Altered airway responsiveness in adult sheep born prematurely: effects of allergen exposure

Improving pregnancy outcomes in humans through studies in sheep

Experimental studies that are relevant to human pregnancy rely on the selection of appropriate animal models as an important element in experimental design. Consideration of the strengths and weaknesses of any animal model of human disease is fundamental to effective and meaningful translation of preclinical research. Studies in sheep have made significant contributions to our understanding of the normal and abnormal development of the fetus. As a model of human pregnancy, studies in sheep have enabled scientists and clinicians to answer questions about the etiology and treatment of poor maternal, placental, and fetal health and to provide an evidence base for translation of interventions to the clinic. The aim of this review is to highlight the advances in perinatal human medicine that have been achieved following translation of research using the pregnant sheep and fetus.

Induced preterm birth in sheep: a suitable model for studying the developmental effects of moderately preterm birth

Our aim was to characterize an ovine model of preterm birth that allows analysis of the developmental effects of preterm birth in the absence of postnatal confounding factors. Preterm birth was induced at 131 days of gestation in 82 lambs; controls (n = 31) were born at term (145 days). Overall survival of preterm lambs was 60%; males had significantly lower survival than females (44% vs 76%); 94% of term lambs survived. Although the birth weight of preterm lambs was approximately 0.9 kg lower than in term lambs, the crown-to-rump and forelimb lengths were similar. At 9 weeks after term-equivalent age, there were no differences in body weight or dimensions between preterm and term lambs; when adjusted for body weight, the heart was 21% heavier in preterm than term lambs. We conclude that moderately preterm birth in sheep is characterized by a greater survival of female lambs than males and has significant effects on organ development.

Lung function in developing lambs: is it affected by preterm birth?

Children born before term often have reduced lung function, but the effects of preterm birth alone are difficult to determine owing to iatrogenic factors such as mechanical ventilation. Our objective was to determine the effects of preterm birth alone on airway resistance, airway reactivity, and ventilatory heterogeneity as an index of intrapulmonary gas mixing. Preterm birth was induced in sheep 12 days before term; controls were born at term (∼147 days). Lung function was assessed at 8 wk postterm. To assess medium-large airway function we measured airway resistance and reactivity to carbachol. Multiple breath N2 washout (MBW) was used to assess ventilatory heterogeneity in conducting (Scond) and acinar (Sacin) airways. Baseline airway resistance and responsiveness to carbachol were similar in preterm and term lambs. Airway responsiveness to carbachol was greater in females than males ( P < 0.05), and baseline airway resistance tended to be higher in females than males ( P = 0.06). There were no significant differences in ventilatory heterogeneity between preterm and term lambs; for all animals combined, mean Sacin was 0.29 ± 0.05 liter−1 and Scond was 0.26 ± 0.03 liter−1. Males had significantly higher Scond than females, indicating poorer gas mixing in small conducting airways; there was no sex difference in Sacin. We conclude that preterm birth per se in lambs does not affect baseline airway resistance, airway responsiveness, or ventilatory heterogeneity as measured by MBW. The observed sex-related differences in airway responsiveness and ventilatory heterogeneity in the conducting airways could help explain sex differences in lung function observed in humans.

Immune response to allergens in sheep sensitized to house dust mite

Background

House dust mite (HDM) allergens are a major cause of allergic asthma. Most studies using animal models of allergic asthma have used rodents sensitized with the 'un-natural' allergen ovalbumin. It has only recently been recognized that the use of animal models based on HDM provide a more relevant insight into the allergen-induced mechanisms that underpin human allergic disease. We have previously described a sheep model of human allergic asthma that uses Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus HDM. The present study extends our understanding of the immune effects of HDM and the allergens Der p 1 and Der p 2 in the sheep model of asthma.

Methods

Peripheral blood sera from non-sensitized (control) sheep and sheep sensitized to HDM was collected to determine immunoglobulin (Ig) reactivities to HDM, Der p 1 and Der p 2 by ELISA. Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid collected following allergen challenge was also assessed for the presence of HDM-specific antibodies. To examine the cellular immune response to HDM allergens, T cell proliferation and cutaneous responses were assessed in sensitized and control sheep.

Results

Strong HDM- and Der p 1-specific IgE, IgG₁, IgG₂ and IgA serum responses were observed in sensitized sheep, while detectable levels of HDM-specific IgG₁ and IgA were seen in BAL fluid of allergen-challenged lungs. In contrast, minimal antibody reactivity was observed to Der p 2. Marked T cell proliferation and late phase cutaneous responses, accompanied by the recruitment of eosinophils, indicates the induction of a cellular and delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) type II response by HDM and Der p 1 allergen, but not Der p 2.

Conclusion

This work characterizes the humoral and cellular immune effects of HDM extract and its major constituent allergens in sheep sensitized to HDM. The effects of allergen in HDM-sensitized sheep were detectable both locally and systemically, and probably mediated via enzymatic and immune actions of the major HDM allergen Der p 1. This study extends our understanding of the actions of this important allergen relevant to human allergic asthma and its effects in sheep experimentally sensitized to HDM allergens.

Does moderate preterm birth lead to altered arterial pressure? Studies in sheep

1. Low birth weight (LBW) is associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease. Preterm birth is a major determinant of LBW and has been shown to result in elevated arterial pressure (AP) in humans, but few studies have investigated the effects of preterm birth in the absence of potentially confounding factors. Our aim was to determine whether moderately preterm birth per se alters the postnatal development of AP in lambs. 2. Preterm lambs were delivered approximately 14 days before term (i.e. approximately 133 days of gestation); controls were born at term (approximately 147 days). Mean arterial pressure (MAP), heart rate (HR), blood composition and indices of growth were measured at 4 and 8 weeks post term-equivalent age (PTEA). We also studied a separate cohort of preterm and term sheep as young adults (approximately 1.1 years). 3. Preterm lambs had significantly lower birth weights than term lambs, but bodyweights were not significantly different by Day 12 PTEA. In addition, MAP, HR and most blood variables did not differ between term and preterm lambs at 4 or 8 weeks PTEA. Preterm birth per se did not alter MAP or HR in young adult sheep. 4. Low birth weight due to preterm birth does not result in an altered AP during early postnatal life or at maturity. Moderate intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) due to twinning, which further reduces birth weight, does not affect MAP in preterm lambs. Other factors, such as the degree of prematurity or IUGR, exposure to corticosteroids or postnatal nutrition, may be important in the later development of elevated AP.

Postnatal growth rate, but not mild preterm birth, influences airway structure in adult sheep challenged with house dust mite

The authors recently showed that preterm birth per se, in the absence of assisted ventilation or elevated inhaled oxygen levels, alters the structure of the airway walls in young lambs. The initial aim of the present study was to determine whether these changes persist into adulthood. Preterm (P; n = 7) lambs were delivered 14 days before term and compared with control lambs (C; n = 8) born at term ( approximately 147 days). After weaning, the sheep were kept as a flock with daily exposure to pasture until approximately 1.2 years old. All sheep were sensitized to house dust mite extract and then given aerosol challenges with house dust mite 10 to 12 weeks before autopsy. At autopsy, the right lung was fixed in neutral-buffered formalin at an inflation pressure of 20 cm H(2)O. The architecture of the walls of airway generations 4, 6, and 8 and the bronchioles was assessed by computer-aided image analysis of histological sections of airway walls cut in cross-section. Morphometric analysis showed that preterm birth per se had no significant effect on airway wall structure. Within both groups (preterm and term), we identified animals that grew at different growth rates after birth; a second aim, therefore, was to determine the influence of postnatal growth rates on airway structure at maturity. The 15 sheep were divided into 2 groups based on nonoverlapping growth rates between birth and 200 days of age: slower growing sheep (SG; n = 7) gained 102 +/- 5 g/day and faster growing sheep (FG; n = 8) gained 197 +/- 14 g/day (P < .01). In SG sheep, the pulmonary airways had thinner walls and less smooth muscle in relation to basement membrane perimeter. The airway epithelium was also thinner in the SG sheep. In the bronchiolar epithelium, there were fewer goblet cells and Clara cells in SG compared to FG sheep. We conclude that the early effects of preterm birth on the airway epithelium do not persist to maturity. However, slow growth after birth results in altered airway development, with effects persisting to maturity.

Lung parenchyma at maturity is influenced by postnatal growth but not by moderate preterm birth in sheep

BACKGROUND

We have recently shown that moderate preterm birth, in the absence of respiratory support, altered the structure of lung parenchyma in young lambs, but the long-term effects are unknown.

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether structural changes persist to maturity, and whether postnatal growth affects lung structure at maturity in sheep.

METHODS

At approximately 1.2 years after birth, lung parenchyma of sheep born 14 days before term (n = 7) was stereologically compared with that of controls born at term (n = 8, term approx. 146 days).

RESULTS

Preterm birth per se had no significant effect on lung volume, alveolar number and size, and thicknesses of the alveolar walls and blood-gas barrier. After combining the preterm and term groups, we examined the effects of postnatal growth rates on lung parenchyma. Slower-growing sheep (SG; n = 7: 4 preterm, 3 term) were compared with faster-growing sheep (FG; n = 8: 3 preterm, 5 term). At approximately 1.2 years, the right lung volume, relative to body weight, was significantly lower in SG than FG sheep (p < 0.05) and alveolar number was significantly lower by approximately 44%. The total alveolar internal surface area of the right lung of SG sheep was 38% smaller than in FG sheep; it was also significantly lower when related to both lung and body weight.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest that moderate preterm birth does not cause persistent alterations in lung parenchyma. However, slow postnatal growth in low-birth-weight sheep results in smaller lungs with fewer alveoli and a lower alveolar surface area relative to body weight.