Effects of experimental immunosuppression on reovirus‐induced tenosynovitis in light‐hybrid chickens

Whole Genomic Constellation of Avian Reovirus Strains Isolated from Broilers with Arthritis in North Carolina, USA

Avian reovirus (ARV) is an emerging pathogen which causes significant economic challenges to the chicken and turkey industry in the USA and globally, yet the molecular characterization of most ARV strains is restricted to a single particular gene, the sigma C gene. The genome of arthrogenic reovirus field isolates (R18-37308 and R18-38167), isolated from broiler chickens in North Carolina (NC), USA in 2018, was sequenced using long-read next-generation sequencing (NGS). The isolates were genotyped based on the amino acid sequence of sigma C (σC) followed by phylogenetic and amino acid analyses of the other 11 genomically encoded proteins for whole genomic constellation and genetic variation detection. The genomic length of the NC field strains was 23,494 bp, with 10 dsRNA segments ranging from 3959 bp (L1) to 1192 bp (S4), and the 5' and 3' untranslated regions (UTRs) of all the segments were found to be conserved. R18-37308 and R18-38167 were found to belong to genotype (G) VI based on the σC analysis and showed nucleotide and amino acid sequence identity ranging from 84.91-98.47% and 83.43-98.46%, respectively, with G VI strains. Phylogenetic analyses of individual genes of the NC strains did not define a single common ancestor among the available completely sequenced ARV strains. Nevertheless, most sequences supported the Chinese strain LY383 as a probable ancestor of these isolates. Moreover, amino acid analysis revealed multiple amino acid substitution events along the entirety of the genes, some of which were unique to each strain, which suggests significant divergence owing to the accumulation of point mutations. All genes from R18-37308 and R18-38167 were found to be clustered within genotypic clusters that included only ARVs of chicken origin, which negates the possibility of genetic pooling or host variation. Collectively, this study revealed sequence divergence between the NC field strains and reference ARV strains, including the currently used vaccine strains could help updating the vaccination regime through the inclusion of these highly divergent circulating indigenous field isolates.

Development of a multivalent adjuvanted inactivated vaccine against variant arthrotropic avian reoviruses

Variant avian reoviruses (ARVs) are economically important emerging pathogens of poultry, which mainly affect young broiler chickens and cause significant production losses. Currently, there are no effective commercial vaccines available for control and prevention of emerging variant ARVs. In this study, monovalent inactivated adjuvated (20% Emulsigen D) broiler breeder vaccines containing antigens from ARV genotype cluster (C) group -2, -4, -5, or -6, and a multivalent vaccine containing antigens from all the four indicated genotypic cluster groups were developed and evaluated for their efficacy in protecting broiler progenies against homologous or heterologous ARV challenge. The use of monovalent or multivalent inactivated vaccines in a prime-boost immunization strategy induced the production of ARV specific antibodies in broiler breeders. The maternal antibodies were effectively transferred to broiler progenies. Broiler progenies obtained from immunized breeders demonstrated milder clinical symptoms and reduced gross and histopathological lesions after homologous ARV challenge. More severe gross and histological lesions were observed in challenged progenies from unvaccinated broiler breeders. However, cross protection was not observed when either of the monovalent-vaccine groups were challenged with a heterologous virus. In addition, the progenies from the unvaccinated ARV challenged control or heterologous ARV challenged vaccinated groups had significantly reduced body weight gain (p < 0.01) than the unchallenged-control, challenged-multivalent, or homologous ARV-challenged monovalent vaccine groups. However, homologous ARV challenged progenies in the multivalent or monovalent vaccine groups had similar body weight gain as the control unchallenged group with significantly reduced viral load (p < 0.01) in the gastrocnemius tendon tissue. This study indicates that broad-spectrum protection of broiler progenies from variant ARV infections is feasible through the development of multivalent vaccines after proper characterization, selection and incorporation of multiple antigens based on circulating ARV genotypes in targeted regions.

Molecular Characterization of Variant Avian Reoviruses and Their Relationship with Antigenicity and Pathogenicity

Avian reovirus variants (ARVs) are important pathogens currently causing losses in poultry production. These variants escape protection elicited by conventional vaccines, i.e., S1133, 2408, and 1733 in chickens. Historically, ARVs have been classified according to their antigenic type and relative pathogenicity. Due to the virus variability, antigenic testing is difficult and laboratory specific, while pathotyping is costly and complex. Current molecular classification methods focus only on one gene, and genomic changes within this gene are not predictive of changes in antigenicity and pathogenicity. This review focuses on existing literature on reovirus antigenicity, pathogenicity, and molecular assessments as an aid to provide insights on how to predict antigenic and pathogenic phenotypes based on genomic information and future focus on development of new and comprehensive classification systems.

Infection and transmission dynamics of Turkey arthritis reovirus in different age Turkeys

Turkey arthritis reovirus (TARV) has been established as a cause of lameness in meat type turkeys in the past decade. However, no information is available on the age susceptibility of TARV or its transmission dynamics. We conducted this study to determine the age at which turkey poults are susceptible to TARV infection and whether infected birds can horizontally transmit the virus to their non-infected pen mates (sentinels). Five groups of turkeys were orally inoculated with TARV (∼10⁶ TCID₅₀/ml) at 2, 7, 14, 21 and 28 days of age (DOA). Two days after each challenge, four uninfected sentinel turkeys of equal age were added to the virus-inoculated groups. At one- and two-weeks post infection, turkeys from each group, including two sentinels, were euthanized followed by necropsy. Inoculated birds in all age groups had TARV replication in the intestine and gastrocnemius tendon with no statistically significant variation at p < 0.5. Furthermore, the inoculated birds at different age groups showed consistently high gastrocnemius tendon histologic lesion scores while birds in the 28-days-old age group had numerically lower lesion scores at 14 days post inoculation (dpi). The sentinels, in turn, also showed virus replication in their intestines and tendons and histologic lesions in gastrocnemius tendons. The findings indicate that turkeys at the age of 28 days or less are susceptible to infection with TARV following oral challenge. It was also found that TARV-infected birds could transmit the infection to naïve sentinel turkeys of the same age.

Virulence of Emerging Arthrotropic Avian Reoviruses Correlates With Their Ability to Activate and Traffic Interferon-γ Producing Cytotoxic CD8+ T Cells Into Gastrocnemius Tendon

Newly emerging arthrotropic avian reoviruses (ARVs) are genetically divergent, antigenically heterogeneous, and economically costly. Nevertheless, the mechanism of emerging ARV-induced disease pathogenesis and potential differences in virulence between virus genotypes have not been adequately addressed. In this study, the life cycle of ARV, including the formation of cytoplasmic ARV neo-organelles, paracrystalline structures, and virus release mechanisms, were characterized in the infected host cell by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). In addition, progressive changes in the structure of infected cells were investigated by time-lapse and field emission scanning electron (FE-SE) microscopy. ARVs from the four genotypic cluster groups included in the study caused gross and microscopic lesions in the infected birds. Marked infiltration of γδT cells, CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T lymphocytes were observed in ARV infected tendon tissues starting day 3 post-infection. The ARV variant from genotype cluster-2 triggered significantly high trafficking of IFN-γ producing CD8⁺ T lymphocytes in tendon tissues and concomitantly showed high morbidity and severe disease manifestations. In contrast, the ARV variant from genotype cluster-4 was less virulent, caused milder disease, and accompanied less infiltration of IFN-γ producing CD8⁺ T cells. Interestingly, when we blunted antiviral immune responses using clodronate liposomes (which depletes antigen-presenting cells) or cyclosporin (which inhibits cytokine production that regulates T-cell proliferation), significantly lower IFN-γ producing CD8⁺ T cells infiltrated into tendon tissues, resulting in reduced tendon tissues apoptosis and milder disease manifestations. In summary, these data suggest that the degree of ARV virulence and tenosynovitis/arthritis are potentially directly associated with the ability of the virus to traffic massive infiltration of cytotoxic CD8⁺ T cells into the infected tissues. Moreover, the ability to traffic cytotoxic CD8⁺ T cells into infected tendon tissues and the severity of tenosynovitis differ between variants from different ARV genotype cluster groups. However, more than one virus isolate per genotype group needs to be tested to further confirm the association of pathogenicity with genotype. These findings can be used to further examine the interaction of viral and cellular pathways which are essential for the pathogenesis of the disease at the molecular level and to develop effective disease control strategies.

Efficacy and Immunogenicity of Recombinant Pichinde Virus-Vectored Turkey Arthritis Reovirus Subunit Vaccine

We created a recombinant live pichinde virus-vectored bivalent codon optimized subunit vaccine that expresses immunogenic Sigma C and Sigma B proteins of turkey arthritis reovirus. The vaccine virus could be transmitted horizontally immunizing the non-vaccinated pen mates. The vaccine was tested for efficacy against homologous (TARV SKM121) and heterologous (TARV O’Neil) virus challenge. Immunized poults produced serum neutralizing antibodies capable of neutralizing both viruses. The vaccinated and control birds showed similar body weights indicating no adverse effect on feed efficiency. Comparison of virus gene copy numbers in intestine and histologic lesion scores in tendons of vaccinated and non-vaccinated birds showed a decrease in the replication of challenge viruses in the intestine and tendons of vaccinated birds. These results indicate the potential usefulness of this vaccine.

Evaluation of Avian Reovirus S1133 Vaccine Strain in Neonatal Broiler Chickens in Gastrointestinal Integrity and Performance in a Large-Scale Commercial Field Trial

Avian reovirus (ARV) is the principal cause of several diseases. The vaccination of breeders allows for the control of viral arthritis and delivery of maternal-derived antibodies to the progeny. The vaccination of broiler chickens with ARV strain S1133 is used to prevent viral arthritis. However, the post-vaccination enteric effects have not been well-characterized. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of vaccination with the S1133 strain on the weight gain and feed conversion of broiler chickens and to characterize the gastric, enteric, and pancreatic lesions that the strain could induce. A total of 672,000 chickens were divided into two groups: a group vaccinated with ARV strain S1133 (S1133ARV) and a control group (not vaccinated). Upon histological analysis, the vaccine group showed less proventricular glandular tissue and atrophy of the pancreas and duodenal villi, as well as having a lower average daily profit. The conclusion based on the results of this investigation is that neonatal vaccination with S1133ARV causes atrophy of the pancreatic acini, proventricular glands, and intestinal villi, leading to an increased diameter of the glandular lumen and atrophy of the enteric villous, as well as weight loss, in broiler chickens.

Genetic characterization and pathogenicity of a divergent broiler-origin orthoreovirus causing arthritis in China

Since 2013, there have been an increasing number of cases of arthritis in broilers caused by avian orthoreovirus (ARV) in China, and the virus remains highly virulent in chicks with high-level maternal antibodies. However, little information is available about the complete gene analysis and pathogenicity of the epidemic ARVs. In the study, the ARV strain (V-ARV-SD26) was isolated from broilers associated with arthritis in Shandong Province. To genetically characterize the ARV strain, the whole-genome sequencing was conducted by next-generation sequencing (NGS) technique. Sequence analysis demonstrated that V-ARV-SD26 might have acquired its current genomic composition through several homologous and, in case of the λC, μA and σB, divergent reassortment events. To further investigate the pathogenicity of the strain, 160 one-day-old Ross broilers with maternal antibodies were equally divided into four groups (foodpad-, eye mucosa- and intramuscular-inoculated groups and the negative control group), three experimental groups were inoculated separately with the low-dose virus fluid, and the negative control was equally inoculated with sterile PBS. The results showed that the symptoms of broilers in foodpad inoculation group were the most serious, while that of the eye mucosa infection group were the mildest. Meanwhile, the cloacal cotton swabs and organs were collected for qRT-PCR detection to evaluate the infection status. In conclusion, these findings indicate that V-ARV-SD26 is a divergent ARV strain, which provide experimental data for the prevention and control of newly emerged reovirus, and have a certain reference value for the preparation and evaluation of new vaccines.

Partial Molecular Characterization and Pathogenicity Study of an Avian Reovirus Causing Tenosynovitis in Commercial Broilers

This study describes the molecular characterization of avian reoviruses (ARVs) isolated during an outbreak in commercial chickens between 2015 and 2016. In addition, a pathogenicity study of a selected ARV strain isolated from a field case of viral tenosynovitis in commercial broiler chickens was performed. On the basis of phylogenetic analysis of a 1088-bp fragment of the ARV S1 gene, the investigated sequences were differentiated into five distinct genotypic clusters (GCs), namely GC1, GC2, GC3, GC4, and GC6. Specific-pathogen-free (SPF) and commercial broiler chickens were challenged with the GC1 genetic type MK247011, at 14 days of age via the interdigital toe web. No significant effects in body weight gain and feed conversion were detected in both chicken types. The Δ interdigital web thickness was most severe at 4 days postchallenge (DPC) in both the SPF and broiler subgroups. The inflammation in SPF birds was slightly more severe compared with broilers. Neither mortality nor clinical signs occurred in the infected groups for the duration of the experiment, despite the presence of significant microscopic lesions in challenged birds. Microscopic changes of tenosynovitis became evident at 3 DPC, with the highest incidence and severity detected at 14 and 21 DPC, respectively. Seroconversion against ARV occurred 3 wk postchallenge, and the microscopic lesions detected in tendon and heart sections were highly compatible with those described in the field. Increased severity of tenosynovitis and epicarditis lesions were noted in the ARV-challenged groups compared with the control groups. Although SPF and broiler chickens showed comparable responses to the challenge with an ARV genetic variant, detected lesions were subclinical, denoting the limitations of our challenge approach. The age selected in this experiment possibly influenced the course of the infection. Data from this study highlight the genotypic diversity of isolates in California, and the outcome of the pathogenicity study can be used as a basis to improve protocols for pathogenicity studies to characterize ARV variants causing clinical disease in the field.

Pathogenicity of a variant duck orthoreovirus strain in Cherry Valley Ducklings

Since 2017, a disease that is characterized by spleen necrosis and swelling has emerged in China's main meat duck breeding provinces, this disease generally causes a large number of ducks to develop a poor mental state and either an increase or loss of appetite, as well as potentially resulting in death. Necrosis of spleen in this disease weakens the duck's immunity, therefore often leading to secondary infection. The net result of this is significant economic loss to China's duck breeding industry. In our previous research, we determined that the pathogen causing this disease is a new variant duck orthoreovirus (N-DRV). Because the morbidity and mortality rates of the isolate were higher than those of the previously reported strains, 180 healthy 1-day-old Cherry Valley ducklings were selected to be artificially infected in order to determine the pathogenicity of the strain. The weight gains of numbers of the infected group were significantly inhibited after they had been inoculated with the virus, which continued to detoxify in the blood and the cloaca. The main target organ of the virus is the spleen, although the virus can also attack the brain, this does not lead to any obvious pathology in this organ. These findings have enriched our understanding of the N-DRV-XT18 virus and have lain the foundation for further study of the pathogenic mechanism of this virus.

Isolation and genomic characterization of a novel chicken-orign orthoreovirus causing goslings hepatitis

A severe infectious disease characterized by nephritis, hepatitis and splenitis has attacked goslings around Shandong province in China since 2016. A novel chicken-origin avian orthoreovirus (ARV) was isolated with LMH cells from affected goslings named Reo/Goose/SDPY/1116/17 (SDPY-ARV) strain, and the infection was successfully reproduced experimentally. The ARV-SDPY full genome sequencing was conducted using Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) technique on Illumina HiSeq platform. The complete genome of SDPY-ARV was 23,427 bp in length and consist of 10 dsRNA segments ranged from 1192 bp (S4) to 3958 bp (L1) which encoding 12 viral proteins. Genomic sequence analysis showed that the SDPY-ARV strain is in the same branch with broiler, pheasant-origin ARV isolates, and shares 51.8-96.2% of nucleotide identity of σC gene with them; while only 49.3-50.3% with waterfowl isolates. In addition, the occurrence of 10 segments genetic reassortment of SDPY strain is confirmed among the PA15511, the 1733 and the PA13649 strains from America. In conclusion, the causative agent of gosling hemorrhagic necrotic hepatitis and nephritis occurring in China is a novel chicken-origin goose orthoreovirus.

Current limitations in control of viral arthritis and tenosynovitis caused by avian reoviruses in commercial poultry

Avian reoviruses are the causative agent of viral arthritis/tenosynovitis in chickens and turkeys. Clinical signs of disease include swelling of the hock joints accompanied by lesions in the gastrocnemius and digital flexor tendons causing lameness in addition to hydropericardium. The economic impact is significant as it results in poor weight gain, increased feed conversion ratios and condemnations at the processing plant. Vaccination with both live attenuated and inactivated oil emulsion vaccines have been used successfully for decades to control the disease. Current commercial vaccine strains belong to the same serotype and are antigenically and serologically distinct from circulating variant field viruses isolated from clinical cases of tenosynovitis. Since 2012, there has been a dramatic increase in the number of clinical cases of tenosynovitis in commercial poultry and commercial vaccines are unable to provide adequate levels of protection against disease. Producers have elected to use custom inactivated vaccines in the absence of any commercially available homologous vaccines. Identification and selection of field isolates for use in autogenous vaccines can be difficult especially when multiple reoviruses are co-circulating among flocks. In addition, field data suggests that in some cases the custom vaccines are providing adequate protection against disease but as new genetic variants emerge, new vaccines are needed.

Detection and characterization of two co-infection variant strains of avian orthoreovirus (ARV) in young layer chickens using next-generation sequencing (NGS)

Using next-generation sequencing (NGS) for full genomic characterization studies of the newly emerging avian orthoreovirus (ARV) field strains isolated in Pennsylvania poultry, we identified two co-infection ARV variant strains from one ARV isolate obtained from ARV-affected young layer chickens. The de novo assembly of the ARV reads generated 19 contigs of two different ARV variant strains according to 10 genome segments of each ARV strain. The two variants had the same M2 segment. The complete genomes of each of the two variant strains were 23,493 bp in length, and 10 dsRNA segments ranged from 1192 bp (S4) to 3958 bp (L1), encoding 12 viral proteins. Sequence comparison of nucleotide (nt) and amino acid (aa) sequences of all 10 genome segments revealed 58.1–100% and 51.4–100% aa identity between the two variant strains, and 54.3–89.4% and 49.5–98.1% aa identity between the two variants and classic vaccine strains. Phylogenetic analysis revealed a moderate to significant nt sequence divergence between the two variant and ARV reference strains. These findings have demonstrated the first naturally occurring co-infection of two ARV variants in commercial young layer chickens, providing scientific evidence that multiple ARV strains can be simultaneously present in one host species of chickens.

Rapid detection of Mycoplasma synoviae and avian reovirus in clinical samples of poultry using multiplex PCR

Mycoplasma synoviae and avian reovirus (ARV) are associated with several disease syndromes in poultry and cause notable global economic losses in the poultry industry. Rapid and efficient diagnostics for these avian pathogens are important not only for disease control but also for prevention of clinical disease progression. However, current diagnostic methods used for surveillance of these diseases in poultry flocks are laborious and time-consuming, and they have low sensitivity. The multiplex PCR (mPCR) developed in this study has been proven to be both sensitive and specific for simultaneous M. synoviae and ARV detection and identification in clinical samples. To evaluate the mPCR assay, the diagnostic test was applied to different clinical samples from natural and experimental M. synoviae and ARV-infected poultry. Results were compared with serologic, single PCR, and immunofluorescence analyses. Tibiotarsal articulation could be the best target for simultaneous detection of M. synoviae and ARV infection. The detection limit by visualization of mPCR-amplified products was 100 pg for both pathogens. Overall, the mPCR developed and standardized in this research is a useful tool for diagnosis and screening and for surveillance and control of M. synoviae and ARV infection in poultry flocks.

Isolation of a reovirus from a broiler chicken flock with high early mortality

A reovirus was isolated from a flock of 12,000 broiler chickens which experienced a total mortality of 6.3% up to 35 days. The reovirus produced large syncytia in primary chicken kidney cell cultures with eosinophilic intracytoplasmic inclusion body formation. Infected cells reacted with fluorescein conjugated specific anti-reovirus serum. Negatively strained virions had a double shelled appearance with overall diameter of 65 to 70 nm. The nucleic acid had ten discrete segments with electrophoretic mobilities as would be expected for a reovirus.

Avian reovirus major mu-class outer capsid protein influences efficiency of productive macrophage infection in a virus strain-specific manner

We determined that the highly pathogenic avian reovirus strain 176 (ARV-176) possesses an enhanced ability to establish productive infections in HD-11 avian macrophages compared to avian fibroblasts. Conversely, the weakly pathogenic strain ARV-138 shows no such macrophagotropic tendency. The macrophage infection capability of the two viruses did not reflect differences in the ability to either induce or inhibit nitric oxide production. Moderate increases in the ARV-138 multiplicity of infection resulted in a concomitant increase in macrophage infection, and under such conditions the kinetics and extent of the ARV-138 replication cycle were equivalent to those of the highly infectious ARV-176 strain. These results indicated that both viruses are apparently equally capable of replicating in an infected macrophage, but they differ in the ability to establish productive infections in these cells. Using a genetic reassortant approach, we determined that the macrophagotropic property of ARV-176 reflects a post-receptor-binding step in the virus replication cycle and that the ARV-176 M2 genome segment is required for efficient infection of HD-11 cells. The M2 genome segment encodes the major mu-class outer capsid protein (muB) of the virus, which is involved in virus entry and transcriptase activation, suggesting that a host-specific influence on ARV entry and/or uncoating may affect the likelihood of the virus establishing a productive infection in a macrophage cell.