states on day 1, but no effect on the other variables. By day 2, mood had tended to recover, though muscle strength tended to be worse in both control and sleep-deprivation experiments. There was also a more general tendency for negative effects to be present at the end of day 1 (02:00) or at the beginning of day 2 (10:00). There was limited support for the view that subjects who were habitually more active showed less negative effects after sleep deprivation and responded less adversely to the poor sleep achieved on the university premises (night 2). These results stress the considerable interindividual variation in the responses to sleep loss and, therefore, the difficulty associated with giving general advice to individuals about work or training capability after sleep loss.