Electron Transfer Mechanisms in Heme Proteins

Amino acid sequence, crystallization and structure determination of reduced and oxidized cytochrome c6 from the green alga Scenedesmus obliquus

Cytochrome c6from the unicellular green alga Scenedesmus obliquus was sequenced, crystallized in its reduced and oxidized state and the three-dimensional structure of the protein in both redox states was determined by X-ray crystallography. Reduced cytochrome c6crystallized as a monomer in the space group P 21212, whereas the oxidized protein crystallized as a dimer in the space group P 3121. The structures were solved by molecular replacement and refined to 1. 9 and 2.0 A, respectively. Comparison of the structures of both redox states revealed only slight differences on the protein surface, whereas a distortion along the axis between the heme iron and its coordinating Met61 residue was observed. No redox-dependent movement of internal water molecules could be detected. The high degree of similarity of the surfaces and charge distributions of both redox states, as well as the dimerization of cytochrome c6as observed in the oxidized crystal, is discussed with respect to its biological relevance and its implications for the reaction mechanisms between cytochrome c6and its redox partners. The dimer of oxidized cytochrome c6may represent a molecular structure occurring in a binary complex with cytochrome b6f. This assembly might be required for the correct orientation of cytochrome c6with respect to its redox partner cytochrome b6f, facilitating the electron transfer within the complex. If the dimerization is not redox-dependent in vivo, the almost identical surfaces of both redox states do not support a long range differentiation between reduced and oxidized cyt c6, i.e. a random collision model for the formation of an electron transfer complex must be assumed.

Anion binding to mitochondrial cytochromes c studied through electrochemistry. Effects of the neutralization of surface charges on the redox potential

The redox potential of horse and bovine heart cytochromes c determined through cyclic voltammetry is exploited to probe for anion-protein interactions, using a Debye-Hückel-based model. In parallel, protein charge neutralization resulting from specific anion binding allows monitoring for surface-charge/E(o) relationships. This approach shows that a number of anions, most of which are of biological relevance, namely CI-, HPO(2-)4, HCO3-, NO3, SO(2-)4, CIO4-, citrate3- and oxalate2-, bind specifically to the protein surface, often in a sequential manner as a result of the presence of multiple sites with different affinities. The binding stoichiometries of the various anions toward a given cytochrome are in general different. Chloride and phosphate appear to bind to a greater extent to both proteins as compared to the other anions. Differences in binding specificity toward the two cytochromes, although highly sequence-related, are observed for a few anions. The data are discussed comparatively in terms of electrostatic and geometric properties of the anions and by reference to the proposed location and amino acid composition of the anion binding sites, when available. Specific binding of this large set of anions bearing different charges allows the electrostatic effect on Eo due to neutralization of net positive protein surface charge(s) to be monitored. (J)H NMR indeed indicates the absence of significant salt-induced structural perturbations, hence the above change in Eo is predominantly electrostatic in origin. A systematic study of protein surface-charge/Eo relationships using this approach is unprecedented. Values of 15-25 mV (extrapolated at zero ionic strength) are obtained for the decrease in Eo due to neutralization of one positive surface charge, which are of the same order of magnitude as previous estimates obtained with either mutation or chemical modification of surface lysines. The effects of the anion-induced decrease of net positive charge on Eo persist also at a relatively high ionic strength and add to the general effects related to the charge shielding of the protein as a whole due to the surrounding ionic atmosphere: hence the ionic strength dependence of the rate of electron transfer between cytochromes c and redox partners could also involve salt-induced changes in the driving force.

Biological electron transfer: progress and future directions

The rich diversity among bacterial cytochromes has played a key role in the development of our understanding of biological electron transfer. Although studies to date have allowed the elucidation of the contributions of driving force, electrostatics interactions and surface topology to electron transfer kinetics in collision-dependent reactions, much remains to be learned. Little is known about intramolecular and intracomplex electron transfer. Several factors controlling intramolecular and intracomplex electron transfer can be defined. These include driving force, the distance between redox centers, the relative orientation of prosthetic groups, the nature of the intervening media and the molecular dynamics within the electron transfer complex. However, at the present time, we have only a limited understanding of the contribution of these factors to electron transfer kinetics in biologically relevant systems. Nevertheless, a wide range of techniques are now available which should soon provide the information necessary to describe in molecular terms the mechanism of intramolecular and intracomplex electron transfer. Principal among these new approaches are site-directed mutagenesis and NMR spectroscopy.