Exact methods of testing the homogeneity of prevalences for correlated binary data

Risk difference tests for stratified binary data under Dallal's model

In medical studies, the binary data is often encountered when the paired organs or body parts receive treatment. However, the same treatment may lead to different therapeutic effects based on the stratified factors or confounding effects. Under Dallal's model, the paper proposes the homogeneity test of risk difference to determine the necessity of stratified treatment. When the stratification is not necessary, common test is introduced to investigate if the risk difference is equal to a fixed constant between two groups. Several statistical tests are derived to analyze homogeneity and common hypotheses, respectively. Monte Carlo simulations show that the score tests behave well in both of hypotheses. Wald-type and Rosner's statistics are always liberal but have higher empirical powers. Especially, the likelihood ratio statistic is better for the homogeneity test in the case of smaller data with larger strata. Two real examples are provided to illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed methods in ankle instability and otolaryngology studies.

Statistical tests under Dallal's model: Asymptotic and exact methods

This paper proposes asymptotic and exact methods for testing the equality of correlations for multiple bilateral data under Dallal’s model. Three asymptotic test statistics are derived for large samples. Since they are not applicable to small data, several conditional and unconditional exact methods are proposed based on these three statistics. Numerical studies are conducted to compare all these methods with regard to type I error rates (TIEs) and powers. The results show that the asymptotic score test is the most robust, and two exact tests have satisfactory TIEs and powers. Some real examples are provided to illustrate the effectiveness of these tests.