Non‐specific reactivity of sera in ELISAs for detecting antibodies to bacterial, viral and mycoplasmal pathogens of poultry

Rate of false positive reactions in 11 M. gallisepticum and M. synoviae serological tests in samples obtained from SPF birds inoculated with heterologous mycoplasma species

No recent information is available on the specificity of current M. synoviae (Ms) and M. gallisepticum (Mg) serological tests. In this study the performance of a currently available Mg and Ms Rapid Plate Agglutination (RPA) test, and three Mg, three Ms and three Mg/Ms combination ELISAs were evaluated on SPF sera that were obtained from days (D) 0-28 after M. gallinarum, M. imitans or M. gallinaceum inoculation, after sham inoculation and without inoculation. Tracheal swabs for mycoplasma culture were obtained before inoculation (D0), 7 and 28 days post inoculation (d.p.i.) in all groups except the sham inoculated group. The different mycoplasma species colonized well. In the early stage after inoculation (7-14 d.p.i.) with heterologous mycoplasma species, the specificity varied from 85% to 100% in the Mg RPA test and from 70% to 85% in the Ms RPA test. The specificity of both Mg and Ms RPA test was 100% in the sham inoculated samples and ruled out the effect of sham medium. In the late stage (21-28 d.p.i.) specificity was 100% for both RPA tests. The test specificity was 100% for seven ELISAs except for two combination ELISAs where a specificity of 95% was found in the late stage after inoculation. However, this was not significantly different from the specificity of all other tests in the late stage of these groups. These results show that it is not advisable to establish Mg and Ms seromonitoring programmes on the Mg and Ms RPA test alone as other mycoplasma species frequently occur in poultry.

Comparison of Culture, PCR, and Different Serologic Tests for Detection of Mycoplasma gallisepticum and Mycoplasma synoviae Infections

In this study, the technical performance of culture, two commercially available polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests, rapid plate agglutination (RPA) test, hemagglutination inhibition (HI) test, and eight commercially available enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) were compared for the detection of avian mycoplasma infections from 3 days postinfection (d.p.i.) through 35 d.p.i. The tests were carried out on samples from specified pathogen-free layers that were infected at 66 wk of age with recent Mycoplasma synoviae (MS) and Mycoplasma gallisepticum (MG) field strains, MS and MG ATCC strains, and Mycoplasma imitans (MIM), respectively. Results showed a high percentage of positive samples in the homologous infected groups and a high percentage of negative samples (100%) in the uninfected and heterologous infected groups during 35 d.p.i. of both culture and PCR tests. For the group infected with the MG 15302 ATCC strain, serology was more sensitive than bacteriology. All MG and MS tests, with the exception of MG ELISA kit D showed a lower percentage of positive samples during 35 d.p.i. for the detection of the MG and MS ATCC strain infection compared with that of the field strains. Also, the number of cross-reactions (false positives) in the serologic tests was lower after infection with an ATCC strain than after an infection with the MG or MS field strain. Contradictory to other studies, the ELISAs and the RPA test using undiluted serum showed a relatively high number of false-positive results. The MG ELISAs (except ELISA kit D) showed more false-positive results (up to 37%) in the MIM-infected group than in the MS-infected groups. This was not unexpected, as MIM and MG have a close antigenic relationship. The results of the serologic tests in this study showed that a certain level of false-positive results can be expected in about any serologic test. Although the level of false-positive results varied between several serologic tests, this study showed that it is not advisable to rely completely on one test (system) only.