Left-handed DNA crossovers. Implications for DNA-DNA recognition and structural alterations

DNA self-assembly: from chirality to evolution

Transient or long-term DNA self-assembly participates in essential genetic functions. The present review focuses on tight DNA-DNA interactions that have recently been found to play important roles in both controlling DNA higher-order structures and their topology. Due to their chirality, double helices are tightly packed into stable right-handed crossovers. Simple packing rules that are imposed by DNA geometry and sequence dictate the overall architecture of higher order DNA structures. Close DNA-DNA interactions also provide the missing link between local interactions and DNA topology, thus explaining how type II DNA topoisomerases may sense locally the global topology. Finally this paper proposes that through its influence on DNA self-assembled structures, DNA chirality played a critical role during the early steps of evolution.

DNA-directed base pair opening

Strand separation is a fundamental molecular process essential for the reading of the genetic information during DNA replication, transcription and recombination. However, DNA melting in physiological conditions in which the double helix is expected to be stable represents a challenging problem. Current models propose that negative supercoiling destabilizes the double helix and promotes the spontaneous, sequence-dependent DNA melting. The present review examines an alternative view and reveals how DNA compaction may trigger the sequence dependent opening of the base pairs. This analysis shows that in DNA crystals, tight DNA-DNA interactions destabilize the double helices at various degrees, from the alteration of the base-stacking to the opening of the base-pairs. The electrostatic repulsion generated by the DNA close approach of the negatively charged sugar phosphate backbones may therefore provide a potential source of the energy required for DNA melting. These observations suggest a new molecular mechanism for the initial steps of strand separation in which the coupling of the DNA tertiary and secondary interactions both actively triggers the base pair opening and stabilizes the intermediate states during the melting pathway.

Local sensing of global DNA topology: from crossover geometry to type II topoisomerase processivity

Type II topoisomerases are ubiquitous enzymes that control the topology and higher order structures of DNA. Type IIA enzymes have the remarkable property to sense locally the global DNA topology. Although many theoretical models have been proposed, the molecular mechanism of chiral discrimination is still unclear. While experimental studies have established that topoisomerases IIA discriminate topology on the basis of crossover geometry, a recent single-molecule experiment has shown that the enzyme has a different processivity on supercoiled DNA of opposite sign. Understanding how cross-over geometry influences enzyme processivity is, therefore, the key to elucidate the mechanism of chiral discrimination. Analysing this question from the DNA side reveals first, that the different stability of chiral DNA cross-overs provides a way to locally sense the global DNA topology. Second, it shows that these enzymes have evolved to recognize the G- and T-segments stably assembled into a right-handed cross-over. Third, it demonstrates how binding right-handed cross-overs across their large angle imposes a different topological link between the topoIIA rings and the plectonemes of opposite sign thus directly affecting the enzyme freedom of motion and processivity. In bridging geometry and kinetic data, this study brings a simple solution for type IIA topoisomerase chiral discrimination.

Differential stability of DNA crossovers in solution mediated by divalent cations

The assembly of DNA duplexes into higher-order structures plays a major role in many vital cellular functions such as recombination, chromatin packaging and gene regulation. However, little is currently known about the molecular structure and stability of direct DNA–DNA interactions that are required for such functions. In nature, DNA helices minimize electrostatic repulsion between double helices in several ways. Within crystals, B-DNA forms either right-handed crossovers by groove–backbone interaction or left-handed crossovers by groove–groove juxtaposition. We evaluated the stability of such crossovers at various ionic concentrations using large-scale atomistic molecular dynamics simulations. Our results show that right-handed DNA crossovers are thermodynamically stable in solution in the presence of divalent cations. Attractive forces at short-range stabilize such crossover structures with inter-axial separation of helices less than 20 Å. Right-handed crossovers, however, dissociate swiftly in the presence of monovalent ions only. Surprisingly, left-handed crossovers, assembled by sequence-independent juxtaposition of the helices, appear unstable even at the highest concentration of Mg²⁺studied here. Our study provides new molecular insights into chiral association of DNA duplexes and highlights the unique role divalent cations play in differential stabilization of crossover structures. These results may serve as a rational basis to understand the role DNA crossovers play in biological processes.

Helical chirality: a link between local interactions and global topology in DNA

DNA supercoiling plays a major role in many cellular functions. The global DNA conformation is however intimately linked to local DNA-DNA interactions influencing both the physical properties and the biological functions of the supercoiled molecule. Juxtaposition of DNA double helices in ubiquitous crossover arrangements participates in multiple functions such as recombination, gene regulation and DNA packaging. However, little is currently known about how the structure and stability of direct DNA-DNA interactions influence the topological state of DNA. Here, a crystallographic analysis shows that due to the intrinsic helical chirality of DNA, crossovers of opposite handedness exhibit markedly different geometries. While right-handed crossovers are self-fitted by sequence-specific groove-backbone interaction and bridging Mg(2+) sites, left-handed crossovers are juxtaposed by groove-groove interaction. Our previous calculations have shown that the different geometries result in differential stabilisation in solution, in the presence of divalent cations. The present study reveals that the various topological states of the cell are associated with different inter-segmental interactions. While the unstable left-handed crossovers are exclusively formed in negatively supercoiled DNA, stable right-handed crossovers constitute the local signature of an unusual topological state in the cell, such as the positively supercoiled or relaxed DNA. These findings not only provide a simple mechanism for locally sensing the DNA topology but also lead to the prediction that, due to their different tertiary intra-molecular interactions, supercoiled molecules of opposite signs must display markedly different physical properties. Sticky inter-segmental interactions in positively supercoiled or relaxed DNA are expected to greatly slow down the slithering dynamics of DNA. We therefore suggest that the intrinsic helical chirality of DNA may have oriented the early evolutionary choices for DNA topology.

Does topoisomerase II specifically recognize and cleave hairpins, cruciforms and crossovers of DNA?

DNA topoisomerase II is an enzyme that specializes in DNA disentanglement. It catalyzes the interconversion of DNA between different topological states. This event requires the passage of one duplex through another one via a transient double-strand break. Topoisomerase II is able to process any type of DNA, including structures such as DNA juxtapositions (crossovers), DNA hairpins or cruciforms, which are recognized with high specificity. In this review, we focused our attention on topoisomerase II recognizing DNA substrates that possess particular geometries. A strong cleavage site, as we identified in pBR322 DNA in the presence of ellipticine (site 22), appears to be characterized by a cruciform structure formed from two stable hairpins. The same sequence could also constitute a four-way junction structure stabilized by interactions involving ATC sequences. The latter have been shown to be able to promote Holliday junctions. We reviewed the recent literature that deals with the preferential recognition of crossovers by various topoisomerases. The single molecule relaxation experiments have demonstrated the differential abilities of the topoisomerases to recognize crossovers. It appears that enzymes, which distinguish the chirality of the crossovers, possess specialized domains dedicated to this function. We also stress that the formation of crossovers is dependent on the presence of adequate stabilizing sequences. Investigation of the impact of such structures on enzyme activity is important in order to both improve our knowledge of the mechanism of action of the topoisomerase II and to develop new inhibitors of this enzyme.

Global structure of a DNA three-way junction by solution NMR: towards prediction of 3H fold

Three-way junctions (3H) are the simplest and most commonly occurring branched nucleic acids. They consist of three double helical arms (A to C), connected at the junction point, with or without a number of unpaired bases in one or more of the three different strands. Three-way junctions with two unpaired bases in one strand (3HS2) have a high tendency to adopt either of two alternative stacked conformations in which two of the three arms A, B and C are coaxially stacked, i.e. A/B-stacked or A/C-stacked. Empirical stacking rules, which successfully predict for DNA 3HS2 A/B-stacking preference from sequence, have been extended to A/C-stacked conformations. Three novel DNA 3HS2 sequences were designed to test the validity of these extended stacking rules and their conformational behavior was studied by solution NMR. All three show the predicted A/C-stacking preference even in the absence of multivalent cations. The stacking preference for both classes of DNA 3HS2 can thus be predicted from sequence. The high-resolution NMR solution structure for one of the stacked 3HS2 is also reported. It shows a well-defined local and global structure defined by an extensive set of classical NMR restraints and residual dipolar couplings. Analysis of its global conformation and that of other representatives of the 3H family, shows that the relative orientations of the stacked and non-stacked arms, are restricted to narrow regions of conformational space, which can be understood from geometric considerations. Together, these findings open up the possibility of full prediction of 3HS2 conformation (stacking and global fold) directly from sequence.

Brownian-dynamics simulations of metal-ion binding to four-way junctions

Four-way junctions (4Hs) are important intermediates in DNA rearrangements such as genetic recombination. Under the influence of multivalent cations these molecules undergo a conformational change, from an extended planar form to a quasi-continuous stacked X-structure. Recently, a number of X-ray structures and a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structure of 4Hs have been reported and in three of these the position of multivalent cations is revealed. These structures belong to two main families, characterized by the angle between the two co-axial stacked helices, which is either around +40 to +55 degrees or around -70 to -80 degrees. To investigate the role of metal-ion binding on the conformation of folded 4Hs we performed Brownian-dynamics simulations on the set of available structures. The simulations confirm the proposed metal-ion binding sites in the NMR structure and in one of the X-ray structures. Furthermore, the calculations suggest positions for metal-ion binding in the other X-ray structures. The results show a striking dependence of the ion density on the helical environment (B-helix or A-helix) and the structural family.

Is counterion delocalization responsible for collapse in RNA folding?

Although energetic and phylogenetic methods have been very successful for prediction of nucleic acid secondary structures, arrangement of these secondary structure elements into tertiary structure has remained a difficult problem. Here we explore the packing arrangements of DNA, RNA, and DNA/RNA hybrid molecules in crystals. In the conventional view, the highly charged double helix will be pushed toward isolation by favorable solvation effects; interactions with other like-charged stacks would be strongly disfavored. Contrary to this expectation, we find that most of the cases analyzed ( approximately 80%) exhibit specific, preferential packing between elements of secondary structure, which falls into three categories: (i) interlocking of major grooves of two helices, (ii) side-by-side parallel packing of helices, and (iii) placement of the ribose-phosphate backbone ridge of one helix into the major groove of another. The preponderance of parallel packing motifs is especially surprising. This category is expected to be maximally disfavored by charge repulsion. Instead, it comprises in excess of 50% of all packing interactions in crystals of A-form RNA and has also been observed in crystal structures of large RNA molecules. To explain this puzzle, we introduce a novel model for RNA folding. A simple calculation suggests that the entropy gained by a cloud of condensed cations surrounding the helices more than offsets the Coulombic repulsion of parallel arrangements. We propose that these condensed counterions are responsible for entropy-driven RNA collapse, analogous to the role of the hydrophobic effect in protein folding.

Structure and recognition of sheared tandem G x A base pairs associated with human centromere DNA sequence at atomic resolution

G x A mismatched base pairs are frequently found in nucleic acids. Human centromere DNA sequences contain unusual repeating motifs, e.g. , (GAATG)n x (CATTC)n found in the human chromosome. The purine-rich strand of this repeating pentamer sequence forms duplex and hairpin structures with unusual stability. The high stability of these structures is contributed by the "sheared" G x A base pairs which present a novel recognition surface for ligands and proteins. We have solved the crystal structure, by the multiple-wavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD) method of d(CCGAATGAGG) in which the centromere core sequence motif GAATG is embedded. Three crystal forms were refined to near-atomic resolution. The structures reveal the detailed conformation of tandem G x A base pairs whose unique hydrogen-bonding surface has interesting interactions with bases, hydrated magnesium ions, cobalt(III)hexaammine, spermine, and water molecules. The results are relevant in understanding the structure associated with human centromere sequence in particular and G x A base pairs in nucleic acids (including RNA, like ribozyme) in general.