Assessment of the convergence of partially self-consistent BSE/GW calculations

Combining Renormalized Singles GW Methods with the Bethe-Salpeter Equation for Accurate Neutral Excitation Energies

We apply the renormalized singles (RS) Green's function in the Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE)/GW approach to predict accurate neutral excitation energies of molecular systems. The BSE calculations are performed on top of the G_RSW_RS method, which uses the RS Green's function also for the computation of the screened Coulomb interaction W. We show that the BSE/G_RSW_RS approach significantly outperforms BSE/G₀W₀ for predicting excitation energies of valence, Rydberg, and charge-transfer (CT) excitations by benchmarking the Truhlar-Gagliardi set, Stein CT set, and an atomic Rydberg test set. For the Truhlar-Gagliardi test set, BSE/G_RSW_RS provides comparable accuracy to time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) and is slightly better than BSE starting from eigenvalue self-consistent GW (evGW). For the Stein CT test set, BSE/G_RSW_RS significantly outperforms BSE/G₀W₀ and TDDFT with the accuracy comparable to BSE/evGW. We also show that BSE/G_RSW_RS predicts Rydberg excitation energies of atomic systems well. Besides the excellent accuracy, BSE/G_RSW_RS largely eliminates the dependence on the choice of the density functional approximation. This work demonstrates that the BSE/G_RSW_RS approach is accurate and efficient for predicting excitation energies for a broad range of systems, which expands the applicability of the BSE/GW approach.

Combining Localized Orbital Scaling Correction and Bethe-Salpeter Equation for Accurate Excitation Energies

We applied localized orbital scaling correction (LOSC) in Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE) to predict accurate excitation energies for molecules. LOSC systematically eliminates the delocalization error in the density functional approximation and is capable of approximating quasiparticle (QP) energies with accuracy similar or better than the GW Green's function approach and with much less computational cost. The QP energies from LOSC instead of commonly used G0 W0 and ev GW are directly used in BSE. We show that the BSE/LOSC approach greatly outperforms the commonly used BSE/ G0W0 approach for predicting excitations with different characters. For the calculations for Truhlar-Gagliardi test set containing valence, charge transfer (CT) and Rydberg excitations, BSE/LOSC with the Tamm-Dancoff approximation provides a comparable accuracy to time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) and BSE/ev GW. For the calculations of Stein CT test set and Rydberg excitations of atoms, BSE/LOSC considerably outperforms both BSE/ G0W0 and TDDFT approaches with a reduced starting point dependence. BSE/LOSC is thus a promising and efficient approach to calculate excitation energies for molecular systems.

The Quest for Highly Accurate Excitation Energies: A Computational Perspective

We provide an overview of the successive steps that made it possible to obtain increasingly accurate excitation energies with computational chemistry tools, eventually leading to chemically accurate vertical transition energies for small- and medium-size molecules. First, we describe the evolution of ab initio methods employed to define benchmark values, with the original Roos CASPT2 method, then the CC3 method as in the renowned Thiel set, and more recently the resurgence of selected configuration interaction methods. The latter method has been able to deliver consistently, for both single and double excitations, highly accurate excitation energies for small molecules, as well as medium-size molecules with compact basis sets. Second, we describe how these high-level methods and the creation of representative benchmark sets of excitation energies have allowed the fair and accurate assessment of the performance of computationally lighter methods. We conclude by discussing possible future theoretical and technological developments in the field.

The Bethe–Salpeter equation in chemistry: relations with TD-DFT, applications and challenges

We review the Bethe–Salpeter formalism and analyze its performances for the calculation of the excited state properties of molecular systems.

Modeling the Photochrome-TiO2 Interface with Bethe-Salpeter and Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory Methods

Hybrid organic-inorganic semiconductor systems have important applications in both molecular electronics and photoresponsive materials. The characterizations of the interface and of the electronic excited-states of these hybrid systems remain a challenge for state-of-the-art computational methods, as the systems of interest are large. In the present investigation, we present for the first time a many-body Green's function Bethe-Salpeter investigation of a series of photochromic molecules adsorbed onto TiO₂ nanoclusters. On the basis of these studies, the performance of time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations is assessed. In addition, the photochromic properties of different hybrid systems are also evaluated. This work shows that qualitatively different conclusions can be reached with TD-DFT relying on various exchange-correlation functionals for such organic-inorganic interfaces and paves the way to more accurate simulation of many hybrid materials.

Benchmark of Bethe-Salpeter for Triplet Excited-States

We have evaluated the accuracy of the Bethe-Salpeter singlet-triplet transition energies as well as singlet-triplet and triplet-triplet splittings for 20 organic molecules, using as reference the CC3 values determined by Thiel and co-workers with both the TZVP and aug-cc-pVTZ atomic basis sets. Our excitation energies are obtained on the basis of GW quasiparticle energy levels that are self-consistently converged with respect to the starting DFT eigenvalues. In its current form, BSE/GW is often unable to provide a balanced description of both singlet and triplet excited-states. While the singlet-singlet and triplet-triplet energy separations are obtained accurately, triplets are located too close in energy from the ground-state, by typically -0.55 eV when using standard functionals to generate the starting eigenstates. Applying the Tamm-Dancoff approximation upshifts the BSE triplet energies and allows reducing this error to ca. -0.40 eV, while using M06-HF eigenstates allows a further increase and hence a reduction of the error for triplet states, but at the cost of larger errors for the singlet excited-states. At this stage, the most accurate TD-DFT estimates therefore remain competitive for computing singlet-triplet transition energies. Indeed, with M06-2X, irrespective of the application or not of the Tamm-Dancoff approximation and of the selected atomic basis set, the deviations obtained with TD-DFT are rather small.

Bethe-Salpeter study of cationic dyes: Comparisons with ADC(2) and TD-DFT

We present a theoretical investigation of the excited-state properties of a large series of structurally diverse arylcarbonium derivatives that are known to be challenging for theoretical models. More specifically, we compare the pros and cons of TD-DFT (TD-M06-2X), ADC(2), and BSE/GW approaches for a large panel of compounds, using two different solvent models. Both 0-0 and vertical transition energies are considered and compared to the experimental values. All approaches reasonably reproduce the auxochromic and acidochromic shifts, although in most cases both TD-DFT and BSE/GW return larger correlation with experimental values than ADC(2) for these shifts. In contrast, the absolute transition energies obtained with ADC(2) tend to be closer to the measurements, TD-DFT using the M06-2X functional largely overestimating the experimental references (by ca. 0.5 eV), and BSE/GW providing intermediate values. In addition, we show that the selected solvent model has a significant impact on the results, the corrected linear-response approach providing larger transition energies than its linear-response counterpart.

Theoretical description of protein field effects on electronic excitations of biological chromophores

Photoinitiated phenomena play a crucial role in many living organisms. Plants, algae, and bacteria absorb sunlight to perform photosynthesis, and convert water and carbon dioxide into molecular oxygen and carbohydrates, thus forming the basis for life on Earth. The vision of vertebrates is accomplished in the eye by a protein called rhodopsin, which upon photon absorption performs an ultrafast isomerisation of the retinal chromophore, triggering the signal cascade. Many other biological functions start with the photoexcitation of a protein-embedded pigment, followed by complex processes comprising, for example, electron or excitation energy transfer in photosynthetic complexes. The optical properties of chromophores in living systems are strongly dependent on the interaction with the surrounding environment (nearby protein residues, membrane, water), and the complexity of such interplay is, in most cases, at the origin of the functional diversity of the photoactive proteins. The specific interactions with the environment often lead to a significant shift of the chromophore excitation energies, compared with their absorption in solution or gas phase. The investigation of the optical response of chromophores is generally not straightforward, from both experimental and theoretical standpoints; this is due to the difficulty in understanding diverse behaviours and effects, occurring at different scales, with a single technique. In particular, the role played by ab initio calculations in assisting and guiding experiments, as well as in understanding the physics of photoactive proteins, is fundamental. At the same time, owing to the large size of the systems, more approximate strategies which take into account the environmental effects on the absorption spectra are also of paramount importance. Here we review the recent advances in the first-principle description of electronic and optical properties of biological chromophores embedded in a protein environment. We show their applications on paradigmatic systems, such as the light-harvesting complexes, rhodopsin and green fluorescent protein, emphasising the theoretical frameworks which are of common use in solid state physics, and emerging as promising tools for biomolecular systems.