Endoscopic endonasal surgery for Clival Chordomas - a single institution experience and short term outcomes

Outcomes of Endoscopic Resection in Pediatric Skull Base Chordoma: A Systematic Review

The endoscopic approach has been recommended as a primary option for treating chordomas, and it is associated with better resection rates and fewer surgical complications than transcranial surgery. This review aimed to assess the long-term consequences and evidence in the current literature regarding the endoscopic approach's efficacy in treating skull-base chordoma in children. A systematic review was conducted based on the PubMed, Web of Science, and EMBASE databases to examine the clinical outcomes of endoscopic endonasal surgery for pediatric skull base chordoma tumors. The review included studies published in English that employed specific research designs and reported on pediatric patients with skull base chordoma. Of the 268 studies initially considered, 25 met our eligibility criteria and were included in the final analysis. The average age of the patients was 11.5 years, with approximately equal number of males and females. The endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) was the most commonly used modality. Gross total resection (GTR) was achieved in 62.7% of patients, while 18.09% had a subtotal resection (STR), and 13.83% had near-total resection only. Most patients showed significant to moderate improvement from their baseline condition and had no recurrence during their follow-up. Our findings further endorse that the endoscopic approach is a viable primary treatment option for pediatric skull base chordoma.

Clival Chordomas in the Endoscopic Endonasal Era: Comparison With Management With Open Skull Base Approaches

BACKGROUND

The most significant paradigm shift in surgical management of skull base chordomas has been the adoption of the endoscopic endonasal approach, but the impact on patient outcomes compared with open skull base approaches remains unclear.

OBJECTIVE

To compare a large series of patients treated by a single surgeon using primarily endoscopic endonasal approaches with previously published outcomes by the same surgeon using open skull base approaches.

METHODS

Between 2006 and 2020, 68 patients with skull base chordoma underwent resection using primarily endoscopic endonasal approaches. Outcomes and complications were compared with previously published results of resection of chordomas from 1991 to 2005 using open skull base approaches.

RESULTS

Compared with the prior cohort, the current principally endoscopic cohort demonstrated similar rates of OS ( P = .86) and progression-free survival ( P = .56), but patients undergoing first-time resection had significantly higher rates of radical resection (82.9% compared with 64.3%, P = .05) and required fewer staged surgeries (9.8% compared with 33.3%, P = .01).

CONCLUSION

There was no difference in survival rates for patients treated in the current era, primarily using endoscopic endonasal techniques, compared with previously published results using open skull-base approaches by the same surgeon. Although use of endoscopic endonasal approach resulted in higher rates of radical resection, patients undergoing first-time resection and fewer staged surgeries were required.

Reconstruction and Cerebrospinal Fluid Leaks in Endoscopic Endonasal Approach for the Management of Clival Chordomas-A Systematic Review

The success of the endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) to surgically manage clival chordomas (CC) relies on robust repair methods to reduce complications, such as cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leaks. Our study aims to evaluate the existing literature to assess reconstructive techniques utilised and post-operative CSF leak rates in this cohort. A systematic review and analysis was performed of all published data related to CC patients managed with an EEA. A total of 24 articles were included, representing 363 patients and 396 procedures. A variety of reconstruction methods were used with 95.9% of studies using an intracranial repair graft, 70.8% using a nasoseptal flap (NSF), 62.5% using glue/haemostat, 58.3% using nasal packs and 75.0% employing multi-layered reconstruction. Post-operative CSF leak rate was 10.1%. The leak rate was less in subgroups where a NSF was used (9.4%) although this was not statistically significant (p = 0.273). There were no differences in leak rates when glue/haemostat (p = 0.139) or nasal packs (p = 0.550) were used. Our review is the most up-to-date synthesis of the existing literature surrounding the EEA to CCs assessing reconstruction and post-operative CSF leaks. It demonstrates most authors employ a multi-layered reconstruction method. The lack of statistical significance observed for CSF leaks in subgroups is likely due to a variety of cofounding surgeon and patient factors. Higher quality prospective randomised multi-centric studies, with reporting of specific repair techniques will enable future systematic reviews to provide a more accurate consensus regarding optimal methods of reconstruction in this field.

Usefulness of endoscope-assisted surgery under exoscopic view in skull base surgery: A technical note

Background:

The use of the exoscope has been increasing in the field of neurosurgery, as it can set the visual axis freely, enabling the surgeon to operate in a comfortable posture. Although endoscope-assisted surgery for compensation of insufficient surgical field is useful under the microscope, we report that using an endoscope in exoscopic surgery is safer and more useful.

Methods:

The exoscope used was ORBEYE. All surgical procedures were performed exoscopically from the beginning of the surgery. When endoscopic observation was required during the operation, the endoscope was inserted under observation by an exoscope. The exoscopic screen was 4K-3D and endoscopic screen was 4K-2D, the operation was performed while observing both screens at the same time. The endoscope was held manually or by a mechanical holder.

Results:

Twenty-two cases, including 14 requiring microvascular decompression (MVD) and eight requiring tumor removal, were performed by endoscopic-assisted exoscopic surgery. The endoscope could be inserted safely because its relationship with the surrounding structure could be observed under the exoscope, and the operator could observe both screens without moving the head. Fourteen of 22 patients required additional endoscopic treatment. Satisfactory two-handed operation was performed in 13 cases. Symptomatology disappeared in all cases of MVD, and sufficient tumor resection was achieved.

Conclusion:

Exoscopic surgery provides excellent surgical view that is not inferior to conventional microsurgery. As a large space can be secured between the scope and the surgical field, it is safer and easier to manipulate the endoscope under the exoscope.

Contemporary surgical management of skull base chordomas - anatomical reflections on a single center experience retrospective case series

Chordoma, a rare, locally aggressive tumor can affect the central skull base, usually centered at the midline. Complete surgical resection remains mainstay of therapy in case of primary as well as recurrent tumors. Owing to their secluded location, surgical resection of skull base chordomas remains a challenge, even though the recent advancement of endoscopic endonasal approaches has had a significant positive impact on the management of these patients. Endoscopic endonasal approaches have been shown to significantly reduce surgical morbidity when compared to traditional open approaches, however the classical endoscopic transclival midline approach fails to sufficiently expose parts of many skull base chordomas. More recent refinements of the technique, such as the interdural pituitary transposition and posterior clinoidectomy, the transpterygoid plate approach and the transcondylar far medial (TFM) approach enable the surgeon the increase the resection rate in these patients. This retrospective case series focuses on anatomical aspects in the surgical management of patients with skull base chordomas. We outline the surgical anatomy of contemporary endoscopic approaches to the skull base based intraoperative illustrations as well as pre- and postoperative 3D reconstructed CT and MR images if our patients. This article should help the clinical choose the most appropriate approach and be aware of relevant anatomy as well as potential shortcomings of a given approach.

Surgical Outcomes of Clival Chordoma Through Endoscopic Endonasal Approach: A Single-Center Experience

OBJECTIVE

Clival chordoma is a locally aggressive tumor with low metastatic potential. In the past decade, endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) for clival chordoma has had a higher resection rate and a lower morbidity rate than transcranial approaches. Here, we present our initial single-center experience after EEA of clival chordomas.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This study retrospectively analyzed 17 consecutive patients with clival chordoma who received EEA in our department between March 2015 and September 2021. The operation was performed by a single surgeon with EEA. The clinical and pathological characteristics were analyzed along with the surgical outcomes and complications.

RESULTS

A total of 17 consecutive patients with clival chordoma received EEA with a median follow-up of 29.2 months (range 1-79). Gross total resection (GTR) was performed in 7 cases (41%), subtotal resection (STR) in 7 case (41%) and partially resection (PR) in 3 cases (18%). Cerebrospinal fluid leakage occurred in 2 cases (12%) and meningitis developed in 3 patients (18%) which were all successfully treated with intravenous antibiotics without any complications. There were no perioperative deaths or new focal neurological deficits postoperatively. Four in 7 patients with STR have had radiotherapy while the other three chose to be monitored. Till the last follow-up, three patients in STR group who received radiotherapy (3 in 4) had no tumor regrowth, while one in STR group with radiotherapy (1 in 4) showed tumor progression. Two patients in STR group without radiotherapy (2 in 3) showed stable tumor while the left one (1 in 3) showed tumor progression. One patient in the PR group died of tumor progression 2 years postoperation and the other one showed tumor progression and died of lung cancer 1 year postoperation. In addition, 1 in 7 patients with GTR had tumor recurrence in situ after 10 months and developed surgical pathway seeding in the spinal canal in C1 after 16 months. No recurrence occurred in the other 6 cases with GTR during the follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Although more cases are needed, our case series showed EEA is a safe and reliable method for clival chordoma with high resection rates and low morbidity rates. GTR without tumor residuum would improve the outcome.

Endoscopic endonasal approach for loco-regional recurrent clivus chordomas

•

EEA represents an ideal approach for loco-regional recurrent CCs.

•

EEA is well tolerated, with preservation of patients QoL.

•

EEA can be considered for patients with perspectives of adjuvant therapies.

•

Otherwise, EEA can be considered only in selected cases with a palliative aim.

Craniovertebral junction chordomas: Case series and strategies to overcome the surgical challenge

Introduction:

Chordomas are rare and malignant primary bone tumors. Different strategies have been proposed for chordomas involving the craniovertebral junction (CVJ) compared to other locations. The impossibility to achieve en bloc excision, the impact on stability and the need for proper reconstruction make their surgical management challenging.

Objective:

The objective is to discuss surgical strategies in CVJ chordomas operated in a single-center during a 7 years' experience (2013-2019).

Methods:

Adult patients with CVJ chordoma were retrospectively analyzed. The clinical, radiological, pathological, and surgical data were discussed.

Results:

A total number of 8 patients was included (among a total number of 32 patients suffering from skull base chordoma). Seven patients underwent endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA), and posterior instrumentation was needed in three cases. Three explicative cases were reported: EEA for midline tumor involving lower clivus and upper cervical spine (case 1), EEA and complemental posterior approach for occurred occipitocervical instability (case 2), C2 chordoma which required aggressive bone removal and consequent implant positioning, focusing on surgical planning (timing and type of surgical stages, materials and customization of fixation system) (case 3).

Conclusion:

EEA could represent a safe route to avoid injuries to neurovascular structure in clival locations, while a combined approach could be considered when tumor spreads laterally. Tumor involvement or surgical procedures could give raise to CVJ instability with the need of complementary posterior instrumentation. Thus, a tailored preoperative planning should play a key role, especially when aggressive bone removal and implant positioning are needed.

Additive Manufacturing for Personalized Skull Base Reconstruction in Endoscopic Transclival Surgery: A Proof-of-Concept Study

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic transnasal transclival intradural surgery is limited by a high postoperative cerebrospinal fluid leak rate. The aim of this study was to investigate the role of three-dimensional printing to create a personalized, rigid scaffold for clival reconstruction.

METHODS

Two different types of clivectomy were performed in 5 specimens with the aid of neuronavigation, and 11 clival reconstructions were simulated. They were repaired with polylactide, three-dimensional-printed scaffolds that were manually designed in a computer-aided environment based either on the real or on the predicted defect. Scaffolds were printed with a fused filament fabrication technique and different offsets. They were positioned and fixed either following the gasket seal technique or with screws. Postdissection radiological evaluation of scaffold position was performed in all cases. In 3 specimens, the cerebrospinal fluid leak pressure point was measured immediately after reconstruction.

RESULTS

The production process took approximately 30 hours. The designed scaffolds were satisfactory when no offset was added. Wings were added during the design to allow for screw positioning, but broke in 30% of cases. Radiological assessment documented maximal accuracy of scaffold positioning when the scaffold was created on the real defect; accuracy was satisfactory when the predicted clivectomy was performed under neuronavigation guidance. The cerebrospinal fluid leak pressure point was significantly higher when the scaffold was fixed with screws compared with the gasket technique.

CONCLUSIONS

In this preclinical setting, additive manufacturing allows the creation of customized scaffolds that are effective in reconstructing even large and geometrically complex clival defects.

A third hand to the surgeon: the use of an endoscope holding arm in endonasal sinus surgery and well beyond

BACKGROUND

Extended endoscopic endonasal operations of the sinuses and the frontal skull base require a bimanual action of the surgeon in many cases. Thus, typically an assistant guides the endoscope and centers the field of view. In this study, we investigate in which cases an endoscope holding arm can be used alternatively.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The electromagnetic system ENDOFIXexo was used in different surgical interventions of the paranasal sinuses and beyond questioning ergonomics and geometrical limitations. The realized degrees of freedom were documented, and a topography of possible applications compiled.

RESULTS

The presented system is limited by the anatomy of the anterior ethmoid and dynamic working conditions in the sagittal direction. Especially in extended interventions in the posterior ethmoid, in which parts of the nasal septum have been resected and a static position of the endoscope is desired the surgeon can greatly benefit from the robotic arm. Moreover, through the high flexibility of the endoscopic arm surgeries of the pharynx and larynx were performed, questioning the current gold standard of microscope-assisted surgical procedures.

CONCLUSION

Under the impression of an urging staff shortage and due to its unlimited patience, the ENDOFIXexo arm seems promising. Taking into account the complex anatomy and the limited access, we especially see a favorable field of application in the surgery of the pituitary gland and skull base tumors.

Endoscopic Endonasal Approach in Clival Chordoma Surgery: Case Series

Chordomas are rare and slow-growing locally destructive bone tumors that can develop in the craniospinal axis. It is commonly found in the sacrococcygeal region whereas only 25-35% are found in the clival region. Headache with neurological deficits are the most common clinical presentations. Complete surgical resection either via open or endoscopic endonasal approaches are the main mode of treatment. Here, we report a series of 5 cases of clival chordomas which was managed via endoscopic endonasal approaches in our center. A retrospective analysis of patients who had undergone endoscopic endonasal resection of clival chordoma in Sarawak General Hospital from 2014 to 2018. A total of 5 cases were operated on endoscopically via a combine effort of both the otorhinolaryngology team and the neurosurgical team during the study period from year 2013 to 2018. From our patient, 2 were female and 3 were male patients. The main clinical presentation was headache, squinting of eye and nasopharyngeal fullness. All our patient had endoscopic endonasal debulking of clival tumor done, with average of hospital stay from 9 - 23 days. Pos-operatively, patients were discharged back well. Endoscopic endonasal resection of clival chordomas gives good surgical resection results with low morbidity rates and therefore can be considered as a surgical option in centers where the surgical specialties are available.