The effects of a standard elliptical vs. a modified elliptical with a converging footpath on lower limb kinematics and muscle activity

Movement direction impacts knee joint kinematics during elliptical exercise at varying incline angles

BACKGROUND

Elliptical trainers are a popular cardiovascular exercise for individuals with injuries or those post-operation. There is currently limited data on the impacts of direction while on elliptical trainers for knee joint kinematic risk factors. This study compared lower extremity kinematics between the forward and reverse direction at varying inclines on an elliptical trainer modified with converging footpath and reduced inter-pedal distance.

METHODS

Twenty-four college age participants exercised on the modified elliptical in both directions at four ramp inclines: 6°, 12°, 25°, and 35°. Three-dimensional kinematics were collected for each direction and ramp incline. A 2 × 4 (direction × incline) repeated measures analysis of variance was run with an alpha of 0.05. Simple effects analysis was run with Bonferroni correction for significant interaction or main effect of ramp incline.

RESULTS

The reverse direction had significantly greater peak knee valgus at 6° incline (mean difference [MD] = 1.35°, p < 0.014, d = 0.31) and 12° (MD = 2.41°, p < 0.001, d = 0.55), peak hip abduction at 6° (MD = 2.86°, p = 0.002, d = 0.49) and 12° (MD = 2.91°, p < 0.001, d = 0.51), but decreased peak knee flexion angles (p = 0.032) at all inclines.

CONCLUSIONS

Individuals with knee pathologies such as knee osteoarthritis or anterior knee pain should exercise in the reverse direction at lower inclines. However, switching to the forward direction and/or increasing incline may increase quadriceps strength during a safe activity such as elliptical trainers.