Renal Oncocytoma in Taiwan

Renal Oncocytoma: The Diagnostic Challenge to Unmask the Double of Renal Cancer

Renal oncocytoma represents the most common type of benign neoplasm that is an increasing concern for urologists, oncologists, and nephrologists due to its difficult differential diagnosis and frequent overtreatment. It displays a variable neoplastic parenchymal and stromal architecture, and the defining cellular element is a large polygonal, granular, eosinophilic, mitochondria-rich cell known as an oncocyte. The real challenge in the oncocytoma treatment algorithm is related to the misdiagnosis due to its resemblance, at an initial radiological assessment, to malignant renal cancers with a completely different prognosis and medical treatment. Unfortunately, percutaneous renal biopsy is not frequently performed due to the possible side effects related to the procedure. Therefore, the majority of oncocytoma are diagnosed after the surgical operation via partial or radical nephrectomy. For this reason, new reliable strategies to solve this issue are needed. In our review, we will discuss the clinical implications of renal oncocytoma in daily clinical practice with a particular focus on the medical diagnosis and treatment and on the potential of novel promising molecular biomarkers such as circulating microRNAs to distinguish between a benign and a malignant lesion.

Renal oncocytoma revisited: a clinicopathological study of 109 cases with emphasis on problematic diagnostic features

AIM

To evaluate problematic diagnostic features in renal oncocytoma.

METHODS AND RESULTS

One hundred and nine cases of oncocytoma were reviewed and the problematic gross and microscopic features recorded. Multifocal and bilateral neoplasms were found in 12 (11%) and five (4.6%) cases, respectively. Haemorrhage was seen grossly in 30 (27.5%) neoplasms and a central scar was identified in 35 (32.1%). On microscopy, perinephric fat extension was present in 17 (15.6%) neoplasms and vascular extension was identified in four (3.7%) oncocytomas. Rare mitoses and focal coagulative necrosis were identified in two (1.8%) cases each. Focal clear cell changes were found in 16 (14.7%) oncocytomas, typically within hyalinized areas. Limited foci with chromophobe-like histology (not exceeding 5% of the neoplasm) were found in 13 (11.9%) oncocytomas. In 12 (11%) oncocytomas, rare papillary formations were noted in the lumina of microcysts. Significant nuclear atypia, oncoblasts and entrapped tubules were identified in 27 (24.8%), 41 (37.6%) and 40 (36.7%) neoplasms, respectively. After a median follow-up of 52 months (range 1-113 months), there was no disease recurrence, progression or death attributed to oncocytoma.

CONCLUSIONS

The recognition of the spectrum of morphological changes observed in renal oncocytoma should help pathologists establish a diagnosis of oncocytoma in problematic cases.

A multi-institutional study on histopathological characteristics of surgically treated renal tumors: the importance of tumor size

PURPOSE

The incidence of accidentally detected small renal tumors is increasing throughout the world. In this multi-institutional study performed in Korea, histopathological characteristics of contemporarily surgically removed renal tumors were reviewed with emphasis on tumor size.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between January 1995 and May 2005, 1,702 patients with a mean age of 55 years underwent surgical treatment at 14 training hospitals in Korea for radiologically suspected malignant renal tumors. Clinicopathological factors and patient survival were analyzed.

RESULTS

Of the 1,702 tumors, 91.7% were malignant and 8.3% were benign. The percentage of benign tumors was significantly greater among those < or = 4 cm (13.2%) than those > 4 cm (4.5%) (p < 0.001). Among renal cell carcinoma patients, the percentage of tumors classed as stage > or = T3 was significantly less among tumors < or = 4 cm (5.2%) than those > 4 cm (26.8%) (p < 0.001). The percentage of tumors classed as Fuhrman's nuclear grades > or = 3 was also significantly less among tumors < or = 4 cm (27.3%) than tumors > 4 cm (50.9%) (p < 0.001). The 5-year cancer-specific survival rate was 82.7%, and T stage (p < 0.001), N stage (p < 0.001), M stage (p = 0.025), and Fuhrman's nuclear (p < 0.001) grade were the only independent predictors of cancer-specific survival.

CONCLUSION

In renal tumors, small tumor size is prognostic for favorable postsurgical histopathologies such as benign tumors, low T stages, and low Fuhrman's nuclear grades. Our observations are expected to facilitate urologists to adopt function-preserving approach in the planning of surgery for small renal tumors with favorable predicted outcomes.

Renal oncocytoma: clinical experience of Taipei Veterans General Hospital

BACKGROUND

Renal oncocytoma has been reported mostly in the Western literature, and only a few cases have been reported in Eastern populations. In the present study, we review the clinical course of renal oncocytoma in our institution.

METHODS

We obtained the files of 13 cases of renal oncocytoma between 1988 and 2006 from the pathological archives of Taipei Veterans General Hospital. We retrospectively analyzed the patients' characteristics, clinical manifestations, surgical technique and clinical outcome.

RESULTS

The study population comprised 10 men and 3 women, and the mean age at diagnosis was 59.6 years (range, 37-75 years). Twelve patients (92%) were asymptomatic at presentation and were incidentally diagnosed to have renal tumor by sonography (9 patients), computed tomography (1 patient) or magnetic resonance imaging (2 patients), and 1 presented with hematuria. The clinical impression of oncocytoma was made preoperatively in only 3 patients by imaging studies, and most of the patients (76.9%) were diagnosed with renal cell carcinoma before surgery. Ten were treated with radical nephrectomy, 2 with partial nephrectomy, and 1 received excisional biopsy. All patients had unilateral solitary renal tumor; the right kidney was involved in 7 cases (54%) and the left in 6 (46%). Mean tumor size was 5.3 cm (range, 2.7-8.5 cm). Three patients were lost to follow-up in our series, and there was no recurrence or death (100% disease-specific survival) in the remaining 10 patients (77%) who were followed-up for a mean duration of 53.2 months (range, 10-117 months).

CONCLUSION

Renal oncocytoma has a benign clinical course with excellent long-term outcomes. Currently, nephron-sparing surgery is the mainstay of treatment, especially in patients with small tumors. However, accurate preoperative diagnosis based only on imaging studies is difficult, and radical nephrectomy was performed for most of the patients in our series.