Evaluation of the impact of current antismoking advice in the UK on women with planned pregnancies

Clinical interventions to reduce secondhand smoke exposure among pregnant women: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To conduct a systematic review of clinical interventions to reduce secondhand smoke (SHS) exposure among non-smoking pregnant women.

DATA SOURCES

We searched 16 databases for publications from 1990 to January 2013, with no language restrictions.

STUDY SELECTION

Papers were included if they met the following criteria: (1) the study population included non-smoking pregnant women exposed to SHS, (2) the clinical interventions were intended to reduce SHS exposure at home, (3) the study included a control group and (4) outcomes included either reduced SHS exposure of non-smoking pregnant women at home or quit rates among smoking partners during the pregnancy of the woman.

DATA EXTRACTION

Two coders independently reviewed each abstract or full text to identify eligible papers. Two abstractors independently coded papers based on US Preventive Services Task Force criteria for study quality (good, fair, poor), and studies without biochemically-verified outcome measures were considered poor quality.

DATA SYNTHESIS

From 4670 papers, we identified five studies that met our inclusion criteria: four focused on reducing SHS exposure among non-smoking pregnant women, and one focused on providing cessation support for smoking partners of pregnant women. All were randomised controlled trials, and all reported positive findings. Three studies were judged poor quality because outcome measures were not biochemically-verified, and two were considered fair quality.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinical interventions delivered in prenatal care settings appear to reduce SHS exposure, but study weaknesses limit our ability to draw firm conclusions. More rigorous studies, using biochemical validation, are needed to identify strategies for reducing SHS exposure in pregnant women.

Smoking cessation during pregnancy: the influence of partners, family and friends on quitters and non-quitters

This research compared pregnant quitters' and non-quitters' accounts of how partners, family and friends influenced their smoking cessation attempts. Qualitative secondary data analysis was carried out on a purposive sample of motivational interview transcripts undertaken by research midwives with pregnant women as part of SmokeChange, a smoking cessation intervention. Interviews with all quitters in the intervention group (n = 12) were analysed comparatively with interviews from a matched sample of non-quitters (n = 12).The discourses of both revealed similarity in how their partners, family and friends influenced their cessation efforts: salient others were simultaneously perceived by both groups of women as providing drivers and barriers to quit attempts; close associates who smoked were often perceived to be as supportive as those who did not. However, women who quit smoking during pregnancy talked more about receiving active praise/encouragement than those who did not. While close associates play an important role in women's attempts to stop smoking during pregnancy, the support they provide varies; further research is needed to develop a better understanding of how key relationships help or hinder cessation during pregnancy.

Intelligence in girls and their subsequent smoking behaviour as mothers: the 1958 National Child Development Study and the 1970 British Cohort Study

BACKGROUND

Exposure to tobacco smoke either in utero or postnatally can have substantial adverse effects on child health, yet many women continue to smoke during pregnancy and after the birth. How women's intelligence in childhood affects their smoking behaviour as mothers is unclear.

METHODS

The participants were from two British national birth cohorts: 3325 women aged 33 years from the 1958 National Child Development Study and 1971 women aged 34 years from the 1970 British Cohort Study. We used structural equation modelling to examine the direct and indirect effects of intelligence measured at age 10-11 years, parental and current social class, educational attainment and age at first birth on smoking during pregnancy and current smoking status.

RESULTS

Forty per cent of women in the 1958 cohort smoked during pregnancy, compared with 28% of those from the 1970 cohort. In both cohorts, women with lower IQ in childhood were more likely as adults to smoke during pregnancy and to be a smoker currently. Structural equation modelling showed that the effects of childhood IQ on smoking behaviour were indirect, as they were statistically mediated by educational attainment and age at first birth. There was some effect of educational attainment and age at first birth on smoking behaviour over and above the effect of intelligence.

CONCLUSION

Childhood intelligence influenced women's smoking behaviour as mothers primarily through its contributions to educational attainment and age at first birth.

Predictors of smoking cessation during pregnancy among the women of Yamato and Ayase municipalities in Japan

Cigarette smoking during pregnancy affects the unborn fetus. This study aimed to investigate: (1) the smoking status of pregnant women before, during and after pregnancy in the Yamato and Ayase municipalities, Kanagawa, Japan; (2) the characteristics that differentiate successful spontaneous smoking quitters from continuous smokers during pregnancy; and (3) the awareness of risks of smoking that may influence smoking cessation during pregnancy. A community-based, cross-sectional survey of 420 postpartum women, who delivered their babies from July 2002 to October 2002, was performed. Out of 420 respondents, 275 (65.4%) did not smoke before and during pregnancy. Of the 145 women who smoked before pregnancy, 101 (69.3%) quit successfully while pregnant. Smoking prevalence during pregnancy was 10.4%. Out of 101 successful quitters during pregnancy, 22 (21.8%) women resumed smoking after childbirth. A multiple regression analysis showed that the independent predictors of smoking cessation during pregnancy were primiparous women and women living with non-smokers in the household. Although maternal age predicted smoking cessation in a simple regression analysis, this predictive value was lost in the multiple analysis. A simple analysis showed no significant association between the awareness of smoking risks and smoking cessation during pregnancy. It is suggested that Japanese smokers are more likely to quit while pregnant than women in other countries. In the future, smoking cessation programmes should be designed to help multiparous women and women living with smokers to give up smoking.